On the Ice formed , under peculiar circumstances , at the bottom of running Water .
By the Rev. JAMES FARQUHARSON , of Alford , F.R.S. Received March 17 , -Read April 2 , 1835 .
ICE formed at the bottom of rivers and streams , frequently in great quantities , is a phenomenon quite common in this climate .
I made for several years past a nunrlber of incidental and desultory observations upon it , and became convinced that the principal explanation of its occurrence is the radiation of heat from the solid opake materials of the bottom ; but as I conceived this to be also the generally admitted one , I took no note of the observations , with the view of vindicating the theory of the radiation .
It appears , however , from a paper of M. ARAGO upon the subject , translated and published in the Edinburgh New Philosophical Journal , vol. xv .
p. 123 , from the Annuaire for the year 1833 , that he entirely rejects the theory of the radiation of heat through a thick layer of water .
In the same paper , although he does not , in conclusion , pretend to give a complete explanation of the phenomenon , he brings forward , as explanations in part , three circumstances , which , although accurately stated by him , appear to be not exclusively appropriate to ice formed at the bottom , and cannot therefore aid us in solving the main question which we have to discuss here , which I apprehend to be , Why is ice formed sometimes on the surface of running water , and sometimes at the bottom ?
On reading M. ARAGO'S paper , I became desirous of offering some remarks in answer to it , as without some one doing this , on proper data , a misapprehension concerning the cause of a natural phenomenon , so much at variance with our most frequent experience of the formation of ice only on the surface of all waters , as to have often greatly excited the attention and even called forth the astonishment of scientific men , would continue to be propagated under the authority of a distinguished name .
Having , however , no record of my former observations to enable me to refer accurately to the time , place , and other circumstances of them , I delayed till a renewed occurrence of ice on the bottorns of our streams should enable me to repeat them .
Such an occurrence , on a great scale , took place in the beginning of this month of January ( 1835 ) ; and I now have the honour of presenting to the notice of the Royal Society a brief account of the observations I have been enabled to make , and of the conclusions to which they appear to direct us .
Previously to entering on this detail and discussion , it seems proper to describe the appearance and quality of the ice formed at the bottoms of streams .
A misapprehension regarding these may have been one cause of the incredulity of its existence , 2u 2 entertained by some persons who have never witnessed it , and which M. ARAGO , in the paper referred to , has deemed it necessary to remove , by bringing forward the testimony of many distinguished men to its reality .
The ice formed at the bottom does not resemble the solid glass-like plates which are formed on the surface .
It has nearly the aspect of the aggregated masses of snow as they are seen floating in rivers during a heavy snow shower ; but , on taking it out of the water , it is found to be of a much firmer consistence than these , although never approaching to the firmness and solidity of surface ice .
It is a cavernous mass of various-sized , but all small , pieces or crystals of ice , adhering together in an apparently irregular manner by their sides , or angles , or points , promiscuously .
Both the firmness of the adhesion and the dimensions of the interstices ( the latter filled with water , and their volume easily estimated by the quantity of it which is discharged when the ice is lifted out of the stream , ) are , however , greatly modified by the intensity and continuance of the previous cold .
When the ice begins first to form on the bottoms of the streams , it presents a rudely symmetrical appearance , which , for illustration , may be compared to little hearts of cauliflowers , fixed on the bottom , having a similar uniform circular outline and protuberance in the centre , with coral-like projections .
These pieces have a shining silvery aspect ; they are dispersed , at first irregularly , in small numbers , but increase both in size and numbers , till the whole bottom is covered , and , if the frost continues severe , grow in height , but in a very irregular manner , so as to obliterate the earlier somewhat symmetrical shapes , till the streams are raised high above their former levels , and frequently made to overflow their banks .
And here I take the opportunity to notice the incorrectness of an observation of DESMAREST , quoted by M. ARAGO , and which , M. ARAGO observes , no one has corroborated , c that it was from the lower parts , which touched the bottom , that the flakes of ice successively increased .
" On the contrary , the forms of the surface of the earlier masses are continually obscured , in succession , by new ice added to the top .
This congealed mass being thus very different in appearance and consistence from the sheets or plates generally known by the name of ice , it were no doubt well that , like the Germans , who , M. ARAGO informs us , name it grundeis , we too designated it by another name , to prevent confusion or misapprehension when we refer to it .
The inhabitants of this part of the country will furnish us with a better one than even that of the Germans .
In a district where it occurs almost every winter , and often repeatedly during that season , and where many of the rivers are crossed by means of fords , its existence influences too much their economical arrangements not to excite their particular attention , especially as many horses refuse to enter any stream even slightly impeded by it , being greatly alarmed by the pieces which break and float up from the bottom by the action of their feet .
A body with which all are so well acquainted is known by an appropriate name .
They call it ground-gru ; gru being the term by which they designate snow saturated with , or swimming in water .
