On the probable Electric Origin of all the Phenomena of Terrestrial Magnetism ; with an illustrative Experiment .
By PETER BARLOW , Esq. F.R.S. Cor. Mem. Inst. of France , of the Imperial Academy of St. Petersburgh , Sc. 8c .
Read January 27 , 1831 .
IN order to show the incompatibility of the observed laws of terrestrial magnetism with the supposition of the earth itself being a magnet , and at the same time their accordance with the laws which appertain to a body whose magnetismis iinduced by electricity , it will be necessary totake a retrospective view of the several discoveries which have been made , connected with these subjects , since the commencement of the present century , and particularly within the last ten or twelve years .
Up to the period of the scientific travels of M. HUMBOLDT , it must be admitted that all the facts with which we were acquainted , relative to terrestrial magnetism , were a mere collection of observations and phenomena , uncertain in themselves , unconnected with each other , and irreducible to any specific laws ; but the confidence inspired by the high character of this distinguished traveller , his accuracy of observation , and the perfection of his instruments , gave a new feature to the inquiry , and laid the foundation of our present knowledge in this science .
M. BIOT was the first to undertake the difficult task of reducing these results to some principle of calculation .
Considering the earth as a magnet , he assumed an indeterminate distance to represent the distance of its two poles ; and then , supposing their power to vary inversely as the square of their distance from the point on which they acted , ( a law which had been already established , ) he obtained a general expression for the direction of a magnetic needle .
He then made his indeterminate distance vary ; and comparing at every step his results with those observed , it was found that the nearer the poles were made to approach , the nearer the computed and observed results corresponded ; and finally , that the errors were reduced to a minimum when the two poles were coincident , or indefinitely near to each other .
o2 This is a highly important determination as it relates to the present inquiry ; for here we have at once a demonstration that the earth is not a magnet , or at least that it does not act according to the laws of a permanent magnetic body , the distinguishing characteristic of which is , the existence of two poles , distinct and distant from each other ; whereas it is shown by this investigation , that in the earth these two poles are indefinitely near to each other and to the earth 's centre .
M. BIOT'S results , however , in consequence of the generality he had given to his first assumption , were involved in a very intricate formlula ; but in the mean time a similar task had been undertaken by M. KRAFT , of St. Petersburgh , on different principles .
This philosopher contented himself with attempting to determine empyrically some mathematical formula to connect the different , dip observations with each other ; and he discovered this very simple relation , viz. " ' That the tangent of the dip of the needle in any place is equal to double the tangent of the magnetic latitude of that place .
" M. BIOT , in consequence of this deduction , re-examined his former investigation , and found that his formula after certain reductions , of which he was not before aware it was susceptible , became identical with that of M. KRAFT ; and thus the fundamental law of terrestrial magnetism was confirmed by two philosophers acting apart and independently of each other , and on principles entirely different .
It followed also from M. BIOT'S formulae , that the intensity of the dipping needle ought to vary inversely as the square root of 4 minus 3 times the square of the sine of the dip ; and that of the horizontal needle inversely as the square root of 3 plus the square of the secant of the dip : conditions which have since been verified , at least approximatively , by observations , extending-even to within one or two degrees of the pole itself .
And these laws , I beg again to repeat , are entirely inconsistent with those which appertain to a permanent magnetic body , while they will be shown , in what follows , to be the fundamental laws of a body which receives its transient magnetism by induction .
We see thus how it happened , that those philosophers of the last century , who endeavoured to illustrate the laws of terrestrial magnetism by what they called terrelle , or round natural magnets , with distinct poles , failed in all their attempts on this subject to establish any mathematical principle of calculation .
It has been seen that up to the year 1809 , the phenomena of terrestrial magnetism had resisted every prior attenlpt to reduce them to the power of analysis .
It will now be necessary to refer to those which relate to the reciprocal action of iron bodies and a magnetic needle on each other , which were still more uncertain , and apparently more anomalous , than the former .
In 1819 I undertook this investigation , and , after an extensive series of experiments , I succeeded in reducing this reciprocal action likewise to very simple laws , derived empyrically from the results I had obtained , but which were obviously only approximative , although the approximation was very close : in the course of these experiments also a very remarkable fact was discovered ; namely , that all the magnetic power of an iron sphere resides on its surface .
