On the Equilibrium of Fluids , and the Figure of a Homogeneous Planet in a Fluid State .
ByJJAMES IVORY , A.M. F.R.S. Instit .
Reg. Sc. Paris .
Corresp .
et Reg. Sc. Gottin .
Corresp .
Read January 13 and 20 , 1831 .
I. Equilibrium of Fluids .
1 .
THE nature of the ultimate particles of a fluid , and the peculiar manner of their mutual connection , are entirely unknown to us .
We conceive that they obey the same meclianical laws to which all matter is subject .
Experience shows that the particles of a fluid move freely among one another , yielding to the least pressure in any direction ; and this is the most general property of such bodies that has yet been discovered .
The perfect mobility of their particles must therefore , in the present state of our knowledge , be considered as constituting the definition of fluid bodies , and as the foundation of all our reasoning concerning them .
We here confine our attention to a fluid in equilibrium , or at rest , in which state every particle is pressed equally on all sides .
It is evident that the mobility of the particles among one another , and their readiness to obey any new impulse , is nowise impeded by the magnitude of their mutual pressure , since this acts at every point with the same intensity in all directions .
If we set aside the effect of gravity , and of all accelerating forces , it follows , from the definition , that the pressure will be equal in all parts of a continuous fluid at rest .
In this state we must conceive that the particles are equally distant , and arranged similarly about every interior point .
Their mutual distance , it is natural to think , must be connected with the magnitude of pressure ; so that when they are more pressed , they will approach one another , and the volume will be diminished ; and , when they are less pressed , they will recede from one another , and the volume will be enlarged .
Accordingly it is found that no fluid is perfectly incompressible .
But in some , such as water and other liquids , a very great external force must be applied to produce an almost imperceptible variation of bulk ; while in others , such as air and the gases , very notable changes of volume are caused by moderate compression .
In the investigation of the properties of the first sort of fluids , to which our attention is here exclusively directed , we shall throw out of view the very small degree of compressibility they possess , and shall suppose them to retain the same bulk whatever changes of figure or pressure they may undergo .
In a fluid in equilibrium , the action of the accelerating forces that urge the particles must be counterbalanced by the pressure propagated through the mass : to find the relation between these opposite forces must therefore be the first object of research .
2 .
Assuming three planes intersecting at right angles which , by the co-ordinates drawn to them , ascertain the position of the particles of the fluid , we shall suppose two points or particles ( x , y , z ) and ( x + x , , y+ y , z+6 z ) at the infinitely small distance 6s from one another ; and we shall put w for the small base of an upright cylinder or prism of the fluid placed between the two points , and having 8s for its length : then the density of the fluid being invariable and represented by unit , and the quantity of matter of the cylinder or prism being denoted by dm , we shall have dm -w X s. Let all the accelerating forces which act upon the particle ( x , y , z ) be reduced to the directions of the coordinates ; and put X , Y , Z for the sums of Ox ay ay the reduced forces respectively parallel to x , y , z ; then because -s , VVs are the cosines of the angles which the line s makes with x , y , z , the partial forces urging the particle in the direction of a s , will be X 8 , Y ' , Z s , and , if we put f=-X 8s +YZ as , the whole accelerating force urging the particle ( x , y , z ) in the direction of s , will be equal tof .
Multiply now by the equal quantities dm and w s , and the result will be fdm = ( X xI+Yy+Z z ) .
110 As the quantities x , By , 6 z , ; s , w may be assumed as small as we please , the forcef may be considered as retaining the same value for all the particles of the cylinder or prism ; and therefore fd m is the motive force of the cylinder or prism , or the effort it makes to move in the direction of ; s from the point ( x , y , z ) to the point ( x +y x , y+ Sy , z+ z ) .
Let p represent the hydrostatic pressure of the fluid at the point ( x , y , z ) .
This term is used to denote the pressure relatively to the surface pressed : it is the whole pressure any surface sustains divided by the extent of surface ; or it is the actual pressure reduced to the unit of surface .
The hydrostatic pressure is obviously variable in thdifferent parts of a fluid , the particles of which are urged by accelerating forces ; and as it can vary only when its point of action is changed , it must be a function of the coordinates of that point .
The whole pressure upon the end of the cylinder or prism at the point ( x , y , z ) will be equal to pX w ; for we may suppose that p undergoes no change in the small extent of the surface w : and , in like manner , th whole pressure upon the opposite end will be equal to ( p + Sp ) X w. As the pressures upon the two ends act against one another , their effect to move the cylinder or prism in the direction of s from the point ( x +Y x , y++ z ) to the point ( x , y , z ) will be equal to bp X w ; and this force , on the supposition that the particles of the fluid are at rest , must be equal to fdm , the directly opposite effect caused by the accelerating forces .
We therefore have this equation for expressing the non-effect of the equal and opposite forces , viz. ; p xw +f m= 0 : and , if we substitute the value offdm found before , we shall get 6p+X ; X+Y ; y+Zz= O. ( 1 ) This equation must take place at every point of the mass of fluid without any relation being supposed between the variations ^ xy , ; z ; which condition will not be fulfilled unless p be a function of the three independent variables x , y , z. We therefore have p= dp 4 die d Ill. and , if we substitute this value of ; p in the formula ( 1 ) , the independence of the variations will require these three separate equations , dp d__p __ dxd X d_p y die dp_ _ z. From this it appears that the algebraic expressions of the forces are not entirely arbitrary ; for they must be equal to the partial differential coefficients of a function of three independent variables .
By differentiating we shall readily obtain the following equations which do not contain the function p , viz. dX die dX dZ die dZ die -d dz ddd dz dy ' Unless the forces possess these properties , which are the well-known conditions of integrability , the equation ( 1 ) will not hold in all parts of the mass of fluid , and the equilibrium will be impossible .
But in the physical questions that actually occur , the forces of nature being either attractions or repulsions directed to fixed centres , and proportional to certain functions of the distances from those centres , they necessarily fulfil the conditions of integrability .
The whole of what has been said is succinctly expressed by the two following equations , p =f(Xdx + Ydy +Z dz ) , } ( 2 ) p=C - , , Here p represents a function of three independent variables x , y , z without any arbitrary quantity ; the constant C required by the integration is necessary only in the expression of p. 3 .
The hydrostatic pressure at every point of the mass of fluid in equilibrium , is expressed by the second of the equations ( 2 ) , viz. p= C. But at all those parts of the outer surface of the fluid which are unconfined and entirely at liberty , there is no pressure ; wherefore we have , for the equation of all such surfaces , =_ C. 112 It may be proper to remark , that although this equation is universally true , yet it is no new or independent condition of the equilibriuinm ; it is merely an inference from the general expression of the hydrostatic pressure .
If we assume two points ( x , y , z ) and ( x + dx , y+ die , z+ dz ) indefinitely near one another in a part of the outer surface at liberty , we shall have , in consequence of the foregoing equation , d +dd xdy dz ; dx + adydz=0 ; or , which is the same thing , Xdx + Ydy + Zdz = 0 ; and if ds represent the distance of the two points , we obtain Xdr + yy+ Z d. ds ds ds dx die dz Now d , -T ' , d-s are the cosines of the angles which the directions of the forces make with no the line ds ; weresfoe the expression on the left side of the foregoing formula is the sum of the partial forces which act in the direction of ds ; and as this sum is equal to zero in all positions of the line ds round the point ( x , , , ) , the resultant of the forces produces no effect in the plane touching the surface , and consequently its whole action is perpendicular to that plane .
The nature of the case requires further , that the same resultant be directed towards the surface of the suafluid .
What has been deduced from the algebraic expressions is evident in another view .