I shall venture to use their term for the ice formed at the bottom .
330 It will be better here also to state , generally , the conditions of temperature and phases of the weather under which the ground-gru is formed .
I have seen it occur only when the temperature of the whole mass of water was reduced to , or nearly to , 32 ?
FAHR. , and when the temperature of the air was several degrees below that point .
I have observed it an invariable condition , that it was preceded by a continuance , for some time , of a clear , or very nearly clear , state of the sky .
This is at variance with another observation of DESMAREST , quoted by M. ARAGO , that cwhen , in consequence of a cloudy sky , the atmospherical temperature experiences little variation throughout the day and night , the ice at the bottom of the water uniformly increases every twenty-four hours ; on the contrary , when the sun shows itself , the ice does not increase during the day .
" It is the fact , that while it is forming under the continuance of a cloudless sky , its increase is impeded during the day .
It may be possible , amidst the infinite variety of measures of cold that may exist at the time , that the increase of the gru may go on for a little time after the sun has been obscured by a thin cloud ; but I have always seen , that when a densely clouded state of the sky supervened , and continued for the space of even only twenty-four hours , the gru became detached from the bottom , and floated down the stream .
Should the temperature of the air continue low , with the clouded sky , or get lower , the ground-gru is not renewed , but the river is speedily frozen over at the surface .
It is , in fact , a matter of frequenlt occurrence , in frosty winters , that our rivers , filled , and so impeded , by ground-gru , as to be raised above their banks , are found returned into their natural channels , and there frozen over at the surface , but flowing over a clear bottom , in a space of time so short as to appear very wonderful to those who have not investigated the cause .
The process is named , by the country people , the fltting of the ice .
In opposition to the observation of DESMAREST , and in confirmation of those which I have made , on this point , I may refer to the Rev. Mr. EISDALE , who , not satisfied with the explanations of M. ARAGo , has published one of his own , in the Edinburgh New Philosophical Journal , vol. xvii .
p. 167 .
His explanation appears equally unsatisfactory , as will be shown afterwards ; but the part of his statement we have to do with here is his notice of this observation of DsSMAREST .
The formation of the ground-gru , under a cloudy sky , is so much at variance with the information which Mr. EISDALE had received , that he resolves DESMAREST'S " ' cloudy sky " into " s an atmosphere loaded with hoar frost , and rendered hazy by its condensation * .
' The state of the air , in respect of being windy or calm , deserves also to be noticed .
The ground-gru occurs most frequently during calm , with a deposition of hoar frost upon the ground at the time ; and this was the condition of matters during the observations now to be detailed .
But it also occurs during a frosty wind , when there is no hoar frost , which is formed only in a calm state of the atmosphere .
The formation of the gru during wind , and consequently without any deposition of hoar frost on the ground , is especially to be noticed in reference to Mr. EISDALE'S explanation , as will be afterwards seen .
It occurred to M. HUGv , as quoted by M. ARAGO , in the Aar , on the 16th February 1827 , with a west wind , after the river had been completely open on the 15th ; and one of Mr. EISDALE'S correspondents ascribed its occurrence in one particular instance , which he related to him , to the prevalence of a very sharp north-east wind , which had blown during the night of its formation .
The following observations were made in the rivers Don and Leochal .
The former , having an easterly course , is about 120 feet broad , and a foot or two deep at the shallows and fords .
The latter , one of the small tributaries of the former , having a northerly course , is about 20 feet broad , and a foot deep at the shallows .
Both rivers possess a like character of very clear water , and alternating rapids and pools .
The rapids in the Don are reaches , where the water falls two or three , or more , feet , from a higher to a lower level , within a distance of fifty or a hundred , or sometimes two or three hundred , yards .
They are generally impeded with many large stones , some of them projecting above the water .
The depth varies greatly , but seldom exceeds two or three feet .
The pools between the rapids are on an average much longer reaches , in which there is little fall , and a greatly diminished velocity of the stream , which often , in them , flows so equably as to give rise to no ripple on the surface .
They too have in them large stones , but fewer in number .
The depth in them too varies greatly , from two or three to four or five feet .
The rapids and pools in the Leochal are of a similar kind , but both much less deep in this smaller stream .
The bed of this river has however , on the whole , a steeper descent , and owing to this there is more broken water and spray in the rapids .
The character of alternating rapids and pools , in both streams , is owing to the varying hardness of the granitic and micaceousschistose rocks in which their beds are formed .
Where the rocks are hard , there is a rapid ; where more friable , a pool .
In the parts of the rivers observed , the original rocks themselves do not anywhere form the immediate bed of the stream .
That , to the depth of two or three , or more , feet , is composed of the debris of these rocks , broken up and sometimes much waterworn , and reduced to the size of a very large gravel , by the action of the stream , but not so small as to deserve to be named sand .
No part of the bottom is muddy .
