Ill. Of such Ellipsoids consisting of homogeneous matter as are capable of having the resultant of the attraction of the mass upon a particle in the surface , and a centrifugal force caused by revolving about one of the axes , made perpendicular to the surface .
By JAMES Ivoyv , K.H. MA .
F.R.S. L. 8S E. Instit .
Reg. Sc. Paris .
Corresp .
et Reg. Sc. Gottin .
Corresp .
Received June 20th , 1837.-Read 11th December , 1837 .
1 .
IN the Conn. des Temps for 1837 it is announced that a homogeneous ellipsoid with three unequal axes , and consisting of particles that attract one another according to the law of nature , may be in equilibrium when it revolves with a proper velocity about the least axis .
LAGRANGE has considered this problem in its utmost generality .
The illustrious Geometer found the true equations from which the solution must be derived : but he inferred from them that a homogeneous planet cannot be in equilibrium unless it have a figure of revolution .
Nevertheless M. JACOBI has proved that an equilibrium is possible in some ellipsoids of which the three axes have a certain relation to one another .
The same thing is demonstrated by M. LIOUSVILLE in 23rd cahier of the Journal de rEcole Polytechnique .
M. DE PONTECOULANT has also touched on the subject* .
M. JACOBI has thus detected an inadvertence into which those had fallen who preceded him in this research .
He has shown that the equations which , according to LAGRANGE , are capable of solution only in figures of revolution , may be solved in a certain class of ellipsoids with three unequal axes .
But the transcendent equations of M. JACOBI , although fit for numerical computation on particular suppositions , leave unexplored the points of the problem which it is most interesting to know .
It is easy to find a property characteristical of all spheroids with which an equilibrium is possible on the supposition of a centrifugal force .
From any point in the surface of the ellipsoid draw a perpendicular to the least axis , and likewise a line at right angles to the surface : if the plane passing through these two lines contain the resultant of the attractions of all the particles of the spheroid upon the point in the surface , the equilibrium will be possible ; otherwise not .
This will be evident , if it be considered that the resultant of the centrifugal force and the attraction of the mass must be a force perpendicular to the surface of the ellipsoid , which requires that the directions of the three forces shall be contained in one plane .
This determination obviously comprehends all spheroids of revolution ; but , on account of the -* Tom. iii .
Thor .
Anal. MDcccxxxvImI .
I complicated nature of the attractive force , it is difficult to deduce from it whether an equilibrium be possible , or not , in spheroids with three unequal axes .
The problem is unconnected with the physical conditions of equilibrium : it is purely a geometrical question respecting a property of certain ellipsoids .
2 .
Let the three semi-axes of an ellipsoid be represented by uk kVI + ?
2 , k V+x2 , X being supposed greater thain At ' ; and put x , y , z respectively parallel to the axes , for the coordinates drawn from a point in the surface to the principal sections of the solid : from the same point draw the line 6 within the ellipsoid at right angles to its surface ; and ?
being limited by the principal section perpendicular toc k , the axis of rotation , put p and q for the coordinates of the end of it in that plane , p being parallel to y , and q to z : from the condition that a is perpendicular to the surface of the ellipsoid , it is easy to deduce the values of p and q , viz. P =t *+ A'q= 1+ x4 Again , from the same point in the surface , draw the line i ' in the direction of the resultant of the attraction of the whole mass of the ellipsoid ; and let r and s , respectively parallel to y and z , represent the coordinates of the foot of I ' in the same principal section as before : then I ' will be the diagonal of a parallelopiped of which the three sides are x , y r , z s ; and the only three forces acting parallel to the sides of the parallelopiped and equivalent to the single force in the direction of the diagonal , will be proportional to the sides , x , y r , z -s .
Now from the nature of the ellipsoid , the attractive forces perpendicular to the principal sections , are proportional to the coordinates x , y , z ; and may be represented by A x , B y , C z : and , as these forces have their resultant in the direction of I ' , it follows from what has been said , that they will be proportional to x , y r , z s. In consequence we have these equations , A y parallel to the line / y2 + z2 drawn from the point in the surface of the ellipsoid at right angles to the axis of rotation ; and this condition requires that the triangle of which the sides are o , r p , q , shall be similar to the triangle formed by the parallel lines / y2 + z2 , y , z. From the similarity of the triangles , we deduce r-p tie S-q Iand hence , in consequence of the last formula , we finally obtain , BA = 1C AI+ 2+ X/ ..(1 .
