rays must remain imperfectly corrected , which imperfection is greater as the indices of the extreme rays bear a higher ratio to the mean index ; and thus it constantly happens in constructions of this kind , that while we are advancing towards perfection on one hand , a corresponding evil enters on the other , a circumstance which renders preliminary experiments so highly necessary in everything connected with practical optics .
As however the whole linear amount of the aberration of the front lens does not amount to Tr 7ths of an inch , I fully determined upon adopting this principle of construction , as it appeared to me that , with so little to correct , the imperfection must necessarily be very inconsiderable .
This circumstance , however , led me to consider what might be the advantages of making the correction for the spherical aberration of the front lens , by means of the glass shells of the fluid lens , reducing that of the fluid either to zero or to a minimum .
And on making independent calculations on both hypotheses , I found , what was perfectly unexpected to me , that the same fluid lens would answer both cases by simply inverting it , or so nearly so , at least , as not to render it necessary to have a second fluid lens made to decide the question .
With these decided advantages , according to either principle , it was obvious that I might venture upon a much shorter telescope than would be required for an eight-inch aperture of the usual kind of refractor ; but the want of preliminary experiments made it impossible to know to what extent this shortening might be carried .
I determined therefore on eight-feet focus ; but the nearest I could come to this length without having new tools made , was eight feet nine inches .
Another principle , which was thought desirable , was to divide the refraction pretty equally between all the four surfaces of the two front lenses ; and this condition was quite consistent with the adoption of two equal convex lenses , as will be seen immediately by taking 500 as an approximate index of crown glass , and -100 inches as the compound focus ; for then the first refraction will make the rays converge to 300 inches , the second refraction to 200 inches , the third to 150 inches , and the fourth to 100 inches .
If however I had to repeat the experiment , I should prefer making all the refractions at the first three surfaces , by causing the light to fall perpendicularly on the last , as in that case the passage of the rays , after entering the second lens , to the focus , would 4 ( employing the first of the above principles , ) be made in precisely the same way as in an uniform cylinder of glass , as in Mr. CODDINGTON'S microscope ; with the exception of the slight refraction they would sustain in passing through the fluid , which must necessarily be very inconsiderable , as its negative focal length is more than six hundred inches .
Moreover , besides this advantage , which may be perhaps rather apparent than real , this form would have given less spherical aberration , and consequently the curvature of the fluid might have been still further reduced , which is at all events a real advantage , but it did not occur to me till I had proceeded too far to make any alteration .
It will be seen from what has now been stated , that the conditions I proposed to myself were : 1st , That the front lens should be composed of two plano-convex lenses of equal focal length .
2ndly , That the curvatures of the fluid shells should be such that the mean rays , after leaving the front lens , should fall perpendicularly on the first surface .
3rdly , That the corrections for colour and aberration should be effected in the passage of the rays through the fluid .
4thly , That they should then impinge perpendicularly on the fourth surface , and be thence transmitted aplanatic to the focus .
Now it may be observed , that as far as relates to establishing the equations of condition , these will be the same as if the rays were refracted at each surface of the fluid lens from , and into , air ; and as this method of considering the subject will throw some facilities into the investigation , it is adopted in what follows ; but it is impossible not to believe that the practical effect must be very different in the two cases , seeing that in one the ray would have to sustain six considerable refractions , correcting each other by their positive and negative effects , while in the other there are only two inconsiderable refractions , equal to the difference .
Having thus settled the general principle of construction , the next step was to determine the dispersive ratio between the fluid and crown glass , these two media having never before to my knowledge been brought into optical combination .
This was done by applying a crown lens to the dispersive instrument , described in the Phil. Trans. for 1827 , p. 235 ; and as a proof of the 5 accuracy of that method , it may be stated , that the calculations founded on the numbers thus obtained , answered most accurately to the focal length intended , and that the corrections for colour and spherical aberration were boti as nearly perfect as is perhaps ever to be expected .
The numbers found as above , were Index of sulphuret of carbon ... + a'= 16343 ---crown glass ... ... 1 -a = 1'5396 Dispersive ratio 1 : 3333 .
