An Account of Experinents on the Refecting Telescope .
By the Right Honourable Lord OXMANTOWN , F.R.S. , 8sc .
Received May 9 , -Read June 18 , 1840 .
FOR several years I have been engaged in a series of experiments , in the hope of increasing the power of the telescope , and I am induced , perhaps rather prematurely , to lay some account of them before the Royal Society , conceiving that , from the scale upon which they have been carried on , and perhaps from their results , they may prove interesting , particularly to those who have devoted their attention to such subjects .
I should have been glad to have postponed this communication to a more distant time , so as to have rendered it in many respects more complete , but as expeliinents on a large scale are necessarily very tedious ( months , even years , passing away almost imperceptibly ) , to have done so would have been to have postponed it indefinitely , and to have withheld facts which may perhaps be useful to those who are engaged in similar pursuits .
All the experiments I am about to describe relate solely to the Reflecting Telescope .
With the exception of a few trifling experiments many years ago on fluid object-glasses , which led to no result , I have not had any experience in the construction of the refractor .
I have long thought that in the present state of knowledge there was not much plrospect of improving the refractor to any considerable extent ; the fluid object-glass , at least in my hands , did not appear promising , and the improvemrents which have been made in the manufacture of glass on the continent , seem to have effected little more than to afford the means of constructing larger discs of tolerably perfect glass , than was formerly practicable ; still wanting , however , that exact homogeneity , and indeed those optical properties essential to any great increase of power .
Upon the whole , therefore , there seemed to 'me to be but little chance of effecting anything really important in the present state of astronomy , except by improving the reflecting telescope ; to that object , therefore , every effort was directed .
The task was evidently a very difficult one , as the late Sir W. HERSCHEL had apparently almost exhausted the subject , having devoted to it acquirements the most varied and extensive , and at the same time the most suitable , during a very long life .
Still it did not seem impossible that , profiting by his labours , and imitating his example of steady perseverance , some advance might be made , trifling perhaps , but eventually leading to valuable results .
The great object seemed to be , to rernove , as far as possible , the causes , owing to which , in increasing the size , much of the perfection of smaller instruments had invariably been sacrificed .
For instance , to avoid the brittleness of the best speculum metal , it had been found necessary , as the dimensions were increased , to use an increased proportion of copper , so that the alloy was inferior in brilliancy , yellower , and much more liable to tarnish* .
In polishing large surfaces also there were great and peculiar difficulties , all the defects having a tendency to augment rapidly with the size , and proportionately to impair the defining power .
I thought , therefore , that were it possible to discover means of securing , in the construction of large instruments , the same excellence of material and accuracy of surface , which on a small scale was attainable by the processes already published , much would be gained ; btut even in the construction of small instruments there was no reason to suppose that the utmost limits of perfection had already been attained .
On the contrary , the unequal performance of specula wrought with the utmost skill by the same hand , and with the same materials , was a fact which clearly prloved that certainty of effect , the usual characteristic of a perfect mechanical operation , was still to be sought for .
It was evident , therefore , that there was ample room for experiment with a prospect of solme success .
With these views , the first experiments were undertaken : they were on a small scale , the earliest as far back as 1827 , and some account of them appeared at the time in Sir DAVID BREWSTER'S Journal for July 1828 .
Since that time , the scale was gradually increased , till an aperture of three feet was attained , beyond which as yet I have not proceeded .
I should , perhaps , however , remark here , that although these experiments were exceedingly numerous , they were not near so tedious as might be supposed from the length of time that has elapsed since their commencement ; for in the midst of other avocations , long interruptions occurred , so that probably more might have been accomplished in one-third of the timte employed continuously : there is nothing , therefore , really calculated to deter others , who have the means , from devoting t their time to the improvement of the reflector : the joint labour of many may effect much , and the object is of no less importance than the advancement of those inquiries in practical astronomy , in which for further progress we must now look solely to an increase in the optical power of instruments .
In describing these experiments , it will be necessary to enter somewhat into detail , so as to enable others to repeat them without much difficulty ; and as success often depends upon attention to minute particulars which have only been obselrved after repeated failures , it will be impossible to be as concise as it would otherwise be desirable ; nothing , however , shall be inserted which has not been repeatedly tried with care , and is not calculated , either by its success or failure , to be practically useful : and first as to the best materials for constructing the reflecting surface .
On this subject many experiments have been tried , but upon the whole I have little to add to what is generally known : tin and copper , the materials employed by NEWTON in the first reflecting telescope , are preferable to any other with which I am acquainted ; the best proportions being four atoms of copper to one of tin ( TURNER'S numbers ) , in fact , 126'4 parts of copper to 58'9 of tin .
This alloy , however , as well as every specimen of speculum metal I have ever examined , is visibly porous when carefully testeed with a microscope ; a very high power is not necessary : CODDINGTON'S microscope , even with its lowest power , is generally sufficient ; with his highest power always so .
When the copper is very impure , and the alloy has been much heated , then the pores are often easily perceptible to the naked eye : contrary , however , to what might have been inferred from this , by making the copper and tin chemically pure , we do not get rid of them altogether ; pores can still be detected by the microscope , even when the metal has been melted at the lowest temperature .
Good cast steel is free from pores , but cannot be hardened without cracking when of considerable dimensions : all copper is , I believe , porous , tin not so .
NEWTON , with his usual acuteness , observed this porousness in speculum metal , and considered it a serious defect ; and , although , where the process of polishing is conducted in the best manner , the evil which he had apprehended , viz. the rounding of the edges of the cavities , is not perceptible , still it is probable that it always takes place in some degree , however trifling , producing a defect so mixed up with other unavoidable errors as to remain undetected .
The smallest defect , however , deserves attention , and perhaps others may succeed in discoveting the cause of this , which I have not : my experiments lead me to think it is in some way connected with the presence of carbon or oxygen ; and that possibly by watching the toughening of copper on a great scale , a process which chemistry has not satisfactorily explained , some information might be obtained .
Upon the whole , therefore , there is at present no sufficient reason for making use of copper in any other state than that in which it can be procured from the merchant , except perhaps for the small flat metals of the Newtonian ; and with block-tin in the proper proportions , we have upon the whole the best material yet discovered for the specula of reflecting telescopes .
It is , however , an alloy which has always been found rather difficult to manage ; it is not easily cast sound , even of moderate dimensions , by the ordinary processes of the founder , or by those which have been published by scientific men ; and even when so cast is very liable to break in cooling , or afterwards by exposure to any slight but sudden change of temperature , sometimes breaking even without any apparent cause .
The difficulties appeared so great , that reflecting upon SMEATON'S account of Sir W. HERSCHEL'S labours , I had very little hope that any very large specula could be cast and safely polished of so brittle and untractable a material ; and although some of the difficulties have been surmounted , still it is probable , that in seeking to obtain the utmost possible amount of telescopic power the state of our atmosphere admits of , the requisite dimensions will not be attained by a simple casting of this alloy .
The idea , therefore , obviously suggested itself of uniting several castings into one re flecting surface , and as the best means of effecting that , to solder them upon an alloy of zinc and copper , ( in fact , upon a species of brass , ) which should expand and contract in the same proportion as speculum metal .
The experiment was tried repeatedly upon a small scale , and the difficulties which presented themselves successively surmounted , till at length a speculum of three feet aperture was completed , which bears distinctly a high power .
The evil most to be apprehended in this construction , was unequal contraction and expansion in the different changes of atmospheric temperature ; that , however , seems to have been sufficiently guarded against , as I have never succeeded in detecting the slightest change of figure .
It is therefore highly probable , that specula very much larger may be constructed upon this plan , and that , in fact , by repeating a number of operations , each on a scale perfectly manageable , we may obtain a reflecting surface the most brilliant , and at the same time as large as can ever be usefully employed in astronomical researches .
I will now proceed with the details of the construction of the three-feet speculum .
