Researches in the Integral Calculus.-Part II .
By H. F. TALBoT , Esq. F.R.S. Received October 26 , -Read November 17 , 1836 . ?
1 .
HAVING explained a general method of finding the sums of integrals , I propose to apply it to discover the properties of different transcendents , beginning with those of the simplest nature .
In the first place , therefore , I will show its application to the arcs of the circle and conic sections .
As there will be frequent occasion to make use of cubic equations , I shall suppose their general form to be _-px2 +qxr -0 .
When therefore the letters pqr occur without explanation , it will be understood that they represent these coefficients .
§ 2 .
Application to the Urcle .
'dx Let us take the integralj I + , and suppose nothing to be previously known concerning the properties of the function which it represents .
Let us put , in the first place , I+ X2 = vX : x-vx +I= 0 .
The two variables xy will be roots of this equation , so that they must satisfy the conditionxy = 1 .
Also dx die dx _8 =1 0 1+ T +-Vye = Vx VZ dx because S -0 in any equation whose last term is constant .
11 'iI+ 14S , t. Mncccxxxvll .
B We thus obtain a characteristic property of the function J dx 1+ x= n namely , that if xy = I , fx + fie = const .
The truth of which is otherwise evident , for if x= tan 0 , then y= cotan df=0 and fie = 900 e.f x + fie = const .
Next let us investigate such a relation between three of these integrals that they may have an algebraic sum .
IV +x Assume 1+ x2 = ax .
whence X3 + VX2 + ( 1-a ) x+v= 0 , where a is any constant quantity .
The three variables xyz must be roots of this equation , which however gives only one necessary relation between them , viz. x+y+z=xy z. We have aV_ 1+ 2 dx dx aS i+2=VS ?
+Sdx .
But .
= vsand S dx = dv , x~~~ d..aS + Pt : dx..sfl dx = const .
whence we obtain this well-known theorem in trigonometry .
If the sum of three tangents equals their product .
, the sum of the carets 'is c0n.vant , The constant = 1800 .
Next let us suppose 1+ x2 a2k x3+ ( v -a ) x2 +x+ v= 0 .
This gives only one necessary relation between the roots , viz. q= xy + xz +y z= Ie For the two other coefficients ( v a ) and v , may be made to agree with nay two arbitrary quantities .
Since we have dx dx dx.*a S I+ X2X S$ 1d But Sy=r - , and here q=1 andr= -v S1 1 ' whence dx dv S -2 = and dx dv V. Also dx dV xV Therefore aS dx dv dv T+XVv sf .
Sdx , = const .
, which furnishes this other well-known theorem , viz. If three tangents are such that the sum of their products = 1 , then the sum of the arcs is constant .
The constant in this case = 90 ? .
The same theorem results from the supposition 11+=v --+ ax ; for this gives x3 + ax2 ++i aa and q=I is the only necessary relation between the roots .
Also dx SI =vSdx+aSxdx .
1 +x2 But S x2=p2-2q= 2- , whence S xdx vdv Sxdx=~ ds Also Sd dvx Therefore S dd vd =+ vdva O E. D. a a These theorems , and the analogous ones which exist between any number of tangents , are well known .
But when we apply the method to the integral / x we obtain relations between circular arcs which appear to be of a more novel description , and perhaps have not hitherto been noticed .
Of which I will proceed to give an example .
Let us suppose 1 V/ 1x-=VX + 1 , whence S+2 w2 + = .
In this instance the symmetrical v= -p , and therefore making this substitution , we have X+r x2 + ( { )x-r= O. There are therefore two necessary relations between the three roots , viz. pr q=_ -i .
And since 1 77/ 172 =vX+1 Bu ~~~~VI =XSt x+ xS dx =vSdx+Sdx .
v7xx= .
i-dr But S X2 _pa_2 q2 F(-)=G vS x dxZ rd.2=r Also Sdx~d Sd =dxdd whence this theorem : If the sines of three circular arcs are roots of the equatiov x3 + rx2 +( X-1)x-r=O .
the sum of the arcs is constant .
I will give a numerical example of this theorem .
The value of r is arbitrary .
Suppose it to be =3-112 --04641016 .
