Report of a Geometrical Measurement of the Height of the Aurora BorealLs above the Earth .
By the Rev. JAMES FARQUHARSON , LL. D. F.R.S. , Minister of the Parish of Alford .
Communicated by Mlajor SABINE , R.A. F.R.S. -c .
Received May 30 , -Read June 20 , 1839 .
hV -IEN , in 1833 , I observed the " instructions for observers of the auroora borealis , " circulated by the British Association for the Advancement of Science , I became desirous of aiding in the attainment of the objects the Association have in view ; the chief of which are , the determination by geometrical measurement of the height of the meteor alove the earth , and of the altitude and azimuth of the point to which the streamers seem to converge , and which has been named the centre of the corona .
The full accomplishment of my purpose has been ( lelayed by impediments , the chief of which will be referred to in the progress of this Report .
I have , however , at length obtained such results as I conceive will be cleeme(l of importance , and I beg leave respectfully to present them to the notice of the Royal Society .
I had soon an opportunity for determining , with sufficient accuracy , the altitude and azimuth of the point in the heavens to which the streamers seem to converge ; and as this constitutes an important element in enabling us to form a clear conception of the whole definite arrangement and prnogress of the meteor , and of the extent of reliance to be placed on the method afterwards had recourse to for measuring the height above the earth , and as that distinguished observer , Major SABINE , has since determined the dip of the magnetic needle at this place , which agrees with the angle of altitude of the point of convergence of the streamers , I shall proceed , first , to detail , from my notes made at the time , my observations on this point .
On the 29th December , 1833 , during the progress of a hard gale at nearly due west , temperature 420 FAHR. , there occurred here an aurora borealis , Inore nearly than any other I have seen , like the one seen by me here on the 29th of Septemlber , 1828 , contemporaneously with a luminous arch seen by DAVIES GILBERT , Esq. P.R.S. , at Roseimorran in Cornwall , as described by me in a letter to the President , which was honoured with a place in the Philosophical Trlansactions* .
The chief difference of the two consisted in there being , on the 29th of December , 1833 , many more arches of great length from east to west , well-defined , and separated , when in the plane of the magnetic dip , by clear lanes , from all the other arches and lights in other parts of the sky .
At 6 P.M. innumerable groups of brilliant streamers , and nebulous patches of light , appeared in almost all parts of the sky , but arranged into narrow arches , with clear lanes between them , near the plane of the magnetic dip .
The sky was clear of clouds , with the exception of one cloud of low elevation at south-east .
When the meteor was first noticed , there was one narrow distinct arch , almost continuous from the eastern to the western horizon , a little north of , and parallel to , the plane of the magnetic dip .
This arch made a rapid progress southward , always preserving its parallelism to the plane of the magnetic dip , and in four or five minutes passed into that plane , where its vertex presented the appearance named by observers a corona , well-defined and brilliant .
The appearance of the corona is that of innumerable pencils , or brushes of light radiating in all directions from a centre .
In the present instance the pencils pointing northward and southward were short , ending at the edges of the arch , which was only 4 ?
or 50 broad ; and those that pointed eastward and westward became blended with the streamers which formed its east and west ends .
A small space in the centre of the corona had a nebulous , rather than radiated appearance .
This was only about one degree broad , but prevented the determination of the centre , excepting by approximation within half a degree .
At the mornment when , in the southward progress of the arch , the centre of the corona became best defined , I had a good resource at hand for determining its place in the heavens , approximately , within such limits as the nebulous centrical light allowed .
This consisted in marking , on an outside stair rail , the precise point from which the centre of the corona was exactly seen , over an extreme projecting point on one of the corners of the Manse here .
The distinct arch of the aurora now described , continued to make a rapid progress southward , preserving always a parallelism with its earlier positions , and with the plane of the magnetic dip .
The short streamers to the north of the centre of the corona became more shortened ; and those to the south of it became proportionally longer , preserving in this way the vertex of the arch of a mean breadth with that of the other parts of it , till at length the corona lost the whole rays that had a northerly direction .
The whole arch , as it went on still further towards the south , became gradually enlarged in its lateral dimensions , that is , in breadth from north to south , as I have described other arches to have done , in the letter to the President of the Royal Society above referred to .
My attention was soon withdrawn from this arch by another now approaching the zenith from the north .
This was composed of much more brilliant streamers than the former .
