On the Double Metamorphosis in the Decapodous Crustacea , exemplified in Cancer Maenas , LINN .
By J. V. THOMPSON , F.L.S. Deputy Inspector-General of Hospitals .
Communicated by Sir JAMES MACGRIGOR , Bart. M.D. F.R.S. Received May 21 , -Read June 4 , 1835 .
IN the Memoir published in my Zoological Researches , p. 1 , with its sequel , p. 63 , having first made known the fact of the Brachyura of the Decapoda ( Crabs ) passing through the intermediate form of Zoea ; I have now to announce that they undergo another metamorphose , no less singular and unlooked for , in which they assume the form of the genus designated by the name of Megalopa by Dr. LEACH , from the disproportionate size of the eyes .
This second stage we may therefore consider analogous to that of pupa in the class Insecta .
By the former memoir it appears that the young of Cancer Pagurus , the common market Crab , first presents itself as a Zoe * , and that a full-grown Zoe was observed passing into some other more perfect form t , which at that time was considered to be that of some species of Crab : the discovery now first detailed , however , shows that it must have been only passing into that of a Megalope .
The first proof I had of this new and extraordinary fact , which cancels another anomalous genus of the Crustacea , was obtained by keeping in regularly renewed seawater a number of individuals of a Megalope + which makes its appearance in the river Lee , just below the city of Cork , in considerable abundance every summer : these , to my very great surprise , began , after a short time , to change into a minute Crab ?
, until the whole of them , to the amount of about two dozen , were so metamorphosed .
I have frequently since observed the same circumstance , and came to the conclusion that these must be the progeny of the only Crab that is ever found in the higher parts of the river , where these Megalopce were taken , viz. Carcinus Mcenas , our common Shore Crab .
The young Crab , it will be noticed , has not the distinctive characters of its parent , which it probably acquires only after several casts of its shelly covering .
To complete the series of metamorphoses in this species of Crab now became a matter of research ; and I have been so fortunate as to succeed in hatching its mature spawn , so as to be enabled to give a representation of its Zoe 11 , or first stage , and thereby render complete its natural history .
In this stage it does not appear to differ materially from that of Cancer Pagurus , formerly figured in Zoological Researches fig. 1 .
It is , however , certainly much smaller , and of a greenish tinge , with a few darker spots .
If the above facts do not warrant the conclusion I have drawn , what other proof can be required ?
Is it necessary that the young Crab should be traced through its subsequent changes until the character of the species becomes more apparent ?
or that the grown Zoe should be actually seen to change into a Megalope ?
Neither of these is impracticable , but may yet for a long time elude the most zealous and scrutinizing observers .
It appears , then , that the animals of this division of the Crustacea not only undergo metamorphosis , as formerly stated , but that they even undergo a double metamorphosis , being hatched from the ova under the singular and grotesque form of Zoea , then assume that of Megalopce , and finally that of their parent Crab .
How long they remain in each of these two intermediate states it may be difficult to determine with exactitude ; but judging from the very considerable size of the Zoe I observed about changing its condition * , compared with their very minute size when filst hatched , and also from Megalopce not appearing before May or June , while Zoea are seen so early as March and April , I think a month may be assigned as the probable duration of the Zoe stage .
The other , or Megalope stage , is less within the scope of observation ; but as there is not that very great disparity of size between young and fullgrown Megalopcw , it is likely that it does not exceed half that of the former .
If further proof of this double metamorphosis be desired , I have been so fortunate as to trace it , but not in quite so satisfactory a manner , in one of the Swimming Crabs , or Portuni , and also in Inachus , belonging to the section of Triangular Crabs .
These examples , derived from some of the principal groups of the Brachyura , may be supposed quite sufficient to satisfy the most scrupulous , as to their metamorphosis ; I propose , however , in future memoirs , to bring under the notice of the yet sceptical , proofs of the same thing in the following genera , viz. Eriphia , Thelphusa , Gegarcinus , and Pinnotheres t. The three former genera , it may be observed , are foreign , which friends in the East and West Indies have enabled me to add to the first proofs of metamorphosis , by having females with ova on the point of hatching , sent home in spirits : the larvae of these , consequently , have not been seen in the living state ; but by examining such as have burst from their envelopes , without being completely developed , it is quite evident that they are Zoea .
