] XV .
On a new Case of the Interference of Light .
By the Rev. BADEN POWELL , M.A. , F.R.S. , F.R.A.S. , F.G.S. , Savilian Professor of Geometry in the University of Oxford .
Received April 6 , -Read May 18 , 1848 .
( 1 .
) IN the state of advance at which the theory of light has now arrived , a single case of interference directly explicable by the ordinary principles of undulations , even though occurring under new conditions , could hardly be deemed of sufficient importance to form the subject of a separate communication to the Royal Society .
But in the present instance though the case presented , in its more general features , is easily accounted for on the acknowledged doctrine of interference and retardation , yet it offers many particulars in its details , in reference to which such explanation is , at least , not equally obvious : while some points require for their elucidation investigations of a more extended character .
Again , it is found to be a case which by no means stands isolated , but offers analogies with other classes of phenomena which have excited considerable interest and discussion , especially with regard to what has been termed , perhaps improperly , a " polarity " in the prismatic rays , -a new instance of which is here exhibited .
In these respects , then , I trust the subject may not appear unworthy of the notice of the Royal Society .
Having arrived at the primary results in July 1847 , I communicated them to my friend Mr. G. G. STOKES of Pembroke College , Cambridge , who has gone extensively into the whole theory of these and other allied cases , and has afforded me much valuable aid in the investigation .
In the present paper I propose only to describe my own experiments , with the general application of the undulatory theory to the explanation of them , supported by some numerical comparisons .
( 2 .
) The main experiment is as follows : in a hollow glass prism , or rather trough , containing some highly refractive and dispersive liquid , such as oil of sassafras , anise , or cassia , a plate of glass is inserted with its lower edge parallel to the edge of the prism , and so that its plane nearly bisects the angle of the prism , while it extends only through the upper half of the liquid , leaving the lower , or thinner part , clear ( see fig. 1 ) .
Light being admitted through a narrow horizontal slit in the usual manner , the spectrum thus formed is seen crossed by a number of dark bands parallel to the slit or edge of the prism .
have tried various combinations of oils and other media with plates of different thicknesses , both of glass and of other transparent substances .
In these different instances some remarkable distinctions are exhibited .
In some cases the bands are sensibly equidistant , in others increasing in number and fineness towards one Fig. 1 .
Fig. 2 .
Position 1 .
Fig. 3 .
Position 2 .
Arrangement I. end of the spectrum : in most cases extending throughout , but in some deficient at one part .
( 4 .
) With the same oil or medium , if the plate exceed a certain thickness , the bands become too numerous and fine to be seen : if less than a certain other limit .
they become too few , broad and faint : and for some intermediate thickness they appear most vivid and distinct .
( 5 .
) With plates and media of different refractive and dispersive powers as well as different thicknesses , changes in the number and vividness of the bands take place , as well as in the limits of their visibility , in a manner evidently dependent on the thickness and relative refractions jointly ; though not in any such obvious relation as can be stated by a simple experimental law .
( 6 .
) It is not necessary that the plate should have precisely the vertical position just described ; if inclined either way , even to being in contact with either side of the prism , the bands are still seen ; but they undergo a slight shifting downwards as the plate is inclined , and are perhaps less vivid ( see figs. 2 , 3 ) .
( 7 .
) Some combinations of a medium and a plate , such as Fig. 4 .
glass with oils of turpentine or angelica , or water , &amp;c. , give no _ bands with this arrangement .
But Mr. STOKES pointed out from theory , that in these cases bands might be expected to M appear with a reverse arrangement ; that is , by placing a\ ; narrow slip of glass , &amp;c. to intercept the thinner part of the prism , leaving the upper or thicker part clear , and of course cutting oftf any portion of light , which might otherwise pass Arrangement II .
below the plate ( see fig. 4 , where s is a small screen for intercepting the light below ) .
On using such an arrangement for the cases just mentioned , I accordingly found bands produced .
( 8 .
