Experimental Researches on Atomic Weights .
By EDWARD TURNER , M.D. F.R.S. Lond. 8 Ed. , Sec. G.S. , Professor of Chemistry in the University of London .
Received April 25 , -Read May 16 , 1833 .
THE present communication may be viewed as the continuation of an Essay on the Composition of the Chloride of Barium , which was honoured with a place in the Philosophical Transactions for the year 1829 .
In resuming the subject after such a long interval , I feel it right to apologize to the Society for the unfinished state in which that Essay has hitherto been left , -an omission far from voluntary , and entirely due to circumstances not subject to my own control .
In one point of view , however , the delay has been advantageous : it has afforded an opportunity to chemists to verify or correct the results contained in my first Essay , and has enabled me to repeat and extend my researches .
The object which I proposed to myself in commencing the present inquiry , was to re-examine some of those estimates which chemists have occasion to use continually as elements in their calculations , and to confide in as the foundation of their doctrines .
With this view I undertook to determine the relative accuracy of the atomic weights which the British and Continental chemists respectively employ ; and several circumstances induced me to begin by analysing the chloride of barium .
Dr. THOMsoN , on whose experiments the British chemists relied , had obtained so many of his results by means of the chloride of barium , that any material ellrror in the constitution of that compound would necessarily vitiate a large part of his table of equivalents ; and if , on the other hand , the estimate of Dr. THOMSON proved to be correct , an important error would be chargeable against BERZELIUS , whose numbers are very generally adopted on the Continent .
The result of the inquiry is now well known : the source of fallacy , pointed out in my first communication , has been admitted by Dr. THOMSON in the new edition of his System of Chemistry* , and he has accordingly changed the equivalent of barium from 70 to 68 .
The inevitable consequence of this change must be apparent to every one who is acquainted with the method of analysis so frequently resorted to by Dr. THoMsON .
Many of the experiments described in his First Principles of Chemistry are now at irreconcilable variance with each other , and , if relied upon at all , subvert the conclusions which they once appeared to establish .
Nor can those parts of his work which are not subject to this criticism be safely applied to the purposes of science .
His view , for instance , of the composition of the compounds of oxygen with phosphorus , arsenic , and antimony , has been lately abandoned by himself* ; and in the course of the present Essay I shall have occasion to prove , that the atomic weights which he has employed for silver and chlorine are likewise inadmissible .
His analysis of sulphate of zinc , which was made , to use Dr. THOMSON'S own words , " the foundation on which he endeavoured to rear the whole subsequent doctrine of the atomic weight of bodiest , " is peculiarly objectionable .
Besides being vitiated by his error in the equivalent of barium , the oxide of zinc was determined by a method which involved an error in principle , and was in practice so complex as to be unfit for the extremely important object which it was intended to serve .
Having shown that the atomic weights current among British chemists , though in some instances correct or sufficiently approximative , have , as a whole , been adopted on insufficient and fallacious evidence , I shall now lay before the Society an account of experiments made for ascertaining the equivalents of lead , chlorine , silver , barium , and nitrogen .
Equivalent of Lead .
BERZELIUS has made repeated and elaborate researches on the atomic weight of lead , and on the composition of its protoxide .
His direct analysis of the oxide by reduction with hydrogen gas , simple as it appears , is liable to practical difficulties , the effect of which may be distinctly traced in the varying results of his experiments .
Calculating from the two most discordant of the six analyses which BERZELIus has published in his last Essay on this subject+ the equivalent of lead , compared to oxygen as 8 , will be 103*42 in one case , and 103*64 in the other .
This difference , considering the simplicity of the method , and the large quantities of oxide subjected to analysis , is very far greater than could arise in the hands of BERZELIUS from the mere accidents of manipulation .
One source of error , which however he appears wholly or in great measure to have avoided , is the tendency of the oxide of lead to unite with the siliceous matter of the tube , and thus to escape reduction .
Another , not improbable , cause of slight error is referrible to the facility with which spurious distillation ensues when gaseous matter passes over the surface of a hot liquid : by this means small quantities of lead may have been carried away by the hydrogen , and the loss in oxygen thereby rendered too large .
Hence the probability is , that the real equivalent of lead is nearer to 103*64 than to 103'42 .
Seeing no chance of procuring by means of hydrogen more uniform results than BERZELIUS obtained , I selected an entirely different method , dependent on the quantity of sulphate of lead which given weights of metallic lead and protoxide of lead respectively produce .
The method consists of a few simple operations , which , with the requisite precautions , may be conducted with ease and accuracy .
A solution of the best commercial acetate of lead was precipitated by carbonate of ammonia in excess , and the carbonate of lead , after being well washed with distilled water , was dissolved in nitric acid .
From the nitrate , purified by repeated crystallization , the lead was again thrown down by carbonate of ammonia , and the carbonate reduced by black flux .
The metal was washed , fused in a clean crucible , and poured on a clean stone : before being used , the superficial film of oxide was scraped off with a penknife .
In the lead thus prepared I could detect no silver , copper , or other impurity : 100 grains of the metal , oxidized , converted into sulphate , and ignited , yielded to hot water a mere trace of sulphate of potash corresponding to what was introduced by the water and acids which were employed .
Conversion of metallic Lead into Sulphate.-The mode which I found most convenient for converting the metal into sulphate , was to introduce it into the requisite quantity of mixed nitric and sulphuric acid , diluted with an equal volume of water .