It was considerably wider from north to south , and less evenly defined at its north and south edges , appearing there fitfully rugged , but quite distinctly separated from the numerous other lights in the sky by lanes clear of any form of the maeteor .
Expecting that it too would pass southward , and form a corona , when it reached the position where the other had done so , I provided a long straight-edged ruler , to ascertain by it whether the streamers in all parts of the sky were directed to the centre of the corona .
The arch soon passed southward into the plane of the magnetic dip , narrowing in breadth till it reached that position , and forming when there a corona , exactly like the former one , the centre of which had the same altitude and azimuth .
On looking at the centre of the corona over the straight edge of the ruler at one of its ends , while it was held out at arm 's length , and at the same time bringing the other end round to all parts of the sky , it was found that everywhere the streamers were directed lengthwise to the centre of the corona .
This latter arch passed southward as the former had done ; and like it also , increased its breadth from north to south in its onward progress from the plane of the dip .
It was succeeded by many other arches and fragments of arches , that is , arches cut short in their east and west dimension , all of which behaved themselves in a manner analogous to the two first arches , or to corresponding portions of them .
About an hour and a half after the aurora was first seen , the phenomena became faint at all points , and the sky soon after became obscured by clouds .
On the day following these observations , I measured , by means of a small graduated semicircle , with plummet , the angle that the line , joining the mark on the stair rail and the projecting point on the corner of the Manse , made with the horizon , and found it about 72 ? .
Major SABINE afterwards , on the 27th and 29th of August , 1836 , by 160 readings of his dipping-needle , determined the dip at this place to be then 72 ? ?
19'-5 .
I also laid down a horizontal line in the azimuth of the two points ; and having suspended over it , by means of a silk fibre , a horizontal magnetic needle , found that the needle came to rest parallel to the line .
It has been a matter of more difficulty to arrange the means , and find a fit opportunity , to determine the height above the earth , by the method recommended by the British Association , namely , by instrumental measurements of the angular elevations of an arch , made contemporaneously at two stations on the magnetic meridian , sufficiently distant from each other to give a clear and satisfactory parallax .
With the view of effecting this , I entered into arrangements with a gentleman whose residence is about six miles north of this place , and very near its magnetic meridian .
There intervenes the ridge of the Coreen hills , extending in length from east and west about ten miles , in breadth from north to south about four miles , and elevated at many points about 1000 feet above the level of the two stations .
After looking out for some years for corresponding observations of the same arch , although there was no want of appearances of the aurora , the gentleman and I found that the observed conditions and circumstances were so discrepant , as to prohibit the i-nference that we had at any time witnessed the same phenomenon .
We had agreed that each should observe to the northward of his own station .
In the mean time I obtained information which I deemed highly valuable for determining the locality of the stations that might be next selected .
The Rev. JOHN MINTO , a native of this parish , and schoolmaster of Clatt , which is on the north side * Major SABINE'S Observations on the Direction and Intensity of the Magnetic Force in Scotland , 1836 .
269 of the Coreen hills , had frequent occasion to pass between this place and Clatt .
His path over the hills is , at its most elevated part , nearly in the line of the magnetic meridian .
HLe informed me that he had passed in this line several titmes after dark , on occasions when the aurora borealis was visible .
At these times he had travelled in the northerly direction only ; but after seeing the whole meteor to the northward of his place , while ascending the south side of the highest part of his path , when he reached the valley on the north side , he then saw the aurora wholly to the south , and at such a low elevation as could not be accounted for by the known movement of the meteor itself , without taking into account its apparent change of place occasioned by his own movement northward .
This circumstance occurred to htim several times ; and he became impressed with the conviction , that the place of the meteor on these occasions was the Coreen hills , and that it was at no great elevation above them .
Mr. MINTO'S conclusion coincided with those I have had reason to form , from many observations of the meteor , respecting the lowness of the region in which it is visible ; and admitting the conclusions to be correct , it became obvious that the two stations , from whence to determnine its height , would be both most expediently chosen on one side of the ridge of hills .
This choice of stations was therefore had recourse to , and with a completely satisfactory result , as will be aftelrwards stated .
But previously to presenting the observations that were made at the selected stations , it seems necessary , for a right appreciation of their value , to mtake some remarks on an obvious misapprehension that yet seems to be entertained of the arrangement and progress of the aurora .