These first experiments , with the exception of the fact last mentioned , which I had not then discovered , were presented to the Royal Society in 1819 .
I afterwards extended my first researches , and published the whole in a small tract , entitled , " An Essay on Magnetic Attraction .
" The simplicity of these results , and particularly the circumstance of the magnetic power residing on the surface only of the sphere , led Mr. CHARLES BONNYCASTLE , ( at present mathematical professor in the University of Virginia , ) to undertake an investigation of the laws which an iron sphere ought to exhibit according to a certain hypothesis relative to induced magnetism ; and he succeeded in eliciting most of the formulae I had obtained empyrically from my experiments .
In the second edition of my Essay , I also examined the subject analytically , making a slight alteration in the hypothesis employed by Professor BONNYCASTLE ; and by this means have been enabled to deduce all my experimental laws without exception , and to supply the small corrective part which was obviously wanted in the several formulae as they were first obtained .
Since that time , M. POISSON has employed his powerful analysis to investigate the subject in all its generality ; and I have had the satisfaction of seeing confirmed by so distinguished a mathematician all my original propositions ; and an action considered till that time anomalous , reduced to laws nearly as general and certain as those which govern the planetary motions .
The application of these deductions to the present inquiry is important .
It follows from these laws , that if an iron sphere , such as we have supposed in a transient state of magnetic induction , be made to act upon a magnetic needle , isolated from the terrestrial magnetism , it will produce in that needle all the 101 phenomena which M. HUMBOLDT observed , and which MM .
BIOT and KRAFT reduced to determinate laws of action * ; the two poles in this case , as in that , being indefinitely near to each other , and to the centre of the sphere .
Hence then it follows , 1 .
That the laws of terrestrial magnetism are inconsistent with those which belong to a permanent magnetic body .
2 .
That they are perfectly coincident with those which appertain to a body in a transient state of magnetic induction .
These results were incontrovertible ; but an insuperable obstacle seemed still to oppose itself to any rational hypothesis relative to the cause of the earth 's magnetic power .
Up to this period we knew of only one means of inducing magnetism , which was by the approximation of a permanent magnet to a ball or mass of simple iron , and one or two other metals : but what body could be imagined capable of inducing this power in the earth ; particularly as the earth preserved its magnetic energy constantly in nearly the same direction , whereas its position with regard to any exterior body was hourly changing ?
Its magnetism could not therefore be induced by any foreign body ; and as no power in itself could be conceived capable of producing this effect , the deductions above made , although they would have stood incontrovertible , yet the causes of them would have remained inexplicable , but for the important discovery of Mr. OERSTED , which threw a new light upon magnetic investigations .
This philosopher discovered that a wire conducting an electric current was , during the interval of transmission , in a state of magnetic induction .
Such a discovery , at such a time , was most fortunate ; and not on this point only , but on various others , it excited the attention of all the most distinguished philosophers of Europe .
The number of interesting facts which were thus elicited will always form a prominent feature in the scientific history of the nineteenth century , but the greater part of them are unconnected with the present inquiry ; I shall therefore only refer to one or two , which have an important bearing upon the question under investigation .
As soon as I was informed of this interesting discovery , I was anxious , by experiments as nearly similar , as circumstances would admit , to those I had adopted with the iron ball , to elicit in this case also the laws which govern the reciprocal action of the wire and the needle ; and after a pretty long series of experiments I arrived at this conclusion , viz."That the force of each particle in the wire on each particle of the needle varies inversely as the square of the distance , and that the nature of the force is tangential , that is , such as would place a needle , neutralized from the earth 's magnetism , always at right angles to the direction of the wire , and to the direction of the line joining the needle with the centre of action of the wire .
" This law , with an account of the experiments from which it was derived , was read to the Royal Society , May 22nd , 1822 , and was afterwards published in the second edition of my Essay above referred to .
While I was thus engaged in endeavouring to elicit the law of action between the wire and the needle , M. AMPERE had entered upon a much more extensive investigation ; that is , not only of the reciprocal action between the wire and the needle , but also between different wires and galvanic currents on each other .
Galvanic needles , both dipping and horizontal , were constructed , which possessed all the properties of the usual magnetic needles .