The vessel employed for the purpose was a small bell jar , such as is used for collecting gases over mercury : when placed in an inclined position on the sand-bath , there was no danger of loss by spirting , the materials could be freely stirred , and the sulphate readily removed by help of a clean feather at the close of the process .
The excess of the acids was next decanted into a platinum capsule two inches and a half in diameter , and expelled by evaporation .
The sulphate of lead was then transferred to the same capsule , and gently evaporated to dryness , care being taken that some free sulphuric acid should be present .
The capsule was then ignited by the flame of a spirit-lamp with a double wick , and its weight carefully taken before and after its contents were removed .
The sulphate of lead should not be evaporated in a crucible , since otherwise the annoyance which BERZELIUS justly complained of , namely , loss by spirting , will be felt severely : by means of a capsule this inconvenience is entirely avoided .
When the quantity of sulphate is abundant , it will be found convenient to transfer most of the salt to a crucible as soon as it is sufficiently dry to form a cake .
To prevent floating particles of dust from falling into the capsule during the evaporation , a disk of glass a foot in diameter was supported just above it , and the glass itself covered with a sheet of paper .
Allowance was made for impurities contained in the water and acids .
Each of these substances had been twice carefully distilled ; but nevertheless , when evaporated , a trace of residue might be perceived : its quantity however was very minute .
An ounce of nitric acid , four ounces of water , and 100 grains of sulphuric acid , ( being twice as much of each as was employed in any single experiment , ) were digested for a whole day on the sand-bath , and the residue was evaporated and ignited , every part of the operation being the same as in the conversion of lead into sulphate .
The solid matter , consisting of the sulphates of lime and potash , amounted to 0 03 of a grain , half of which was therefore subtracted from the weight of ignited sulphate of lead in each experiment .
Another precaution , which ought not to be neglected in delicate atomic researches , was suggested to me by Dr. CLARK of Glasgow .
In the conversion of lead into a sulphate , the same substance is weighed in two different states , its density in one form being 11 358 , and 6'298 in the other , -a circumstance productive of a small error , which is appreciable when the difference between the two densities is considerable .
I have always avoided this error , when it was of sufficient amount to affect the second place of decimals , by using absolute instead of apparent weights , that is , adding to the weight of each substance in air , the weight of the air which they respectively displace .
The quantity of sulphate of lead yielded by a given weight of metallic lead 526 is shown by the three following experiments , all corrections being allowed for .
They werle made after determining on the exact mode of manipulating by several previous trials : Lead .
Sulphate .
Lead .
Sulphate .
Exp. 1.-79-968 grains of metallic lead yielded 117-097 , being the ratio of 100 to 146-43 ExP .
2.-63-257. .
92-607 --146-398 ExP .
3.-92-92 -- .
136'011 146-375 The mean of the three experiments gave ... ... ... ... ... ... ... .
100 to 146-401 Four experiments of the same kind , published by BERZELTUS , gave the following numbers:-1 .
2 .
3 .
4 .
Mean .
Lead. .
100. .
100 ... 100 ... 100. .
100 Sulphate ... 14638 ... 146-4 ... 14644. .
146'458 ... 146-419 I adopt the ratio of 100 to 146*41 as being the mean of the whole .
Conversion of Oxide of Lead into Sulphate.-BERZELIUS has correctly shown that pure protoxide of lead cannot be prepared by decomposing the neutral nitrate by heat in a platinum crucible , since the crucible itself is always attacked , and the resulting oxide of lead intermixed with fine particles of platinum .
To avoid this impurity , the oxide was prepared , as BERZELIUS recommends , from the subnitrate .
To a cold solution of the neutral nitrate , pure ammonia was added in slight excess , and the white subnitrate collected on a filter , and dried .
It was then introduced into a covered platinum crucible , and was heated for a full hour by a charcoal fire in an open grate , taking care to maintain it at a distinct red heat , but insufficient for fusion .
The oxide was thus obtained in a pulverulent state , quite free from platinum , and of a pretty lemon-yellow colour .
It ought to dissolve completely and easily in cold dilute acetic acid , yielding a colourless solution , which , on standing , does not deposit any brown particles of peroxide .
I may here mention the mode I adopt for weighing pulverulent or porous substances , so as to avoid the possibility of error from the condensation of air or moisture .
The substance is well dried at the requisite temperature , and while hot is introduced into a small flask , capable of holding about an ounce of water , and of bearing a considerable temperature without breaking .
The flask and its contents are placed in the sand-bath , and while yet hot a tight cork is inserted : the whole , when cold , is weighed , the required quantity for experiment gently poured out , and the flask again restored to the balance .
By this means the weight even of a deliquescent substance may be exactly determined .
It is necessary before the first weighing to restore the equilibrium of the air within the flask by a momentary removal of the cork .
A given weight of carefully prepared protoxide of lead was dissolved in hot dilute nitric acid , yielding a perfectly clear colourless solution , and the lead was thrown down by an excess of sulphuric acid .
After evaporating the clear liquid , and expelling the nitric acid , the precipitate was transferred into the platinum capsule , and the quantity of sulphate determined in the manner already described .
I subjoin several of my results , calculated to 100 parts , with all corrections made : the actual quantity of oxide employed in almost every case exceeded 100 grains .
The numerals indicate the order of time in which the experiments were made:1 .
2 .
3 .
4 .
5 .
6 .
Oxide. .
100 100 ... 100 ... 100 .
100 ... 100 Sulphate ... 135-84. .
135-71 ... 135-84 ... 13575 ... 13579. .
13578 On comparing the second with the first and third experiments , it was manifest that there was some source of fallacy , since the difference was fully twice as great as I expected to arise from mere error in manipulation .