With these data and conditions we must now proceed to determine the radi ' of curvature of the lenses , by establishing and solving the following equations .
Let nf = the focal length of the compound front lens .
f= the part of that focus which falls beyond the fluid lens ; and consequently , according to our condition , f= also the radius of curvature of the front surface of the first fluid shell .
= the sum of the reciprocals of the radii of curvature of the interior surfaces of the two shells , and consequently also of the fluid .
y= the distance of the back surface of the second fluid shell from the focus ; and consequently also , by our condition , y= the radius of the concave curvature of the back surface , 1+a the index of crown glass .
1+ a ' the index of the fluid ; and a'-a a " .
Then it is obvious we must have , ( 1x)I a , 1I 1+a 1.+a a " or --J ' y~ a'lfy whence x(a .
a ... ... . .
( 1 ) This equation has reference only to focus .
We must now provide for achrormatism , and for this purpose must determine the dispersive power of all the crown lens , considered as a simple lens , situate in the place of the fluid .
6 To effect this , Let = the absolute dispersive power of crown glass .
n the dispersive power of the front compound lens , as referred to its remaining focus at the place of the fluid lens .
f ?
= the focal length of the shells of the fluid lens .
Then ( j + -y a f. ' . ?
o jy..\ ... ... ... .
or ~ay2af/ ( y-x).*.** ... ( 2 ) Now the dispersive power of these combined lenses , with that of the front lenses , reckoned from the place of the fluid , will be ( denoting that power by " l ) + ?
S ft st ( See Journal of the Royal Institution , N(o .
IV .
p. 6 .
) And to produce achromatism ( remembering that -r = focal length of the fluid , and = the combined length of all the crown lenses , ) we must have ( calling " Y ' the dispersive power of the fluid ) , to produce achromatism , fjo 'x ffA0 .
f , .
= r. Or substituting for Y ' its value as above found , and writing m6 for " ' , ( m being the dispersive ratio between crown glass and the fluid , ) we have 0ff ?
x. + nf ?
f+fo .
a f. Jf ? .
m which when reduced gives 0~ ffx f ma'fy-nx ... .
( 3 ) from which three equations , the values of x and y may be determined .
That is , we first find _(m a'a ) ( 1 + a)fa a"f ay ( ma'a)(i a ) ( + n)a w and then x is readily determined by means of equations ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) .
7 In this expression for y ; m , a , a ' , a " are given quantities , but n is assumable at pleasure , within all practicable limits .
In my former construction I found the rationality of the spectrum best preserved when n was taken = 2 , and taking it so in the present instance with the proper value of the other quantities , viz. a= -540 , a ' = -634 , a " = -094 , and m= 3'333 , we have 1-573 x P1540.05076 Y 1-573 X 1-540 '*2387( f= 1'086f , consequently 2'086f =1 the whole length .
Hence any length whatever being assumed for a proposed telescope , or any value off , all the other quantities may be immediately found .
It is also quite indifferent what length is assumed , as all the other quantities will be proportional .
Assuming then a length 1= 150 inches , we have 150 f-= 086 = 71-9 inches y= 1086f/ 78-1 inches , and nf = 143-8 inches , the combined focus of the front lens , and equation ( 1 ) x= 55'3 inches , or x =55.3 = the sum of the reciprocals of the radii of the interior surfaces of the fluid shells , or of the fluid itself , considered as negative .
If therefore in the particular case in question we denote the radii of the several curvatures of the fluid shells by r , r ' , r " , r " ' , we shall have r= 71-9 , r"'== -78-1 , and 111rT r " ',55'3 and the whole focal length of the two combined front lenses = 143'8 inches .
Thus far then we have provided for focal length and achromatism , and have still r ' and r " undetermined , but which must now be found from these conditions ; viz. so that 111 and that the spherical aberration at these surfaces may correct that of the 8 front lenses , the radii of whose surfaces might also be left undetermined , we having at present only considered their focal length .
It is proposed , however , that in this case these lenses shall be both equal plano-convex , which limits their radii , these being found one hundred and fifty-five inches .
