i XIX .
Discussion of the Magnetical Observations made by Captain BACK , R.N. during his late Arctic Expedition .
By S. HUNTER CHRISTIE , Esq. MA .
F.R.S. Syc .
Received and Read June 2 , 1836 .
PREVIOUS to Captain BACK 's departure in 1833 with the expedition for the relief of Captain Ross , he consulted me respecting the nature of the magnetical observations which I considered it desirable should be made in the regions he was likely to visit .
I was fully sensible that , however available the expedition on which he had so nobly volunteered might be made to the cause of science , its primary object , and that to which all others must give place , was the relief of our gallant countrymen , at that time considered to be in imminent danger of perishing in the inhospitable regions which their enterprising spirit had led them to explore .
I therefore considered it an object of the first importance , , that whatever observations were to be made during the movements of the expedition should be so conducted as to cause as little delay as possible consistently with obtaining data for correct results , and also , that they should be made in the order of their importance .
Compared with observations of the direction of the magnetic needle , both with reference to the meridian and to the vertical , other observations are of minor importance towards establishing anything like a theory of terrestrial magnetism .
Considering that observations of the direction of the needle with reference to the meridian , though quite as important in a theoretical point of view sa those with regard to the vertical , were necessarily called for in the conducting of the expedition , I , in the first instance , pointed out the observations which I considered necessary for determining the dip of the needle at the various stations where it might be practicable to make such observations ; and I left the less important ones for the determination of the relative intensities of the absolute force acting upon the needle , which required nor care , attention and assistance , to be made or not , according to the circumstances under which the expedition might be placed .
Itivinediately on his return , Captain BACK ( lid me the favour to place all his magnetical observations at imy disposal , and I feel that I should sot do justice to the zeal and ability which that enterprising officer has displayed in the cause of science , if I did not , nowx that I have had leisure to reduce the observations , lay an ) account of them before the Royal Society .
I. Observations of the Dip of the lagnetic Needle .
The instrument employed for determining the dip was a small but very accurate one , by DOLLOND , furnrished with two rectangular needles , each three inches in length~ This instrument is more fully described in the Appendix to Captain BACK'S Narrative .
I have already stated that , in the mode of observing which I recommended to Captain BACK , I had particular regard to the economy of time .
Considering , therefore , that the operation of inverting the poles of the needle more than doubles the time required for observing without performing it , and , indeed , that it is one which can only be tolerated because generally necessary to counteract imperfections in the instrument employed , I proposed that , in general , this operation should be dispensed with .
In order that the dip may be determined independently of this operation , it is necessary that the position of the centre of gravity of the needle employed , with reference to the axis of vibration , should be permanent , and that that position should be ascer .
taimed .
Owing to the very short interval between the completion of the instruments and the departure of Captain BACK , the observations made in London , from which , in conjunction with those to be made at the winter quarters of the expedition , I proposed determining this point , were not so satisfactory as might be desired ; and I have consequently been under the necessity of having recourse to the latter alone .
It is therefore necessary that in giving an account of the observations for the dip of the needle I should commence with those at Fort Reliance , the winter station .
Dip at Fort Reliance.-Of the two needles No. IL .
and No. 1I .
belonging to the instrument , No. II .
was reserved for determining the dip and intensity at the various stations , and was carefully preserved from all interference with its magnetic state ; but with No. 1 .
the dip at Fort Reliance was determined by observations made with its poles direct and likewise inverted .
In the following Table are given the means of five observations made with this needle in each position of the instrument , and the mean results of two sets of observations .
Observations of the Dip at Fort Reliance with the Needle No. L. Poles of the needle direct .
roles of the needle reversed .
Face of the needle Face of the needle to the face of inistrument .
reversed .
the face of instrument .
reversed .
Date .
Time .
Therm.._I__ ___ __ __. .
_ok_ .
M eans Face of instrument Face of instrument Flacc rf instrument Face of instrument East .
YWest .
East .
West .
East .
West .
East .
West .
159 1 15 A.M OO .
0 0j I ? ?
1 0l ?
I ?
82 Oct. 10 .
2 15.M .
} 41]25 84 1951 84 17'5 84 54 84 25 82 34-5 86 9'5 85 47'5 82 12 84 19 56 1 8343 10 P. I May 2/ 2 .
{ 8 20 P.M 470 85 27 83 27 83 21 85 00 81 15 83 44 5 85 385 182 0'S 83 42 30 Mean dip at Fort Rteliance .
84 1 13 }in a paper " On Improvements in the Instruments and Methods employed in determining the Direction and Intensity of the Terrestrial Magnetic Force , " published in the Philosophical Transactions for 1833 , 1 have given the equations wg cos ( , + y ) Im sin(,4 =0 }d* wgcos tO-y ) -Imsin ( a ' =0 for the determination of the dip , without inverting the poles of the needle , when the position of the centre of gravity of the needle is known .
These equations , when the dip is known , determine the position of the centre of gravity .
The form , however , in which I have given the expression for the determination of the dip , tan~= -(cot 'e cot i0 ) cot y cott0+ cot = is not so convenient for computation as another which it may be made to assume .
The above equations may be put in the form , M sin ( '0 cos ( '0= 0 *(1 .
) M sin ( 1O- ) cos ( 0 + r ) = ... ( 2 .
) ; where M will represent the ratio of the static momentum of the magnetic force acting upon the needle , to the static mnonientum of its weight , about the axis of motion ; z representing the inclination of the direction of the terrestrial magnetic force to the .
horizon , or the dip ; y the angle which the line joining the centres of gravity and motion makes with the magnetic axis of the needle ; '0 and,0 the angles which that axis makes with the horizon , when the centre of gravity is above the axis of motion , and when it is below that axis .
From these equations we obtain M { sin ( '0 ) + sin ( C-I ) { os ( '0 y ) + cos ( 1O + r ) } = 0 , M { sin ( '0 ) sin ( ,0 ) } { cos ( '0 r ) Cos ( , O + y ) } = 0 .
Cos sequently , M. cos. sin:-I } cos-o cos { y IO +'0-j , .
0 '+0 .
f M. sin.cos -sin 2 sin { } '1-0 '0-A or , putting S= ' and D=M cos D sin ( S)-cos S cos ( ry-D ) = 0. .
( 3 .
) M sin D cos ( S-)-sin 3 sin ( y-D ) = 0.(4 .
) .
Hence we have tanS.tan(S-I ) =tanD.cot(y-D).(5 .
) ; a most convenient equation for computing the value of , that of y being known ; , or , vice versed , for determining the value of y from that of L , to which purpose I shall now apply it , with reference to the observation made at Fort Reliance with the needle No. II .
In the following Table are given the means of five observations made with the that I , by any means , consider that the dip has been in this , or that it is in any case determined to anything like such a degree of accuracy ; but because such results rendered testing the accuracy of calculation more convenient ; and that having , in subsequent calculations , employed the actual results obtained , I have thought it right to give them in all cases .
In order to show the care which Captain BACK took , in malking the observations , to be as free as possible from the effects of any particular local influence , it is necessary that I should give his notes on the situations , with reference to surrounding objects , of the spots on which the observations were made ; and it will be proper that I should do so previous to making any remarks on the results contained in the foregoing Table .
New Fork .
" ; The observations were Made in the garden of the British consul under temporary shed , erected for the purpose , and distant from the house eighty paces .
" Montreal .
" The observations were made under a tent on the island of St. Helen 's , in the St. Lawrence , one thousand yards from the city of Montreal .
There was no iron near ; the roofs of the houses in the city are most of them covered with tin .
" Fort Alexander .
There is no note appended to the observations , on the position of the instrument here ; but , in his Narrative , Captain I3ACi inakes a remark on sOmlli discrepancies in the dip of the needle , which he attributes to the influence of a distant thunder storm* .
Cumberland House .
" The observations were made in a tent about two hundred yards from the house .
" Isle ' la Cross .
" The observations were made in a tent forty paces from the stockades of the fort .
" Fort Chipewyan .
" The observations were made in a tent to the westward of the fort .
" Fort Resolution .
" This set was made in a tent placed inside of the stockadles of the fort , but quite free from the influence of any iron .
" It is necessary I should remark , that in this set of observations the differences in the observed angles were considerable , with the face of the needle reversed and then face of the instrument west .
Six observations were made in this position ; they were s follow : 790 00 ' ; 790 17'5 ; 790 55'9 ; ( 00 5 " ; 800 12-5 ; 80P 17'5 .
The result given in the eighth column of thefrable is the mean of the last four : I rejected the first two , because the others are very accordant and indicate no disposition in the needle to return to its first posit-ion .
On the subject of these observations Captain BACK has mGade this remark : " At the time the needle changed from 790 J15 to 80 ' ( lower readings ) the weather was more than commonly gloomy , and some few drops of rain fell .
During the time of making this whole set of observations " the weather was gloomy , dark , and overcast , with light rain at intervals : " so that the discrepancy here noticed was most probably owing to some change in the electric state of the atmosphere .
M Narrative of the Arctic Land Expedition , p. 41 .
$1#3 82 MR. CHRISTIE ON THE MAGNETICAL OBSERVATIONS Fort Reliance .
" These observations were made in my tent , which had a leather circular lodge or wigwam attached to it , in which was a small fire .
The ground on which the stand was placed was gravel , abo'ut one hundred yards from the lake .
" Rock Rapid .
" These observations were made as before in the tent , the theodolite stand being placed on shingle , at the foot of a high gneiss rock .
" Point Beaufort .
" The observations made as usual ; the stand on shingle at the base of a gneiss rock three to four hundred feet high .
" Montreal Island .
" ' The stand was placed on firm sand about sixty yards from some low rocks , and a sail was put over the tent to afford more shade .
" Point Ogle .
" ' The stand was firmly fixed in sand and shells , of which the beach was composed , thirty paces from the beach , which was packed with ice .
" Independently of the accuracy with which the observations were tmade , and of the precautions taken to exclude the effects of any particular local influence upon the needle , it is evident that the correctness of the results deduced from them in the foregoingTable must depend upon the permanence of the angle A , and upon a correct value having been assigned to that angle .
It is therefore necessary to inquire whether mynv tests can be applied to these observations which may indicate the extent of the errors by which these results may be afficted .
Values being assigned to y and z in the equations ( 1 .
) and ( 2 .
) or ( 3 .
) and ( 4 .
) , these equations furnish measures of the terrestrial magnetic intensity , viz. Cos ~~ __Cos ( 10 +)( ) I2 _ts-s oiiNIasit()- ) .
a ) cosS cos ( y-D ) sin S sin(y-D ) cosD sin ( S a0M o sin cos(-a ) ( In order , however that the values of M , thus determined , should be as little as possible affected by errors of adjustment of the instrument or needle , it is necessary that the centre of gravity of the needle should be distant from the axis of motion , and that the angle y should be large* .
