Experimental Researches in Electro-Magnetism , and Magneto-Electricity .
By the Rev. WILLIAM RITCHIE , LL. D. F.R.S. , Professor of Natural Philosophy at the Royal Institution of Great Britain and in the University of London .
Received March 20 , -Read March 21 , 1833 .
PART I. ON ELECTRIC CONDUCTION .
ACCORDING to the experiments of Professors CUMMING and BARLOw , the conducting power of a wire for voltaic electricity varies directly as its diameter , and inversely as the square root of its length .
My own previous experiments on this subject , with all the conductors I then tried , led to the same result .
According to the experiments of M. BECQUEREL , the conducting power varies directly as the square of the diameter or area of the section , and inversely as the length .
M. POUILLET , from an extensive series of experiments , arrived at the conclusion that the conducting power was exactly proportional to the section of the wire , and inversely proportional to the length , increased by a constant quantity .
Such discordant results , in establishing a fundamental law in electromagnetism , obviously require a more careful examination than has yet been bestowed on them .
Before we admit the accuracy of the conclusions , we must first examine the accuracy of the galvanometer employed , and the different modes of using it .
The mode employed by Professors CUMMING , BARLOW , and POUILLET , was to observe the deflections of a compass needle placed over the conducting wire , and calculate the forces by assuming that the tangents of deflection were proportional to the deflecting forces .
ow , when the conductor is indefinitely long , the wire very fine , the needle placed very near it , and the arcs of deflection small , the results obtained will not be very far from the truth .
These conditions approach to the assumptions from which the mathematical law is deduced .
But when the wire placed below the needle is short , when the diameter is considerable , and when the arcs of deflection rise to sixty , seventy , or eighty degrees , the results calculated in this way will be found to deviate very far from the truth .
When the wire is for'ned into a short rectangular coil , as in the common galvanometer , no numerical results can be obtained from its indications ; for all the conditions assumed in the mathematical investigation are here completely violated .
A single experiment will prove the truth of this assertion .
Having placed four~ copper wires , about four inches long , parallel to one another , on a divided circle , I soldered the ends to those of four other wires about ten feet long , these wires being connected with an elementary battery , composed of two parallel plates of zinc and copper , each containing four square inches .
The plates were immersed in diluted acid and the degree of deflection observed .
An elementary battery , composed of two parallel plates , each one inch square , and having a single copper wire of the same diameter and length soldered to each , was connected with the ends of the four short wires , the battery immersed in the same acid , and the deflections observed .
The tangents of these deflections , reckoning from the middle of the wires , were very nearly in the ratio of one to two , whereas the quantities of electricity were very nearly as one to four .
When my torsion galvanometer ( which is founded on no assumption , ) was employed , the degrees of torsion were found to be nearly as one to four .
Since the tangents of deflections do not afford us accurate measures of the deflecting forces , it is obvious that any law deduced from this method must be fallacious .
The mode employed by M. BECQUEREL in determining the law of conduction was the following .
Two wires of different diameters being placed parallel to each other , had electricity in opposite directions induced on , and the length of one of the wires shortened till the needle remained stationary and parallel to the conductors .
Instead of using a thick wire , the section of which was double that of the other , he employed three wires of the same diameter , and found that two of the wires having the same length , and conducting electricity in the same direction , neutralized the effect of one wire having half the length , and conducting electricity in the opposite direction .
From this he concluded that the conducting powers were directly as the area of the conducting section , and inversely as the length .
It is somewhat remarkable that the fallacy of this conclusion has never been observed , or at least pointed out .
314 He might as well have concluded that the conducting power was directly as the square root of the area of the section , and inversely as the square root of the length , or , in short , as the nth root of the area of the section , and inversely as the nth root of the length .
The fact is , M. BECQUEREL has deduced the values of two unknown quantities from one equation .
Having shown that the laws of conduction , which we have examined , have been deduced either by false processes of reasoning or by employing galvanometers founded on false principles , these laws must be equally fallacious .
Let us examine the law , if any such exists , which connects the conducting powers of wires with the lengths when the diameters are the same .
If two wires of the same diameter , but of unequal lengths , ( for example , the one being four times the length of the other , ) be connected with a single pair of zinc and copper plates of the same size , and immersed in diluted acid of the same strength , the short wire may be found by my torsion galvanometer to have twice the deflecting force of the other .