On the night between the 31st of December 1834 and the 1st of January 1835 , after the mean temperature of the air had continued for three days at 470 FAHR. , and when there had been little frost in the season before , there commenced a hard frost , with a calm and perfectly cloudless sky , which continued with little abatement till the 5th of January , at 10 A.M. On the night between the 3rd and 4th , the temrperature of the air was 23 ?
F3AHR .
; and on the 4th , the bottoms of the rapids in the Leochal were seen coated in some places with silvery cauliflower-shaped clusters of ground-gru .
I neglected at this time to examine the temperature of the water .
Between the 4th and 5th , the temperature of the air was down to 19 ?
FAHR. ; and on the 5th I examined the Don and the Leochal along half a mile of each , beginning the examination at half-past 8 o'clock A.M. The examination began at the bridge of 332 Alford , built of granite over the Don , in the middle of one of the rapids .
At this rapid , the whole bottom , with the exceptions to be immediately stated , was covered with silvery gru , appearing from two or three to five or six inches deep .
My attention was particularly directed to the exceptions , as throwing a clear light on the question of the radiation of heat from the bottom .
Round each of the piers , and in front of the abutments of the bridge , there was a space quite clear of all frozen matter , excepting at a side of one pier under an arch , where a piece of very still water , caused by an obstruction at the bottom , was covered by clear sheet ice .
On the south side of the river , two embanking walls , one up and the other down the stream , each twelve yards long , are built in a line with the water-courses of the abutment .
Close to the bridge these walls are eight feet high from the bottom of the streaom , but as they recede from the bridge the nlasonry slopes gradually to a lower level , till the extremities are little above the level of the water .
The bottom in front of these walls was clear of ground-gru , as well as that in front of the abutments ; but the breadth of the clear space in front of the walls narrowed gradually towards their extremities , in proportion as the masonry became lower , till at the extremity of the downward wall especially , which ends at a sloping gravelly bank , the gru came to the edge of the water .
The space of the bottom clear of gru was about five or six feet broad at the high parts of the walls next the bridge ; and the water runs on the place at the medium depth and velocity of the rapid .
There was another clear space in the bottom of this rapid .
About twenty-five yards above the bridge there is , in the middle of the stream , a piece of still water , caused by an elevated bed of gravel , just below it , over which the stream is very shallow .
The still water , for an extent of two thin , but white , opake deposition of hoar frost .
From under this ice the water , flowing rapidly over the gravel bed below , had no ground-gru for a space of eight or ten yards downwards .
Above this rapid , a pool of moderate stillness , about three or four feet deep , extends a hundred and fifty yards in length .
Over the bottom of this there were scattered , in an irregular manner , many cauliflower-shaped clusters of silvery gru , most of them very small , and none that were observed covering more of the bottom than a square foot or two at one place .
In the deepest and stillest part of the pool there were several tufts of water starwort , with sooty-coloured decaying leaves , forming the darkest-coloured objects seen at the bottom .
These were all densely tangled with fringes of silvery gru .
At the head of the pool , where the velocity acquired by the water in the rapid immediately above it was not yet greatly diminished , an appearance of a different kind presented itself .
There are here several large stones in the bed of the stream , but none of them projecting above the water .
On the faces of these opposed to the stream there were seen quantities of gru of a different aspect from that further down .
It was not arranged in the same cauliflower shapes , but in angular masses , like wreaths of snow blown by the wind .
It wanted , too , the silvery glance of the other , and had more the appearance of a pale ash-coloured mud .
On reaching it with the end of a pole , its consistency was found to be less firm ; in fact , it was only a heap of detached uncemented spiculae pressed against the stones , and retained there mechanically by the action of the water , in a certain modified state of its velocity .
The source of these heaps of uncemented spicule will soon be noticed .
This pool , as indeed was the case with all the pools in the river , had at its edges and in its little bays narrow pieces of surface-ice , extending a foot or two from the banks .
The rapid immediately above this , not unlike that at the bridge , was covered at the bottom with silvery gru , with one exception .
The river was low at the time from long-continued deficiency of rain , and the water had deserted the south side of the channel , leaving many little pools among the stones , communicating more or less frieely by irregular little currents with the main stream .
The pools were covered over with sheet-ice , and that with a thin opake deposit of hoar frost like snow .
In the little currents returning from under this ice there was no frozen matter .
At the head of this rapid there is a pool much deeper and stiller than that above the bridge-rapid already described .
The depth is five feet , and the stillness such that , at many points of it , there is no ripple or wave on the surface .
None of the silvery cauliflower-like ice was seen on the bottom here ; but near the head of it , in a modified state of the current pouring in from the rapid above it , there were , on the faces of several large stones opposed to the stream , collections of uncemented icy spiculae .
The source of these collections was very readily observed in a great rapid immediately above this .
In that rapid the water has a much quicker descent than in the others referred to .
