Some Remarks in reply to Dr. DAUBENY'S Note on the Air disengaged from the Sea over the Site of the recent Volcano in the Mediterranean .
By JOHN DAVY , M.D. F.R.S. Assistant Inspector of Army Hospitals .
Received May 19 , -Read May 29 , 1834 .
IN the second part of the last volume of the Philosophical Transactions , at the request of the Council of the Royal Society , Dr. DAUBENY has stated his objections to the explanation which I have proposed of the origin of the air disengaged over the sunken remains of the volcano of 1831 , as described in my last paper on the subject .
I am induced to reply to these objections on the ground that they do not appear to me well founded , nor compatible with the facts which I have brought forward .
In the paper alluded to , after having noticed the composition of the air , which I had found to consist of about 80 per cent. azote and 10 oxygen , I remarked that two views might be taken of its origin ; one , that it was of volcanic source ; the other , that it was derived from the sea water , and merely disengaged by the heat of the volcano .
The first view , that which Dr. DAUBENY advocates , I could not adopt , as it appeared to me least probable .
The minuteness of the quantity of air observed in its ascent by Captain SWINBURNE , rising " in small silver threads of bubbles , " ( this is his expression , ) seemed very unfavourable to the idea of a deep volcanic source ; and the admixture of oxygen with the azote seemred to me to demonstrate that its source could not be deep .
For the sake of argument , let us suppose , with Dr. DAUBENY , that the volcano had a submaline communication either with Malta , more than 100 miles distant , or with the nearest parts of Sicily , at least 20 miles distant .
Supposing it possible that air could penetrate so far , taking the shortest distance of 20 miles , it appears incredible that it should not be deprived of its oxygen in its passage , especially considering the nature of the matter thrown up by the volcano , containing elements possessing an attraction for oxygen .
Whether the whole intermediate tract is imagined to be similarly composed , or only the volcanic region , seems immaterial , as a few feet thickness of such material may be supposed sufficient to deprive of its oxygen a very large quantity of atmospheric air .
I-lad the volcano been supplied with atmospheric air through channels of communication with the land , some indications of such a supply , it might be expected , would have been witnessed during the period of its active eruption .
But , as I have stated in my former paper , no indications of the kind occurred : the iron contained in the ejected ashes was generally in the state of protoxide , and the cinders generally contained traces of sulphur , and the gaseous products appeared to be very inconsiderable , and such as might be fairly attributed * Philosophical Transactions , 1833 , Part I. to the effect of heat in expelling carbonic acid from carbonate of lime and magnesia , and the burning of the sulphur thrown out in coming into the atmosphere .
The second view , that which Dr. DAUBENY opposes , appears to me to be free from all ser ious difficulties , and not liable to the objections which Dr. DAUBENY has brought against it .
Very niinute streams of air , differing only from common air , or the air contained in water , in having less oxygen , are observed rising from a bed of volcanic ashes and scoriae a few fathoms below the surface of the sea ; and where they rise , the cinders are not black , as they are elsewhere , but of an ochry hue .
These were the circumstances of the occurrence .
The inference I drew was , that the air was expelled from the water by the heat of the bottom , and that it was deprived of part of its oxygen by the attraction of the black oxide of iron , and its conversion into peroxide .
If we suppose that the spots from whence the air rose were the mouths of fissures through which steam ascended , the results , it appears to me , were precisely those which might be expected .
What the exact state of the bottom was in regard to temperature , it is impossible to decide from that of the surface ; but that it might have been what I have supposed , is most easy of belief .
When the volcanic island was last visited , just before its disappearance , and its crumbling masses falling to pieces , from the pressure of the hand or foot , eluding the grasp , and suggesting to the illustrious individual who last landed on it the notion of a magician of the old romance , as I heard Sir WALTER SCOTT relate on his arrival in Malta , even then its sides were still warm , and in some places so hot that Miss SCOTT'S shoes were burnt .
If so , four months after its eruption had ceased , there is no difficulty in the idea that the shoal it forimed seven months after submersion might , in relation to temperature , be what I have imagined .
Dr. DAUBENY in his remarks omits to notice the cause I have considered in special operation for the removal of a portion of the oxygen of the air , namely , the peroxidation of the iron .
He combats chiefly the opinion I have expressed , that , generally , air in descending from the surface to the depths of the ocean , will be deprived of oxygen by the action of living and dead matters swimming or suspended in the water .
He is of opinion that this is not the case ; that it is contrary to the analogy of nature ; that it is disproved by the existence at grleat depths of algae of an intensely green colour .
Were this a well authenticated fact , I should consider it a decisive proof ; but I am doubtful of the fact .
I have never heard of sea weed having been brought up by the lead from great depths in sounding ; in no charts which I have ever consulted is such bottom noticed .
And there are certain facts which are hardly in accordance with it ; such as the state of iron cannon which have been sunk in deep water during a long period , and have been converted , as it were , into plumbago ; such as the preservation of wood under sea water for many years , and indeed for many centuries , in the bed of the sea , but occasionally brought to light and thrown up by storms , sweeping away the incumbent layer of sand .
The depths of the ocean , as well as its breakers , may be intended in the economy of nature for other purposes than those of animal or vegetable life .