I had previously ascertained that an alloy consisting of about 2-75 of copper to 1 of zinc , gave the same contractions and expansions as speculum metal ; it was necessary , however , to repeat the measurement with care , using the identical materials which were to be employed in the construction of the speculum .
The following simple contrivance for obtaining the relative contractions and expansions of a bar of speculum metal , and different alloys of zinc and copper , had been employed in the previous experiments , and was again resorted to .
A bar was cast of speculur metal fifteen inches long , and one inch and a quarter square ; similar bars , but only three-fourths of an inch thick , were cast of the alloys to be tried , containing a little more or less zinc than the proportions I have given .
A piece of brass , consisting of 2'75 of copper to 1 of zinc , was also cast and soldered to the bar of speculum metal , as represented in Plate .
fgure f 1 , where AB is speculum metal , CD brass , and OF the bar of alloy , with a small excavation in the lower end fitted by grinding , so as to rest steadily on thie hemispherical disc G ; a thin slip of brass was also soldered at the upper end of the bar of speculum metal , and the two bars made to fit neatly there , so that when brtought together , a very fine line could be drawn across them with scarcely any troublesomne patrallax at the joint ; the whole was then immersed almost to the top in a tin vessel of water of the temperature of the atmosphere , and that vessel placed in another mruch larger , also containing water .
Pieces of ice were then dropped into the outer vessel , so that the temperatute of the whole was evenly and gradually brought down nearly to 320 ; and a straight line , as fine as possible , was then drawn across both bars , and examined with a microscope to ascertain that it was perfect .
The termperature was then gradually raised by pouring hot water into the outer vessel until nearly 212Q had been attained , and the line was again examined with a microscope , and wherle the alloy had been made by mixing 2'74 of copper with 1 of zinc , and the loss in melting amotnted to j oth of the whole , the continuity of the line was not broken in that Iange of temperature ; according , 506 Phif .
/ wns .
M Nf1/ - ) ( A( 1 , P/ 'ih .
p.t/ b5o6 ' &gt; / q , , J / .
, .
ibii .
/ . . ?
7i : .
f. , / / Sf s7 ' W Ic , c c. 4'1 " i ?
i &lt; / i JnI however , as the proportion of the zinc was more or less , the expansion of the brass bar was greater or less than that of speculum metal .
As speculum inetal and brass cannot be soldered together , except on a very small scale , with certainty by the ordinary methods practised in the arts , it may be useful to mention , that all that is necessary is , first , to fit the brass and speculum metal nicely , by filing or grinding , according to circumstances ; the brass is then to be tinned , and suffered to cool ; the sureface of the speculum metal should be scraped lightly with a sharp chisel all over ; the two surfaces are to be placed in contact , and matters so managed , that a slight pressure may be applied after the fusion of the tin , and continued until it has again become solid ; the temperature should then be gradually raised till the tin melts ; and then , but not till then , resin applied in fusion , and also a little melted tin ; if resin or tin is applied in the solid state , owing to their rapid absorption of heat in becoming fluid , they will crack the speculum metal : the surfaces may be slightly separated , so as to ascertain that the speculum metal is tinned all over , which will be the case when the temperature reaches 400 ?
: the whole must then be suffered to cool gradually .
In casting the alloy of zinc and copper , some precautions are also necessary , not practised and not required in the arts .
At the commencement of these experiments , a difficulty occurred which for some time I failed in overcoming ; in making the alloy of zinc and copper , and recasting it when made , much of the zinc was always volatilized , and the amount lost differed considerably each time , though the process was conducted as nearly as possible in a similar manner , so that it was impossible to allow for it , and the composition of the alloy was therefore uncertain ; a fatal objection to the whole process .
The furnace was the ordinary brass-founder 's furnace , the air furnace of the chemist .
I found , however , that the zinc was not volatilized in its metallic state ; its affinity for the copper was sufficient to prevent that , but it was first oxydized .
To prevent the fresh air from beating down upon the crucible whenever the lid of the furnace was removed , the furnace was made much deeper ; this was of great use , but still the air which had passed through the fuel retained oxygen enough to act considerably on the zinc .
Charcoal was next heaped over the crucible , still this was not effectual ; at length , charcoal in fine powder was tried in a layer two inches thick on the surface of the metal , occasionally renewed ; this was effectual .
The crucible , therefore , must not be filled completely , and the charcoal dust can be conveniently thrown into it , whenever required , folded up in paper .
If the process has been conducted with these precautions , the loss will be about.i8th , and almost exactly the same each casting .
The proportions of the zinc and copper having been determined , the brass work was first cast .
By a reference to figures 2 , 3 , and 4 , Plate XX .
, it will be at once seen in what way the materials were disposed of .
Figure 2 .
represents one-eighth part of the whole seen in the reverse , a single casting ; fig. 3 .
the whole speculum , also seen in the reverse ; and fig. 4 .
the speculum seen on the opposite side previous to the soldering 3T2 507 on of the plates of speculum metal ; fig. 5 .
the speculum complete , faced with sixteen plates of speculum metal .
The whole depth of the brass work was five inches and a half , and weight about four hundred and fifty pounds ; the sides IB ( fig. 2 .
) were made square and true , and then tinned , and the whole bolted together with iron bolts , as represented in the figure ; the temperatiure was then raised till the tin was in fusion , and the bolts tightened to the utmost , so as to make close joints ; in this state the speculunr was turned , plated with speculumn metal , and polished ; but it was found that the joints had not been sufficiently seciured , owing to which the bracing had not produced its proper effect , and flexute was quite pereeptible by its effects in the different positions of the telescope ; on a close examination , there was reason to suspect that the solder was not everywhere perfect , though it had been so originally ; that in the rough operation of bolting to the lathe and turning , it had been in some places detached , and had not subsequently united , though it had necessarily been fulsed when the plates of speculumn metal were soldered on : it was evident , therefore , that tin alone was not to be depended upon in putting together a speculurn of this size .
The iron bolts , of course , contracting less than the brass , had added nothing to the security of the joints ; brass bolts had been tried formert lie in consttructing a specululn two feet diameter , but they were not strong enough to bring the joints close , and were replaced by iron ones .
The plates of specullum metal were , therefore , taken off , and the joints sectured in the following manner .
The whole mass of brass work was imbedded in casting sand everywhere in contact with it ; over it there were about three inches of sand .
The sand was then rermoved from the centre , so as to expose a circular surface of about one inch and a half in diamtneter , and about forty-five pounds of very hot mnelted brass , in the same proportions as the brass speculu , were poured uponl it in a continued streamtn from a perpendicular height of about ten inches : the sand having been so arranged , that after the mnelted brass had reached the depth of two inches , the remainder continued to flow off ; the melted brass as it began to cool was therefore continually replaced with hot brass ; and from the height at which it was poured , it was necessarily in imnmediate contact with the sturface of the cold metal , and soon completely fused it , and perfectly united it in that place .
This was repeated in thirtyfour different places , marked by dots in the figures : it was also try ( I in the places markedc , ,(fig.3 .
) but failed .
When the redundant brass had been renoved with a saw , and the surface made smooth , a slight hair crack was perceptible at the boundary of the fused metal , proceeding no doubt from expansion and contraction after the brass had ceased to be fluid , but before it had become ductile .
This process is made use of by the brass-founder in stopping holes in defective castings ; he calls it burning .
The failure of this process at the places marked c , c , is a fact which it would be important to keep in view in dlisposing of the parts of a large speculumn .
As it was desirable that sonie further attemnpt should be made to secure the joint at c , c , holes of about one inch and a half in diamreter were bored completely through at c , and the 508 intermediate brass chiseled out , as represented in the figure .
They were then filled with melted brass , which was easily effected by imbedding the whole in sand ; clearing the sand completely out of the spaces , and pouring the brass into each through a hole in a flat suIrface of sand packed in a small flask ; when the brass cooled , the contraction was sufficient to draw the joint firmly together .