It is about a hundred yards long , and cumbered with many large stones , over which , at many points , through its whole length , the water breaks with a great deal of spray .
Here an immense quantity of gru occupied the bottom , impeding much the course of the stream .
At the time of observation many pieces of this gru were seen edging up , and in some instances breaking quite away from the bottom , apparently by the increasing pressure of the water , as it became damrmed back by the increase of the gru itself .
This at least was the appearance , although there may have been another cause for the disengagement of it from the bottom , and that is , the impeding , by the imperfectly translucent gru , of that radiation of heat from the bottom which , I trust in conclusion to demonstrate , is the immediate chief agent in the whole phenomenon .
It is now to be observed , that a number of pieces of loose gru , the origin of which was so clearly ascertained at this last rapid , were floating down in all parts of the river .
In passing through the rapids , they were broken into fragments , and , where the fall was violent , shivered into minute pieces .
The larger pieces that remained after passing through the rapids floated at the surface , immediately as they got into the uniformly flowing currents at the heads of the pools ; but the minuter ones , mixed with the water to all depths by the plunging whirls in the rapids , not being so speedily disentangled from their cohesion with the water , by the action of gravity , floated 334 for a greater distance immersed in the water , and were intercepted by , and mechanically retained against , the faces of the stones by the action of the stream at the heads of the pools .
Further down , and in stiller water , where no such intercepted heaps were seen , their buoyancy had , no doubt , by degrees , overcome the cohesion and raised them to the surface ; and in fact , in the still water , many minute icy fragments were floating in the surface .
Mr. KNIGHT , the celebrated botanist , quoted by M. ARAGO , has obviously , in part , but not completely , distinguished between the " frozen matter which reflected a silvery kind of whiteness , " which covered the stones in the rocky bed of the river , and " floating spiculae under water , " which he found to " accumulate much more abundantly upon such parts of the stones as stood opposed to the current , where that was not very rapid , below the little falls or very rapid parts of the river .
" In the smaller stream of the Leochal , the quantity of ground-gru was comparatively much more abundant , occupying the bottoms both of the pools and rapids in close masses , and in the latter , at many parts , forming such an impedinment as to urge the water over its usual banks .
But there were two remarkable exceptions .
One of the pools flows close to the foot of a steep bank about fifteen feet high , and in the side next the bank there was little ground-gru .
In a rapid , which at a turn of the river has an easterly course , there was a very dense fringe of Phalaris arundinacea standing , with its dense foliage of withered leaves , in the south edge of the water .
Its height was four feet , and it extended fourteen feet in length along the stream .
At the foot of it the bottom of the rapid was clear of ground-gru to the breadth of three feet .
The temperature of the air and water , at the time of these observations , was particulaily ascertained .
That of the air at sunrise , about an hour before the observations commenced , had been 230 FAHR. ; but it was rising rapidly during their progress , and was at 36 ?
FAHR. before their conclusion .
The temperature of the water in the Don varied from 32 ?
to 330 FAHR. ; but the variation could not be distinctly traced as depending on the depth or velocity , as there was a temporary variation in the same place , both in the pools and rapids .
At one of the small streams , returning from under the sheet-ice on the little pools at the edge of one of the rapids , the temperature was nearly steady at 33 ?
FAHR. In the Leochal the temperature was nearly steady everywhere at 32 ?
FAHR. By 10 o'clock A.M. on the same day , a cloud obscured the whole sky , and at 2 o'clock P.M. the temperature of the air was 40 ?
FAHR. At this time much gru rose from the bottom and floated down the streams of both rivers .
The relaxation of the frost , however , was of very brief continuance .
Before sunset the temperature of the air was again down to 31 ?
FAHR. , with a perfectly calm air and clear sky ; and the clear sky continued till the evening of the 7th of January , the thermometer durling the two intermediate nights being at 23 ?
, and during the intermediate day at 26 ? .
The same parts of the Don and Leochal were again examined at 10 o'clock A.M. on the 7th .
In the Don the ground-gru now covered all the bottoms of the pools as well as of the rapids .
It was of less depth in the deep still pool below the great rapid ; but everywhere else it formed a great impediment to the stream , raising it so much above its former level that it covered deeply the pieces of sheet-ice formed at the edge on the 5th .
New piec'es of similar ice were now forming at the same places on the more elevated surface .
The Leochal was still more impeded by the gru than the Don .
But , what is worthy of particular notice , the clear spaces of the bottom , at the piers , abutments , and embanking-walls of the bridge on the Don , and at the Phalaris grass in the Leochal , still continued so , but were now considerably narrowed in their lateral dimensions , the ground-gru having encroached upon them on the sides next the streams .
The temperature of the air was 24 ?
FAHR. ; of the water , everywhere nearly steady at 32 ? .
Several circumrstances occurred on some subsequent days which deserve to be noticed , as throwing light , by the contrast which they exhibit , on the phenomenon now under consideration .