I had shown that its arrangement and progress are definite in relation to the lines of magnetism of the earth , in a paper published in the Edinburgh Philosophical Journal in April , 1823* , and afterwards in the letter addressed to the Presidert of the Royal Society , and published in the Philosophical Transactions , 1829 , above referred to .
In the latter publication , after describing various appearances of the aurora , I stated that these appearances indicated the following necessary results : " 1st .
That the aurora borealis always presents itself in definite and very curious relations to the lines of magnetism indicated by the needle .
; 2nd .
That the streamers , in the direction of their length , coincide with the plane of the dip of the needle , or nearly so ; and that each individual streamer is , in fact , parallel to the dipping-needle .
" 3rd .
That they [ the streamers ] form a thin fringe , stretching often a great way from east to west at right angles to the magnetic meridian .
c " 4th .
That the fringe moves away from the north magnetic pole , by the extinction of streamers at its northern face , and the formation of new ones , contiguous to its southern face .
5th .
That the invariable regularity of its appearance , as seen by many observers , when it comes fully within command of the eye near the zenith , shows the apparent irregularities , when it is seen either more northerly or southerly , to be only optical illusions .
" 6th .
That the region which it occupies is above , and contiguous to that of the clouds , or that in which they are about to form .
" Some terms employed in the " Instructions " of the British Association , and some also employed by M. ARAGO , in a passage of his printed in the Edinburgh New Philosophical Journal* , show , that these inductions of mine , regarding the arrangement and progress of the meteor , have been misunderstood or not admitted as accurate .
In the " I Instructions " it is said , " the determination of elevation can scarcely be applied to streamers of aurora , except when some sudden incurvation , or change , occurs which may happen to be noticed at two stations ; but the arches are of a less evanescent nature .
" This obviously implies that the streamers and the arches are two distinct and unconnected branches of the phenomena .
The terms of M. ARAGO imply the same thing .
He says , " when in our climates the aurora borealis is complete , when one part of its light pictures on space a well-defined arch , the culminating point of this arch is in the magnetic meridian ; and its two points of apparent intersection with the horizon are at equal angular distances from the same meridian .
When it projects luminous columns , [ by which he evidently means streamlers , ] from different portions of the arch , their point of intersection , called by certain meteorologists the centre of the cupola , is found in the magnetic meridian , and precisely upon the prolongation of the dipping needle .
" Here too the arches and the streamers are considered as distinct objects .
But an arch of the aurora is composed of a number of streamers grouped and aggregated togethier within a defined stereomrnetric space , whose bounding planes bear certain relations to the lines of magnetism of the earth .
It is this fact that I announced in the Edinburgh Philosophical Journal in 1823 , and afterwards in the letter to the President of the Royal Society ; and if the arrangement is not yet understood , it may have been owing to a misapprehension of the terminology I employed ; or , more probably , to my not having , in the letter to the President , entered into a detail of the varieties of the arches that often present themselves , as I had done in the Edinburgh Journal .
I would endeavour now to supply the deficiency , by defining the terms , and entering into some more detail of the varieties , or rather apparent varieties of the arches ; for the numerous observations of the aurora I have since made , convince me more fully of the existence of that definite order of its arrangement and progress which I have formerly described , and that it is worthy of being understood , however much I may have hitherto failed clearly to explain it .
The terms arch and streamer of the aurora , I had used without defining them , because I conceived them to be in common use among observers ; and I shall now perhaps be able best to define them , after presenting anew one part of the description of the whole meteor , which I had given in the Edinburgh Philosophical Journal in 1823 , which is as follows .
" In this latitude , ( about 57 ? ?
12 ' N. ) the aurora borealis , on those evenings when it is visible , generally first shows itself , after dark , like a bright but circumscribed twilight on the visible horizon , the centre of which is exactly on the northern point of the magnetic meridian .
So long as the bright space continues low , its light often nearly resembles the pale blue white light of the real twilight ; but varies momentarily by incessant and undefined fits of gleaming and obscluration .
By degrees the meteor enlarges itself , rising higher , and extending more from east to west on the horizon .
The play of the fitful gleaming light becomes gradually better defined ; and the whole luminous space presents the appearance of pencils , or bundles , of rays pointing upwards , and , when viewed in narrow compartments , maintaining a parallelism among themselves , similar to that exhibited by the rays of the sun when he shines through broken clouds athwart a hazy atmosphere .