) In any case to see the bands well , especially towards the violet end of the spectrum , a strong light is requisite : that of the sun direct , shaded by a blue glass , or at least that of the bright part of the sky near the sun , was usually thrown in by the shutter apparatus ; and though a small telescope was usually employed , yet the bands , in cases where they are vivid and broad , may be seen by the naked eye ; and for such cases lamp-light may be used , but it will not suffice for the more delicate .
( 9 .
) When crystallized substances are employed as plates other peculiar phenomena are presented .
A plate of calc-spar ( formed by the natural cleavage ) with oil of cassia gives two distinct sets of bands ; the one finer and narrower than the other , which about the middle of the spectrum may be seen distinctly superimposed one on the other .
On applying a Nicol-prism each set disappears alternately , leaving the other visible at each quarter of a revolution of the analyser ; showing them due to the two oppositely polarized pencils .
It is easily ascertained that thefiner bands belong to the extraordinary , the broader to the ordinary ray .
( 10 .
) A plate of quartz , cut perpendicular to the axis , with oil of sassafras , gives very distinct bands , which may be seen to be in fact composed of two sets superimrposed and nearly coinciding , since when the plate is inclined ( as in position 1 , see fig. 2 ) at intervals throughout the spectrum the near coincidence of the dark spaces of one set , with the bright of the other , occasions an extreme faintness in the bands .
In this case the two pencils deviate sufficiently from the axis to approximate to plane polarized light , and thus the Nicol-prism causes the indistinctness to disappear at each quarter of a revolution by stopping one of them alternately .
( 11 .
) For an explanation of the general phenomena of the formation of bands under the conditions specified , the simple interference-theory suffices .
Of the homogeneous pencil going to form any one ray of the spectrum , that half which passes through the thicker part of the prism is more retarded than that through the thinner ; but uniformly , and in proportion to the difference of refraction , throughout the spectrum .
The plate of glass , however , having different indices for the several primary rays from those of the medium , interrupts this uniformity , and causes the one part of the pencil to be always retarded in an increasing ratio with respect to the other , throughout the spectrum ; and as this difference of retardation amounts successively to an odd or an even multiple of a half wave-length , the rays will be in discordance or accordance , or give a dark or bright band accordingly .
( 12 .
) But to account for the different conditions which determine the number and character of the bands , and the limits of thickness , as well as which of the two arrangements before described , will produce them , it is necessary to consider more precisely the relative refractions of the plate and medium , or the amount and direction of the retardation ; and it is found that on such considerations we obtain an expression which includes these conditions ; the difference of sign corresponding to the two arrangements : while it assigns the number of bands which will be formed between any two given rays , or throughout the whole spectrum , with a given thickness of the plate .
( 13 .
) In the comparison of theory and observation , the broad facts , -that bands will be produced in the respective cases by the one or the other arrangement , -as well as their general character , -show an entiLre agreement with theory .
The more precise comparison of the number of bands formed throughout the spectrum , or within certain definite spaces of it , though in some cases unavoidably imperfect from the difficulty of distinguishing the bands , yet upon the whole gives accordances as good as perhaps can be expected .
( 14 .
) When plates of doubly-refracting crystals are employed , the calculation for the extraordinary ray in particular directions in the crystal , becomes more complex , involving the laws of crystalline refraction .
In all cases a small error in the index causes a comparatively large difference in the calculated number of bands .
But , from whatever cause , in these last instances the application of theory is , as yet , less satisfactory than in others ; at least in the instance of calc-spar .
( 15 .
) The first observation of the general phenomenon reminded tne of the precisely analogous result obtained by BARON VON WREDE , though in a manner so totally different * ; in which two portions of light , unequally retarded the one by reflexion from the first , the other from the second surface of a plate of mica , impinge jointly on a prism , whence results a spectrum crossed with bands ; while the author 's profound analysis ( founded on the hypothesis of the internal reflexions of a ray among the molecules of a medium ) opens an extended analogy between these cases and those of the absorption of definite rays by media in general .
( 16 .
