j XIII .
On the Errors in the Course of Vessels , occasioned by Local Attraction ; with some Remarks on the recent Loss of His Majesty 's ship Thetis .
By PETER BARLOW , Esq. F.R.S. Cor. Mem. of the Inst. France , Imp .
Acad. Sciences St. Petersburgh , Acad. Sciences Brussels , 8Sc .
8Sc .
Read April 21,1831 .
ON presenting the following remarks to the attention of the Royal Society , I feel it necessary , first , to apologize for their not possessing that degree of scientific novelty which is generally expected in such communications , and secondly , that in enforcing my argument , I may perhaps seem to give more value to my own investigations than is consistent with good taste .
I must , however , either in some measure do this , or leave the evil untouched , which I feel it my duty to endeavour to remove ; and therefore , trusting to a liberal interpretation of my motives , I shall state without reserve such facts as appear necessary to establish the object I have in view , and it is hoped the want of novelty will be compensated by the importance of the subject under consideration .
That a ship 's compass is subject to a deviation from its true direction in consequence of the attraction of the iron used in the construction and appointments of the vessel , is now too generally admitted to require any argument , although I believe there may be still some few officers who are sceptical on this point ; I have at least been seriously assured by one of rank and long standing , " that there certainly was no local attraction when he was at sea .
" Now there is really more in this observation than one would imagine , for there can be no question that forty years back the error arising from this disturbing force was very inconsiderable to what it is at present ; every year in fact increasing the amount , and rendering a correction of the error more and more necessary .
This increase is occasioned by the immense quantity of iron now employed in the construction of a ship of war and its appointments .
At the period above alluded to , iron ballast and iron tanks were perhaps scarcely known ; now we have , besdes these , iron knees , iron cables , and above all iron capstans , besides various other articles of the same material , which together form such an attracting mass , that if we cannot allow that there was no local attraction forty years back , we must at least admit that it was certainly then very inconsiderable to when t iis at present , and that navigation by compass was at that time comparatively on equal terms with nautical astronomy ; but since that period , the errors of the one have been gradually removed by improvements in instruments , the introduction of chronometers , and the correction of astronomical tables and data , whereas the compass still remains the same uncouth machine , and the disturbing forces to which it is exposed have been increased in , perhaps , a fourfold proportion .
At all events the disturbing force is now considerable , and the deflection it causes in the needle , under some circumstances , very great ; and as this effect is perpetually varying as the course of the vessel is changed , as it is also as she changes her latitude , though the course should remain the same , a constant attention to the amount of this error seems to be indispensable , at least in those circumstances where the whole safety of the vessel is dependent on the certainty of the courses steered , which is in fact always the case in a dark night , and when land is near .
It is almost impossible to give a very popular idea of the direction and amount of this deflecting force .
It may however be stated , that in this latitude , and in all those northern latitudes where the dip is considerable , the greatest deflections take place , on an east or on a west course , diminishing both ways to the north and south , where it vanishes ; and in all these cases the direction of the deflection is always to the right or left of a person , looking forward in the vessel , accordingly as the course of the vessel is to the right or left , that is to the east or west of the meridian , and it is exactly the reverse in a high southern latitude or with a considerable southern dip .
But as we approach the equator , where the dip is small , the deflections at the east and west points vanish , and we have then four points of greatest attraction , viz. the N.E. , N.W. , S.E. , and S.W. , the direction of the deflection changing as we pass through the N. , S. , E. , and West points ; but the deflection at its maximum is much less in these latitudes than in those where the dip is more considerable , all other things being the same .
216 These rules , which are given upon the supposition that the compass is situated in its usual place , aft in the vessel , will furnish a general idea of the direction of the deflection .
With regard to the actual amount , it is of course different in different vessels , varying in these latitudes from 5 ?
to 120 or 14 ?
with an easterly or westerly course ; which become greater as we increase our latitude , but diIninish ( without however vanishing ) at the equator , whence it again increases as we approach the southern pole .
The following are some results , several of which I have assisted in taking ; they rest , as will be seen , on the best authorities , and will give a good general idea of the maximum amount .
Ship .
Conway .