) Every ellipsoid which verifies this formula is capable of an equilibrium when it is made to revolve with a proper angular velocity about the least axis ; for the line a ' representing the attraction upon a point in the surface , the line a will represent a centrifugal force , both in quantity and direction ; and the resultant of these two forces will be perpendicular to the surface of the ellipsoid .
The equation ( 1 .
) results immediately from the investigation of LAGRANGE , who concluded that it admits of solution only in spheroids of revolution , that is , when =X and B= C. By expressing the functions A , B , C in elliptic integrals , M. JACOBI has found that the equation may be solved when the three axes have a certain relation .
It is therefore demonstrated in general , that a certain class of ellipsoids with three unequal axes is susceptible of an equilibrium on the supposition of a centrifugal force ; but it still remains to investigate the precise limits within which this extension of the problem is possible , and to determine the ellipsoid when the centrifugal force is given .
3 .
In order to solve the problem in the view now taken of it , we must have recourse to the equations of LAGRANGE , which contain all the necessary conditions .
Letf denote the intensity of the centrifugal force at the distance equal to unit from the axis of rotation ; the same force urging the point in the surface of the ellipsoid at the distance / y2 + z2 from the axis , will be equal tof/ y2 + z2 , the components of which in the directions of y and z are respectivelyfy andfrz .
Now Ax , By , Cz , are the attractions of the mass of the ellipsoid ; wherefore the total forces urging the point in the surface are Ax , ( B-f)y , ( C-f ) z. These forces must have their resultant in the direction of g perpendicular to the surface of the ellipsoid ; and as they are parallel to the sides of a parallelopiped , of which g is the diagonal , they will be proportional to those sides , that is , to i2 x~~~~~ 2 We thus obtain these two equations , B-f I C-f IA 1+x2 ' A =J g2 ; and from these we deduce f=B2f=C+ AWE which coincide with the equations of LAGRANGE , It is next requisite to substitute for the symbols A , B , C , what they stand for .
The values given in the Mldcanique CUleste are in a convenient form for this purpose , viz. dF=~ed V ( 1 + X2x2 ) .
( 1 + X12 _2 ) 3M '61 3M dF sM p1dF A= f dF B= Cj J , =+ 3MJ1 dF In these expressions MI is the mass of the ellipsoid ; therefore if we put f for the density , we shall have M 47r p]M 4 .
( + X2 ) !
( ( 1 + x27 These several values being substituted in the equations ( 2 .
) , the result will be q= 4 &lt; .rX1 3 / 1 + ) &lt; f2tat 2.3 x9d x ( i -2 ) XI *.(0 q=V1+ Ado ( 1 + 2X2X2 ) ( I + ?
t2X-)2 V+ f2 X.3 x2 dx ( 1 2 ) 1 V ?
?1 +./ PJ o ( I + A2 X(2)1 ?
x ' ? !
J Here q stands for the proportion of the intensities of the centrifugal and attractive forces ; it depends only on the kind of matter of which the spheroid is formed , and the velocity of rotation .
4 .
The equations ( 3 .
) comprehend all ellipsoids that are susceptible of an equilibrium on the supposition of a centrifugal force .
To begin with the more simple case of the spheroid of revolution , let X ' = 1 ; and the two equations will coincide in one , ViZ .
q.1.22 ) .
which expresses the relation between q and 1 , in a spheroid of revolution having its semi-axes equal to k and k / 1 + 12 .
From the equation ( 4 .
) we learn that q will be known when I is given , or that every spheroid of a determinate form requires an appropriate velocity of rotation .
The inspection of the same equation is sufficient to show that q is positive for all values of 12 ; and as it vanishes both when 12 is zero and infinitely great , it must pass at least once from increasing to decreasing , or it will admit of at least one maximum value .
By differentiating with regard to I we obtain dq -3 x2(I x2 ) ( I -12x2 ) ( J ( l +1 j ; *X2)*.(5 ) from which formula we learn that ddq is positive between the limits 12 0 and,21 dl 12 = 1 ; that it will consist of a positive and a negative part when 12 is greater than I ; and the positive part decreasing while the negative part increases , that it will ultimately be negative when / 2 is infinitely great .
It follows therefore that 21d q can be only once equal to zero , and consequently that q can have only one maximum value , while P increases from 0 to cG .
Applying to the equations ( 4 .
) and ( 5 .