) There is also obviously a general analogy between these phenomena and those observed by Mr. Fox TALBOT and Sir D. BREWSTER , on partially intercepting the spectrum by a plate of mica covering half the pupil of the eye ; -especially in the circumstance , that here also the plate must be applied towards one side of the prism , which corresponds to what has been described as a species of polarity .
In those experiments the retardation is the difference of the retardations of the plate of mica and of a plate of air which would be contained between the surfaces of the mica produced : in mine it is the difference of the retardation of the glass and of an equal thickness of the liquid medium of the prism .
Hence Mr. STOKES illustrated the case by supposing the glass plate inserted in a vessel with parallel , sides filled with the medium ; when if the spectrum formed by any prism were viewed through this combination , with the plate towards the thick part of the prism , the effect would Fig. 5 .
be the same ; and if the prism were of the same substance , the cases would be identical ; the liquid prism in my experiment _____X _ serving the double office of the prism and -------1---X the flat vessel .
( See fig. 5 , where P is the --- ' plate and M the medium .
) = ( 18 .
) Another remark here offers itself : If it should be considered that the theory is sufficiently established to give confidence in deductions from it , it may be applied to the inverse problem of finding the refractive indices of a plate , those of the medium , and the number of bands , being known .
This may be important for many substances which occur in the form of plates , but cannot be cut into prisms .
( 19 .
) There remain also other features of the case to be accounted for , which , if slight in appearance , are yet not unimportant in a theoretical point of view ; such as relate to the changes in the vividness of the bands , especially as affected by the thickness or inclination of the plate , by enlarging or contracting the aperture , or breadth of the prism , and some other points , to which the simple interferencetheory cannot apply .
In all experiments of this kind it is now generally understood that there must be , theoretically at least , even if it be practically insignificant , another species of action concerned , dependent on the diffraction of the lens , whether that of the eye , or of the object-glass of the telescope , producing that " diffusion , " as it has been termed , in the optical image , which , if of sensible amount , may influence the phenomiena .
The method of investigating this species of action in general is equally well understood , though in some parts the theory has been found susceptible of improvement .
In the present instance such an investigation is necessary to include some of the peculiar modifications of the phenomena observed ; and this constitutes the subject of Mr. STOKES'S researches , which he will give in a separate form .
The remainder of this/ paper is devoted to the details of the observations and the theoretical investigations .
Theoretical Investigation .
( 20 .
) The intensity of the incident light being unity , and the direct vibration for any point in the spectrum being that for the part retarded by r will be sin y ( vlt-x-r ) ; 01o , sin f ( Vt- ) COS C r-Cos A ( vt-x ) sin A r. Consequently the intensity I for any point of the whole resulting wave will be the sum of the squares of the coefficients of ( vt-x ) , or we shall find on squaring and reducing , I=2 ( 1+ cos ) ; 4r 0o if we assume p= An it becomes I=2(1+cos 'p &gt; ( 21 .
) And if we suppose p to be originally an even number and to increase by unity for successive rays of the spectrum , we shall have the corresponding values , pSS e@ **CosSp=-1 , and therefore 1=0 P4+ ... ... . .
= 0 ... ... . .
1=2 p4-2. .
+ I..1 ... .
=4 p+3 ... ... . .
0 1.=2 p+4 ... ... . .
= ... ... .
v1=0 &amp;c. &amp;c. &amp;c. Thus for any two values PI , P2D if Pl-P2=4 , they correspond to a change from one dark band to another , and consequently , if for two rays P1-p2=4n , n will be the number of bands in the space comprised between those two rays : and if they be the extremes of the spectrum , n will be the whole number of bands .
Its value may be assigned by considering the nature of the retardation , or obtaining an expression for r , as follows : ( 22 .
) On inserting the plate P of thickness 'r whose index is pp , as above , into the medium whose index is pm , the retardation of the light which passes through the plate being the difference of the retardations of the plate and of an equal thickness of the liquid , will be expressed by r ( hp P0 ) ?