I speedily traced one error by finding , in the second experiment , that some nitrate had escaped decomposition , and by ignition had been left as oxide .
This was indicated by a yellow stain , and was proved by digesting the ignited sulphate with dilute nitric acid , when lead was readily taken up .
This inconvenience was effectually avoided in the later experiments , by carefully expelling the nitric acid before bringing the precipitate into the capsule , and moistening it with a distinct excess of free sulphuric acid during evaporation .
Another fallacy , which affects all the results above quoted , arose from traces of red lead remaining in the oxide and eluding detection by being decomposed in the hot , rather strong dilute nitric acid which was used as the solvent .
I was led to suspect this error by the escape of globules of gas while the oxide was dissolving ; and accordingly on taking up a portion in cold acetic acid , the peroxide was readily brought into view .
It was this circumstance which 528 induced me to express a belief , in a short report of these experiments to the British Association last June , that the equivalent of lead would be found rather higher than was then stated .
Subsequent observation has justified that statement .
Some pure protoxide of lead was prepared as before , and was then a second time kept at a red heat for a whole hour : it dissolved completely in cold dilute acetic acid ; and 164'766 grains , treated as in the preceding experiments , yielded 223*943 of sulphate , being in the ratio of 100 to 135*92 .
Every part of this experiment was successfully performed , and I therefore confide in it as representing the true constitution of sulphate of lead .
It is accordingly composed of Protoxide of lead. .
164'766 grs ... 100. .
73*575 Sulphuric acid ... 59177 grs ... 35*92. .
26425 223*943 135*92 100*000 Assuming , agreeably to the experiments already described ( page 527 ) , that 100 parts of metallic lead yield 146A41 of the sulphate , or that 100 of the sulphate contain 68*301 of metallic lead , it follows that the oxide consists of Lead ... . .
68-301. .
103*6 Oxygen ... .
5'274 ... 8 73-575 111*6 The equivalent of lead , according to these results , may be safely estimated at 10366 .
It cannot be so high as 104 , as is supposed by some British chemists ; for according to the numbers current in this country , 100 of metallic lead ought to yield 146*16 of sulphate , instead of 146*41 found experimentally ; and agreeably to the same estimates , 100 of the protoxide of lead should yield 135'72 , instead of 135'92 , the experimental quantity .
Equivalent of Chlorine .
The most conclusive experiments I have met with on this subject , are those of BERZELIUS .
He obtained from 100 parts of chlorate of potash 39'15 of oxygen and 60,85 of chloride of potassium ; and he also found that 100 of chloride of potassium correspond to 192A4 of chloride of silver .
According to my own experiments , which coincide very closely with those of BERZELIUS , 529 parts of silver yield 132-8 of the chloride .
From these data it follows that the equivalent of chlorine is 35*45 .
Chloride of Lead.-To compare with this number the equivalent of chlorine deduced by a different process , some pure carbonate of lead was dissolved in muriatic acid diluted with boiling water , and the purity of the chloride ensured by repeated crystallization .
The dry crystals were then fused in a tube filled with dry chlorine gas ; and while the chloride was yet warm , the chlorine was displaced from the tube by dry carbonic acid gas .
The resulting chloride of lead was colourless , and dissolved completely in hot water .
The analysis was performed by decomposing the solution of chloride of lead by carbonate of soda , acidulating the clear solution with nitric acid , and precipitating with nitrate of silver .
The carbonate of lead , after being washed , was dissolved in acetic acid , and tested for chlorine .
The quantity of chlorine was inferred from the quantity of chloride of silver , and that of lead from the quantity of chlorine .
After a few repetitions I obtained uniform results , and subjoin the proportions of the two most successful experiments : 1 .
2 .
Lead ... ... . .
19582 ... .
1036 ... ... .
23-099 ... .103-6 Chlorine ... ... 6-708 ... 35-48.91 ... ... . .
35-43 These results , then , give an equivalent for chlorine closely agreeing with that calculated from the analysis of chlorate of potash as above quoted from BERZELIUS .
They are , at the same time , entirely inconsistent with the atomic weights current in this country .
For , supposing 104 , 36 , and 110 to be the respective equivalents of lead , chlorine , and silver , it follows that 100 parts of the chloride of lead should yield 104 28 parts of chloride of silver , instead of 103'24 as given by experiment , --a difference very far beyond the reasonable limits of error .
Oxide of Mercury.-Wishing to obtain still further evidence respecting the ratio of the atoms of chlorine and oxygen , I determined on performing a careful comparative analysis of the binoxide and bichloride of mercury .
I at first employed some red oxide prepared by myself from the nitrate ; and though the analyses made with that substance are subject to a slight error , yet as the side on which the error lies is apparent , it will not be unprofitable to record them .
A quantity of oxide of merciury was decomposed in a porcelain retort by a red 530 heat , and the mercury was received in distilled water .
It was well boiled successively with muriatic acid , potash , muriatic acid , and distilled water .
The pure metal was oxidized by very pure nitric acid , and the nitrate decomposed by heat , the temperature at the last being urged so fully to a decomposing heat , that some metallic mercury sublimed .
This was done to decompose every trace of nitric acid , and it succeeded to a very great extent ; but when considerable quantities of the oxide , such as 150 grains , were decomposed by heat , the sublimed mercury exhibited a faint yellow ring , indicative of a small quantity of nitric acid .
Even digestion with a solution of potash did not prevent this appearance .
The method of analysis was by the direct action of heat .