This process may , possibly in engineering , prove usefuil as a means of connecting large masses of metal : I am not aware of its having before been put in practice .
Conceiving that any further yielding in the joints was now impossible , the speculum was again placed on the lathe and turned to a radius of fifty-four feet , and new plates of speculum Inetal prepared for it .
Notwithstanding the small dimensions of these plates , none exceeding nine inches square , more difficulty was originally experienced in casting them than could have been anticipated .
A great many unsuccessful attempts were made to cast them in sand , according to the directions of Mr. EDWARDS and others ; they were seldom free from flaws , and , although cooled very slowly in an oven , they were extreminely brittle , sometimes flying in pieces the moment they were touched , and generally breaking in the attempt to heat them again for soldering .
The cause of this brittleness was evident , as the broken parts when replaced no longer fitted exactly , the metal therefore had been in a state of tension , owing no doubt to the edges of the plates becoming solid sooner than the centre .
The next plan tried was this : a number of equidistant thin plates of iron were immersed in a square crucible of cast iron filled with fluid speculum metal , so as to divide the whole mass into plates of equal thickness : this failed altogether , the plates of speculum metal were full of flaws ; their contraction had been prevented by the unavoidable irregularities of the plates of iron , and crucible .
Another plan was then tried , more successful than any of the preceding .
A circular sawing machine was constructed , the blades were of soft iron , and while revolving were always partially iminersed in emery and water ; with this a block of speculum metal was without much difficulty cut into plates , which were perfectly free from flaws , and not liable to crack .
Still their texture was not uniformn ; for about thtree quarters of an inch from their edges the arrangement of the particles was different from what it was in the remainder ; so much so , that thie edge of the plates for that distance evidently resisted the action of emery more thian the remainder , and therefore probably a speculuni made of such plates would not eventually be as true as if they were free from that defect .
Upon this point , however , I cannot speak quite decisively ; from what I have observed I have strong reasons to think it is so ; but were it of any imiportance to determine it , further experiments would be necessary .
I have a speculum two feet aperture formed of such plates ; it was however polished long ago , and I have not a polishing tool of the constrtuction I now make use of , of the proper size ; so it has not had a fair trial .
The samrne plates were also originally used for the three-feet speculum I am describing , but when it becarxme necessary further to secure the joints , 509 they were taken off and spoiled , and in the meantime another process suggested itself , which seetned to be decidedly preferable .
It was evident that the flaws of so frequent occurrence in the plates formerly cast , and also their extreme brittleness , arose from the contraction of the metal in sorme places more than others , just at the time of transition from the fluid to the solid state .
The edge of the plates always became solid first , and the central portions thus prevented from contracting were strained when no longer ductile .
Were it possible , therefore , to satisfy the following conditions , viz. that heat should be abstracted rapidly and equally from the lower surface of a fluid disc of speculum metal , so that it should solidify from the bottom upwards in strata , or rather infinitely thin laminae , the surface being the last to solidify , we should have a perfect casting ; for the particles in that case being deposited , not uniformly , indeed , owing to the unknown action of the forces of crystallization , but in such a way as to fill up the interstices , there would be no flaws ; and the temperature being uniform in a horizontal direction , and in the vertical varying in reagular gradation from the lower surface to the upper , there would be no strain .
This , I believe , is the true principle upon which the most perfect castings can be obtained : its truth has been fully proved by practice ; and , although in the arts fortunately it is not necessary often to attend to such minutiae , as the materials employed are in some measure ductile , and therefore adapt themselves to the unequal strain to which they may be subjected , still it seems probable that the not unfrequent failure of large castings under a pressure much less than they were calculated to bear is due to this cause .
The management of speculum metal may be regarded as an extreme case , where all the defects of manipulation are strikingly developed .
There are evidently two ways in which it might be possible to attain the required adjustment of temperature ; the one by cooling the lower surface of a mould containing the liquid speculum metal , while the heat of the upper remained undiminished ; the other by constructing the mnould itself , so that the lower surface sliould absorb the heat rapidly and the upper retain it .
Both were tried ; the first by making the mould itself of cast iron , in which the metal was fused , and then exposing its lower surface to the action of a jet of cold water ; the result justified the theory , but the mould very frequently cracked , and where this occurred before the speculum metal had become perfectly solid , the casting was spoiled ; discs were , however , obtained of different sizes , the largest eighteen inches diameter , which was merely by chance , as a mould of that size almost invariably cracks before the completion of the process .
The experiment , therefore , is not worth repeating , particularly as the other plan is simple and succeeds perfectly .
It is obviously to make the lower surface of the mould of iron and the upper sides of sand ; at first a simple disc of iron was tried , but although the castings were sound , there was this defect ; that bubbles of air were often entangled between the iron and speculum metal , producing cavities which it was tedious to grind out : the iron disc was therefore replaced by one made of pieces 510 of hoop-iron placed side by side , with their edges up , tightly packed in an iron frame : the edges were brought to a smooth surface of the proper curve either by the file or lathe , whichever was the most convenient .
A metallic surface was thus constructed everywhere porous ; as however close the hoop-iron had been packed , the interstices suffered air to pass freely through .
So successful was this expedient , that of sixteen plates cast for the three-feet speculum , not one was defective : the following particulars require to be attended to .
The disc of hoop-iron should be as thick as the speculum to be cast upon it , so as to cool it with sufficient rapidity ; it requires to be warm , so that there may be no moisture deposited upon it from the sand ; it may be heated to 2120 without materially lessening its cooling power .
The metal should enter the mould by the side , as is usual ill iron founding , but much quicker , almost instantaneously ; one second is sufficient for filling the mould of a nine-inch plate or speculum .
As to the temperature of the metal , this can best be ascertained by stirring it with a wooden pole occasionally after it has become perfectly fluid ; when the carbon of the pole reduces the oxide on the surface of the metal , rendering it brilliant like quicksilver , the heat is sufficient .
When the metal has become solid in the ingate or hole through which it enters the mould , the plate is to be removed quickly to an oven heated a little below redness , to remain till cold , which , where the plates are nine inches diameter , should be three or four days at least .
The metal which had filled the ingates having been separated from the plates by a file , they were fitted to the brass speculum by grinding each separately by hand upon it till brought to the same cu ?
rve .
The surface of the brass speculum was then scraped and tinned , and when cold all resin was removed by washing it first with spirits of turpentine , and then soap and water .
The lower surfaces of the plates which fitted the brass speculum , were carefully scraped all over with broad flat chisels of thin steel , perfectly hard ; it is necessary that no spot should be passed over unscraped , and that the plate should be kept perfectly dry till soldered to the speculum .
The plates were then arranged in their places on the brass speculum , which had been previously placed in an oven so constructed that the temperature could be gradually and equally raised .
The bo'ttom of the oven consisted of a cast-iron plate four feet diameter , set in brick work , as if it was intended for a sand bath ; the brass speculumni rested upon this , with loose bricks between to protect it from radiation , so that it should acquire heat solely from the heated air ; the top of the oven had a cover in four pieces , that one might be opened at a time .
In about eight hours the tin on the speculum was fused , and then inelted resin was poured in between the plates ; tin in fusion was also applied in the same manner , and the plates moved a little backwards and forwards .
As soon as from the aspect of the edges of the plates it was certain that the tin was acting on the speculum metal , the fire was almost all withdrawn , and the temperature was not suffered to rise higher .
The joints of the plates were now made straight , and kept open about one-twentieth of an inch by chips of wood ; the whole was then suffered to cool gradually , and in five days it was ready to be grounld .
511 There are here also some points which it is necessary to attend to .
The perfect union of the plates with the brass speculuin depends upon the fact , that if a plate of speculum metal , scraped as directed , is laid upon a clean surface of tinned brass , and the temperature raised a little beyond the fising point of tin , and then melted resin and tin applied , the plate of speculum metal will be immediately tinned all over , and the union of course will be perfect .