But since rA ( 20 .
) , we shall have P=(A PIm ) 4 -\ A~ And for any two rays whose indices are c , , P2 , and wave-lengths 7 Xi , we have rPoP2p t n= le ltfeune tw Thsforlll avaol oth haelnohofth .
sferl tknflto xo4ar treme rays .
And the thickness of the plate being known , we may find the number of bands by computing the coefficient in terms of ( h and X which are known .
( 23 .
) Writing this coefficient =q or n=qr , since here n is supposed a whole positive number , and q may be either + or -according to the values of C and X , we have , n-r q Hence if , taking successive rays , we have always through the spectrum from the red to the violet , or the value of q negative , the effect of the plate will be such that the arrangement I. will give bands : if q be positive , the effect of the plate will be such that arrangement II .
will give bands .
If for any combination of a plate and a medium ( k , j ' ) should have a maximum or minimum value at any ray , the difference would change signs , and bands be formed towards that end of the spectrum where it waswith arrangement I. ; and towards that end where it was + with arrangement II .
( 24 .
) The general principles of the " 1 diffraction-theory , " as applicable to the present case , are precisely the same as in Mr. AIRY'S paper* .
But it will not be necessary here to go into the subject any further , since Mr. STOKEs has greatly generalized and improved this theory so as to lead to other important results , the whole of which are discussed in his paper , in the present part of the Philosophical Transactions .
Observations .
( 25 .
) Arrangement .
Plate .
Medium .
Number of bands .
Glass .
Oil of Sassafras .
B to D. D to F. F to G. G to H. Total .
inch .
v=*5 No bands visible .
*34 Very fine and close .
I'17 Fine .
'08 Clear .
'04 Broad and clear .
6 14 21 24 65 *015 Very broad and faint .
Ii .
No bands .
( 26 .
) Oil of Cassia .
I. | o08 4 } Too fine to count .
0 4015 Fine .
15 29 32 Faint .
116 | II .
N_| I Lo bands .
___________l ________ __ Arrangement .
Plate .
Medium .
Number of bands .
Glass .
Oil of Cummin .
B to D. D to E. E to F. F to G. G to H. Total .
r ' ~~~inch .
__Faint .
I. |'r= 04 Broad .
005 11 { a } 31 II .
| INo bands .
( 28 .
) Oil of Turpentine .
I.No bands .
*08 Fine .
IL r Clear in the red ; ) 04 broader towards 14 20 15 10 59 Lblue.9_ __ __ __ _ ( 29 .
) Water .
I. No bands .
*04 , Too fine to count .
l. II* { Fine and faint ; 19 30 ? ?
22 ? ?
15 ? ?
86 ( 30 .
) IArrangement .
Plate .
Medium .
Number of bands .
Calc-spar ( by Oil of Cassia .
B to D. D to F. F to G. G to II .
natural cleavage ) .
II I Or the same result might perhaps be deduced more directly from considering that as 0 is polarized parallel , and E perpendicular to the principal section , and that the short diagonal of the Nicol-prism is horizontal when light polarized by reflexion from an horizontal surface is transmitted , -or that the short diagonal is perpendicular to the plane of polarization of the transmitted ray .
Then since when the short diagonal is perpendicular to the principal section of the calc-spar , the fine bands are stopped and the broad transmitted , it follows that the broad bands are polarized parallel to the principal section , or belong to 0 .
( 32 .
) Arrangement .
Plate .
Medium .
Number of bands .
diQulartz cut perpen .
Oil of Sassafras .
B to D. D to F. F to G. G to H. inch .
Too fine to count ; =15 FBands fine and clear , ) estimated at I. |Position vertical.( broader towards red 88 43 70 ? ?
80 ?
____ _iton 1. .
_ _,. .
I____ L..end _ __ ... ... ._ __ ... ... Position i ... ... Bands rather finer .
Position 2 ... .
With the plate inclined in position 1 , eight intervals of indistinctness ( extending over four or five bands each ) occur from H to about E ; from E to D the bands altogether become very faint : perhaps two such intervals may be discerned : from .