A given weight of the red oxide , previously exposed to a heat of 600 ?
to expel all trace of metallic mercury , was introduced into a tube of German glass , five eighths of an inch wide , and about ten inches in length ; and the oxide was decomposed by the flame of a spirit-lamp , the remainder of the tube being kept cool by moistened paper .
The gas as it escaped passed through a bent narrow tube , containing pieces of silver , and ultimately passed over a surface of gold-leaf : this tube was weighed at the beginning and close of each experiment , but in general the quantity of mercury conveyed into it was not appreciable .
When the decomposition was complete , the tube was filled with dry carbonic acid gas , and the metal was again distilled .
The subjoined numbers contain the results of two experiments performed after acquiring experience in the manual part of the method by several previous trials : 1 .
2 .
Mercury ... ... .
144-805 grs ... .
200768 ... ... .
12598 grs ... .
199'968 Oxygen ... ... .
1154 grs ... 16 ... ... .
1008 grs , ... 16 The figures at the left hand of each bracket indicate the quantities actually observed .
The oxide employed in the two analyses was prepared at different times .
Neither portion was wholly free from nitric acid ; and hence it is apparent , as the loss was thereby rendered greater than it ought to be , that the real equivalent of mercury must exceed 200'768 .
I next proceeded to analyse peroxide of mercury prepared by heat ; and for that purpose a number of pure scales was selected fro among aon large sample of commercial oxide .
On exposure to a temperature of 600 ?
, a portion of metallic mercury was expelled , and the colour of the oxide brightened ; indeed , every specimen of oxide which has fallen into my hands contained some free mercury , separable by heat , and due , I presume , to the deoxidizing agency of light .
A similar remark was made some years ago by Professor DANIELL .
The sample"analysed contained likewise 0 01 per cent. of fixed matter , which was silica or peroxide of tin coloured by iron , together with a little lime .
Allowance was of course made for it .
The following is the result of two careful analyses : 1 .
2 .
Mercury ... ... . .
173-561 grs ... .
20094 ... ... 114-294 grs ... .200-93 Oxygen ... ... . .
1382 grs ... .
16 ... ... 9101 grs ... . .
16 From this it would seem that the equivalent of mercury is not 200 as commonly believed by British chemists , but about 201 .
For the moment , I adopt this number , and will revert to the subject afterwards .
Bichloride of Mercury.-The corrosive sublimate of commerce was purified by repeated crystallization from distilled water , and was then well dried at its subliming temperature .
It might in that state be sublimed without giving any trace of humidity .
Of this chloride 137'595 grains were dissolved in warm water , and directly decomposed by nitrate of silver ; and the chloride of silver was washed with water acidulated with nitric acid , and amounted in the fused state to 144'374 grains , equivalent to 35*659 of chlorine .
The bichloride of mercury would hence seem to be composed of Mercury ... 101936 ... 201 Chlorine ... .
35659 ... 70'31 giving 35'16 as the equivalent of chlorine .
This result led me to suspect some imperfection in the method of analysis ; and I accordingly found that some of the bichloride of mercury is apt to combine with the chloride of silver , and being expelled when the latter is fused , a loss of chlorine is occasioned .
To avoid this error , the bichloride was decomposed by lime , which was prepared from Carrara marble , and was quite free from muriatic acid .
The requisite quantity of lime , previously slaked , was mixed with a little warm water , and the solution of a known weight of corrosive sublimate gradually added , shaking the mixture after each addition .
After a short digestion and filtration , the 532 liquid was neutralized by nitric acid , and the chlorine determined by nitrate of silver in the usual manner .
Every trace of muriatic acid may thus , without the necessity of boiling the materials together , be transferred to the lime and rendered soluble , while the oxide of mercury , of an orange colour , is left with the excess of lime .
In this way I obtained the three following ratios:1 .
2 .
3 .
Mercury ... .
113-441. .
201 ... .
113149. .
201 ... .
112535 ... .
201 Chlorine ... .
39-748 .
70-428 ... .
39'723. .
70565 ... .
39-433 ... .
70'43 According to these results we obtain 35,214 , 35-28 , 35,26 as the equivalent of chlorine .
Calomel.-The proto-chloride , though much more stable than the protoxide of mercury , is very subject to change .
I believe it is impossible to sublime calomel without a portion being resolved into mercury and corrosive sublimate ; and after washing calomel , so as to remove the adhering bichloride , the heat subsequently required for rendering it quite dry causes a fresh production of corrosive sublimate .
I selected for analysis the pulverulent white calomel prepared by Mr. HOWARD , and dried it by exposure to a continued heat of 3000 FAHR. ; at which temperature it undergoes no appreciable decomposition , and contains only a trace of moisture .
But that trace of humidity affects the ensuing results with a small error , the tendency of which is to make the equivalent of chlorine smaller than it is .
The following are the ratios of three careful analyses , which were made by means of lime , as in the analysis of corrosive sublimate .
1 .
2 .
3 .
Mercury ... .
100-048. .
201 ... 95154. .
201 ... .
76'565. .
201 Chlorine ... .
17'602 .
35-361 ' ... .
16-721..35-32 ... .
13-473. .
35-37 .
It will now be convenient to compare together the numbers expressive of the equivalent of chlorine as determined from the four sources above enumerated : these are From Chlorate of Potash , Choride Bichloride of Protochloride of ( BERZELIUS .
) of Lead .
Mercury .
Mercury .
Equivalent of chlorine ... 35-45 ... ... 35'45 ... ... 35-28 ... ... 35-35 .