The conducting powers of the wires might , from this experiment , seem to be inversely as the square root of the length .
If the strength of the acid be increased , the ratio of the deflecting forces will have changed , the long wire having now more than half the deflecting force of the shorter one .
If , on the contrary , the strength of the acid or the size of the battery be diminished , the ratio of the deflecting forces will also have changed in favour of the short wire .
Again , if the diameter of the wires be altered , the lengths being the same , the ratio of the deflecting forces will also vary with the size and energy of the battery employed .
This is indeed what we might expect , without experiment .
The conducting power of a wire must be a function of all the quantities concerned in the experiment .
These quantities are obviously the diameter of the wire , its length , the size of the battery , and the strength of the acid .
It is not , therefore , to be wondered at , that those who have attempted to ascertain the law of conduction , have failed in their attempts , since all of them have overlooked one of the essential quantities concerned in the investigation , viz. the size and energy of the battery .
These deductions are in perfect accordance with the views of conduction which I have already published in the Transactions of the Royal Society .
Let us suppose that there is no actual transfer of electricity along the wire , but that all the phenomena of deflection , &amp;c. , result from a definite arrangement of the 315 electric fluid essentially belonging to the wire itself .
Let us further suppose that a section of wire contains one hundred particles of electricity , and that the battery is capable of arranging one fourth of these , or twenty-five particles , then there will only remain seventy-five to be arranged by any increase of power .
Let us now suppose we have another wire of the same length , whose section contains only twenty-five atoms ; it is obvious that this battery will be able to arrange more than one fourth of this number , so that the ratio of the conducting powers cannot be as one to four , but will be found by actual experiment a very different ratio .
If we increase the size of the battery , suppose the size of the plates to be doubled , then it is obvious we shall not double the deflecting power .
For out of one hundred particles there are only seventy-five remaining , a part of which only can be arranged by the increased part of the battery .
Hence the deflecting force increases very slowly with the increased size or energy of the battery .
We may conceive one of the conducting wires so diminished that the battery has arranged almost the whole of its electricity , in which case any increase in the size of the battery would scarcely produce any increase of deflecting force in the conductor .
If these views be correct , it will obviously be in vain to look for a simple law of conduction involving only the lengths and diameters of the wires .
PART II .
ON CERTAIN PECULIAR PROPERTIES OF ELECTRO-MAGNETS , Though the astonishing lifting powers of electro-magnets be sufficiently known , yet no attempt seems to have been made to investigate the law , if such exists , which connects this power with the length of the magnetic circuit .
The subject appearing to me worth investigating , I procured two soft iron horseshoe magnets ( Plate VII .
fig. 1 .
) , with a short lifter , L , and having rolled the same quantity of covered wire about each , I had obviously the same inducing power when the ends were connected with the poles of the same battery .
The lifter being suspended from the shorter end of a beam of light wood , and brought down on the poles of the magnet , the force by which the lifter was held could easily be ascertained by means of a sliding weight on the longer arm .
The magnets , A and B , and lifter , L , were made from the same bar ; the complete metallic 316 cr ; j ii u ii 1u ii i N\\\\\\\\\\\\S ms~ Illii i~~~Al &gt; i. tIK K~ Jet -.11,11"N"I'l IIll uiiLLL , -A , ' , / ... .1 ... I r19 vIolIuImuiloa - , ILX -1 X4jmu\l : " i4 lm0 ----- , ---.1------- , --- , .
11 -'iI.ii i I.-----:7=-= -..| @\BaB@X gp 11 mim-|liiil[.1If _ ijr i At1 , ll .
} sEt ; SIlI circuit in A being one foot , whilst that in B was four feet .
By placing these magnets successively below the lifter , and connecting them with the poles of the same battery , the attraction of the short one was very nearly double that of the long one .
This result seemed to lead to the conclusion that the lifting powers were inversely as the square roots of the length , which appeared to connect , in a remarkable degree , magnetic induction with voltaic conduction .
Having discovered the fallacy of the generally received law of conduction , I began to suspect that no such simple law would be found to connect the lifting powers with the lengths .
Having substituted a more powerful battery , this simple ratio was immediately altered in favour of the long magnet , so that it now attracted the lifter with more than half the force of the smaller one : by diminishing the power of the battery , the ratio increased in favour of the short one .
The reason of this variable law is obvious .