The roots of the equation then have the following values : x-= 05 sin 30 ' =vsinO yz 0 94565-=sin 7101 ' -sin 7z =-098154 sin ( 780 59 ' ) sin ?
" ; and the theorem gives the surm of the arcs , or S7= const .
The word sum is used in an algebraic sense , as including the case where one or more of the arcs are to be taken negatively , or its definition is S ?
=+0 + ?
§§7 " .
The same ambiguity in the signs pervades the whole of this class of formule .
In the present instance 300 + 710 11 + 780 591 1800 the constant is a semicircle .
Ex. 2 .
Let r= 0 .
*3 Ax= 0 ; and the roots are x=0= sin 00 z =-1 = sin -900 * . ?
7=0 ?
a-90o ?
7=_-90 ?
; and the same formula gives , as before , o+ # " = 1800 .
A very extensive class of formulae respecting the arcs of the circle may be obtained in a similar manner , by applying the method more generally .
Thus , if we make the supposition 1l ] ao + a , x ... ... ia n-I where a0 , al. a.- , are constants , or any entire rational functions whatever of the variable v. we have an equation of 2n dimensions , of which x is a root .
If x= sin 7 , , and the other roots are sin 02 ' sin 03 , .
sin d2n then r dx d vl-x2 o and the other integrals = -2 , ?
3 .
* If we consider the generality of the supposition [ 1 .
] , which admits any number of arbitrary quantities , it certainly appears remarkable that this equationf .
v=0 should be always verified . ? .
3 .
Application to the Parabola .
If the tangent at the vertex of a parabola be taken for the axis of abscissas , and the semiparameter = 1 , then if x be the abscissa , the equation of the curve will be 2y=2 and the arc , which may be designated as arc x , dx Vi + x2 .
The known value of this is [ 2 .
] Arcx =1 xVI+x2 + slog ( X + VI +x2 ) .
This is a function of x , the properties of which appear to have been hitherto little examined .
I will establish two theorems concerning it , which are of considerable simplicity .
Theorem I.-If three abscissae are the roots of the equation x rx2 ++Ir0 the sum of the arcs equals the sum of the abscisssw .
Since each arc is greater than its corresponding abscissa , it is evident that the word sum is to be understood in an algebraic sense , or that at least one of the arcs must be taken negatively .
Theorem II.-.If three abscissc are the roots of the equation x3 x2 +(b a2a ) + 4= O the sum of the arcs equals the product of the abscissce .
This theorem is remarkable for its simplicity , when it is considered that it contains two arbitrary quantities , a and b , which , as it appears , may have any values .
Demonstration of Theorem I. Put 1+ X2 = X2 +vX+ 1 : whence F[i .
Xx3+2vx2+ ( v2+ 1)x+2v=0 .
Also SdxVL+x2=Sx2dx~vSxdx+Sdxr 8t di x / I + X2 =S 2d +vSx dx + St.x..SfdxV1I+X2= +fSxdx +Sx .
The first term.q +r in all equations .
Herep -2 vq =v2 +r= -2 v. braic quantity , which is considered to be impossible .
This is verified by calculation ; for 2 arc x= xZ / 1 +X2 + log ( X + / 1 +X2 ) .
Calling log ( x +1+ x2 ) =f .
x , we have fx = 0'881372 = 2-143099 fJ = 1261722 fx +fz =2 143094 2 143094 sum =0 000005 This sum approaches zero very nearly .
The quantitiesf x , fz are subtractive , being parts of 2 arc x and 2 arc z , which have been already shown to be so .
Demonstration of Theorem II .
Let v/ 2jF7 2= nx2+ x+ v , where n is a constant , -2 1+ vn-v % 21v X3 +n2+2 n2 = ? . ?
and vS./ dx2.dx=nSV2dx+ Sxdx , the term vSdx being omitted ; because , since Sx is constant , the factor S dx = 0 .
The formula S x3 = p3 3p q+3r gives S X3 3p3 ?
s y-pq2+r , ( observing that p is constant and =S x2 dx +dq+d r. Therefore the first term , or nS x2 dx =2dq+nd r. The formula SX= p2 2q gives the second term , or Sxdx= -dq.nSX2dx + Sxdx= dq + ndr .
013 vSJF Kd x= dq + ndr .