The equivalent of chlorine is thus limited by the numbers 35 28 and 35 45 , and the mean is 35'33 .
Though this number has been obtained by four distinct methods , yet there is one element of the calculation common to all , namely , the composition of chloride of silver .
Should any material error exist in this fundamental point , a doubt may still be raised respecting the equivalent of chlorine ; but if we can rely on the constitution of the chloride of silver as here employed , then I should feel no hesitation in confining the equivalent of chlorine within the limits which have just been assigned .
Now it happens that on this very question a doubt has been raised by my friend Dr. PROUT , whose remarks are always pertinent , being founded on careful observation .
Chloride of silver , as Dr. PROUT informs me , invariably gives out muriatic acid at a certain stage of drying ; and he suggests whether the loss may not be sufficient to influence the atomic weight of chlorine .
Into this point I have carefully examined .
Nitrate of silver was precipitated by muriatic acid in excess , was well washed with warm water , and set to drain in a dark closet .
Exposed to light it acquired an acid reaction ; and heated in contact with litmus-paper , the colour was reddened , even though not at the same time under the influence of light .
A portion was introduced into a clean retort , and heat applied so as to dry it in that situation , day-light being excluded : the water which thus came over was quite neutral , and the chloride was at length left quite white and dry , without a trace of acid being lost .
The same experiment was repeated with the same result .
I hence consider it as certain that pure chloride of silver may be completely dried at 300 ?
FAHR. without loss of any acid , if light and organic matter be excluded .
On heating this dry and white chloride in a test-tube , a portion of acid sufficient to redden litmus was given out , just as the colour of the chloride darkened in the act of fusing .
This phenomenon is constant .
To try the amount of the loss , a quantity of pure chloride of silver was well dried at 300 ?
FAHR. ; and in one experiment forty-one grains , and in another ninety grains , were fused in a platinum crucible .
In neither case did the loss amount to an appreciable quantity : I could not satisfy myself that it reached 0'01 of a grain .
In these trials , however , the dry chloride was corked up in the weighing flask while still warra ; for if allowed to cool in the open air , it absorbs a little air and moisture , and then on being fused a slight loss is perceptible .
These experiments have been preferably made with chloride of silver thrown down from the nitrate by muriatic acid : the results are similar with any pure chloride ; but when precipitated by sea-salt , it is apt , unless very carefully washed , to retain a little chloride of sodium , and then I 534 believe the developement of acid is more easy than when the chloride of silver is quite pure .
The foregoing experinents have given me the most perfect conviction that my estimate of the constitution of hornsilver , deduced from the researches published in my last Essay , is in no wise vitiated by the fact noticed by Dr. PROUT .
But in order , on a point of so much practical and theoretical interest , not to omit any evidence which might elucidate the subject , I endeavoured to analyse corrosive sublimate by directly ascertaining the quantity of mercury which it contains .
For this purpose a quantity of grain tin was oxidized by nitric acid , and the resulting oxide , after being washed and ignited , was reduced by charcoal .
The pure tin , after being granulated and washed , was dissolved in strong muriatic acid .
The solution was colourless and transparent , and an excess of acid was added to it .
The reduction of the bichloride was thus effected .
A given weight of the compound was dissolved in a small quantity of hot water acidulated wlith mur iatic acid , and the protochloride of tin , likewise hot , was added in excess .
A tube twelve inches long , surrounded by a moist cloth , was then attached to the flask containing the mnixture , and ebullition was kept up for a few minutes , the extremity of the tube being closed by the finger .
This precaution was taken in order to prevent , as far as possible , loss of mercury by the ebullition which is required for collecting together the finely divided metal .
Most of the mercury was thus obtained in one bright globule : it was fully washed by tepid water acidulated with muriatic acid , and the decanted washings were set aside till the suspended particles had subsided .
The mercury was ultimately collected on a double filter , which was dried under a bell-jar with a vessel of sulphuric acid , the air at the close being rarefied .
The two most successful experiments supply the following numbers:1 .
2 .
Mercury ... ... 44782. .
201 ... . .
7309. .
201 Chlorine ... ... 15'90. .
71-366 ... ... 25-97. .
71'413 .
I should be unwilling to adduce these experiments as giving an exact view of the composition of corrosive sublimate , because the chlorine is inferred from the quantity of mercury collected , and the mercury is obtained by a method in which a small loss is , I believe , unavoidable .
They answer the purpose , however , which they were intended to serve .
For in giving 35-67 as the equivalent of chlorine , they show the highest practicable number ; because , since 3z2 535 the mercury obtained was pure and dry , its quantity could not represent less than was present in the compound subjected to analysis .
It may have contained more , but not less mercury than was collected ; and any quantity to be added to that above given would proportionally diminish the quantity of chlorine .
Thus , if these analyses are at all trustworthy , they prove that the equivalent of chlorine may be less than 35'7 , but that-it cannot be greater .
There seems , therefore , to be no reason to call in question the methods which have been used to find the equivalent of chlorine .
The real number , as above stated , is to be sought within a range extending from 35*28 to 35,45 .
This range may be much narrowed by facts supplied by other experiments .
Were 35*35 assumed as the equivalent of chlorine , 107-78 would be the equivalent of silver , deducible from the composition of chloride of silver ; but this number for silver is inconsistent with the analysis of nitrate of silver to be afterwards mentioned , and consequently the hypothesis which led to it is inadmissible .
By a similar line of reasoning the equivalent of chlorine may be brought within the limits 35-4 and 35'45 .
