On the Reflex Function of the Medulla Oblongata and Medulla Spinalis .
By MARSHALL HALL , M.D. , F.R.S. L. 8 E. , 8fc .
Scc .
Received June 11 , --Read June 20 , 1833 .
1 .
Introduction .
THE higher departments of every science are doubtless its general principles and its laws .
These have a claim to our consideration beyond that of insulated facts or mere details .
Impressed with this truth , I have hitherto devoted my attention chiefly to the laws and principles of physiology .
In a former memoir* , I gave the outline of one of the most general of the laws of this science , -that of the inverse ratio of the respiration and of the irritability .
In the present memoir , I propose to give an account of a principle of action in the animal economy , which has not hitherto , I think , been distinguished with sufficient precision from the other vital and animal functions .
The principle to which I have adverted is connected , in a peculiar manner , with the medulla oblongata and the medulla spinalis .
There is still much discrepancy of opinion amongst physiologists , in regard to the properties and functions of these parts of the nervous system .
LEGALLOIS concluded , from his interesting series of experiments , that the spinal marrow , as a whole , and in distinct portions , is the exclusive source of sensation and voluntary motion .
He observest , " La vie du tronc depend de la moelle 6piniere , et celle de chaque party depend sp6cialement de la portion de cette moelle dont elle re*oit ses nerfs .
De plus , il est facile de d6montrer que cette prerogative de la moelle epiniAre , d'etre la source du sentiment et de tous les mouvemens volontaires du tronc , lui appartient exclusivement a tout autre organ .
" The Reporters of the Institute adopt the conclusions of LEGALLOIS : " M. LEGALLOIS , " they observe+ , " a demontr6 que la section de la moelle 6pini8re sir les premibres ou sir les derni'res vert6bres cervicales , n'arrete que les inouvemens inspiratoires , et qu'elle laisse subsister dans tout le corps le sentiment et les mouvemens volontaires .
Cette distinction est capitale : personne no l'avait faite avaunt lui* .
" M. CRUVEILHIER , on the other hand , denounces this view of the functions of the spinal marrow as one of the errors of modern physiology .
He observest , CL'ind6pendence des diverses parties de la moelle les unes des autres , l'ind6pendence de la moelle du cerveau , assez g6n6ralement admise dans ces derniers temps , me parait un grave erreur physiologique fond6e sir d'ing6nieuses experiences .
L'opinion des anciens , qui regardaient la moelle comme un gros cordon nerveux destin6 a r6pondre lui seul A tous les nerfs de l'6conomie , pour transmettre en definitive au cerveau les impressions , ou pour en recevoir les impulsions volontaires ou organiques , cette opinion est bien plus en harmony avec les faits , avec la grande loi anatomique de la continuite du systSme nerveux .
" It will not be difficult to prove that the conclusions of LEGALLOIS and the Reporters of the Institute , are not legitimate deductions from the facts before them .
But M. CRUVEILHIER altogether overlooks these facts , which are amongst the most interesting in physiology , and adopts an opinion which , however true , is far too exclusive .
On the more recent occasion of a report upon the admirable work of M. FLOURENS , the Perpetual Secretary of the Institute states his opinion on this point in a manner far more problematical .
" L'auteur , " he observes , " conclut que la sensation et la contraction n'appartiennent plus a la moe*he 6piniAre qu'aux nerfs ; et cette conclusion est certain pour les animaux entiers .
Ce serait un grande question de savoir si elle l'est 6galement pour les animaux qui ont perdu leur enc6phale , et qui , dans certaines classes , paraissent loin de perdre sur-le-champ leurs fonctions animales+ .
" It was a singular mistake to imagine that the same conclusion could be just in reference to the entire animal , which was incorrect in reference to the animal deprived of its encephalon .
The facts are these : in the entire animal , sensation and voluntary motion , functions of the cerebrum , combine with the functions of the medulla oblongata and medulla spinalis , and may therefore render it difficult or impossible to determine those which are peculiar to each ; if , in an animal deprived of the brain , the spinal marrow , or the nerves supplying the muscles , be stimulated , those muscles , whether voluntary or respiratory , are equally thrown into contraction , and , it may be added , equally in the complete and in the mutilated animal ; and , in the case of the nerves , equally in limbs connected with and detached from the spinal marrow .
The operation of all these various causes of muscular contraction may be designated centric , as taking place at , or at least in a direction from , central parts of the nervous system .
But there is another function the phenomena of which are of a totally different order and obey totally different laws , being excited by causes in a situation which is eccentric in the nervous system , that is , distant from the nervous centres .
This mode of action has not , I think , been hitherto distinctly understood by physiologists .
It is involved in the question which Baron CUVIER considers as so full of interest , and is that treated of in the following pages .
Many of the phenomena of this principle of action , as they occur in the limbs , have certainly been observed .
But , in the first place , this function is by no means confined to the limbs : for , whilst it imparts to each muscle its appropriate tone , and to each system of muscles its appropriate equilibrium or balance , it performs the still more important office of presiding over the orifices and terminations of each of the internal canals in the animal economy , giving to them their due form and action ; and , in the second place , in the instances in which the phenomena of this fiunction have been noticed , they have , been confounded , as I have stated , with those of sensation and volition ; or , if they have been distinguished from these , they have been too indefinitely denominated instinctive , or automatic .
I have been compelled , therefore , to adopt some new designation for them , and I shall now give the reasons for my choice of that which is given in the title of this paper .
This property is characterized by being excited in its action , and reflex in its 4N2 637 course : in every instance in which it is exerted , an impression made upon the extremities of certain nerves is conveyed to the medulla oblongata or the medulla spinalis , and is reflected along other nerves to parts adjacent to , or remote from , that which has received the impression .
It is by this reflex character that the function to which I have alluded is to be distinguished from every other .
There are , in the animal economy , four modes of muscular action , of muscular contraction .
TheJirst is that designated voluntary : volition , originating in the cerebrum , and spontaneous in its acts , extends its influence along the spinal marrow and the motor nerves , in a direct line , to the voluntary muscles .
The second is that of the respiration : like volition , the motive influence in respiration passes in a direct line from one point of the nervous system to certain muscles ; but as voluntary motion seems to originate in the cerebrum , so the respiratory motions originate in the medulla oblongata : like the voluntary motions , the motions of respiration are spontaneous ; they continue , at least , after the eighth pair of nerves has been divided .
The third kind of muscular action in the animal economy is that termed involuntary : it depends upon the principle of irritability , and requires the immediate application of a stimulus to the nervo-muscular fibre itself .
These three kinds of muscular motion are well known to physiologists ; and I believe they are all which have been hitherto pointed out .
There is , however , afourth , which subsists , in part , after the voluntary and respiratory motions have ceased , by the removal of the cerebrum and medulla oblongata , and which is attached to the medulla spinalis , ceasing itself when this is removed , and leaving the irritability undiminished .
In this kind of muscular motion , the motive influence does not originate in any central part of the nervous system , but at a distance from that centre : it is neither spontaneous in its action , nor direct in its course ; it is , on the contrary , excited by the application of appropriate stimuli , which are not , however , applied immediately to the muscular or nervo-muscular fibre , but to certain membranous parts , whence the impression is carried to the medulla , reflected , and reconducted to the part impressed , or conducted to a part remote from it , in which muscular contraction is effected .