As on those shores on which the waves dash 552 with greatest violence , sandstone barriers are forming from the deposition , amongst the sand thrown up , of cementing carbonate of lime , set free from its solution by the disengagement of the carbonic acid gas , owing to the agitation ; so , in the greatest depths , deprived of oxygen , vegetable matter may be tranquilly subsiding , and in process of conversion into beds of coal , for which the temperature of the water at its maximum density , judging from the formation of peat , appears to be most favourable .
Dr. DAUBENY objects to the disengagement of air from water under the circumstances supposed , subjected to a high temperature under pressure .
he says : " Either in this situation the pressure of the superincumbent mass of fluid is sufficient to prevent the conversion of the lower strata of water into steam , or it is not .
If it be , this same pressure will enable the water to retain in solution its original quantity of air , or at least the greater proportion of it .
If , on the contrary , there be not sufficient pressure for the purpose , then no doubt the water will rise up in the form of steam , through the superincumbent mass , along with the air which it had contained ; but , as the temperature of the sea round about the volcano , at least near its surface , is stated by Dr. DAVY not to be higher than that of the atmosphere , it is plain that all the steam must become rapidly condensed , and when it returns to its liquid state , there seems no reason why it should not exert its affinity for the air intermixed , and combine with it as before .
" The greater part of this reasoning relative to the effect of pressure does not appear to me applicable to the phenomenon in question .
The volcanic shoal over which the air rose , as already mentioned , was only a few fathoms deep : the circumstances may be considered somewhat analogous to those of an experiment in the laboratory for the expulsion of air by boiling water in a retort connected with a pneumatic apparatus .
In this latter instance , the air is disengaged and the steam is condensed , and yet the air is not reabsorbed ; nor does there appear to me more reason why it should be reabsorbed in the instance under consideration .
Supposing a portion of sea water to be converted into steam in the fissures of the shoal , the instant it comes in contact with the cold water it will be condensed , like the steam from the retort , and will be diffused by ingling with adjoining water : but the air disengaged at the same time will not be reabsorbed ; owing to its comparative lightness , it will immediately ascend , and passing through water already saturated with air , reach the surface .
Dr. DAUBENY supposes that the quantity of air emitted , as observed by Captain SWINBURNE , bore some relation to that evolved from chalybeate springs ; from whence he infers that " so constant a supply could hardly be derived from such a source as sea water .
" Were not the quantity very minute , " in small silver threads of bubbles , " and varying from time to time in the same place , as Captain SWINBURNE relates , the objection would have weight .
But Dr. DAUBENY admits that this minute quantity is very much less than occurs in most thermal springs ; consequently the argument loses its force .
Relative to the analogy alluded to by Captain SWINBURNE between the bottom from whence the air rose and a chalybeate spring , it appears to me that 553 Dr. DAUBENY has mistaken his meaning , and that the similarity he wished to point out existed not in the bubbling of the gas ( that not being peculiar to a chalybeate spring ) , but in the change of colour of the bottom ; for he says where the air came up most plentifully , there " the cinders ( elsewhere quite black ) had a rusty appearance .
" As to the inferior degree of interest which Dr. DAUBENY connects with mry manner of explaining the phenomenon , it is of little importance .
Truth , of course , or an approximation to it , is the end of inquiry ; and the explanation which I offered had the preference , because it appeared most in accordance with the facts .
I would not wish to undervalue Dr. DAUBENY'S speculations ; but in attaching so much interest to his opinion , that the atmosphere is the source of the gas disengaged , derived through subterranean channels , I cannot help thinking he has had recourse to a difficult hypothesis of little usefulness ; for what facts are there in favour of the idea that volcanic fires are fed like ordinary fires , or in any way dependent on the atmosphere for their activity ?
That azote is often a product , and an abundant one , of extinct volcanos is certain ; but it does not follow that it is also a product of active volcanos .
Probably the ammoniacal salts which form in such abundance in certain solfataras , of which that of the island of Volcano is the most remarkable , is owing to a complicated play of chemical affinities , in which atmospheric air , sulphur , alumnine , and steam are the elements chiefly concerned .
Dr. DAUBENY concludes his note by expressing the wish that the quantity of gas evolved by thermal springs should be ascertained .
This is a scientific desideraturn ; but some caution is required how the knowledge so obtained is made a test of the truth of any theory of the origin of the air in such springs .
Atmospheric air may be carried down not only dissolved in water , as in the rains feeding springs , as I have dwelt on in my former paper , but it may be also forced down mechanically in froth by the impetus of a descending stream of water , and , so entangled , may find its way to a great distance ; and accorlding to the nature of the strata and channels through which it passes , it may either lose oxygen by the attraction of metallic bodies , or have its oxygen converted into carbonic acid by the action of carbonaceous matter , or it may ascend unaltered .
A remarkable instance of this last-mentioned condition presents itself in the springs of the Sava , about a quarter of a mile above Wurzen .
It is recorded in my brother 's Journal , in which , on the 27th of August 1828 , he has written : " Admired the sorgente Sava , -a number of deep circular holes , with air bubbling through them , and large jets of water , which is beautifully clear .
" And on the 30th he added : " Examined this evening the air disengaged in such large quantities where the Sava rises .
It appeared to me to possess all the characters of common air , was not absorbable by water , and supporited flame in the same manner as comimon air .
" Malta April 20 , 1834 .
554