For , could we suppose that the resultant of the forces is not at every point perpendicular to the surface at liberty , it might be resolved into two partial forces , one acting in the tangent plane , and the other perpendicular to that plane ; and as the first force is opposed by no obstacle , it would cause the particles to move , which is contrary to the equilibrium .
If we suppose that p is constant in the general formula of the hydrostatic pressure , we shall have an equation , =Cp , which is exactly similar to that of the surface at liberty , and which will determine an interior surface at every point of which there is the same intensity of pressure .
By differentiating the equation of the interior surface , we obtain Xdx + Ydy +Zdz= -O ; from which we deduce , by the like reasoning as before , that such surfaces are perpendicular to the resultant of the accelerating forces urging the particles contained in them .
The interior surfaces in question were named level surfaces by CLAIRAUT ; and they are distinguished by the two properties of being equally pressed at all their points , and of cutting the resultant of the forces at right angles .
They spread through the mass , and ultimately coincide with those parts of the outer surface which are at liberty .
It may be observed , that what essentially constitutes a level surface is its equation , which must differ from the equation of the outer surface at liberty in no respect , except that the constant Cp takes the place of the constant C ; for we shall afterwards find that , in some cases of the equilibrium of a fluid , the two properties of being equally pressed , and of cutting the resultant of the forces at right angles , belong to more sets of interior surfaces than one .
4 .
In what goes before , we have supposed that the density is constant , but it is easy to extend the investigation to heterogeneous fluids .
Let 6 be put for the function of the co-ordinates which expresses the variable density ; then admitting that g has the same value at every point of the small elementary cylinder or prism , we shall have dm = gc s ; but , / being the whole accelerating force , urging every particle of dm in the direction of 8 s , we have fw= Xs s+ Z wherefore , fdm=(Xx+YSy+ZSz ) .
The equation expressing that the action of the accelerating forces is equal and opposite to the variation of pressure , is the same as before , viz. wX Ip +fdm =0 ; and by substituting the value offdm , we deduce 114 6p + ?
( X 6 X+ +Y 6+ 6 ) O ( 3 ) This equation must hold at every point of the mass of fluid without any relation being supposed between the variations , wherefore p must be a function of three independent variables ; and in consequence the foregoing equation implies the three separate equations following , viz. dp eX d dp _ dp dxdy -X--Y d z--It now appears that the conditions of integrability must be fulfilled , viz. d.gX d.g Y d. X d. Z d.eY d.g Z die -d dx dx dz d die and unless the forces possess the properties expressed by these equations , the equilibrium will be impossible .
Without pursuing the investigation in all its generality , we shall confine our attention to the case in which Xdx + Ydy + Zdz , is an exact differential ; a supposition that comprehends all the applications of the theory .
If we represent the integral of the differential by p , so that d p=Xdx+Ydy+ Zdz ; and convert the variations of equation ( 3 ) into differentials , we shall obtain dp +g d(p = 0 ; and hence p =C -fg d. ( 4 ) From this we deduce the equation of those parts of the outer surface which are at liberty , by making p= 0 ; and that of a level surface , by assigning to p some constant value .
And if we differentiate the same equation ( 4 ) on the supposition that p is invariable , we shall get d p=(Xdx +Y die +Z dz ) =0 , which differential equation is common to the outer surface at liberty , and to all the interior level surfaces ; and from which we deduce by the like reasoning as before , that all such surfaces are perpendicular to the resultant of the accelerating forces urging the particles contained in them .
The quantity under the sign of integration in the formula , p =C -f/ g dp , Q2 115 must be an exact differential , for p must be a function of the co-ordinates ; which condition will not be fulfilled unless g be a function of p. Thus both the pressure p and the density g are functions of the same quantity p , and they are both invariable where p is constant .
The density is therefore the same at all the points of any level surface .
If we conceive a heterogeneous fluid in equilibrium to be divided into thin strata by level surfaces infinitely near one another , the density will be the same throughout every stratum , but it will vary from one stratum to another .
5 .
We have now placed before the reader the general points of the theory of the equilibrium of fluids .
What has been said comprehends all that can be determined when a fluid is conceived to extend indefinitely ; but in applying the theory to limited masses , it is necessary besides , that the pressures propagated through the interior parts either be supported or mutually balance one another .
In treating of the equilibrium of fluids , another mode of investigation is sometimes employed , which it would be improper to pass by without notice , as it is useful on many occasions to fix the imagination , although it leads to no new results .
We allude to the narrow canals supposed to traverse the mass in various ways , of which so much use has been made by CLAIRAUT and other authors .
Let two points ( x ?
, y ?
, z ?
) and ( x ' , y ' , z ' ) be assumed in the interior of a mass of fluid in equilibrium , and conceive an infinitely narrow canal of any figure to pass between them ; we may suppose that the whole fluid , except the portion within the canal , becomes solid without any change taking place in the position of the particles , or in their mutual action upon one another ; for , as this supposition makes no alteration of the forces urging the particles contained within the canal , these particles will remain at rest after the solidification as they were at first .
Suppose that the canal is divided into infinitely small parts by sections perpendicular to its sides ; at any point ( x , y , z ) let u be the section ; the infinitely small part of the length of the reanal ; dm the quantity of matter in the length 6 s , that is , the product of the volunme and the density , or XwX s ; and the sum of all the partial forces that urge the particles of dm in the direction of the canal ; then , the motive force of dmn , or its effort to move , will be equal tof d m. Further , p being the hydrostatic 116 pressure at the point ( x , y , z ) , the like pressure at the distance of Ss will be p+ 6p ; therefore the opposing pressures which act upon the two ends of the part of the canal in the length s , will be pXw and ( p + pp ) X W ; and bp xc will be the effective pressure which pushes dm towards the point ( x , y , z ) .
Because every part of the canal is supposed at rest , the tendencies of dm to move in opposite directions must be equal , and we shall have this equation , Ip X w+f dm =0 ; consequently , ~P += O ; and by taking the surm of the similar quantities in all the parts of the canal , we obtain fP + =fdS 0 .
But p being a function of three independent variables , the sum of its variations , supposing the flowing quantities to follow any arbitrary law of increase or decrease , is equal to the difference of p ' and p ?
, the final and initial values of the function ; wherefore we have p , _pO+fdm O. Now fdm , that is the quantity of matter multiplied by the accelerating force , is the impulse or pressure in the direction of the canal caused by all the forces urging dm ; and as this pressure is exerted on the surface t , -mis the same pressure reduced to the unit of surface .
Therefore , whatever be the figure of the canal , it follows from the foregoing investigation , that the difference of the pressures at its two extremities is equal to the sum of the impulses of all the contained molecules of fluid , every impulse being reduced to the direction of the canal and to the unit of surface .
If the extremities of the canal be both in the parts of the outer surface which are at liberty , the pressures p ' and p ?
will be both evanescent , and there will be no effort of the fluid either way , and no tendency to run out at one end .
Further , if a canal be continued through the fluid till it return into itself , the 117 initial and final pressures being the same , the impulses of the molecules in the whole circuit will balance one another .
But in this case , the reasoning we have employed will not be exact , unless p , the algebraic expression of the pressure , be such a function as admits of only one value for any three given co-ordinates ; a restriction however , which , in every point of view , seems indispensable .
6 .
The whole theory , it will readily appear from the foregoing investigations , is built on the assumption , That the hydrostatic pressure at every point of the fluid is the same function of the co-ordinates of the point .
The accelerating forces are represented by the partial differential coefficients of the pressure ; and therefore they are likewise the same functions of the co-ordinates of their point of action in every part of the mass .
The whole reasoning rests on these fundamental points ; and if the state of a fluid were such that they are not verified , the equations for determining the required figure could not be formed , and the equilibrium would be impossible .
As the hydrostatic pressure is known only by means of the given accelerating forces , it seems most suitable to employ the properties of the latter in laying down what is required for the equilibrium of a mass of fluid .