When the battery is very powerful , it may be nearly able to arrange all the particles of electricity belonging to the soft iron , so as to give the short magnet nearly its greatest power .
Any increase , therefore , in the size of the battery will produce very little increase of power in the short one , whilst the long one , not having more than half the power it is capable of receiving , will receive a considerable increase with every increase in the size or energy of the battery .
As a long magnet requires a large quantity of wire to cover it , and as the conducting power diminishes rapidly with the length , it is obvious the increase of lifting power which we gain by increasing the length of the magnet goes on very slowly , and that we must soon reach a limit beyond which no increase of power could be given .
The truth of this observation will be rendered striking by the following experiment .
Having constructed , with great pains , an electro-magnet according to the American method , and connected it with a battery , I found it would carry about one hundred and forty pounds .
I then rolled about twelve feet of copper ribbon about the middle of the lifter , which weighed about half a pound , and connected the ends of the coil with the same battery , the electro-magnet being now used as the lifter , and was surprised to find that the lifter was a more powerful magnet than that which had cost me so much labour to pre pare .
All that is necessary , then , in making a powerful electro-magnet , is simply to roll : a ribbon of copper ( metallic contact being prevented by a thin tape interposed ) about a short bar of soft iron , and use a short-shoe lifter .
In constructing an electro-magnet , it is necessary to attend particularly to the quality of the iron .
I have tried experiments with various kinds of iron , from the best mitre to the worst English iron , and have observed that the worst iron I could procure is best adapted for making an electro-magnet .
When a piece of fine iron is broken , it appears fibrous like a piece of wood .
When the worst English iron is broken , it appears of a crystalline texture , exceedingly porous , resembling cast iron .
This structure appears peculiarly adapted to allow the particles of the electric fluid to arrange themselves round the crystalline particles in that mode which constitutes a magnet .
It is easy to ascertain , before making an electro-magnet , whether a certain kind of iron be well adapted for the purpose .
All that is necessary , is to forge a small lifter , and try it with a common horse-shoe magnet .
If it be powerfully attracted by the magnet , it is good for the purpose ; if not , it should be rejected .
HIaving made two lifters , one of them of the best iron I could procure and the other of the worst , I found that a hlorse-shoe magnet with the first would carry only fourteen pounds ; with the second it carried no less than twenty-seven pounds .
These facts will enable us to obtain the most powerful electric state by the induction of magnets .
A lifter made of the iron I have described will give a much larger spark than one made of good iron .
Another circumstance to be attended to in obtaining a large spark , is to use a short lifter , with a magnet having its poles near one another .
When the lifter is short , the recomposition of the electric fluid , on the return of the particles to their natural state , is almost instantaneous , and consequently induces , for an instant of time , a more powerful electric state on the coil surrounding it .
When the deflection of the needle is the object , a longer lifter may be employed with advantage .
That the recomposition of the electric fluid goes on more slowly in a long than in a short magnet may be shown by the following experiment .
Take a long horse-shoe magnet of soft iron and convert it into an electro-magnet .
Change the poles of the battery , and the lifter will fall off by its own weight .
With a short magnet the lifter will not fall off when the poles are rapidly changed ; or if it does fall a little , , it will be again attracted so rapidly as to bring it back to its former position .
In repeating these experiments , I was struck with a curious property of a long electro-magnet which had not been previously observed .
When the wires were connected with the battery , and allowed to remain for a few seconds , and then removed , the lifter being disengaged , the soft iron scarcely retained any magnetic power .
When the wires were again connected with the battery , it was rapidly converted into a magnet of considerable power .
Having again removed it , and found the magnetic power almost destroyed , I connected the wires with the opposite poles of the battery , and was surprised to find that it required a long time to convert it into a magnet of much inferior power .
But the most beautiful result I have obtained from changing the poles of an electro-magnet , is the rapid rotation of such a magnet about its centre .
The following short description of the first actually constructed will be sufficient to show how others of greater power may easily be formed .
Let AB , fig. 2 .
, be a section of a circular sole of wood , having a circular groove , a a , turned in it for the purpose of holding mercury .
The groove is divided into two compartments by thin slips of wood .
These divisions are to be connected with the poles of the battery by means of cups , or in any other convenient way .
NS is a piece of soft iron , having a copper wire rolled round it , the ends of the wires being made to touch the mercury in the two divisions of the groove .