The formula I employ for this determination is that given in Phil. Trans. for 1827 , p. 247 , observing only , that what is there denoted by d , which is the dispersive ratio , or the ratio of the focal length of the two lenses , must here be modified , in consequence of the lenses not being in contact , and the aberration being produced in the passage of the rays through the fluid , from glass to glass , that is , the effective index is on this account found by the proportion 1'540 : 1-634 : : 1 : 1061 we must therefore consider a ' = 061 and the effective focal length of the fluid == 906'6 inches =f ' .
Referring now to the original formula above quoted , and putting C to denote the first factor , we shall find that the real equation is a !
'ty p , ' Cx ( + )a ( qt f1- ) Za which , in the common form , as y ' = y , and = d , becomes da Cx q-t=p But in our case y ' = y ; and our formula therefore is fa CX 4f ( q ? ?
1 ) consequent d - , = -0398 .
In the calculation for correcting aberration , we must therefore take p and d as above , a=,540 , d= 061 , and then proceed exactly as in common cases , except that in this instance , as it is proposed to form the front lens of two planoconvex lenses , we must find the amount of aberration for such a combination , and then determine the ratio r ' : r " that shall produce in the fluid such amount of aberration as may correct that of the front lens ; whereas , in the usual case , we first find the aberration of the concave lens , and adjust the front lens accordingly .
By the latter method there is only required the solution of a qua dratic equation , whereas , in reversing the operation , as here proposed , we arrive at a very intricate equation of difficult solution .
Instead therefore of attempting a direct process by leaving the ratio ?
=q indeterminate , it will be best to proceed by the method of position , which , though less elegant , is much more simple and expeditious .
First , then , let us compute the amount of spherical aberration for parallel rays produced by two plano-convex lenses , the convex side of each being turned towards the object .
The aberration of a single convex lens , convex in front , whose focus isf and diameter 2 y , is a ' .
, as +1y aberration a ( a +aX ea ( a 1+ !
'0 1a a y2 which , when a= 540 , becomes and since the focus of the combined lenses is 143'8 inches , that of this single lens isf = 287'8 inches , and 87-8 155 inches = radius of the front surface .
At the second lens , therefore , the rays are converging to a distance d= 287'6 ; and this lens being equal to the former , its radius r= 155'*3 r ' being infinite , and it remains to determine its aberration .
d -87-6 Calling r= 1,553 = -1'85 , and ad b==-35 a+ -1 the formula for the aberration ( Phil. Trans. for 1827 , p. 243 , ) becomes a ( m + 1 ) m+a+ Q2 1 ( amI)X ( a+ l)m XT b^ , b Jf +T 1 ( b61 ) x1i424r J which in numbers gives , .
f5Q9ye aberration of the second lens only .
We have already found in the first lens , aberration 10 ]012 , y ' = --f ' ; but this is reduced by the second lens to one fourth its amount , or , l25531 y2..,1593/ -4079lt to , whence the aberration of the combined lenses is 9 or nf denoting the compound focus -= f , according to our first notation .
And it remains to find such a ratio of r ' : r " or such a value of s= q ' as shall produce the aberration in question .
The formulae for the calculation of this aberration with any given value of q ' already referred to in the Phil. Trans. are , f , ,a * c= ^ ( a ' + l)f " ba and then r"~~a f"r/ a +I ( c + q/ ) c+ ( a ' +2 ) 1 v , y. x ' ( b + I ) xcJ in this equation p= -4079 , a= *540 , a= 061 , f " =y = 78 , and d= 0398 , -"= q ' being at present undetermined , but which is now to be assumed so as to give an approximate value to p. A few simple trials will show that the value of c ' must be about 3 .
Assuming then q'= 3 , we have r " -=f a ' ( q'+ 1 ) = 1106 r =f a ( q ' f)= 37 of and as we already know r= 72 , and r " ' -78 ( taking only their nearest integral values , ) we find by substitution in the preceding formula , p= 4211 instead of p= '4079 .