If resin , however , is applied at the beginning of the process , and therefore exposed for hours to an increasing temperature , the resin , before the temperature has reached the proper degree , will have been decomposed , and will effectually prevent the success of the operation .
In my earliest experiments , I was not aware of this fact , and was therefore obliged to turn the plates over repeatedly with a wooden tongs , to remove the decomposed resin ; and , although where the plates were small this was practicable , in attempting t.o Inanage the plates of the three-feet speculum I failed : several were broken by unavoidable exposure to variation of temperature .
I may perhaps as well mention , that formerly I tried the muriate of ammonia instead of resin , and also a variety of other processes , but none was completely successful but the one I have given .
The resin should not only be in fusion , but where the plates are large it is more prudent to regulate the temperature by a thermometer .
The same observation applies to the tin ; I have found , however , that guarantee against a too great disparity of temperature .
The brick work should be perfectly dry , as a drop of condensed steam falling upon a plate would certainly crack it .
Before I proceed to the grinding and polishing of the speculum , I will conclude the remaining experiments on the process of casting .
The ease and certainty with which perfect plates of speculum metal of moderate dimensions had been obtained , obviously suggested a trial of the same principles on a larger scale .
A perfect disc of fine speculum metal , twenty inches diameter , was immediately obtained , and recently so large a disc as three feet was cast perfect the first attempt , and has been finished without accident .
Although the principles which guided the manipulation have been fully explained , there are some practical details necessary to success , which might not perhaps suggest themselves immediately to others who have not had the same experience in managing this intractable alloy that I have had ; a few remarks may therefore be useful .
The disc , when cast , was about three inches and three quarters thick , and weighed about thirteen hundred weight ; the metal for it was fused in two cast-iron crucibles .
In my earliest experiments , in consequence of the failure of a very large crucible of cast iron , one inch and thiree quarters thick , made for me at one of the principal London foundries , I concluded too hastily that cast iron would not answer .
The first time the crucible was tried , after it had been about four hours in the fire , the speculum metal oozed through it ; when cold the defective portion was bored out and stopped with a screw ; the next time the metal oozed out in several places .
The crucible was 512 then broken , and it was found that the speculum metal had penetrated into the iron in various directions , and a small porltion of specutlun metal , when analysed , yielded iron .
The reveLberatory furnace was therefore resorted to , but I found that , owing to the rapid oxidation of the tin , the quality of the alloy was continually changing , and the result therefore was uncertain .
In the mean time I found that the affinity of speculum metal for cast iron was very slight , although for wrought iron it was considerable ; that the iron detected in the speculum metal was owing to the corrosion of the wrought-iron screw , with which the hole had been stopped , and that the failure of the crucible had arisen , riot from the unfitness of the material , but from defective workmanship .
After some experiments in my own laboratory , I found that crucibles cast in the usual way , with the mouth down , were generally defective , the speculum metal passing through minute pores not visible externally , as quicksilver through the sap vessels of wood .
When the crucible , however , was cast with the mouth up , there was no such defect ; we therefore have in cast iron a material capable of being formed into crucibles of unlimited dimensions .
I cast one which held fifteen hundred weight , in which the speculum metal was made , but two crucibles of half the size were manageable with less machinery , and there ?
efore were used in casting the speculumn ; they were raised from the furnaces by proper tackling , and placed in iron swing frarnes , so contrived that each crucible of metal could be thrown almost instantaneously into the mould .
The fuel I make use of is wood or peat ; the latter when of proper quality is preferable , as it yields a steadier fire , without the intense heat of coke , which would without great care endanger the crucibles .
The mould was made in the same manner as in casting the plates , differing from it merely in shape and dimensions ; it was what founders technically call an open one .
The disc of hoop-iron was made circular three feet six inches diameter , three inches and a half thick , and turned upon a lathe convex to a radius of fifty-four feet .
The speculum was cast with a groove round the edge , so that it might be securely embraced by a circular clamp tightened upon it with screw-bolts , to which the proper tackling could be hooked whenever it was necessary to move it .
When the metal had becorne solid , but was still red-hot , a strong hoop , somewhat larger than the diarmeter of the speculum , was placed upon it ; to this hoop a chain from a windlass , passing through the annealing oven , had been previously attached , and by the action of the windlass the speculunm was drawn into the hot oven , and every opening closed ; in about a fortnight it was cool , and was found to be free from blemish .
It is of course impossible to ascertain a pr7iori , whether it would be practicable to obtain still larger discs of fine specultun metal by this process , and polish them without accident ; possibly it might , as the principal cause of fracture , unequal contraction , no longer exists .
The question , therefore , will arise , whether in endeavouring to obtain still larger specula , to approach nearer that limit beyond which it is not permitted to us to pass , the better course would be to attempt , with the risk of failure , a single casting of very great size , or at once to have recourse to the expedient of combining together a number of small castings , a process perhaps more tedious , possibly less perfect , but more certain .
However , a further comparison of the two specula as to defining power , under all circumstances , and with the utmost care , will determine the future course of these experiments ; at present there is no appreciable difference referable to their very different principles of construction ; they both are free from flexure in the different positions of the instrument , and have defined equally well when polished with equal success .
With a single lens of one quarter of an inch focus , giving a power of about thirteen hundred , they have both shown satisfactorily the dots on the dial-plate of a watch more distinctly than a very good refractor with a much lower power .
Hitherto the processes I have described were so effectual in producing the desired result , that there seems to be but little room for improvement , except in the discovery of new and better materials , an event by no means probable ; but the case is far otherwise in the remaining operation , that of polishing the speculum ; there , though the experiments have been even more numerous , much still remains to be accomplished .
Before the speculuin is polished , it is worked to a spherical figure by a process technically called grinding , where the mutual attrition of the speculum , and a inass of nearly equal size of some hard substance , eventually produces a figure nearly spherical ; and that , notwithstanding the irregularities , however great , of the surfaces of either , or both , at the commencement of the operation .
Several ingenious devices have been , indeed , from time to time , suggested , more or less independent of the process of grinding , among which , perhaps , the most remarkable is that of Mr. BARTON , who proposed to communicate the figure and the polish at once , by turning the speculum with a diamond , constrained , by very delicate machinery , to move in the proper path , and with a motion so slow that the resulting grooves should act on light as a polished surface ; but when we recollect the extreme accuracy required , that an error of figure amounting to but a small fraction of a hair 's breadth would destroy the action of a speculum , it is scarcely to be expected that any process can succeed in practice , which has not , like that of grinding , a decided tendency to correct its own defects , and to produce a result in which the errors may be said to be infinitely small in comparison with the errors in any of the previous steps from which it was derived .
I need , perhaps , therefore hardly say that all my experiments have been directed to the one object , that of endeavouring to improve the common published process of grinding and polishing , particularly in its application to large surfaces ; for although the accuracy usually attained is so great that we fail in detecting by mechanical means , among a variety of specula made at different times and by different persons , any deviation from the proper figure , still by optical means , in fact , by trial in a telescope , the defects are at once apparent ; and we shall probably find among them examples of every grade of defining power , from the speculum which is almost perfect , to that which does not define at all .
This difference , so great , is mainly owing to a variety of minute circumstances incidental to the process of polishing , which influence the result in a greater or less degree ; among which , the most important are , variations in the extent or relative velocities of the motions by which the necessary friction is produced ; alterations of temper.ature ; or some accidental pressure during the process .
With a view of obviating these causes of uncertainty at a very early stage of these experiments , a machine was constructed for grinding and polishing , where the different motions were susceptible of separate adjustment , and were all under complete control .
The first trials with it were upon the whole satisfactory , and I sent a sketch of it to Sir D. BREWSTER'S Journal for October , 1828 , in the hope of directing the attention of practical men to the subject , and perhaps of raising a doubt in their minds as to the justness of a very deep-rooted opinion , that specula could not be polished successfully except by the hand ; an opinion which , if unfounded , must necessarily have been a serious obstacle to iInprovement , by precluding the use of the only means available in making accurate experiments under circumstances identically the same , or , indeed , of trying any series of experiments on a large scale .
