On the Nervous System .
By Sir CHARLES BELL , F.R.S. SSc .
Received February 24 , -Read April 2 , 1840 .
TWENTY years have passed since the Society honoured me by printing my first paper on the functions of the nervous system .
It is thirty years since I circulated a short essay , in which the idea of the new principle which has guided me in my inquiries into this subject was pointed out .
The Society will acknowledge that since that time , investigations into the nervous system have been prosecuted with a success strongly in contrast with that attending the inquiries during the long period of some hundred years , in which a false hypothesis had satisfied the minds of the medical profession , and chained down physiologists in inactivity .
In 1821 I had made so much progress in these investigations , that I was encouraged to present my first paper to the Society , as no longer the expression of mere opinions founded on experiments too delicate to be generally appreciated , but demonstrations of substantial facts , easily proved to be correct , and such as the Society has always sought to encourage .
After the principle had been once established by anatomy and experiment , that the nerves possess distinct functions in correspondence with their origins from the brain and spinal marrow , time and opportunity were alone wanting for collecting the pathological facts which were to give importance to the observations in these early papers .
Those facts I am now desirous of placing before the Society , to complete the subject as far as regards my own labours .
First in regard to The Spinal Nerves .
In the earliest part of my investigations I performed experiments on the roots of these nerves .
I exposed the spinal marrow , separated the distinct roots , and found that the anterior root on being irritated excited motion , while the posterior rootr did not excite the muscles .
By inference , and by comparing the spinal nerves with those of the encephalon , I was at length led to conclude that the anterior root is provided for motion , and the posterior for sensation ; and that the spinal nerves , instead of being common nerves , are in truth combined of roots , one of which gives motion and the other sensation .
Many instances have presented themselves in the prosecution of this subject , to show that , until directed by a knowledge of function , we are inattentive to facts of daily occurrence .
To take an example , since I had reason to conclude that the columns of the spinal marrow , and the roots arising from them , were distinct in function , I have met with no instance of disease in the bodies of the vertebrae attended with paraplegia , in which the muscular power of the limbs has not been the first affected : in all , the defect of motion has been greater than the diminution of sensibility ; in some , the motion of the limbs has been lost , whilst the sensibility has been exquisitely acute .
These facts , it is now obvious , are to be accounted for by the motor roots of the spinal nerves being more directly exposed to the influence of the inflammation seated in the bodies of the vertebrae , than the posterior Iroots of sensation , which arise more remote from the disease .
In a case now before me , there is disease affecting the bodies of the vertebrae of the neck ; the arms hang powerless , whilst the sensibility is perfect ; and the patient walks stoutly .
By looking to the roots of the great nerves of the axillary plexus , in the dead body , the cause of this is manifest ; we see that the notor roots cover the spinal marrow , and that , whilst they protect the body of the spinal imarrow , they are exposed themselves , by them tir proximity , to participate in the inflammation of the bone .
When a section of the spine and sheath of the spinal marrow is made , especially in the neck or in the loins , it is observed that not only do the anterior roots of the nerves protect the colun of the uspinal m ow fro which the o they arise , but these roots , together with the ligamenta denticulata , whilst they are themselves exposed to the influence of disease in the bodies of the oo vertebrae , guard the posterior column and sensitive roots .
If the inflammation or morbid influence , in this case , had penetrated to the spinal marrrow , and had paralysed the muscles of the upper extremities , by affecting that organ , the muscles of the lower extremities would have suffered equally with those of the upper .
The spinal marrow , properly speaking , terminates at the second lumbar vertebra : but the anterior roots of the nerves forming the cauda equina , cover and protect the posterior roots from the influence of disease in the bodies of the vertebrae .
The following occurrence will be iegarded with interest in connexion with this subject .
Plate IX .
exhibits a tumour which engaged the anterior roots of the sacial nerves , as they form the cauda equina within the tube of the vertebrae .