The first three modes of muscular action are known only by actual movements or muscular cointractions .
But the reflex function exists as a continuous muscular action , as a power presiding over organs not actually in a state of 638 motion , preserving in some , as the glottis , an open * , in others , as the sphincters , a closed form , and in the limbs , a due degree of equilibrium , or balanced muscular action , -a fuinction , not , I think , hitherto recognised by physiologists .
The three kinds of muscular motion hitherto known may be distinguished in another way .
The muscles of voluntary motion and of respiration may be excited by stimulating the nerves which supply them , in any part of their course , whether at their source , as a part of the medulla oblongata or medulla spinalis , or exterior to the spinal canal : the muscles of involuntary motion are chiefly excited by the actual contact of stimuli .
In the case of the reflex function alone , the muscles are excited by a stimulus acting mediately and indirectly in a curved and lreflex course , along superficial sub-cutaneous or submucous nerves proceeding to the medulla , and muscular nerves proceeding from the medulla .
The first three of these causes of muscular motion may act on detached limbs or muscles .
The last requires the connexion with the medulla to be preserved entire .
All the kinds of muscular motion may be unduly excited .
But the reflex function is peculiar in being excitable into modes of action not previously subsisting in the animal economy , as in the cases of sneezing , coughing , vomiting , &amp;c. The reflex function also admits of being permanently diminished or augmented , and of taking on some other morbid forms , of which I shall treat hereafter .
I shall thus have occasion to speak of the reflex function as the source of equilibrium in the muscular system ; as excitable into various actions , which , however familiar , are not constant ; and as assuming morbid forms .
Before I proceed to the detail of the experiments upon which this disquisition rests , it may be well to point out several instances in illustration of the various sources and modes of muscular action which have been enumerated .
None can be more familiar than the act of swallowing .
Yet how complicated is this act !
The apprehension of the food by the teeth , the tongue , &amp;c. , is voluntary , and cannot , therefore , take place in an animal from which the cerebr um is removed .
The transition of the food over the glottis and along the middle and lower parts of the pharynx depends upon the reflex function : it can take place in animals from which the cerebrurn has been removed * , or the ninthl pair of nerves divided t ; but it requires the connexion with the medulla oblongata to be preserved entire ; and the actual contact of some substance which may act as a stimulus ?
: it is attended by the accurate closure of the glottis , and by the contraction of the pharynx .
The completion of the act of deglutition is dependent upon the stimulus immediately impressed upon the muscular fibres of the oesophagus , and is the result of excited irritability .
The example which I have given is one of excited reflex function .
The condition of the glottis during respiration , and that of the pharynxand of the sphincters at all times , except during the acts of deglutition , or of excretion , afford equally interesting and familiar examples of the permanent influence of that function .
Whilst the netvous connexion between the larynx and the medulla oblongata is preserved entire , in the rabbit ( Lepus cuniculus ) , for example , the glottis is preserved open , being slightly dilated during each act of inspiration ; but if the superior laryngeal nerves be divided , the aperture immediately becomes so much diminished , that a state of excessive dyspnoea is induced .
The sphincter any , on the other hand , remains closed in the decapitated turtle ( Chelonia mydas ) , if the lower part of the medulla spinalis be left in its canal ; but it becomes immediately relaxed and open , if this part of the nervous system be withdrawn .
The action of this muscle depends upon the medulla spinalis , and not upon the brain only .
However plain these observations may have made the fact , that there is a function of the nervous and muscular system distinct from sensation , from the voluntary and respiratory motions , and from irritability , it is right , in every such inquiry as the present , that the statements and reasonings should be made with the experiment , as it were , actually before us .
It has already been remarked , that the voluntary and respiratory motions are spontaneous acts , not necessarily re* Du Syst6me Nerveux , par M. FLOURENS , Paris 1824 , p. 90 .
j The Nervous System , by CHARLES BELL , F.R.S. 4to ed. 1830 .
Appendix , p. cxviii .
+ De l'Usage de l'Epiglotte , par M. MAGENDIE , Paris 1813 , pp. 6 , 23 , &amp;c. ?
This is the reason of our inability to perform the act of swallowing two or three times in rapid succession , without taking something into the mouth , or allowing time for the secretion of a portion of saliva .
The reflex function must be excited into action by the contact of a stimulus .
The act of swallowing cannot , therefore , be renewed unless some substance , as saliva , be carried into contact with the pharynx .
See further , p. 661 .
640 quiring the agency of a stimulus .
If , then , an animal can be placed in such circumstances that such motions will certainly not take place , the power of moving remaining , it may be concluded that volition and the motive influence of respiration are annihilated .
Now this is effected by removing the cerebrumn and the medulla oblongata .
These facts are fully proved by the experiments of LEGALLOIS and M. FLOURENS , and by several which I proceed to detail , for the sake of the opportunity-afforded by doing so , of stating the argument most clearly .
I divided the spinal marrow of a very lively snake ( Coluber natrix ) , between the second and third vertebrae .
The movements of the animal were , immediately before , extremely vigorous and unintermitted .
From the moment of the division of the spinal marrow , it lay perfectly tranquil and motionless , with the exception of occasional gaspings and slight movements of the head .
It became quite obvious that this state of quiescence would continue indefinitely , were the animal secured from all external impressions .
Being now stimulated , the body began to move with great activity , and continued to do so for a considerable time , each change of position or situation bringing some fresh part of the surface of the animal into contact with the table or other objects , and renewing the application of stimulus .
At length the animal became again quiescent ; and being carefully protected from all external impressions , it moved no more , but died in the precise position and form which it had last assumed .
It requires a little manoeuvre to perform this experiment successfully : the motions of the animal must be watched , and slowly and cautiously arrested by opposing some soft substance , as a glove or cotton wool ; they are by this means gradually lulled into quiescence .
If at this moment the figure last assumed be sketched upon paper , and the animal be left , protected from external impressions , it will be found to retain the same identical form when all vitality has ceased .
The slightest touch with a hard substance , the slightest stimulus , will , on the other hand , renew the movements of the animal in an active form .
But that this phenomenon does not depend upon sensation , is further fully proved by the facts , that the position last assumed , and the stimuli applied , may be such as would be attended by extreme or continued pain , if the sensibility were undestroyed : in one case the animal remained partially suspended over the acute 641 edge of the table ; in others the infliction of punctures , and the application of a lighted taper , did not prevent the animal , still possessed of active powers of motion , from passing into a state of complete and permanent quiescence .
The same observations were made upon various other animals the turtle , the viper ( Jlipera Berus ) , the toad ( Bufo vulgaris ) , the frog ( Rana temporaria ) , the eft ( Triton cristatus ) , &amp;c. It may therefore be stated as a general fact , that if an animal be deprived of the cerebrum and medulla oblongata , and placed under an inverted bell-glass , or otherwise protected from external stimuli , it will not move , however easily it may be excited to motion by external impressions .
I must now solicit the attention of the Society to three important points : it is obvious , 1st , That sensation can act , in inducing muscular motion , only through the medium of volition ; 2ndly , That , in the experiments which have been described , volition , the will , and not the power , to move , was annihilated ; 3rdly , That , in such cases , --volition being destroyed and the agency of sensation excluded , the influence of external impressions , which might be supposed to induce pain , must have been exerted upon some property of the nervous system different from sensibility .
