On the performance of Fluid Refracting Telescopes , and on the applicability of this principle of construction to very large instruments .
By PETER BARLOW , Esq. F.R.S. Cor. Mem. Inst. of France , of the Imperial Academy of St. Petersburgh , Ssc .
Sgc .
Read December 9 , 1830 .
IN the Philosophical Transactions for 1827 , a paper of mine was published containing an account of a series of experiments which I had carried on with Messrs. W. and T. GILBERT on the curvature of object-glasses for telescopes .
In the course of these experiments , I saw so much the difficulty which opticians experience in obtaining large pieces of good flint-glass , that I turned my attention to supplying this material by a fluid .
Having , after several attempts , at length found an admirable substitute in sulphuret of carbon , I wrote a short account of my intended construction , addressed to His present MAJESTY , at that time Lord High Admiral , and , as such , President of the Board of Longitude , soliciting from that Board assistance in carrying forward my experiments .
Having obtained this aid , the result of my first trial was the construction of an eight-inch fluid telescope , at that time the largest refractor in this country .
A description of this instrument is given in the Philosophical Transactions for 1829 , and some objects are pointed out which had been selected as tests of its performance .
I have however since had more time and better means of testing the instrument ; first , through the kindness of Mr. HERSCHEL , who pointed out to me several objects that he had observed with his new twenty-inch speculurl ; and secondly , by direct observations on the saine objects in Sir JAMES SOUTH'S new twenty-feet refractor , and in my own telescope .
A few of these , which serve to mark distinctly the progress I have made , are given below ; but I will first state two or three of my own observations , which , I conceive , tend also to the same object .
In the paper last referred to , I have stated my observation on a Persei , marked as double in SOUTH and HERSCHEL'S catalogue , with a smlall star at a greater distance ; this star is seen distinctly sextuple in my telescope .
These stars I had the satisfaction of showing to M. STRUVE in his recent visit to England , and I have since seen them in Sir JAMES SOUTH'S telescope .
Another good test of the light of my telescope is found in a Orionis , marked in the above catalogue as two distinct sets of stars , each triple ; whereas , in my telescope , both sets are quadruple , with a double star , or rather two very fine stars between them ; the fourth star in the bright set , is a remarkably fine brilliant point , very near to the principal star , and in the same line as the nearest of the original small stars , on the opposite side , so that the three are in one line ; or more accurately , the line joining the two small stars touches the margin of the bright star .
I might mention several other cases of fine double stars which I have discovered , but I select the above because it is evident that both objects have been well examined with fine instruments , and that the stars I have mentioned had , notwithstanding , escaped detection .
Of the tests furnished me by Mr. HERSCHEL I shall only select two , one of which in particular serves to point out in a very precise manner the limit of power of my telescope .
This is the star 3 Capricorni , which , in the finder , is a coarse double star of about 3 ' ; but between these two stars , nearly in the middle , but a little below the line of junction , is a very fine double star , discovered by Mr. HERSCHEL , and which he considers a very severe test ; he says indeed that he requires no other , of the light of a telescope .
This star I can see , and , under favourable circumstances , distinctly ; but still I have not sufficient command of it to see it double .
We have thus the exact limit defined at which the light of this splendid instrument surpasses that of my telescope .
The other object to which I have alluded is p Virginis : this he considers a very easy double star , although it had before escaped detection ; it is however rather close .
This star I could see very distinctly one evening ( June 4th ) , the moon being very bright and full , on the meridian , and within an hour of the star .
I mention this object because it requires a certain degree of defining power ; in point of light it involves no difficulty .
Mr. HERSCHEL could see it when his aperture was reduced to six inches .
Amongst the objects which I have seen in Sir JAMES SOUTH'S twenty-feet , there is also one in particular which forms a good test of the relative power of 10 his instrument and mine ; this is MESSIER 's twenty-second nebula .
This object , which in a good 31-inch refractor has only the appearance of a white cloud , I saw in the above instrument resolved into an immense number of brilliant small stars .
In my telescope also it is resolved into apparently as great a number of stars , but the full power of the instrument is exerted , and still the resolution seems scarcely complete .
In fact , my instrument appears to labour to effect what seems to be quite within the power of the other .
I wish particularly to direct attention to this object and that of 3 Capricorni , because , where the same object can be seen without any very apparent difference in two instruments , or where it can be only seen in one , the great test of comparison is lost ; but in those I have mentioned , the exact limit of power is defined .
Amongst the objects I have examined in Sir JAMES SOUTH'S telescope , and repeated in mine , for the purpose of comparing the defining powers of the two instruments , were the planets Jupiter and Mars .