The needle with which these observations were made not having been constructed for this purpose , but with the view of deterimining the variations in the terrestrial intensity by means of its times of vibration , its centre of gravity was made to coincide as nearly as possible with its axis of vibration .
In determining therefore the values of M from the equations ( 6 .
) by means of it , we are not to expect very close approximations to the values derived from other principles .
Admitting this , however , the results ought not in any case to be quite discordant .
In the following Table I have given the values of M deduced from the equations ( 6 .
) , assuming the value of y to be 160 29 ' 19 " ; and in the following column , for the putrpose of comparison , the relative values of M deduced from the times of vibration of the needle No. II .
in the plane of the meridiant .
leative intensity cos ( )r Relative intensity , or Plwe of servation *+ _3 orvalue of M deduced frm l sin S.sin ( y -D ) I the time of vibration of.__ ______________ I____ _ cos_(_S _ ) the needle No. I I. New York ... ... ... .
38'41 8'140936 Montreal .
1660 83 ?
Fort Alexander.2325 8.6961 q Cumberland House 6-76 8'409142 Isle i la Cross ... .
8.12 8-278406 Fort Chipewyan y. an ... ... 9'23 8'324042 Fort Resolution ... ... .
6'29 8-612853 Fort Reliance ... ... ... 8'26702 8'26702 Musk-Ox Rapid. .
10-73 8-169870 Rock Rapid .
8 8'3 7"42 Point Beaufor lo0-90 8'041422 Montreal Island ... ... 14-80 8'1.541.52 Point Ogle ... ... ... ... . .
16-82 8'277498 Fort Reliance , Oct. 9 , 1834 .
10O03 8 269714 Making every allowance for the want of adaptation of the needle to this -method of determining the relative intensities , for errors of observation in determining the times of vibration of the needle , and for any disturbing causes affecting these observations , such differences are here exhibited in the restilts obtained by the two methods , at New York , Montreal , Fort Alexander , Montreal Island , and Point Ogle , 'ts cal only be accounted for by errors in the assumed value of the angle r and clearly indicate a want of permanence in that angle .
It therefore becomes necessary to inquire what changes in the angle y will account for these discrepancies , and how far the dip may be affected .
For this purpose either ' y or w must be eliminated from the equations ( 3 .
) and ( 4 .
) , and the val ie of the other 1etermined in terms of M. Putting these equations in the form M2 CosD.si2(S )= cos2 S. cos D ) M2 sin2 D cos2 ( S ) =sin2 S.sin2 ( y-D ) p we obtain immnediately M2 { sin2 S. CoS2 ) COS2 S. sin2ID}.sin2 ( S- ) = sin2 S. cos2 S-M2 cos2S.sin2D ) M2 { sin2 S. COSDcos2 S. sin2D}.cos2 ( S- ) M2 sin2 S. cos2D-sin2 S. CoS2 sin D cas D Putting P= M.sin S and Q M. these equations become sin 81CosS M2sin'sin sin2 ( S-b ) = +sin2 2S ( 1 P2 ) ) , nsin 'e sin , cos2 ( S whence , The equation ( 5 .
) gives cot 1 or , putting , _P and Q , Cot yD)= / u } ?
*****o.**(1 .
Assuming that the values of M deduced from the time of vibration of the needle at the several stations are the correct values , and substituting them in the equation ( 10 .
) , I have computed the values of S 3 , yD , and thence determined the dip and the angle y at these stations.r The results are arranged in the following Table .
Value of M Value of 7-D Value of SF Value of a deduced from deduced from deduced from Resulting Resulting deduced Difference Place of observation .
the time of the foregoing the foregoing value of 7 .
value of D. from the between the two vibration of the value of M. value of M. constant value values of A. needle No. 11 .
7y==16 29/ 19"/ .
0II0/ i0/ i0/ /0 NewYork ... 8-140936 3|2 5 37 3 45 40 71 12 29'72 4918 +1 3649 Montreal ... ... ... ... . .
8-3 ? ?
7 43 10 1 26 41 8 37 34 76 21 55 77 6 27 +0 44 32 Fort Alexander.8-569610 5 46 71 13 54 6 25 45 78 6 3 !
78 53 37 +0 47 34 Cumberland House ... . .
&amp; .
8409142 18 1 36 127 20 6 31 79 46 34 79 29 59 -0 16 35 Isle a la Cross ... ... &amp; . .
8278406 15 0 21 15 37 16 46 28 79 29 45 79 28 24 -0 1 21 Fort Chipewyan ... ... . .
8-324042 13 24 54 0 56 54 14 59 47 80 54 44 81 00 39 +0 5 55 Fort Resolution ... ... . .
8-612853 19 43 10 0 45 6 21 56 55 82 21 39 82 39 -0 18 30 Fort Reliance , October9 , I8-267020 14 44 00 37 34 16 29 19 84 10 84 10000 1833 , andMay 21 , 18341 Musk-Ox Rapid..8 ... ..1 .
s169870 11 26 22 0 27 16 12 49 39 85 45 24 85 53 32 +d0 88 Rock Rapid ... ... 8 ... ... 8327742 14 56 30 0 14 35 16 42 53 87 39 48 87 39 34 -0 0 14 ; Point Beaufort.8 ... ... . .
8-041422 11 la ' 49 0 13 5 12 28 4 87 59 40 88 3 15 +0 3 35 Montreal Island ... ... . .
8.154152 8 26 47 0 16 25 9 55 17 87 27 13187 35 49 +08 36 Point Ogle.8-277498 7 35 38 0438 30 31 89 22 5 89 24 12 +0 27 FortReliance , Oct. 9 , 1834 8,269714 12 20 15 0 35 23 13 48 45 84 24 52 84 31 24 +0 6 32 The differences between the values of y in the above Table , deduced from the equation ( 11 .
) , and its assune d value , are certainly in manycases considerable ; and the dip also , ill some , differs considerably from that previously deduced .
It is , however , to be remarked with regard to these differences , that the above values of Y are deduced from the assumnption that no other sources of error existed in the instrument than the want of permanence in the axis of the needle itself .
Those who have been most in the habit of making observations for determining the drip , will be best able b~~~~~~ * Either of the equations ( 8 .
) or ( 9 .
) gives a convenient expression for the calculation of S 6 , viz. sin ( S ) si2 M i-Pg or Cos ( S-a ) __ _ iL but the equation ( 10 .
) is even more so .
It might appear that the equation ( 10 .
) would be better adapted for logarithmic computation , if put in the form tan ( S C ) =/ +(Q +-lPj ) -to judge how far this is likely to be the case in any dipping instrument ; I can only say that in the observations which I have myself made , and in those of others which I have examined , I have rarely considered that the observed angles could be relied upon , as being absolutely those which the axis of the needle would make with the horizon , if perfectly free , in any assumed position ; and even when a mean .
of several observations has been taken , I have in general felt that it might differ from the truth by several minutes .
I do not therefore consider that all the discrepancies in the relative terrestrial intensities can properly be attributed to the want of permanence in the axis of the needle , though no doubt some , those which are the greatest , are principally attributable to this cause .
It may , however , be proper to inquire what errors in the observed values of '4 and,0 will account for these discrepancies , as we shall thus be enabled to judge whether they may not in some cases be ascribed to this cause .
It however unfortunately happens that in this inquiry a knowledge of the dip itself is absolutely necessary ; and it is only by assuming that which has been determined by means of the values 'd and 4 , now supposed to be erroneous , that we can determine the changes requisite in the values to account for the discrepancies in the relative intensities .
The equations ( 1 .
) and ( 2 .
) give immediately , cot Id = Mcos -sin..(12 .
) Mcosa + sinny cot i=M sin a _co OSY.(13 .
) Assuming then the values of M already given as deduced from the times of vibration of the needle , the dips as first deduced from the observations , and the constant value 1= 16 29 ' 19 " , the values of '4 and 1 in the following Table are deduced from these equations .
Value of M deduced from Dip first Value of '0 Resulting Value of , Resulting Place of observation .
the time of deduced or computed Observed error in the computed Observed error in the vibration of value of a. frompthe value of '0 .
observed value from the value of,0 .
observed value the needle equation ( 12 .
) .
of '1 .
equation ( 13 .
) .
of,0 .
No. I I. New York ... ... ... ... .
8-140936 7 ?
2 49 18 76 21 23 73 37 51| +2 43 32/ | 72 53 48 7,2 50 21 +0 32 Montreal ... ... ... ... .
8-3 X 77 6 27 80 10 10 78 43 00 +1 27 10 76 43 16 76 54 12 -0 10 56 Fort Alexander ... ... 8'569610 78 53 37 81 41 53 79 59 35 +1 42 18 78 19 54 78 40 19 -0 20 25 Cumberland House ... 8'409142 79 29 59 82 17 38 82 53 37 -0 35 59 78 51 53 78 43 45 +0 88 Isle a la Cross .
8 ... .8 ... .
827840679 28 24 82 18 34 82 21 28 -0 2 54 78 49 54 78 49 15 +0 0 39 Fort Chipewyan ... ... 8-324042 81 00 39 83 40 48 83 26 30 +0 14 18 80 12 29 80 16 45 -0 4 16 Fort Resolution ... ... 8-612853 82 39 84 32 23 85 20 30 -0 48 7 81 9 59 80 53 00 +0 16 59 Musk-Ox Rapid ... ... 8-169870 85 53 32 88 6 16 87 35 56 +0 30 20 84 32 58 84 49 23 -0 16 25 Rock Rapid ... .8327742 87 39 34 89 39 9 89 40 45 -0 1 36 86 9 13 86 8 00 +0 1 13 Point Beaufort ... ... .
8 041422 88 3 15 90 47 89 35 00 +0 29 7 86 27 28 86 50 30 -0 23 2 Montreal Island ... ... 8-154152 87 35 49 89 38 5 88 46 30 +0 51 35 86 49 86 42 45 -0 38 36 Point Ogle ... ... ... .
8-277498 89 24 12 91 13 34 90 21 00 +0 52 34 87 42 22 88 31 15 -0 48 53 The differences here shown between the observed and computed values of the angle,0 are , with a few exceptions , within the limits of the errors of dip observations ; but those of the angle '4 are by no means so , exceptingin a few instances .
Upon thewhole we must therefore conclude , that the discrepancies which appear between the values of the terrestrial intensity , as deduced from the times of vibration of the needle , and from the observed angles of inclination to the horizon , are principally attributable to a want of absolute permanence in its axis of motion .