The absence of spontaneous motions in decapitated animals , proves the privation of volition ; and the privation of volition removes all evidence of sensibility in excited motions , and indeed positively excludes its influence .
Sensation , volition , and motion , may be viewed as three links of the chain , in the case in which motion is induced by pain .
If the second link be destroyed , the connexion between the first and third is dissolved .
The proof , in fine , that the excited motions which belong to the reflex function are independent of sensation , is precisely of the same character as that by which the motions due to irritability are distinguished from the same principle .
We are hence led to the conclusion that the excited motions of decapitated animals are dependent upon a principle different from sensation and volition ; and we are further led to the inquiry--What is the nature of that principlewhat the cause of those motions , which remain after sensation and volition are destroyed ? ?
642 But before I enter upon this question , it is important to show still more distinctly than I have done , the distinction between the movements arising from the reflex function of the medulla oblongata and mnedulla spinalis , and those arising from irritability itself .
If the glottis of an animal be touched , there is an immediate contraction .
If the heart be touched , the same phenomenon is observed .
What is the difference between the excited movements of these two organs ?
If the brain be removed , the same events still take place .
If the medulla oblongata be removed , the contractions of the stimulated larynx suddenly cease , whilst those of the heart continue as before .
The difference consists , then , in the presence of the medulla oblongata , which is essential to the contractions of the larynx , but of which those of the heart are entirely independent .
The influence of the stimulus upon the heart is immediate .
That of a stimulus applied to the larynx must pass to the medulla oblongata , and be reflected upon the part moved .
It is interesting to compare the excited movements of the glottis and the submaxillary textures , of the sphincter any and the tail , and of the heart , in these several parts of the recently killed turtle , placed together upon the same table .
All continue vigorous for a considerable time , until the medulla oblongata or the medulla spinalis be withdrawn , when the movements of that portion of the respiratory apparatus which is attached to the head , or of the sphincter and tail , cease in an instant .
The reflex tunction of the medulla is most permanent and apparent to observation in those animals in which the respiration is lowest .
The cold-blooded animals , the hybernating animal , and the very young of the warm-blooded , are therefore the subjects in which this function can be best studied .
It may be retained , or restored , however , in the adult warm-blooded animal , by retaining the respiration , or by renewing the respiration artificially , -a fact , which constitutes another characteristic of the reflex function , and distinguishes it from irritability , and which is , in my opinion , one of the most remarkable in physiology , and highly worthy of further investigation .
These remarks will readily suggest the proper choice of animals , and mode of experiment , for the display of the reflex function .
I now proceed to the detail of the various experiments which I have made upon this subject , and shall then deduce the conclusions which appear to flow from them .
Experiments .
The phenomena of the reflex function , like those of the irritability , are , as I have just stated , more observable in the lower orders of animals , in the very young of the higher orders , and in the state of hybernation .
It will be found , however , that the full-grown mammalia are not less distinctly endued with this property of the nervous system , whilst the functions of respiration and circulation are continued .
The first experiment which I made was upon the turtle .
This animal was decapitated in the manner usual with cooks , by means of a knife , which divided the second or third vertebra .
The head being placed upon the table for observation , it was first remarked that the mouth opened and shut , and that the submaxillary integuments descended and ascended , alternately , from time to time , replacing the acts of respiration .
I now touched the eye or eyelid with a probe .
It was immediately closed : the other eye closed simultaneously .
I then touched the nostril with the probe .
The mouth was immediately opened widely , and the submaxillary membranes descended .
This effect was especially induced on touching the nasal fringes situated just within the anterior part of the maxilla .
I passed the probe up the trachea and touched the larynx .
This was immediately followed by a forcible convulsive contraction of the muscles annexed to it .
Having made and repeated these observations , I gently withdrew the medulla and brain .
All the phenomena ceased from that moment .
The eye , the nostril , the larynx were stimulated , but no movement followed .
The next observations were made upon the other parts of the animal .
The limbs , the tail , were stimulated by a pointed instrument or a lighted taper .
They were immediately moved with rapidity .
The sphincter was perfectly circular and closed ; it was contracted still more forcibly on the application of a stimulus .
The limbs and the tail possessed a certain degree of firmness or tone , recoiled on being drawn from their position , and moved with energy on the application of the stimulus .
On withdrawing the spinal marrow gently out of its canal , all these phenomena ceased .
The limbs were no longer obedient to stimuli , and became perfectly flaccid , having lost all their resilience .
The sphincter lost its circular form and its contracted state , becoming lax , flaccid , and shapeless .
The tail was flaccid , and unmoved on the application of stimuli .
'644 This experiment affords evidence of many important facts in physiology .
It proves that the presence of the medulla oblongata and spinalis is necessary to the contractile function of the eyelids , the sub-maxillary textures , the larynx , the sphincters , the limbs , the tail , on the application of stimuli to the cutaneous surfaces or mucous membranes .
It proves the reflex character of this property of the medulla oblongata and spinalis , and the dependence of these motions upon the reflex function .
It proves that the tone of the limbs , and the contractile property of the sphincter , depend upon the same reflex function of the medulla spinalis , -effects not hitherto suspected by physiologists .
I must now state that the phenomena which have been detailed subsist in distinct portions of the divided nervous system .
If , after severing the head of the turtle , the lower extremities and the tail be separated together , in the manner usual with cooks , the phenomena which I have described are still observed in the distinct and separate portions of the animal .
The head , the anterior extremities , and the tail present the movements which have been described , when severally stimulated .
The posterior extremities alone were observed to be flaccid and unimpressible by stimuli ; and these were found , on examination , to have been separated from their connexion with the spinal marrow .
An interesting experiment demonstrates the powerful influence of the reflex function over the sphincter any in the turtle .
If , after the removal of the tail and the posterior extremities , with the rectum , and of course with a portion of the spinal marrow , water be forced into the intestine , by means of READ 's syringe , both the cloaca and the bladder are fully distended before any part of the fluid escapes through the sphincter , which it then does on the use of much force only , and by jerks .
The event is very different on withdrawing the spinal marrow : the sphincter being now relaxed , the water flows through it at once in an easy continuous stream , with the application of little force , and without inducing any distension , even of the cloaca .
I was first struck with the phenomena of the reflex function of the spinal marrow in the separated tail of an eft .
On being excited by the point of a needle passed lightly over its surface , it contracted and -moved as if it still formed a part of an entire animal .
On another occasion , having removed the head of a frog , I divided the spine between the third and fourth vertebre , and separated the upper portion of the 4o2 645 animal from the lower .
There were then the head , the anterior extremities , and the posterior extremities , with their corresponding portions of medulla , as three distinct parts of an animal .
Each preserved the reflex function .
On touching an eye , it was retracted , and the eyelids closed , whilst similar phenomena were observed simultaneously in the other eye .
On removing the medulla , these phenomena ceased .
On pinching the toe of one of the anterior extremities , the limb and the opposite limb equally moved .
On removing the spinal marrow , this phenomenon also ceased .
Precisely similar effects were observed in regard to the posterior extremities .
Similar phenomena are also observed in the snake .
If the head be removed , and a pointed instrument or a lighted taper be brought into contact with any part of the surface , it is instantly moved .
The motion consists in a flexion of the entire part , and in a concentric movement of the integuments towards the point irritated ; so that the muscles situated along the spine , and certain muscles analogous to the panniculus carnosus , are excited to contraction .