The electro-magnet is made to turn easily on a vertical axis , or on a fine point .
The ends of the wire are adjusted so as to clear the two small divisions of wood , the surface of the mercury rising a very little above the divisions .
If a horse-shoe magnet , having a considerable distance between its poles , be placed above the temporary magnet , the poles of the permanent magnet being directly above the slip of wood which divides the groove into two compartments , whilst the soft iron is converted into a magnet by means of the battery , a powerful and rapid rotation of the electro-magnet will take place ; for the electromagnet , being put in motion by the attraction of the poles of the other , will have its poles reversed the moment the wires pass the two divisions .
At that moment attraction will be changed into repulsion , and the momentum thus acquired will be sufficient to carry the electro-magnet to that point where the 2T2 319 poles will be again changed , and consequently attraction will now take place .
A single magnet , with one of its poles opposite the point where the change of poles takes place , is quite sufficient to continue the rotation .
By a slight modification of the apparatus , horse-shoe magnets may be made to revolve with considerable force .
I have fitted a revolving apparatus of this kind , which has a power sufficient to raise several ounces over a pulley .
When the apparatus is placed so that the change of poles of the electro-magnet may take place in the magnetic meridian , the action of the earth is sufficient to make the magnet revolve without the aid of exterior magnets .
By fitting it up so as to revolve in the plane of the magnetic meridian , and to change its poles at the point to which the needle dips , a dipping needle might be made to revolve in a vertical plane .
PART III .
ON A MODE OF OBTAINING AN ALMOST CONTINUOUS CURRENT OF ELECTRICITY BY THE INDUCTION OF MAGNETS .
After the nature of magneto-electric induction had been developed in the splendid and ingenious researches of Mr. FARADAY , and the mode of obtaining a spark from a common magnet by the method of SS .
NOBILI and ANTINORI pointed out , I clearly perceived the mode of obtaining a current of electricity , almost continuous , by the revolving apparatus which I am now to describe .
Though the apparatus was partly constructed nine months ago , yet the laborious duties of my profession prevented me completing it till very lately .
The following is a description of the best form of the instrument for answering the various purposes to which it may be applied .
In fig. 3 , AB is a sole of wood , with two supports , B C , A D. Through the tops of the two supports , an axis passes , having two circular discs of wood , a b , c d , fixed on it for the purpose of holding four cylinders of soft iron , of which two of them , b c , a d , are seen in the section of the instrument .
These cylinders have ribbons of copper , r r ' , similar to those used in my apparatus for exploding the gases by the magneto-electric spark .
Wires , proceeding from the corresponding ends of these ribbons , are made to press against a circular plate of copper , of , well amalgamated .
The other ends are made to pass through the axis , and being bent as represented in the figure , are made to 320 press on a circular rim of copper , g h. This arc may be nearly a quadrant .
The circular plate of copper and this rim have each strong copper wires soldered to them , and terminating in two cups for holding mercury .
A horseshoe magnet , either permanent or electric , is placed perpendicularly on the sole , so that each of the cylinders , when made to revolve by turning the handle , may pass very near the poles of the magnet .
If the handle be now turned rapidly round , each cylinder , in passing the poles of the magnet , will become a temporary magnet , and in doing so will induce an electric state on the ribbon of copper , the two cups being connected either with a galvanometer or in any other way .
After passing the poles , it returns rapidly to its neutral state , and in doing so would induce an opposite electric state on the coil if the wire did not leave the rim of copper at the proper time .
When one of the wires is leaving the rim , another is just entering , so that whilst one current is ceasing to act , the other current is just beginning .
We have thus a series of currents of a variable nature following each other in rapid succession , and all acting in the same direction .
This current will keep the needle of a galvanometer almost steadily deflected , and will make a wire revolve about a magnet as in Mr. FARADAY'S first experiment .
By increasing the size of the apparatus , all the other rotations might of course be produced .
If a circular piece of copper be fixed on one of the supports on the outside of the rim formerly described , and having its circumference cut into teeth like a saw , and if the ends of the wires be made to revolve on these teeth , this plate , and that on which the other ends of the wires revolve , being connected , a series of magneto-electric sparks will follow each other , in rapid succession , for very nearly a fourth part of the circumference .
If four magnets be placed opposite the four cylinders of soft iron , almost the whole circumference may be illuminated at the same instant , producing a very beautiful effect .
321