Leven Baracouter Hecla Fury Griper Adventure Gloucester Commander. .
Captain BASIL HALL. .
Captain OWEN ... .
Captain CUTFIELD. .
Captain Sir E. PARRY .
Captain HOPNER. .
Captain CLAVERING .
Captain KING ... Captain STUART .
Place. .
Portsmouth .
Northfleet Northfleet Northfleet Northfleet .
Nor .
Plymouth .
Channel Local Attraction .
o 1 .
4 32 .
6 7 .
14 30 * .
7 27. .
6 22 .
13 36 7 48. .
9 30 Giving a mean of 8 ? ?
44 ' at the east and west points in these latitudes .
The latter observation by Captain STUART is from the remark-book of the Gloucester , and from which I beg to give the following extract : ( 1830 .
30th August .
From not having had a favourable opportunity of ascertaining the ship 's magnetism or local attraction in steering down the British Channel , I only allowed the true variation as found , but observed the ship was invariably drawn to the southward of her intended place , notwithstanding the greatest care being taken in steering her .
But on taking an amplitude of the sun at setting on the 1st September , I found the variation to be 340 W. ( when the ship 's head was west ) , which difference from the true variation in the Channel 240 30 ' W. will account for the ship being so drawn to the southward of her intended track .
" It would be quite superfluous to give further evidence of the existence of this disturbing power ; and little , I conceive , need be said to show how much such deviations from the estimated course of a vessel , in channels and narrow seas , are calculated to lead to the most disastrous events .
To take the last case , for example , where the deviation is 9 ? ?
30 ' , and for the deviation in miles the general expression ( dist. X2 sin I deviation ) , we shall find that after running ten miles , the vessel would be more than a mile and a half to the southward of her reckoning ; in a distance of twenty miles , three miles and a quarter to the southward ; in thirty miles , five miles to the southward , and so on as the distance increases .
Now it requires no knowledge of navigation to estimate the fatal consequences that might attend such an error in a narrow channel and in a dark night , if it were wholly unknown or disregarded .
We see also how very easy it is , after an accident has occurred , to imagine a current ( unknown of course to exist before ) , to account for the disaster .
The Gloucester , for example , in the above instance was constantly " drawn to the southward ; " and this might have been set down to the effect of a current , had it not been proved to be local attraction .
That a ship is sometimes involved in an unknown or unusual current , which may lead her into an error of reckoning , no one can for a moment deny ; but I do at the same time maintain , that unless a proper attention be paid to the local attraction , a vessel is as it were in a perpetual current , setting sometimes in one direction , and sometimes in another , sufficient to baffle the most experienced pilot ; and I further maintain , that science and humanity both require , before we admit the plea of unknown currents to explain the cause of every disaster , that it be sufficiently ascertained how far allowance has been made , or a correction obtained for that current , which it is now well known a vessel carries with her through every league of her voyage .
Let us now turn to the late melancholy wreck of His MAJESTY'S ship Thetis .
It appears from the account given of this disaster in the United Service Journal , that " the Thetis sailed from Rio Janeiro on the 4th of December , with a million of dollars on board , besides other treasure , and every prospect of a fine passage , stretching away to the S.E. The next day , the wind coming rather favourable , they tacked , thinking themselves clear of land ; and so confident were they , that the top-mast studding sails were ordered to be set , the ship running at the rate of nine knots ; and the first intimation they had of being near land , was the jib-boom striking against a high perpendicular cliff , when the bowsprit broke short off , the shock sending all three masts over the side ; " and thus in a moment perished twenty-five valuable lives , and a fine vessel , with her cargo , worth nearly a quarter of a million sterling .
Here then we have a case of a ship leaving port one day , with every prospect of a fine passage , which had so far lost her reckoning on the evening of the next day , as to be wrecked on a rock not more than seventy miles from her point of departure , which was supposed to be some miles to her west .
I have no desire to prejudge the cause of this unfortunate misreckoning ; I wish only the true cause should be ascertained .
In the letter of the cominander of the Thetis to the admiral on the station , he says , that " from all the precautionary measures taken , nothing but the strongest currents , and the thick hazy weather , and hard rain , can be pleaded in extenuation .