The machine was soon after enlarged , so as to be capable of working a speculum three feet diameter as its maximum , and otherwise improved , and since that no further alteration has been found necessary .
From an experience of several years , during which specula have been ground and polished with it in working large surfaces , a degree of precision can , with certainty , be obtained by it , unattainable by the hand , even by accident .
The machine , in its present state , is represented in Plate XX .
fig. 6 , and Plate XXI .
where A is a shaft connected with a steamengine ; B an eccentric , adjustable by a screw-bolt to give any length of stroke from 0 to 18 inches ; Ca joint ; Da guide ; EFa cistern for water , in which the speculum revolves ; G another eccentric , adjustable like the first to any length of stroke from 0 to 18 inches .
The bar DG passes through a slit , and therefore the pin at G necessarily turns on its axis in the same time as the eccentric .
HI is the speculum in its box immersed in water to within one inch of its surface , and KL the polisher , which is of cast iron , and weighs about two and a half hundred weight .
M is a round disc of wood connected with the polisher by strings hooked to it in six places , each two-thirds of the radius from the centre .
At M there is a swivel and hook , to which a rope is attached , connecting the whole with the lever N , so that the polisher presses upon the speculum with a force equal to the difference between its own weight and that of the counterpoise 0 .
For a speculum three feet diameter I make the counterpoise ten pounds lighter than the polisher .
The bar DG fits the polisher nicely , but without tightness , so that the polisher turns freely round , usually about once for every fifteen or twenty revolutions of the speculum , and it is prevented by four guards from accidentally touching the speculum , and from pressing upon the polisher by the two guides through which its extremities pass .
In fig. 7 .
this bar is on a larger scale .
I have tried a variety of contrivances for connecting the machinery with the polisher , but 3u2 515 the one I have described is by far the best .
The wheel B makes , when polishing a three-feet speculum , sixteen irevolutions in a minute ; to polish a smaller speculumr the velocity is increased by changing the pulley on the shaft A. The machine is in a room at the bottom of a high tower , and doors can be opened in the successive floors , so that a dial-plate of a watch placed perpendicularly over the speculum can be examnined at any moment .
The dial-plate is attached to a mast , so as to be much higher than the tower and about ninety feet from the speculumn ; and a small flat metal and eye-piece , with its proper adjustments , completes the arrangements for a Newtonian telescope .
This simple contrivance has greatly facilitated the progress of these experiments .
As appears in the plate , all the motions are produced by bands three inches wide , instead of the more permanent gearing of cog-wheels : although ban &amp; ds are liable to break , I think they are preferable to cog-wheels , because in a machine like this , which is for experimental purposes , if any part should become fast , which has happened more than once , the band falls off or breaks , and no mischief is done : it is only in a manufactory , where there are no experiments , but merely a routine of unvaried operations , that such accidents can be guarded against .
One-horse power is quite sufficient to drive this machine while it is working a speculum of three feet diameter .
The engine , however , is three-horse power , as from the distance of manufactories , it has been necessary to execute all the turning and casting work in my own laboratory .
The first serious difficulty which presented itself in polishing specula of considerable size , according to the common process , was this : when the layer of pitch was thin , as it must be to produce a good figure , however accurately at first it fitted the speculum , it soon ceased to do so , and the polishing did not of course proceed properly .
This derangement , which in the ordinary mode of polishing by the hand is perceived at once by the feel , is as soon perceptible with the machine , because mrinute bubbles from the air , which has insinuated itself between the speculum and the polisher , are immediately observable .
For some time this difficulty was exceedingly puzzling , and it was not until after many abortive attempts that the cause becamne evident : during the operation of polishing , the abraded matter , mixed with the polishing powder , is in part taken up by the pitch , but not equally over the whole surface ; as , however , pitch is not sensibly elastic with a moderate pressure , wherever mIost is taken up , there the surface will be most prominent , and the figure of the polisher destroyed , unless the pitch can spread laterally .
To allow of this lateral expansion a certain thickness of pitch is necessary , and I found , as might indeed have been anticipated , that the thickness required to be increased with the size of the speculum ; in fact , if I may be allowed so to express myself , that the necessary thickness was some function of the diameter of the speculum .
By using a layer of pitch sufficiently thick , a solid speculum of twenty inches aperture and a divided speculum of twentyfour inches aperture , the subjects of these and many other experiments , were made to define tolerably with a low power , and , at the same time , had acquired a high polish .
516 Mr. EDWARDS mentions that he had found , that , unless the pitch was of sufficient thiclkness , it would not preserve its figure ; he had observed the fact correctly : in assigning the cause he was evidently in error , as he attributed it to the circumstance that the thin coat of pitch , as he supposed , acquired more heat from the friction than the thicker , while the reverse must have been the fact , as the thinner the imDperfect conducting material , the quicker the metallic plate , to which it was attached , would have dissipated the heat , by radiation and conduction..Mr .
EDWARDs'S specula were very small , and he found the thickness of half-a-crown sufficient .
It was , however , evident , both as a deduction from all that had been written upon the subject , and from some experiments on small specula , that the necessity of using a layer of pitch thicker in proportion to the size of the speculum was a great evil , and was alone sufficient to make it impossible to polish large surfaces as accurately as small ones .
A consideration of the theory , which I have ventured to put forward , suggested a very obvious remedy .
It was very evident that by grooving the layer of pitch , provision might be made for its lateral expansion , wherever required , without so great a thickness .
The experiment was first tried by reducing the thickness of pitch one-half , and making furrows in it by means of a hot iron quite down to , the metallic plate ; the furrows were two inches apart , and there were two sets at right angles to each other , so that there were nowhere more than four square inches of pitchy surface in continuity .
The result was , that the defining power of the speculum was immediately much improved .
After many trials , however , a far better mode of effecting the same object suggested itself .
The furrows were with difficulty kept everywhere open , and where there was a failure in this respect the old evil recurmr ed , thickness of pitch to a minimum , which was a great object , and tlere were other mninor practical inconveniences .
These defects were all remedied by dividing the iron disc itself instead of the pitch ; this could be done to any degree of minuteness requiredl , and the continuous pitchy surface so reduced that its thickness might be made a minimum , in fact , not greater than necessary to satisfy the condition of enduring the small amount of abrasion which takes place during the time required to complete the polishing .
The improvement which immediately followed this simple device was far greater than could have been anticipated , and the divided three-feet speculum , after this change , defined better with a power of 1200 than it had done before with a power of 300 .
Several polishers were made on this construction , the arrangement and dimensions of the grooves being somewhat different : that last used in polishing the two three-feet specula I think is the best , and a drawing of it has been anntlexed , figs. 8 and 9 : the circular grooves were turned with a slide rest and are three-eighths of an inch deep and one quarter wide , leaving bands of continuous surface one quarter of an inch wide ; the grooves at right angles are about one inch and a quarter apart , one quarter of an inch wide , and half an inch deep ; they were cut with a small circular saw , under which the polisher was made to traverse on the bed of a large lathe .
517 The speculum was of course truly ground with the polisher first , and then the layer of pitch or resinous composition applied , the grooves remaining empty .
There are two conditions which I have found essential in producing a successful result ; the one , that the polisher should fit the speculumn exactly during the whole process ; the other , that the resinous surface in contact with the speculuin should be as hard as possible consistent with its admitting the polishing powder to imbed itself in it : without an attention to both of these , however accurately the motions of the machine may have been adjusted , however nearly a general parabolic figure may have been attained , the speculum will not define well .
The first condition is satisfied by grooving the polisher , provided the resinous surface is sufficiently soft to expand laterally into the grooves when necessary ; but when it is so , I have not found it hard enough to give a very true surface , and therefore the second condition is not satisfied .
