On the Chorda Dorsalis .
BY MARTIN BARRY , M.D. , F.R.SS .
L. and E. Received January 3 , -Read January 7 , 1841 .
FOR the discovery of the remarkable structure in the embryo of some of the Vertebrata denominated the chorda dorsalis , we are indebted to Professor BAER .
This naturalist considered it " the axis around which the first parts of the feetus form , " and " the true virga mensoria for the whole body and all the chief systemst .
" RE.iCHERT supposes it to be that embryonic structure which serves as a " support and stay " for parts developed in two halves+ .
In the course of my researches on the maminiferous ovum , an object was noticed which seems to correspond in appearance to the incipient chorda now referred to .
I am desirous of drawing attention to this similarity in appearance , but more particularly to point out some important differences between my own observations and those of others , as to the mode of origin of the objects in question , and their relation to surrounding parts .
For , should it be found that these objects are the same , mDy belief is that even the most recent views on the incipient growth of the embryo must undergo a change .
Before entering upon the comparison , I must ask the reader to place before him .
my Second Series of Researches in Embryology ?
, Plates VI .
VII .
and VIII .
; to certain of the figures in which I will now briefly refer .
The object bb , figs. 113 to 116 , is the rudimental embryo of the Rabbit in its earliest stage .
It is a finely granular , hollow sphere the nucleus of a cell .
Its centre , the nucleolus , is brilliantly pellucid .
The changes which this nuicleus undergoes are two-fold .
The one consists in the formation of a pointed process , as in fig. 121 D , which is sometimes , and perhaps generally , curved ; its concave side being directed towards the centre of the ovum .
In this state the rudimental embryo appears to correspond to what has been supposed to be the " primitive trace " in the ovum of the Bird .
The other change which this nucleus undergoes consists in the origin of fresh substance in its pellucid centre , and the expansion of its peripheral portion into cells .
Some of these cells occupy the area pellucida : others , coalescing , form a little sac ( fig. I1 7 .
bb21 .
) , which , expanding and receiving the yelk into its cavity , assumes the form of a network ( fig. 132 .
) , and lines the remainder of the ovum ( fig. 119 .
bb2 ' .
) .
f Ueber Entwickelungsgeschichte der Thiere .
Beobachtung und Reflexion , 1828 .
Taf .
I. fig. II .
III .
a. p. 15 .
+ Das Entwickelungsleben , 1840 , p. 108.-The chorda dorsalis has received other names ; viz. Chorda vertebralis , Riickensaite , Spinalsaite , Wirbelsaite .
6 Philosophical Transactions , , 1839 , Part II .
p. 307 .
This two-fold change is but the commencement of a series of metamorphoses , by which the minute object bb of fig. 113 , is converted into the objects bbl , bb2 , and bb2 ' , collectively , of fig. 122 .
For it is to be remarked that there is a continual origin of fresh substance in the centre ; by which means previously formed parts are pushed further out .
These parts consist of cells arranged in layers ( fig. 122 .
) each cell )eing the seat of a process essentially the same ( fig. , 149 .
) .
As the cells are pushed into a more external situation , they expand and become pale ; while in the centre the continued origin of new and unexpanded cells , presents the appearance of a row of globules , nearly black ( fig. 122 .
) .
The larger end ( fore-end ) of this row of globules is spherical , and , as we have seen , has a minute pellucid centre .
It is this row of globules , in the mammiferous ovum , which I think must correspond to BAER 's incipient chorda dorsalis of the Bird , described by him in the following passage .
c " The chorda dorsalis , " he says , " originally consists of a simple row of dark globules , which towards the fore-end are more closely pressed together , and towards the hinder end more separated.***It becomes thicker and darker , from an increase in the number of its globules .
The fore-end is at a very early period developed into a round , much thicker knob ; and hence the whole chorda resembles a very fine needle with a minute headt .
" Although the object thus described by BAER , as seen in the ovum of the Bird , presents a sufficiently close resemblance to that which I had delineated and have just described in the mammiferous ovum , to warrant the belief that both objects are the same , yet there are some important differences between the two descriptions.-VON BAER speaks of the " 1 fore-end " of his incipient chorda as becoming " at a very early period developed into a round , much thicker knob .
" With me , on the contrary , the linear portion proceeds from the round and thicker knob.-Again , he makes no mention of the remarkable pellucid cavity , contained within this round and thicker knob -a part of prime importance , if it be , as my observations show , the main centre for the origin of new substance .