The tumour was of the form of an almond , but larger , and into it , the motor roots , both of the right and left side , were gathered , whilst the sensitive roots were free .
The peculiar circumstances attending the case were communicated to ime while the patient , who was in the public hospital of Edinburgh , was alive .
The lower extremities were deprived of motion , whilst they retained sensibility ; and symptomns of so mtuch interest were noted and discussed by the physicians and pupils .
When a tumour on a nerve interrupts the communication between the brain and the extremity of the nerve , and the consequences are observed , they are conclusive as to the functions of that nerve , and afford a proof of them much superior to experiment .
When a case of disease in the fifth nerve of the brain presents itself , the insensibility of the side of the tongue , of the side of the face and head , and of all the 246 / z./ .
2 }'z 's .
: , ] : ) CCCXN : .
/ ' IXpz .
26 .
1 / Diseast , ' / i/ c'/ ' &lt; Sp7iczlJ i / 'rveKs..B.B.7 / atuowur on , / i./ f a erCwlr rools , dia/ wed .
C.C.C.C. H7Iw.otCior roooc if / aY oc we ci.v'es pcasslai ize/ ihazour / &amp; firce .
V / Ji , 61/ bib ... .
0:- .
: ?
: ; .:0..:flf ( ( , " " / gzz ?
?C .
if , , cavities with the loss of power in the muscles of the jaw of that side , unequivocally confirm the deductions which I drew from the anatomy , that the fifth pair confers motion and sensation , in correspondence with its rising from the brain by two roots .
In such a case , the trunk of the nerve , consisting of the united roots , is affected ; and the privation of function is complete .
In the present instance , the motion alone of the limbs was lost , by the destruction of the anterior roots of the nerves ; whilst the sensibility remained , owing to the posterior roots being unaffected .
I atn unwilling to enter on so great a subject as the influence of the cerebellum , and of that posterior column of the spinal marrow which descends from it .
Irportant as these parts must be in the oeconomy , there are no facts to countenance the belief , that they are directly connected with the functions of motion and sensibility .
Indeed the posterior column of the spinal marrow has been found softened to a degree , which we must suppose inconsistent with the continuance of its functions ; and yet sensibility has been entire .
But let not this fact militate against our conclusions .
The column in the spinal marrow which gives rise to the sensitive roots , is posterior to that from which the mtotor roots arise ; but is not the posterior portion of the spinal marrow .
Some have imagined , from finding the posterior column of the spinal miarrow softened , in cases where sensibility was entire during the life of the patient , that they had found an argument unfavourable to our general conclusions .
In consideration that the results of the experiments on the roots of the nerves of the spine , first made thirty years ago , have thus been confirmed by pathology , the Society will perhaps permit me to state how I was induced to commence these experiments .
In thus adverting to my early investigations , I am only desirous of showing the principle which guided me in these pursuits .
Some of the physiologists , at home and abroad , who have treated of this subject , have appeared to consider the facts brought out by the experiments on the spinal nerves , as accidental results .
Misconceiving the just application of experiments to this inquiry , they have made it a boast , that they proceeded to their experiments without preparation ; and have gone so far as to represent the person who dissects living animals , indifferent to the results , and only curious to find something new , as the true philosopher !
However this may be , my experiments on the spinal marrow and roots of the nerves were not undertaken till after long consideration and much minute dissection .
Many of my pupils , now risen to eminence , may remember that at the time alluded to , my lectures on the nervous system extended beyond what was customary in the courses delivered in London : not trusting to preparations , minute dissections were made for each lecture ; and to afford time for these , discussions on the physiology and pathology of the nervous system were thrown into the demonstration .
The first lecture on the distribution of the nerves , was upon presenting a display of thejirst , second , third , fourth , fifth , and sixth nerves .
It appeared incumbent on me 247 to remark , that between the opinions taught in the schools , and the inferences to be deduced from the distribution of these nerves , there was no correspondence .