But here it is necessary to explain the Ineaning which I attach to the words true surface , in contradistinction to accurate general igure .
A true surface is one which observes the law of continuity , when , in fact , the normal to the surface everywhere cuts the axis in conformity to the law of the curve , whatever that may be .
In practice , the defect , which I call an untrue surface , is perceptible at a glance where it is very considerable , and the speculum is of long focus , for instance , twenty-seven feet ; it is then only necessary to place the eye a few inches within the focus , while the speculum is turned to some bright object , as for instance the enamelled dial-plate of a watch , or the moon .
The irregularity of the whole surface will then be apparent , more at the joints where the speculum is in separate pieces , but still more where there is a flaw or crack .
The cause is obviously this : the metal under equal friction wears everywhere unequally , and therefore the inclination of the minute portions , I might almost say elements , of the surface , deviates slightly , but sensibly , and quite irregularly from the general curvature , producing an aberration independent either of general figure or aperture .
A surface of speculum metal yields in the same irregular way to the action of acids , as indeed all metals do , but the more so as their texture is crystalline or fibrous .
In proportion as the resinous surface is soft , and the polisher heavy , the irregularity increases , and therefore we should conclude that the harder the surface and lighter the polisher , the less the defect ; and such is the fact .
The accuracy of the general igure depends mainly upon the motions of the machine and the thinness of the resinous surface .
If the resinous surface is so hard that the particles of polishing powder no longer sink into it deep enough to be held fast , then the polish is destroyed , the polishing process passing into that of grinding ; long , however , before that limit of hardness has been attained , the resinous surface has lost its essential quality of expanding laterally , and therefore of preserving its exact coincidence of figure with the speculum .
I have found that the two properties apparently inconsistent with each other , can be imparted to the polisher at the same time , simply by busing the resinous composition of two different degrees of hardness , so as to form two very thin strata , the outer one being the harder .
The resinous surface 518 in contact with the speculum carl thus be made as hard as necessary , while the thin subjacent layer of softer resin expands laterally , so as to preserve the figure of the polisher .
The process of polishing for optical purposes appears to me in some measure to resemble that of filing , the polishing powder imnbedded in the resinous surface representing the teeth of the file : while the polister preserves its figure exactly , and consequently its contact with the pecu is exceedinly t the close , every particle of polishing powder , as it insinuates itself between the r ubbing surfaces , must be instantly forced into es the resin , deeper as the esin is softer , producing a grooving or grain in the speculum , finer , if the fineness of the polishing powder is given , in proportion to the softness of the resin , and , consequently , to the depth the particles have beconme imbedded , and , therefore , the smallness of the portion of each wh-ich projects ; but the oment the figure of the pouisher ceases to be exact , then the polishing powder is no longer forced into the resin , but runs loose , producing a grain perhaps as coarse , or coarser than the size of the particles of the powder itself .
Hence , therefore , in practice it is of no less importance to the production of a fine polish , than it is to the production of a fine figure , that the polisher should very exactly fit the speculum during the whole operation .
I find invairiably that the moment that exact coincidence ceases , the polish rapidly declines , and is soon completely spoiled .
I have hitherto observed that the quality of the polish which yields the maximum of defining power is that which is technically called a black polish , provided a very fine grain is perceptible when the speculum is placed near a window .
A speculum may be polished so that the surface appears black , and without grain , like a surface of quicksilver ; but I have always found it necessary for that purpose , to employ a softer resinous composition than seems consistent with the production of a very true surface .
Conceiving that such a polish , though I did not find it reflected more light , was likely to reflect more accurately , I tried a vast number of experiments with the view of obtaining it in conjunction with the truest surface , but hitherto without success : the subject , however , perhaps , deserves to be pursued further , and as it seeins impracticable without injury to soften the r esinous surface , the best chance seems to be to search for some polishing substance consisting of snialler particles than the fine peroxide of iron , the one I have always used , so as to produce a grain not exceeding the magnitude which theory has assigned as that of an undulation of light .
In preparing the resinous surface for the polisher , I have for a long time employed a mixture of common resin and turpentine , instead of pitch , having previously experienced much inconvenience in polishing large surfaces from the gritty particles whichll the pitch I was in the habit of using very frequently contained .
However , whether pitch ort resin be made use of , it is absolutely necessary that the hardness should be adjusted to the proper standard with great care .
Mr. MUDGE and Mr. EDWARDS have given different directions on this subject ; Mr. MUDGE recomnmending the pitch to be rather soft , and Mr. EDWARDS very hard ; but in the common mode of conducting the operation , no precaution being used to 519 prevent the temperature of the speculum from progressively increasing from friction , at length a point will necessarily be attained , sooner or later , according to the hardness of the pitch , when the pitch will yield so as accurately to fit the speculumn , and the polish will then rapidly improve : but should the temperature rise further before the polish is complete , the pitch will have become too soft to work a very true surface , and the speculum , even though in every other respect perfect , will not define very sharply .
It is very evident that , under such circumstances , a steady temperature could not be maintained , except where the heat evolved by friction exactly balanced that dissipated by radiation and conduction , and that the result even on the limited scale of Mr. MUDGE'S and Mr. EDWARDS'S operations must have been uncertain ; but in working large specula , the uncertainty was so great , that it gave rise to difficulties which I found it impossible to cormbat , and therefore I resorted to the simple expedient of making the speculuin revolve in water , kept at an uniform telmperature , generally 55 ?
: all change also in the figure of the speculum , from variation of temperature during the process , was thus at the same time prevented .
The hardness of the resinous surface was , therefore adjusted to suit the temperature , which is thus easily effected .
Common resin is melted , and when nearly boiling , spirit of turpentine is added to it , perhaps about one-fifth of its weight ; but resin varies so much in quality , that there is no guide except actual trial .
When the mixture has been incorporated by stirring , a cold piece of iron is to be immersed in it , and then placed for some minutes in a vessel of water at a temperature of 55 ?
; if then a moderate pressure of the nail makles a decided impression without splintering , it is of a proper hardness for the first layer on the polisher , and only requires to be strained through canvas .
I know of no mode which in practice answers better than the very rude one of judging of the hardness by the effects of the pressure of the thumb nail : there are pthers more precise , but they all take too much timte , and sufficient accuracy can be attained without them .
For the second layer , it is mixed with one-fourth of wheat flour , which , by increasing its tenacity and diminishing its adhesiveness , prevents that accident complained of by practical men , viz. the separation of minute particles of pitch from the polisher , which afterwards run loose between the polisher and the speculum .
It is to be boiled till the water of the flour has been expelled , and the mixture becomes clear , and the boiling further continued till some of the turpentine has been driven off , and the mixture has become so hard , that at a temperature of 55 ?
, a very strong pressure of the nail makes but a slight impression : it is still too soft , and I then add to it an equal weight of resin ; it will then be hard enough to produce a very true surface , and , at the same time , soft enough to suffer the particles of polishing powder to imbed themselves , and consequently to produce a very fine black polish .
Whenever the resinous mixture is remelted , I suspend the vessel to the bealm of a scale , counterpoise it , and take re to apply the heat so gradually as not to drive off any of the turpentine , which is immediately perceptible by the disturbance of the equilibrium .
To apply the resin , the polisher is first heated to o520 about 150 ?
, and the soft mixture laid on with a large flat brush , to about the thickness of one-thirtieth , or one-twenty-fifth of an inch ; it is then suffered to cool to about 1000 , and the hard mixture applied in the same way and to about the same thickness .
When the temperature has sunk to 80 ?
, the polisher is placed on the speculurn previously covered with peroxide of iron and water , of about the consistence of thin cream .
It may be well to observe , that the speculum is not endangered by applying a polisher at 80 ?
, while it is but 550 , because the thin layer of resin retards very much the transmission of heat ; but in grinding , where there is no resin , were there such a disparity , the speculum would be broken .