The rays which are on the magnetic meridian are parallel to that line , pointing exactly to the zenith ; and those which are considerably to the eastward or westward of that meridian are directed to a point which appears within the limits of 10 ?
[ 18 ?
] to the southward of the zenith .
The bluish white light changes into a beautiful pale green , which when the ineteor rises quite above the horizon , as will be afterwards described , becomes tinged at the lowser extremity of the rays with bllue and violet , and at their upper extremity with yellow and orange .
The rays are very various in their intensity of light , as compared with one another ; their higher and lower portions also frequently differ from each other in that respect ; and the whole appea-rance of each ray variies incessantly .
It now breaks off , and disappears for a considerable space at its higher or lower extrernity , and then immediately becomes again luminous to its former extent ; now seemingly runs from east to west or from west to east through 5 ?
or 10 ?
or 12 ?
during the space of a second or two , preserving correctly its parallelism with other rays , which it approaches or passes in its progress ; then remains stationary for a second or two , undergoing varlious changes of vividness ; and afterwards disappears instantaneously , to have its place supplied by another ray , created as rapidly as its predecessor was annihilated .
This magnificent and beautiful light gradually extends itself towards the south , and at length separates itself from the northern horizon at the point of the magnetic meridian , and forms a flat luminous arch in the northern part of the heavens .
The arch still goes on to make progress towards the south , its convex or upper part approaching the zenith , and its concave or lower side becoming more widely separated from the horizon .
When it reaches an elevation of about 45 ?
, it presents the appearance of a broad [ curved ] zone , occupying from north to south the space of from 25 ?
to 350 at its vertex , and having its eastern and western extremities resting on the visible horizon .
" In this passage , both the streamers and the arch of the aurora are described .
The streamers are the narrow pencils , or bundles , of rays whose upper extremities are directed to that point in the heavens which forms the upper prolongation of the line of the dipping needle .
They are severally in a state of incessant extinction and renovation .
An arch is the curved zone of light formed by an aggregation or grouping of a great number of streamers into a definite form .
Although composed entirely of parts ( streamers ) which are severally evanescent , yet the perpetual renewal of these within a definite space , or in a definite direction in relation to the place of the extinct ones , renders the arch relatively permanent ; and it often continues for several hours , shifting however gradually towards the south .
In continuation of the above passage taken from the Edinburgh Philosophical Journal , I had described the further progress of such an arch as that mentioned in it , and shown , that it passes at length into the plane of the magnetic dip , gradually contracting its breadth , from north to south , as it nearly approaches that plane , the streamers of which it is composed still pointing , in every part of it , to the point which is on the prolongation of the dipping needle ; and that , when it at last reaches the plane of the magnetic dip , it forms a narrow zone , seldotn exceeding 4 ?
or 5 ?
from north to south , stretching across the heavens at right angles to the magnetic meridian , and composed now , in its east and west ends , of streamers which no longer cross its breadth , as they did while it was in a more northerly position , but are parallel to the zone itself , and therefore pointing east and west .
In that journal , I had added to the description of the arrangement and progress of the longer and more complete arches that present themselves , a description of some of the varieties , or shorter arches , which at various times occur , either by themselves , or mingled up with the longer arches .
I shall quote from the Edinburgh Philosophical Journal the account I had given of these varieties , because , in the letter to the President of the Royal Society , I neglected to describe them along with the more lengthened arches ; and the neglect may have occasioned misapprehension of the whole subject on the part of those who have seen only the letter to the President .
In the Edinburgh Journal , after a description of the more lengthened arch , and its progress , it is added , " such is the order of appearances presented by the aurora borealis , when it is observed under the most favourable circumstances .
It is very seldom , however , that all the successive phenomena , now described , have been observed continuously on the same evening ; but those observed at any one particular time have always been entirely consistent with the above description ; and I shall now enter a little into a detail of the varieties which present themselves .
It very frequently happens , that the twilight-like appearance on the northern horizon is all that is visible , and the phenomenon begins and ends with that .
In this case the meteor is seldom of long continuance ; but during the time that it lasts , the luminous space gradually enlarges itself towards the south .
It then gradually disappears ; frequently to be succeeded by another , appearing low on the horizon , to enlarge , and afterwards disappear , as its predecessor had done .