Why do six nerves pass into the orbit ?
Why should two nerves descend into the nose ?
Why should three nerves penetrate the coats of the eye ?
Why should some of these nerves have ganglions on them and others none ?
If it be correct , that the brain is the officina spirituum , and gives out a common influence through the netves , what is the meaning of this intricacy in the distribution of the nerves ?
I then held the following argument .
Conmmon occurrences , and the symptoms of disease , correspond with the anatomical facts , while they are adverse to the received opinions .
1 .
A catarrhal inflammation of the membrane of the nose is attended with the loss of the sense of smelling , and the increase of the sensibility to common irritation .
Does not this imply a difference in the functions of the first and of the fifth nerve ?
and that their offices are not transferable 2 .
In performing the operation of couching the cataract , as the needle touches the surface of the eye , it pricks it , and the patient feels a pain similar to what he would do were the skin pricked ; but as the needle passes through the retina , he has a flash of fire .
Does not this imply a difference of sensibility from the same injury , or the same impulse ?
Do we not perceive that there is a nerve of vision , and a nerve appropriated to the external surface ? ?
3 .
When we receive a blow on the head , does not the same vibration affect the nerves of sense differently ?
In the ear , it produces sound as of the ringing of bells ; in the eye , corruscations of light .
4 .
But here is the third nerve passing into the eye ; is it also for sensation , or is there a motion of the iris to be established in relation to the sensorial impressions ? ?
5 .
Shall we admit the interpretation , that the brain is the common sensorium , and that the peculiar office and sensibility of the external organ of sense result from the organization of the extremity of the nerve ?
On the contrary , it is capable of proof , that the trunk of a nerve , even of sense , receives and conveys an impulse which gives rise to the ideas belonging to that sense and to no other .
The agony which accompanies the extirpation of the eye , forbids us to expect an account of the sensation experienced when the optic nerve is cut across .
But we have other proofs .
When the pudic nerve is exposed , the sensation is that which is appropriate to the glans .
The subject was followed up in the succeeding lecture ; which , in order , was a demonstration of the nerves of the tongue-where three nerves are given to one organ .
Such , then , were the suggestions from anatomy and common experience , which led me to the conclusion , that nerves have appropriate properties ; and that these properties are derived from the roots of the nerves , that is , their origins in the brain .
To verify this view , I was first led to make experiments on the brain .
These proved futile ; and I then thought of determining the matter by experiments on the spinal marrow , and the roots of the spinal nerves .
248 The Society must perceive , that when it was demonstrated that the anterior and posterior roots differed in function , the whole investigation became anatomical .
Tracing the column of the spinal marrow which gives rise to the anterior roots , upwards , we meet with the ninth , sixth , and third , arising from the same tract ; and as these are distributed to muscles exclusively , we must infer that they are motor nerves ; thus confirming the deductions from the experiments , that the whole anterior column gives off only nerves of motion .
It must likewise be obvious how these investigations into the functions of the spinal nerves , their roots and columns , carried my back to the original field of inquiry , the cerebral nerves ; and this conducted me to the observation , that the fifth pair of the brain is analogous , in the structure of its roots , and its functions , to the spinal nerves .
The next subject to which I request the indulgent attention of the Society , regards those nerves , which in a paper delivered in 1821 , I called The Respiratory System of Nerves .
I foresaw that my views on this subject would prove embarrassing to physiologists .
But the length of time that has elapsed , and the ingenuity of many men who have engaged in the investigation , have made it ripe for further inquiry .
In the paper alluded to , certain nerves , very distinct from the thirty spinal nerves and fifth pair , which from their uniformity of origin and course I called regular nerves , were pointed out .
These nerves also bore distinct features from the nerves of the encephalon .
They were the portio dura of the seventh nerve , the glossopharyngeal nerve , and the spinal accessory nerve ; to which I added the diaphragmatic , and external respiratory nerve .