With regard to the other great division of the Decapoda , viz. the Macroura , or those with extended tails , I shall only now say , that as far as my observations have gone they also undergo metamorphosis , being Ipizopoda when first hatched , and during the whole of their progress to the perfect animal ; such is the case in Astacus marinus , Palinurus , Palcemon Squilla , Crangor , Galathea , Pagurus , and Porcellana .
To return to the immediate subject of the present memoir , the Carcinus Mwnaas .
In its first or Zoe stage it is wholly natatory from structure , while in its second it occasionally walks by means of its thoracic members , now become simple , but more commonly swims by the motion of its subabdominal fins , which are greatly developed for this purpose* .
In both stages it is therefore a Macroura , but only in the latter evidently related to the Decapoda .
It will be quite superfluous to enter into a minute detail of the structure of this Megalope , further than may be collected by a reference to the figure and its accompanying explanation .
It must certainly be considered surprising that so many curious facts should have remained until the present time undiscovered ; but still more , that from the first announcement of metamorphosis no person has attempted to follow it up ; so that I have not only the honour of the discovery , but also the entire merit of having rendered this interesting part of the natural history of the Crustacea nearly complete , as the announcements in the previous part of this memoir testify , and my subsequent memoirs will prove .
The facts connected with the metamorphosis in the Crustacea and the Cirripedes are indeed so much at variance with our previous knowledge , with the dicta of some of our leading naturalists , and of so very extraordinary a nature , that the scepticism which still exists with regard to them may admit of some excuse .
The approaching summer I hope will put it in my power to remove all doubts upon the subject , by submitting such of them as offer themselves to the scrutiny of other observers , a circumstance which never occurred to me as necessary beyond the circle of my own family ; had there been any zoologists in my neighbourhood the case would have been different , but in respect of this branch of science I here unfortunately stand alone .
Whatever indifference may be charged to our own zoologists in regard to these important discoveries , we must do our scientific neighbours the Fr ench the justice of noting , that they immediately took up the subject , and two naturalists were selected and deputed to spend a summer at Isle Re1 , to make their observations .
However , by a subsequent report of one of these gentlemen , M. MILNE-EDWARDS , to the French Institute , it appears that so far from verifying the metamorphosis in Crustacea , he pronounced that they were hatched with the form and structure of tleir adult parent !
The observations upon which this decision was based I have not seen stated ; but whatever they may have been , they are completely invalidated by the positive proofs I have given and enumerated in the present memoir .
The animals of this class are so recondite in their habits , so difficult to preserve alive for any time , so little known to naturalists beyond the more common species , that the investigation is necessarily attended with great difficulty and frequent disappointment .
It must be allowed that I have been peculiarly fortunate ; and I am so sensible of the obligation I owe to that Source from whence springs all our knowledge and intelligence , that I hasten to acquit myself of so sacred and valuable a trust with all the ability I am yet permitted to retain .
PLATE VI .
Fig. 1 .
Zoe of Carcinus Mcenas , magnified , and also of its natural size .
Fig. 2 .
Megalope of the same , magnified , and also of its natural size .
The terminations of three pair of the subabdominal fins are only seen in the figure .
Fig. 3 .
One of its subabdominal fins more highly magnified .
Fig. 4 .
The posterior pair of fins magnified .
Fig. 5 .
One of its inner antennae , highly magnified .
Fig. 6 .
The Young Crab , resulting from the above Megalope , magnified , and also of its natural size .
t. ?
-/ 2 / ',.4- ' - , -'N D : --AD f. .
&gt; - ' ' ',._ ; : 4..( ' ?
, ' , ,r,.,.~~~~~~l ' ... ... ... ... . .
4/ .
* , / ' ?
' -/ 7 K ? ? ?
?15 K..I : i~i 1'- ? ? ? ?
-N , ~ Ii N N , 2 ' ?
' " ~ ' ?
: ? ? ? ?
; i ; ~~~ii -s d ~~ ci ?
a ' : ?
ii .
, .
, y y~~~il ti ' *V\ ... ..f C0 u-3yc4 d'mrAn Z &gt; Ax AXXKXXY z2i\ I 2M / 2 'N.y '4 ... ..z