D to B no bands appear .
On applying a Nicol-prism , the intervals of indistinctness disappear at each quarter of a revolution .
Calculation .
( 33 .
) In all the following calculations for n by the formula ( 22 .
) , the values employed for the reciprocals of the wave-lengths of primary rays are as follows : l Ray..X(decimals of 1 French 1 Ray .
~~~inch ) .
B. *00002541 39354 D. *00002175 45977 E. *00001945 51413 F. *00001794 55741 G. 00001587 63011 H. *00001464 68306 The values of the term ( e " jm)r are interesting as expressing the absolute interval of route in wave-lengths of the two interfering rays , and thus , when compared with observation , conveying an idea of the extent to which the regularity of the undulations is kept up .
The indices here used are those contained in my " Report on Refractive Indices"* .
For glass I have assumed the indices of FRAUNHOFER'S crown glass , No. 9 .
Glass and Oil of Sassafras , a= 04 inch .
Ray .
|pP 1| pm .
f. PMz &gt; .
DfJ.=A .
| Remarks .
B. 1P526 1#526 000 D. 1.529 1-532 -003 138 5^5 5 F. 1.536 1^545 -009 501 -,20 -15 Hence in this case G. 1 542 1 557 -015 945 -37^8 -18 arrangement I. will H. 1-546 1 1569 -Q023 -1571 -62-8 25 give bands .
-65 ( 35 .
) Glass and Oil of Cassia ( Report , No. ii .
) , r=015 inch .
B. 1-526 11594 -068 2676 40 D. -529 1^607 --078 3586 54 14 F. 1-536 1^636 -100 5574 84 _ 30 G. 1-542 1-667 -125 7867 -118 34 H ere arrangement H. 1^546 1*702 -^156 -10656 -160 42 .
wi give ands .
-120 ( 36 .
) Glass and Oil of Cummin , 7r='04 inch .
B. 1l526 1-502 +-024 + 944 +3717 D. 1^529 1-507 + 022 +1011 +40-4 +2 E. 1#533 1^513 +^020 +1028 +40 8+1 here arrangement II .
would give bands F. 1536 1.520 +-016 + 891 +35 6 from B. to E , and G. 1 542 1P533 + 009 + 567 +22 6 -12 arrangement 1 .
from H. i 546 1P543 + 003 + 205 +8 -14 E to H. -32 ( 37 .
) We may remark that the indices for oil of cummin are all open to some uncertainty* , and it is easily found that a change in the indices of D and E of *001 only would give no bands between B and E with either arrangement ; for we should have .
on this suppositionRay .
PP .
PM .
St eP Pp r.nJ*p .
= .
Diff. Remarks .
B ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... .
+37-7 D ... ... .
P1508 + ?
021 +564 +38-5 0 No bands .
E ... ... .
1'514 +019 +976 +38-8 0l ( 38 .
) Glass and Oil of Turpentine , r= 04 inch .
B. 1.526 1 470 +-056 +2203 + 88 D. 1 529 1-474 +-055 +2528 +101 +13 F. 1-536 1 482 + 054 +3009 +120 +19 Hence arrangement G. 1I542 l1488 + 054 +3402 +136 +16 II .
will give bands .
H. 1-546 1 494 +-053 ? ?
3619 +145 +9 +57 Glass and Water , r==0J5 inch .
Ray .
PI .
PA(A ) A ' Diff.=n .
Remarks .
B. 11526 1-331 + 195 + 7672 + 115 D. 1.529 1-333 +196 + 9009 +135 +20 F. 1'536 1 337 + 199 + 11092 +166 +31 Hence arrangement G. 1-542 1-341 +201 +12663 +190 +24 II .
will give bands .
H. 11546 1 344 +202 +13796 +207 +17 +92 ( 40 .
) Calc-spar and Oil of Cassia , ordinary ray .
RUDBERG'S indices .
Ray .
PrmtP .