It happens also , very frequently , that , even when it makes more progress towards the south , it becomes gradually extinct long before it reaches the zenith ; for it is liable to a total extinction in every stage of its advancement ; but while it does continue , it follows the order above described , presenting the longest 2N2 273 pencils of rays when about 45 ?
elevation , and more dense , compact and shorter ones near the zenith .
It also very frequently happens that the meteor is suddenly formed high above the horizon , at first by feeble detached rays , becoming quickly more condensed and luminous .
But in whatever stage it first begins , the , succeeding relative progress is the same as above described .
It was chiefly those meteors , which were first formed above the horizon , that were observed to pass over the zenith .
Those formed further northward generally disappeared before reaching that point .
There is another modification of these appearances , and that is , when the meteor is entirely to the eastward or westward of the magnetic meridian ; and this is of not unfrequent occurrence .
In this case , the appearance and progress of the whole exactly agree with those of corresponding portions of the above described zone , which is formed when the meteor extends across the magnetic meridian .
The extremity of the luminous space which is nearest the magnetic meridian becomes first elevated above the horizon ; the pencils of rays are directed , longitudinally , to a point a little south of the zenith ; and the meteor moves gradually towards the south , contracting gradually its lateral dimensions as it reaches the prime vertical to the magnetic meridian , where it assumes the appearance of a nearly vertical column of brilliant light , 3 ?
or 4 ?
in diameter , composed of pencils of rays parallel to itself .
After passing some degrees to the southward of the prime vertical , the meteor begins to enlarge gradually in width , in an order the reverse of that in which it had become narrowed .
Some other apparent irregularities have been at times observed .
Thus the pencils of rays have sometimes been seen separated into detached groups ; but each group consistent in its appearance and position with those of the other groups , so that , had the spaces between them been filled up , a complete zone , such as above described , would have been formed .
A detachment into distinct groups sometimes takes place immediately previous to the disappearance of the meteor ; but sometimes also it is not immediately followed by that disappearance , but the zone becomes again complete , or nearly so , at a further stage of the progress southward .
But no [ real ] anomalies have been at any time observed ; nothing that is inconsistent with the described order of the phenomena .
" In addition to this detail of the varieties taken from a foirmer description , it seems necessary here to add , that although the most frequent appearance of the meteor consists of one , or a few regular zones behintd each other in a north and south direction , of great length from east to west , yet sometimes , as on the evenings of the 29th Septenber 1828 , and 29th December 1833 , the lengthened zones are accompanied with * Major SABINE , while here in 1836 , and observing the range of the Coreen hills , northward of this place , to run exactly at right angles to the magnetic meridian , suggested that the great regularity of the appearance and progress of the aurora here might be dependent on that circumstance .
The suggestion is highly worthy of attention .
The natural tendency of the meteor to the described order may be aided by the position of the hill ?
; and hence a peculiar regularity here ; but that the tendency is not altogether dependent on the locality , is proved by the crown of a lengthened arch being , in all places in Britain , on the magnetic meridian , and by the narrowness of the zone of light in the plane of the dip , as witnessed and reported by many observers .
y/ , ,y / 7 .
Puzi.:a'~ .
MDCCCXXXdX.(-I/ z/ ' Up , .
1 .
8/ ' ( 2/ iZ1 ?
nWnE72rOW1 .
A.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~i .
1'1~~~~~:rCA* ? ?
8 ?
I'c . !
ii^^ l^lllf ' : : : ; " 2 .
8^ ; w 9 ' ' : -. .
: : : .
; ' .
: , ' " , : ' ?
C all the described varieties , placed in the intervals between them .
The whole hemisphere is , in such instances , pervaded by the meteor ; and , on looking northward or southward , no regularity in the arrangement can be readily distinguished .
But on looking up in the plane of the magnetic dip , the described order is there immrnediately discovered .
The meteor there presents the appearance of intermingled longer or shorter narrow belts of fitful light , at right angles to the magnetic meridian , or columns at the east or west , having all clear intervals between them , and all making progress towards the south , preserving at the same time their parallelism with each other .
It seems also necessary to add , that the light of the several belts differs greatly in intensity ; some being composed of closely crowded and very brilliant streamers , and others of a few feebly-lighted , ill-defined ones .
It is now apparent , from the description , that the streamers are not phenomena distinct from the arches , but that the latter are just aggregations of the former within certain stereometric spaces , whose bounding planes bear definite relations to the lines of magnetism of the earth .