On the 8th of January there occurred a thaw , when the thermometer suddenly rose to 47 ?
FAHR. The rivers were speedily cleared of ice and ground-gru , which last rose from the bottom and floated away with the stream .
The atmosphere at the time was considerably clouded , with a brisk S.W. wind .
On the.9th of January the temperature of the air fell to 36 ?
FAHR. ; and on the morning of 10th of January , with a temperature of the air at 29 ?
FAHR. , there was a fall of snow , of about an inch deep , which ceased by 8 o'clock A.M. The snow that fell into the rivers was observed to be entangled , and stuck fast , in irregular crushed masses , in many parts of the rapids ; and there were collections formed of loose spiculae of a muddy aspect , at the sides of the stones opposed to the streams , in the heads of the pools , where the velocity of the currents was intermediate between that of the rapids and that of the stiller parts of the pools ; but there was no appearance on any part of the bottom resembling the symmetrical cauliflower-shaped ground-gru .
On the evening of the 10th the temperature of the air fell to 23 ?
, and continued at from 23 ?
to 21 ?
till the morning of the 12th , with a densely clouded state of the sky .
During this time extensive sheets of surface-ice were formed on the pools of the Don , and many of the pools of the Leochal were quite frozen over , but the ground-gru was nowhere renewed ; on the contrary , the masses of snow entangled in the rapids on the 10th disappeared to a great extent , obviously floating away in the stream .
In this state of the river and weather , the collections of uncemented spiculae , on the faces of the stones opposed to the streams in the heads of the pools , appeared in their places the same as before , neither increasing nor diminishing in size .
M. ARAGO , in his paper , refers to three circumstances , as partly , at least , explanatory of the formation of ground-gru in running water .
1st .
The inversion , by the motion of the current , of the hydrostatic order , by which the water at the surface , cooled by the colder air , and which at all points of the telmperature of water under 39 ?
FAHR. would , in still water , continue to float on the surface , is mixed with the warmer water below , and thus the whole body of water to the bottom is cooled alike by a mechanical action of the stream : 2nd .
The aptitude to the formation of crystals of ice on the stones and asperities of the bottom , in the water wholly cooled to 32 ?
, similar to the readiness with which crystals form on pointed and rough bodies in a saturated saline solution : 3rd .
The existence of a less impediment to the formation of crystals in the slower motion of the water at the bottom , than in the more rapid one near , or at the surface .
There is no denying the justness of these three positions , and yet the slightest reflection teaches us that neither singly nor combined do they aid us in answerling the main question before us , " Why is ice formed sometimes at the surface of running water , and sometimes at the bottom ?
" All the circumstances , or conditions , referred to by M. ARAGO , are present when ice , as most frequently takes place , is in the course of being formed only on the surface , as well as when the formation is going on at the bottom .
Were we to admit them as an answer to our question , then running water ought always to freeze first at the bottom .
But a most extensive experience teaches us that this is not the case .
The illustrations of M. ARAGO , indeed , just and true in themselves , are not to be overlooked when we would investigate and explain the formation of ice either at the bottom or at the surface .
They will serve to enlighten us greatly in both these events , but they have no exclusive relevancy to either , and we must therefore look out for another solution of the problem .
M. ARAGO , in his conclusion , does not present these three circumstances as a complete explanation ; but he says , the reader may ask why he has not done so , and he answers to this , " that we have no observations which prove that this kind of ice is seen , until the temperature of the whole of the water is at zero " ( centigr .
) ; and that it is not certain that the little icy particles , seen by Mr. KNIGHT , floating on a milldam , at the time ground-ice was forming in the stream , and which may have acquired in contact with the air a temperature below zero ( centigr .
) , do not play an important part in the phenomenon which he has overlooked .
In regard to the former of these points , I cannot say what M. ARAGO would have deduced from it , had it been established in one way or the other .
The observations made on the Don on the 5th of January show that the temperature of the whole water was not quite down to 32 ?
FAHR. when the ground-gru was forming in large quantity .
In regard to the latter , the little icy particles seen by Mr. KNIGHT , the same condition belongs to them that belongs to the circumstances professedly adduced by M. ARAGO as explanations ; that is , they occur as well when the ice is forming o the surface only as when it is forming on the bottom .
They account well , however , for the collections of frozen matter seen by him at the sides of the stones opposed to the stream , in parts where its velocity had a certain modification .
And here I may advert to the explanation offered by the Rev. Mr. EISDALE , in his paper already referred to .
From the information he received , he was led to believe 2x2 337 the ground-gru does not occur but when there is a hoar frost on the ground ; and he explains the ground-gru to be particles , or crystals as he afterwards names them , of hoar frost precipitated into the water , retaining there the shapes in which they descended , brought into contact with the rocks by the agitation of the water , and forming nuclei for the accumulation of ground-gru .
