An Experimental Inquiry undertaken with the view of ascertaining whether any , and what signs of current Electricity are manifested during the organic process of Secretion in living animals , being an attempt to apply some of the discoveries of FARADAY to Physiology* .
By H. F. BAXTER , Esq. Communicated by Sir BENJAMIN BRODIE , Bart. , F.R.S. Received May 6 , -Read May 25 , 1848 .
THE conjecture and experiment of WOLLASTONt , the cautious opinion of PROUT+ , the experiments of DONNE1 ?
and of MATTEUCCIII , are so well known that a mere allusion to them may be deemed sufficient .
BECQUEREL ?
[ , in speaking of MATrEUCCI'S experiment , adds , " Si de nouvelles experiences confirment les r'sultats , il faudrait en conclure rdellement que les organes qui s6cretent an liquide acide ou alcalin , ont des facult6s 6lectriques analogues a celles de la pile .
" POUILLET** inserted one of the platinum extremities of a galvanometer into the jugular vein of a rabbit , the other into the carotid artery , without any effect being produced on the needle .
MUiLLERt ?
says , " With the galvanometer no electric current can be discovered in the blood .
I perceived no variation of the magnetic needle of the multiplier , even when I inserted one wire into an artery of a living animal , the other into a vein .
" The galvanometer++ that was used in these experiments is one of the common and ordinary construction , astatic , consisting of but few coils ; the needles suspended by silk-worm silk , and the electrodes attached by screws .
As the object was to ascer* It would be unjust to BECCQUEREL not to state , that great and important assistance was obtained during the progress of the inquiry from his valuable work , entitled " Trait6 de I'ElectricitW , " respecting one class of phenomena especially , viz. the action of an acid and an alkali upon each other when separated by a membrane or any other porous diaphragm .
But , at the very commencement of the inquiry , it soon became apparent that no real progress could be reasonably expected until clearer ideas had been obtained as to the origin of the power in the voltaic circle .
This le to the study of those admirable memoirs of FARADAY .
The inquiry and the study of those memoirs went hand-in-hand .
The opinions supposed were those from FARADAY ; the experiments , tests of those opinions .
The endeavour to master the meaning of that important , comprehensive , and expressive phrase , " an axis of power having contrary forces , exactly equal in amount , in contrary directions , " was the mental difficulty ; in that consists the requisite mental labour .
It is not too much to add , that without those memoirs the inquiry would not have been continued .
t Philosophical Magazine , vol. xxxiii .
p. 488 .
+ On Stomach and Urinary Diseases , 3rd edit .
p. xxv . ?
BECQUEREL , Traite de l'Electricit6 , tom .
i. p. 327 .
11 Ibid. tom .
iv .
p. 300 . ?
Ibid. p. 301 .
** Journal de Physiologie , tom .
v. p. 5 .
1t MULLER'S Physiology , translated by BALY , vol. i. p. 148 , 2nd edit .
t Made by NEWMAN of Regent Street .
There is one advantage attending the use of a galvanometer that is not very delicate in its construction in these experiments ; the vibrations of the needle soon subside , and consequently more information can be obtained from a single experiment .
tain , if possible , the existence of the current , an accurate description of its delicacy will not be necessary .
It is sufficiently so to indicate the existence of a current during the combination of an acid with an alkali , such as very dilute solutions of nitric acid and of potash , when separated by a membrane .
In several unsuccessful experiments , the following electrodes were used:-Two platinum wires , -hnth of an inch in thickness and eleven inches in length , were pointed at one extremity , to be easily inserted into a blood-vessel or an organ , and coated with sealing-wax for about two inches , leaving the extreme point bare to the extent of one-fourth of an inch , the other extremities being attached to the galvanometer .
But during the inquiry , in consequence of the stiffness of the wires forming the electrodes occasioning a motion of the whole instrument , when making and breaking contact , the following alteration was made in the arrangement .
Thick copper wires ten inches in length were connected with the galvanometer by the screws , and each of the free extremities so bent as to rest in a separate wooden cup containing mercury .
A platinum plate , an inch square , was attached to one extremity of each of the platinum electrodes to increase the extent of surface , and being placed in the wooden cups , a communication was formed with the galvanometer by means of the mercury , the pointed extremities serving , as before , to be inserted into the different parts of the animal .
Great care was taken to ascertain that the different contacts were perfect , and no result upon the needle occurred from the whole arrangement , when a circuit was formed with a weak solution of salt , or water , previous to each experiment .