The law of action of galvanic currents on each other was reduced to that of attraction ; and by 103 assuming the magnetism of the needle to be due to an infinite number of galvanic currents parallel to each other and at right angles to the axis , the action of needles on each other , of these on galvanic currents , these currents on each other , and of the earth itself on each , were all reduced to one general principle , admitting of accurate and determinate calculation .
The view which I had taken of the subject was more limited .
Having obtained a law which expressed a particular class of these phenomena , I proceeded no further ; but it was satisfactory to me to find , that as far as these extended , the expressions were identical , and that all the observed phenomena due to every variety of experiment were equally explicable on the one or the other hypothesis .
It will not be necessary to enter further into the many beautiful effects which were obtained by the various arrangements of different galvanic conductors .
I shall therefore proceed at once to describe the Experiment alluded to in the head of this article , which is intended , if not to prove , at least to show the high degree of probability , that all terrestrial magnetic phenomena are due only to electricity , and that magnetism , as a distinct quality , has no real existence .
Having , as stated in the preceding part of this paper , discovered that the magnetic power of an iron sphere resides only on its surface ; having also shown that when we suppose the earth 's magnetism to vanish , the fundamental laws of terrestrial magnetism are exhibited by this superficial action , the resulting expressions being identical with those obtained by M. BIOT for the earth ; it occurred to me , by a very natural induction , that if I could distribute over the surface of an artificial globe a series of galvanic currents , in such a way that their tangential power should every where give a corresponding direction to the needle , -such a globe ought to exhibit , while under electrical induction , all the magnetic phenomena of the earth upon a needle freely suspended above it , the needle itself being neutralized from the earth 's magnetism , so as to leave it wholly under the influence of this superficial action .
This idea was put to the test of experiment as follows .
I procured a wooden globe sixteen inches in diameter , which was made hollow for the purpose of reducing its weight ; and while still in the lathe , grooves were cut to represent an equator , and parallels of latitudes at every 41 ?
each way from the equator to the poles ; these grooves were about one 104 eighth of an inch deep and broad : and lastly , a groove of the same breadth , but of double the depth , was cut like a meridian , from pole to pole , half round .
These grooves were for the purpose of laying in the wire , which was effected thus .
The middle of a copper wire , nearly ninety feet long and one-tenth of an inch in diameter , was applied to the equatorial groove , so as to meet in the transverse meridian ; it was then turned down that groove , one end towards one pole , the other towards the other pole , as far as the first parallel ; it was then made to pass round this parallel , returned again along the meridian to the next parallel , then passed round this again , and so on till the wire was thus led in continuation from pole to pole .
The length of wire still remaining at each pole was bound with varnished silk , to prevent contact , and then returned from each pole along the meridian groove to the equator : at this point , each wire being fastened down with small staples , the two wires for the remaining five feet were bound together to near their common extremity , where they opened , to form two points for connecting the poles of a powerful galvanic battery .
When this connection was made , the wire became of course an electric conductor , and the whole surface of the globe was put into a state of transient magnetic induction ; and consequently , agreeably to the laws of action above described , a neutralized needle freely suspended above such a globe , would arrange itself in a plane passing from pole to pole through the centre , and take different angles of inclination according to its situation between the equator and either pole .
In order to render the experiment more strongly representative of the actual state of the earth , the globe in the state above described was covered by the gores of a common globe , which were laid on so as to bring the poles of this wire arrangement into the situation of the earth 's magnetic poles , according to the best observations we have for this determination .
I therefore placed them according to the mean results of Sir EDWARD PARRY and Captain FOSTER in latitude 72 ?
N. and 72 ?
S. , and on the meridian corresponding with longitude 76 ?
W. , by which means the magnetic and true equators cut one another in about 14 ?
E. and 166 ?
W. longitude .
The globe being thus completed* , a delicate needle must be suspended above it , neutralized from the effect of the earth 's magnetism , according to the principle I employed in my observations on the daily variation , and described in the Philosophical Transactions for 1823 ; by which means it will become entirely under the superficial galvanic arrangement just described .
Conceive now the globe to be placed so as to bring London into the zenith ; then , the two ends of the conducting wire being connected with the poles of a powerful battery* , it will be seen immediately that the needle , which was before indifferent to any direction , will have its north end depressed about 70 ?