In the letter to the President of the Royal Society I named these aggregations fringes ; and , in fact , they resemble long fringes composed of threads , the threads being represented by the individual , nearly vertical streamers , or lengthened narrow straight pencils of rays of light .
The length of these filled stereometric spaces , at right angles to the magnetic meridian , is often very many miles , extending over head , when they come to the zenith , from the east to the west horizon , although they are frequently cut short in this dimension .
Their depth in a nearly vertical direction , or more properly in the plane of the magnetic dip , is determined by the length of the individual streamers that fill them .
This length of the streamers seems to vary considerably ; as some of the arches at about 45 ?
elevation may be seen about 20 ?
broad from north to south , and others 30 ?
and upwards .
The streamers in the same space , too , are not equal in length amrnong themselves , their inequality in this respect causing the jagged appearance of the north and south edges of the arches ; but in this respect also there are great differences , the edges of some arches , especially on very calm evenings , being even and regularly defined .
The thickness of the filled spaces from north to south appears to be always much less than their depth in the plane of the magnetic dip .
This thickness from north to south is clearly seen when the meteor comes into that plane , in its progress southward .
When there , an arch that at 45 ?
elevation may have been 20 ?
or 30 ?
broad from north to south , generally appears no broader than 4 ?
or 5 ?
, or even than 2 ?
or 3 ?
in some cases* .
It is the regular southward progress of the meteor that gives opportunity for the determination of the depth and thickness of the spaces filled with streamers .
When the meteor is considerably to the north , its depth is more or less directly seen ; when in the plane of the dip , its thickness from north to south is seen ; and when in that station , also , its progress southwards is seen to be occasioned by the extinction of streamers at its northern face , and the formation of new ones at the southern face ; and when it proceeds further south than the plane of the dip , its depth comes again more or less directly into view .
It is obvious that the stereometric spaces thus filled with streamers , when of considerable length from east to west , necessarily present to the eye the appearance of arches of light ; but the peculiar direction of the streamers gives to the arch , when in the plane of the ( lip , a very different aspect from what it has in a more northerly or southerly position .
I have so frequently seen the northerly arch pass into the plane of the magnetic dip , and assume there a very different appearance , as to leave no room for the suggestion in the " Instructions " of the British Association , that the arches in the two positions may be of different origin .
We are now prepared to make some observations on M. ARAGa'S reference to Iluminous columns projected from different points of the arch .
" Such an appearance is often seen , that is , luminous columns seeming to spring out of a lower and regular arch ; but it is only seeming ; for the columns belong to another arch composed of fewer streamers , more near the place of the observer , and therefore seen at a higher angle of elevation .
This is discovered when both the appearances come southward towards the plane of the magnetic dip .
Then the columns are seen to be advanced southward of the arch ; and there is observed an interval , frequently a wide one , clear of lights , between the two appearances .
The space occupied by the columns ( streamers ) may become more densely crowded with additional streamers in its onward progress , in which case it will become a well-defined arch , before it reach the plane of the dip ; or the streamers may not increase in number , yet , when it gets into that plane , it will be seen as one of those feebly lighted belts composed of few streamers which I have recently described .
I have so fiequently seen one or other of these results , in the case of columns seeming to project from a lower arch , as to leave no doubt that the appearance was an optical illusion , and that the columns were much nearer the eye than the arch .
I trtust it will be admitted , that we are now able to decide , under what conditions of its appearance , we shall effect a satisfactory geometrical measurement of the height of the aurora above the earth .
No measurement of this kind , it is obvious , can be obtained , as M. ARAGO justly observes in the passage I have referred to , by taking elevations of the centre of the cupola , or corona , when the meteor is in the plane of the magnetic dip .
When the meteor is there , each observer sees a centre peculiar to his own station , and which is in the line of the upper prolongation of the dipping needle ; just as in a row of persons placed under the key-stones of a bridge of masonry , each one sees a joint of the masonry vertical to himself , and different from the joints over the others .
But , as in the case of the bridge , when we remove ourselves quite from beneath it , and to some distance from it , we can then easily determine the height of either the upper or lower parts of the key-stones , by means of a combination of parallaxes , so we may in like manner measure the height of an arch , or fringe , of aurora , which is placed considerably to the northward or southward of the stations we may select for determining the elevations .
But in the case of the aurora there are serious impediments to the process , in the generally fitful unsteadiness of the object , and equally fitful irregularity of its edges .