I am disposed to select 35'42 as agreeing closely with my own results , coinciding with the number given in the most recent tables of BERZELIUS , and as giving a convenient number for silver .
Equivalent of Silver .
It appears , at first sight , such a simple operation to prepare oxide of silver , and to reduce that oxide by heat , that my first attempts to ascertain the atomic weight of silver were made with that compound .
It was soon apparent , however , by want of uniformity in my results , that some fallacy existed ; and after numerous unsuccessful efforts to detect it , I abandoned the method altogether .
The examination of sulphuret of silver was likewise begun , and subsequently abandoned for a similar reason .
The analysis of the oxide was thought of as a means of comparing the equivalents of oxygen and chlorine through the medium of silver ; but as this object has been attained by other means , it is easy to infer the equivalent of silver by the constitution of the chloride .
In the belief that 100 parts of silver unite with 32-8 of chlorine , the atomic weight of silver will be 107-92 , 108 , or 108 08 , according as we adopt 35A4 , 35*42 , or 35'45 , as the equivalent of chlorine .
As the whole number has as equal a chance of being correct as either of the others , it may be adopted with propriety , and is certainly a very close approximation .
536 Equivalent of Barium .
The atomic weight of barium may be calculated from my analysis of the chloride of barium already published in the Philosophical Transactions .
According to the proportions there stated , 100 parts of the chloride consist of 65*984 of barium and 34*016 of chlorine ; the equivalent of barium is therefore 6817 , that of chlorine being 35'42 .
The analysis of BERZELIUS differs slightly from mine , giving 68*53 as the equivalent of barium .
I adopt 68'7 , as confiding in the indications of frequently repeated experiments ; but at present I have no other proof that this number is more exact than that employed by BERZELIUS ; it appears certain that 69 is too highl , and that 68 is too low , being incompatible with our analyses .
Equivalent of Nitrogen .
I have endeavoured to ascertain the equivalent of nitrogen by the analysis of the nitrates of silver , lead , and baryta .
Nitrate of Silver.-Pure silver was oxidized and dissolved in nitric acid , and the concentrated hot solution set aside .
In cooling , it deposited numerous transparent thin tabular crystals , which were fused , redissolved in water , evaporated , and again kept for some time in a state of fusion .
The fused nitrate was quite colourless , and dissolved in water without the least turbidity .
It was analysed by solution in water and precipitation by rnuriatic acid ; the whole was transferred to a porcelain capsule , evaporated on the sand-bath to perfect dryness , being protected at the same time from dust and light , and was then fused .
The impurity introduced by the acid and water employed in each analysis amounted to 0'01 of a grain , which was subtracted from the whole weight obtained .
The following is the result of two very successful analyses , made after several preliminary and less satisfactory experiments:1 .
2 .
, --- , ------r--Nitrate of silver ... 124-892 grs. .
100. .
118544. .
97992 grs ... 100. .
1185 Fused chlorideof silver 105-355 grs ... 84-357..100..82-695 grs ... 84389. .
100 .
It may therefore be inferred , as a mean of these closely corresponding ratios , that 100 parts of the fulsed chloride corresponds to 118 522 of the fused nitrate of silver .
By the analysis of chloride of silver , 100 parts contain 75*3012 of metallic silver , corresponding to 80 87 of oxide , the equivalent of silver being 108 .
Hence 118*522 parts of nitrate of silver contain 8087 of oxide and 37 652 of nitric acid ; and on subtracting from this quantity of acid five times the oxygen of the oxide of silver , viz. 27'844 , there remain 9'808 of nitrogen .
The equivalent of nitrogen , calculated from these numbers , is 14*09 .
Nitrate of Lead.-Carefully prepared nitrate of lead was reduced to a very fine powder , and then dried at a temperature of 300 ? .
It is not safe to expose this salt to a temperature much beyond 300 ?
FAHR. , as it is apt , when so heated , to suffer partial decomposition : perfect desiccation must be secured by fine levigation , and the continued action of a comparatively moderate heat .
Known quantities of the salt were then dissolved in distilled water , and decomposed by anl excess of sulphuric acid ; and the resulting sulphate was collected in the same manner and with the same precautions as were described in a former part of this Essay , ( page 526-528 .
) .
The following is the result of three successful experiments:1 .
2 .
3 .
Nitrate of lead .
132 grs ... 109-312. .
99-888 grs. .
109-31. .
130-122 grs ... 109-3 Sulphate of lead .
120-755 grs ... 100. .
91-38 grs ... 100. .
119-05 grs ... 100 .
As a mean of these analyses , it follows that 109'307 parts of nitrate yield 100 of sulphate of lead ; and it has already been shown that the latter contain 73'575 parts of oxide , and 68301 of metallic lead .
From these data , and by the same mode of reasoning as was applied to nitrate of silver , it follows that 14'201 is the equivalent of nitrogen .
Nitrate of Baryta.-This salt was prepared from the native carbonate , and was purified by repeated crystallization ; no impurity could be detected in it , and it was especially examined , by well known tests , for lead and strontia .
It was converted into sulphate in the same manner and with the same precautions as were explained in the experiments with lead .
It was dried by being reduced to a fine powder , and exposed to a temperature of 500 ? .
The following is the result of three satisfactorily conducted analyses , performed after several preparatory trials:1 .
2 .
3 .
C---^-----n C------ACC---^ barium .
Hence , as in the former instances , it may be calculated that 14*17 is the atomic weight of nitrogen .
It is assumed in this calculation that 68'7 is the equivalent of barium , and that 100 parts of chloride of barium contain 65*984 of barium , and correspond to 112'18 of sulphate of baryta .