It is necessary , and it is sufficient for the equilibrium of a homogeneous fluid , first , that the accelerating forces acting in the directions of the co-ordinates be , in every part of the mass , the same functions of the co-ordinates ; and , secondly , that these functions possess the conditions of integrability .
When these two conditions are both fulfilled , the determination of the figure of equilibrium is reduced to a question purely mathematical .
For we can form the equation ( 1 ) which makes the accelerating forces balance the variation of pressure ; and , by integrating this equation , we obtain the hydrostatic pressure , from which is deduced the equation of all those points at which there is no pressure , or in other words , the equation of all those parts of the outer surface which are at liberty .
Nothing more is required for securing the permanence of the figure of the fluid , except that the pressures propagated through the mass be either supported or mutually balance one another .
The conditions for the equilibrium of a homogeneous fluid , as they are here laid down , do not enable us in all cases to form immediately the equation of the figure of equilibrium .
If the particles attract or repel one another , the accelerating forces will , for the most part , vary as the fluid changes its form , 118 and they may not be at every point the same functions of the co-ordinates in all the figures , of which it is susceptible ; but , notwithstanding the equilibrium may still be possible , because this indispensable condition may be fulfilled when figures of a certain class are induced on the mass .
In such cases , the determination of the equilibrium necessarily requires two distinct researches ; of which one is to find out what are the particular figures into which the mass must be moulded , so as to make the accelerating forces at every point the same functions of the co-ordinates .
After these figures have been found , we can apply to them the equations expressing the conditions of equilibrium , and accomplish the mathematical solution of the problem .
But if it shall appear that no figure whatever capable of fulfilling both the conditions laid down above can be induced on the fluid , the equilibrium will be absolutely impossible .
In the usual exposition of this theory , the equilibrium is made to depend on conditions that do not exactly coincide with those at which we have arrived .
According to CLAIRAUT and all other authors who have written on this subject , it is necessary , and it is sufficient , for the equilibrium of a homogeneous fluid , first , that the expressions of the accelerating forces possess the criterion of integrability ; secondly , that the resultant of the forces in action at all the parts of the outer surface which are at liberty , be directed perpendicularly towards these surfaces .
We may throw out of view what regards the criterion of integrability , about which there is no difference of opinion , and which in reality is always fulfilled by the forces that occur in physical researches .
The perpendicularity of the forces to the outer surface is a property of the differential equation of that surface , and will necessarily take place whenever it is possible to form that equation .
Nothing more is required for forming the equation mentioned , than that the accelerating forces at every point of it be expressed by the same functions of the co-ordinates of the point.* It follows Tare perpendicular to every surfce in which the pressure is constant .
The outer surfaces are those at every point of which there is no pressure .
In all the questions that have occurred , the forces at the outer surface of the fluid are the same functions of the co-ordinates of the point , whatever geometrical figure the fluid is supposed to assume ; and on this account the equation of the outer surface can be formed without reference to any particular class of figures .
But this is not sufficient ; for , according to the fundamental assumption laid down by CLAIRAUT himself , the theory-of equilibrium cannot be applied , unless the forces be the same functions of the co-ordinates of their point of action in every part of the mass .
119 therefore , that the difference between the conditions of equilibrium hitherto universally adopted , and those laid down above , amounts to this : according to the former it is required that the texpressions of the accelerating forces be the same functions of the co-ordinates at every point of the outer surface , this being all that is necessary for forming the differential equation of that surface ; according tola the latter , the forces will not balance the pressure , and the laws of equilibrium will not be fulfilled unless the forces be the same functions of the co-ordinates at every point whether situated in the outer surface , or in the interior part of the mass .
If a homogeneous fluid , of which the particles are urged by accelerating forces be in equilibriun , all that is required by CLAIRAUT'S theory will undoubtedly be fulfilled ; but the converse of this cannot be affirmed .
It is no where proved generally by unexceptionable arguments , and indeed no proof can possibly be given , that the forces in the interior parts of the fluid will balance the pressure , merely because the resultant of the forces in action at the outer surface is perpendicular to that surface .
All the attempts that have been made to demonstrate this point , tacitly assume that the expression of the forces is the same at the surface and in all the interior parts ; which is not universally true .
In a very extensive class of problems the difference between the two ways of laying down the conditions of equilibrium disappears .
This will happen when the accelerating forces are independent of the figure of the fluid , as will be the case if the particles exert no action on one another by attraction or repulsion .
In such problems the forces impressed upon every particle , whatever be its situation , and whatever be the figure of the fluid , are by the hypothesis , the same given functions of the co-ordinates .
The figure of equilibrium will be the same whether , following CLAIRAUT , we obtain the equation of the outer surface by means of the forces in action at that surface , or , making use of the property that the pressure vanishes at all the points where the fluid is at liberty , we deduce the same equation from the pressure that prevails generally throughout the mass .
But CLAIRAUT'S theory cannot be extended to the solution of other problems than those of which we have been speaking .
In no other cases is it evident without inquiry that the proposed accelerating forces urging a particle , are , in 120 every part of the mass , the same functions of the coordinates of the particle ; and unless this be verified , the theory of equilibrium cannot be applied .
In a homogeneous planet in a fluid state , there are forces which prevail in the interior parts and vanish at the surface ; and , as CLAIRAUT'S theory notices no forces except those in action at the surface , it leaves out some of the causes tending to change the figure of the fluid , and therefore it cannot lead to an exact determination of the equilibrium .
II Application of the foregoing Theory to the Question of the Figure of the Planets .
7 .
Having now explained the general theory of the equilibrium of fluids at sufficient length , I proceed to apply it to the question of the figure of the planets , in which it is required to determine the equilibrium of a fluid entirely at liberty , and unconfined by any obstacle or support .
The problem is one of considerable difficulty .
It is necessary to distribute the investigation under distinct heads .
It would otherwise be impossible to preserve perspicuity and precision of ideas in an inquiry essentially different in different hypotheses .
The equilibrium of a homogeneous fluid must occupy our attention before that of one having its density variable .
For although it may at first appear that the latter problem is the more general , and includes the former , yet it will be found that the equilibrium of a fluid of variable density , depends upon that of a homogeneous fluid , and is deducible from it .
And even with regard to homogeneous fluids , distinctions must be made , because what is required for the equilibrium varies with the nature of the accelerating forces .
In this respect we distinguish these two general cases , of which we shall treat in two separate problems ; First , when the accelerating forces depend only on the coordinates of their point of action , and are explicitly known when the coordinates are given ; Secondly , when the accelerating forces depend not only upon the coordinates of the particle on which they act , but likewise upon the figure of the whole mass of fluid ; as happens for the most part when the particles attract or repel one another .
Problem 1st.-To determine the equilibrium of a homogeneous mass of fluid which is entirely at liberty , when the accelerating forces are known functions of the coordinates of their point of action .
The equilibrium of a mass of fluid which is entirely at liberty , can depend only upon the action of such forces as tend to change the relative position of the particles with respect to one another .
It is not affected by any motion common to all the particles , nor by any force which acts upon them all with the same intensity in the same direction ; the effect of such motion , or of such force , being to displace the centre of gravity of the whole mass without altering the relative situation of the particles .
In estimating the accelerating forces upon which the figure of equilibrium will depend , we must therefore begin with reducing the centre of gravity , if it be in motion or urged by any force , to a state of relative rest ; which is accomplished by applying to every particle a force that would cause it to move with the same velocity as the centre of gravity , but in a contrary direction .
In the investigation of this problem we may therefore suppose that the centre of gravity is at rest and undisturbed by the action of any accelerating force .
Suppose now that a mass of homogeneous fluid entirely at liberty , is in equilibrium , and conceive three planes intersecting at right angles in the centre of gravity of the mass , to which planes the particles of the fluid are to be referred by rectangular coordinates .