In grinding the three-feet speculum formed in separate pieces , the iron plate happened to have been washed with warm water , and though but little warmer than the speculum , the moment it was put on several of the plates cracked , but from the construction it was but little injured : had it been the other speculum in one piece , it would of course have been destroyed .
I prepare the peroxide of iron by precipitation with water of ammonia from a pure dilute solution of sulphate of iron ; the precipitate is washed , pressed in a screw press till nearly dry , and exposed to a heat which in the dark appears a dull low red .
The only points of importance are , that the sulphate of iron should be pure , that the water of ammonia should be decidedly in excess , and that the heat should not exceed that I have described .
The colour will be a bright crimson , inclining to yellow .
I have tried both potass and soda pure instead of water of ammonia , but after washing with some degree of care , a trace of the alkali still remained , and the peroxide was of an ochrey colour till overheated , and did not polish properly .
THOMSON says the peroxide of iron is sometimes of an ochrey colour , probably owing to some impurity , and I have found that the slightest trace of potass or soda produces that effect .
Possibly even washing with a degree of care , too troublesome for practice , would be ineffectual in removing the last remains of the alkali , as DAVY found that silica prepared with an alkali always retained a trace of it , even after the most careful washing ; but this is not exactly a case in point .
Having thus endeavoured to point out as concisely as possible what I have found essential in producing a ve.ry true surface and a fine polish , without at all wishing it to be inferred that I consider these processes quite perfect , -for , on the contrary , I believe much still remains to be accomplished , -I will next describe the means by which I have endeavonred to obtain a very good general figure .
When I had but little experience in working specula , considering the subject more theoretically than practically , I thought that a spherical figure was the only one which could be wrought with sufficient accuracy for optical purposes , and therefore that an original spherical aberration was an unavoidable evil ; but that were it possible by any counteracting means to neutralize , or even diminish it , we might have telescopes of greater aperture with a given focal length .
I constructed , therefore , a Newtonian telescope of six inches aperture , and two feet focus * : the speculum was in two concentric portions of such dimensions , that , presuming the original figure to have been accurately spherical , each should by calculation have one-half of the whole aberration : by drawing , therefore , the central portion back the proper calculated distance by a delicate screw adjustment , and bringing the images into exact coincidence , the aberration should have been reduced to one-half .
The experiment was so far successful , that an instrument of eighteen inches aperture was commenced , and the castings of the speculum in three adjustible portions were completed .
In the mean time , however , with additional experience , I found it necessary to adopt new views , and was soon convinced that it was not impossible to work figures which , though not rigidly accurate , were , however , better for specula than the spherical .
The undertaking was , therefore , abandoned , but the , original instrument still remains , and is so far curious as showing that an adjustment of such delicacy can be practically accomplished .
The experiments to which I have alluded , were made with the elliptic polisher of Mr. EDWARDS , a contrivance in my opinion possessing more merit than has usually been ascribed to it : I found that a speculum of four inches aperture , and eighteen inches focus , after having been polished by hand as truly spherical as I could make it , was invariably improved by working it on the elliptic polisher ; however , on applying the same principle to larger specula , the result was less successful ; and after a great many trials with a speculum of eighteen inches aperture , I found it would not answer .
On measuring the focal length of the surface at different distances from the centre of the face , it was certain that the radius of curvature always increased much too rapidly towards the edge ; and when the principle upon which the elliptical polisher acts is considered , it is evident that such a result might have been anticipated , and that the defect , though scarcely perceptible in very small specula , would have been very important where the dimensions were considerable .
Having observed that when the extent of the motions of the polishing machine were in certain proportions to the diameter of the speculum , its focal length gradually and regularly increased , that fact suggested another mode of working an approximate parabolic figure .
If we suppose a spherical surface , under the operation of grinding and polishing , gradually to change into one of longer radius , it is very evident that , during that change , at no one instant of time will it be actually spherical , and the abrasion of the metal will be more rapid at each point as it is more distant from the centre of theface .
When , however , the focal length neither increases nor diminishes , the abrasion will become uniform over the whole surface , producing a spherical figure .
According , however , as the focal length ( the actual average amount of abrasion during a given time being given ) increases more or less rapidly , the nature of the curve will vary , and we might conceive it possible , having it in our power completely to control the rate at which the focal length increases , so to proportion the rate of that increase as to produce a surface approximating to that of the paraboloid .
Of course the chances against obtaining an exact paraboloid are infinitely great , as an infinite number of curves may pass between the parabola and its circle of curvature , 522 and it is vain to look for a guide in searching for the proper one in calculations founded on the principles of exact science , as the effect of friction in polishing is not conformable to any known law ; still from a number of experiments it might be possible to deduce an empirical formula practically valuable : this I have endeavoured to accomplish .
The weight of the polisher was constant , being the least possible consistent with its working properly , viz. ten pounds for a speculum three feet diameter .
The distance of the counterpoising lever would obviously influence the curve ; that I have regarded as constant also , viz. twelve feet , as also , in all my most recent experiments , the length of the stroke of the first eccentric B , which was one-third of the diameter of the speculum ; the only variable quantity was , therefore , the stroke of the second eccentric G. Under these circumstances , the most accurate determination at which I have as yet been enabled to arrive is , that when the stroke of the second eccentric G is such as to communicate a lateral motion to the polisher equal to about -27 of the diameter of the speculum , the curve will be nearly parabolic .
The curvature I measure as MUDGE did , by means of diaphragms ; and when the surface is true , the separate portions of it , though the general figure may be indifferent , will define sharply , and their focus can be ascertained with great precision .
If the surface is not true , the curvature cannot be ascertained with any degree of accuracy ; the watchdial , the test object , is but ninety feet from the speculum , and could not be placed higher without inconvenience ; it is therefore necessary in measuring the curvature of the speculum to allow for its distance .
This I do simply by calculating the spherical aberration , the radiant being ninety feet distant , at two points , one i-th of the radius , and the other -ird of the radius from the centre of the face , deducting that from the aberration for parallel rays at these points , and endeavouring so to figure the speculum that it should be over corrected that much .
Any further refinement would be but waste of time in the present state of these experiments ; and although we cannot hope to obtain anything but an approximation , still the limits of error will be so small that even a large fraction of that quantity may not in practice be very important .
The adjustment , however , can be made with such accuracy , that the three-feet metal at present in the telescope , with its whole aperture , is thrown perceptibly out of focus by a motion of theeye-piece , amounting to less than the thirtieth of an inch ; and even with a single lens of one-eighth of an inch focus , giving a power of 2592 , the dots on a watch-dial are still in some degree defined .
A watch-dial is , upon the whole , as good a test for very large specula as can be desired , as there is so much light that the magnifying power can always be increased till indistinctness is perceptible ; and although eventually the performance of the instrument on the heavenly bodies , the development of new details , or the discovery of new objects , which other instruments have not reached , are the proofs that an accession of instrumental power has been obtained , still as a test to have recourse to during the progress of experiments , a watch-dial , which is always at hand , and so 3x2 523 near that atmospheric changes do not very materially affect the result , is a far better object .
By keeping the same principles in view , a very perfect plane speculum can be worked with facility , difficult as that operation has been found in practice .
The polisher I make use of for a metal about three inches by two , is three inches diameter , divided exactly like the large polisher , but with proportionate minuteness ; when the metal is polished , it is tested in the usual way by viewing an object alternately by direct and reflected vision , with a very good thirty-inch achromatic , the aperture of which has been previously contracted to an inch and three quarters .
If the metal is concave , it is worked with shorter strokes for about half an hour and then tried ; it will be found to have become less concave , possibly convex ; in the latter case it is to be worked with longer strokes ; thus with the utmost facility a metal can be worked alternately concave and convex , and , with a little practice , the limit between the two can be hit with such exactness , that even with the severe test of a thirty-inch achromatic , no deviation from the plane can be perceived , and the loss of light will be the only evidence that the rays have suffered reflexion before their incidence on the object-glass .