The equivalent of nitrogen thus appears to be somewhere between the numbers 14*09 and 14*2 , and the mean is 14'15 , which corresponds closely with the number selected by BERZELIUS from his analysis of nitrate of lead .
It must be admitted , however , that this mode of deducing the equivalent of nitrogen is not a desirable one , since the slightest error in the equivalents of silver , lead , and barium is multiplied five times in estitating the composition of nitric acid .
The united testimony of three independent sets of experiments ( or rather four , including the analysis of BERZELIUS , ) serves to diminish the force of this objection ; but still chemnists must give a preference to the Inore direct method , founded on an exact determtination of the densities of oxygen and nitrogen gases , such as we anticipate from the labours of Dr. PROUT .
Equivalent of Sulphur .
I have not yet entered upon a systematic investigation of the atomic weight of sulphur , but merely purpose , on the present occasion , to extract the information which flows incidentally out of the researchles in which I have been occupied .
It has been shown that 100 parts of sulphate of lead consist of 26*425 of sulphuric acid and 73'575 oxide of lead , which last contain 5'274 of oxygen .
From these data , coupled with the known atomic constitution of sulphuric acid , it follows that this acid is composed of Sulphur ... .
10603 ... 16'083 Oxygen ... ... 15822 ... 24 26'425 40'083 Similarly , from the estimates above given , it follows that 100 parts of sulphate of baryta consist of 34'331 of sulphuric acid and 65'669 of baryta , which contain 6'8495 of oxygen .
Hence it follows that sulphuric acid is composed of Sulphur85 ... 13782 ... 16097 Oxygen ... . .
20'5485. .
24 34'3310 40'097 .
539 These estimates agree closely with that of BERZELIUS , deduced by a similar method .
Though in some measure subject to the criticism already referred to in the foregoing observations on nitrogen , they leave no doubt on my mind of the equivalent of sulphur being rather more than exactly double the equivalent of oxygen .
I hope , however , to examine this point more narrowly on a future occasion .
Equivalent of Mercury .
The principal experiments which have been published on the equivalent of mercury are by SEFSTRiM and DONOVAN .
According to three analyses of the red oxide of mercury by SEFSTR8M , the results of which are given in the Annals of Philosophy* , 16 parts of oxygen unite with 202-78 , 202-54 , 200*24 of mercury .
DONOVAN found the peroxide to consist of 16 parts of oxygen and 204'6 of mercury , and the protoxide of 8 of oxygen and 194*2 of mercury .
It is difficult from such very discordant results to strike any mean which should be moderately trustworthy .
DONovAN 's analysis of the protoxide is of no use , as that compound is so very unstable as to be wholly unfit for atomic researches ; and his analysis of the peroxide must certainly be erroneous , owing , perhaps , to his having overlooked the presence of metallic mercury in the peroxide which he examined .
Even the analyses of SEFSTROM indicate that the equivalent of mercury lies within the somewhat wide range extending from 200'24 to 202*78 .
The number may be brought within a narrower limit by the researches already described in this Essay .
The equivalent deduced from the analyses of the red oxide is 200*94 and 200 93 : the three analyses of calomel , taking the atomic weight of chlorine as 35*42 , give 201*28 , 201*3 , and 201*57 , of which the mean is 201*38 , as the equivalent of mercury ; and the numbers deducible from the three analyses of corrosive sublimate are 201*78 , 202'16 , and 202'18 , of which 202'04 is the mean .
Thus the equivalent is included within the numbers 200*93 and 202'18 .
Moreover , it will be remembered , that on calculating the equivalent of chlorine on the hypothesis of 201 being the real equivalent of mercury , an error was committed , which involved the alternative , either that 201 was too low , owing to a slight error in the analysis of the oxide of mercury , or that all the analyses of calomel and corrosive sublimate were inaccurate .
The latter supposition is very much less probable than the former .
With regard to the relative value of the experiments made with calomel and corrosive sublimate , I rely most on the analyses of the latter , since it is much more stable as regards the action of heat , and hence more certainly obtained in a pure state than calornel .
I therefore infer that 202 may be considered as a close approximation to the real equivalent of mercury .
Before closing this communication , I will avail myself of the opportunity to make a few remarks on the employment of filters .
In so far , indeed , as respects the experiments which have been described in the present and preceding Essay , the discussion is not very material , since most of the principal facts have been ascertained by processes independent of filtration ; but in reference to analysis in general , the subject is very important .
In my own researches I am in the habit of determining the weight of substances collected on a filter in one of three different ways .
One of these , introduced by BERZEZLIUS , consists in burning the filter in a platinum crucible , and deducting the weight of its ashes .
This method is peculiarly applicable to the analysis of minerals , where such substances as silica , alumina , and lime are frequent .
Even some substances of easy reduction , such as peroxide of iron and sulphate of baryta , may be safely treated in the game way ; but in these cases it is advisable not only , as usual , to separate the mass of the precipitate from the filter before setting it on fire , but to moisten both with a little nitric acid , and to ensure very free exposure to the air during the burning of the paper and the subsequent ignition .
For such purposes I commonly use some excellent Swedish filtering paper , kindly procured for me by BERZELIUS .
Another method is that of the double filter , introduced by Dr. THOMSON , which I have used in all the experiments where filtration is spoken of in the present and former communication .
Both BERZELIUS and Dr. THOMSON himself seem inclined to doubt the accuracy of this method ; and it is certainly liable to objection , except with certain precautions and with very compact filtering paper .