It will be unnecessary to relate the experiments , thirteen in number , upon cats , kittens , a guinea-pig and rabbits , in which an endeavour was made to ascertain whether the effect of a diverted current might not be obtained by inserting the electrodes into the portal vein alone , supposing that the stomach and liver formed poles similar to those of a galvanic circle ; or whether a current might not be obtained by inserting them into the portal and hepatic veins .
rrllese failures , combined with theoretical reasoning , led to the supposition that the effect sought for existed in a different quarter .
The inquiry will therefore commence with relating the last of the unsuccessful experiments .
Experiment 1.-Rabbit , six weeks old .
( a ) .
One electrode inserted into the vena porta , the other into the vena cava , at the entrance of the hepatic veins ; no effect .
( b ) .
Caput coli , and a vein coming from the same part ; A slight effect appeared : the electrodes were cleaned and reinserted , but the same effect did not occur .
( c ) .
Stomach and liver .
( d ) .
Stomach and vena porta .
( e ) .
Stomach and gall-bladder ; no effect .
In these and the following experiments the electrodes were cleaned after the formation of a previous circuit , whenever the substances adhering to them might influence the result .
Repeating the experiments of MATTEUCCI and of DONNE , only once did the effect occur , and that but slight , in the guinea-pig .
The following fact may perhaps account for it .
Instead of the plates dipping into the mercury , the points were used for this purpose , and the surface of the plates served to form the free extremities of the electrodes .
The stomach was laid open , one of the plates pressed on the mucous membrane , the other upon the surface of the liver ; a decided effect was now produced upon the needle , and by making and breaking contact so as to catch the vibrations of the needle , made to increase to 15 ?
or 20 ? .
The points were used as before ; no effect .
When the surface of the plate of one electrode was connected with the mucous ernembrane of the stomach , and the point of the other electrode with the liver , the effect upon the needle was greater than when the pointed extremity of the electrode was connected with the stomach , and the surface of the plate with the surface of the liver ; in the latter instance the effect was very slight , ; but in neither instance was the effect so great as when both plates were used .
The direction of the current , as indicated by the needle , was from the stomach along the metallic conductor to the liver , The liver was removed and placed upon the intestines , the stomach remaining ; the same actions occurred , but not to the same extent , Stomach almost empty .
Considering that the failure in former experiments arose from the want of surface at the free extremities of the electrodes , the sealing-wax was removed .
Experiment 2.-Rabbit .
The pointed extremity of one electrode was inserted into the caput coli , and pressed against the mucous membrane , the inferior mnesenteric vein was wounded , and the plate of the other electrode dipped into the blood ; the latter positive 50 , and made to increase by making and breaking contact .
An incision was made into the stomach , and the plate of one electrode inserted into it ; the plate of the other lightly pressed on the surface of the liver ; stomach positive 100 , and made to increase by making and breaking contact .
In cleaning one of the electrodes it broke , about half an inch from the plate .
The plate of the electrode was in contact with the mucous membrane of the ilium , and the pointed extremity of the broken electrode inserted into a vein coming from the same part ; blood slightly positive .
A platinum wire ( No. 18 ) , six inches in length , was flattened out at one extremity so as to present a surface three-fourths of an inch in length , and one-sixth of an inch in breadth .
This will be called electrode A ( E A ) .
The former electrode with the plate attached , electrode B ( E B ) .
The broken electrode , having the broken extremity flattened out to the extent of one-fourth of an inch in length and to one-eighth of an inch in breadth electrode C ( E C ) .
In describing the circuits , when the pointed extremity is in contact with the animal , it will be stated the p of E A , &amp;c. , otherwise the broad extremity is used .
Experiment 3 , -Rabbit .
Mucous membrane of the ilium and vein from the same part ; the p of EA in contact with the former to the extent of an inch and a half , the p of EB with the latter ; blood positive 40 ; when EB was used a greater effect , and made to increase ; no effect ensued when the p of EB was inserted into a different vein ; returning to the former vein , the action upon the needle occurred ; should the blood however frLom the two veins become mtixed , then an efect upon the needle ensued , more especially if EB be used .
No effect when EB was placed 2xS2 rTo TH E EXISTENCE on the outside of the gut over EA where the blood had not been , whereas withi blood flowing from the vein , they may be separated to the extent of an inch or more , the effect occurring .
