On the extensive Atmosphere of Mars .
By Sir JAMES SOUTH , F.R.S. Communicated by His Royal Highness the President .
Read June 16 , 1831 .
THAT several of the planets as well as that which we inhabit are surrounded by atmosphere , astronomical observations have long since established ; the extent , however , to which in particular planets such atmospheres are diffused , is as yet not satisfactorily determined .
The former rests principally upon phenomena observed on the planets ' discs , whilst the latter derives its support chiefly from those detected at or near their respective limbs .
Every night , nay almost every hour , may give us indication of the one , whilst years are sonietimes necessary , as in the case of planets unattended by satellites , to help us to the other ; thus the hypothesis of the extensive atmosphere of Mars derives its origin from the observations of CASSINI and ROEMER , and has stood more than a century and a half without refutation or support .
The observations to which I allude formed part of a series undertaken for the determination of the parallax of Mars , and are recorded in the M6moires de l'Acad6mie des Sciences .
CASSINI'S were made at Briare and at La Charit6 sir Loire ; whilst ROEMER'S was obtained at the Royal Observatory of Paris .
Of the Briare observation CASSINI says , " Le premier Octobre 1672 a 2h 45111 du matin a Briare , Mars vu par un lunette de trois pieds , sembloit toucher par son board septentrional , la ligne droite tirde par la premiere et par la second de l'eau d'Aquarius marquee 4 , d'oh il n'6toit plus eloign6 que de six minutes .
Cette 6toile paroissoit si diminu6e et si affoiblie de lumiere , qu'on no la pouvoit plus distinguer ni a la vue simple , ni par un lunette un peu plus foible."Mem .
de l'Acad .
tome vii .
p. 357 .
The La Charit6 and Paris observations entitled " Eclipse de la Moyenne ?
dans l'eau d'Aquarius " are thus narrated : " Quoique le ciel fut alors assez beau de part et d'autre , et que l'on vit Mars pendant un assez long espace de temps , on no vit point l'etoile moyenne 4 , qui devoit etre cachde par son disque .
Le diametre de Mars 6toit alors de 25 secondes.-Mem .
de l'Acad .
tom .
vii .
p. 358 .
" Les nuages qui survinrent no permirent pas d'en voir la sortie ; et l'on no sgait pas mneme si on l'auroit pu voir immediatement , car trois quarts d'heure apres le ciel s'tant decouvert a Paris , M. ROEMER la chercha attentivement autour de Mars , et il no la trouva qu'apres l'attention de deux minutes , quand elle 6toit d6ja eloignee bu board oriental de Mars de deux tiers de son diamntre .
C ' &amp; toit alors ll1h 15"1 , et le parallele de l'Ptoile coupoit le diarnetre de Mars en raison de 2a 3 .
I1 commenqa de la voir sans difficult6 , quand elle 6toit eloign6e de Mars de trois quarts de son diametre."-Mem .
de l'Acad .
torn .
vii .
p. 359 .
Hence we learn that a star of the fifth magnitude at the distance of six minutes from the planet Mars became invisible to CASSINI ; and that after occultation by the planet , the same star could not be detected by ROEMER , till the planet 's limb had receded from it , almost seventeen seconds of a degree .
Experience , however , has long shown us that stars of the same magnitude are visible even when in actual contact with the moon 's enlightened limb ; to what cause then is the invisibility of the star when in the vicinity of Mars referable ?
CASSINI attributed it to the atmosphere of Mars ; and although it seems difficult to imagine one of such enormous extent as the Briare observation would require , still , as any oter ypothh hesis would involve us in greater difficulty , I shall adopt it , and shall present it , as also the comments which precede it , in CASSINI'S own words : " Cette difficult de voir cette etoile de la cinquieme grandeur tres proche de Mars est considerable , d'autant qu'il n'y a point de difficult6 a voir des etoiles de la meme grandeurl jusqu'au board de la lune .
Ce qui pourroit fair juger que Mars est environne de quelque atmosphere."-M6m .
de l'Acad .
tom .
vii .
p. 359 .