Now we have ( omitting constants ) , q -~ Un leq 2 2vd v..dq dv ' dn le~ and ndr= dv n !
2vdv.-.dq+ndr= , , Therefore. .
~~~~~~d S.J4 1+ X2 .
dx= --vn SVI+X2.dx= Sf2l+x2.dx=-n= r. Now writing n-- , vb we have the equation in the form given above , viz. Xa_ X2 + T-a b ab ) X+ a2 0 ; ' and therefore the theorem is demonstrated .
Examples .
Ex. 1 .
Let a=2+ 12 , r 1 , the roots of the equation are x= X=1. .
arc X=P 147793 y= 3906278.arc y= 8911399 z= 1,492065 .
arc z= 1P935186.Sx 3A414213 2+ / = a and xyz= -(3+2 V 2 ) -5 &amp; 828426 .
Now we have Arcy = 8911399 ( 1 .
) Arc x+ Arc z= 3082979 ( 2 .
) Sum ( subtractive ) =-5 828420 = ( 2 .
) -(1 .
) xwy z 5-828426 Error 0,000006 The quantity which we previously called fx= log ( x + I1+ X2 ) has the following values* fx =0 881372 fy= 2-071728 fz = P190354 we havefx +fz = 2-071726 fie = 2'071728 Error 0000002 T~hus it is seen that the logarithmr4ic parts destroy each other as in the first theorem.n Ex. 2 .
Let x=y= be assumed for two roots of the equation ; in which : 45 35 case we finda -6 , ab = and the third root z Since xy =I in this example , the theorem gives the sum of three arcs = xy z z= which we propose to verify .
Now the formula 2 are x= xVI+ X2 log ( V+ VI +X2 ) gives ( 3 1.5 2 arc ( 4 ) 6+ log 22 arc( ) =+ log3 the sum of which two =45 + log 6 35 1295 and 2 are ( 1)-14 + log 6* ~~~~F 144 +o6 Therefore the , sum ( subtractive ) 840 70 144 le..arcx+arcy-arcz= F But on the other hand we have 0 , Therefore the sum of the arcs = z : which was to be shown .
§ 4 .
Analogous Properties of the Circle and Parabola .
There is a manifest analogy between the area of the circle and the arc of the parae bola , the former being expressed by fdIx l _x2 , the latter byfdVI +x2 , which only differ in the sign .
The same analogy is seen in the theorems which may be deduced respecting these integrals .
Thus , for instance , the Theorem II .
, which we have demonstrated in the parabola , may be applied , with a slight modification , to the circle .
If we put v V/ I ?
x 2= n V2 +X+ V , we find the sum of three integrals of the form fd VlIx2 = r , the constant being = 0 .
The upper sign applies to the parabola , the lower to the circle .
The demonstration of the latter case is omitted for brevity , being exactly similar to that of the former .
1i The three variables xyz are roots of 1 .
] X3 -ax2 +b a2b 0 the upper sign applying to the parabola ; a and b being two arbitrary quantities .
To exemplify this theorem in the circle.-Since 2fdvd x -.x2 XSI x _2 + arc sin x , the theorem gives 2rSX VI X2 +S arc sin w. The latter term , being the sum of three circular arcs , cannot form any part of the quantity 2 r : therefore we must have this other equation , S arc sin x= 0 , which we propose to verify .
Ex. 1 .
Suppose a= 6 , b= - , the equation [ 1 .
] becomes 63 6 27 12 and its roots are 4 a , _5 y=1 X _T 5:.arc sin x=53 ' 8'= O arc sin y= 90 ?
= O ' arc sin z 143§ 8 ' _ 0 ' 0+ 0 ' + 0"f = 0,7 in accordance with the theorem .
We may assume two of the arcs arbitrarily , and thence determine the third , so as to satisfy the theorem .
4 12 56 12 EX .
2 .
Thus , let x = , y= we finda= a , - .
LHere it happens that Xyb= - : therefore , dividing the equation a ' b xy7 = by the equation ab we find the third root z= a. c 2 Now these three values satisfy the theorem ; for we have.4 arc sin s 530 8 ' =0 arc sin = 670 23 ' 4'.56 -arc sin= 120§ 31 ' 0 " and d+ o ' + " f = 0 .