-A P M. D(ffrnRemarks .
_ P. .
_ .
_ B. 165 31 1 5945 +*0586 + 2306 +92 Hence with arrangeD .
1i6585 1-6073 +-0512 +2353 +94 +2 meant I. there will be no bands from F. 1 6680 1 6358 +*0322 +1794 +71 23 B to D , but bands G. 1-6762 1-6671 + 0091 + 573 +23 48 from D to H. H1 .
P6833 1-7025 --0192 +1311 -52 75 146 ( 41 .
) For the extraordinary ray , in a plate bounded by the planes of cleavage , Mr. STOKES has calculated the results as follows:"The incidence is supposed to be perpendicular ; that is , strictly , the rays B. , D , &amp;c. are supposed to be received in succession at a perpendicular incidence : but the results may be applied with very little error to the case in which rays of mean refrangibility are incident perpendicularly .
c ; The dihedral angle of the rhomnbohedron of calc-spar is 105 ? ?
5'* .
" If i be the inclination of the axis to the normal of the plate , we get by a spherical triangle , sin i= cos 520 32 ' 5 cosec 600 whence i=44V 36 ' 6 .
Nowt we have V=-a2 cos2 j+C2 sin2 i=a cos i see 0 where tan 0=a tan i= tan i , and if t'= vPOt '=pjo secicosd .
Also log tan i=9-99409 , and log see i= 10 14758 .
Hence log tan 0= log P'O log p'E +9 99409 log 4'-= log p.0-j log cos d+10 14758-20 .
PROFESSOfR POWELL ON A NEW CASE OF " In this manner we obtain the following table : ( 42 .
) Calc-spar and Oil of Cassia .
Extraordinary ray .
Ray .
4 Calc-spar Calc-spar O Cassia , of .
X1 Diff. R,..l.ay .
0 .
0.,.0. .
B. 1'6531 1'4839 47 42-0 i'5628 1'5945 -*0317 -1248 49'9 D. 116585 1'4863 44'8 1i5665 116073 -10408 -1876 75'0 25'1 F. 1*6680 1'4907 49'5 1'5731 iP6358 -0627 -3495 -1398 64'8 G. 116762 1P4945 5316 1'5787 116671 -'0884 -5570 -22288310 H. 116833 1-4978 5710 1'5837 1-7025 -1188 -8115 -324'6 -101,8 direction from the ~~~~~~~~~~275 " The diection considered being about 45 ?
from the axis , o ' ought to be nearly equal to the mean of a I 'd .
Now the values of p , ' found above , fall short of the mean of P ' , and R'E by the following quantities .
For B ... .0057 D ... .
059 F..'0062 G ... .
'0066 H ... .
e '0068 " The smallness and regularity of these numbers is a test of the correctness of the arithmetic .
" ( 43 .
) Quartz and Oil of Sassafras .
The angle of the prism being 60 ?
and the ray F at the minimum deviation , and As P ' being the angles of incidence and refraction for the first surface , we have for either pencil p/ F=300 , sin PF:'PF sin F , which gives F , and therefore p for the other rays ; also sin @'= &gt; gives p ' for the other rays .
If i be the angle of incidence on the plate then in position ( 1 ) ( see figs. 2 , 3 ) i=60 -I 'd and in position ( 2 ) i=p ' .
Then ( as in AIRY 's Tract , Art .
151 ) if i ' be the angle of refraction referring to the normal of the wave , we have a sin Z tan i'= where aC ( ho and vf = 7a2 cos2 il + c2 sin2 il UP and if V be the velocity in air , so that -v =p , and we take v , then - ?
=X and M being the retardation expressed by the number of waves ' lengths , we get MA Cos i ' ( v Cos ( i ) ) .
Also i ' is found to differ but little from 300 ( about 30 ' for the extreme rays ) and cos ( i-i')=-9999 , which may be put 1 .
Thus MA see i ' ( z - ) For the ordinary ray we have simply sin i'= -sin i0 and Msec I ( 44 .
