S'ome Remarks on an Error respecting the Site and Origin of Grahanz Island .
By Captain W. H. SMYTH , R.N. F.R.S. F.S.A. Read February 9 , 1832 .
IN consequence of accounts recently published concerning the rise and progress of this island , which I conceive to have been stated materially in error , and in order that physical inquiry may receive as exact data as can be afforded , I beg leave to offer the following remarks to the Royal Society .
It was stated , in the first letters which arrived from Malta , that an officer on the Mediterranean station was in possession of an old chart , whereon was " a shoal with only four fathoms on it , and called Larmour 's Breakers ; " -and this being asserted to be " within a mile of the latitude and longitude " of the new island , was consequently announced as its nucleus .
On reading some of these letters I saw at once that the chart was mistaken for a valuable document ; but being aware that its particulars were well known to navigators , I should not have deemed it to require notice , had not the erroneous inference been repeated , both in the Journal of the Geographical Society , and in the Quarterly Review .
The danger alluded to as existing , upon the " old chart " , was never ascertained or verified ; it was only thought to have been seen , by Captain LARMOUR , when in command of the Wassanaer , a troop-ship , on the Egyptian expedition .
But the same impression did not strike all the officers and passengers ; and on , the commander-in-chief dispatching two or three vessels to examine it for a more detailed report , no shoal-water could be found .
The present Captain RICHARD SPENCER , C.B. , then a lieutenant on board the Wassanaer , was one of the officers sent to assist in the search ; and from him I had these particulars .
Yet the minute which had been forwarded to me from the Admiralty , being written in these decided terms2L2 Ship Wassanaer , 11th of December 1800 , P. M. The island of Pantellaria S.W. by W. 9 or 10 leagues , saw a reef of rocks S.S.E. , distant 3 or 4 miles , extending N.N.W. and S.S.E. , about one mile in length .
Hauled up S. by W. , to clear them .
Saw something on the reef like a ship 's mast .
Bearings by compass."I examined the spot with a rigorous strictness , ( see Plate VII .
) ; and from the various traverses which I made in every direction , with the lead going by night and by day , I feel prepared to assert that , no reef of the nature described by Captain LARMOUR in 1800 , and no shoal of four fathoms water , could have existed in 1814 .
How the said " four fathoms " crept into our charts , is best known to the ship-chandlers who too long purveyed to the scientific wants of seamen ; but from the absence of positive testimony , from the careful search made by order of Lord KEITH , from my own several cruises , and from the material fact of its being in the high road which is annually beaten by hundreds of ships , it is not presuming greatly to say , that neither the one nor the other had any existence .
Nor is the assigned place " within a mile " of the position of the volcanic islet , though it may accidentally have been so marked upon the " sea-cards ; " for it should be remembered that the true site even of the principal headlands around was not then decided .
According to the minute just quoted , corrected for magnetic variation , LARMOUI'S supposed reef is no less than sixteen miles W. by N. from it , on a part of the sub-aqueous plateau ( which I named Adventure Bank ) uniting Sicily to Africa by a succession of ridges , -about a spot where I found from 40 to 50 fathoms of water .
Graham 's Isle , however , is not upon this bank ; it arose between it and a knoll some miles to the eastward , which , from a shell brought up by the arming , I called Nerita ; and , if the observations which determine the latitude and longitude of the stranger as in 37 ?
08 ' 25 " N. and 12 ? ?
43 ' 50 " E. be correct , it must have been elevated through more than a hundred fathoms of water .
In thus doubting the actual existence of the Larmour Shoal , it is not my intention to dispute the appearance and disappearance of natural phenomena ; nor that stupendous alterations may occur by the subsidence and uplifting of strata , -because an obstinate scepticism would be absurd , especially in a part of the globe where , to use a well-expressed Italian metaphor , the whole ground 256 lz a ; fk 4i +a*fkt tw .
R^^..t aS r3$ +^ 4 .
0 ; 5 i_tAt ' - &gt; L ' Xg0 ^"*^~ " ^ N. 1 5I f^ j ^-s ' Ini 5+'. . ? ? ?