Let x , y , z , represent the coordinates of a particle , and having resolved the accelerating forces acting upon it into other forces that have their directions parallel to the coordinates , put X , Y , Z , for the sums of the resolved parts respectively parallel to x , y , z , and tending to shorten these lines .
According to the hypothesis of this problem , the forces X , Y , Z , depend only upon the coordinates of their point of action ; and they are at every point the same functions of those coordinates .
The equilibrium will therefore be impossible unless Xdx + Ydy + Zdz be an exact differential , this being necessary in order that the hydrostatic pressure be a function of three independent variables as the fundamental assumption of the theory demands .
Let p denote the integral , and p the 122 hydrostatic pressure at the point ( x2 , y , z , ) : the equations that determine the equilibrium will be these two * , = ( Xdx + Ydy+ Zdz ) , } p= C- .
If we make p= 0 , we shall obtain the equation of the outer surface of the fluid , viz. p=C .
The differential equation , dx+ d die +z dl d3c+ die die +z dz= 0 , or which is the same , Xdx+ Ydy + Zdz =0 , is common to the outer surface and to all the interior level surfaces at every point of which there is the same intensity of pressure ; and it shows that the resultant of the accelerating forces is perpendicular to all such surfaces ~ .
The figure of the fluid being determined , it remains to inquire whether the equilibrium is secured .
By varying the coordinates in the formula for p , we obtain dx die dz -p +d zx + ?
+y + d-z =o .
which equation proves that , if a particle be moved from its place a very little in any direction , the variation of the intensity of pressure is equal and opposite to the action of the accelerating forces .
A particle has therefore no tendency to move from inequality of pressure .
But we must not from this hastily conclude that there is no cause tending to change the figure of the fluid .
For , as in the simple case of a fluid contained in a vessel , the equilibrium requires not only that the accelerating forces balance the inequality of pressure , but likewise that the total pressures tending outward at the boundaries of the mass , be supported by the sides of the vessel ; so in the problem under consideration , there being no external support , the figure of the fluid will not be permanent unless the pressures propagated inward , which increase as any point sinks deeper below the surface , mutually compensate and destroy one another .
Some further discussion is therefore necessary in order to prove that the equilibrium is completely established .
The function p , in which we may suppose there is no constant quantity , can contain no term having the coordinates for divisors ; for , were this the case , the pressure would be infinite at all those points where such coordinates are equal to zero .
Let the terms of p be arranged in homogeneous expressions of one , two , three , &amp;c. dimensions ; then = ( Alx +A2y + A3 ) + ( B1 x2 +B B232 + B3 + By B5xBz+ B , y z ) + ( D x3+ D2y3 + D3 3+ D4 2y+ &amp;c. ) + &amp;c. Differentiate this expression , and after the operations put -0 , y-0 , z 0 : then dx " dy-A dz A3 But the differentials of p are no other than the expressions of the accelerating forces acting on a particle ; consequently A1 , A2 ' A3 are the forces in action at the origin of the coordinates , that is , at the centre of gravity of the mass .
Wherefore , according to what was observed , we shall have A-=0 , A2=0 , A3=0 , p= ( Bi2 + B2 2+ B3 2+ B4xY + B5 Xz + B ; y z ) + ( D1 X3 + D2Y3 +3 3+ D4 xSY + &amp; C. ) + &amp;c. lThat the expression of p must be of this form is required by the nature of the problem : for ?
must be always positive , and it must increase continually from the centre of gravity to the surface of the fluid .
Let us now put x=r cos 0=r e , y == r sin 0 cos = r , z=r sin 0 sin = r , 124 then r will be the line drawn from the centre to the point ( x , y , z ) ; and the arcs 0 and 4 determine the direction of r , 0 being the angle between r and the axis of the coordinates parallel to x , and A4 the angle which the plane containing r and the same axis makes with the plane of x , y. By substituting , we get p= r2 ( B1 i2 + B2 q2 + B3 +2 ?
_ B4 n+ B5 e$+ B6 )+ r3 ( D1 3+ D2 43+ D3 3+D2+ &amp;c. ) + &amp;c. The symbols f , 7 , $ , represent three rectangular coordinates of a point in the surface of a sphere having unit for its radius ; and , in order to simplify , I shall write Q2 , Q3 , and generally Q , for homogeneous functions of I , n , 4 , of two , three , and n dimensions : then , d= r2Q2 r3 Q3 + r4 Q , + &amp;c. For the sake of distinction , let R represent a line drawn from the centre of gravity to the surface of the fluid ; and ra line drawn from the same centre to any interior point at which the pressure is p , the directions in which R and r are drawn being determined by the arcs 0 and , : the equation of the fluid 's surface , and the expression of p , will be as follows , C= R2 Q2 + R3 Q3 + R4 Qn + &amp;c. p=C(r2Q2+r3Q3+r4Q + &amp;c. ) By mneans of these equations a radius , R or r , will be known when the arcs b and A4 which determine its direction are assumed ; and in this manner we may find all the points of the outer surface , and of any interior level surface in which p has any assigned value less than C. All these surfaces will return into themselves and enclose a space : because in whatever direction we proceed from the centre of gravity to the surface , the function p passes through every gradation of magnitude between zero and the maximum .
It is now easy to complete the demonstration of the equilibrium .
A stratum of the fluid between the outer surface and any interior level surface will evidently be in equilibrium , if we suppose that the level surface maintains its figure , or rather , that there are no forces urging the particles contained within that surface : for , the upper part of the stratum cuts the resultant of the forces 125 at right angles , and the fluid presses perpendicularly and with the same intensity at every point of the lower surface which supports the stratum .
What is here affirmed is true , however near the level surface be to the centre of gravity ; and as the accelerating forces urging the particles within the surface decrease without limit in approaching that centre , they may finally be regarded as evanescent when the internal body of fluid is no more than a drop occupying the centre of gravity .
Wherefore , by taking the radius of the level surface small enough , the enclosed fluid may be considered free from any accelerating forces , and subject only to the external pressures ; and , these being perpendicular to the surface , and acting with the same intensity , the whole mass of fluid will be in equilibrium by the known laws of hydrostatics .
It may be proper to add that the mass of fluid has no tendency to turn upon an axis .
For no motion of this kind can be produced by the pressures propagated inward from the surface , the directions of which pass through the centre of gravity .
Neither can the accelerating forces urging the particles , cause any such motion , these being wholly employed in counteracting the inequality of pressure .
For the sake of illustrating the problem we have solved , we shall add one example , which is besides intimately connected with the principal subject of our research .
Example.-To determine the figure of equilibrium of a homogeneous mass of fluid entirely at liberty , the particles being supposed to attract one another with a force directly proportional to the distance at the same time that they are urged by a centrifugal force caused by rotation about an axis .
At first view the proposed problem may seem one in which the accelerating forces depend upon the figure of the fluid , since it is supposed that every particle is attracted by every other .
But , in the particular law of attraction assumed , the force which urges any particle is directed to the centre of gravity of the whole mass of matter , and is proportional to the distance from that point * .
The hypothesis of the problem is therefore equivalent to the supposition that the particles of the fluid are attracted to a fixed centre with a force proportional to the distance ; so that the accelerating forces are independent of the figure of the fluid .
As the centre of gravity of a mass of fluid in equilibrium must be free from the action of any force , except what is common to all the particles ; and as the attractions of the particles balance one another at that point ; the centrifugal force must likewise be evanescent at the same point , and consequently the axis of rotation must pass through it .