Could it be proved that such crystals are precipitated into the water , they would serve no more for explanation than the icy particles of Mr. KNIGHT .
We have learnt , indeed , from travellers in high northern regions , that , in certain states of cold and moisture of the air , such crystals , as Mr. EISDALE assumes , are there seen and felt floating in it ; but nothing of that kind was observed in January last ; and when Mr. EISDALE , from the existence of spiculee of hoar frost on the ground , would infer the like may be formed in the air to fall into the water , he neglects to take into the account , that the spiculae of hoar frost have not fallen from above , but that their symmetrical arrangement , round on all sides of the bodies on which they are found , and their slow increase , prove they have been deposited on their places by a gradual deposition of invisible watery vapour , owing to the substances to which they are attached being cooled below the temperature of the surrounding air , by the radiation made known to us by the experiments of Dr. WELLS .
Besides this we have to remark , that the groundgru sometimes takes place , agreeably to the information of one of Mr. EISDALE'S own correspondents , in a windy state of the atmosphere , at which time no hoar frost is seen .
The interesting experiments of Dr. WELLS just referred to enable us to give , after all , a very satisfactory explanation of the ground-gru ; and Mr. M'KEEVER , quoted by M. ARAGO , had gone far to illustrate it by means of them , although he had overlooked some conditions necessary to be taken into the account for a complete explanation .
M. ARAGO , however , entirely rejects the explanation of Mr. M'KEEVER , and it is fair to set down the terms in which he does so .
After having shown that the ground-gru cannot be explained by the action of the moon* , according to the sailors , nor by the friction of running water producing more heat at the surface than at the bottom , nor by referring its source to the smaller tributaries of the streams , nor to different layers of ice foirmed at the several surfaces , when the water in the river , from whatever cause , is in a state of varying fullness , all of which have been assigned as causes of the ground-gru , M. ARAGO proceeds : c We come now to Mr. M'KEEVER , who , confining himself closely to the most subtle principles of the theory of heat , has not on this account been more fortunate than his predecessors .
According to this author , the rocks , stones and gravel , which generally cover the bottom of rivers , have powers of radiation superior to those of mud , perhaps on account of their peculiar nature , but chiefly because they have rough surfaces .
Thus rocks in large or small masses will become much cooler in consequence of radiation : when the atmospherical temperature is very low , they of course freeze the water which touches them .
' It is unnecessary to examine here whether heat radiates through a thick layer of wateri , as Mr. M'KEEVER supposes , as the most simple observation is sufficient to overthrow it .
Where is the person who has not observed that the strong radiation , which the Irish philosopher admits , would be more plainly manifested , or as completely , in still water than in running water ?
but no one has seen a piece of still water frozen at the bottomx .
" But there is nothing more easy of experimental proof than that heat radiates through water .
I do not mean , however , to vindicate the reasoning of Mr. M'KEEVER respecting the more powerful radiation of it from stones than from mud .
His reasoning respecting that matter is , on his own part , conjectural , to explain the readier formation of gru on a stony or gravelly bottom ; but the gru also forms on a muddy bottom , a fact which M. ARAGO notices , when he brings the attachment of mud to the under side of the floating flakes as a proof that they have been formed at the bottom .
Mr. M'KEEVER was driven to his conjecture from having overlooked the more complete and sudden inversion of the hydrostatic order that takes place over stones than over mud ; which last is deposited only in places where the water has a stiller and more equable motion .
In such places the ground-gru is later in forming , and therefore is more rarely seen ; and it is doubtful whether Mr. M'KEEVER had a proper opportunity for noticing it in them .
But to return to the main point which we have here to maintain in opposition to the reasoning of M. ARAGO , the radiation of heat through a body of water .
When we construct an achromatic object-glass for a telescope , it does not the less remain a burning-lens when we have included in it a transparent fluid , and no experiment has proved that were the fluid water the case would be altered .
We are aware of the danger that has been incurred of setting fire to an apartment by an ornamental glass globe filled with water , and placed in the sun at a window .
But as I cannot particularly refer to circumstances of time and place of the cases now mentioned , I made an experiment on the subject with such apparatus as I could find readily at hand , having no access to better in a remote country placet .
In a room , of which the temperature was 50 ?
FAHR. , a semiglobular tumbler filled with water , containing about a pint and a half , was placed inside a window , in the rays of the low but clear winter sun .
The bulb of a thermometer , which had been previously placed in a similar situation till it rose and remained steady at 61 ?
was shifted into the brightest part of the fan-shaped focus of rays , into which the light was refracted through the tumbler .
In this position it was raised in four minutes to 72 ? .
It was again shifted into the unconcentrated rays passing through the window , when it fell , but more * Edinburgh New Philosophical Journal , vol. xv .
pp. 132 , 133 .
t It may seem absurd to have had recourse to experiment in a case so plain ; but the procedure seemed , at the same time , indispensable , to meet reasonings promulgated with the authority of such a distinguished name .
