_. .
= _I _I '"g'a z ?
z'T ; r~~-W\-=='''~~~~r`=~=~L--I 7 lr j , / I AT~ I2I _P _ *^/ ^ ^_/ i._l f ... ... . .
i. I : ___..__. .
FV I L__ !
~ L'- ?
xlN'lX ; 27r / IXXXDo9 ( N / 'Z'Zt/ z/ v -r-7 --- : : 7 , 9E *I I ll [ 50 ] XXVIII .
On the power of masses of Iron to control the Attractive Force of a Magnet .
By WILLIAM SNOW HARRIS , Esq. F.R.S. Read June 16,18,31 .
1 .
IT may not be unfavourable to the further elucidation of the interesting subject of screens , treated of in my last paper , and which I had the honour of laying before the Royal Society , to give a short account of some subsequent experiments concerning the effects of masses of iron on a magnet , as they have more particularly arisen out of the investigation above alluded to .
2 .
The principal part of the apparatus which I employed in these experiments is represented in Plate XIV .
, fig. 1 &amp; 2 ; it is extremely simple , and will be readily understood by the following description of it .
A light beam of dry clean-grained deal , of about fourteen inches in length , and somewhat less than a quarter of an inch square , is allowed to rest freely , by means of a delicate axis , on two horizontal bars of glass ; the glass bars are secured on a convenient frame and stand , and the axis of the beam , as in many similar cases , is formed of a fine sewing-needle it was passed in this case through the opposite angles , directly at the centre .
From the extremity of one of the arms is suspended a small cylindrical piece of iron , about an inch and a half long and one fifth of an inch diameter , which is counterpoised by an equivalent weight , placed in a small pan suspended from the other ; the method of suspension is by light hooks and rings , so as to obtain every possible degree of motion .
The under part of the centre of the beam carries an index of about a foot in length , constructed of short pieces of straw , which , being tubular , are easily secured at their extremities one within the other ; an index thus formed is very straight and true .
By means of this index and a graduated arc the slightest motion of the beam is apparent .
3 .
The beam and index may be so managed , that for a short distance the deviations from the horizontal position , with equal and very small sweights placed in the pan , will correspond to equal divisions on the are , or very nearly so .
To regulate the distance between a magnet or other bodies , and the suspended iron , when placed immediately under the latter , either vertically or horizontally , I employed a simple screw and nut , attached to a brass frame similar to that shown in Fig. 2 : thus any required altitude could be obtained , the distance between the magnet and the suspended iron being estimated by a graduated scale resting on the magnet .
5 .
Wherever magnetic attraction is exerted between two bodies , it seems to be accompanied by a sort of neutralization of the same force in respect of a third substance .
( a ) .
Thus if the magnet A , Fig. 1 , be attracting the suspended iron b , the vicinity of a mass of iron C will diminish the apparent force of A upon b : if , therefore , when the force of A upon b is exerted so as just to depress the beam , the force being measured by the inclination of the index ( 3 ) , we place a mass of iron C close to A , the beam will immediately tend to recover its previous position .
( b ) .
This power of the iron C to control the attractive force of the magnet upon b , seems only to extend to a given point within the magnet , the distance between the magnet and iron remaining the same ; for if the small iron b be suspended over a point at some distance from the extremity , as at w , then the action of C will not be felt at that point w , except by decreasing the distance between the iron and magnet , or otherwise by increasing the neutralizing power of the iron C. 6 .
That this depends on a sort of action which is not inappropriately termed a neutralization of force , in regard to the suspended iron b , is evident from the following experiments .
( c ) .
The mass of iron C may be placed immediately below A , as in Fig. 3 , the effect will be the most apparent when the thickness of A is not considerable ; but if the magnet A be very thick , then the neutralizing effect of C is not so evident , on account of the intervening mass of which the magnet is composed , as also on account of the iron C being kept as it were at a greater distance from the immediate surface of attraction .