The extremity of the tail is most impressible .
The function which presides over these movements subsisted in every part of the animal separated from the rest , but instantly ceased on removing the spinal marrow .
On touching a point immediately within the teeth of the upper jaw , the larynx was suddenly drawn downwards and closed .
These movements could also be excited by touching the nostrils .
They ceased on removing the medulla oblongata .
Similar phenomena are seen also in the very young of the mammalia .
A rabbit , one day old , was immediately deprived of all voluntary or respiratory motion , with the exception of gaspings , by dividing the spinal marrow near the occiput .
Yet the head and the limbs moved , on stimulating the ears or the feet .
These movements ceased in a quarter of an hour , but were renewed by artificial respiration .
The phenomena were precisely similar after decapitation , haemorrhage being prevented and artificial respiration maintained .
All ceased on removing the medulla oblongata and spinalis .
One of the most remarkable of the phenomena attached to the reflex function in animals , is that presented by those muscles of the hedgehog ( Erinaceus europtaus ) by means of which that animal assumes , in certain circumstances , the form and firmness of a ball .
The reflex function seems especially to connect the roots of the spines with the muscles .
If the animal be examined under the influence of hybernation , the reflex function continues for some hours after the brain is removed ; the panniculus carnosus , the limbs , the tail , the larynx , the sphincter any , remain excitable , and retain a degree of tone .
These phenomena cease on removing the medulla spinalis .
The phenomena of the reflex function seen in the panniculus carnosus , and in other muscles of the hedgehog , are also particularly displayed in the very young animal , in which the peculiar movements of this creature are excitable for a considerable time after decapitation , or the division of the spinal marrow , and long after the cessation of the voluntary and respiratory motions , when it is in a languid and dying state .
In the case of the decapitated young hedgehog , after all gasping has ceased , motions of the larynx are still excited on irritating the nostrils , or on irritating the medulla itself ; just as the peculiar motions of the trunk are excited on irritating the limbs , tail , or spines , --or the spinal marrow .
Nor are we without evidence that the same principles obtain in the human subject .
The condition of the infant born without cerebrum or cerebellum , and breathing from the influence of the medulla oblongata alone , is precisely that of the reflex function , with the addition of respiration .
Such a case has been witnessed and described by Mr. LAWRENCE * .
' The child moved briskly at first , but remained quiet afterwards , except when the tumour was pressed , which occasioned general convulsions .
It breathed naturally , and was not observed to be deficient in warmth , until its powers declined .
I regret that , from a fear of alarming the mother , no attempt was made to see whether it would take the breast : a little food was given it by the hand .
It voided urine twice in the first day , and once a day afterwards : it had three dark-coloured evacuations .
The medulla spinalis was continued for about an inch above the foramen magnum , swelling out into a small bulb , which formed the soft tumour on the basis of the skull .
All the nerves , from the fifth to the ninth , were connected to this .
" This brief detail is full of interest .
The respiration was natural , the medulla oblongata being entire .
Swallowing was effected when food was brought into contact with the pharynx ; the sphincters performed their functions ; the limbs were moved when the skin was first impressed by the atmospheric air .
There was no indication of sensation the child remained quiet after the first brisk movements ; and no event is mentioned which could establish the existence of voluntary motion , the acts of swallowing , and of the expulsion of the urine and faeces , with the functions of the larynx and of the sphincters , belonging distinctly to the reflex function .
M. LALLEMAND has briefly described a case of anencephalous foetus* .
" J'ai vu , il ya quatre ans , a 1'Hotel-Dieu , un foetus anencephale , h term , ou &amp; peu pros , qui v6cut trois jours .
Pendant tout ce temps il poussa des cris assez forts , exer ?
a des mouvemens de succion .
toutes les fois qu'il sentit quelque chose entre ses levres ; mais on fut obligE de le nourrir avec dlt lait et de leau sucree , parce qu'aucune nourrice no voulait lui donner le sein .
I1 executait des mouvemens assez 6tendus des membres thoraciques et abdominaux .
Quand on plagait un corps etranger dans ses mains , il fl6chissait les doigts comme pour le saisir ; mais en g6n6ral tous ses mouvemens avaient moins d'energie que ceux d'un foetus de mme age .
c Le cerveau et le cervelet manquaient enti[rement : il no restait a la base du crane que la moelle allongee et la protub6rance annulaire , avec rorigine des nerfs pneumo-gastrique , trifacial et optique .
Le tout etait recouvert par les debris des os du crane , des meninges et de la peau .
" A similar case is detailed by M. OLLIVIERt , who remarks-- " J'observai l'entant anenc6phale deux heures aprSs sa naissance .
Les yeux etaient constanment fermes ; il poussait des cris frequens qu'on calmait facilement en intro(luisant le petit doigt dans sa bouche : il exer(ait alors des mouvemens de succion r6petes ; il agitait ses membres avec assez de force , et serrait entre ses doigts les corps qu'on pla(ait dans ses mains .
" Je le revis an bout de trois heures .
Les pieds et les mains etaient devenus violets et froids ; la respiration no s'operait plus h des intervalles aussi rapproches ; les mouvemens de la moelle 6pinibre , que j'avais remarques d'abord , continuaient toujours d'avoir lieu , et suivaient chacune des grandes et longues inspirations qu'il faisait .
Les cris 6taient moins forts et moins frequens : on lui donna a diverses reprises de petites cuiller6es de vin vieux sucr6 .
" Insensiblement le refroidissement des extremit6s gagna le rest des mem* Observations Pathologiques , p. 86 .
f Traits de la Molle Epiniire , ed. 2 , Paris 1827 , p. 155 .
648 bres et le tronc ; la respiration s'op6rait a de plus longs intervalles : elle devint convulsive .
Cet 6tat persista pendant six ou huit heures ; ses cris devinrent plus faibles et plus 6loign6s , de meme que les mouvemens de la respiration , qui etaient accompagnee de colnvulsions gen6rales , et il mourut dans un veritable 6tat d'asphyxie , apres avoir pousse un cri analogue a celui qui resulte du hoquet .
" M. OLLIVIER adds , ( p. 161)- " I1 n'existait pas ici un seul rudiment de l'encephale et des prolongemens de la moeille along6e ; la moelle epiniere seule etait restee intacte , et cependant cet infant exergait des succions repetees , et serrait avec assez de force entre ses doigts les corps qu'on plagait dans sa main ; ces mouvemens etaient loin d'etre automatiques comme ceux qui agitaient les membres inferieurs .
" These cases , in connexion with the preceding one , are full of interest .
The peculiar cries , which resemble , in their rationale , the croup-like convulsion from dentition ; the closed state of the eyelids ; the action of suction excited by the contact of the finger ; the closure of the fingers excited by objects placed in the palm of the hand , and the movements of the inferior extremities , in this acephalous infant , are phenomena of the reflex function of the most deeply interesting character .
The following facts are extracted from a letter addressed by Mr. SWEATMAN to Sir CHARLES BELL , and published in the " 'Nervous System"*:- " After the membranes had given way , and the liquor amnnii had escaped , the midwife on examining found another membranous bag presenting , which she naturally supposed belonged to a second child , and therefore did not interfere .