To avoid the latter inconvenience , the British Association direct the angles of elevation to be taken at the lower edge of the arch ( which , it is said , is always best defined ) at its summit .
I have not observed this edge better defined than the other , excepting on the occurrence of a dark mass under the luminous space , which sometimes takes place , as stated in the instructions .
On such occasions , however , the lower edge of the luminous space is always comparatively low , and therefore no clear parallax could be obtained from two stations , unless they were very remote from each other .
Besides , the dark mass and defined lower edge are of rare occurrence here , not having been seen for several years .
I have observed already , that in very calm weather the upper edge of the arches is sometimes well-defined ; and as that edge , generally , in the arch which first ap pears here in the evening , is clear from interference with subsequent arches , which for the most part appear only under it , I made preparation for taking elevations of such an arch from two stations , by obtaining the favour of the Rev. HUGH M'CONNACH , the schoolmaster of this parish , to make the observations at one of the stations .
The stations were chosen with reference to the aurora being probably immediately over the Coreen hills , as indicated by Mr. MINTo'S observations .
The Manse here answers , in this view , for one station , being by measurement 15,700 and 12,500 feet distant from the two nearest elevated summits of the hills respectively ; the nearest of the two being almost on its magnetic meridian .
The other station could not be placed at a sufficient distance on the north side of the Manse for the river Don intervening .
It was therefore placed at Hillhead of Kingsford , on the magnetic meridian of the Manse , and 6810 feet distant from it towards the south .
A further extension of the base line in this direction was prevented by a rapid descent of ground , a little beyond the south sta'tion , which would have placed the observer out of sight of the Coreen hills .
Besides , it was considered inexpedient to have the stations more remote from each other , as it seemed very desirable for the observers to meet before commencing their operations , that they might , on trial , discover how nearly they would agree in taking the elevation of the vertex of the arch of the aurora , an object , in the most favourable case that they could anticipate , somewhat undefined .
After having looked out a considerable time for a proper display of the meteor , and allowed many to pass which had not the requisite conditions , at length , on the 20th of December , 1838 , a little after 6 P.M. , a very low complete arch , having a welldefined and regular upper edge , presented itself over the Coreen hills .
There was a dead calm at the time , with a clear sky ; thermometer 39 ?
FAHR. The arch rose slowly upwards , becoming more bright , and promising to be of some continuance .
Mr. M'CONNACH and I met soon after its appearance ; and on repeated trials with two 277 small quadrants with plummets , attached to poles for fixing in the ground , found we agreed in determining the angle of elevation of the vertex of the upper edge of the arch within the limits of half a degree .
We then adjusted our watches to the same time ; and Mr. M'CONNACH went with an assistant to I-lillhead of Kingsford , to take elevations at every five minutes by the watch , while I remained at the Manse , to take elevations contemnporaneously with his , and notice and describe the appearances of the aurora .
It may be best to give a brief account of the successive appearances of the arch , and of those of the contemporaneous phenomena , before presenting the measures of its elevations .
When first seen , its lower edge was not yet above the northern hills ; but at half-past six o'clock it was quite clear of the horizon at its vertex , and at that point was about 9 ?
broad .
The light at this time was nebulous , and equally clear in all its parts , with no certain display of streamers .
The upper edge vanished off from the brightest light within the limits of rather less than a degree .
At the lower edge the vanishing off was considerably broader .
At 6h 35m P.M. a brilliant display of streamers suddenly appeared over Callievar , a detached mountain three miles due west of the Manse , somewhat higher than any part of the Coreen hills ; and over that mountain a solitary dense cloud was formed , two or three minutes after the appearance of the streamers there .
These phenomena were quite disjoined from the arch , which in the mean time rose gradually higher above the horizon , and in place of the nebulous light began to exhibit , especially near the vertex , streamers or pencils of rays pointing upwards .
These were not very brilliant , but quite defined .
At 611 40m , a few detached very brilliant streamers , whose lower ends were concealed by the hills , appeared under the arch a little to the eastward of its vertex .
These seemed to flit with great velocity from west to east , and from east to west , and appeared and disappeared in quick succession for about the space of five minutes .
Their upper ends passed the lower edge of the arch , but never extended so high as the upper edge .
When they disappeared the lower edge presented the same regularity and gradual vanishing off of the light as before their appearance .
