Remarks on the Theory of the Dispersion of Light , as connected with Polarization .
By the Rev. BADEN POWELL , MIA .
F.R.S. F.G.S. , Savilian Professor of Geometry in the University of Oxford .
Received May 10 , -Read May 31 , 1838 .
Introductory Observations .
( 1 .
) IN the course of four successive papers , I have laid before the Royal Society the comparison of observations of the refractive indices for the standard rays in various media , with the results calculated from the formula of theory , as deduced upon the most improved views of the hypothesis of undulations ; the cases discussed including the greatest range of data which experiment has yet furnished .
The degree of accordance , thus exhibited between observation and theory , even in the most extreme case , I believe will now be considered sufficient to warrant the conclusion that the theory at least affords a very satisfactory approximation to the expression and explanation of the actual law of nature ; and this in the instance of a class of phenomena which it had long been the reproach of that theory to be supposed incapable of accounting for , if they were not absolutely contradictory to it .
At any rate , if , in the instances referred to , the discrepancies should by any be thought still too great , or , if it should be contended that other cases may yet arise in which theory may be put to a severer test , yet , with so strong a presumption in its favour , the only fair inference would be , that further examination was required of the principles on which any extension or modification of the theory might be pursued .
( 2 .
) The investigation , then , having advanced thus far , it seemed desirable , as a sequel to my former papers , to devote the present to some remarks connected with the theory which has been thus applied .
The facts of interference , on which the undulatory theory was originally based by Dr. YOUNG , obliged us to adopt some idea of an alternating mIotion , as well as a motion of translation , in our conception of light .
And this , with all the accessions it has received , especially from the investigations of FRESNEL , has at the present dav been connected by the labours of M. CAUCHY and others With general dynamical principles , which regulate the propagation of vibratory motions through an elastic medium .
( 3 .
) More precisely , from such dynamical principles certain differential equations of motion have been deduced .
the integration of which gives the well-known expression for a wave , involving the relation between the velocity and the wave-length which explains the dispersion .
The direct and complete integration of these form.s , effected lie M. CAUCHY , and simplified by Mr. TovEY and Mr. KELLAND , involves certain conditions , viz. the evanescence of certain terms ; the interpretation of which implies peculiar views of the constitution of the ether .
Whether a direct and complete solution , without the introduction of these conditions , can be attained , does not appear .
But Mr. TovEY has been the first ( as far as I am aware ) to point out ( in one of his valuable series of papers in the London and Edinburgh Journal of Science ) that , without these conditions , a certain form of the wave-function is a particular solution of the equations ; and this form is precisely that expressing elliptically polarized light .
( 4 .
) Upon a careful examination of that most important and ingenious investigation , it appeared to me that there were one or two questions connected with the subject still requiring to be cleared up .
If the absence of the conditions in question be essential to the case of elliptically and circularly polarized light , it follows that all the preceding investigations ( which depend on the fulfilment of those conditions ) are applicable only to unpolarized and plane-polarized light , and consequently the general integration is limited in a most material part of its application ; a defect which is only remedied by the supplementary investigation of Mr. TovEY , in which , for this case , a particular solution is assigned .
It seemed , then , necessary to show explicitly that the non-fulfilment of the conditions , that is , the non-evanescence of the terms in question , is essential for elliptically polarized light , as their evanescence is for common light ; and thus to exhibit distinctly the relation between the cases of elliptically polarized , and those of plane-polarized and unpolarized light : and again , to remove , if possible , the obscurity and discrepancy of opinion in which the physical interpretation of those conditions , with regard to the supposed constitution of the ethereal medium , appeared to be involved .
With this object , it seemed necessary to take up the subject from its first principles ; and , in pursuing the inquiry , I gladly acknowledge the valuable suggestions I have derived in the course of some correspondence with Mr. LUBBOCK .
I have been thus led to combine the elucidation of the points just referred to , in a connected view with preceding results , by a simplified method ; and to trace clearly the relation between the changes in the conditions supposed with regard to the ether , the resulting state of polarization in the ray , and the expression for the dispersion .
Analytical Investigation .
( 5 .
) For the purpose of the ensuing investigation it will be necessary to premise a brief statement of the formulas adopted from the undulatory theory .
On the ordinary principles of that theory , the form u= { ca sin(nt-kx)}.(1 .