Take therefore q= 3 ?
, then r " = 129 , and r ' 38'7 which , by substitution , gives p= 3930 .
It is clear therefore that the value of q lies between the limits -3 and 3-333 , and it will be observed that these values of p , vary principally as the factor varies ; and treating the subject upon the common arithmetical principle of position , we find q= 14565 , or q'= 3'2 very nearly .
This value of q gives r"=f'a ' ( q'+ 1 ) = 121-5 inches r ' =f ' a ' ( = -38 inches .
We have now therefore all the numbers answering to a total length of 150 inches , viz. I= 150 inches whole length , r= 72 inches first surface of fluid shell , r ' = 38 inches second surface , r"= 121'5 = third surface , r"= 78 inches fourth surface , R= 155'3 inches convex surface of front lens , A= 72 inches distance of the lenses .
And it is only necessary for any proposed lengths to use these proportions .
On consulting with Mr. DOLLOND , I found that to have confined myself to eight feet length , two or three new tools would have been necessary , but by taking 1== 105 inches , he had only occasion for one .
I therefore adopted that length ; for although Mr. DOLLOND was very desirous of working out my nuinbers to any acculracy I wished , I had no desire to urge this point to an unnecessary degree of refinement , particularly as the nature of the construction always admits of producing chromatic correction to any degree of precision .
I have already stated that the lenses worked according to these proportions , when placed in their respective cells , agreed in every respect with the computed results , as well in focus as in chromatic and spherical correction .
These remarks , it will be observed , apply to the arrangement of the fluid lens according to the first principle , in which the corrections are all made in the passage of the light through the fluid , and by the fluid only .
By reversing this lens we have a telescope on the second principle , in which the correcting power of the fluid for spherical aberration is a minimum , or at least very small 12 in comparison with that of the glass in which it is enclosed ; and on trial it was found , I must admit contrary to my expectation , that the performance of the telescope was better with the lens in this position than in the former ; the difference however is but little , and this little has reference only to figure ; I therefore am rather inclined to attribute this preference to some accidental better adaptation of the glasses to each other when in this position than to any actual theoretical advantage .
In both cases the spherical aberration is equally well corrected , there being no perceptible change of focus , whether we employ the whole aperture or the central four inches , or a simple ring of an inch of light round the margin of the lens .
In each of these three cases I have repeatedly seen the small star in Rigel without the slightest change of focus .
For the rest it is not my intention to offer any remarks on the performance of the telescope , as I conceive this will be best reported upon by the committee , after they have submitted it to such tests as may be judged most proper for determining its defining and penetrating power .
It only therefore remains for me to state , that I feel much indebted to Mr. DOLLOND for the readiness with which he has complied with all my suggestions , and for the accuracy with which he has executed every part of the instrument .
P.S. Since this paper was written , Mr. DOLLOND has reworked one of the surfaces , and there is now no question that the preference in the performance is decidedly with the fluid lens in its first position .
13 An Account of the Construction of a Fluid Lens Refracting Telescope of eight inches aperture , and eight feet and three quarters in length , made for the Royal Society by GEORGE DOLLOND , Esq. F.R.S. By PETER BARLOW , Esq. F.KRS .
F.R.A.S. M.C.P.S. Cor. Mem. Inst. France , 8$c .
Read November 22 , 1832 .
IN my former papers on the construction and performance of fluid refracting telescopes with open lenses , I have pointed out the great variety of cases included in the general formula , which have since been increased by the ingenious construction of Mr. ROGERS , and have referred to the difficulty of carrying one 's mind through all their intricacy , so as to select , independently of experiment , from amongst the several cases , that which would produce the best result .
The form I gave to my original construction was founded principally upon the idea of lengthening the focus beyond the length of the tube , and as far as that object was concerned , the result was perfectly satisfactory ; but , as I have stated in my description of that instrument , it was found , as this principle was extended , that the perfect part of the field became more contracted , so as to render it questionable at what point to stop , to produce upon the whole the best effect .