At 7h P.M. the play of streamers across the arch had become somewhat more brilliant ; and its edges remained equally even and well-defined as at the earlier periods , the upper one still maintaining its superiority over the lower in that respect .
The arch was at this time about 12 ?
broad ; and a few very small clouds appeared in its west end , concealing the light at their places , but the edges were clear .
At 7h1 5m , although the clouds had increased in number , they formed no impediment to the determination of the elevations ; but by 7h lom the whole sky had become too much obscured to admit of longer continued contemporaneous observations .
At 7h 25"m an opening in the clouds permitted the vertex of the arch to be seen , at the Manse , when it was observed to be still regular in its edges , and to have become of higher elevation .
Observed Angular Elevations of the vertex at the upper edge of an arch of aurora borealis , by the Rev. JAMES FARQUHARSON , at Manse of Alford , and contemporaneously by the Rev. H-UGH M'CONNACH , at Hillhead of Kingsford , on the same magnetic meridian with Manse of Alford , distant from it in a southerly direction 6810 feet , and about 300 feet higher in level .
At Manse of Alford .
At Hillhead of Kingsford .
Angle of elevation .
Angle of elevation .
At 6h 45m P.M ... 16 .
6 50 ... 17. .
, 6 55. .
19. .
*70 ... 21 ... 14 ? ?
7 5 ... .22 ... 15 7 10 arch obscured by clouds at both stations .
7 25 ... .
28 seen only at Manse of Alford .
In making out the calculations of the height from these data , it is obvious that we may disregard the corrections for the rotundity of the earth , the difference of refraction at the two stations , and the difference of the horizontal and inclined distances of the stations , as they are all within the limits of the effect of the probable errors in observing a somewhat undefined object like the edge of the arch .
But there is a considerable correction to be made in the angle observed at the Hillhead of Kingsford station , arising from its height above the level of Manse of Alford .
Several years ago I had occasion to determine this , and found it about 300 feet by the barometer .
This correction and the mode of calculation will become evident by means of the following diagram , which represents the first contemporaneous observations at seven o'clock .
Hillhead C( S ^ , 300f Cf --..E B 6810 f. A. Manse .
Calculating from these data , we have the height DE= 5693 feet .
Thus the height of the upper edge of the aurora was 5693 feet above the level of the Manse of Alford .
The vertex of the arch is found from these observations to have been 14831 feet northward of the same place , that is , over the nearest summits of the Coreen hills , two of which , it has been stated , are respectively 12500 and 15700 feet distant in the same direction .
The most continuously elevated ridge of the same hills is about two miles farther north , and it was probably over it that the arch had its commencement .
At the time of the contemporaneous observations , whose results are given , the arch was 12 ?
broad .
This gives by calculation 3212 feet for the vertical extension of the fringe of streamers , and leaves 2481 feet for the height of the lower edge above the level of Alford .
The tops of the Coreen hills are about 1000 feet higher than that level ; and thus the lower edge of the arch , whose elevation was measured , was only about 1500 feet above these hills at their highest points .
The Iesult of this measurement agrees sufficiently with that of incidentally contemporaneous observations made by the Rev. JAMES PAULL of Tullynessle and me , on the 20th of December , 1829 , as reported by me in a communication to the Royal Society , honoured with a place in the Philosophical Trransactions of 1830* , and by which it appeared the aurora of that evening was within the limits of 4000 feet above the earth .
These observations , although not made with instruments , were too decisive in all their conditions of the length of base line , clearness of parallax , and certainty that we had both seen the same phenomenon , to admit of doubt of the very limited elevation above the earth .
The result agrees also with the ingenious observation of Mr. MINTO , and with that which might have been considered decisive of the question , namely , the observation of Captain PARRY and Lieutenants SHERER and Ross , on the 27th of January , 1825 , of the light of the aurora coming between them and a neighbouring height .
JAMES FARQUHARSON .
Alford , May 13 , 1839 .
P.S. I delayed making this Report , in expectation of finding other opportunities of making similar measurements , with the view of determining the variations of height to which the aurora is liable .
My former communications upon the subject went to show that the height is dependent on that of the clouds , an inference which it will be observed is strengthened by some things contained in this Report .
There have been many displays of auroria since the 20th of Decenmber last , but none that I have seen having the necessary conditions for obtaining a just measurement of the height ; and as the ordinary season of its appearance is now over , I do not longer withhold the Report .