Smaller flat metals I find it better to polish on the same polisher , several together , according to their size .
The telescope is mounted very similarly to Sir JOHN HERSCHEL'S , but in consequence of its greater size and weight , I have counterpoised botht the tube and the whole machine , which makes it easily manageable ; so that upon the whole , though , with the experience I now have , I believe the mounting might be improved , it is sufficiently convenient .
I use it as a Newtonian , as I find that , with its large aperture and short focus , the saving of light by the Hlerschellian construction is not at all an equivalent for the sacrifice of defining power , at least that is the result of my present experience ; the indistinctness , however , from the obliquity of the speculum , does not appear to me to be so great as I should have expected , considering the size of the circle of least confusion ; for this I cannot account .
To prevent flexure in specula of moderate dimensions , I find it is quite sufficient to support them in their box on three strong iron plates , each plate being one-third part of a circular area , the same size as the speculum , and a sector of it ; the plates rest at their centres of gravity on points fixed at the bottom of the box of the speculum , and therefore no flexure of the box can affect the speculum .
Although the same simple means would probably be effectual for specula of the largest size , in supporting .
specula of three feet diameter I have availed myself of the suggestion of a clever Dublin artist , Mr. GRUBB , and , at the expense of a little more complication , have substituted nine plates for the three , resting on points supported by levers , which rest on three original points ; and if flexure is thus more effectually prevented , which I think it ought to be , the additional workmanship is of no importance .
This lever apparatus , however , must be exceedingly substantial , quite disproportionately so , otherwise tremors would be introduced by it , attended with the worst consequences .
524 In selecting the materials for this communication from a vast mass of experiments , I have endeavoured to collect together such results as were most likely to be useful , and to work the whole into a shape as practical as possible , compressing it at the same time into the smallest compass : there are many minor matters of detail , which , therefore , I have unavoidably omitted ; some of them possibly might be valuable to men of science , who may be disposed to take up the sublject practically with a view of proceeding further than I have done .
I have , however , the less regret on this account , as , although the instrument and the laboratory where it was constructed are in the centre of Ireland , the facilities of communication are such , that those who may desire further information , can easily obtain it on the spot , and form their own estimate of the performance of the instrument .
Since the commencement of last Septemnber , when the telescope was completed and in perfect working order , till Christmas , all opportunities which presented themselves for observing , not very many indeed , were taken advantage of .
A considerable number of Sir JOHN HERSCHEL'S test objects were examined , and the performance of the instrument was quite satisfactory ; but as to double stars , perhaps the most striking contrast between its action and that of other instruments , was the extreme brilliancy of the minute companions of large stars ; for instance , the companion of Polaris , with six hundred , was very like Polaris itself in a forty-four inch achromatic , with a two and three quarter object glass .
The companions of Alpha Lyrae , and Rigel , were brilliant objects .
As to the nebulae , though it was impossible not to feel persuaded that a larger , and equally perfect instrument would have done much more , still there was enough , I think , to justify a confident expectation , that evein the present instrument will add something to the very little that is known respecting these wonderful bodies .
I think I might almost venture to say that the nebulae , 27 Messier , the annular nebula in Lyra , and what is perhaps more curious , the edge of the great nebula in Andromeda , have shown very evident symptoms of resolvability ; as also other nebul)e less remarkable* .
The appearance is that of a resolvable nebula in a telescope not quite powerful enough to resolve it completely .
No such appearance , however , was observed till the power reaclied six hundred , and sometimes it was more decisive with powers of eight hundred and one thousand .
It is evident , therefore , that , except for the discovery of very faint nebulae , an object , perhaps , of but little interest , nothing would be effected by constructing a telescope of the greatest dimensions , unless it was at the same time proportionately perfect ; that a mere light grasper would do nothing .
This instrument acts veiry powerfully on the lunar surface , and , as might be supposed , shows everywhere a variety of details not marked in the beautiful map of BEER and MCEDLER .
A much higher magnifying power can also be used with decided advantage than they say has hitherto been practicable , viz. 300 * : with a power of 600 , and sometinles with a power of 900 , many details are brought out , not visible with lower powers .
Were it practicable to construct a rectangular prism , reflecting as accurately as a flat metal , notwithstanding the thickness of the glass , there should , I think , be a considerable saving of light : I have not as yet had time to try the experiment , but I think it worth a fair trial .
Such prisms , however , do not seem to have performed as well as might have been expected , perhaps owing to imperfect workmanship .
A still greater accession of light might be obtained without sacrifice of defining power , by using the Herschellian construction , were it possible to discover some means of working approximately the surface of accurate reflexion for oblique rays .
I have recently tried a few experiments on a small scale on this subject , and amn disposed to think the task is not hopeless ; but a couIse of experiments on a large scale would be required to afford a decisive result .
The question is not whether such a figure could be worked as accurately as a spherical one ; of that I have no hope ; but whether , in practice , such a degree of accuracy might not be obtained , that the mirror would define decidedly better than if it had been spherical , and as well , or nearly so , as when worked to the best parabolic figure that can be executed , and used as a Newtonian .
The principle on which I have proceeded in these experiments was simply to consider the reflecting surface sought , as a portion of a paraboloid whose axis coincided with the side of the tube , the eye-piece of course placed on the axis ; and in endeavouring to work that figure , I have had recourse to no other expedient than an adjustment of the motions with respect to the position of the speculum , guided by the same view of the subject which directed the attempts to work the paraboloid for the Newtonian , varied merely to suit the altered circumstances ; but in the present imperfect state of these experiments it would be waste of time to enter more into particulars .
I have mentioned the subject merely for the purpose of directing the attention of others to it .
Sir WILLIAM HAMILTON , in his paper in the Transactions of the Royal Irish Academy for 1828 , on Systems of Rays , considers the surface as the envelope of an ellipsoid of revolution , having a constant axis , but a variable eccentricity , moved in such a manner , that while one focus traverses in all directions the surface which cuts the incident rays perpendicularly , the other focus remains fixed at the point through which all the reflected rays are to pass .
I have not , however , discovered any practical means of availing myself of his very original mode of treating the subject .
To conclude , I think I may state as the results of all these experiments , that specula can be made to act effectively , cast of the finest speculum metal , in separate portions , retained in their positions by an alloy of zinc and copper , as easily wrought as common brass , and that they can be executed in this manner of any required size ; that castings of the finest speculum metal can be executed of lar ge dimensions , perfect , and not very liable to break ; that machinery can be employed with the greatest advantage in grinding and polishing specula ; that , to obtain the finest polish , it is not necessary that the speculum should become warm , but that any temperature may be fixed upon and preserved uniform during the whole process ; and that large specula can be polished as accurately as small ones , and be supported so as to be secured from flexure .
To form any other than a very vague estimate of the dimensions which the reflecting telescope may yet attain , would be impossible .
Without allowing for further improvements in the process of polishing , which certainly may be confidently anticipated , I think that a speculum of six feet apertule could be made to bear a magnifying power more than sufficient to render the whole pencil of light available , and that in favourable states of the atmosphere it would act efficiently , without having recourse to the expedient which NEWTON pointed out as the last resource , that of observing from the summit of a high mountain .
The construction , however , of such an instrument would be a serious task , and I should be sorry to attempt it , till , after additional experience in observing , and further opportunities of comparing the two threefeet specula already finished , I felt more competent to do justice to the undertaking .
In the mean time , I hope to receive from scientific men suggestions , which would be most valuable ; to continue the experiments already in progress , and to arrange the details of the mechanism necessary to render so large a tube conveniently manageable .
Everything , then , having been previously determined with care , subsequent alterations would not be required ; tedious experiments would not now be necessary , either in constructing the speculum , or in the less interesting but necessary task of acquiring a practical knowledge of the mechanic arts ; and an instrument even of the gigantic dimensions I have proposed might , I think , be commenced and completed within one year .
527