The paper which I use for the double filter is considerably thicker than the Swedish paper , and of such compact texture that recently precipitated oxalate of lime , or sulphate of baryta thrown down by GLAUBER'S salt in a neutral solution of the chloride of barium , may be filtered by it .
The precautions employed are these .
The paper , folded into filters , is macerated in dilute nitric acid for two days , is then fully washed with warm distilled water , and dried at a temperature of about 212 ?
FAHR. After acquiring its hygrometric moisture , two of the filters of nearly the same weight are poised against each other , and any small difference marked in pencil on the lighter one .
Before being used , a pin-hole is made in the outer filter , in order that any accidental imperfection in the inner filter should be made apparent .
After filtration both filters are dried at the same temperature , and are afterwards allowed to recover their hygrometric moisture completely before removal to the balance .
In repeated trials I have found a pair of filters to recover , aftel use , their original relation in weight to within the OOdth part of a grain ; nor have I ever noticed a greater deviation than may well be expected in every process where filtration is concerned .
Additional testimony of the same kind will be found in my Essay printed in the Philosophical Transactions for 1819 , where , in two sets of experiments , the same point is investigated by the use of double filters and by evaporating the precipitate to dryness without filtration .
The series with silver , moreover , are interesting in reference to theremarks of Dr. PROUT above noticed ( p. 534 ) ; for it is manifest from those results that chloride of silver may be collected on paper and dried , ( in my experiments the filters were dried in a dark , warm air-closet , ) without appreciable loss of acid .
A third method consists in employing a single filter , which is dried before and after filtration at some fixed temperature , as at 212 ?
FAHR. ; and when so dried is enclosed in a light silver vessel , the cover of which is tightly fitted by grinding .
The filter may thus be deliberately weighed without absorbing moisture during the operation .
In case of its being inconvenient to employ an uniform temperature , the filter may be dried at a variable heat , be allowed to absorb hygrometric moisture , and afterwards kept at about 600 FAHR. for two hours in a closed bottle , the bottom of which is covered with pulverised quicklime .
In this method , while operating at least with paper of British manufacture , it is essential , more so than with the double filter , to have previously macerated the filter in dilute acid ; for all such paper , which I have examined , contains lime .
I now , in conclusion , subjoin a list of the atomic weights ascertained by the researches described in the present communication , and add for the conveniience of comparison the corresponding numbers of BERZELIUS from his latest table of equivalentsx , as well as those published by Dr. THOMSON in his First Principles of Chemistry .
THOMIsoN .
BERZELIUS .
TRNER .
Lead. .
104. .
103'5598 ... . .
103'6 Silver ... .
110 ... 108'1285 ... . .
108 Chlorine. .
36 .
35'412. .
35-42 Barium. .
70. .
68-5504 ... . .
687 Mercury ... 200. .
202'5315 ( SEFSTROM .
) 202 Nitrogen. .
14 ... 141628 ... . .
1415 Sulphur .
16..16'0932 ... . .
16'09 The equivalents fixed on by BERZELIUS are in general substantially the same as mine .
I have had continual opportunities of witnessing the extreme care which he employs in his experiments , as well as the fairness with which he reports them .
His estimates , when directly drawn from his own experiments , are in general very close approximations .
The chief difference between us is in the mode of representing equivalents : BERZELIUS strikes a mean of his results , and then calculates the atomic weight to a number of decimal places , which , in general , far exceed the degree of approximation justified by experiment ; whereas I calculate extreme equivalents , and take the mean of them , rejecting all decimals which follow the first doubtful figure .
Thus the two last decimals in his equivalent of lead are useless ; since the experiments of BERZELIUS leave it doubtful whether the equivalent of lead may not fall short of 103'55 instead of exceeding that number .
This doubt respecting lead again operates on the equivalents of nitrogen and sulphur ; so that it is doubtful if the equivalents of these elements may not be smaller instead of greater than 14-16 and 16'09 .
With regard to the numbers employed by British chemists , it is apparent that they are in many instances inconsistent with experiment .
Numbers asserted to be correct to a minute fraction of a unit , are found in error to the extent of a unit and a half , or two entire units : the equivalent of silver , for instance , instead of being 110 , is exactly or nearly 108 ; and the equivalent of barium has been reduced by Dr. THOMSON himself from 70 to 68 .
The atomic weights * POGGENDORFF'S Annalen , xxi .
614 .
4A2 543 of chlorine and lead are likewise incorrect ; and thus are found to be erroneous four quantities which have been employed as elements in calculating the equivalents of nearly all the other elementary substances .
Under such circumstances , Dr. PROUT'S hypothesis , as advocated by Dr. THOMSON , -that all atomic weights are simple multiples of that of hydrogen , -can no longer be maintained .
I grant most willingly , that a system of whole numbers , considered as moderate approximations , may , with advantage , be retained for the use of medical men , students , and manufacturers ; but as the strict representative of scientific truth , applicable to all the purposes of science , this hypothesis is at present untenable .
Let me not however be misunderstood : I mean simply to affirm that the experiments by which it has been attempted to prove the truth of this hypothesis are inaccurate : I may go further , and declare it to be not only unsupported by evidence , but to be at variance with the most exact analytic researches which have been conducted .
I deny not that some simple relation subsists among atomic weights , and that their ratios may possibly be expressed by some simple series of numbers ; but at present no one has assigned any physical cause for the existence of such a relation ; no such relation has hitherto been discovered ; nor , as appears to me , has analytic chemistry attained that degree of perfection which can justify any one in finally asserting or denying its existence , 544