Let three planes intersecting at right angles , one being perpendicular to the axis of rotation , pass through the centre of gravity ; and assuming any particle of the fluid , let r denote its distance from the same centre , and x , y , z its coordinates , z being parallel to the axis of rotation : further , let g represent the attractive force of the whole mass of fluid at the distance equal to unit from the centre of gravity ; and f the centrifugal force ( that is , its proportion to g ) at the distance equal to unit from the axis of rotation : then gr will be the central attraction urging the particle , and g x , gy , g z , will be the resolved parts of the same force in the directions of the coordinates : also , / z2 + y2 will be the distance of the particle from the axis of rotation ; f/ j 2+ y2 , the whole centrifugal force estimated as tending to shorten the coordinates ; and -fx , -fy , the resolved parts of the same force , parallel to x and y : collecting , now , the partial forces which urge the particle in the respective directions of the coordinates , we shall find , X=(g -f)x , Y= ( g y , Z gz .
The equations of equilibrium will , therefore , be p =f(Xdx+ Ydy Zdz ) = { ( g -f ) ( 2 +y2 ) +gz2 } , p=C{ ( g -f ) ( x2 +y2 ) +g 2 } The equation of the surface of the fluid will be found by making p= 0 , viz. c= ( g f ) ( 2 + y2 ) +Ig 2 .
And , if we put e2 -= , the same equation may be thus written , i2 -m2 eqy2 t , --which belongs to an elliptical spheroid of revolution having the equatorial semidiameter equal to a , and the polar ?
semi-axis to a ^/ 1 e2 .
8 .
The order of discussion that has ibeen laid down now brings us to the 127 more difficult part of this research , when the accelerating forces urging the particles of the fluid , depend upon the very figure of equilibrium which is to be investigated .
This must happen in fluids consisting of particles that mutually attract one another , if the attractive force acting upon a particle vary with th e figure of the attracting matter .
In this division of our subject , the law of attraction that prevails in nature being in reality the only one which it is of much importance to consider , will chiefly engage attention .
Problem 2nd.-To determine the equilibrium of a homogeneous fluid entirely at liberty , the particles attracting one another with a force inversely proportional to the square of the distance , at the same time that they are urged by a centrifugal force caused by rotation about an axis .
The fluid being supposed in equilibrium , the axis of rotation must pass through the centre of gravity of the mass .
For , abstracting from any motion or force common to all the particles , that centre may be considered at rest and free from the action of any accelerating force ; and , as the attractive forces balance one another at that point , the centrifugal force must likewise vanish at the same point .
Conceive three planes intersecting at right angles in the centre of gravity of the mass , one of them being perpendicular to the axis of rotation : let x , y , z represent the coordinates of a particle in the surface of the fluid , x being parallel to the same axis ; and put V for the sum of the quotients of all the molecules of the mass divided by their respective distances from the particle : then the attractive forces urging the particle inward in the directions of x , y , z , will be respectively equal to dV dV dV d- .
dz Further , iff denote the centrifugal force at the distance unit from the axis of rotation , the action of the same force at the distance ^/ yi2+ z2 from the same axis will befJy2 + Z2 ; and the resolved parts of this force urging the particle to move in the prolongations of y and z , will befy andfz .
Wherefore the total forces parallel to x , y , z , and tending to shorten these lines , are respectively , '128 dV ( dV dV dx 'd -+ d+fz and the condition that the resultant of these forces is perpendicular to the surface of the fluid is expressed by this differential equation , dV dV dV dV d~ die +dV dz +f ( y die +z d ) =0 ; and the integral , viz. C= V+ ( y +2 ) is the equation of the surface of the fluid in equilibrium .
This is incontestably the true equation of the surface in equilibrium , since all the forces in action at that surface have been taken into account .
Using x , y , z to represent generally the co-ordinates of any particle of the mass , and the symbol V , to denote the function of x , y , z , which is equal to the sum of the quotients of all the molecules of the mass of fluid divided by their respective distances from the particle , it will be convenient to have some means of pointing out whether V belongs to a point in the surface , or to one differently situated .
For this purpose we shall put r= ^x 2+ y2 + z2 for the distance from the centre of gravity , and shall write V ( r ) for the value of V relatively to a point within the mass ; and we shall suppose that r becomes R at the upper surface , so that V ( R ) will denote the value of V for a point in that surface .
According to this notation , the foregoing equation of the surface of the fluid in equilibrium , will be thus written , C=V(R ) + ( y2 +z ) .
( 1 ) The attraction of the whole mass and the centrifugal force , which are the only forces that urge a particle in the upper surface , likewise act upon every particle in the interior parts of the fluid .
It will contribute to perspicuity if to these forces we give the name of the principalforces , in order to distinguish them from any other forces which an attentive examination may enable us to detect .
Assuming any molecule in the interior parts , r being its distance from the centre of gravity , and x , y , z its coordinates , we have only to proceed as before , writing V ( r ) for V , in order to find the resolved parts of the principal forces which urge the molecule inward in the respective directions of x , y , z , viz. dV ( r ) ( r ) + )V(r ) +f ) --dx -dy d and if these forces be multiplied , each by the variation of its direction , the sum of the products will be the variation of the intensity of pressure , which is equal and opposite to their action , according to equation ( 1 ) of the general theory ; thus , we have , zPd .
V ( r ) bX dV ( r ) d y-d ( -(y zy +z ) ) 0 ( 2 ) dx ^*Y-I .
( , :r ) d. V(r ) P-ad die %y~ y. .
-f(y +~)o ; ( 2 ) and , as this equation is true at every point of the mass , we further obtain p -V ( r)+ ( y2 + ) C , ( 3 ) the constant being the same as in the equation ( 1 ) of the upper surface , because the two equations must coincide when the interior molecule ascends to the surface .
It must be observed that p represents the intensity of pressure caused by the principal forces alone , and not the whole pressure upon the molecule , if besides these forces there exist other causes of pressure in the interior parts .
From the nature of the function V or V ( r ) , it has its maximum at the centre of gravity of the mass , or when r= 0 ; for at that point we have the equations d. V(r)_ d. V(r ) d. V(r)_ dx -dy dz , because the attractive forces balance one another .
While r , without any change in its direction , increases to be equal to R , V ( r ) continually decreases .
In whatever direction the radius R be drawn to the surface , there is always a point in it , the coordinates of which will satisfy equation ( 3 ) , supposing that p has any assigned value less than the maximum which takes place at the centre of gravity .
All the points in which p has the same given value will form an interior surface , returning into itself and pressed with equal intensity by the action of the principal forces upon the exterior fluid .
Such interior surfaces are likewise perpendicular to the resultant of the principal forces 130 urging the particles contained in them , as will readily be proved by differentiating equation ( 3 ) , making p constant .
In order to place what has been said in the clearest light , let ABC represent the mass of fluid , the surface being determined by the equation , C=V(R)+( +( 2 ) ; and suppose that abc is an interior surface , obtained by making p constant in the equation , p =V(r ) + ( 2+2)C then , if the narrow canal AamM jP stand upon the molecule am of the interior surface , and extend to the upper surface of the fluid , the intensity of pressure upon a m , or the given quantity p , will be equal to the sum of all the impulses caused by the action of the principal forces upon the molecules contained in the canal , every impulse being reduced to the direction of the canal and to the unit of surface .
The same thing is true of any other molecule in the same surface upon which there stands a similar canal Bbn N. If we attend to the conditions of equilibrium required by the general theory , it will readily appear that the equilibrium of the mass ABC will be impossible , if at any point , as a m , of the interior surface ab c , any other pressure exist besides that represented by p , or any other forces be in action besides those expressed by the coefficients of the variations in equation ( 2 ) .
For , at the upper surface , there are no forces in action but the principal forces , and the equilibrium will be impossible if other forces prevail in the interior parts besides the principal forces .
On the other hand , the matter contained in the stratum between the two surfaces will attract every particle , as a m , situated in the interior surface .