( d ) .
Conversely , the mass of iron C may be placed above , immediately between b and A as in Fig. 4 ; but in this case we have to take into account the inductive effect on C , by which it becomes itself a temporary magnet , and consequently takes on an attractive power ; the experiment should therefore be so managed as to have the distance between C and b such , that whilst by the intervention of C the action of A is neutralized , its induced magnetic state does not become sensible upon b at that distance ; this will be always very evident when C is of some considerable thickness , and the previous distance of A and b taken just within the limit of the attraction .
7 .
In this case C is said to screen or stop out the attraction of A upon b , and this probably explains the way in which screens operate in impeding the magnetic influence .
It seems therefore not unreasonable to infer , that substances , possessing the greatest inductive energy , are at the same time the most powerful neutralizers .
Hence in employing various bodies as screens , those are the most efficient which are susceptible of the greatest transient magnetic state : thus zinc is more efficient than lead ; copper more efficient than zinc ; silver than copper , and iron the most efficient of any .
8 .
As the distance within the magnet , to which the neutralizing force can extend , must necessarily depend on the magnetic energy of the substance employed , it would be difficult with non-ferruginous bodies to control any very sensible portion of the action of a magnet by placing them at its extremity , Fig. 1 , or beneath it , Fig. 3 , except in the latter case we suppose the magnet to be extremely thin ; but by intervening a considerable mass , Fig. 4 , immediately between the magnet and the substance acted on , we operate directly on the contiguous attracting surface of the bar , and thus the neutralizing effect at length becomes sensible .
9 .
The attractive force exerted between a magnet and a mass of iron is in the direct ratio of this neutralizing power of the iron ; the distance between the magnet and the iron being the same .
( e ) .
Let a magnet A , Fig. 5 , of about ten inches in length , and three eighths of an inch square , be placed at some convenient distance , immediately under the suspended iron b , and the observed force carefully counterpoised by small weights placed in the opposite pan at p , so as to bring the index of the beam , Fig. 1 , to zero of the graduated arc ; then the neutralizing power of a few small pieces of very soft iron , w , x , y , z , about the same diameter as the magnet , and varying from a quarter of an inch to two inches in length , may be easily estimated on the graduated arc , Fig. 1 , by bringing each piece successively in contact , or very nearly so , with the extremity of the magnet a ( 3 ) .
Let these small iron cylinders be now substituted in succession for the suspended iron b ; and being first nicely counterpoised , let the attractive forces be determined at a constant distance from the magnet A by means of the graduated scale s ; then these respective forces will be found to be very nearly in the same ratio as the previous powers of neutralization : in a great variety of cases they were found to be exactly in the same ratio .
( f ) .
Where the neutralizing power is equal , there the attractive force is also equal ; thus the neutralizing power , with a given magnet , not being greater in a cylindrical mass of iron of two inches in length than in one of an inch and half in length , no difference was subsequently found in the respective forces of attraction .
10 .
The foregoing illustrations seem to throw some light on the manner in which magnetic action may be supposed to pervade bodies .
( g ) .
Having assigned any given distance , A b , Fig. 6 , through which we know the influence of a magnet A can extend as estimated by some sensible measure b , then in interposing a third substance C in the space A b , the latter may receive a temporary magnetic state in two ways , either by the immediate action of the magnet A upon every particle of C , or otherwise by the propagation of magnetism from particle to particle , or by both : now these operations seem to be in some inverse ratio of each other ; thus when the induced magnetic energy in C is considerable , the influence of the magnet A is more or less arrested by the laminwe first acted on , which operate as screens on the succeeding ones ; so that the magnetic development after a certain distance proceeds entirely by propagation from one particle to another , until it is finally as it were expended ; and a body b which was before attracted at the distance Ab will at the same distance now remain at rest c. Such is the case in interposing a screen of iron between a revolving magnet and a metallic disc ; but if the body C be low in the scale of magnetic energy , then the induced magnetic state is so weak that little or no screening influence is exerted between its particles , and the body b may be attracted as before : hence , each particle of C will owe its magnetic development to the direct operation of the exciting magnet ; and it is only by the successive action of a great number of particles that we at length neutralize or cut off the magnetic force by means of sucha substance employed as a 504 screen : it therefore follows in this instance , that whilst an inconsiderable portion of the magnetic action is neutralized , a considerable mass of the screen is pervaded ; at the same time a very thin stratum only of the magnet is penetrated b ( 8 ) .