) is the sum of a number of functions , each expressing a single wave , whose aggregate constitutes a ray of light ; ( u ) is the displacement of the vibrating molecule of ether ; ( a ) the amplitude of vibration ; ( t ) the time from the beginning of the disturbance ; ( ) the distance along the ray from the molecule first agitated ; while ( - % ) is the velocity of propagation , which further involves the relation 1nr =k and k= * ... ( 2 .
) where ( ' ) is the refractive index , and ( X ) the wave-length in the mediurm .
( 6 .
) The investigations of FRESNEL require us to suppose the vibrations performed in planes at right angles to the direction of the ray : or , in general , referring the whole motions to three rectangular axes x , y , z , of which we may suppose x to coincide with the direction of the ray , and naming the displacements in each of those directions respectively I , a , 4 , we must suppose a= 0 , while each of the others are functions of x and t of the form above , viz. = { c. sin ( n t-kx ) } .
i E3 sin ( n t-k ) } { .j ) In polarized light the amplitudes a are in FRESNEL 's notation o=cosi and(_=sini , where i is the angle formed by the direction of the vibration with that of polarization ; whence also as2 + P2 1 ... ... ... .
2ndly .
If n be an independent constant these expressions give the index in the simple inverse ratio of the wave-length , which is manifestly not the law of the unequal refrangibility of the primary rays as appears at once from what is termed the irrationality of dispersion .
But the application of the formulas to the ordinary .
phenomena is in-dependent of this , and will be equally valid if d be dependent on X , precisely or very nearly in the relation expressed by the formula which has been compared with experiment in my previous papers , and which thus explains the unequal refrangibility .
Now it has been shown by the distinguished mathematicians already mentioned , that , under certain conditions , the expressions ( 3 .
) can be derived from equations of motion for the vibrations of an elastic medium on dynamical principles , which also involve the desired relation between p and X. It will be necessary to state and explain these equations , which may be most shortly done as follows : ( 8 .
) Let the coordinates in space of any molecules m , m ' be respectively m ... . .
X mt ... ... X+ At X Yv+Ay ?
+ AZJ and the distance between them r= ( Ax2+Ay2+A 2).(8 .
) Let the force which maintains the system of molecules as an elastic medium be any function of the distance as f ( r ) : then it will be easily seen that we have for the forces in the direction of the three axes , in equilibrium , If ( r ) =0 _f ( r ) , =.(9 .
Az If ( r ) = ?
J Let the system be disturbed , and after a time ( t ) let the displacements in the direction of the three axes be respectively M ... .
~e+ An* m { + , t+w C ?
t.*.4 .
( 10 .
) also the distance becomes r+Ar= V{(AX+A)2+(Ay+A ; )2+(AZ+At)2 } ( 11 .
) In this condition it will be easily seen that we have for the forces in the direction of the three axes , dg { f ( + X r ) r+A dt2+ rr}A d9-4 ts= &gt; f(r+ A+A|d~~~~+ r. .
1 .
~~ r+ Are 5r On epaningthevale 0f(r +A r ) On expanding the value of f+ Ar ' neglecting the squares , substituting in the above equations ( 12 .
) , observing that they will involve the expressions ( 9 .
) for equilibrium , which vanish , and writing for abridgement , f ( r + Are ) =_f ( r ) +_ ( r ) rA rr +A r. r ) r--drr r while we have rArA a+ Ay A ; o+ Z AA these equations of motion ( 12 .
) will ultimately become d~ gs=2{ p ( r ) / f r+4(r ) AxZ(/ AxL/ \ + idYL/ fi+A/ z A ) } dgs 2{((r)A\+4(r)Ay(AxA\+ AyA\+ / zA ) } ( 13 .
) dd ts r iC++()AZ( + A\y A7 + Az }J d2 ~ These equations form the common basis of all the investigations of the subject as originally pursued by MM .
NAvIER and CAUCHY .
They apply generally to all elastic media , or systems of molecules , affected only by their mutual attractions and repulsions , and slightly disturbed .
( 9 .
) In applying this hypothesis to the case of light , agreeably to what has been already observed ( ? .
6 .
) , we have Aa=O and ds Z= , so that the equations ( 13 .
) are reduced to dId t2 = &gt; ( r ) Ai+Y ( r ) Az [ A\y A\ + Az A / \i ] } .