Admitting , then , that an extensively diffused atmosphere of Mars is indicated by the observations above quoted , let us see if modern observations can confirm it .
On the 27th October 1783 , Sir WILLIAM HERSCHEL , with a new 20-feet Reflector of 18.7 inches aperture , saw a star of the 13th or 14th magnitude at a distance of two minutes and fifty-six seconds from the planet , " not otherwise affected by the approach of Mars , than what the brightness of its superior light might account for."-Vide Phil. Trans. vol. lxxiv .
p. 272 .
On the 19th of February 1822 , in Blackman-street , a star of the 9th or 10th magnitude was for several hours seen in the field of the 5-feet Equatorial with the planet Mars .
At a distance of one minute and forty-three seconds of a degree firomin the planet , ( which took place at 1 1h 15m sidereal time , ) its splendour suffered no sensible diminution .
On the following night a star 42 Leonis , of the 6th magnitude , was in the field of the same instrument with Mars , and the planet 's progress towards the star was observed micrometrically for several hours ; nor did the star suffer any loss of its brilliancy as its distance from the planet diminished .
Fatigued by previous watchings , at about two in the morning I retired to rest ; but thinking it probable that the star would undergo occultation , accompanied by my brother Mr. HENRY SOUTH I returned to the instrument about 4 o'clock , and found Mars about half his own diameter from the star .
The planet had about twenty-four degrees of altitude ; its limb was at times well defined and steady , at other times extremely unsteady ; the star was compaIatively steady* , could be kept tolerably well upon the micrometer-wire , and was of a beautiful blue colour .
At 15h 3m 23s.3 sidereal time , it was seen admirably defined , and was distant from the limb of the planet a diameter of one of the micrometer-wires , equal nearly to one second of a degree ; from which time till 1511 3m 53s the planet 's limb was so extremely unsteady and ill defined , that the precise moment of occultation could not be obtained .
After emersion , at 1511 20m 38S.3 the star was seen when it was about 12 diameter of the wire , or one second and a half from the limnb ; it was almost indigo blue ; and the contrast between it and the planet , which was of a deep red , was exquisitely beautiful .
By reference to the double star 48 Cancri , some idea of it may be entertained , if we regard the larger of its stars as Mars , and the smaller as 42 Leonis .
At the time of observation the planet had passed his opposition only forty-seven hours , and his apparent diameter as measured with the micrometer , was sixteen seconds and six tenths .
The phenomena were also witnessed by Mr. HENRY SOUTH , and his observations strictly accorded with my own .
To render our results as independent as possible of optical misrepresentation , his instrument was my Gregorian reflector , by WATSON , of six inches aperture and thirty inches focus ; the figure of its metal was exquisitely perfect , whilst twelve years of constant use , had not occasioned the slightest tarnish of its almost colourless surface .
Accustomed as the first business of the night , to point a telescope to such of the principal planets as are above the horizon , on the 17th of March of the present year I had the satisfaction of seeing in the field of the 5-feet Equatorial , with the planet Mars , several stars , some of them minute , but one of the 5th and another of the 6th magnitude .
Convinced that the planet would pass close by , or perhaps occult the larger , I took its place , and found it to be 37 Tauri .
The covering under which the dome for my large equatorial was being built , unfortunately rendered the 5-feet equatorial useless , when the planet had approached within forty seconds of the star .
The observations therefore were continued with the 12-feet Achromatic of 7t inches aperture , and also with the 42-inch of 2m aperture , till the star was one diameter and a half of the planet from his nearest limb ; wlen , fearing lest the trees to the north-west of my grounds , might intercept the planet from my view , at the instant of nearest appulse or occultation , the 8-feet Achromatic of six inches aperture previously placed on the top of the house , was recurred to .
The star , from being a full diameter distant from the planet when first observed with this telescope , was watched most unremittingly till the planet , having been in contact with it , had receded from it a quantity equal to its own semi-diameter .