) the known method of integration , we get 3 ( 3 + 12 ) 9 q= 13 are tan Il-gI ?
dq _3(9+12 ) 3 1(9 + 7l2 ) 2IdI 214 are tan l-I -l of which expressions the first will verify the other .
To determine the maximum of q , we have dq l d= 0 91l 7 13 are tan 1-(1 12 ) ( 9 + 12 ) ; and the only value of I in this last equation is l 25293 .
By substituting this value of I we obtain 0 3370 for the maximum of q. With respect to spheroids of revolution it thus appears that an equilibrium is impossible when q or is greater than 0 3370 : in the extreme case , when q is equal to 0,3370 , there O3 is only one form of equilibrium , the axes of the spheroid being k and k , / I ( 2.5293)2= 2-7197 k ; but when q is less than 0'3370 there are two different forms of equilibrium .
, the equatorial radius of one being less , and of the other greater , than 2'7197 k , k being the semni-axis of rotation .
The number of the forms of equilibrium in spheroids of revolution is purely a mathemuatical deduction from the expression of q ; and as this has been known since the time of MACLAURIN , the discussion of it was all that was wanted for perfecting this part of the theory .
Returning now to the general equations of the problem , let _/ 3 X2 d V( + Al ) .
( I+ A ' % ) a , ~~~V ( I/ + 9X2 ) , ( + lt ' ) and it will be found that the two equations ( 3 .
) are thus expressed : -d_ dp q -d-xX q=d xtIt Further , put pX X1'5 , r2 -= ( A XI)2 , and we shall have pf'3x2dx V(1 +p ) +2 o(0 ' 3 X2 dx , ( 1 +P -X9T +T2t and the two values of q in the partial differentials of pr elatively to X and X ' being expressed in the palrtial differentials relatively to p and T2 , we shall obtain dc~ dp d cp q -d-x= dp= + -d ( - ?
) , q=d q5 41 : d P_ d @( s These two values of q coalesce in one when x XI 0 .
that is , in spheroids of revolution ; and we thus fall again upon the same equation that has already been discussed .
In all other cases the two values cannot subsist together , unless q dp.(6 .
-v r ' which equations apply exclusively to ellipsoids with three unequal axes , and solve the problem with regard to that class .
The latter of the equations ( 6 .
) expresses the relation that the two quantities p and r2 m Lust have to one another in every ellipsoid with three unequal axes which is susceptible of an equilibrium .
The fluxional operation indicated being performed in the same equation , the result will be , pI 2(1 x2)(1 p2v2)dx 0= I , ... ... .
1. .
( 7 ) 0 ?
( ( 1 ?
+ X 2 ) ?
+s X2 ) &lt; ' which is no other than a transformation of the equation ( 1 .
) , and is equivalent to other transformations of the same equation found by M. JACOBI and M. LIoUSVILLE .
The formula ( 7 .
) cannot be verified unless p , or X X ' , be greater than 1 ; for if p were equal to 1 , or less than 1 , the integral would be positive .
This agrees with the limitation of M. JACOBI .
If any value be assigned to X2 , it is evident that a corresponding value of p may be found which will verify the formula ( 7 .
) : for , if p be made to increase continually above I , the integral , which is positive at first , will finally be negative ; and it must be zero , in passing from one of these states to the other .
This proves that there does exist an infinite number of ellipsoids not of revolution , which are susceptible of an equilibriu.rn Let V stand for the integral in the equation ( 7 .
) ; and supposing that p and r2 vary so as always to satisfy that equation , we shall have dV dV do 0 .
dp -d0 Now , r2 representing any positive quantity , we may conceive it to increase from zero to be infinitely great ; in which case it follows from the nature of the function V , that during the whole increase rdV 'r dr will be negative : wherefore the other term d V~~~~~~~~~~~~~~rdI dV dp will be positive ; which requires that p decrease continually .
Since p decreases when r2 increases , the greatest value of p will answer to the least value of r2 , that is , to zero ; and hence , by making 2=0 in the formula ( 7 .
) , we shall obtain this equation , viz. I1 ( 2 ... -)(_-p2x2)dx JO PX p2)3 for finding the greatest value of p. It is obvious that there is only one value of p that will verify the equation just found ; for the integral can pass only once from being positive to be negative while p increases from 1 to be infinitely great .
Let p= 12 , l = , ; and the equation will be changed into this which follows , Xl/ ( 12 l3 + 14 ) ? ?
4+ 12 6 ) ?
o ( I + z2)3 of which the integral is , l2z+(1 *,12)2 3 ?