Stomach and liver ; the p of EA inserted into the former to the extent of an inch , EB lightly pressed on the surface of the latter ; stomach positive 80 ; an attempt was made to insert the p of EB into a vein coming from the stomach , but failed from the difficulty in obtaining a vein of sufficient size ; when it was inserted into the portal vein , no effect .
EC inserted into the caput coli ; stomach slightly positive .
Experiment 4.-Cat .
Prussic acid dropped on the nose .
Mucous membrane of the ilium , and a vein from the same part ; the p of EA in contact with the former to the extent of an inch and a half , the p of EB with the latter ; blood positive 50 , and made to increase : a vein coming from a different part was punctured , no effect : with the former vein the effect ensued , but not when it had become empty .
Mucous membrane of the stomach and blood from the sanie organ ; the p of EA was in contact with the great curvature of the stomach to the extent of an inch , a vein corresponding to the lesser curvature was punctured with the p of E B ; no effect : the portal vein was punctured at its commencement ; as the blood flowed out a slight effect occurred , blood positive : EB was lightly pressed on the surface of the liver ; the latter slightly positive .
Mucous membrane of the upper part of the colon , and vein from the same part ; p of EA in contact with the former to the extent of an inch and a half , the p of EB with the latter ; blood positive : EB pressed on the .
surface of the liver ; the latter positive .
The liver and intestines covered with blood .
The p of EA inserted into the stomach , EC into the colon ; no effect .
Stomach and small intestines empty .
Experiment 5.-Cat .
Killed as the last .
In opening the abdomen the liver was wounded .
The mucous membrane of the upper part of the small intestine , where active digestion was going on , was in contact , to the extent of an inch , with the p of E A ; an artery going to the same part was punctured with the p of EB no effect : when the vein was wounded , a decided result ; blood positive .
The inside and outside of the gut were formed into a circuit ; no effect .
The mucous membrane of the stomach , in contact with the p of E A , to the extent of an inch , EB with blood flowing from the vena porta ; blood slightly positive : placed on the liver ; the same result , but not when the point was used .
The liver covered with blood from the wound .
The pelvis and renal vein of the same kidney were formed into a circuit , with the p of EC and of E B ; vibrations occurred , but impossible to obtain any decided effect by making and breaking contact .
Between the mucous membrane of the colon and vein ; blood positive .
Stomach half-full of food .
The following experiment was to ascertain how far the diffNeret solid and fluid substances in contact with ] the electrodes might interfere with the result .
Experiment 6.-E B covered with some blood from the cat , was dipped with EA into water .
A similar circuit was formed with fresh blood and water containing fecal matter from the colon , the electrodes were close to each other .
A portion of the colon of the cat , with its contents , was removed and placed in a weak solution of potash ; ?
A and EB were dipped , one into the solution , the other into the gut , and then changed ; in no instance did any effect occur .
Some very dilute nitric acid was mixed with the contents of the colon and the same circuit formed ; , contents of the colon positive 30 .
Can the difference , which is observed between cats and rabbits , as to the direction of the current when the stomach and liver are formed into a circuit , be attributed to the action of the poison , although no poison had been taken into the stomach ?
Experiments 7 and 8 were upon rabbits ; in one , prussic acid was used as in experiment 5 ; in the other , after a circuit had been formed between the mucous membrane of the stomach and blood flowing from the aorta , an opening was made and about ten drops of prussic acid poured into the stomach .
The results only need be detailed .
The mucous membrane of the stomach was positive to the following parts : surface of liver , mesentery , blood flowing from the vena porta and aorta , gall-bladder , mucous membrane of the duodenum and of the caput coli .
The blood flowing from the mucous membrane of the ilium and of the caput coli was positive to these parts from 30 to 50 .
The surface of the liver and the mesentery were slightly positive , when EB was in contact with them , to the mucous membrane of the ilium and caput coli .
In the following circuits no result was obtained:-Mucous membrane of the stomach and vena porta , the pointed extremity being inserted into the latter .
Gallbladder and vena-porta .
Mucous membrane of the ilium and that of the caput coli .
Mucous membrane of the ilium and vein coming from the same part ; this occurred when the aorta had been wounded , no blood flowed and the intestine was pale .
The contents of the stomach were positive to those of the colon when formed into a circuit out of the body ; the effect was not so great as when the circuit was formed between the stomach.and caput coli , the parts remaining in situ .
In one experiment , the stomach , liver and intestines were removed from the body : the stomach was positive to every other part ; it was detached , emptied of its contents , and washed , the same circuits then formed , but no effect ; some of the food replaced , the former effects were reproduced , but not so decided .