?. .
a ; -L-~~-~..I~~1-1__ ___N-1 N. .
N~ ; N % ' , N ' , , , S| z*/ ^ I\R " ; n --stw h. , .
~ ... ... ... ... .** ... ... . . ?
I Nrs I " S-S " a~~~~~ , i L. * , I1 ri , .
" " " " " -- .
, ,""'- " " ' '** ' ... , ... ... * " " ..^ st A\ , t\t\ " " 1z tR t 9..- " ' E^a N~~~~~ ?
N^^ I ?
~.i'/ " " / ^.N N ?
' ' ?
's " ?
N N ?
I -IS .
O -1^ *1 ?
l^^ .
^N N'y]l N IC3 ?
ic ' " ' h~N~ S s~~~~~ ts N * , %N N " NN ' N. * .
7777777~ N~~~~~~~~t N N~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~z N lc8 i ; *1 Ui 'N.*** ** is -"tremblingly alive .
" But it is reasonable and proper to question such rumours as have been made without due examination .
In the instance before us , no endeavour was made to establish the truth by either shortening sail , lowering a boat , or even getting a cast of the lead ; moreover , they were three or four miles from the supposed object , and opinions on board the Wassanaer were not at all unanimous .
By similar indecision a teasing knot of perils has gained randomt insertion upon our charts , to the disquietude of sea comnianders ; but it is a fault which is fast disappearing , and it may be trusted that there are few officers who would not think themselves liable to the imputation of culpable carelessness , did they not seek to verify such ' " dangers " as they might accidentally encounter .
I do not think sub-aqueous volcanic explosions are of such rare occurrence as is generally supposed ; and extremely sudden intumescence may arise from the expansion of an inferior lava bed .
It is not at all improbable that gaseous fluids , and ejectamenta , may have been seen , before the accumulation of solid matter , protruded from the vent , was sufficient to form a crater of eruption .
A volcanic apex may become visible , and again be quickly destroyed by trituration , the solution of mineral substances , and the repressive force of the column of water over the vent .
Now , as there was a chance that something of the kind had occurred in the neighbourhood assigned to Larmour 's reef , breakers having been reported near the same spot by the Greyhound frigate , and shoals having been immemorially marked there under the names of La Ajuga , and B. Scoglio , -I laboriously explored the whole vicinity .
In examining the chart which resulted from this undertaking , it will be found that a knoll , with only seven fathoms upon it , was discovered not far from the site of all these reports , and that the Adventure Bank extends from Sicily nearly to Pantellaria , where the water deepens at once from 76 fathoms to no bottom with 375 fathoms of line .
A further inspection will show that the Phlegraean islands of Pantellaria and Linosa have been protruded from the greatest depths , where perhaps the fires found the least resistance .
All these considerations led me to suppose that though the reports were exceedingly vague , volcanic agency might still have given grounds for them .
I therefore made particular inquiries , both in Sicily and Pantellaria , as to local earthquakes , and whether any volumes of smoke , ferilli or jets of flame , 257 comminuted ashes , or other fragmentary ejectments , had been noticed in that direction ; but I could hear of none .
Yet we are told , as a " fact " of weight , that a tradition is current , which says , " A volcano existed in the same spot about the commencement of the last century .
" It would be difficult to say how this tradition was preserved amongst a people little given to letters ; and I never , in my long residence and systematic researches at the above place , and in Malta , heard the slightest hint of it .
I am therefore led to the conclusion , -firstly , that no shoal or danger has lately existed in that channel , excepting only an occasional overfall in very heavy weather on the 7 fathom knoll where I anchored H. M. ship Adventure , and which is sufficiently near for bearings taken at random , and without suspicion of the existence of local attraction , to be placed in identity with the reports above mentioned .
Secondly , that even if what Captain LARMOUR became persuaded he saw , was actually a temporary volcanic effect , it had no possible relation to breakers with " four fathoms " upon them .
And it follows , that the assertion of Graham Island having been formed by the mere " lifting up " of such shoal , must be utterly destitute of foundation .