The attraction of the stratum is an indelible force not s2 131 to be destroyed , which will produce its full effect according to the figure and quantity of the attracting matter and the situation of the attracted point .
The equilibrium will therefore be absolutely impossible , unless such a figure can be induced on the mass of fluid as will set free every particle in the surface abc from the attraction of the stratum .
If such a figure can be found , every molecule of the mass will be urged by the principal forces only ; because a surface such as ab c , at every point of which these forces alone will be in action , may be described through any interior molecule am arbitrarily assumed .
We must therefore turn our attention to investigate such figures , if there be any , as will make the irregular attraction in the interior parts disappear , so as to leave the principal forces alone in action ; for , unless this can be effected , the fluid cannot maintain a permanent form .
According to the notation we have used , if r denote the distance of am from G , V ( r ) will represent the sum of the quotients of all the molecules of the whole mass divided by their respective distances from a m ; let V ' ( r ) denote the same thing , relatively to the interior mass ab c , that V ( r ) does , relatively to the whole mass AB C ; then V ( r ) V ' ( r ) will denote the sum of the quotients of all the molecules of the stratum divided by their respective distances from am .
Take a point ( x + dx , y+ die , z+ dz ) in the surface abc infinitely near a m ; and , differentiating in the surface , the expressions , d. ( V ( r)-V( , ) ) d. ( v)(r ) ) d. ( V ( V r ) )V ( r ) d. ' d'y ' dz will be equal to the attractive forces of the stratum upon the particles of a m , in the respective directions of x , y , : but , as we have shown , the equilibrium indispensably requires that these attractions be evanescent , so that we have these equations , d. ( V(r)-V ( r ) ) .
( ( r)-V(r d. ( V V ( ) ) d---=0 , -d^ =0z =0 , * The perpendicularity to the surface ab c , of the attraction of the stratum upon a m , is expressed by this equation , d. ( V -v ( r ) -V}I ) d. ( V ( )-V ' ) ) d. ( V ( ) V ' ( ) ) x. d , y + ... a dd=O ; ddx ' die dz and it is a consequence of the differential equations in the text .
The neglect of this consideration , and the assumption that the level surfaces depend solely upon the outer surface in every case , is the great blemish of CLAIRAUT'S theory .
132 which are no other than the partial differentials of the equation , V ( r ) V ' ( r)= constant .
( 4 ) This equation must hold at every point of every interior surface , such as ab c ; and , as its differentials are separately equal to zero , it must not contain the coordinates of the surface .
If such a figure can be induced on the mass of fluid as will possess the property expressed by equation ( 4 ) , every particle of the mass will be urged by the principal forces alone , the equilibrium will be possible , and it will be determined in the very same manner as in the first problem .
We have now obtained a mathematical property that distinguishes the figures with which the equilibrium is possible from all others .
We have also , in another place* , investigated the figures that alone possess this property ; and it appears from what is there shown , that ABC can be no other but an ellipsoid , and that every interior surface , as ab c , is similar to the outer surface , and similarly posited about G. Having demonstrated that the fluid in equilibrium must be an ellipsoid , it readily follows that the axis of rotation must be one of the three axes of the geometrical figure .
For , as the axis of rotation passes through G , the centre of gravity , it is a diameter of the ellipsoid ; and the centrifugal force being evanescent at the extremities of this diameter in the surface of the fluid , the only force in action at those points is the attraction of the mass of matter .
But the whole force urging every particle in the outer surface of the mass in equilibrium , is perpendicular to that surface ; wherefore , the attractive force of the ellipsoid is perpendicular to its surface at the extremities of the diameter about which the fluid revolves ; and as there are no points on the surface of that geometrical figure at which the attraction of its mass is perpendicular to its surface , except the extremities of its three axes , it follows that with one or other of these , the axis of rotation of the fluid in equilibrium must coincide .
Let us now determine the relations between the axes of the ellipsoid and the centrifugal force .
Of the three planes of the coordinates , one , which is perpendicular to the axis of rotation , is a principal section of the ellipsoid ; and we may suppose that the other two coincide with the two remaining principal sections .
We may therefore compute V ( R ) for a point in the surface ; and by substituting this value in the equation , = v ( R ) +f ( y2 + z2 ) _ C , and making the result coincide with the geometrical equation of the figure , we shall obtain the expressions of the axes in terms of the centrifugal force .
But it will be more simple to use the differential equation , d. V ( R ) ( d.V(R ) + fie ) die d.(R ) )d = , _* X d. d..- .
d. +/ y d-J 4 z ) = 0 , which expresses the perpendicularity of the forces to the outer surface .
The quantities , d. V ( R ) d. V ( R ) d. V ( R ) dx ' die dz z are the attractive forces of the ellipsoid , urging a particle of the surface in directions parallel to the axes ; and these forces , by the nature of the ellipsoid , are proportional to the coordinates of the point on which they act , and may be represented by A'x , By , C ' z , the coefficients A ' B ' , C ' being known quantities depending upon the ratios of the axes of the ellipsoid ; wherefore , these values being substituted in the differential equation , we shall have , A'x , dx + ( B'-J)ydy + ( C ' -f)zdz= 0 ; and by integrating , B ' - ] fCf x2 + A'y2 + -z2 = constant .
Now , if hi , , h " represent the axes of the ellipsoid , h being that about which the fluid revolves , the equation of the surface of the figure will be , X2 + y2+ j Z2 = h2 and with this equation the foregoing one must be made to coincide .
On account of the arbitrary constant , we have only to equate the coefficients of y2 and z2 , and the resulting formulas may be thus written , f=B ' A ' / _ _k -f-A'f C= =C -A ' .
But , on examining the functions that At , B , C ' stand for , it will readily appear that the expressions on the right side of the two formulas will not be positive , and consequently they cannot be equal to , unless and be both less t and consequently they cannot be equal tof~ unless 177and 7-73 be both less than unit : and supposing that h is the least of the three axes , the two values off will not be equal , unless B ' = C ' , and h ' = h " , in which case both the formulas coincide in one , viz. f= B ' t A ' .
In conclusion , it follows that the figure of the fluid in equilibrium is an oblate elliptical spheroid of revolution , of which the equation is x2 +^ ( y2 + z2 ) h2 , the mass turning about h the less axis , and the relation between the centrifugal force and h ' the ratio of the axes , being determined by the equation f= B'A ' .
The complete solution of the problem is now brought to the discussion of this last equation ; and as this is a question purely mathematical , but slightly connected with the physical conditions of the equilibrium , which we have undertaken to investigate , we shall refer to the M6canique C6leste of LAPLACE and to the Th6orie Analytique du SystSme du Monde of M. de PONTECOULANT , in which works this point is amply treated .
The foregoing solution , being perfectly general , proves that the equilibrium is possible only when the elliptical spheroid is oblate at the poles .
When the spheroid is oblong , and the axis of rotation h greater than the other axis h ' , the expression that must be equal to the centrifugal force is negative ; and as that force is essentially positive , the equilibrium becomes impossible. .
It will not be necessary to retrace the steps of the foregoing analytical process of reasoning , in order to show synthetically that the equilibrium will be secured if the conditions deduced be fulfilled .
For , as soon as such a figure is found as will make the forces that actually urge every particle of the mass the same functions of the coordinates of their point of action , this problem comes under the hypothesis of the first one , and may be demonstrated in the very same manner .
The method of solution we have here followed may be applied to all problems concerning the equilibrium of a mass of fluid , when it is possible to form the equation of the outer surface ; that is , when the forces in action at all the points of the outer surface are the same functions of the coordinates of those points , whatever geometrical figure the mass may be supposed to assume .