§ 5 .
Application to the Ellipse .
In order to obtain a relation between three elliptic integrals , the simplest supposition which we can make appears to be X 12 =-V x+ whence 3+ Q , -2 + Qe v. 0 .
x3y2 V XV~0 This determines the value of the symmetrical v to be =r and therefore making this substitution we have x3 +r x2 + ( 14 e. r=0 and V+-e:e2 x whence Sdx\ , / l rS dx +S dd .
But since SX2=p2 2~2~( r2-~2)=ij0U2 ?
-2 Stz p2qr ( .r 2 1+ e2 Svdx=rdr.-.rS xcd x ( 1 +e2)dr .
Also Sdx= dr r Sxdx+Sdx e2 dr .
SdxV e= e2dr w1es x2 ed/ i -Oe 2r +C Or , if we suppose the radical to have a negative sign , Pd$ Xl_= C-e2r ; whence the following theorem : If three abscissce of an ellipse are roots of the equation s+r x2 + ( 1 .
e r2I 1 -r =-0 the sum of the arcs 2Q e2 r , Q being the quadrant of the ellipse .
Ex. I. Let e 0 .
or the ellipse be a circle ; the theorem then assumes this form : If three abscissce of a circle are roots of the equation X3 +r x2 +(x r-O , the sum of the arcs is a semicircle ; the truth of which has been demonstrated previously ( vide page 4 .
) .
FAGNANI'S theorem becomes illusory when e= 0 : it is therefore interesting to obhserve that the present theorem , on the contrary , has a real application to the circle .
Ex. 2 .
Let e have any value , and r=0 then the roots are x=O..arcx=0- ?
( 1 .
) Y_1 arCy-Q=Q(2 .
) Z =arc z=Q(3 .
) and the sum , viz. ( 1 ) + ( 2.)-(3 .
) =2 Q , whiCh is therefore the value of the constant .
Ex. 3 .
When x is not actually = 0 , as in the last example , but has an indefinitely small value = c ) , it will be found that the values of y and z differ from 1 and 1 by a quantity of the order of &amp; j2 .
But nevertheless the arcs which subtend these abscissa differ from a quadrant of the ellipse by a quantity of the order of w. This arises from the direction of the arC at the extremities of the axis being perpendicular to the abscissa , so that its increment is infinitely greater than that of the latter .
It will be well to show the truth of the theorem in this case .
When x= c ' we have ( putting 1-e2 b2 ) 62 cv2 y= 1z =-yi .
For from these values we deduce y+z= 0 , and thence ( neglecting quantities of the order aJ3 ) X+Y+Z=X= xy+xz+yz~yz=-y2= _1 So ta xZy Z= rot 4 So tat yz re oot of + ( 1 2_ I ) X+= Xwhich agrees with the given form by putting r. We have now to find the sum of the arcs .
The arc subtending the abscissa ( x = a ) may be considered as equal to it .
The arc subtending the abscissa y differs from the elliptic quadrant by an ace which may be considered equal to the ordinate which corresponds to y. And the , same with respect to z. Let y ' be the ordinate corresponding to y. The equation of the curve gives = bV1-y2 ; but since 2 b2W 2 b , 6o b2 Y2 4 *@/ =2 Y3 62 and the arc subtendingy =Q The arc z has the same value .
Therefore arcy + arc z=2Q -b2 adding arc x= w , we have Sum of arcs 2Q+ e2 a , ( or , since c= r ) 2Q e2r , in accordance with the theorem .
2 Ex. 4 .
Let 1-e2 = .
And also let r=9 31/ i = 04868331 ; the roots of the equation x3 + rx2 +( - ) x-r=O are x= 05 =sin 30 Y= 0,98019 = sin 78§ 34 ' z= 0@99336 = sin 830 24 ' Entering LEGENDRE'S Table IX .
with modulus e=4= sin 540 44 ' and these amplitudes , we find arc x= 0O5081 arcy = 11446 arc z= 11944 Sum 2'8471 On the other hand we have 2 Q= 2 are ( 900 ) _25224 e2 r 0'3246 2Q e2 r= 28470 Sum of arcs 28471 Error = 000001 I will now indicate two other theorems respecting the sum of three elliptic arcs .