J The general direct integration of these forms , and even of the preceding ( 13 .
) , has been effected by the writers already referred to ; but only upon the suppositions E { Ay Az } = 0 , and I { sin kA x } = 0.(15 .
) the import of which will be considered in the sequel .
Mr. TOvEY by a skilful analysis gives a particular solution corresponding to the case of elliptically polarized light , without introducing those conditions .
The investigation , however , appears susceptible of being simplified ; and we shall here pursue a method at once attaining this , object , and enabling us more clearly to trace out some interesting results , as follows : Taking the finite differences of the expressions ( 5 .
) , we have 2sin2 x sin ( n t-k x)-sinkAxcos(nt-kx ) ( 16 .
) fcos b [ 2 sin2 Q')sin ( n t-kx)-sin kAx cos ( n t-k kx ) ] C|+Psinb si'nkAxsin(nt-kx)-2sin ( e cos ( nt -kx)j .
Also , differentiating them , we find , d n2 05 sin ( n t-Akx ) ... ... . .
( 18 .
) dt2= =-2 cos bsin(nt-kx)-n21sinbcos(nt-kx ) ... ( 19 .
) On arranging the terms in ( 14 .
) we may write for abridgement , p= p(r ) + 4(r ) Ay2 p'(r ) +4 ' ( r ) A\ z2. .
* .
* ( 20 .
) q=4i(r ) AyAz 20=kAx J and those forms ( 14 .
) will thus become , d z2 =N DP A8 +q A i ] ** *..(21.a ) dt2d =P [ p ^A+q Ant ] ?
valuesof those variable terms ) , we shall have the following equations : r+y{p sinb } sin2dj flca= + q{t3cosb}2i0. .
( 25 .
) 2 sin2 &amp; .(2 ) + p{V J ? ?
2{ P{ b } ~~sin 2 } q { j3 sin b } 2 sin2J +p'{ sinb } sin2 ' -n2 cos b= +P { cos b } }(27 .
) 2 sin2 0 -n2 dsinb= p{ cosb J ( 28 .
) -p ' { fsin b}2 sin2 0 From the two last forms ( 27 .
) ( 28 .
) we obtain by multiplication and addition , p ' I{ cos 2b2 sin20 n2 q ~{cos b J } ... ( 2,9 .
) q { asin b } sin2 0 And in like manner from ( 25 .
) and ( 29 .
) we deduce [ p { P2 cos 2 b1 -n2 ( 22 + r2 ) +p { 6c2 I2sin2O } .
v* ( 30 .
) l+q { 2zfcosbJ In the case of elliptically polarized light we have o2 + P2 = 1 ; and it is thus obvious that when the quantities involved give the value of n2 as here expressed , viz. , pI { 32 cos 2 b } 1 -n2 i+p { 2 } [ 2 sinn2 } .
* * which , on dividing by k2 , restoring the value of d ( 20 .
) and of k ( 2 .
) , will give for the velocity ( or k ) ( on multiplying both numerator and denominator by ( 42 ) on the second side of the equation , and including all the coefficients in a new single term , ) the formula 1 z,1 2( x , ... ... .
( 3 H ~~~~~~~~~~~~33 .
) the same which has been deduced for unpolarized and plane polarized light .
From this formula , on the supposition of a common coefficient , I made my approximate computations in Nos. I. and II .
of my former Researches .
On expanding the sine and dividing by the arc there results a series of even powers of k , which , in a generalized form , is that from which Sir W. R. HAMILTON deduced his elegant formula for interpolation , by which I performed my calculations in No. III .
From a similar series , also , M. CAUCHY has deduced the elaborate method of calculation which he has applied to FRAUNHOFER'S indices in his Nouveaux Exercices de Mathdenatiques , and also in his lithographed memoir on Interpolation : whilst the same series obtained by Mr. KELLAND , and modified by the introduction of the value of x , in vacuo ( that terma being in the above formula the wave-length in the medium ) , or ( Q L ... ( 34 .
) is the formula which I employed and explained in No. IV .
Precisely equivalent results are also deduced by Mr. TOvEY .
( 11 .
) The term on which the dispersion depends , viz. sin 'r ( , : A ) .
, ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... .
( 35 .