With respect to the amount of the change in this axis , it is to be observed , that in this needle the centre of gravity was nearly coincident with the axis ; and , consequently , that a very minute derangement of the axis would cause a considerable change in the value of the angle y. We must not therefore infer , in consequence of the differences in the values of this angle exhibited in the preceding Table , that the needle itself received any serious injury during the expedition .
To such it could not be liable , being , during the whole expedition , under the personal charge of Captain BACK , who , aware of the importance of preserving this and other needles as nearly as possible in the same state , carried them himself with the same care as he bestowed on the chronometers .
Having now fully discussed the observations which Captain BACK made with the dipping needle , it is proper that I should state how far I consider that the dip is determined by them at the several stations .
If we refer to the Table at p. 384 , it will be seen that , excepting the New York , Montreal , and Fort Alexander observations , the differences between the dips as determined by means of the constant value assumed for the angle y , and as determined from the relative terrestrial intensities , deduced from the times of vibration of the same needle , are generally much within the limits of the errors to which observations of the dip , with our present instruments , are generally found liable .
I think therefore that we are to consider the results not only as entitled to the confidence which is generally given to those deduced from observations carefully made with good instruments , but that the differences in the last column of the table , in general , fairly exhibit the amount of the error in each case , by which the result may be affected .
In the cases of New York , Montreal , and Fort Alexander this is so considerable that much uncertainty must attach to the results determined by means of the constant value assumed for the angle Y. With respect to the dip at these places as determined by means of the intensity , it may be considered that the same degree of uncertainty may not attach .
It is , hoowever , singular that the results at New York and Fort Alexander in this case differ more widely from preceding determinations than in the other .
Sir JOHN FRANKLTN* determined the dip at New York in 1825 to be 73 ? ?
27 ' 3 " , which differs only 37 ' 45 " from the dip determined from Captain BACK'S observations by means of the constant value of y , but differs 20 14 ' 34 " from the result obtained by means of the intensity .
At Fort Alexander Sir JOHN FRANKLIN'S determination of the dip in 1825 was 780 47 ' 8 " , differing only 5 ' 29 " from the result from Captain BACK'S observations in the first case , but + 41 ' 5 " from the result in the second .
In December 1822 Captain SABINE determined the dip at New York to bet 730 5 ' by means of a MEYER'S needle , and 55'* by the times of vibration in the meridian and at right angles to it , which differ but little from the first determination from Captain BACK 's observations .
Looking to the geographical positions of some of the stations , Rock Rapid , Point Beaufort , Montreal Island , and Point Ogle , we should be led to infer that the small difference in the dip at Rock Rapid , Point Beaufort , and Montreal Island , and the considerable difference between the dip at the two latter stations and that at Point Ogle , must be due to errors of observation , or to some local cause influencing the direction of the needle .
The results at all the other stations would lead us to expect , at Point Beaufort and Montreal Island , a dip but little under 890 ; and it will be seen that the observations for determining the intensity by the times of vibration of horizontal needles , indicate that such should be nearly its amount .
Independently of the reduction of Captain BACK 's observations , and ascertaining the degree of reliance which might be placed on the results I have deduced , I had another and more general object in the long discussion into which I have entered , that of pointing out the kind of tests which may be applied to dip observations , in order to ascertain whether the observations are consistent with themselves , and by this means whether the results deduced from them are worthy of confidence .
I have not yet had leisure to enter upon such an inquiry with many observations ; but in some which I have examined I find far greater discrepancies in values of the angle y than the greatest which I have noticed in the present instance .
On some future occasion I may perhaps enter more fully upon such an inquiry , but for the present I shall leave it , and proceed with Captain BACK'S observations .
II .
Observations of the Variation of the Magnetic Needle .
As these observations are published in Captain BACK'S Narrative , it would be superfluous to introduce them here in the form of a table , particularly as they are given in a subsequent table , in which I have instituted a comparison between results deduced from them , in conjunction with the dip observations which I have detailed , and certain theoretical results , with the view of ascertaining how far these observations tend to support the theory .
I shall therefore here simply refer to the table at p. 390 for the variation at the different stations of observation .
III .
Comparison of the Observations of the Dip and Variation of the Needle with theoretical results .
On the hypothesis of two magnetic poles symmetrically situated in a diameter of the earth and near to its centre , the poles of verticity and of convergence will coincide , and the tangent of the dip will be equal to twice the tangent of the magnetic latitude .
Although , viewing all the phenomena on the whole surface of the earth , such an hypothesis is clearly inadequate to their explanation , it is interesting to inquire how far it may be consistent with those observed on a limited portion .
For such an inquiry , the observations made by Captain BACK are peculiarly well adapted , since in no case has so direct a progress been made , to such an extent , towards the magnetic pole , whether we consider that , point as the point of convergence of magnetic meridians , or that at which the direction of the force is vertical .
Assuming then the coincidence of these points , I had proposed inquiring whether the differential of the dip and the differential of the magnetic latitude , taking the increments in observations not very distant from each other to express these differentials , had the ratio which the theory gave , and had indeed made the requisite computations and comparisons ; but on further consideration it appeared to in that this comparison was not so good a test of the theory as the more direct one of the dip itself with the magnetic latitude , since small errors in the dip would become very sensible in the value of the differential , and if these errors happened to conspire at two stations , this value might be doubled or reduced one half .
I do not propose in the first instance giving the detail of that comparison , but it may be proper to mention the general nature of the , results .
If x represents the magnetic latitude , and 6 the dip , then the equation tan 6=2 tanX gives da 3cos2a +54 In comparing the observations with this formula , I took the sum of the dips at two stations as the value of 2 &amp; The first observations which I employed in this comparison were those at Musk-Ox Rapid and Rock Rapid ; and here the agreement was so marked that I certainly anticipated a general close agreement of the observations with the theory .
This , however , was the only instance of that agreement which we ought to expect in such cases , if a theory be correct .
As the magnetic polar distances of two stations are determined from their geographical position and the observed variations of the needle by the solution of two spherical triangles , it would be superfluous to point out the course of calculation which I adopted ; but it is necessary that I should state the nature of the comparison which I propose instituting between the results of theory and observation .
If p is the magnetic polar distance of one station , and p , that of another , the dip at the two stations being b and I , , then if the theory and the observations be both correct we shall have tan .
tan p=2 and tan I , tan , = 2.(15 .
) ; and we may judge , by the approximation of these products in all cases to the number 2 , of the degree of coincidence between the theory and the observations .
In the third column of the following Table are given the distances of the several stations from the magnetic pole of convergence , whose position is determined from the variations in the second column at the respective stations , combined as indicated in the first column ; in the fourth column , the dip of the needle at these stations , as already determined from the constant value of the angle y ; in the fifth column , the numerical value of the product tan b. tan p ; and in the sixth column , the differences between this product and the number 2 , that is , the error of the theoretical result .
In the three following columns are given , first , the value of df A , deduced from the observations ; secondly , the value of 4 - , to which the former should , according to the theory , be equal ; and thirdly , the difference between the values of these fractions , or the error of the theoretical result .
In this Table I have not included the observations at Point Ogle , because , from the greatly diminished horizontal force acting upon the needle , I do not consider that the variation could have been determined with any precision ; indeed , the amount of the daily variation , in such a position , would , supposing that the variation could be accurately determined at any instant , render the hour at which the observation was made a matter of the first importance , the position of the magnetic pole resulting from an observation made at one period of the day being necessarily very different from that deduced from observations made at others * .
This remark would in a great degree apply to the observations at Point Beaufort and Montreal Island , but these places are more conveniently situated with respect to Rock Rapid , for a comparison of the observations , than Point Ogle : indeed , the variation at Rock Rapid would assign a position to the south of Point Ogle for that of the magnetic pole , which position is quite at variance with the observations at the latter station .
Places from the observations Observed Magnetic Value of Error , or Value of Value of Error , or value of at which the position of the pole variation polar Dip .
tan a tan q ) .
value of d. a 3ncos 2+5 d. 3 cos 2 a+5 .
of convergence is determined* .
of the distance .
tan a.tan 'p-2 .
d.xA 4 dZ .
X4 needle .
06 tt20 2/ 4/ 3 78 3/ 3 " / 171 Fort Alexander 1 15 16 E.t 28 22 43 78 53 37 2'7519 +2874 '5527 '2653 and Cumberland House f 19 14 E.t 26 16 11 79 29 59 2 6630 + 0'6630 Cumberland House 1 ... 19 14 E.t 22 20 28 79 29 59 2'2173 +0 2173 1316 '5499 '4183 and Isle I la Cross 3 ... 19 E.t 22 8 26 79 28 24 2 1897 + 0'1897 Isle a la Cross l ... 23 19 E.t 32 13 34 79 28 24 3'3931 + 1'3931 '6921 '5431 + '1490 and Fort Chipewyan f ... 25 30 E.t 30 0 16 81 0 39 3'6504 +1 6504 Fort Chipewyan 1 ... 25 30 E.t 21 19 2 81 0 39 2'4668 + 0-4668 '6244 '5325 + '0919 and Fort Resolution ... 29 15 E.t 19 38 56 82 39 2'5575 + 0-5575 Fort Chipewyan. .
25 30 E.t 10 6 50 81 0 39 1'1276 0'8724 '7044 '5325 + '1719 and Fort Resolution I ... 37 20 E. 8 38 6 82 39 1'0878 0'9122 Fort Resolution ... 37 20 E. 94 53 82 39 1'1449 0'8551 '7521 '5220 ?
'2301 and Fort Reliance J ... 35 19 E. 628 11 84 10 1'0770 0'9230 Fort Reliance. .
35 19 E. 7 13 11 84 10 1'2087 0'7913 '9148 '5116 + '4032 and Musk-Ox Rapid f. .
44 24 E. 5 30 14 85 53 32 1-3417 0 6583 Musk-Ox Rapid ... 44 24 E. 7 52 46 85 53 32 1'9271 0'0729 '5205 '5047 + '0158 and Rock Rapid I ... 29 16 E. 4 29 4 87 39 34 1'9188 0'0812 Rock Rapid..29 16 E. 2 21 16 87 39 34 1'0059 0'9941 '1868 '5021 '3153 and Point Beaufort. .