I. We may put the integralfd dx / 1I_ in the form f ( 1 +ex ) dx ce x ) ( 1-x2 ) ) and assume(1 + ex)(1 g to be a symmetrical= v. This gives X3 Jr e2 ( V + l ) X+v0O and the result which I find is , that if three abscissa are the roots of this equation , the sum of the corresponding arcs =2 eV -b+ C. II .
We may put the integral in the form ( 1 + x ) ( 1 e2.x2 ) and assume I= v , whence +3 + -2 v+v 0 .
The result which I find is , that if three abscissa are the roots of this equation , the , sumi of the arcs = 2..b/ v+ C. These theorems respecting the sums of elliptic arcs appear to be some of the simplest which exist ; but an unlimited number of theorems of a higher order and more complicated nature are obtainable , the discussion of which would lead too far at present .
Thus if we assume V I.j any XX +Xan-2 X+ &amp;c. where the coefficients are constants , or entire rational functions of v , we have an equation of 2n dimensions , which gives the sum of 2n elliptic arcs in terms of v. There is no difficulty , beyond the length of the operation , in deducing these theoremns , as they are all obtainable by an uniform method .
But it will be of iinportance to show the relation between them and the previously received doctrines respecting elliptic integrals as established by LEGENDRE and others , the connexion between them not being at first sight very evident .
Application to the Equ'lateral IHyperbola .
In order to obtain a relation between three values of the integral fV+4 which expresses the arc of the equilateral hyperbola , we may put 4/ 1 +4V+ 1 , whence 3v2x 2v= 0 , we have therefore 2v= r , and making this substitution , V3-e 0 .
Also 4/ 1 + X4 r1S__+_XX X2~~. .
S4/ 1yt.4drSd Sw2 +27Z - .
Now we have r dx r dcr dr x 2'r -t and S5= ir _r4i dr__ @ J2 4 SS 1 +XV4 dx +dr dr 3dr X2 * X ! .
1_ 44 sf A/ 1.I d =d 3r+ C. X2 ~~ 4 so that if three abscissa of the equilateral hyperbola are roots of the equation ---x r=0 the sum of the arcs =r+ C , which is the theorem which I originally met with concerning the hyperbolic arc* .
It will be seen how very simply and directly we are conducted to it by the present method of investigation .
Next let us suppose -VI +aA-VX3 ?
+I whence Q 8_ 2+V= VtSV Put v=* Philosophica Transactions , 1836 ' Part I. p. 185d _ 42= o uand j/ I+ X',4 2x x2 r+ Therefore _ VI+ X4 dx -S 2 dx= --Sxdx+ SXrx but dX dr x2 4 as in the last example ; and Sx2 = r:.-..Sxdx=--dr.*.~~ S o.d c=4 s XVJ 4d dd This result therefore agrees with the last example , and gives the same theorem but it supplies a different demonstration of it .
We will now suppose _ 41p H+a +.P a being a constant .
This gives a3 + ?
, V2 +v+_2a '0 ' ' Q and I find this result , that if three abscissae are roots of this equation , which may be written 3 _p x2 +qx -r 0 , then the sum of the arcs tV2 =P r+ constL pv + C. This sum is therefore constant if w is so .
Let v-k , v= ' , be two values of v , which give the same value to p v , or p -\ ' Let the three hyperbolic arcs in the first case be a a ' a " , and in the second case ( 3 ( 3 ' ( 3 " , then a+ a , + al " + Pt'+ PI " .
All the abscissae have the same origin at the centre of the curve , therefore the arcs have the same origin , and therefore can be subtracted from one another .
Therefore putting a -(=y , a'-3'r ' , At/ -( 3r " we have r+ r ' + r " 0 .
This appears to me to show the possibility of finding three arcs such that ( neglecting MDcccxxxvII .
D i18 MR. TALBOT9S RESEARCHES IN THE INTEGRAL CALCULUS .
their signs ) the sum of two of them shall be equal to the third ( though not superposable in any part ) .
I believe that it has been hitherto held that this equality is impossible in the ellipse and hyperbola , without the addition of some algebraic quantity .
I should have wished therefore to have added some numerical illustration of such a result , but the length of the calculation has hitherto prevented me from doing so .