During the passage of this bag under the os-pubis , it suddenly burst , and the whole of the brain escaped from the opening very much smashed , and hanging together only by its membranes .
The child breathed with perfect freedom and cried strongly , rolling its eyes about in a wild , staring manner .
It moved its lower extremities freely , and that not from spasm , but obviously in obedience to ex ternal impressions .
There was no motion whatever of the upper extremities .
In this state it remained for about three hours , when all motion in the extremities ceased , the eyes became fixed , and the breathing gradually slower , till it ceased altogether , just seven hours after the birth of the child .
During this time neither urine nor meconium passed , nor had there been any haemorrhage from the vessels of the brain .
" On examination the occipital bone and the posterior part of several of the cervical vertebrae were found wanting , and their place had been occupied by fluid , surrounded by a membranous bag ; an instance of spina bifida of the neck .
The spinal marrow was perfect .
" A somewhat similar case occurred to me about three years ago , when I had occasion from peculiar circumstances to remove the brain of a child through the anterior fontanelle .
In that instance , about ten minutes elapsed before its birth , yet it drew a deep inspiration , and would have cried had it not been prevented ; and the motions of the lower extremities continued about half an hour , although the whole of the brain had been removed , and a blunt instrument repeatedly thrust down the foramen magnum x. " It is distinctly proved , by this series of observations , that the reflex function exists in the medulla independently of the brain ; in the medulla oblongata independently of the medulla spinalis ; and in the spinal marrow of the anterior extremities , of the posterior extremities , and of the tail , independently of that of each other of these parts , respectivel-y .
There is a still more interesting and satisfactory mode of performing the experiment : it is to divide the spinal marrow between the nerves of the superior and inferior extremities .
We have then two modes of animal life : the first being the assemblage of the voluntary and respiratory powers with those of the reflex function and irritability ; the second , the two latter powers only : the first are those which obtain in the perfect animal , the second those which animate the foetus .
The phenomena are precisely what might have been anticipated .
If the spinal marrow be now destroyed , the irritability alone remains , -all the other phenomena having ceased .
The spinal marrow of a frog was divided between the anterior and posterior extremities .
It was immediately observed that the head and the anterior extremities alone were moved spontaneously and with design , the respiration being performed as before .
But the posterior extremities were not paralyzed : they were drawn upwards , and remained perfectly motionless , indeed , unless stimulated ; by the application by any stimulus , they were moved with * See a similar case by Mr. HAMMOND , in the Medico-Chirurgical Transactions , vol. xii .
p. 308 .
650 energy , but once only , and in a manner perfectly peculiar .
The stimulus was not felt by the animal , because the head and anterior extremities remained motionless at the time it was applied .
Nothing could be more obvious , and indeed striking , than the difference between the phenomena of the functions of sensation and volition observed in the anterior part of the animal , and those of the reflex function in the posterior : in the former there were spontaneous movements with obvious design ; in the latter , the mere effect of stimulus .
The same experiment was made upon the toad ; but for some reason , probably anatomical , it does not succeed so uniformly in this animal as in the frog .
The experiment was repeated upon a guinea-pig .
The effect was an immediate and total paralysis of sensation and voluntary motion in the posterior extremities : there was no expression of pain when they were pinched , nor was there the slightest indication of a power of spontaneous motion : they were dragged along when the animal moved .
But they were not unimpressible by stimuli , nor destitute of the power of moving when stimulated : on the contrary , when pinched , they displayed a sort of repeated , hurried motion , altogether peculiar .
The power of the sphincters was evidently preserved .
In a word , the reflex function remained entire .
In all these experiments the upper part of the animal presented the phenomena of sensation and of spontaneous movements ; in the lower , there was total paralysis of these powers ; yet the reflex function , the excitability , the firmness of the limbs , and the irritability remained .
It now remains to be stated , that the reflex function admits of exaltation and of diminution .
If a frog be made to swallow a watery solution of strychnine or of opium , or if such a solution of strychnine or opium be applied to the skin , the animal soon becomes affected with symptoms perfectly similar to those of tetanus .
The surface becomes highly susceptible to the impression of stimuli , and the muscles of the limbs become affected with continued spasmodic action .
The affection is obviously one of augmented reflex function of the medulla .
It accordingly ceases instantly on destroying the nervous masses .
A frog made tetanic by opium was decapitated , and divided just below the third vertebra .
The eyes were retracted , and no movement could be detected on irritating the eyelids or skin .
Both the anterior and posterior extremities remained susceptible , and tetanic , as before : the limbs were moved in the same spasmodic manner by the same slight impressions .
All was changed on removing the brain and spinal marrow .
The eyes were no longer retracted .
The muscles of the limbs were immovable under the action of stimnuli , and perfectly flaccid , having lost their exalted tone .
Precisely similar phenomena were observed when the frog was made tetanic by opium or strychnine and divided into three portions , the head , the anterior and the posterior extremities ; and in the eft made tetanic and divided into the head , anterior and posterior extremities , and tail .
Each part remained tetanic , impressible by the slightest touch , and spasmodically contracted on any application of stimulus .
The tetanus in each is instantaneously terminated by destroying the corresponding portion of spinal marrow , the head , the limb , or the tail , instantly manifesting a perfectly relaxed and flaccid condition of the muscles .
The irritability remains unimpaired .
These facts complete the proof that the phenomena which I have referred to the reflex function , do not depend either upon sensation and volition , or upon irritability .
It is plain that the spasmodic actions in tetanus are not voluntary actions , and they obey the same laws as the movements observed in an animal , or parts of an animal , not tetanic , under the influence of stimuli .
It is equally plain that phenomena which depended upon excited irritability would not cease whilst that irritability remained unimpairedk .
The phenomena of tetanus , in its effects upon the limbs , enable us to conceive more distinctly than we should otherwise do , the effect of the reflex function in its natural state , in maintaining the due degree of balance and antagonism of the muscles and firmness of the limbs .
If a few drops of dilute hydrocyanic acid be placed upon the tongue of a frog , a state of things the reverse of that just described as the effect of opium or strychnine is induced : the contractions which depend on the reflex function are observed to become less and less energetic and excitable , and at length cease altogether .
* Having observed these facts in connexion with the reflex function , it became a question whether the rigidity of the muscles immediately consequent to death depends upon the same principle .
Two rabbits were killed ; in one the spinal marrow was destroyed , in the other it was left entire .
Both , however , became equally rigid .
So that the spasm of death is a mere effect of irritability , and not of the reflex function of the spinal narrow .
652 Having thus detailed the phenomena of the reflex function , as they are observed in their ordinary and augmented and diminished degrees of force , I shall briefly enumerate some of those excited motions observed in various parts of the animal frame , which are obviously referrible to the same function .
The most healthy condition of the reflex function is that , the result of which is the due state of balance between antagonist muscles .
But certain excited states of this function can scarcely be viewed as otherwise than healthy : such are-winking when an object touches the eyelid , the singular effect of dashing cold water on the face , and the singular effect of tickling * upon the respiration , sneezing from irritation of the nostrils , cough from that of the larynx , vomiting from that of the pharynx , strangury from irritation of the rectum , and tenesmus from that of the bladder , &amp;c. The excited reflex function is observed on touching the eye , the nasal fringes , or the larynx , in the separated head of the turtle ; and on touching the sphincter , the tail , or the limbs , of the separated lower portion of that animal in the frog , the lower extremities are sometimes moved with violence even , on the application of a stimulus , after the division of the spinal marrow .