6 00W .
t0 14 28 88 3 15 0'1239 1'8761 Rock Rapid ... 29 16 E. 2 29 56 87 39 34 1'0677 0'9323 '0288 '5025 '5313 and Montreal Island f ... 2 00 W. 0 19 30 87 35 49 0'1352 1'8748 Fort Alexander 15 16 E.t 27 55 38 78 53 37 2'7003 + 07003 '5096 '5411 '0315 and Fort Resolution f 29 15 E.t 21 43 42 82 39 2'8546 + 0'8546 Fort Alexander 15 ... iS 16 E.t 23 9 47 78 53 37 2-1794 + 0'1794 '5909 '5411 + '0498 and Fort Resolution J ... 37 20 E. 17 49 1 82 39 2'3021 + 0'3021 Fort Reliance l.*35 19 E. 10 53 26 84 10 1'8357 0'1643 '7017 '5079 + '1938 and Rock Rapid f.129 16 E. |5 41 56 |87 39 34 1 2'4415 1+ 0'4415 By an inspection of the numbers in the sixth column of this Table , which indicate the errors of the theoretical result , it will be seen that , with very few exceptions , there is not that accordance between the observations and the theory which , for the establishment of the theory , we ought to look for ; and that they rather indicate that although the theory may be true as a first approximation , yet it requires considerable modification to render it accordant with the observations .
The numbers in the ninth column point to the same conclusions .
It must however be borne in mind that the variations at Fort Alexander , Cumberland House , Isle a la Cross , and Fort Chipewyan , which determine the positions of the pole of convergence in these cases , are those observed by Sir JOHN FRANKLIN in 1825 , and that the dips at these places , which determine the situation of the pole of verticity , are those resulting from the observations of Captain BACK in 1834 : so that these observations cannot be considered as strictly comparative .
This objection cannot , however , be urged against the observations from Fort Resolution to the sea , which give results equally discordant with the theory .
We have already seen that the dip at the several stations , as determined front the constant value of the angle y , differs , and in some cases considerably , from that deduced from the value of that angle determined by means of the relative intensities .
It may therefore be satisfactory to inquire whether , by employing the dips obtained from these values of the angle y , we shall obtain results more accordant with theory .
In the following Table I have arranged the results in the same form as in the preceding , the variations and magnetic polar distances employed being those there given .
Places from the observations Observed Magnetic Value of Error , or Value of Value of Error , or value of at which the position of the pole variation polar Dip .
tan a tan @ value of d. a3 cos 2 a+ d. a3 cos 2 a+5 of convergence is determined .
of the distance. .
tan a. tan P-2 .
d. A4 4d .
needle .
0/ Q/ 1/ 0/ / .
Fort Alexander 15 16 E. 28 22 43 78 63 2-5815 + 05815 7944 *5552 + *2392 and Cumberland House f 19 14 E. 26 16 11 79 46 34 2 7366 + 0-7366 Cumberland House ... 19 14 E. 22 20 28 79 46 34 2-2786 + 0-2786 1_3975 5485 19460 and Isle a la Cross I ... 23 19 E. 22 8 26 79 29 45 2-1944 + 0.1944 Isle a la Cross ... 23 19 E. 32 13 34 79 29 45 314005 + 1P4005 6375.5309 + W1066 and Fort Chipewyan 4. .
25 30 E. 30 0 16 80 54 44 3-6101 + 1P6101 Fort Chipewyan l ... 25 30 E. 21 19 2 80 54 44 2-4396 + 0-4396 8683 5317 + 3366 and Fort Resolution 4 ... 29 15 E. 19 38 56 82 21 39 2 6621 + 0-6621 Fort Chipewyan ... 25 30 E. 10 6 50 80 54 44 1P1152 -0-8848 *9795 *5317 + 4478 and Fort Resolution 4. .
37 20 E. 8 38 6 82 21 39 1P1322 08678 Fort Resolution ... 37 20 E. 94 53 82 21 39 1-1917 08083 7863 *5198 + *2665 and Fort Reliance 35 ... 19 E. 6 28 1 ] 84 24 52 1 J596 08404 Fort Reliance ... 35 19 E. 7 13 11 84 24 52 1P2953 017047 7823 5110 + *2713 and Musk-Ox Rapidl ... 44 24 E. 5 30 14 85 45 24 1P2987 0-7013 Musk-Ox Rapid ... 4 24 E. 7 52 46 85 45 24 1-8653 0-1347 5616 5047 + 0569 and Rock Rapid f ... 29 16 E. 4 29 4 87 39 48 1 9220 0-0780 Rock Rapid 1 29 16 E. 2 21 16 87 39 48 1P0076 09924 and the observations , independently of their magnitude , strongly corroborates this conclusion .
In all the results deduced from the observations at stations from Fort Alexander to Fort Resolution , in deducing which the variations observed by Sir JOHN FRANKLIN in 1825 have necessarily been employed , these differences indicate that the pole of convergence is more remote from the place of observation than the pole of verticity ; whereas , in those deduced from observations at stations from Fort Resolution to Point Beaufort , in deducing which both the dip and variation are derived from Captain BACK'S observations , these differences indicate precisely the reverse .
If , however , we are not to suppose considerable errors in the observations of either the dip or variation of the needle , this comparison clearly indicates that the theoretical magnetic pole of verticity does not coincide with the pole of convergence , even when .
the positions of these points are deduced from observations made at very limited distances from them .
Having compared the results deduced from Captain BACK'S very interesting observations with some of those derived from theory , I might now proceed to point out the actual positions which these observations , variously combined , would assign to the northern magnetic pole of convergence , and also those which according to this theory , they would give to the pole of verticity .
As , however , I propose investigating this subject with reference not only to Captain BACK'S but also to other observations made in the same regions , I will reserve this branch of the inquiry for another communication .
IV .
Intensity of the Terrestrial Magnetic Force .
The observations which were made by Captain BACK for the determination of the magnetic intensity were of two kinds , viz. by the time of vibration of a needle in the plane of the magnetic meridian , and by the times of vibration of three needles suspended horizontally , according to HANSTEEN'S method .
I shall first discuss the observations which were made with the needle vibrated in the plane of the magnetic meridian .
This needle is that with which the observations for the determination of the dip without the reversion of the poles was made , No. II .
belonging to the dipping instrument , in which instrument its times of vibration were determined .
The times of vibration were determined with the face of the instrument east and with its face west , the face of the needle being towards the face of the instrument ; and also , where time admitted , similar observations were made with the needle reversed on its axis .
In some cases two sets of observations were made in each position of the needle .
The following Table contains the results of the observations which were made at various stations , and , in all cases , on the same spot as the corresponding observations for the dip , the two sets of observations having been made consecutively .
To this Table of the direct results of the observations , it is necessary that I should add a few remarks of Captain BACK'S , on circumstances connected with the observations , and of my own , on the observations themselves .
At Montreal , Captain BACK remarks , that " from some mistake of the assistant the observations were so confusedly set down as to be useless : " and afterwards , that " not having an assistant to take time , &amp;c. I adopted this plan ; " that is , the time at which the needle commenced vibrating being noted , the vibrations were counted until the semi-arc of vibration was reduced to 20 or 30 , and the time again noted ; so that , in each case , the time could not well be determined more accurately than to the nearest second .
He subsequently instructed his servant WILLIAM MALLY in the manner of noting the time by chronometer ; and although , as I any sorry to have to notice , there are , in the early observations , manifest errors in the time , yet this person appears , from thbegreater detail in the observations at Fort Reliance and subsequently ( the arc and time being each noted at every tenth vibration ) , to have given very efficient assistance in this operation .
In the foregoing Table I have marked with an asterisk those observations in which I consider that an error must have been made , either in the time or the number of vibrations , and which I have consequently omitted in taking the mean ; and it will be proper that I should point out more particularly the results which these observations give .
At Cumberland House , with the face of the instrument east and the needle reversed on its axis , 112 vibrations appear to have been made in 310 9s8 giving Isi6875 as the time of one vibration , which is so greatly at variance with the other results , that no conclusions could possibly be drawn from a mean in which it should enter .
We may conceive that an error of ten vibrations in counting , or of one minute in the time , may easily have been made , but neither supposition would give a result at all in accordance with the others .
It is scarcely conceivable that any change in the terrestrial intensity , whether arising from atmospheric or any other influence , could have caused so great an increase in the time of vibration ; it is , however , proper to give Captain BACK'S remarks on the weather , which I shall do after noticing other observations which have been omitted in taking the means .
At Isle a la Cross , with the face of the instrument west and the face of the needle to the face of the instrument , it appears that 72 vibrations were made in 2m 30 .
, the times at beginning and ending being 8h 561n 30s and 8h 59m OOs , by chronometer 13m 20S slow of Greenwich time .
This interval would give 2S.083 for the time of vibration .
If we suppose an error of one minute to have been made in the time , then 1T-25 would be the time of vibration , a result by no means improbable ; but I consider that the safest course is to reject the observation .
With the face of the needle reversed and the face of the instrument east , the times at beginning and ending were 9h 50m 30S and 9h 58m 258 .
We may conceive that here in transcribing 5611 may easily have been mistaken for 501m ; and this would reduce the interval in which seventy-four vibrations were made to Im 55s , and the time of one vibration to s1554 ; but even this is a most improbable result .
In the subjoined Table I give the times of beginning and ending the vibrations , with Captain BACK'S remarks on the weather , &amp;c. at the times of observing .
Face of the needle to the face of the instrument .
Face of the needle reversed .
Place of obserFace of the instrument Face of the instrument vation .
East .
West .
East .
West .
Time commencing lOh22m25S .
Time commencing 1oh 50m 22s .
Time commencing 9h 47m32s .
Time commencing 9h 18m 59 .
X Time concluding 10 24 40 .
Time concluding 10 52 30 .
Time concluding 9 50 41 .
Time concluding 9 21 31 .
E0 Wind S.W. by compass .
Wind S.W. by compass .
Wind S.W. by compass .
Wind S.W. by compass. .
Weather squally , with rain ; Weather squally , waith light Weathersqually , with rain ; dark Weather calm and sultry , with cloudy .
rain ; overcast .
clouds , but no thunder .
distant thunder .
Time commencing Sh 37m 00 ' .
Time commencing Sh 56 " ' 30 ' .
Time commencing 9h 50m 30 ' .
Time commencing 9h 28 ' 00 ' .
, Time concluding 8 38 23 .
Time concluding 5 59 00 .
Time concluding 9 58 25 .
Time concluding 9 29 39 .
a ?
Weather overcast , calm .
Weather clearer ; the sun seen Weather clearer ; sun out .
Weather clearer .
Needle sluggish .
at intervals .
The needle was decidedly slug.ish though carefully wiped .
At Rock Rapid it appears that there was considerable difficulty in counting more than forty or fifty vibrations of the needle , its motion being extremely unsteady , and occasionally it came to a dead stop .