) manifestly approaches to unity as Ax diminishes in comparison with X , the application of which was originally pointed out by Mr. AIRY .
The dispersion is insensible in free space , and large in dense media .
Hence Mr. KELLAND has inferred that the ether is in a state of greater density in free space , and less in dense media .
We shall recur to this point in the sequel .
( 12 .
) Experiment does not show that the state of a ray as to polarization , produces any difference in the magnitude of its refractive index .
Hence it follows that in the formula ( 30 .
) the values of n2 must be constant for all values of b , as well as of a and j3 .
Hence for any particular value of b the several sums of terms involved must be supposed to vary in magnitude , so that , joined with the condition ( 4 .
) , the whole expression shall always remain constant , and equal to that in the case where b vanishes , and where as and f are no longer restricted to the condition ( 4 .
) .
The examination of the cases thus arising , is closely connected with the question of the evanescence of the terms before alluded to ( 15 .
) .
These relations therefore we shall now proceed to trace .
But it will be desirable first to point out more clearly the nature and meaning of those conditions .
( 13 .
) It is evident from the value of r ( 8 .
) that it does not change its sign along with a change of sign in A x , A y , or A z ; the same is true therefore of P ( r ) and %4 ( r ) .
It is also evident that A y2 , A %2 , do not change the signs .
But the product AyA z , will change signs as each value of Ay corresponds to a negative and a positive value of A z. Hence the terms + ( r ) sin kAxA ( r)lAy2 sin kAx 4(r ) A Z2 sin kA x ( r ) Ay A zsink Ax A ( r ) Ay Az Sin2 A x ) will have values with opposite signs .
But , ,1 ( r ) sin2 ( k A A(r ) Ay2 sin2 ( Jc ) ' ( r ) A z2 sin2 ( A ) will have all their values with the same sign .
If then we consider the sums of a number of such terms respectively , those of the first set may become 00 if the positive and negative sums be equal .
In those of the second set this cannot happen .
Hence resuming our abridged notation we may have either Y(p sin 2 ) =0 or I(p sin 2O ) =1 E ( p'sin2 ) ) =. .
( 36 .
) Y ( p'sin2d)=s. .
( 38 .
) 1 ( q sin 2 ) =0 Y ( q sin 2 O ) = sJ I ( q sjrn2 )= Oka ( 37a ) 1 ( qsin2 d ) s , , .
( e0 ( 9 .
) but always I ( p sin2 0 ) = }* E ( p ' sin2 0 ) = ( 4 .
The conditions which give these values respectively , are dependent on the general supposition relative to the arrangement of the molecules .
If the distribution of the molecules in space be uniform , the values ( 36 .
) ( 37 .
) obtain .
If not uniform , the values ( 38 .
) ( 39 .
) may obtain ; but in particular cases , or for particular directions of the ray , the greater number of terms of one sign may compensate for the greater magnitudes of those of the other ; or the conditions ( 36 .
) ( 37 .
) may hold good .
( 14 .
) We now resume the consideration of the formulas before deduced .
From ( 28 .
) we have sinb _ cae(q singe ) + cosbE ( p sinQO ) ( 41 .
) sn I QfE ; ( pI sinu O ) Now if the conditions ( 36 .
) obtain , that is , if we have : ( q sin 2 0 ) = 0 , and E ( p ' sin 2 ) .
( 42 .
) then ( 41 .
) will give sin b =O ; or b= 0 .
( 43 .
) But if the polarization be elliptical , b must have a finite value ; or in this case , consequently , the conditions ( 38 .
) must obtain ; or the non-evanescence of those terms is essential to the investigation for elliptically polarized light .
( 15 .
) If the polarization be circular , we have sC 3 , and b _cos b= 0 , sin b= l ; thus the form ( 26 .
) becomes 0 { 4.(psin24 ) } ( 4 ) { 2 ( q sin2gd ) .
But the condition of the non-evanescence of the terms holds good for the same reason as in the last case .
( 46 .
) ( 16 .
) For plane polarized light let X 0 , then the form ( 26 .
) becomes 0=E ( p sin 2 d ) ; ... ... ... .
( 47 .
) or for plane polarization it is essential to suppose the terms evanescent , or the conditions ( 36 .
) ( 37 .
) to befujJilled. .
* have any position whatever in respect to particular lines of direction which may subsist among the molecules of the ethereal medium .