The caput coli was slightly negative to the liver and mesentery .
With the small intestines no effect .
In both experiments the contents of the stomach reddened litmus paper , and formed a coarse , dry , compact mass ; those of the caput coli a soft homogeneous mass , but produced no effect either on litmus or turmeric paper .
From these two experiments , the difference of effect between cats and rabbits , when the stomach and liver are formed into circuits , cannot be attributed to the action of the poison .
At the present stage of the inquiry we may be justified in drawing the following inference:-JWhen the electrodes of a galvanometer are brought into communication , one with the mucous membrane of the alimentary canal , the other with the bloodflowing from the same part , a deviation of the needle takes place , indicating that the secreted product and the blood are in opposite electric states .
The two following experiments 9 and 10 , upon rabbits , were undertaken to ascertain how far they would confirm this inference .
To avoid unnecessary repetition , it may be stated , that the same results occurred as in experiments 7 and 8 ; and , in addition , the following circuits were formed .
Renal vein and pelvis of the same kidney ; renal vein of the opposite kidney and urinary bladder : in both instances vibrations only were produced .
Mucous membrane of the stomach and bile flowing from .
the gall-bladder ; the former positive .
Food from stomach and blood ; former positive .
No result was obtained in the following circuits:-Gall-bladder and vena cava at the entrance of the hepatic veins .
Gall-bladder and vena porta .
Mucous membrane of the ilium and superior mesenteric artery .
Stomach and gall-bladder ( the pointed extremity being inserted into its whole length ) .
Mucous membrane of the stomach and vena cava at the entrance of the hepatic veins .
Mucous membrane of the stomach and vena porta .
Contents of caput coli and blood .
Mucous membrane of the ilium and blood on its outer surface .
In one experiment the liver was much diseased , dark-coloured , and half the usual size ; the rabbit appeared weak and unable to support itself .
The parts in the last experiment were covered over with a towel and allowed to remain undisturbed for eight hours .
It will be unnecessary to state the circuits that were then for miled , with their results , and likewise those in a rabbit , which died from natural causes , twenty-two , twenty-five , and thirty-nine hours after death , as the following experiment containing the principal facts worthy of notice will be related at full length .
Experiment 11.-Rabbit six hours after death , which arose from natural causes .
The surface of the viscera and contents of the abdomen were remarkable for their appearance , being so similar to that of a healthy and live rabbit .
The veins being full of fluid blood , a favourable opportunity occurred of ascertaining whether the same effects would be produced as in the living animal .
The following circuits were formed:-The blood flowing from the iliulm , an empty portion of the descending colon , and caput coli and the mucous membrane of these parts ; in the latter only did any effect occur , the mucous membrane slightly positive .
Contents of the caput coli produced no effect on litmus paper .
Mucous membrane of the stomach and the following parts , surface of the liver , mesentery and small intestines ; each of the latter slightly positive .
Food in the stomach acid : the moisture covering the different viscera restored the slightly reddened litmus , but produced no effect upon turmeric paper .
A i nserted into the centre of the mass of food in the stomach , EB lightly pressed on the upper external surface over E A ; EB slightly positive : EB placed on the liver or intestines ; EA slightly positive .
EB and the broken plate of EC were placed , one on the upper surface of the stomach , the other on the mesentery ; no effect .
Some food was taken out of the stomach and placed on the intestines , the broken plate on the mesentery , EB on the food ; EB positive .
The same arrangement was made with some of the contents of the caput coli ; the latter slightly positive .
The following circuits were formed : food from the stomach and contents of the caput coli ; the former positive : some food from the centre of the mass in the stomach , and some in contact with the mucous surface ; the latter positive .
The mass in the stomach was coarse , dry and compact ; that in the caput coli of a finer and softer consistence .
The parts were covered over with a towel for twelve hours .
EB placed on the upper external surface of the stomach , EA inserted into the caput coli ; EB positive .
EA remaining , EB on the small intestines ; effect very slight .
EC inserted into the centre of the contents of the stomach , EB lightly pressed on the upper external surface ; EC positive .
The stomach was moved over and EB placed on that which had been its inferior surface ; EB positive : EB was placed on the part where the stomach had been lying ; EB positive .
The different parts had become more moist .
No doubt can exist as to the cause of the production of the effect 's obtained in the last experiment , viz. the difference of the fluids and solids in contact with the elec , trodes .