As these nerves are peculiar in their origins , so are they in their course and distribution .
On the outside of the corpus olivare , and anterior to the processus ad cerebellum , when the pia matter is torn away , a tract , marked by the size of the holes from which the nourishing vessels have been withdrawn , and continued downwards behind the ligamenta denticulata , is perceived ; from the upper part of this column these nerves arise conspicuously , and from this they diverge as from a centre .
They differ in length , and perhaps in importance ; but they go to every part , throughout the extended frame , associated in the act of respiration , or in the many lesser actions in which the organs of respiration participate .
Another circumstance was pointed out as marking their peculiarity .
When sense and volition are lost , and the individual is dying , these nerves retain their power , and are the last to yield to the influence of death .
In marking the difference in these nerves from the regular spinal nerves and fifth pair , we may add to their peculiar mode of origin , the distinction in the columns from which they arise .
The peculiarity of the columns which give origin to the regular nerves is their decussations : but such decussations are not found in the columns which give off the respiratory nerves .
Let us be distinct .
There are two anterior or motor columns in the spinal marrow ; and two , more posteriorly situated , sensitive columns .
These resemble each other in this , that they respectively interchange filaments , the anterior columns with each other , and the posterior columns with each other .
No other columns of the spinal marrow make this interchange ; and the respiratory columns are far apart .
It is not unnatural to conclude ttat such interchange is necessary to the infinite varieties in the associated actions of the frame , where sensation and voluntary motion are in operation ; whilst the uniformity of the respiratory act requires no such provision .
At all events , the respiratory nerves arise from columns which do not decussate , a circumstance which distinguishes the systems .
It was an early object with me , to make out the connexion between the roots of the diaphragmatic nerve and of the spinal accessory nerve .
I conceived that as these nerves were closely united in office , the latter elevating the shoulders , so as to assist in the due expansion of the chest , while the former excites the diaphragm *-for the expansion of the chest is necessary to the full action of the diaphragm they might have the same origin .
But independently of anatomical investigation , and waiting for those occurrences in practice which are perhaps better than experiment , symptoms seem to confirm the correctness of this view .
In the case already alluded to , of disease in the bodies of the cervical vertebrae , and which I have selected from among others , merely because at the time of writing it is a subject of daily inspection , the common muscular motions of the neck and arms are entirely suspended , whilst the breathing is not , and never has been affected .
The arms hang like empty sleeves , the head falls forward , if not supported with the hand or by an instrument , the muscles are wasted , and the neck thin ; yet in breathing , the mastoid muscle and the trapezius muscle swell and become as firm as a piece of board .
Anatomical investigation shows the roots of the spinal accessory nerve arising far apart from the muscular roots of the nerves of the arms : indeed they are more nearly allied to the roots of sensation than of motion ; and in the instance above , we find common muscular actions cut off ; and those of respiration perfect .
We see the sensibility in the whole extent of the respiratory passages , and the influence of the will retained , through the respiratory nerves .
The same phenomena are presented in the common case of hemiplegia .
Such facts countenance the view which was presented to the Society , where a peculiar office was ascribed to these nerves , and a distinct name given to them .
But there remain some questions of great difficulty and much interest .
And I am now happy in taking the assistance of the experiments made by various ingenious gentlemen .
When the dissected body exhibits to us this extensive class of respiratory nerves , traceable from a centre to all the organs of respiration , a question alises , by what means do the sensibilities of the pharynx , larynx , lungs , stomach , bring these respiratory nerves and muscles into action ?
Is the system which we ave e been considering complete in itself ?
Are these respiratory nerves both sensitive and muscular ?
Are the necessary sensations propagated along sensitive nerves bound up with the muscular respiratory nerves , or do they owe their sensibility to the numerous connexions with the regular nerves formed in their course ?
That a regular nerve may animate the whole class of respiratory nerves is demonstrated in the office of the fifth , in the Schneiderian membrane .