I have selected the two sets of vibrations in which it continued vibrating for the longoest time .
In two other sets , in similar positions , it made only thirty-two vibrations in the one case , and thirty-eight in the other : Captain BACK has a remark on these observations in his Narrative*k .
It is difficult to conceive any local cause for this tendency of the needle to come so much quicker to rest than in other cases , and I cannot but attribute it to the influence of the sunt .
The observations were made as usual in a tent , but the height of the thermometer clearly indicates that the sun must have had considerable influence even under this screen .
This view of the cause of the needle so soon corning to rest at Rock Rapid , is corroborated by the fact that , at Montreal Island " 'a sail was put over the tent to afford more shade , " and therce " the needle was particularly lively , and vibrated smoothly until it finally rested , " the number of vibrations being one hundred .
Whatever may have been the cause which thus affected the vibration of the needle , the circumstance must throw some uncertainty on the measure of the intensity deduced from its time of vibration .
Although I have found it necessary to make these remarks on Captain BACK'S observations , it cannot , I trust , be supposed that I attribute the errors which I have pointed out to want of care or attention on the part of that most enterprising officers , for no one can appreciate more highly than I do the zeal which he manifested for the promotion of scientific research , by undertaking to make these observations on such an expedition as that on which he so nobly volunteered .
I attribute these errors solely to Captain BAcK 's destitution of assistance ; and I cannot but regret that it should not have been afforded him from that service , the Royal Navy , which has furnished , and still continues to furnish , abundant instances of zeal and intelligence in the prosecution of scientific inquiry .
In order to deduce the relative magnetic intensities at the several stations from the results in the foregoing Table , it will first -be necessary that a correction should be applied for the difference of temperature at which the observations were made .
Iumediately that I received the needles belonging to Captain BACK'S instruments , I instituted experiments for the determination of the correction to be applied , for this purpose , to the observations with each needle .
As the method I adopted was the same with all the needles , I consider that it will be better to give all the experiments with their results in one view , and shall therefore defer giving these experiments and deducing the intensities at the different stations from the preceding observations until I have given anaccount of the observations which were made by Captain BACK with horizontal needles , for the same purpose .
A small apparatus , on the plan first suggested by HANSTEEN , was employed for determining the horizontal intensity .
It was furnished with two cylindrical magnetical needles , and a brass one of the same form and weight to divest the suspending silk fibres of torsion .
As I had always found that pointed needles , whether of the form of a double segment of a circle or of that of a lozenge , vibrated more quickly than rectangular needles of the same weight , I suggested the advantage of having such a needle .
A needle of a lozenge form was in consequence added to the apparatus .
The horizontal intensity was therefore , where tirmde admitted of it , determined by the vibrations of these three needles distinguished as No. 1 , No. 3 , and Lozenge Needle .
The observations appear to have been made in the usual manner , by noting the arc and time at the commencement ; the time at every ten vibrations ; generally the time and vibration at which the arc was diminished one half , and the terminal arc of vibration .
The vibrations were , in general , continued until the arc was reduced to two or three degrees ; but it appears that only with one of the needles , No. 3 , could the vibrations be counted , even in London , as far as three hundred .
As the dip increased , the number of vibrations , within the same limits of arc , decreased , and was ultimately reduced , at Point Ogle , to forty or fifty .
I do not consider that in these observations , the time could have been determined with sufficient accuracy to admit of the application of the method adopted by HANSTEEN , of taking a mean of several intervals , or that much advantage would arise from the application of a correction for the arc , to the time of vibration .
I have not therefore thought it necessary to give the observations at length , but still I have , in the following Table , given the times in all cases where the arc was noted , in order that such a correction might be applied , if thought necessary .
This Table will , I consider , require little explanation .
In each case , the number of vibrations , the corresponding arcs , where observed , and the times , are given in three consecutive columns ; and where the vibrations are continued beyond one hundred , the arcs and cor responding times are given in two subsequent columns , in which those corresponding to 100 , 150 , &amp; c , vibrations are opposite to 0 50 , &amp; c , int the first column .
shall not now make any remarks on the results contained in the foregoing Table , but proceed to describe the method I adopted for determining the correction necessary to be applied , in order to reduce the measures of intensity at different temperatures , to be derived from the times of vibration in this and the preceding Table , to measures of intensity at the same temperature .
Determination of the Correctionfor the Djfference of Temperature .
Since I first pointed out the necessity of applying a correction for the difference in the temperature at which observations for determining the magnetic intensity may have been made * , such a correction has , in many instances , been applied ; but its amount has seldom been determined from direct experiments on the individual needle employed in the observations from which the intensities were to be deduced .
This I consider to be essential ; for in the numerous experiments which I have made on the subject , I have found that , in different needles , there is a very considerable difference in the amount of this correction ; and M. KUPFFER'S experiments t show that this amount depends upon the nature and the temper of the steel employed .
I therefore proposed to determine this correction for each of the needles which had been ernployed by Captain BACK .
For this purpose I employed an earthenware vessel having a wooden bottom firmly fixed in it , to which the needle under trial could be securely attached by means of ivory pegs .
Above this vessel was placed a stage , supporting a compass having a small trial-needle , 136 inch long , delicately suspended by a single fibre of silk .
The time in which this needle performed 100 vibrations having been carefully determined by two trials , the needle under examination was fixed to the wooden bottom of the vessel below , but separated from the wood by narrow slips of glass .
This needle was placed with its centre exactly below the centre of the trialneedle , its axis in the magnetic meridian and its marked end towards north ; and the distance of the upper or vibrating needle from the lower was so adjusted that its marked end still pointed north , but with a greatly diminished force .
A small thermometer was placed on the glass of the compass , to indicate any change of temperature that the vibrating needle night undergo ; and another thermometer was placed in the vessel containing the needle under trial , with its bulb close to that needle , and not touching the bottom of the vessel .
Water , of as low a temperature as could be obtained , without employing chemical means , was then poured into the vessel coiltaining the needle under trial ; the temperature of this needle and also of the vibrating needle having been noted , the time of vibration of the latter was determined by two successive trials , and the temperature of both needles was again ascertained .
Water of a higher temperature was then poured into the vessel , and the whole well agitated ; and as soon as the temperature becamie uniform , the foregoing observations of ternperature and time of vibration were repeated .
In this manner , the temperature of the needle was successively raised to the highest temperature at which observations had been made by Captain BACK ; after which it was lowered , by as nearly as possible the same intervals , to the lowest at which the experiments began ; the temperature and time of vibration being similarly determined in all cases .
Tjhe needle under trial being removed , the time in which the trial-needle made 100 vibrations was again ascertained .
The needle , in all cases , commenced vibrating from the same arc 350 ; the time , however , of commencing the vibrations was reckoned froimits first passing zero , and the time of completing each ten vibrations , at the same point , was noted , up to one hundred .
The following Table exhibits the observations that were made with the needle No. IL .
belonging to Captain BACK'S dipping instrument .
When under the influence of this needle , the time of vibration of the trial-needle was so much increased that 50 vibrations were performed in nearly the same time as 100 had been made when it was uninfluenced ; and the vibrations could not have been conveniently counted much beyond this number .
In all cases , the time was determined by two observations .
In this Table , Thermometer IL .
indicates the temperature of the needle No. II .
, and Thermometer N , nearly that of the trial-needle .
Trial-needle uninfluenced .
First Last Trial-needle under the influence of the needle No. II .
obserobservation .
vation .
BeginrTherm .
I. 600 ... ... 462 600.0 7206 84'6 72.0 59-8 46'2 fling ITherm .
N. 57.2 60'2 ... ... . .
58'2 59'6 60'0 61i0 61i0 6110 60-6 5S88SS88S Time of 100 vibra1 147'8 147'8 Time of 50 l 157'2 155-6 153'8 152-6 154'0 155-5 157-1 tions .
148-0 147'9 vibrations f 157-0 155'7 154'0 152'8 154'0 155'6 157'1 End[ Therm. II .
6080 0 ... ... .
47.8 59'6 71 .
82'8 772'0 60 ' 47'0 ing Therm. N. 58-0 6Q'2 ... ... ... 59'0 60'0 60'6 62'0 6i10 60'8 60'4 fTherm .
II .
60'0 ... ... ... 47'0 59'S 7 '1 53*7 72'0 60'3 46'6 ean ) 'Therm .
N. 57'6 60'2 ... ... . .
586 59'8 60'3 61i5 6i1O 60'9 60'5 $SSSSS$ Mean time of one 147875 ... ... 3'142 3-113 30078 3 054 3'080 3'110 3'142 vibration The first observation commenced at 1h Om p.M. 5th March , and the last concluded at 4h 35n p.M. If we call the terrestrial force acting upon the vibrating needle , M ; the force withy which the needle II .
acts upon it , at any given temperature , m ; the time of vibration of the trial-needle , when acted upon by the terrestrial force alone , T ; and its time of vibration , when influenced by the needle IL .
, that is , when acted upon by the difference of the two forces M and rn t ; then we shall have M-m Te M =t2 ' and M. *(6 .
) Substituting in this equation the observed times of vibration at different temperatures , we shall obtain the values of M ' that is , the measures of the intensity of the needle II .
corresponding to these temperatures .
The following Table contains the values of M thus deduced , and in the last column are given the differences in the value of M corresponding to a change of one degree in the temperature of the needle No. IL .
Difference in Values of value of Therm. II .
Differences .
Therm. N. as Differences , cor ding M ~~~~~~to difference of 1 ?
in Therm. II .
47.0 18 58-6 '7784982 '0041462 '0003239 5948 1238 986 1743520.0051603 '0004195 72'1 1236 60'3 *7691917 '0036425 '0003140 83-7 11'6 61*5 *7655492.0039416 '0003369 72'0 1117 610 17694908.0045710 '0003907 60 3 13'7 6059 '7740618 '0044364 '0003238 46.6 137 60'5 '7784982 Mean ... .
000351 There are here , certainly , considerable discrepancies in the differences in the value of M corresponding to a difference of 1 ?
in the thermometer II .
These , I consider , have arisen in a great measure , if not wholly , from the thermometer II .
not indicating , in all cases , precisely the temperature of the needle No. IIL : and this is one of the principal difficulties which occurs in an inquiry into the effects produced on the intensity of magnets by changes of temperature .
From experiments which I long since made*k , and from others which I have made more recently , I consider that the differences in the values of M[ corresponding to a change of 1 ?
in the temperature of a magnet increase with the temperature ; but the foregoing results can scarcely be considered to indicate such a law .