This in reality comprehends every question that has hitherto occurred ; and , as the conditions which we have laid down are necessary and sufficient for the equilibrium in every hypothesis of the forces that can be imagined , we shall not enter into any further discussion of this point .
9 .
The preceding analysis , by which we have investigated the figure of equilibrium of a homogeneous planet is direct and unexceptionable in point of rigour .
It seems hardly possible to express simply in algebraic language , all the forces that urge the interior particles of the fluid ; and this makes it necessary to have recourse to peculiar modes of reasoning for determining the figure of equilibrium .
The problem , being one of great importance and difficulty , which has much engaged the attention of geometers , and which requires for its solution principles different from those that have so long passed current without suspicion of their accuracy , it may not be improper to add another investigation of it by a process of reasoning very different from the foregoing .
Second investigation .
We shall begin with laying down the following lemma .
If a mass of homogeneous fluid , consisting of particles which attract one another inversely as the square of the distance , be in equilibrium when it revolves with a certain angular velocity about an axis ; any other mass of the same fluid , the particles attracting by the same law , will be in equilibrium , if it have a similar figure , and revolve with the same rotatory motion about an axis similarly placed .
Take any two particles similarly placed in the two bodies , and having the same proportion to one another as the whole masses ; it is proved in the Principia of NEWTON , and in the works of other authors , that the resultants of the attractive forces acting upon the particles , have similar directions , and are proportional to the linear dimensions of the two bodies .
Further , the centrifugal forces urging the two bodies to recede from the axes of rotation , are proportional to the respective distances from the axes , that is , to the linear dimensions of the two bodies .
Wherefore the joint action of all the forces is to urge the two particles in similar directions with intensities proportional to the linear dimensions of the bodies .
And as the same thing is true of all particles similarly situated in the two bodies , if there be an equilibrium in one case , there will be an equilibrium in the other ; for the forces which urge the particles of one body are in no respect different from the forces which urge the particles of the other , except in being all increased or all diminished in the same given proportion .
This lemma being premised , let ABC reprep sent a mass of homogeneous fluid in equilibrium , by the attraction of its particles in the inverse proportion of the square of the distance , and a cen/ / trifugal force caused by revolving about the axis P Q. The axis PQ will pass through G , the centre of gravity of the mass .
For , abstracting from any motion or force common to all the particles , that centre may be considered at rest ; and , as a the attractive forces of the particles balance one another at that point , the centrifugal force must likewise vanish at the same point .
Let any radius G B , drawn from the centre of gravity to the surface of the fluid , be divided in a given proportion at 6 ; and supposing it to turn round G so as to be directed successively to all the points in the outer surface of the fluid , the radius G b , being always the same part of G B , will describe an interior surface similar to the outer one , and similarly posited about G. And because the whole mass ABC is in equilibrium , it follows from the lemma that the interior mass ab c , which is similar to the whole mass , and revolves with it about the common axis P Q , will be separately in equilibrium , supposing the exterior stratum of matter were taken away or annihilated .
In the interior surface abc assume any molecule am : the forces that act upon am are ; first , the resultant of the centrifugal force and the attraction of the mass ab c ; secondly , the attraction of the stratum of fluid between the two surfaces .
Because the interior body of fluid abc is separately in equili brium , the first of these forces , namely , the resultant of the centrifugal force and the attraction of the mass ab c , is perpendicular to the surface ab c , and destroyed by the resistance of the fluid within that surface ; and from this it follows that the attraction of the stratum upon a m , must likewise be perpendicular to the same surface .
For , if it acted obliquely to the surface ab c , it might be resolved into two partial forces , one perpendicular , and the other parallel , to the plane touching the surface ; and as there is no obstacle to oppose the latter force , it would cause the molecule am to move , which is contrary to the equilibrium of the whole mass AB C. It appears therefore that two distinct and independent conditions are required for the equilibrium of the fluid mass : for all the particles situated in any interior surface abc similar to the outer surface , and similarly posited about the centre of gravity G , must be urged perpendicularly to the surface in which they are contained , not only by the resultant of the centrifugal force and the attraction of the interior mass , but likewise by the attraction of the exterior stratum of fluid .
Conceive three planes intersecting at right angles in the centre of gravity of the mass , one of them being perpendicular to the axis of rotation P Q : let x , y , z represent the coordinates of the molecule a m , and r= -Jx2 + y2 + z2 its distance from G , x being parallel to P Q ; and put V ( r ) for the sum of the quotients of all the molecules of the whole mass AB C , divided by their respective distances from a m : further , let V ' ( r ) denote the same thing relatively to the interior mass ab c , that V ( r ) does relatively to the whole mass AB C. : then V ( r ) V ' ( r ) will be the sum of the quotients of all the molecules of fluid contained in the stratum between the two surfaces , divided by the respective distances of the molecules from a m. According to the known properties of this function , the partial attractions of the stratum upon a m , in the directions of x , y , z , and tending to lengthen these lines , will be respectively equal to d. ( V ( r)-V d ( r ) ) d. ( V ( r ) V(r ) ) dx die dz Take any point ( x + dx , y+ die , z+d ) in the surface ab c , at the infinitely small distance ds from am : then the resultant of the foregoing attracting forces in the direction of ds will be equal to 138 d. ( V(r)-VI(r ) ) dx d.(V(r ) V'(r ) die d. ( V ( r ) V'(r ) ) dz dx ds + die ds dz ds and this resultant must be equal to zero in whatever direction ds is drawn , if the attraction of the stratum upon am be perpendicular to the surface ab c. Wherefore we have , d. V ( Vr ) Y'(V ( r)-VI(r ) ( d. ( v ( r)V ( r ) ) ( dd+ die yV+ ) d=-O : ( 5 ) and , by integrating , V ( r ) V ' ( r ) = Constant , ( 6 ) which equation must be true at every point in the surface ab c. Again , the attractive forces of the interior mass urging the molecule am inwards in the direction of x , y , z , are respectively equal to d. V ' ( r ) d. V ' ( r ) d. V ' ( r ) dx d ' die y dz Letf denote the centrifugal force at the distance unit from the axis of iotation ; and , the distance of am from the same axis being jy2 + Z2 , the centrifugal force of the particles of am will befV/ y2 + z2 ; and the resolved parts of this force acting in the prolongations of y and z , will befy and f z. Wherefore the total accelerating forces urging am in the directions of x , y , z , and tending to shorten these lines , are respectively , d. VI(r ) d.*V'(r ) + ) d.V(r ) +/ ) + fie ) , qdz +fz : and , the condition that the resultant of these forces is perpendicular to the surface ab c , is expressed by this differential equation , d. V ' ( r ) ( d.V'( ) ( d dV ( r ) +fz ) dz = ( 7 ) dx die dyz In the equations ( 5 ) and ( 7 ) the forces expressed by the co-efficients of the differentials , act on the same particles and have opposite directions in the same lines wherefore by subtracting the former from the latter , we have , T2 139 d d.V ( r ) d.V(r ) _ d. V ( r ) +Jdz= , ( 8 ) d-dx dd + fie ( dz +f z dz = O , ( 8 ) in which the co-efficients of the differentials express the whole forces urging the molecule in the directions of x , y , z. It is obvious that the equations ( 7 ) and ( 8 ) must be identical ; for they are both true at every point of the same surface ab c. But if the co-efficients of the differentials of these two equations be identical , the like co-efficients in the equation ( 5 ) must be separately equal to zero ; and this proves that the coordinates of the surface abc do not enter into the equation ( 6 ) , which therefore contains such quantities only as remain invariably the same at all the points of that surface .
The equations ( 7 ) and ( 8 ) being identical , the latter will belong indifferently to all the similar surfaces in the interior parts , and to the outer surface which is their limit .
Wherefore , if for the sake of distinction we suppose that r becomes R at the upper surface , we shall obtain the equation of that surface by integrating , viz. c=V(R)+ ( y2 + z ) .