Now , supposing the arrangement of the molecules to be perfectly uniform since the direction of the ray ( x ) must pass through m. , it follows that the sums of the distances of all those on each side of the line x , whether in the plane of y or of z , will be equal , or the hypothesis ( 36 .
) ( 37 .
) , or ( 48 .
) ( 50 .
) exactly fulfilled , for all positions of x in the medium .
If the arrangement be not uniform , the same hypothesis in general may be approximately fulfilled in proportion as we suppose a greater number of such molecules taken into account , or the summation extended to a greater number of terms , that is , a greater number of molecules within the sphere of the influence of the propagation of motion from the molecule first agitated .
But if we suppose any portion of the ether be so circumstanced that the sphere of influence is more limited , then the conditions ( 36 .
) ( 37 .
) will not be fulfilled even approximately , or the hypothesis ( 38 .
) ( 39 .
) will obtain ; though they would approach more or less towards fulfilment in different positions of the ray .
The diminution of the sphere of influence may arise either from a decrease in the force , or an increase in the distances of the molecules .
( 19 .
) Here also we may remark , in connexion with what was observed before ( ? .
11 .
) , that at the bounding surface of vacuum and a medium , or generally of two media of different densities , we can hardly suppose the change of density in the ether to take place abruptly ; but must , from all analogy , imagine a thin stratum on either side , within which there is a gradual alteration in the arrangement of the molecules , and this more considerable in proportion to the difference of refractive powers of the media .
Thus , even supposing the molecules uniformly distributed in the two media or portions of space , it is evident that within this stratum they will not be uniformly airranged .
And hence , though on either side the conditions ( 36 .
) ( 37 .
) should be fulfilled , within the stratum the conditions ( 38 .
) ( 39 .
) would take effect .
Conclusion .
( 20 .
) The general conclusions which I conceive have been obtained are as follows : When light is elliptically or circularly polarized , that is , when one of the two component vibrations is retarded behind the other , then , in the differential equations of motion , the opposite terms do not destroy each other in the summation ; that is , the arrangement of the molecules is not uniform .
When light is plane-polarized , or unpolarized , that is , when there is no retardation , or the phases of the component vibrations are simultaneous , then the opposite sums destroy each other ; that is , either the arrangement is uniform , or the sphere of the influence of the force so great , that the conditions are fulfilled very nearly .
Since both kinds of light can be propagated indifferently through ordinary media , it follows that the sphere of influence of the force , or number of molecules taken into account , -does not here depend on the arrangement of the molecules of ether in the medium , but on the retardation of one of the vibrations behind the other , or the absence of it , originally impressed on the ray in the respective cases .
These inferences appear of importance in connexion with the consideration of the causes on which polarization depends , and the laws of elasticity of the ether in crystallized bodies , as also the state of the ether at the bounding surfaces of media of different density , and the changes which may be effected in the state of polarization of a ray : and in what has here been laid down , I trust that the whole subject ( without entering into specific controversy ) will be found relieved from some degree of difficulty and objection .
NOTE TO ART .
6 .
If in equation ( 5 .
) b=2 ( without supposing oa = ) the vibration resulting is still elliptical .
In this case the expressions may be put into the form oi= E { acsin(nt -kx)}..(52 .
) 4= Y{fcos(nt-kx ) } This form is that adopted by Professor MACCULLAGH *to express the elliptical vibrations of the two rays in quartz , and by means of which he connects the laws of M. BiOT , and the theory of Mr. AIRY , with certain differential equations of vibratory motion , provided the quantities a , P , n , and k , are so assumed as to fulfil these conditions , viz. that if A and B be the squares of the velocities of the ordinary and extraordinary rays in common double refraction , in quartz we replace them respectively by A-k-s-C andB-k-f C where C is a new constant determined from BlOT'S observations .
The differential equations referred to are these : d8 -A d !
+Cd dt des dx3 cd j. ( 53 .
) d2 CX d2 XXX WF dx2dx3 But on taking the partial differential coefficients of the expressions ( 52 .
) it is easily seen ( from the particular forms of those functions ) that the equations ( 53 .
) are reducible to , d= [ A k dx+ dt B [ B+ ki ]C 4J which are of the well-known form ( ? .
7 .
) for vibratory motion .

