On Ground Gru , or Ice formed , under peculiar circumstances , at the bottom of Running Water .
By JAMES FARQUHARSON , LL. D. F.R.S. , Minister of the Parish of Alford .
Received March 1 1 , -Read March 25 , 1841 .
IN a paper of mine on Ground Gru , or ice formed at the bottom of running water , which was honoured with a place in the Philosophical Transactions* , I had inferred , from a great many conditions attending a remarkable occurrence of the phenomenon in the rivers Don and Leochal , in the beginning of January 1835 , as well as from its occurring only when the air is at the time quite clear , that it is caused , when the water has gone down in temperature to the freezing point , by the bottom of the water being cooled to a still lower temperature , in the same manner as the surface of the dry land , under a clear sky , is cooled down below the temperature of the air , as first demonstrated by the experiments of Dr. WELLS .
As the accuracy of the conclusion at which I arrived respecting the question has been controverted , I respectfully request the Royal Society to permit me to present to them brief notices of some recent occurrences of ground gru , in the same rivers to which I formerly referred , the conditions of which seem to me strongly to confirm the accuracy of the views I presented regarding the cause of the phenomenon ; and also to answer some of the objections which have been brought against it .
Cold weather commenced on the 20th December 1840 ( on which night the thermometer went down to 31 ?
) , and continued with frost every night , yet never below 260 , and with frost also through most of the day , till the 31st of the same month .
By the 26th December , surface ice in considerable quantity was formed on the edges of the small river Leochal , and the temperature of the water was down to the freezing point .
Down to the evening of the 28th the weather was cloudy , and there was no appearance in the river of anything resembling ground gru ; but on that night the sky suddenly became clear ; and before the morning of the 29th , the bottoms of all the rapids of the little river were thickly coated by the ground gru .
The gru disappeared as speedily as it had formed , when , on the 29th , a close cloud , depositing slight showers of snow , again covered the whole sky , and continued till the temperature of the day and night rose above freezing .
In coinparison with this , I would refer to a series of frosty days from , the 1st to the 11t ih of February 184 1 , with a temperature the same as from the 22nd to 31 st December , 1840 , never descending below 260 .
The water of the river descended to the freezing temperature , and surface ice was formed in large quantity on the edges of both the Leochal and the Don .
A dense cloud covered the sky during the eleven days and nights , and no ground gru appeared in the rivers .
A remarkable occurrence of ground gru took place in both the rivers from the evening of the 7th to the morning of the 9th January 1841 , with a completely clear sky during the time .
The thermometer was at 2 ?
below zero on the night of the 7th , at 90 at mid-day on the 8th , and at 70 below zero on the night of the sth .
I ex. amined particularly the state of the Don , during this extreme and clear frost , before it abated on the morning of the 9th .
The bottom of the river was everywhere coated by an immense quantity of ground gru , excepting where it was partially shaded by bridges , or lofty banks close to the stream .
In the partially shaded places the bottom was clear of gru .
Thus this remarkable formation of ground gru took place under exactly such circumstances -as those in which hoar-frost or dew takes place on the dry land , when the surface of the earth becomes colder than the air , ( which we explain by a radiation of heat from the surface of the earth into the clear sky , or by impulses of cold from the sky to the earth , ) with only this difference , that there was an additional transparent fluid over the bottom of the river , namely , the water ; and thus also a shade prevented the formation of ground gru in the river , as it does that of hoar-frost or dew on the land .
In noticing the objections to the explanation I have given of the cause of ground gru , I shall confine myself to those brought forward by a writer in the Penny Cyclopaedia , under the name of Ground Gru , which I have seen only very lately , although I believe they have been published for some years .
He says the explanations of the formation of ground gru , given by Dr. FARQUHARSON and Mr. EISDALE , are least of all satisfactory , and adds , " T'he former gentleman says it is the result of radiation , and endeavours to substantiate his reasoning upon the principles of the formation of dew , seeming to forget entirely , that Dr. WELLS maintains expressly , that wind and shade are alike obstacles to radiation ; and that consequently a body of moving water so deep as to be impervious to light , and particularly when covered , as in the case of the Neva , with a sheet of ice three feet thick , and as much more snow , must present an insurmountable obstacle to the radiation of heat from the bottom of the river .
" Now , in the first place , with respect to shade ; I was so far from forgetting that it is an obstacle to radiation , that , on the contrary , in my observations in 1835 , I had shown by very many instances , that shade had prevented the formation of ground gru , just as it prevents dew .
Wherever shade intervened to prevent radiation from the bottoms of the rivers Don and Leochal , there no ground ice was formed ; while the unshaded parts of the bottoms were coated with it .
My explanation thus mainly rested upon the fact that shade prevents radiation .
In the next place , with respect to wind ; the writer in the Cyclopeedia himself forgets the difference of the statical conditions of air and water in connexion with temperature .
Air becomes heavier by diminution of temperature .
Water under 390 FAHR. becomes lighter by diminution of temperature .
During wind , on the land , the cold air at the surface of the earth is continually mixed with , or displaced by , the warmer air above ; and by this process both the earth and air in contact with it are prevented from being reduced to a very low temperature by radiation .
But in a body of moving water , whose temperature is under 390 , the eddies of the current throw down the coldest parts , which in still water would remain at the surface , to come into contact with the bottom .
This last circumstance is the explanation of M. ARAGO ; and it well accounts for the formation of ground gru taking place first in the most rapid parts of the streams ; although neither by itself , nor when taken in conjunction with the other two circumstances to which he refers , namely , aptitude to formation of crystals on asperities at the bottom , and less impediment to the formation of crystals in a slower motion , will it account for the formation of ground gru , as all these circumstances are present when the water forms only surface ice .
The formation of ground gru requires for its explanation an additional element , namely , the radiation , into the clear sky , of heat from the bottom of the river ; and the formation never occurs but under a clear sky .
As to the ground gru , observed by Colonel JACKSON in the Neva under three feet of ice and three feet of snow , that can form no valid objection to the explanation I have given , unless it were ascertained that the gru was formed after the surface ice and the fall of the snow , and not before them .
All rivers issuing from lakes , like the Neva , have very clear waters to admit of radiation through them , although as deep as it is ; and all rivers are very clear during frost , owing to the freezing up of the little land rills that would convey earthy particles into them .
Ground gru formed in the Neva would be much more permanent than in our rivers .
The mean temperature of Alford is 450 FAHR. , and that of the earth of course the same ; and on the remission of its cause , the ground gru is here speedily detached from the bottom , by the transmission of heat from below .
Not so in the Neva .
There , according to KUPFFER , the mean temperature is only 38 ?
75 ; and under the action of a frost so severe as to form three feet depth of ice , although the condition of the clear slky mightnot continue , previously formed gru would , at that mean temperature , be of great permanence .
This applies also to the Siberian rivers .