( 9 ) The integral of ( 8 ) will likewise give the equation of any of the interior surfaces , as a6 c , viz. p= V ( r ) +f ( y2 + z2 ) C , ( 10 ) the quantity C being absolutely constant in all circumstances , and the same as in the equation of the upper surface , and p being a new quantity which is constant when the co-ordinates are taken in the surface ab c , but varies when the co-ordinates belong to any point of the mass not contained in that surface .
At the upper surface p vanishes ; it changes its value in passing from one of the interior surfaces to another ; and it is evidently the hydrostatic pressure at every point of the mass , becausedp d-p dp are equal to the co-efficients of the differentials in equation ( 8 ) and to the accelerating forces which oppose and destroy the variation of pressure .
The equations ( 6 ) and ( 9 ) and ( 10 ) at which we have arrived by this new train of reasoning are the very same with the equations ( 4 ) and ( 1 ) and ( 3 ) of the first investigation ; and as the 140 remainder of the solution is deduced entirely from these equations , it would be superfluous to repeat here what has already been fully explained .
The same procedure as in the first investigation will prove , that the figure of the fluid in equilibrium is exclusively an oblate elliptical spheroid of revolution turning about the less axis h , and that the ratio -T of the two axes is derived from the centrifugal force by means of the equation f= B'A ' 10 .
The level surfaces of the mass in equilibrium are properly the interior surfaces similar to the outer surface , and similarly posited about the common centre .
Such surfaces agree with CLAIRAUT'S definition ; for they are perpendicular to the resultant of the forces urging the particles contained in them , as appears from the differential equation ( 8 ) , which is common to them all .
But as every particle within the mass is acted upon by several forces , it may become a question whether there are not other interior surfaces besides those similar to the outer one , which possess the properties of being equably pressed , and of being perpendicular to the resultant of the forces in action .
It is this point that we are now to investigate .
Suppose that ABC represents an oblate elliptical spheroid of homogeneous fluid in equilibrium by revolving about the axis P Q ; and let abc be an oblate elliptical spheroid within AB C , the centres , the less axes , and the equators of the two figures coinciding : ( ( ' taking any particle ( x , y , z ) of the interior mass ab c , the attractions of the whole mass AB C urging the particle in the respective directions of the co-ordinates , c_ may , as before , be represented by A'x , Bly , B z : and in like manner the attractions of the interior mass abc upon the particle , may be denoted by 141 A " x , B " y , and the attractions of the matter between the two surfaces upon the particle , will be ( At A " ) x , ( B ' B " ) y , B ' B " ) z. As these forces act upon every particle of the mass ab c , they will cause an internal pressure ; let p ' denote the hydrostatic pressure at the point ( x , y , z ) caused by the attraction of the external matter ; then , by the general theory , we shall have dp ' + ( A ' A " ) x dv + ( B'--B " ) ( ydy +z dz ) 0 ; and , by integrating , p ' = C'(A ' A")(B B). .
( 11 Further , the joint effect of the centrifugal force and the attraction of the whole mass ABC upon the particle ( x , y , z ) in the respective directions of the coordinates , is expressed by these forces , A ' , ( B'-f ) , ( B ' -f ) z : and if p be the pressure thence arising , we shall have dp + A'xdx + ( B'-f ) ( ydy + zdz ) = 0 ; and consequently , = CA ' 2 ( B'-/ ) ( 12 ) which is equivalent to the equation ( 10 ) , and expresses the whole hydrostatic pressure at every point ( x , y , z ) within the mass AB C. In order to form a just notion of the pressures p and p ' , we shall suppose that the point ( x , y , z ) is in the interior surface , at a m : conduct a narrow canal from G to a m , and continue it outward to the upper surface of the fluid , at A M. Now p is the effort of all the molecules in the canal AamM produced by all the forces that urge them along the canal ; and p ' is the effort of the canal aGm caused by the attraction of the matter between the two surfaces upon the particles contained in the canal .
The pressure p is always directed inward ; but the direction in which p ' acts will depend upon the nature of the interior spheroid .
If it be more oblate than the exterior spheroid AB C , A " will be greater than A ' , and the attraction ( A ' A " ) an tending from the equator , the pressure of the canal aGm will be outward and opposed to that of the canal Aam M. On this supposition , therefore , the whole action of the matter exterior to the spheroid abc will cause a pressure upon the molecule a m , equal to p p ' .
By subtracting the equations ( 11 ) and ( 12 ) we get ?
+ z " p-p -= CC'-A " ( B"-/ ) .
( 13 ) and we have now to inquire whether a spheroid can be found that will satisfy this equation , on the supposition that p p ' is the same at all the points of the surface of the spheroid .
The equation ( 13 ) evidently comprehends the level surfaces , which are similar and similarly situated to the upper surface AB C : for , on the supposition that the figures are similar , we have A ' A " , B'B " , p ' = C ' , and the equation ( 13 ) is identical to the equation ( 12 ) which , by giving different values to p , determines all the level surfaces .
The equation ( 13 ) is similar in its form to the equation ( 12 ) , A " and B " being the same functions of the excentricity of the spheroid ab c , that A ' and B ' are , of the excentricity of the spheroid AB C ; and the centrifugal forcef enters alike into both equations .
It is therefore evident that the solution of the latter , supposing p constant , and the solution of the former supposing p p ' constant are both contained in the equation , f= B'-h A ' and , as from this two values of ^ are in general obtained , one of these results determines the spheroid ABC and its level surfaces , and the other determines the interior spheroid ab c , the surface of which sustains the same pressure at every point by the action of the exterior fluid , and which is therefore separately in equilibrium .
There is this difference between the level surfaces and the other surfaces of equable pressure , that the former spread through the whole mass and ultimately coincide with the upper surface , whereas the latter , on account of the dissimilarity of figure , are confined to a part of the mass .
Of the two spheroids 143 answering to the same centrifugal force , when the exterior one is the less oblate , the greatest interior surface of equable pressure , which is not a level surface , stands upon the equator ; and the rest are within this , similar and concentric to it , as in this figure When the exterior spheroid is the more oblate of the two , the greatest interior surface is described on the less axis , and the rest are similar and concentric to it , as thus , When the centrifugal force f has a certain relation to the attractive force , the two dissimilar spheroids ABC and abc coincide in one ; and in this case there are no interior surfaces of equable pressure except the level surfaces .
It has now been demonstrated that , in every oblate spheroid in equilibrium by a rotatory motion , there are two sets of interior surfaces equably pressed by the action of the exterior fluid ; and , in consequence , that there are two different figures of equilibrium , and only two answering to the same velocity of rotation .
But in the hypothesis of the first problem of this paper , and according to the theory of CLAIRAUT , which as far as regards a fluid entirely at liberty , is equivalent to that problem , there is in every case of equilibrium , only one set of interior surfaces equably pressed by the exterior fluid ; and this is an incontrovertible proof that the theory of the French geometer is insufficient for determining the figure of equilibrium of a homogeneous planet in a fluid state .
144 first demonstrated synthetically the equilibrium of an oblate elliptical spheroid when it revolves about the less axis with a certain angular velocity .
In examining the equation of the surface of the fluid , D'ALEMBERT discovered that it admitted of being solved more than one way , that is , he found that there are spheroids of different oblateness which will be in equilibrium with the same velocity of rotation ; and LAPLACE proved that there are two such spheroids and no more .
Of this truth , first made known merely as a mathematical deduction from an algebraic equation , we have here attempted to give the physical explanation .
H1aving now fully treated of the equilibrium of a homogeneous fluid , the order of discussion laid down would lead us to investigate that of one of variable density ; but the length of this paper makes it advisable to reserve this part of our subject for another occasion .