, as nearly as the eye can judge , which is the actual dip in Lolndon ; it will also be directed towards the magnetic poles of this globe , thereby also showing a variation of about 24 ?
or 25 ?
to W. , as is also the case in London .
If now we turn the globe about on its support , so as to bring to the zenith places equally distant with England from the magnetic pole , we shall find the dip remains the same ; but the variation will continually change , becoming first zero , and then gradually increasing to the eastward as happens on the earth .
If again we turn the globe so as to make the pole approach the zenith , the dip will increase , till at the pole itself the needle will become perfectly vertical .
Making now this pole recede , the dip will decrease , till at the equator it vanishes , the needle becoming horizontal .
Continuing the motion , and approaching the south pole , the south end of the needle will be found to dip , increasing continually from the equator to the pole , where it becomes again vertical , but reversed as regards its verticality at the north pole .
Nothing can be expected nor desired to represent more exactly on so small a scale all the phenomena of terrestrial magnetism , than does this artificial globe : besides , we know from the mathematical laws of action which have been referred to , that it is not merely an exhibition of effects , but that if we could increase our currents indefinitely , every circumstance of dip and direction would admit of actual and accurate computation .
I may therefore , I trust , be allowed to say , that I have proved the existence of a force competent to produce all the phenomena of terrestrial magnetism , without the aid of any body usually called magnetic , except perhaps it may be said the small needle employed for exhibiting the effects ; and even this , but for its necessary minuteness , might be replaced by a galvanic needle on M. AMPERE'S construction .
At the same time , I must beg again to observe , that it follows from the laws obtained by M. BIOT , that no position of a single magnet , nor the arrangement of any numbers of such bodies within the globe , could by possibility exhibit the same phenomena , particularly as relates to the intensity of the needle .
I am quite aware that , after all , this does not amount to a demonstration that the magnetic phenomena of the earth are produced only by electricity ; yet seeing as we do , in every operation of natural effects with which we are acquainted , that the agents employed are not more numerous than necessary , it will perhaps be admitted that I have at least shown the high probability that all terrestrial magnetic phenomena are due to some particular modification of electricity , and that magnetism , as a distinct quality , has no real existence in nature .
It is true , that as far as the discovery of Mr. OERSTED goes , we have no idea how such a system of currents can have existence on the earth , because , to produce them , we have been obliged to employ a particular arrangement of metals , acids , and conductors ; but , fortunately , a subsequent step , not less important than the former , was made by Professor SEEBECK of Berlin , who discovered that the mere application of heat to a circuit composed of two metals , was competent to produce the same development of galvanic and magnetic effects as those above described ; and there can be no doubt , that if the conducting wire of the globe I have described , were removed , and each parallel made complete in two metals , that all the phenomena it now exhibits by aid of the galvanic battery might be represented by the application of heat only .
The effect of heat is so obvious in the production of magnetic developments , that I have seen a rectangular circuit on Professor SEEBECK'S principle , constructed by Messrs. WATKINS and HILL , which , by the momentary application of a spirit lamp , became sufficiently magnetic to deflect the needle several degrees , and even the minute change of temperature that could be produced by contact with the hand , exhibited a sensible effect : this circuit , however , was formed of two metals as proposed by Professor SEEBECK j but Mr. STURGEON of P2 107 Woolwich has been enabled to produce a similar effect with a rectangle of bismuth only .
This important discovery of M. SEEBECK brings us therefore , as it were , a step nearer to our object , by referring us to the sun as the great agent of all these phenomena ; indeed but one link seems wanted to connect together a chain of highly interesting phenomena , and thereby to reduce to simple and intelligent principles what has hitherto been considered amongst the most mysterious laws of nature .
P.S. I have not in the above article made any reference to the irregularity of the magnetic lines on the earth .
I have spoken of the law as deduced by M. BIOT , as if it answered accurately all the conditions required : it is however very well known that there are irregularities which it will not reach , and much credit is due to Professor HANSTEEN for the talent and industry he has applied in the collection of results , and the reduction of them to principles of calculation .
These discrepancies however are by no means opposed to the foregoing view of the subject , but are , on the contrary , rather favourable to it ; for if , as is implied in the preceding remark , the development of terrestrial magnetic phenomena be due to the transmission of caloric and inequality of temperature , we ought to expect the same kind of irregularities in this action as we know to exist in the temperature and climate of places situated geographically the same .