+5Z3 3+ 1412 + 3l4 f4 dz Supposing , and X ' to vary from this extreme , when the first increases , the other will decrease ; so that , when X is infinitely great , A ' will be zero ; which proves that the other extreme limit is a cylinder extending indefinitely on either side of the base , which is a circle having k for its radius .
6 .
It remains to consider the value of q. In the first of the equations ( 6 .
) , let the operation indicated be performed , and the result will be f= p3x2(I x)dx { ( + ?
p)(l +px2 ) + pv2x2 } q ( ( +p ) +I ( ( i + p2)2 + r2X2 &gt; and from this we obtain the value of q in the extreme case when r2 _ 0 , or when X and ?
J are equal , viz. -1 SO .
z1_Xi ) dxq J ' P ( I +2PY)d2 which is no other than the determination of q in a spheroid of revolution having its axes equal to k and k V2-9414 =X 1x7150 .
In the other extreme case , when r2 is infinitely great , q is zero .
It has been shown that for every given value of r2 , there is only one value of p , and only one ellipsoid ; and when r2 and p are both ascertained , the foregoing expression proves that q is fully determined .
Thus there is an appropriate value of q to every ellipsoid susceptible of an equilibrium .
In the formula for q , one of the two quantities , r2 and p , increases when the other decreases ; and hence it may be surmised that more than one ellipsoid may answer to a given value of q. Some calculation is necessary to elucidate this point .
For the sake of abridging expressions , put P=V(1 + p)2+r2 Q / ( I +pX2)2 +r2X2 Mp ( I +rp)(1 +pX2 ) +p2r2x2 du 3x2 ( 1 -_x2 ) dx , the variation of du being between the limits x=0 and x 1 : then , the foregoing value of q will be thus written : rdcM qYfd / QS and , q being considered a function of p and r2 , the fluxion with respect to p will be d qfr duJdM ( 1 + p ) M 3x2(1 +pX2)M dpP Qs * ldp-P p2 Qs 5 it will be found that p2 ?
( )+ p XI ) pi 3x( pX2 ) M= 3p( ( + p ) 1 -px ) 02p ( Lp)2 wherefore dq ( 1 Jr T2( ) + p)du ( I-2 ) dp P '(d PidUI~2 +Q12 + ~IS X4 _26 in consequence of the formula ( 7 .
) the first term is zero , so that we have dq=f(d 12 fQ+ ( 3 + 4p)_-p2X6 + 2T2vX4 ~~~ u ( IX)1UdQ And because 3+4p is always greater than p2 , it follows that dq is essentially podp sitive .
Again , by taking the fluxion relatively to r2 , we have ___ __ M ?
U2 2_M } __ =J pQ~s *t p2 --+ Qs J that is , dq p 2fd u 1p2X2 'rdv p3 J8 *P3 3P fndu ( q + ?
Qp ) x2 + ( 0 p+ p2 ) 4 p3 X6 +2 pr2 X2 Of this value the first term is zero by the formula ( 7 .
) ; and attending to the limits of p and of the integral , the second term is essentially negative .
Now we have dq dq -= .
dp + r , rd : if we suppose Tr2 to increase , p will decrease ; and according to what has been shown the two parts of dq will be negative .
Wherefore , while 2 increases from zero to be infinitely great , q will decrease continually from its first value to zero ; and for every possible value of q there will be only one value of r2 , and consequently only one ellipsoid susceptible of an equilibrium .
It would be superfluous to pursue this investigation further , and a mere waste of labour to seek the easiest formulas for solvino a problem which , it appears from what has been shown , can have no application in the theory of the figure of the planets .
It is extremely probable that no such figures as those required for the equilibrium of ellipsoids with three unequal axes , will be found to exist in nature .
It seems difficult to admit that any circumstances , or the action of any forces we are acquainted with , could induce upon a mass of fluid a figure adjusted with such mathematical nicety to the attraction of the mass and the centrifugal force .
If the existence of such a figure can be supposed , would it be permanent ?
Would not the least action of the other bodies of the system upon it be sufficient to destroy the exact confor nation on which the equilibrium depends , and leave the fluid to adjust its figure solely by the attraction and the centrifugal force of its particles ?
The discovery of JACOBI makes no change in the usual theory of the figure of the planets ; but it is valuable , as it completes a mathematical speculation , and finally settles what relates to the figure of ellipsoids susceptible of an equilibrium .