For the purpose , however , at present in view , this is not of great importance ; and with regard to the discrepancies I have noticed , I may remark , that if these have arisen from the cause I have assigned , their effect on the mnean result will be extremely small ; for in this case the errors in the results arising fromI errors in the divisors would tend to destroy each other .
In order that the results should be accurate , it is necessary , either that the temperature of the trialneedle should be the same throughout the observations , or that a correction should be applied for the changes which may have taken place in that temperature .
This correction might be determined by observations similar to the preceding , but in this manner the final correction would form an infinite series .
In these observations the indications of the thermometer N were not constant , but , as the whole difference did not amount to 30 , I do not consider that this can materially affect the result .
It is , however , probable that the difference in the temperature of the needle N did not even amount to this : for in consequence of the glass shade under which the needle vibrated being too small to contain a thermometer , that instrument was placed on the outside , and would therefore be more affected by small changes in the tempera. .
ture of the room than the needle which was enclosed .
If we take the mean of the values of M corresponding to the indications 590.8 and 600.3 of the thermometer IL .
, we shall have 7742069 as the value of M corresponding to the temperature 600.05 of the needle IL .
Adding -0009175 to this value , for the difference 00.05 , we have 7742244 for the value of at the temperature 600 .
If now we consider the intensity of the needle II .
, or the value of 1\[ at 60 ?
FAHR. to be 1 , we shall have , The increment in the value of for each 10 above or below 600 _ -+0003515 =+ '0004540 .
Let I be the.measure of the terrestrial magnetic intensity resulting from observation , at any station , of the time of vibration of the needle No. II .
, at the temperature 60 ' ? ?
4s and I the measure of the intensity at the temperature 600 : then 1 , I '000454 1.0 ; and I +0004540 ( 17 .
II* ) By means of this formula , the -measure of the intensity with the needle II .
at any temperature 60 ' +0 may be reduced to the measure of the intensity at the standard temperature 600 FAHR. In order to determine the corrections to be applied , for difference of temperature , to the observations made with the horizontal needles No. 1 , No. 3 , and the Lozengeneedle , experiments similar to those which I have described were made with these needles .
As these experiments were made consecutively , it is necessary that I should give them in the order in which they were made .
With the Lozenge-needle , two sets of experiments were made .
In the first set , this needle occupied the same position precisely as that in which the needle No. IL1 had previously been placed .
The results are given in the following Table : mi)cccxxvi.e 3 Trial-needle under the influence Trial-needle of the Lozenge-needle .
uninfluenced .
Beginning Therm. L ... ..46-0 79 46~ 0 Therm. N ... ... 646 6| 4 65'0 63-0 SSSS Time of 100 vibrations ... { 17489 174'4 174.6 14764 174'8 174'4 l.74-8 147.43 Ending. .
Therm. L. 48'0 77-4 47'6 0 Therm. N. .
66-0 66'0 66-0 67 6 Mean ThermL .
e. e 47-0 78-4 46S3 Therm. N. 65 3 67-o 65.5 65.3 sI sSs Mean time of one vi bration 1j '7485 17 4 1_7 147 , the observations commenced at 7h 8m P.M. , and concluded at 8h 4511 P.m. 6th March .
Finding that in this position of the lozenge-needle the times of vibration of the trial-needle were so little affected by changes in the temperature of the former that a small error in these times would materially affect the results , I made a second set of observations , in which the lozenge-needle was raised *84 inch , its distance from thb trial-needle being reduced to 3-06 inches .
The following Table contain].s the results of this set : Trial-needle uninfluenced .
Trial-needle under the influence First Last of the Lozenge-needle .
observation .
observation..eininf Therm. L 4 ... " 46-s 80.0 49.0 Beginning 't Therm. N ... e. .
60'0 6i6 59.46 6oo 6(C'0 SISSS Time of 100 vibrations 147'S 147'S 216-83 21 54 216'8 TmoflO ... e 147'7 147-9 21 7'2 215-4 216-3 Ending. .
Thermn .
L..0 0 48'4 77$0 5O- ' The 'm .
N. .
59,2 6 7 .
610 0 610 40 S faTherm .
L ... ... .
47-6 785-5 49'6 Mean * .
DifTfrence in Values of value of m Therm. L. Differences .
Therm. N. Int Differences .
| -~~~~~ ~corresponding N ~~~~~~to difference of 10 in Therm. L. 4784 314 656 2 '2900090 0036684 r0001168 78*4 31 .
67'0 '28S63406 '003 44S '0001178 46s8 65*5 '2887895 0024489 0000775 Mean ... .
'0000972 Taking the mean of the values of in corresponding to the indications 470.0 and 460.8 of the thermometer L , we have 2893993 as the value of M corresponding to the temperature 460.9 of the needle L. Subtracting from .
this '0000972 X 13'1 , or ^0012733 , we have '288126 for the value of M at the temperature 600 .
If we take the value of M at the temperature 600 to be 1 , we shall have , The increment in the value of M for each i ?
above or below 600 } '0003374 .
Substituting the times in the second set of observations in the equation ( 16 .
) , we obtain the following results : Difference in Values of value of Therm. L. Differences .
Therm. N. Differences .
voaresue of to difference of iJ in Therm. L. 7~ 59.S '.5360947 '0069i7.5 '003 30'9 60 ' 503 917729 4976 28'9 60.i *.5341648 '0049876 '0001726 Mean. .
is *0001982 From , these , taking a mean as before , we obtain '5351298 as the value of M corresponding to the temperature 48 ?
'6 of the needle L ; and subtracting '0001.982 X 11.4 from this value , we have '5328704 for the value of M at the temperature 600 .
Taking the value of M at the temperature 600 to be 1 , we have , The increment in the value of for each 10 above or below 600 =+ *0003719 .
the mean of the two results gives The 'increment in the value of for each 1 ?
above or below 600 = +0003546 .
We therefore obtain , for the correction of observations made with the Lozengeneedle , the equation I H.00ooo6u In the experiments with HANSTEEN'S cylindrical needle No. 3 , that needle occupied the same position which the lozenge-needle had previously in the last set , the -experiments with the two needles immediately following each other .
The results obtained with this needle are given in the two following Tables : Trial-needle uninfluenced .
Trial-needle under the influence First obLast obof the needle No. .
servation .
servation .
Beginning Therm. 3 ... . .
| 47'6 76|4 48-0 Beginning { Therm. N. , , , .
60o0 61i6 61i1 62 0 60^2 .
8283 Time of 100 vibrationsoe .
{ .
147'S 147'S 205'S 204'2 205'7 14717 147'9 205-6 204'2 205'9 Ending Therm. 3.0 ... . .
oo 49'0 75'0 50'0 ETherm .
N. 59'2 61'2 61-2 62'4 61-0 Mean. .
fTherm .
3 ... ... . .
48'3 7517 49'0 * Therm. N ... * .
59'6 61-4 61'15 62*2 60'6 5SS$ Mean time of one vibration. .
1'478 2'057 2'042 2'055 Difference in m Values of value of 9n Therm. Differences .
Therm. N. __ Differences corresponding M ~~~~~to difference of 10 in Therm. 3 .
48 ?
3 1 27-4 6115 i 4837261 '0076128 *0002778 75'7 26-7 62'2 '4761133 '0081145 '0003039 4911 60 60-6 '4842 78 Mean ... .
0002909 Adopting similar methods of reduction to the preceding , from these results we obtain , for the correction of the observations made with the needle No. 3 , the equation IT0 0. .
( 17 .
3 .
) 1+ *C000fiO5( .
*** ( )* The needle No. 3 being removed , its place was occupied by the needle No. 1 , with which the following results were obtained : Trial-needle uninfluenced .
Trial-needle under the influence First obLast obof the needle No. 1 .
servation .
servation .
Beinn Therm. 1 ... . .
0 45.4 7910 46'0 B eginning iTherm .
N. 60'0 61.6 6|'0 6008 60'6 S147S 147'S 202-4 200S1 S019 Time of 100 vibrations ... .
14787 147'9 202'3 200'3 201'9 Meabn .
Ti. .
of The vibrm .
ion .
1 46478 2 723 0 47105 I~~lierm .
N. 59'6 61~~4 60'0 014 6 ' S S~~~A4 S1AG Difference in ThermoDifferThermoV of m value of m meter 1 .
ences .
meter N. ues o ifferences .
c difference of 10 in Therm. 1 .
46 2 60o0 *4664903 78-O 31.8 61*4 *4549698 *0115205 0003623 305 608 *4641094 *0091396 '0002997 Mean .
0003310 Again , making use of similar methods of reduction with these results , the equation for the correction of the observations made with the needle No. 1 becomes In=I * .
0 .
0 .
( 17 11 F0007181 of comparison were necessary .
At New York the times of vibration were only determined with the face of the needle to the face of the instrument ; and I have therefore compared these observations with those in London , where the needle was vibrated in the same position .
At the other stations the observations were made with the face of the needle to the face of the instrument , and likewise reversed ; and these observations are compared with the similar observations in London .
Time of Thermo Measure of inRatio of in .
Place of observation .
Date .
vibration of meter .
tensity at tensity to that needle .
teimp .
GO " .
at London .
i833 .
o_0 London. .
, ... ... . .
February 9 .
1'3625 500 *5362407 100000 New York ... .
April 1 .
1 28572 69 0 *6074147 1-13273 London. .
February 9 .
1'3828 5O0 '5206021 1.00000 Fort Alexander June 10 .
125315 71'4 *6400997 1-22954 Cumberland House July 6 .
1 %26505 62 75 *6256439 1-20177 Isle i la Cross .
July 17 .
1'2750 74'25 *6191539 18930 Fort Chipewyan July 31 .
1 2715 95'0 *6283987 1'20706 Fort Resolution .
A gtst 9 .
I1 500 i64-8 *6413976 1 23203 f October 9 .
1-27455 41'9 |6105560 | 17279 1834 .
Fort RIliance .
May 21 .
12772 49'63 *6101570 1'17202 October 9 .
1P2756 7 29581 |6061936 1-1|441 I. 1 , IMe-n '6089 89 1'16974 From these results it is veryevidentthatfrom some cause or other , very possibly front having been subjected to a high temperature , the magnetism of the needle suffered a permanent change in the interval between the observations at Fort Resolution on the 9th of August , and those at Fort Reliance on the 9th of October .
Judging from the results of the observations at Fort Reliance in May 1834 , and those in October of the same year , it would not appear that the magnetism of the needle underwent any material change during that interval ; for although the intensity , as deduced in this Table , is somewhat less in October than in May , yet , as will be seen in the Table which I shall immediately give , taking the vibration with the face of the needle to the face of the instrument alone , the intensity appears to be rather greater in October than in May .