" I most sincerely hope that amongst " the precautionary measures taken , " that of correcting or making proper allowance for the local attraction was included ; for I have no hesitation in asserting , if such precaution was not taken , that this omission would be quite sufficient to account for the accident .
It is obvious from the general principles which I have stated in the preceding part of this paper , that at Rio , where the dip of the needle is about 220 south , ( the course steered on the 4th of December having been S.E. , and on the 5th of December necessarily somewhere between the east and north , ) the local attraction would be constantly drawing the vessel over to the westward , and there can be no question that her being more to the westward than her reckoning , was , from whatever source it might have proceeded , the cause of the disastrous event .
Without therefore in any way prejudging the case , I have only to express a hope that some inquiry may be made , to ascertain whether any and what allowance or correction was made for the local attraction of the vessel .
It is impossible now , if the local attraction of the Thetis has not been before taken , to know its amount ; but we can ascertain , at least approximatively , what would have been the deflection of the Gloucester under similar circumstances ; and as the amount of attraction in this vessel is nearly the mea-n of all those I have given in a former page , it may be interesting to see the result .
2r2 219 It has been stated that the maximum attraction or deflection is much less ( all other things being the same ) with a small dip than with a large one ; the proportion being , " that the tangents of the angles of deflections are inversely as the cosines of the dip : " now , the dip at Rio Janeiro being about 22 ?
, and in London 69o ?
, we have cos 22 ?
: cos 69 ?
o : : tan 9 ? ?
30 ' : tan 3 ? ?
33 ' .
That is , the Gloucester leaving Rio under similar circumstances to the Thetis , would on any course about the S.E. or N.E. ( the former being stated as the course of the latter vessel on the 4th , and the other her probable course after tacking on the 5th of December ) , be constantly deflected about 3- ?
* out of her supposed course , and as the sine of 3 ? ?
33 ' is about l-lth part of the radius , it is obvious , taking only the error due to the 5th of December , and reckoning the distance run at eighty miles , that the ship would pass five miles nearer to Cape Frio than her reckoning , an error quite sufficient to account for the fatal catastrophe which has occurred to the Thetis ; for it appears that a distance of only so many fathoms would have nearly carried her clear of the land .
I do not include the error due to the first day , because its tendency would only be to carry the vessel to the southward about the same quantity , which of itself could have produced no evil .
After all , let it be remembered that this is a supposititious case , and that my object in stating it is merely to show what might happen if the deflection from local attraction were disregarded , and thereby to prove the propriety and necessity of ascertaining whether in the case of the Thetis , and in all similar cases , the proper correction was made , before the apology of currents can be admitted .
I urge this the more particularly , because I fear this source of error is too much disregarded , and as I think it probable that in the several investigations which have been held to inquire into cases of vessels lost in a similar way for the last ten years , since I have been interested on this subject , no question has been asked whether or not the error of the compass had been corrected ; and thus vessel after vessel is lost , and current after current is imagined to ac* 1 say about 30 ?
, because much depends upon the direction of the centre of attraction in the vessel .
'220 count for the loss , while an actually existing and known cause is allowed to remain uncorrected and disregarded .
That the remedy for this evil , which I have been so fortunate as to discover , is simple and universal , is , I believe , generally admitted ; indeed , after being submitted to trial by two of our most scientific officers from 570 south latitude to 800 north latitude , and having been found to be effective to the most extreme point , it is impossible that any doubt should remain on that head .
It must be , therefore , that the error itself is disregarded , and it would consequently be rendering an essential service to the navy , when any loss is sustained from neglecting this necessary precaution , that it should be traced to its proper source ; and it is with this view that I have drawn together these few remarks .
If I overrate the importance of the error or the value of the remedy , my apology must be the opinions which have been given on the subject by many distinguished naval commanders , both English and foreign , and the high marks of approbation with which my investigations have been acknowledged by the Royal Society , and other learned societies of Europe .
To which I may aso add my anxiety , that where science can be brought to facilitate the progress of navigation , and to contribute to its security , it may not be allowed to be neglected in the British navy .
221