Whether these differences between the objects of our respective descriptions really exist ( supposing them to be the same objects ) , or whether , if the embryo of the Bird were examined in a sufficiently early stage , it would not be found to begin in the way I have described as producing the embryo of the Mammal , future observation must determine .
VON BAER farther says that his row of dark globules is " surrounded by a pellucid border : " and that " the border is seen from all sides , " being therefore " a sheath for the chorda .
Originally the chorda and its sheath are one+ .
" How far these particulars accord with my observations , will be seen on reference to figs. 121 to 123 .
VON BAER considered the chorda to arise simultaneously with his " laming dorsales ; " and this by " 1 a separation of the [ supposed ] primitive trace into two lateral halves ( the laminae dorsales ) and a middle streak ( the chorda)+ .
" The separation here mentioned , I can regard as no other than the pushing out of the lateral portions of the so-called " primitive trace , " by the formation of fresh substance in the interior ( compare with my fig. 122 .
) .
If so , the formation of BAER'S incipient chorda is not simultaneous with , but subsequent to , that of his " laminge dorsales .
" ( The " laminae dorsales " of BAER correspond to REICHERT'S " central nervous system .
" ) VON BAER describes the chorda as " the axis , around which the first parts of the foetus formt .
" The dark pin-like object we have been considering in the mammiferous ovum , presents merely one of the many layers of incipient cells into which a nucleus becomes resolved .
Notwithstanding these differences , however , facts mentioned by authors regarding the chorda dorsalis at later periods I think afford evidence of the identity of the two objects in question , as will be seen by what follows .
RATHKE states that in osseous fishes the chorda dorsalis is enclosed in a membranous sheath ; and that from this sheath there grow in pairs a great number of minute filaments , which are the incipient crura of the arches of the vertebrae .
' The foundations of the bodies of the vertebrae appear , from the description given by this author , to consist of minute tables or traces , which proceed out of the vertebral arches ; and he adds , that " the thickening and ossification of the vertebrae take place at the expense of the enclosed nucleus of the chordat .
" REICHERT , in his researches on the development of the Batrachian Reptile and the Bird , found the chorda to decline more and more as the vertebral system advanced in its formation ? .
" The chorda , " says this author , " is reduced in proportion as ossification proceeds , until for the most part only its remains are to be found between the vertebrae II .
" It is known that the chorda dorsalis in a comparatively advanced state is composed of cells .
For this discovery we are indebted to Professor J. MULLER .
SCHWANN has since found the characteristic nucleus in its cells ? .
" If we closely examine , " says this observer , " the outer rind of the chorda in Pelobatesfuscus-covered as this rind is with scattered grains we find these grains closely to resemble the nuclei of cells ; only that they are about half the size .
They are besides oval , and furnished with a nucleolus .
This rind is not distinctly separated from the proper tissue of the chorda dorsalis : and as the cells of the latter rapidly diminish in size towards the rind , I believe these grains of the rind to be the cytoblasts of flattened down cells , which form the rind++ .
" I think there is a great deal in what has now been quoted from these authors , that t L. c. , p. 15 .
I BURDACH'S Physiologie als Erfahrungswissenschaft , 1837 , Band II .
pp. 279-281 . ?
L. c. , p. 68 .
11 L. c. , p. 71 .
1 ?
Mikroskopische Untersuchungen uiber die Uebereinstimmungen in der Struktur und dem Wachsthum der Thiere und Pflanzen , 1838 , 1839 , Tab. I. fig. 4 .
1t L. c. , p. 12 .
It is deserving of notice that SCHWANN conjectures the chorda dorsalis to contain no vessels .
shows a " growing from " the sheath , as it is called , of the chorda , - " at the expense of its enclosed nucleus , " -or as the chorda is " found to decline , even in these the last stages of this structure .
But if we examine it at periods anterior to these , I think we shall find still stronger grounds for believing , that the chorda dorsalis of authors , in an early state , corresponds to the pin-like object in the mammiferous ovum which I have been comparing with it .
REICHERT seems to have been led to form the opinion above-mentioned , that the chorda serves as a " support and stay " for parts developed in two halves , by the following observations ; namely , that the chorda becomes visible as a single structure at the same time as the foundations , in two halves , of the central nervous system ; and that the central nervous system on the one hand , and his Membrana intermedia on the other , are so intimately connected by means of the chorda , that it is not possible to separate them .
