Note on a Paper by Dr. JOHN DAVY , entitled " Notice on the emains of the recent Volcano in the Mediterranean .
" By CHARLES DAUBENY , MI .
D. F.R.S. , Professor of Chemistry in the University of Oxford .
Received May 13 , -Read May 16 , 1833 .
AT the request of the Council of the Royal Society , I propose to submit the following remarks on a paper of Dr. JOHN DAY'S that has recently been read on the subject of the new volcanic island lately thrown up in the Mediterranean ; being desirous of directing the attention of men of science in a more particular manner to the examination of the gases evolved by volcanos , and likewise of pointing out to them certain objections which appear to militate against the hypothesis , by which , in the communication alluded to , the disengagenent of nitrogen , accompanied with only half the proportion of oxygen present with it in atmospheric air , is accounted for .
Nitrogen gas has not hitherto , I believe , been often observed to issue from volcanos in action ; but the fiequent presence of ammoniacal salts amongst the vapours given off by them affords a fair presumption that , if looked for , the gas itself miglt be found to occur more commonly ; especially as the great majority of hot springs-whether such as are immediately and confessedly connected with volcanos , as that of Castella , near Naples , or that more numerous class which are supposed by many geologists ( though without such direct evidence , ) to owe their temperature to causes of an analogous nature , -copiously evolve it , often in a state of purity , but sometimes , as in the specimen examined by Dr. DAVY , intermixed with a certain proportion of oxygen * .
Under such circumstances , the more obvious conclusion would seem to be , that the evolution of this gas is in some way or other connected with certain chemical processes going on at , or near the place of its occurrence .
And in this point of view any account relating to the phenomenon in question derives an interest beyond what it would obtain according to Dr. DAVY'S mode of considering it , as being calculated in a more especial manner to afford us a clue to the hidden causes of volcanic action in general .
It may therefore not appear irrelevant , if I proceed to point out certain objections that have occurred to me with reference to the latter portion of Dr. DAVY 's paper ; in which nothing more than the mere evolution of the gas is attributed to the volcano itself ; whilst the absence of a portion of that oxygen which accompanies it in common air , is resolved into putrefactive processes , going on generally at the bottom of the sea , and therefore wholly unconnected with the particular nature of the locality .
I would observe in the first place , that the notion of sea-water at great depths being wholly or partially deprived of its oxygen by animal putrefaction , &amp;c. , seems inconsistent with the general analogy of nature , since in all other cases there appear to be counteracting causes which restore to the air its purity ; and that notwithstanding the rapid diminution of light in descending through so dense a medium as water , still the existence , at great depths , of Algae possessing an intensely green colour would seem to indicate , that the decomposition of carbonic acid is going on there as well as upon land .
Indeed , owing to the constant circulation taking place in every mass of water , especially if supposed to rest upon a heated substratum , any influence that night be exerted upon the nature of the air contained would be quickly spread over the whole body of the sea , instead of being limited to its inferior portions , where , moreover , the very existence of animals , which must imbibe this air , leads us to conclude , that no material difference in its quality could obtain .
Granting even the nature of the air contained in sea-water at the bottom of the Mediterranean to be such as Dr. DAVY represents , I do not understand to take place also at Bakewell and Stony Middleton , in Derbyshire , and at Taafe 's Well , near Cardiff in South Wales ; -that I have likewise detected it issuing from the hot springs of Mont Dor , and Chaudesaigues in central France , and those of St. Gervais , Cormayeur , St. Didier , and Bonneval in Savoy ; -and that Longchamp states its occurrence at Vichy and in all the thermal waters at the foot of the Pyrenees .
Other instances are mentioned in the paper referred to .
546 how it can find its way to the surface , in consequence merely of the high temperature to which it is subjected below .
Either , in this situation , the pressure of the superincumbent mass of fluid is sufficient to prevent the conversion of the lower strata of water into steam , or it is not .
If it be , this same pressure will enable the water to retain in solution its original quantity of air , or at least the greater proportion of it .
If , on the contrary , there be not sufficient pressure for the purpose , then no doubt the water will rise up in the form of steam through the superincumbent mass along with the air which it had contained ; but as the temperature of the , sea round about the volcano , at least near its surface , is stated by Dr. DAVY not to be higher than that of the atmosphere , it is plain that all the steam must become rapidly condensed , and when it returns to its liquid state , there seems no reason why it should not exert its affinity for the air intermixed , and combine with it as before .
For these reasons , amongst others , I conceive that the air which Dr. DAVY examined cannot have been derived from sea-water , but must have originated from the atmosphere itself , with which this volcano , from its contiguity to Malta and Sicily , may with less difficulty be supposed to communicate ; and this is favoured by the probable upheaving of the bed of the Mediterranean underneath the spot at which the island made its appearance ; for the proofs of which I may appeal to the memoir of Captain SMYTH , lately published in the Transactions , as an Appendix to Dr. DAVY'S former paper on this subject .
Now the upheaving of the bed of the sea would imply the existence of hollows or caverns underneath , into some of which , if not in immediate connexion with the water above , atmospheric air would doubtless find admission .
I would also observe , that if the quantity of gas emitted bore any proportion , as Captain SWINBURNE states it did , to that observed in chalybeate springs , so constant a supply could hardly have been derived from such a source as sea-water ; for 100 cubic inches of pure distilled water ( which holds in solution rather more air than sea-water will do , ) only contain about one cubic inch and a half of nitrogen ; and in most thermal waters that have been examined , the evolution of this gas is much more copious than it is here represented , and makes its appearance in large and frequent bubbles , and not cin minute silver threads .
" In a word , I conceive that Dr. DAVY has under-rated the interest which 547 &amp;c. ought to attach to the information he has afforded respecting the gases given off on the site of this new volcano , by explaining their composition on principles unconnected with volcanic action ; whereas a higher importance really attaches to them , if considered , as it appears they ought to be , intimately i'elated to the latter train of effects .
As , however , our estimate of his theory ( at least as extended to the case of thermal waters , ) may in part depend upon the quantity of gas evolved in a given time , it is to be regretted that no accurate statements of this have as yet , so far as I am aware , been published ; and I therefore would invite such men of science as may chance to be conveniently situated for such researches , to examine the volume of gas emitted by some of our own warm springs , as by those at Bath or Buxton ; which inquiry , indeed , I hope at some future time to undertake myself , should not the necessity for it be superseded by the previous investigations of others .
548