) In this way the following results are obtained , =-l5 inch .
Ray .
Quartz Oil of Sas/ PM'me Posittion MMsito 1 .
i. * safras , M vertical n 13 .
1-5409 A5257 +-0152 +598 + 89-7 +103-4 D. 1P5441 15321 +-0120 +552 + 82,8 7+ 95 77 E. 1-5471 1-5387 + -0084 + 432 + 64 18 + 73,9 22 F. 1-5496 1-5448+ +0048 +267 + 40 24 + 46 28 G. 1-5542 1-5575 --0033 -9208 31 71 35-8 82 H. 1-5582 1-5693 -_0111 -758 -113 82 -131 95 90 2 234 ( 45 .
) For the extraordinary ray Mr. STOKES has made a calculation , of which the following are the principal steps and results .
From the expression above , v'=a cos I X , / +J tan2i ' ; and assuming tan d-a tan z\ -tan i ' , a whence v'= a cos i ' see 0 , V Z=-W Pjosec cos 0 .
To obtain x , assuming i ' approximately as differing little from i , which is near enough for this purpose , the following values result Ray .
~ Pssin p=p sin mu .
Pos. 1 .
Pos. 2 .
Ray . !
Posu g(1 ) .
Pos. ( 2 ) .
Sassafras. .
i=6)-ai .
i=2i B. 1-5409 1X5499 1P5430 1-5432 1-52575 30 25 29 35 30 25 D. 1-5442 1X5533 P 5464 1-5465 1P53215 30 16 30 29 43 30 30 16 30 E. 1-5471 1-5563 1-5494 1-5494 P-53870 30 30 80 29 52 0 30 30 80 F. 1-5496 ] 5589 1 5519 1 5519 1'54485 30 00 30 00 30 00 G. 1-5542 1X5636 1i5566 15565 155750 29 44 0 30 16 0 29 44 0 H. 1 5582 1P5677 P5607 1P5605 1*56935 29 29 0 30 31 0 29 29 0 ( 47 .
) Then with more accurate values of i ' we obtain , successively , sin i ' sin i. ___ Ray .
| 7 ' , j x-a .
| A~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ACos i ' A , Cos z ) , r=M.| Diff. Wf .
R ay .
1_________________________ Position 1 .
Position 2 .
Pos. ] .
Pos. 2 .
Pos. 1 .
Pos. 2 .
Pos. 1 .
Pos. 2 .
Pos. 1 .
Pos. 2 .
0i_0/ B. 29 13 0 30 20 +*0173 +*0175 +779 +795 +117 +119 D. 29 25 30 29 58 0+ 0143 +-0144 +754 +762 +113 +114 45 E. 29 38 30 29 54 + 0107 + 0107 +633 +634 + 95 + 95 -18 -19 F. 29 51 29 51 +'0071 +-0071 +451 +451 + 68 + 68 27 -27 G. 30 17 29 45 -0009 -0010 65 73 10 11 -78 -79 1-1 .
30 42 29 40 -o0086 -0088 -683 -694 -102 -104 -92 -93 Hence arrangement I. gives bands .
( 48 .
) For the ordinary ray with the plate vertical , the number of bands agrees well with observation as far as it goes .
It is obvious in general , that if two sets of bands differing in number be superposed , there will be a number of coincidences equal to their difference , separated by spaces of partial obliteration , which if the bands be of sensible breadth , will extend over several bands .
On comparing the above values of p for 0 and for E in position 1 , we findFrom B to E ... 2922= 7 } From E to 11. .
205-197= 8 =number of intervals of indistinctness .
From B to H ... 15 From E to H this agrees with observation , and may do so from B to E , occasioning a total disappearance of bands .
Postscript.-At the time the foregoing paper was communicated to the Royal Society , I had not seen Mr. STOKES'S paper ; nor in writing his , had he seen mine at length ; hence it will be found that there are some repetitions in the latter , of points mentioned in mine , but usually put in so much clearer a light that the reader will not regret the repetition .