All the systems of muscles , therefore , obviously partake of this remarkable action .
It is plain , from the preceding observations , that the reflex function may be viewed as subsisting in its natural state , in its state of general excess or failure , and in its state of momentary and partial excitement .
III .
Pathology .
There still remains an interesting part of this inquiry .
What relation does the reflex function bear to the art of physic ?
It will soon be seen that it throws a ray of light over some obscure points in medicine .
Indeed the study of the reflex function appears to me to reveal and explain a totally new order of facts in pathology , and to lead to a new division of the diseases of the nervous system , coinciding with the different modes of operation of their causes , into those of centric and those of eccentric origin .
One of the most interesting of medical subjects , in relation to the reflex function , is that of dentition .
Dentition is a sort of natural experiment upon this function .
The general convulsion , the strabismus , the spasm of the fingers and toes , the croup-like affection of the respiration , the repeated vomitings , the tenesmus , the strangury , the involuntary discharge of urine and of the feces , from its operation , denote the influence of irritation of the maxillary nerves , through the medium of the medulla , upon the muscles of voluntary and respiratory motion , of the eye , the larynx , the sphincters , &amp;c. , in the human subject , and indicate so many arcs of the reflex function .
However these facts may have been known , their true rationale has not been discovered .
In all such cases the remedy is , to relieve the part in which the cause is operating .
In the present instance the maxillary nerves and vessels are to be relieved by free scarification ; the lancet should be used freely , daily , or still more frequently .
The young of other animals , and especially of the feline and canine species , are exceedingly subject to similar effects from dentition , which are not unfrequently fatal .
The fatal event is frequently owing to interrupted respiration .
In one instance , the asphyxia was averted , in a very young puppy , by artificial respiration , effected by alternate compression and relaxation of the parietes of the thorax .
The reflex function is far more excitable in the very young animal .
The second dentition rarely , therefore , induces such affections as the first .
With the effects of dentition in infants , some affections of the adult may be compared , as chorea , some forms of epilepsy , and some forms of asthma .
The diseases to which these designations have been given vary exceedingly in different instances ; inasmuch as some cases are of centric and others of eccentric origin .
One characteristic distinguishes the latter form of the disease , -it usually combines more affections of the reflex function than one .
Such a form of epilepsy , for example , combines hickup , or even vomiting , with the epileptic attack .
The usual source of those forms of disease is in the intestinal canal , the stomach being irritated by improper diet or the bowels by morbid contents .
This division of the subject leads to an important distinction of these cases into those which admit comparatively more easily , and more difficultly , of cure .
Epilepsy is plainly of two kinds : the first has a centric origin in the medulla itself ; the second is an affection of the reflex function , the exciting cause being eccentric , and acting chiefly upon the nerves of the stomach or intestines , which consequently form the first part of the reflex arc .
The fact of the frequent occurrence of a fit of epilepsy in coitu is very interesting in reference to the reflex function : it distinctly connects these two events ; and it affords another instance of an influence exerted , through the medium of this function , between distant parts of the spinal marrow .
There is but a step , as it were , from the normal affection of the nervous , muscular , and respiratory systems , in that circumstance , to an attack of epilepsy itself .
The disease termed asthma claims rather more than an incidental notice in this place .
True asthma , viz. that form of this disease which occurs in youth , and assumes a distinctly spasmodic form and course , like so many other morbid conditions of the reflex function , frequently arises from gastric or intestinal irritation .
It is also frequently excited by the contact of certain powders , as that of ipecacuanha , with the larynx , just as sneezing is induced by similar impressions upon the nostrils .
It appears to consist in an action excited , through the reflex function , in the larger bronchia .
The influence of the smoke of the stramonium in relieving the attack of asthma is another argument in favour of its being an affection of the reflex function .
Indeed , a comparison of the various causes , the mode of attack , the course , and the effects of remedies , in this singular morbid affection , alike denote its relation to this peculiar function .
With the effects of dentition , those of gastric or enteric irritation , in their multiplied forms , may be compared .
Tenesmus and strangury are affections of other arcs of the reflex function .
One circumstance in the pathology of the reflex function is very remarkable .
Several forms of the morbid affections of this function occur during the first sleep .
This is the case with the croup-like affection arising from dentition , with spasmodic asthma , and with a peculiar painful affection of the rectum , not hitherto described .
Tetanus and hydrophobia appear equally to result from injuries inflicted upon the extrenmities of certain nerves , by means of which the morbid influence is conveyed to the medulla , whence it is reflected through the miotor nerves to the muscular system .
As free lancing of the gums in dentition , so the early division of the wounded nerve or amputation in tetanus , has , at once , checked the morbid affection .
Is it possible that hydrophobia might be arrested by a 655 similar procedure ?
The subject is of intense interest , and deserving of the fullest attention .
Certain poisons , as the strychnine , induce excess in the reflex function ; other poisons , as the hydrocyanic acid , destroy it altogether .
In both cases the muscular irritability remains perfect and undiminished .
It is probably through the medium of the same functions that many other poisons act upon the animal economy .
In a frog , recently killed by strychnine , the irritability of the muscular fibre remained unimpaired , -a proof that the tetanus of strychnine is an exalted condition of the reflex function , and that the consequence is the exhaustion of that function , and not of the irritability .
Another frog , destroyed by the hydrocyanic acid , presented similar phenomena of unimpaired irritability on the application of galvanism .
In either case , if the animal be placed in water through which a slight galvanic spark is passed , the limbs are immediately and forcibly extended .
The study of the reflex function will doubtless throw an important light upon toxicology , as well as some parts of pathology , and of the causes and treatment of diseases , -subjects which , as they are more immediately connected with medicine , I purpose forthwith to pursue elsewhere .
Diseases of the nervous system , then , may be divided into those which have their origin at the nervous centres , and those which originate at a distance from those centres ; and especially in some part of the nervous arc , the function of which has formed the subject of this paper , -into those of centric and into those of eccentric origin .
It is highly probable that the diseases of the latter class are more numerous than they may at first be supposed to be .
Chorea , hysteria , tremor , and convulsion have , doubtless , sometimes a centric , sometimes an eccentric origin .
In the latter case , the nervous centres may become morbidly affected in the course of the disease , and the appearances after death may mislead the medical inquirer as to the original cause and seat of the disease .
But the whole of this investigation must be reserved for the Transactions of another Society .
I shall add but one fact more of a medical character in this place .
LEGALLOIS appears to have experienced great difficulty in explaining the occurrence of paralysis from disease of the cerebrum , impressed , as he was 656 that the spinal marrow constituted the source of voluntary motion .
He observes , Quand bien m6me on n'apercevrait aucun moyen de les concilier , il n'en demeurerait pas moins vrai , d'une part , qu'une affection born6e uniquement au cerveau peut 8ter le sentiment et le mouvement volontaire a la moiti6 du corps , et de l'autre , que le sentiment et le mouvement volontaire peuvent subsister et 8tre entretenus dans un animal d6capit6 .
Quelque opposes que ces faits paraissent &amp; , il faut se souvenir que deux faits bien constat6s no peuvent jamais s'exclure Fun rautre , et que la contradiction qu'on croit y remarquer tient a ce qu'il ya entre eux quelque interm6diaire , quelque point de contact qui nous echappe * .