11 .
The diminished influence of a magnet on a metallic disc , observed to ensue on intersecting the surface of the disc by radiating grooves varying in depth * , may possibly depend on the above-mentioned circumstance ( 10 ) for in this case we actually take away a portion of the substance in which the magnetic development takes place , and thus diminish the force .
I wish , however , to be understood as speaking with some degree of reserve on this point , although the conclusion is by no means unwarranted , as in the following experiment .
( h ) .
The number of vibrations of a delicately suspended bar in a given arc taken in vacuo , in two similar rings of copper of equal weights and quality as nearly as may be , did not materially differ , althoiugh one of the rings was made up of separate concentric larninm , the other being a perfectly solid mass ; whereas the removal of a very thin lamina externally from the former caused a very decided change in the number of the vibrations of the bar + .
12 .
The preceding inquiries appear calculated to modify in some measure our views concerning the operation of a magnet , which by experiment ( e ) is rather the patient than the agent in the production of the observed effects : it cannot therefore be considered as a purely active force , much less can it be viewed as a substance , from which emanations of an unknown subtle fluid are constantly proceeding ; for it may be shown , Exp. ( c ) , that a magnetic lamina of steel , supposed without sensible thickness , cannot act at the same time on two masses of iron , in every respect alike , when placed between them , and at an equal distance from each ; as in this case we should have an annihilation of power as regards the magnet : hence each mass of iron , if at the same time drawn by some other force , and free to move , would drop away from the magnetized steel in opposite directions .
If therefore the attractive energy of a magnet be supposed to arise out of any subtle principle emanating from it , such emanations cannot pass off in opposite directions at the same instant : now there is no sufficient reason why they should pass rather in one direction than another , and it therefore remains that an hypothesis which supposes them to pass in either , is quite unwarranted .
The arrangement assumed by fine particles of iron , sifted on paper immediately over a magnet , arises out of the circumstance that the bar has generally a very sensible thickness ; vlwhilst the small particles of iron cannot operate beyond a certain distance a , b , c , and this equally applies to other cases in which the opposite sides of a magnet appear to attract at the same time .
Moreover , the superficial boundaries of a magnet may be considered as so many distinct magnetic laminae of uncertain thickness , as is evident from the circumstance , that the magnetic centre and poles of one surface of a bar very frequently fall in a different way from those of another surface according to the trifling variations in the progress of magnetizing ; and sometimes all the surfaces differ in this respect in the same bar , that is to say , the centre and poles do not correspond to the same relative points on any two sides .
13 .
The wonderful phanomenon of magnetic attraction then is evidently the result of an impression first made on the magnet e , since with different masses of iron the attractive force at the same distance is unequal e : hence a magnet must be considered as a body in a peculiar state or condition , by which it Inay be caused to exhibit given powers or capabilities in consequence of external excitation .
15 .
It is always difficult in inquiries of this nature to employ terms which shall seem altogether without objection .
I trust therefore that those resorted to in the course of this paper , will be taken only in the arbitrary sense in which they have been used , and not as having any necessary connection with a particular set of opinions : thus the expressions neutralizing force , magnetic development , magnetic excitation , and so on , must be taken merely as arbitrary terms , employed of necessity to facilitate the progress of inquiry , and to render its description as intelligible as possible , according to the general and unembarrassed acceptance of such terms .