The sensibility of the cavities of the nose bestowed by the branches of the fifth nerve , excites the act of sneezing .
But , on the other hand , if we place confidence in the experiments of VALENTIN on the roots of the Vagus , it is purely the central sensitive nerve of the respiratory system ; for having exposed its roots , and taken them off from the side of the medulla oblongata , and at the same time having separated them from the roots of the glossopharyngeal nerve and spinal accessory nerve , he irritates these roots of the vagus , and finds no conseqluent action in the pharynx , stomach , or respiratory muscles : no motion is produced .
But again , taking the trunk of this nerve , where it lies in the neck , all the connexions of the nerve being entire , the irritation of it produces muscular actions , and the act of respiration is imitated .
There is no doubt that the nervus vagus is a sensitive nerve .
When I have examined the abdomen of a man completely paralytic from disease , or from fracture of the vertebrae high up , the patient , though outwardly insensible below the neck , has felt when I pressed the stomach .
Again , with respect to the glosso-pharyngeal nerve , the experiments of Dr. REID go to prove it a sensitive nerve .
It is impossible to cavil at these experiments .
They were often repeated , and with a perfect understanding of the subject .
He first finds that pinching the nerve gives pain .
He then divides the nerve , and irritates the divided portion next the brain , by which muscular movements are produced in the throat .
I am well aware that , dissecting deep among nerves , the experimenter is subject to be mistaken ; and in surgical operations on the human body , the exposed trunks of nerves give little pain , compared with the fine sensibility of their extremities .
We find experiments by different hands giving different results , and the same experiments differing on one day from another , performed by the same person .
But the force of evidence is all in favour of the nervus vagus and the glosso-pharyngeal nerve being sensitive .
And Dr. REID'S experiments give a perfect example of what I have called the Nervous Circle* ; the sensibility or nervous influence flow* Phil. Trans. 1826 .
p. 163 .
2K2 251 ing towards the origin of the nerve , to be returned by parallel nerves upon the inuscles : for the uniformity of nature 's laws is maintained in both the great systems , the regular , and the respiratory .
Experiments countenance another early conclusion .
Of the three conspicuous nerves of this system which have been associated under the name of the eighth pair of nerves , the spinal accessory nerve is proved to be the essential muscular nerve .
The experiments of Professor MULLER , Drs. REID and VALENTIN , exhibit this nerve as purely muscular .
I drew this conclusion when I presented to the Society the plan of the respiratory nerves and muscles .
I suggested that the roots of the spinal accessory nerve and of the diaphragmatic nerve arose from the same portion of nervous matter : and that whilst the one went directly , and by the shortest way to the diaphragm , the other proceeded upwards , entered the head , and came down in association with the other nerves , in order , by these communications , to unite the motions of the air-tubes with the play of the chest in respiration , and that the whole respiratory apparatus might consent in action .
Often as I have set my young friends to determine the question by dissection , I have found them puzzling and giving up the pursuit .
No doubt the dissection is difficult ; and we must still rest satisfied with a process of reasoning .
The influence of these nerves is necessary to each other .
The muscles of the chest and the diaphragm continue in action when the motions of the arm and of the muscles of the neck are lost .
These nerves and their respective muscles continue in office when both sense and motion are gone .
In making two distinct systems of the nerves arising from the spinal column , it was never my intention that it should be believed that they were cut off from the sensorium .
The connexion of the brain with the spinal marrow is a distinct subject of inquiry .
We know that concatenated motions can be excited in the body where there is no brain .
We know that the action of respiration will continue when the brain is taken away ; so far , then , it is obvious that the relations of the fraime , whether for the purpose of locomotion and action , or of breathing , are perfect , independently of cerebrum and cerebellum .
The question remains , what is the nature of that relation , or of that influence , maintatined by the brain over the nervous system of the body ?