' The facts which have been detailed in this paper enable us readily to remove this difficulty , and to account for the paralysis induced by disease of the cerebrum , on one hand , and for the movements of an anencephalous foetus in utero , or of a decapitated animal , on the other .
The paralysis consists in the loss of voluntary motion ; the movements of the anencephalous foetus result from the agency of the reflex function of the medulla spinalis .
LEGALLOIS ' error was that of mistaking the phenomena of the reflex function for sensation and voluntary motion ; and his difficulty naturally arose out of this error .
There is no real discrepancy between the two orders of facts to which LEGALLOIS refers .
The same facts enable us to understand how a perfect action of the sphincters is compatible with paralysis of the limbs from disease of the cerebrum , and even of the higher parts of the medulla spinalis ; whilst paralysis of the sphincters is usually conjoined with paralysis of the limbs , arising from disease of the lower part of the spinal marrow .
The first intercepts the principle of voluntary motion ; the second affects the very seat of the reflex function which presides over the action of the sphincters .
IV .
Inferences .
I shall now briefly enumerate the inferences which flow from the preceding facts and experiments .
Physiologists have hitherto enumerated only three sources or principles of muscular action , -volition , the motive influence of respiration , and irritability .
There is , however , a fourth source of muscular motion distinct from any of these , though not hitherto distinguished , to which I have ventured to give the designation of the reflex .
Volition and the motive influence of respiration are direct in their course , and spontaneous in their action ; the former proceeding from the cerebrum , the latter from the medulla oblongata* .
The movements of irritability are the result of the immediate application of a stimulus to the nervo-muscular fibre itself .
The reflex function is different from any of these : It remains attached to the medulla spinalis , when the cerebrum and the medulla oblongata are removed : it is not direct like volition , or the motive power of respiration .
Its seat is the medulla generally : it ceases when the medulla is removed , leaving the irritability entire : it is not excited immediately , like the movements of irritability , but mediately , in a reflex course , through the medulla , from the part stimulated to the part moved .
In a state of health , the reflex function presides over the orifices and terminations of the internal canals , such as the glottis and the sphincters , preserving the former open , the latter closed ; and it maintains the due tone of each muscle , and the due equilibrium of each system of muscles .
When excited , it gives origin to the movements observed in deglutition , or vomiting , sneezing , tenesmus , &amp;c. The fingers passed into the pharynx of a dog , through an incision made between the thyroid cartilage and the os hyoides , excites the act of deglutition* ; passed over the root of the tongue -or the fauces , it excites the associated actions of the muscles of the larynx and of expirationt , which constitute the act of vomiting .
When morbidly augmented , it constitutes certain forms of disease , as tetanus , hydrophobia , certain forms of tremor , paralysis agitans , chorea , stammering , &amp;c. ; when diminished , it induces those forms of tremor observed when the vital powers are enfeebled .
When otherwise morbid , it occasions other forms of disease , as the convulsion , the croup-like respiration , the affection of the sphincters , observed in dentition , the various effects of intestinal irritation , &amp;c. The effects of the excited reflex function are sometimes observed in a part near that irritated , as in the eyelids in winking , in the glottis on inhaling a drop of water or particle of food , in the sphincter any in dysentery , &amp;c. ; sometimes in parts remote , as in the irritation of teething when this induces strabismus , convulsion , the croup-like respiration , relaxed sphincters , &amp;c. However some of the facts detailed in this paper may have been previously known , and many were so known + , they have never been accurately dist'inguished from sensation and volition , and associated with a peculiar reflex function of the medulla oblongata and medulla spinalis , influencing other organs besides the limbs , and constituting the principle of tone and of a particular series of actions .
It has long been known , for example , that the limbs of a decapitated animal moved on being stimulated ; but the phenomenon was confounded with sensation and voluntary motion .
It has long been known that carbonic acid could not be inhaled through the larynx ; but it has not been shown that this phenomenon depends upon the presiding agency of the medulla oblongata ; nor has it been distinctly demonstrated that the functions of the sphincter any , by which the intestinal excretions are retained for a time , is constantly dependent upon a similar agency of the lower part of the medulla spinalis .
In like manner , the facts relative to the irritability were altogether known before GLISSON and HALLER finally separated this principle of motion from sensation and volition , with which , like the reflex function , it had previously been confounded .
An interesting parallel might , indeed , be instituted between the principle of the reflex function and that of the irritability , in regard to their history and degree of importance : their history is the same ; for both had been confounded with sensation and voluntary motion * : their importance is precisely the same ; for each presides over its own distinct order of functions .
LEGALLOIS plainly mistook the reflex function of the medulla for the principle of sensation and voluntary motion ; and no physiologist has distinguished its agency , in the function of the larynx and of the sphincters , from the influence of the brain , or from irritability .
The view of M. CRUVEILHIER , that the medulla spinalis is a mere nervous chord , is at variance with all the facts and experiments detailed in the course of this paper .
It is obviously from the mistake which has been pointed out , that LEGALLOIS experienced the difficulty expressed in the following words : " Comment se fait-il qu'aprAs la d6capitation , les seuls mouvemens inspiratoires soient an6eantis et que les autres subsistent ?
C'est l ' , a mon sens , un des grands mysteres des puissances nerveuses , mnystere qui sera devoile tot ou tard , et dont la decouverlte jettera la plus vive lumiere sir le m6chanisme des fonctions de cette merveilleuse puissance+ .
" It was impossible to explain this difficulty whilst the moveiments of the excited reflex function were confounded with those of voluntary motion ; but when this distinction is duly made , nothing is more easy .
Decapitation removes , in fact , the sources both of voluntary and of respiratory motion ; both these kinds of motion consequently cease : but a class of motions still remains , viz. those of the reflex function , attached to the remaining portion of medulla .
Thus is the veil raised from this apparent 'mystery ' .
As LEGALLOIS has confounded the reflex function with the sensibility and voluntary motions , M. BRACHET+ has confounded it with the functions of the ganglionic system , or the sympathetic .
The latter physiologist concludes , that whatever function rernains after the division of the spinal mairrow , in the organs below that division , must be referrible to the influence of the ganglionic system .
In this manner he attempts to prove that some parts of the act and function of generation , in both sexes , besides the secretions , depend upon this influence ; whereas it is certain that they depend upon the lower portion of the medulla spinalis and belong to the reflex function .
It is obvious , that , whilst the secretions may depend on the ganglionic system , the act of excretion , and especially the action of the ejaculatory Inuscles , is an excited act of the reflex function , which has been fully proved to subsist in every portion of the divided medulla spinalis .
This view of the subject is greatly confirmed by a comparison of the act alluded to , with that of deglutition ( p. 640 , note ) , and others demonstrably belonging to the reflex function .
We know that some reptiles remain in coitu after the head is removed .
This is then an act of the reflex function alone .
It may take place without sensation , as in cases of disease of the medulla spiinalis .
I may state , in conclusion , that all the functions of the muscular system which remain after the sources of the motive influence of the voluntary and respiratory motions are removed , with the exception of those of the heart , and other muscles which contract upon the principle of excited irritability , depend upon the reflex function .
The principles of the movements in the animal economy , viewed in an anatoinical and functional point of light , may now be enumerated thus : 1 .
The cerebrum , or the source of the voluntary motions .