Other considerations also presented themselves , and I wished therefore to have the means of making certain preliminary experiments , with a view to the determination of a few such practical points , before selecting out of the multiplicity of arrangements ( all theoretically true , ) that which should be adopted in the construction of so large a telescope as that which I ventured to propose in my last paper , Phil. Trans. for 1831 .
The advantage , if not the absolute necessity , of such experiments in a novel case of this kind must be obvious to every one who has had any experience in practical optics , where having several objects to fulfil , interfering more or less with each other , it is only by experiment it can be ascertained how far an advantage can be pushed on one side without making too great a sacrifice on another ; and such experiments are too expensive to be conveniently carried on by a private individual who has no other object in their success than the advancement of optical and astronomical science .
The Council of the Royal Society therefore appointed a committee to report upon my former paper , who were of opinion that it would be advisable to proceed at once to the construction of an eight-inch telescope for the Royal Society , the success of which might decide the question of proceeding upon the scale I had proposed .
They accordingly ordered a telescope of the above dimensions of Mr. DOLLOND , leaving to me the arrangements relative to curvatures , focal length , &amp;c. After due consideration , I determined on the adoption of a form and principle of construction which I thought likely to embrace the most advantages , and I am in hopes the result will not be considered unsatisfactory , although I have in the progress of the construction seen one or two changes which , in a future case , might be advantageously adopted .
The aperture of the telescope is eight inches clear glass , and focal length eight feet and three quarters .
The spherical aberration is perfectly corrected , the field is open and flat , with abundance of light , -all very desirable qualities in an astronomical telescope ; with respect to colour , there is perhaps more outstanding on the violet side of the spectrum , than is generally found in the usual refractor , particularly towards the limits of the field .
I estimate the extent of the field by the product of the minutes it contains , multiplied by the power , and I find this product with my four powers , varying from 100 to 450 , ranges between 3000 and 3450 , which rather exceeds perhaps the usual fields of refractors ; at all events there is a great improvement in this respect as compared with my former instrument .
As to the length , although I am unwilling to think that upon the whole the telescope is too short , yet it must be admitted that where minute definition is wanted , an advantage is gained by contracting the aperture , but the whole is certainly available for bringing to light very small stars ; and probably more 2 distinctness with the whole aperture might be derived from a little increase in the aperture of the fluid lens .
Having made these few general remarks , I shall endeavour to explain the reasons which induced me to select the particular case I have done , and the principles on which I have established the equations of condition .
In my former paper I have explained my reason for using a double instead of a single front lens .
It moreover occurred to me , that altlough the chromatic dispersion of a lens of any medium , or the coloured part of its focus , bears a fixed ratio to its nean focal length , this is not the case at the first immersion of a ray and during its progress in the medium itself , a remark I do not remember to have seen made by any optical writer .
Also , as the dispersion of a lens depends upon the relative indices of the extreme and mean rays of the spectrum , this will vary according to the medium from which a lens receives and into which it transmits those rays , so that the dispersion of the fluid will be much greater receiving and transmitting rays into glass than into air .
To take advantage of this circumstance I resolved to make all the correction for colour and aberration in the passage of the rays from one fluid shell to the other , by causing the mean rays from the front compound lens to impinge perpendicularly on the first surface of the fluid shell , and again perpendicularly on the fourth surface , and thereby , of course , preventing any further chromatic development .
By this arrangement , the dispersion or coloured part of the focus of the front compound lens is reduced on entering the first shell of the fluid lens , in the ratio of about 3 to 2 , while that of the fluid is so much increased , that the dispersive ratio of the two during the passage of the ray through them is reduced to *08 , whereas , in the usual refractor , it is .
about *60 or *65 ; the dispersive ratio is therefore only about one eighth of its usual amount , and the spherical aberration is also reduced by the nature of the construction in about the same proportion , that is , to about one third , in consequence of the double front lens , and to about one third again by the focus being nearly three times as long as that of the crown lens of the usual refractor .
There was only one doubtful point connected with , this form , which was , that as in providing for the correction of the spherical aberration we can only effect this for one index ( generally the mean ) , the aberration of the extreme B2 3