339 slowly than it had risen ; and the experiment was repeatedly renewed with similar results , leaving no doubt that the heat , like the light , radiated through , and was refracted by the water .
If the fact is so in regard to the radiation of heat through a mass of water four or five inches thick , where ought we to set the limits of thickness of the mass throughl which it cannot pass ?
Obviously only where the thickness is so great , that the aggregation of the fluid , and of its minute impurities , prevents the transmission of light , as in the deeps of the sea , but not within the ordinary depths of our clear streams .
Of the effect of radiation in cooling down the surface of the ground , and substances placed upon it , during a clear sky , we cannot give a more lucid account than that of M. ARAGO , in his paper c On the supposed Influence of the Moon on Vegetation .
" 6 " No one had supposed , " says he , " ' before Dr. WELLS , that terrestrial substances , excepting in the case of a very rapid evaporation , may acquire during the night a different temperature from that of the surrounding air .
This important fact is now well ascertained .
On placing little masses of cotton down , &amp;c. in the open air , it is frequently observed that they acquire a temperature 6 ?
, 70 , or even 8 ?
centigr .
below that of the surrounding atmosphere ... . .
These differences of temperature between solid bodies and the atmosphere only rise to 6 ?
, 7 ?
, or 8 ?
of the centesimal scale , when the sky is perfectly clear .
If the sky is clouded they become insensible .
" This lucid statement , however , requires one modification ; for the greater cooling of the solid substances , under a clear sky , takes place not only during the night , but also during the day , in places not directly exposed to the sun 's rays .
This radiation , as it passes freely through the transparent atmosphere , may , as we learn from the above experiment , pass also through the transparent water , to cool down the solid substances at the bottom below the temperature of the surrounding fluid .
That fluid is permeable to radiating heat as well as the atmosphere .
The application of the thermometer , in the hands of Dr. WELLS , instructed us regarding the cooling of the surface of the ground ; but the water of a river , placed under the very same condition of a clear sky , fluid above and freezing below , is a great natural thermometer , teaching us that a corresponding cooling is going on on the surface of the solid opake substances of the bottom .
In fact , if we may so speak , the phenomenon of the ground-gru is the result of an experiment in the water , entirely similar to that of Dr. WELLS on the land , performed by nature on a large scale , and presented to us for our interpretation and instruction .
And when we look back to the observations made in the month of January , we find the results of the modifications of this great natural experiment corresponding with those of similar modifications of the experiment on the dry land .
The cooling of the surface of the ground by radiation , discovered by Dr. WELLS , takes place only under a clear sky .
It is therefore greatly modified on parts of the ground screened from a part of the sky by opake objects , as walls , trees , hedges .
In illustration of the extent to which a screening or shading body , near at hand , 340 modifies the radiation , I shall detail some observations I made on the 7th of January last , incidentally in the first instance , but then extended , in reference to the observations on the ground-gru , which I was making at the time .
Having occasion that day to dig into recently hoed ground , in the middle of a garden , remote from shade , the soil was observed to be frozen to the depth of four inches , by the clear frost , which had continued from the 1st of January , with the trifling intermission above mentioned .
On digging into similar ground at the north base of a wall six feet high , the soil was found , close at the foot of the wall , frozen to the depth of only half an inch ; at a foot distance from it , about an inch ; at two feet , little more ; and it was only at the distance of ten or twelve feet that it was frozen hard to the depth of three inches .
A similar modification of the effect of radiation was observed in the shade of trees .
Under the Scotch fir the soil , slightly covered with decaying herbage , was not at all frozen ; although in similar ground similarly covered , but remote from shade , it was hard frozen to the depth of two or three inches .
Now the ground-gru in the rivers was modified in a way strictly similar by the effect of shade .
The bridge of Alford , over the Don , is happily situated for illustrating this , being on one of the rapids , where Ihe ground-gru is earliest and most abundantly formed .
While the other rapids , and the unshaded parts of this one , were quite occupied by gru on both the 5th and 7th of January , spaces in the shade of the masonry at this bridge were quite clear of it .
It cannot be admitted as an explanation of this fact , that heat may have been there laterally transmitted to the water by contact with the piers and walls ; for if this took place , why then did the clear spaces on the bottom narrow gradually towards the low extremities of the embanking walls ?
Besides , the transmission of heat laterally had not hindered the formation of surface-ice , in contact with a pier , on a piece of still water under one of the arches .
The modification of the radiation by shade was also exhibited in the absence of all gru on the bottom , along the foot of the dense tuft of Phalaris grass in the Leochal , where there could be no more transmission of heat laterally , than at the general line of the grassy banks of this stream .
The water , too , returning warmer from under the surface-ice , on the little pools at the edge of one of the rapids , is another instance of the modification of the radiation by shade .