The star suffered not the least change of colour , nor the least diminution of its lustre , except what of the latter might fairly be attributed to the splendour of the planet ; its rays were certainly in contact with the planet 's limb , but only at their circumference ; at times the planet and star were very steady , at other times far otherwise ; but at no period was there such contrast between the steadiness of the star and the unsteadiness of the planet , as occurred at the occultation of 42 Leonis .
As the star 's distance from the planet diminished , the former seemed to undergo not the slightest alteration ; and when in actual contact , both the star and the planet were red , but the planet had the deeper tint .
The night was remarkably fine , and although Mars had not more than seven or eight degrees of altitude , a power of 320 was used with advantage .
The diameter of Mars , as taken with the 5-feet Equatorial , was about ten seconds .
The observations were commenced at about seven hours sidereal time , whilst the nearest appulse was perhaps at about eleven hours ; they were not made for determining the place of Mars , but for noticing any phenomena which the star might exhibit .
The facts being now before us , the inferences may be comprised in a few lines .
Sir W. HERSCHEL'S observation of the 27th of October 1783 , and mine of the small star on the 19th of February 1822 , are at variance with CASSINI'S observation , but impugn not the accuracy of ROEMER'S ; whilst my observations of 42 Leonis and of 37 Tauri , being apparently subversive of the observations both of CASSINI and of ROEMER , point out the " extensive atmosphere of Mars " as a subject meriting further investigation .
Such are all the observations relative to the extensive atmosphere of Mars which my observatory can furnish .
One of these , viz. that of the 17th of last March , demands further consideration , lest , having served to invalidate one hypothesis , it might be brought forward to support another ; namely , that " the red colour of the planet Mars is dependent upon the physical properties of his atmosphere."* Moreover , it seems inconsistent with a previous observation .
The star 37 Tauri had " nearly the colour of Mars " whilst in contact with the planet ; whereas , the star 42 Leonis was " beautifully blue " previously and subsequently to occultation by the planet .
The facts are different ; -are they reconcileable ?
The following then are extracts from the Observatory Journal .
On the night following the observation of 37 Tauri , namely , the 18th of March , " the five-feet Equatorial was placed upon Mars , in order to compare its colour with that of 37 Tauri ; the star and planet were still in the field together , though nearly at opposite points of its circumference .
" I can have no hesitation in saying , that the star is red , but not of so deep a tint as the planet .
" " Mars being placed out of the field , I requested an attendant ( accustomed to use a telescope ) to look at the star and to tell me its colour ; entirely un* Vide BREWSTER'S Encyclopaedia , vol. ii .
pages 636 &amp; 637 ( article Mars ) .
acquainted with the bearing of the question , and ignorant of the colour assigned to it by me , he replied , ' Certainly a light red .
' Mars was now brought into the field with the star , and being asked what colour he now considered the star to have , he answered , ' Certainly red , but not so deep a red as Mars .
' Looking at it again , he said , ' Mars is the darker , but there is not a great deal of difference .
' " " I now applied several other eye-pieces , magnifying from 70 to 548 times , and with all of them I felt convinced that the star was red , but not so deep a red as Mars .
" " Whilst the colour of 37 Tauri was fresh in my recollection , " I placed the Equatorial upon 42 Leonis , when it had nearly the same altitude as that star ; I instantly pronounced the star 42 Leonis to be blue-light blue .
The attendant was now requested to look again at 37 Tauri , and to retain its colour in his mind as much as possible : 42 Leonis was next brought into the field ; he said , " This star is certainly not red at all ; I do not know what colour it is , unless a light blue .
" Alternating the examination of the one star with that of the other several times , and with various powers , he at last said , c It is certainly blue , and the first is certainly red .
" The comparisons were repeated with the 12-feet Achromatic of 7inches aperture , and the inferences drawn from them were the same ; and , if just , the observations of 37 Tauri and 42 Leonis are perfectly reconcileable .
Hypothesis , therefore , is not needed , to explain under similar circumstances with regard to Mars , the " red " colour of the one star , or the " blue " colour of the other .