However that connexion may hereafter be found to be established , it will not invalidate the conclusions as to the unity of office of the nerves employed in respiration , and in the actions where the respiratory apparatus is brought into play .
Before concluding this subject , it is pertinent to notice , that writers have been led to attribute the entire action of respiration to the sensation in the lungs .
To a certain degree this is undoubtedly true .
When I formerly stated , that upon dividing the par vagurm ( and with it the sympathetic nerve ) , and cutting through the spinal marrow , the act of respiration continued , I established the fact that there was a source of motion in the respiratory organs independently of any sensation in the lungs .
I 252 may be permitted to doubt , if in common breathing there is any sensation ; we are certainly not conscious of it .
It cannot at least be anything like the exercise of sensibility of which we are conscious , and which is wearied and exhausted by repetition .
There is then , we must apprehend , another source of the regulated drawing of breath , which excites the respiratory muscles not to occasional and sudden actions , but to the constant combined action of opening the passages to the air .
Even in the decapitated head , this influence will cause the muscles of the nostrils to be drawn repeatedly , as in natural breathing* .
Of the Supply of Blood to the Nerves of the Respiratory System .
We have seen that the lateral part of the medulla oblongata and cervical part of the spinal marrow are more necessary to life than the brain itself ; that as on this part and the nerves thence arising , the actions of respiration depend , the phenomena of life depend more directly upon them than on any part of the animal body .
It being at the same time perfectly well understood , that no quality of brain or nerve , or vital property in any part , can exist without a supply of arterial blood , it becomes an object of interest to know how nature has provided for a bountiful arterial circulation to these important organs .
Our books , in treating of the circulation in the brain , state that the supply of blood to it is very much greater than to any other part of equal weight .
This is correct , and would of itself mark the importance of the organ .
But in proceeding to show how this is accomplished , they state , that four great arteries ascend to the brain , and that of these the vertebral arteries , for greater security against the supply of blood being dangerously diminished , ascend through the foramina in the cervical vertebrae .
We object to this last conclusion .
It is not to secure the free circulation through the brain that the vertebral arteries take this tortuous and concealed course .
It is for the supply of arterial blood to these vital nerves , and to that part of the spinal marrow which gives origin to them .
This idea suggested itself to me , on observing , in a subject minutely injected , with what a copious supply of tortuous arteries these nerves and the side of the medulla oblongata were surrounded .
When these arteries , branches of the vertebral artery , and their accompanying veins were removed , we saw the foramina by which they enter into the respiratory column conspicuous beyond what is seen in other parts .
This opinion was pointed out in a former paperf ; but the subject acquires a higher interest from the observations of Sir ASTLEY COOPER .
He found that , on compressing the vertebral arteries at the lower part of the neck , where they are about to enter the canal of the bone , the animal ceased to breathe .
It did not die like an animal suffocated by compression of the windpipe , but there came a gradual subsidence of the motion of respiiation , evincing that the source of activity and of sensibility in the centre of the respiratory system was withdrawn .
Practically considered , this is a subject of interest .
Are we not daily seeking for the cause of sudden death in organs , the condition of which cannot explain the phenomena ; for example , the heart and brain ?
The pathologist is satisfied when he finds the heart in a slight degree removed from a condition of health ; and yet he must be aware that when wounded or deeply diseased , death is protracted : there is the agitation of dying , the labour of these organs of respiration .
It is only in violent injury , which shall affect the centre of the respiratory system , that there is no act of dying , but a sudden cessation of all action .
The bruiser , on receiving a blow on the throat , or a blow on the stomach unexpectedly , is killed , as by the coup-de-grace given to the malefactor broken on the wheel .
He dies instantly without a sigh , and without a motion of the features indicative of agony .
Are not these instances of injury propagated to the centre of the nerves of this system , on which the vital action of respiration and expression depend The cause is equal to the effect ; while death from organic lesion in the thorax , is attended with symptoms , with suffering , more or less prolonged , with the act of dying .
254