Whether the magnetism of the needle suff red any change in the interval between the observations in London and those at Fort Resolution , cannot be determined ; but it is at least not probable that it did so from New York , and the result at that city would not lead us to suppose that it had previously .
We may therefore consider that no exception can be taken to these results on this ground .
With regard to the results at Fort Reliance , the observations that were made in London , subsequent to the expedition , indicate that they are considerably in defect , -as will be seen by the comparison which I shall now make between the observations at Fort Reliance and those at stations subsequently visited .
In the observations which were made in the course of Captain BACK'S perilous voyage to the mouth of the Thew-ee-choh , -which river , in justice to its discoverer and first navigator , should , henceforward , be named the Back , the needle was , in consequence of other most pressing calls on his time , only vibrated with its face to the face of the instrument , excepting at Point Ogle , where a vexatious detention afforded more time for these observations .
In comparing , therefore e , the results fitoln these observations with those at Fort Reliance , I have onlyT taken those derived from observations made there in the same position of the needle .
I have , however , deduced the measure of the intensity at Point Ogle both from the observations made in this position of the needle , and also from a mean of these and of those with the needle reversed on its axis .
In the following Table are given the measures of the intensities at the temperature 60 ?
; the relative intensities , taking the mean of the intensity at Fort Reliance before quitting , and on the return to that station , as unity ; and likewise the relative intensities , taking that at London , on Captain BACK'S return , as unity .
Time of ThermoMeasure of inRatio of inRatio of inPlace o. observation .
Date .
vibration of meter .
tensity at tensity to that at tensity to that needle .
temp. 60 ? .
Fort Reliance .
at London .
1834X .
o May 21 .
128440 49-13.603192 Fnort Reliance ... ... ... .e .
&lt; Oct.9 .
91 13 67.62*603416 Oct. 9 .
Mean ... ... ... . .
603304 1l00000 1-25450 Musk-Ox Rapid July 2 .
il28726 64 0 6604584 1.00212 l 25 717 Rock Rapid .
July 23 .
1P28000 8675 *617S55 P102412 1*28473 Point Beaufort ... ... July 31 .
12975 72o5 -597388 0.99020 1 -S4220 Montreal Island. .
Aug. 1 .
P2885 74-12 *606212 1.00482 1 26055 Point Ogle ... ... . .
Aug. 1 2 .
126563 53 ?
0 62 2317 1X03152 129404 1836 .
London ... ... ... ... Feb. 12 .
|14368 44 0 4809i0 0'79713 1.00000 Fort Reliance ... .
M ay 21 .
Mean needle direct *608175 1*00000 Oct. 9. .
and reversed 4 Point Ogle..Aug .
12 .
5 5406 -613426 100863 P2 76 On the hypothesis of two magnetic poles not far removed from the centre of the earth , to which I have already adverted , if I represent the intensity of the force in the direction of the dip , then I ( 3 cos 2+ 5)(9 ) ; where h is a constant , whose value may be assumed in a comparison of the intensities corresponding to different values of k , or may be determined from the observed values of I. If we assume the intensity at the magnetic equator to be 1 , then p =2 / V2 , and the equation becomes IV ( 3 cos 2a+ 5).(20 .
) In the Table which follows I have given : the dip as already determined from Caps tain BACK'S observations ; the intensities as deduced in the preceding Tables , taking the mean of the results at Point Ogle ; the values of I deduced from the last equal tion ; and , for comparison with these , the relative intensities , assuming the intensity at London to be the theoretical value so determined .
I have also given the values of X resulting from the equation =.V/ ( 3 cos2 +.). .
( 21 .
) , by assuming for I the ratio of the intensity to that at London , as deduced from the observations ; and taking the mean of these values , ( excluding that for London , on account of its incongruity with all the others , ) as the value of p in the equation ( 19 .
) , I have deduced the values of I from that equation , and given the differences between these values and those resulting from the observations .
Ratio of Computed Value of I Value of Difference computed Place of observation .
] Dip . !
intensity value of I , deduced Difference .
constant t , between value of 1 , Error of Plac ofobsevaton .
ip .
to that at equation from equation values of equation co puted London .
( 20 .
) .
observation .
( 21.).and mean .
( 19 .
) value of 1 .
10P7927 .
London 6. .
69 43 1i0000 i17166 1'7i6G + 0000 1i6496 New York ... .
72 49 1'1327 1'7804 1'9445 +'1641 1_799_ _+006 1-1285 -'0042 Fort Alexander. .
78 54 1'2295 1'8973 2-1107 +'2134 1'8330 +'0403 1'2025 -'0270 CumberlandHouse 79 30 1'2018 1'9073 2'0630 +*1 557 1'7822 -0105 1-2088 + ?
0070 Isle 'a a Cross . .
79 28 1'1893 1'9068 2'0416 +-1348 1'7642 -'0285 1*2085 +0192 Fort Chipewyan. .
81 1 1'2071 1-9306 2'0726 + ?
1420 17684 -'0243 1'2237 +0166 Fort Resolution. .
82 3 1'2320 1'9450 21150 +*1700 1-7917 0010 1'2328 +-0008 Fort Reliance. .
, .
84 1 1i2545 1'9682 2'1535 +-18.53 1-8028 +'0101 1'2475 -'0070 Musk-Ox Rapid. .
85 54 1'2572 19851 2-1581 +1730 1-7915 -0012 1-2580 +'0008 Rock Rapid ... .
87 40 1 2847 19951 2 2055 + ' 2104 1'8214 + 0287 1 2645 -0202 Point Beaufort. .
88 3 1-2422 1'9965 2'1324 +*1359 1'7598 -'0329 1'2654 +'0232 Montreal Island. .
$7 36 1'2606 1'9948 2'1639 +X1691 1'7874 -'0053 1-2643 +'0037 Point Ogle ... .
89 24 1'20799 1'9997 2'1971 +'1974 18103 + ?
0176 1|2674 -0125 Mean. .
1|7927 Admitting the accuracy of the results by which the intensities at the American stations are connected with the intensity at London , the results in this Table are , I consider , quite conclusive against the correctness of the formula on which the value of I depends , and , consequently , against that of the hypothesis from which it is deduced if applied to the whole of this extent of the earth 's surface ; the intensities deduced from observation at the American stations , as compared with the intensity at London , being , without any exception , , considerably in excess of the theoretical results .
But if we look to the values of { D in the sixth column , excluding that for London , we cannot fail to be struck by their reinarlIable agreement with each other r and I must candidly confess , that although , previously to deducing these results , I might expect something like a tendency to agreement , yet I by no means anticipated such an accordance as is here manifested .
If we examine the differences between the values of pb and its mean value , excluding that for London , we shall see that only in one instance does this difference amount to one forty-fifth of the mean , and rarely to one sixtieth , Although a comparison of the observed and computed intensities must lead to the same conclusions , I have considered it would be satisfactory that such a comparison should be made .
A most striking agreement is here manifest between the computed values of I and those deduced from observation , in every instance from New York to Point Ogle .
It will be seen that the greatest error in the computed value of I , that corresponding to the observations at Fort Alexander , does not amount to a forty-fifth of the intensity ; and if a mean of all the errors , without regard to their signs , be taken , it will be found that this mean error does not amount to the one hundred and fourth part of the mean of all the intensities .
Such differences as are here indicated are quite within the limits of the errors to which observations of this nature , when carefully made , are liable , and are much less than are , generally , to be expected in any comparison of results with a formula that ought to represent them , when those results are deduced from the vibrations of a needle .
It certainly does appear that the intensity did not in all cases increase with the dip ; but it is probable that these discrepancies have arisen either from small errors in the observations , or from local causes affecting the intensity of the terrestrial force .
Upon the whole , I think we are fully warranted in concluding that in the track of country embraced by Captain BACK'S observations , from New York to the Arctic Sea , the phenomena of terrestrial magnetic intensity are very correctly represented by the formula with which I have compared them .
I now proceed to discuss the observations made with horizontal needles for determining the intensity .
In order to determine the measures of the horizontal intensity resulting from the observed times of vibration of the three needles given in a preceding Table ( p. 397 ) , it is necessary to apply corrections for the difference of temperature , as indicated in the equations ( 17 .
1 .
) , ( 17 .
3 .
) , ( 17 .
L. ) and in the following Table I have given the results so corrected : Needle No. 1 .
Needle No. S. Lozenge-needle .
Place of observation , Time of Measure of hori Time of Measure of horiTime of Measure of h orione Therm. zontal intensity one Therm. zontal intensity one Therm. zontal intensity vibration .
at Temp. 600 .
vibration .
at Temp. 600 .
vibration .
at Temp. 600 .
s00 ~~~~~~~~~-82 00-236 London , Feb. 7 , 1833 4*445 560 -0504675 4-36167 56.0 *0524378 158525 50 0 *290366 Montreal ... . .
i. .
No observations made .
4-82857 56-5 -0428001 No observations made .
X rOct .
1 , 1833. .
7170001 45.5 1 *0166925 7 4790 46.0 *0177276 31535 46o0 1000563 0J Feb. 8,1834. .
No observations made .
7-4941 4.5-25 *0176483 3-14844 35 0 0999945 X(L , May2l,1834 7-68931 5iF0 o0168047 7-42692 50-5 *0180258 3-1650 510 *0995105 9 Oct. 9,1834. .
No observations made .
7-62S1 30-0 -0168793 3'1423 30-0 1002096 Musk-Ox Rapid. .
No observations made .
8-8909 71-0 -0127353 No observations made .
Rock Rapid O A. No observations made .
13-0256 82-0 -0059707 No observations made .
Point Beaufort. .
No observations made .
18-5000 74-0 -0029468 No observations made .
Montreal Island ... No observations made .
16-7750 67.5 -00356986 6(880 63-5 -0211526 Point Ogle .
No observations made .
2217125 62-13 00194097 85825 63-5 *0128561 London , Feb. 12 , 1836 466321 45-0 1 -0455006 455588 | 45.251 04769145 18944 4475 277152 If we compare the measure of the intensity in London previous to Captain BACK'S departure with its measure by the same needle on his return , it is evident that each Mncccxxxvl , 3 G needle must have lost intensity during the expedition .
The loss of intensity by the needles No. I and No. 3 appears to have been nearly the same , but that by the lozenge-needle is proportionally less than one half that by either of the others .
With two of the needles , No. I and the Lozenge , it is not possible to determine whether this diminution of intensity took place previous to the arrival at Fort Reliance or subsequent to the final departure from that station ; but with the other , No. 3 , it is clear that it lost intensity during the progress of the expedition from Fort Reliance to Point Ogle , and its return to the former station .