~He even states , that the chorda passes into the foundation of the embryo .
Farther , REICHERT says , " There are developed on the chorda dorsalis the original halves of the central nervous system , with the higher organs of sense , separating as these do from the central nervous systemt .
" He states that , with a union of the two halves of the central nervous system-such union taking place first at the foreend-there is observed a decline in the corresponding part of the chorda .
On the subject of the mnembrana intermedia , the same author remarks , that it is found between the central nervous system and the mucous membrane ; and that it ( the membraua intermedia ) " is the common original foundation of all structures , systems , and organs , which are the means of operation for the two central organs of animal life .
Hence from it [ the membrana intermedia ] there are developed the vertebral system , the dermal system , the circulating system , and finally , all the structures which support the mucous membrane , and which , " says he , " I comprehend under the name of system of the intestinal membrane 4 .
" It would thus seem , according to REICHERT , that there is little in the embryo which is not developed out of either the central nervous system , or the membrana intermedia .
But these are the very parts which the same observer found so intimately connected by means of the chorda , that it was not possible to separate them .
And it appears to be these same parts called by REICHERT " the foundation of the embryo , " into which he says " the chorda passes .
" Taking then the observations of BAER , RATHKE , and REICHERT , in connection with my own , I venture to believe , that it is not enough to say , with BAER , that the chorda dorsalis is the axis around which the first parts of the feetus form ; nor , with RET-t L. c. , pp. 58 , 59 .
+ L. C. , p. 107 .
" Da die ferneren Doppel-gebilde , " says REICHERT , " sammtlich von der membrana intermedia ausgehen , so tritt die Wirbelsaite [ chorda dorsalis ] in die innigste Beziehung zu der Letzteren .
" to denominate it a support and stay for surrounding parts : but that it is the continually renewed central portion of the nucleus of a cell , it being out of this nucleus that the embryo arises:in other words , that growth at the earliest periods consists , not in external additions , but in the continual origin of new substance in the centre , by which means previously formed substance is pushed farther out .
The nucleus of every cell , also , of which the embryo is composed , seems to be the seat of a like process ; that is , a subordinate point for the origin of new substance .
The origin of the embryo from the nucleus of a cell , may assist to solve a question on which , I believe , physiologists are not agreed .
" The primitive trace , " says VALENTIN , " as well as the***chorda dorsalis , has been made use of by BAER and BURDACH against SERRES , BOURDON , and others , to show that the first rudiments of the parts are not two halves , but a whole , which subsequently splits into two oppositely situated halves .
Such positions , however , " VALENTIN adds , " are altogether more adapted for metaphysical acumen , and cannot , and never will , be settled by experience and observation ; since by this we do not learn the act of arising itself , -it shows no more than an arisen turn in the formation.***Such problems must remain far from the province of the observing part of anatomy and physiologyf .
" I am here compelled to express a different opinion from that of Professor VALENTIN .
The subject in question seems to me very properly to belong to the province of observation .
But then it is essential that observation should be directed to a period earlier than that with which physiologists have usually begun .
By this means it seems possible actually to observe , that if the nucleus of a cell is a single object , the first rudiments of the embryo are not two halves .
Unless the condition just mentioned be fulfilled , namely , an investigation of the earliest periods , it is in vain that we attempt to learn what it is of which the rudiments of the embryo are composed .
It appears to have been because of the non-fulfilment of this condition , that physiologists supposed their " primitive trace " to arise in the substance of a membrane .
And to the same cause seems referable the opinion recently advanced by REICHERT , that the first traces of the new being are derived from cells of the yelk .
t Handbuch der Entwickelungsgeschichte des Menschen mit vergleichender RUcksicht der Entwickelung der Siugethiere und Vogel , 1835 , p. 156 .
+ REICHERT very properly denies that the embryo arises in the substance of a membrane ; and it is gratifying to me to find an observation previously published by myself confirmed by this talented investigator .
Dr. REICHERT , however , does not seem to be aware that he had been anticipated in this discovery , as he will perceive on reference to the " Proceedings " of the Royal Society , April 18 , 1839 , published at that time , and copied into several periodicals , among which may be mentioned VON FRoRIEP'S " Notizen , " No. 228 , July 1839 , p. 116 .