2 .
The medulla oblongata , or the source of the respiratory motions .
3 .
The medulla spinalis generally , the middle arc of the reflex function .
4 .
The nervo-muscular fibre , or the seat of the irritability .
5 .
The sympathetic , or the source of nutrition , of the secretions , &amp;c. It is not pretended that this arrangement is either strictly accurate or complete .
These principles of action are , besides , frequently and variously combined , and much ulterior investigation is required to ascertain the share and fix the limit of each in various compound operations of the animal economy .
The reflex function of the different portions of the medulla presides over their corresponding organs : the medulla oblongata presides over the larynx and the pharynx ; the lumbar and sacral portion of the medulla spinalis presides over the sphincter any , the cervix vesicae ; and the intervening portions of the medulla give tone and equilibrium to the corresponding portions of the muscular system , and what LEGALLOIS has so vaguely designated " ife , " to the corresponding regions of the body .
But the operation of the reflex function is by 4Q 2 661 no means confined to parts corresponding to distinct portions of the medulla .
The irritation of a given part may , on the contrary , induce contraction in a part very remote : the irritation of teething may induce spasmodic action or relaxation of the sphincters : the irritation of the nostrils , in the case of a young hedgehog , when so languid that voluntary motion and respiration had ceased , induced as energetic contraction of the most distant part of the panniculus carnosus and of the muscles of the posterior extremities , as irritation of the posterior extiemities or tail themselves .
It would seem , from what I have observed in the young of the hedgehog and of other animals , when languid , torpid , or dying , that the voluntary motions cease first , then the respiratory motions , next those of the excited reflex function , and , lastly , those of the irritability ; the last act of the irritability being that which induces the cadaveric rigidity .
After all evidence of irritability has ceased , it is probable that the functions of the sympathetic may still continue .
Such is the order , then , in which this series of functions disappear in death ; an order which is inverted when the same functions and their appropriate organs gradually came into existence , in the foetal and natal states , and in the progressive series of the animal kingdom .
The movements of the foetus in utero , are entirely phenomnena of the reflex function : they occur in the anencephalous as well as in the perfect foetus* .
This function and the irritability constitute , indeed , the principles of life and motion in the fetal state .
The functions , in sleep , seem to be diminished , and that in the same order .
This is particularly seen in the deep lethargy of the hedgehog .
The animal becomes quiescent ; then it nearly ceases to respire ; then the action of the panniculus carnosus yields to partial relaxation ; lastly , the heart beats with a reptile slowness .
In ordinary sleep , the muscles which retain the eye open lose their powers , and the eyelids close by an act of the reflex function , just as they are kept closed in the anencephalous infant .
The eye is only partially closed , even during sleep , in cases of extreme languor and exhaustion , with diminished energy of the reflex function , .
Volition is first impaired , and the eyelids close ; the reflex function next fails , and the eyelids close partially only .
It appears probable that the facts of this paper may lead to some important additions to our kiowledge of anatomy , by inducing an accurate inquiry into the origin , cour ?
se , connexion , and distribution of the subcutaneous , or submucous , and muscular nerves , which constitute the arcs of the reflex function .
There can be no doubt that a system of nerves takes its origin from the lower portion of the spinal marrow , to supply the sphincters and the organs of generation , which may be compared to those which concentre in the medulla oblongata .
The medulla is also , in its whole course , the source of nerves which supply the limbs , the tail , and the panniculus carnosus , in those animals which possess these structures respectively .
It was observed in one frog that the strychnine applied to a single posterior extremity induced general tetanus .
General tetanus , in the human subject , is the effect of the local wound of a nerve .
These facts demonstrate the strict connexion and unity of the different parts of the nervous system .
The anatomy of the reflex function must be particularly studied in the medulla oblongata ; in the portions of the spinal marrow which give origin to the nerves of the anterior and posterior extrenmities ; in that of the intermediate space which supplies the trunk ; in that which is the source of the nerves of the sphincters , the ejaculators , &amp;c. , and in that which supplies the tail ; and , lastly , in reference to the several columns of which the spinal marrow is composed .
I think the investigation of the anatomy will , for various reasons , be best pursued in the hedgehog .
It is gratifying to me to state that no part of these experiments has inflicted pain , beyond that of prompt decapitation , or division of the spinal marrow .
This is true , at least , if the conclusion be correct , that when the head is removed from the body , sensation and volition cease , whilst the reflex function and the irritability alone continue ; and it may be satisfactory to the humane to know that the motions of the eel , for example , after the head is removed , are not motions arising from sensibility , but from another principle , as distinct from feeling as the irr ?
itability of the mere nervo-muscular fibre .
This fact will suggest the propriety , as well as the means of avoiding such monstrous cruelty as that of skinning eels alive .
This will be effectually done by first rnemoving the heead , however the animal may afterwards move on the applicationi of stimuli , and appear to feel .
663 Recapitulation .
To avoid misapprehension , I think it right , in conclusion , very briefly to recapitulate the claims of this paper : 1 .
Many of the facts which depend upon the reflex function have long been known to physiologists : 2 .
But these facts only extend to the excited action of the reflex function , seen in the limbs , and even they have been erroneously ascribed to sensation and volition , or instinct : 3 .
The facts of excited movements of the larynx , pharynx , sphincters , and ejaculators , and of the panniculus carnosus , have not been shown to be allied to these , and to be dependent on the same individual function of the nervous system : 4 .
It has not been shown that this function , in its natural state , constitutes the principle of equilibrium and tone , in the whole muscular system , and the principle which presides over the orifices and sphincters of the internal canals : 5 .
And certainly not , that this principle , morbidly affected , constitutes , in its different forms , the diseases arising from dentition , and the diseases termed tetanus , hydrophobia , chorea , paralysis agitans , certain forms of epilepsy , of tremor , of asthma , &amp;c. &amp;c. : 6 .
Nor that the same individual function is augmented or diminished to a fatal degree , by certain poisons .
7 .
This series of facts has not been duly associated and shown to belong to one particular order : 8 .
The principle of action in this order of facts has not been demonstrated to be at once excited , and reflex , in its operations , to be essentially connected with corresponding portions of the medulla oblongata and medulla spinalis , and to be independent of the brain : 9 .
Nor has it been clearly distinguished from the other sources and principles of muscular motion existing in the animal economy , viz. volition , the motive influence of respiration , and irritability , or shown to constitute , with the irritability , the principle of life in the foetal state : 10 .
The reflex function appears , in a word , to be the complement of the f-netions of the nervous system hitherto known .
664 trust it will be found , from this brief recapitulation , that the foregoing paper may have done some little service to physiological science .
I consider the subject as but sketched , the investigation as but just begun .
One part of this inquiry is altogether untouched , the influence of the mind and emotions , and the corresponding parts of the nervous system , upon the organs which are the subjects of the reflex function .
The muscles of voluntary and respiratory motion are alike under the influience of the reflex function ; and the muscles over which this function more peculiarly presides are impressible through volition and respiration : other muscles , which are especially attached to the reflex function of the lower portion of the medulla spinalis ( p. 661 ) , are apparently under the influence of the cerebellum* .
Mental emotions modify the reflex function : they induce sickness , relax the sphincters : they also ggravate the diseases of this function , inducing the attacks of epilepsy , of the croup-like convulsion , &amp;c.