The thin white opake covering of hoar frost on the ice prevented radiation , at least in a great measure , and the heat of the bed of the river , in the course of continual transmission upwards , from strata not yet cooled to much depth by the frost , finding no outlet by the radiation , was expended in heating the water by contact .
There was another phenomenon observed on the 5th of January , ( although no longer seen on the 7th , being then concealed by the immense formation of gru , ) which can be readily explained by the admission of the radiation of heat through the water , and therefore goes to support the justness of the theory .
The tufts of water starwort , in the deepest and stillest parts of one of the pools , were the darkestcoloured objects seen at the bottom , and they were fringed in every part with spiculae of gru , at a time while it yet occupied little of the bottomn of this pool .
The experiments of BOYLE , FRANKLIN , RUMFORD , LESLIE ( although he denies the conclusion himself ) , DAVY , and STARK appear too uniform in their results to leave any doubt remaining , that dark-coloured bodies both absorb and radiate heat more freely than those which are light-coloured .
It is in consistency , then , with an ascertained law of the radiation of heat , that the very dark-coloured tufts of the water starwort should have been the first bodies in the pool cooled to a very low temperature , and of course first covered with gru .
In arguing the whole question , let us not forget to assign a proper value to the illustrations of M. ARAGO .
The first of them suggests a ready and satisfactory answer to one of the objections which he brings against the theory of radiation , which is , that the effect of it should be as readily manifested in still as in running water , and yet no one has seen a piece of still water frozen at the bottom .
In still water , that hydrostatic order , which M. ARAGO has so well illustrated as belonging to water when reduced to a temperature under 39 ?
FAHR. , has friee play to establish itself , and is not inverted by the mechanical action of a stream .
When the temperature of a body of water is under 39 ?
, then the coldest portions of it are the lightest , and naturally rise and float on the surface .
When in a still pond the water nearest the bottom has been cooled below the general temperature by contact with the solid materials cooled by radiation , it is displaced by the heavier warmer water above .
Hence ice forms first on the surface by the meeting there of both the cold M. ARAGO'S illustrations also furnish us with a satisfactory explanation of the curious facts , that th e ground-gru es its first apatpeaiance in the more rapid and agitated parts of the stream , and begins to show itself on the bottoms of the bottoms of the stiller parts , and to accumulate there in quantity , only after a longer continuance of the clear frosty weather .
In the rapids the hydrostatic order is overturned , and the colder , which is also the lighter , water not only mixed with the warmer below , but , at the whirls of the greatest rapids , brought suddenly , without much mixing , into direct contact with the bottom , cooled still lower than itself by radiation .
If the water is at the temperature of 32 ?
FAHR. it can give out no heat to the colder bottom * There is an exception to the universality of this position , which , although rare , I have sometimes witnessed ; and as the phenomenon is in accordance with the theory of the radiation of heat from the bottom , it deserves notice .
In little ponds of a foot or two deep , dug to obtain the materials for building or agricultural purposes , of which there are many examples in this neighbourhood , after they have been covered , owing to hard and longcontinued frost , by a thick sheet of ice , that is sometimes nearly melted off , and the remaining fragments driven to the lee side by a strong westerly gale of high temperature .
Such a gale , in this climate , frequently , towards its conclusion , shifts to N.W. , when the temperature of the air falls again below the freezing-point of water , with a generally clear sky .
In such peculiar circumstances the little ponds are suddenly filled with gru , commencing at , and shooting up from the bottom .
The whole water is here at 32 ?
FAHR. when the gru begins forming , and the hydrostatic order is deranlged by the wind .
342 without part of it being converted into ice , the spiculae and crystals of which find a solid body for their attachment at the very point where the heat is given out* .
But while in this manner we can explain some of the incidents , may it not be held , as above demonstrated , that the chief cause of the ground-gru is the radiation of heat from the bottoms of the rivers ?
Every branch of the phenomenon is of easy explanation when we admit the radiation ; and among the rest a circumstance to which I have yet made no reference , and that is , the disappearance at the bottom of the watel of the immense quantity of heat , 140 ?
of FAHR. , which constitutes the caloric of fluidity disengaged , when water at 32 ?
FAHR. is converted into ice at the same ternperature .
The answer to our original question then is , That ice is formed sometimes on the surface of running water , and sometimes at the bottom , because frost sometimes .
takes place with a clouded sky , which is incompatible with radiation of heat from the bottom of the stream , and sometimes with a clear sky , when that radiation takes place through the water , in the same manner as the experiments of Dr. WELLS prove it goes on , under a like sky , through the atmosphere .
The bottoml is by this cooled down below the freezing point of water , before the water itself ; ice is formed on it , and its detachment by transmitted heat from below prevented , as long as the radiation continues .
*-We may observe also , that there is a local source of greater cold of the water in the rapids , in its being brought into more active and extensive contact with the air by the sharp ripple and spray .