The proposition , that , when two heterogeneous fluids are separated from each other by a mtemabrane , or any other porous diaphragm , that which performs the part of an acid takes positive electricity , the other , that of an alkali , takes negative electricity , has been well established by BECQUEREL* .
The results observed in the last experiment beautifully illustrate it ; and at the same time show how impossible it is to say , a priori , what would be the effect upon the needle when the electrodes are inserted into different parts of a dead animal .
The mere circumstance of placing the electrodes in contact with different portions of the contents of the stomach produces an effect or not upon the needle ; the state of the parts as to moisture , and the transudation of the secreted fluids or contents through the walls of the different viscera ; the contents of the colon and of the stomach considered as a mass , forming one conducting body ; the difference with respect to the extent of surface of the electrodes ; each of these circumstances may be readily seen to be influential and unnecessary to particularize .
There may be two or three acting points between the electrodes , determining the current in opposite directions , or assisting each other , the action upon the needle being the result of a differential , or of a combined current , according to circumstances .
Shall we be justified in referring the effects observed in experiments 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 7 and 8 to the same cause ?
Let us take the simple fact , that , when the mucous memnbrane of the small intestine and the blood flowing from it are formed into a circuit , a deviation of the needle amounting to 30 , 40 or 50 is obtained , the intestine being empty and therefore uninfluenced by the circumstances we have just now mentioned ; why did the effect not occur in experiment 11 ?
the conditions appeared to be precisely similar ; or in experiments 7 and 10 , when the artery was wounded ; or in experiments 3 and 4 , when blood flowing from a different part formed the circuit ; or in experiments 3 , 5 , 9 , when a circuit was formed between the inside and outside of the gut ?
Did not the failure arise in these instances in consequence of the absence of one necessary condition , the flowing of the blood from the same part , the transmission of the carrying particles from one electrode to the other , as shown in experiments 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 and 7 ?
Without entering into any discussion as to the mode in which the effect may be supposed to be brought about in the living animal , and the difference observed when the stomach and other parts were formed into circuits in rabbits , and when the same circuits were formed in cats , we may be justified in adding the following to our former inference , viz. that the eSefct is produced during the organic action of the part , it ceasing after the death of the animal .
Instead of endeavouring to refute the notion that the stomach and liver form poles similar to those of a galvanic circle , let us briefly allude to the experiment and conjecture of WOLLASTON .
Was not that experiment to illustrate , rather than to prove his conjecture ?
and are not these experiments identical with that conjecture ?
He evidently saw , mentally speaking , the meaning of that phrase " AN AXIS OF POWER , " &amp;c. This inquiry has been undertaken with the advantage both of FARADAY'S labours and the use of the galvanometer .
WOLLASTON 's conjecture and experiment have existed for forty years .
The following is a brief recapitulation of the general conclusions which may be deduced from the foregoing experiments and reasonings : 1 .
When the electrodes of a galvanometer are brought into communication , one with the mucous membrane of the alimentary canal , the other with the blood flowing from the same part , a deviation of the needle takes place , indicating that the secreted product and the blood are in opposite electric states .
2 .
That the effect occurs during the life of the animal , it ceasing after its death .
3 .
That the effect may be considered as arising from the decomposition of the blood ; i. e. the changes which occur during the formation of the secreted product and venous blood .
4 .
That these changes are effected by the organic action of the part .
The author begs to acknowledge the great kindness that he has received from Sir B. C. BRODIE , Bart. , and from Dr. TODD .
12 New Burlington Street .
Fig. 1 .
Wooden mercurial cup .
Fig. 2 .
Copper wire to form the communication between the galvanometer and mercury .
Fig. 3 .
A section of the mercurial cup , showing the mode in which the thick copper wire was connected with it .
Fig. 4 .
Shows the manner in which the plate of platinum was soldered on to the platinum electrode , pure gold being used ; all the part within the dotted line , and for a short distance up the wire , was coated with shell-lac to prevent the action of the mercury upon it .
Fig. 5 .
Electrode A. Fig. 6 .
Electrode B. Fig. 7 .
Electrode C. Fig. 8 .
The arrangement with the galvanometer previous to each experiment .
Fig. 9 .
aa a , arteries ; bb b , veins ; the arrows indicate the course of the blood : c , point of the electrode in contact with the wounded vein ; the dotted line of d the electrode in contact with the mucous surface of the small intestine .
Fig. 1 .
Fig. 3 .
Fig. 9 .
Figs. 5 .
6 .
7 .
Fig. 4 .
Fig. 2 .
Fig. 8 .