The results do not indicate that any material change took place in the intensities of any of the needles during the residence at Fort Reliance .
From the results with Nos. 1 and 3 it would appear that at Fort Reliance the horizontal intensity was rather greater in May than in the preceding October ; but those with the lozenge-needle indicate the reverse ; and this cannot be attributed to any loss of intensity in the needle itself , for the observations with that needle in the following October , on the return to Fort Reliance , give an intensity greater than any preceding .
If , in deducing the intensity in the direction of the dip from the horizontal intensity , we take the mean of the results in London , and the mean of those at Fort Reliance previous to quitting and on the return there , we shall have the following as standards for comparison : Mean measure of horizontal intensity .
Needle No. 1 .
Needle No. 3 .
Lozenge-needle .
At London ... .
'047984.0500646 '283759 At Fort Reliance. .
*0167486 '0173400 '100032 7 -I Assuming these and the measures of the horizontal intensity in the foregoing Table , corresponding to the respective stations , and dividing by the cosine of the dip , we obtain the results in the following Table for the measures of the intensity in the direction of the dip : _ Needle No. 1 .
Needle No. 3 .
Lozenge .
needle .
Place of observation .
Dip .
Measure of Ratio of inMeasure of Ratio of inintensity .
tensit to that intensity .
tensity to that intensity tensity to that at London .
at London .
at London .
0 London ... ... ... 69 43 *138417 1'00000 *144429 1'00000 *818545 1*00000 Montreal ... ... . .
77 6 ... 191714 1'3 479 Fort Reliance ... ... 84 1 *160675 1i160803 *166348 1'15185 -959637 1'17237 Musk-Ox Rapid ... 85 54 ... 178122 1-23337 Rock Rapid .
87 40 ... ... ... ... 146653 1-01547 Point Beauort .
88 3 ... ... 086601 0.59965 Montrea Island. .
87 36 ... ... .
'085249 0.59029 *505126 0'61710 Point Ogle ... ... .
89 24 ... ... . .
| 185352 1 28344 1 22769 1'49984 There is but little agreement between these results and those obtained from the times of vibration of the needle No. II .
in the plane of the meridian ; and in some cases they are quite incongruous .
If we suppose that the needles retained their intensities unimpaired from the time of the last observations at Fort Reliance until the observations were made in London , that is , if we take the results of the latter observations as standards for comparison , the agreement will in general be greater ; but still similar incongruities will exist .
The results thus obtained are given in the following Table : Needle No. 1 .
Needle No. 3 .
Lozenge-needle .
Place of observation .
Measure of Ratio of is Measure of Ratio of ea Ratio of inintensity .
tensity to that intensity to ethat in sity tensity to that at London .
at London .
at London .
London.- ... ... ... .
*131253 1'00000 '137573 1.00000 '799485 1'00000 Fort Reliance. .
Needle No. 1 .
Needle No. 3 .
Lozenge-needle .
Obserfved Computed d Difeence of Computed dip Difference of Computed dip Difference of .
Dip .
cos =_ computed and Cos = computed and cos B= computed and IN obsered dp observed dip .
I observed dip .
I= 138417 .
rvddP* I =144429 .
1= 818545 .
00/ U001i0/ f0i FortReliance ... ... 84 1 84 27 54 + 26 54 84 30 29 + ?
0 29 29 84 24 35 +0 23 35 Musk-Ox Rapid. .
85 54 .
85 58 40 ?
0 4 40 Rock Rapid ... ... 87 40 ... .
88 9 21 +0 29 21 Point Beaufort ... .
88 3 ... ... ... 89 3 32 +1 0 32 MontrealIsland ... .
87 36 ... ... ... .
* ... ..88 52 35 +1 16 35 88 49 31 +1 13 31 Point Ogle. .
89 24 ... ... ... ... ... .
89 23 54 -0 06 89 17 49 -0 6 11 I=131253 .
I= 137 57 .
|I= '79985 .
FortReliance ... ... 84 9 43 +8 43 84 14 1 +0 13 1 84 16 34 +0 15 34 Musk-Ox Rapid ... ..* ... * ... .
that on calling Captain BACK'S attention to the circumstance , and referring to the register of the observations , he could recall no circumstance that could induce him to think that in these observations the reading of the needle was beyond 900 on the northern limb , though he perfectly remembered remarking that such was the case at Point Ogle , and that the angle registered was that on the southern limb , and so marked .
I have already stated my opinion of the inapplicability of HANSTEEN'S method of determining the intensity , to cases where the dip is great-but my objections to the method are by no means limited to such cases-and I may notice another source of error , besides that to which I have adverted , to which results deduced from the times of vi bration of a horizontal needle are in these cases peculiarly subject , -local influence .
The directive force acting upon the horizontal needle is , in these cases , greatly diminished , and consequently the relative effect of an extraneous force is , with little exception , increased ; so that masses of rock which are magnetic , although without polarity , may , by their position , exert an influence on the time of vibration of a horizontal needle , which would be altogether insensible on that of the dipping needle .
That the times of vibration of the horizontal needle at Point Beaufort may have been thus affected , is not altogether improbable .
On the observations there Captain BACK has this remark : " Instrument in perfect adjustment ; stand on shingle at the base of a gneiss rock three or four hundred feet high .
" There is no remark on the position of this rock with respect to the needle , and I cannot now consult Captain BACK on the subject ; but that in particular positions such a mass would affect the horizontal needle , and even the dipping needle , is more than probable .
At Montreal Island the stand was ' " placed on firm sand , about sixty yards from some low rocks " ; so that here there does not appear any particular cause for suspecting local influence .
It is , however , proper to give a remark of Captain BACK 's relative to these observations : '"No .
3 vibrated slowly , and on the first trial stopped dead at 100 .
Two kettles , twenty yards off were then taken further away , and I took off my bracebuckles ; it then vibrated regularly , but made a long rest at each extreme , as if disposed to remain there .
We have only made twelve miles N.W. 4 W. from the last place , so that one would imagine some local cause , such as the rock , to account for the difference in the interval of vibrations .
" But I must now close my remarks on the observations at these two stations , although I may , very unwillingly , leave some degree of uncertainty attached to the results deduced from them .
Whatever uncertainty may attach to the results of the observations at Point Beaufort and Montreal Island , every circumstance tends to confirm the correctness of the observations at the more important station , Point Ogle , and to indicate the very near approach which was here made to the northern pole of verticity .
If any doubts could be entertained with regard to the amount of the dip at this station , as determined from the observations , they must be completely removed by Captain BACK'S remarks on the difficulty of adj u sting the horizontal needlel , -which , it will be borne in mind , were delicately suspended by fibres of silk , and the uncertainty of the'ir zero points , at Point Ogle , totally unconnected as these remarks are with the cause of this difficulty and uncertainty ; and I cannot omit to give them precisely as they are appended to the observations : " This needle ( No. 3 ) was extremely difficult to get into adjustment , and was so dull and heavy in its motion , that to have mriked the precise time when it turned at each extremity would have required a fixed reading-glass .
At the conclusion it settled within half a degree of its zero , but in 'five minutes after altered , without any apparent cause , 6 ? .
I then made the following set ( the second set of vibrations ) .
This did not correspond with the former , neither did the needle settle at the same zero I began from , but returned to the first , and what I supposed to be the correct one .
" With respect to the lozenge-needle , he remarks : " There was a difference of no less than 22 ?
between the north points of this and No. 3 , though this agreed with DOLLOND'S light needle for adjusting the dip in .
strument .
As usual , it was more active , and , in this instance , far more regular ( in its vibrations ) .
Nevertheless another set was taken : the needle remained in perfect adjustment * .
" If we contrast the difficulty here manifest , in determining the direction of the magietic meridian by means of needles delicately suspended , with the facility with which its direction was , apparently , determined by Sir JOHN Ross at Victory Harbour and Padliak , at which places he states that he ascertained the dip to be 890 55 ' and 890 56 ' , we cannot but conclude that such results are greatly in excess .
With such a dip , all determinate direction in a horizontal needle , arising from the force of terrestrial , magnetism , however delicate might be the suspension of the needle , is quite out of the question ; and if a horizontal needle , so situated with respect to the pole of verticity , had a determinate direction , it must have been due to the force exerted upon it by some mass in its vicinity .
The dip at Victory Harbour , according to Captain JAMES Ross 's observations t , is 88 55 ' , and at Padliak 890 17 ' ; but even with this amount of dip I do not consider that the direction of the magnetic ineridan could be ascertained , with anything like precision , by means of a KATER'S azimuth compass , however accurate might be its construction , and with whatever care it might be used .
A-t Cape Isabella , where Captain JAMES Ross observed the dip 890 22 ' , the north point of a KATER azimuth compass was directed to the north-west , but " its action was uncertain to eight or ten degrees f. " Captain BACK remarked this sluggishness of the compass-needles from the time he quitted Rock Rapid ; his own , -a small KATER'S azimuth very probably , certainly one of very delicate suspension , -he remarks , " frequently remained wherever it was placed , without evincing the slightest tendency to recover its polarity ? .
" I have referred to these circumstances of the two expeditions , because they all tend ' to show , quite independently of the agreement which I have noticed among the results deduced from the observations , that at Point Ogle , at least as near an approach was made to the northern pole of verticity as at Padliak or Cape Isabella ; and because the observations at Rock Rapid , the last point where , probably , the direction of the magnetic meridianK could be ascertained with some ething like precision , would assign a position to this pole different from that assigned to it by Captain JAMES Ross .
As , however , I propose on some future occasion , investigating the positions which the observations on the continent and in the archipelago of North America would assign to the poles of verticity and convergence , I shall not now pursue the subject further .
I cannot conclude this discussion of Captain BACK 's highly interesting observations without expressing my own obligation to him for having placed them at my disposal , and , at the same time- , my sense of the zeal he has shown in the prosecution of scientific inquiry .
The undivided responsibility which rested upon Captain BAcK during the expedition , and particularly during the progress from Fort Reliance to the sea , by a navigation of unparalleled danger , was of no ordinary kind ; and it was scarcely to be expected that , under such circumstances , any other observations than those absolutely requisite for the prosecution of the voyage would have been made .
We however find that during this perilous and unknown navigation , Captain BACK availed himself of every opportunity for making observations , necessarily tedious in their nature , and requiring much care and attention , but which he considered requisite for the attainment of particular scientific objects and I feel I should be committing injustice were I not to express that I consider science is greatly indebted to him for the zeal and ability he has manifested in its cause .