These were both more sharply defined in Sir JAMES SOUTH'S than in my telescope , but the superiority was by no means so great as I had expected .
I fortunately saw the shadow of Jupiter 's third satellite pass over the disc , on the 8th of August , at Kensington , and it exhibited a fine black round spot , extremely well defined ; and on the 13th of the same month , I witnessed precisely the same phenomenon in mine , and , as far as the definition of the shadow was concerned , with an effect in which I could not distinguish an inferiority ; it had the appearance of a small black wafer on a sheet of white paper ; still , however , the edge of the planet was certainly sharper in the twenty-feet .
Both evenings were amongst the finest this climate affords , and the powers employed as nearly as possible equal ; viz. about 260 and 450 in both instruments .
We also , at Kensington , observed Mars with various powers from 260 to 1400 , and it carried 1200 well ; with this the white spot near its south pole was seen beautifully distinct , as also a long dark spot on its apparent eastern limb .
The bright spot at its south pole I saw also remarkably well defined in my own telescope on the 13th , and a dark spot on its disc very distinct ; but it occupied the centre of its disc .
The highest power however I used was 500 , and it was probably best seen with 260 .
There can be no question of the superior defining power of the twenty-feet , c2 11 and the light is of course also greater ; still , however , when I consider that I have been comparing with two telescopes , one of twenty inches aperture , and the other of twelve inches , and each of them twenty feet in focal length , or nearly , while my telescope is barely eight inches aperture , and only twelve feet in length , I cannot but consider the comparison as highly satisfactory .
In addition to the above observations , which have been certainly highly gratifying to myself , I have also had the honour of showing the instrument to many persons , both Englishmen and foreigners well acquainted with astronomy , and in every instance the practicability of the principle of construction has been admitted ; a point by no means generally granted when the suggestion was first advanced .
Other obstacles also , independent of the arrangement of the lenses , were foreseen , which time is gradually dissipating ; such as the difficulty of permanently securing the fluid , and then , admitting this to be effected , the probability of a decomposition of the glass by the fluid , &amp;c. &amp;c. I have , however , now the satisfaction to state , that the lens of my 3-inch telescope , filled August 5th 1827 , continues in precisely its original state , no perceptible change having yet taken place in either the quantity or quality of the fluid , or in the transparency of the glass .
As far as the above observations and remarks extend , therefore , it appears that the essential properties of the flint lens are supplied by the fluid .
I beg now to state a few particulars in which the sulphuret of carbon has advantages which the glass has not:-these are , first , that in consequence of the very high dispersive power of this fluid , the correcting lens is placed so far behind the principal plate or crown lens , as to require to be only one half as much in diameter ; a highly important consideration in the construction of a very large telescope .
Secondly , the combination is such as to give a focal power one and a half times the length of the tube , or , which is the same , the telescope may be reduced to two thirds the length of a glass telescope of the usual kind , without incurring a greater amount of spherical aberration in the front lens .
Of the latter advantage , however , I have not ventured fully to avail myself in my 8-inch , because , as I knewl oin the general opinion was against the success of the experiment , I was fearful of failing in the beginning by attempting too much .
12 have therefore made the length twelve feet , to an aperture of eight inches , which , although shorter than opticians would choose to work in the usual achromatic , is not so short as this principle of construction would admit , and which in any new case I should not hesitate to adopt .
Indeed , according to the form of construction I am now about to propose , a telescope of two feet aperture and twenty-four feet in length would not have more spherical aberration to contend with , than a telescope of the usual construction of six inches aperture and twelve feet length , which is fully within the range of the usual practice ; at the same time I will not undertake to say that I could on so large a scale confine the length to twelve times the aperture , although I should certainly attempt it in the first instance .
But if the length extended to even fifteen or eighteen times the aperture , I have little doubt of making the instrument manageable by one person , by adequate mechanical arrangements , and of producing a telescope which would as much exceed the most powerful telescopes of the present day , as these exceed the refractors of highest repute at the close of the last century .
Whether such an instrument will be undertaken at present , depends upon circumstances which I cannot command .
I can only say , that if such a construction were entrusted to my direction , no exertion should be wanted on my part , to render it complete and worthy of the present state of English science .
At all events I cannot doubt that the spirit of scientific enterprise will lead ultimately to the attempt ; and in order to facilitate the accomplishment of it , as far as lies in my power , I have in the following pages described the nature of the arrangements which in my opinion would most contribute to success .
In my former paper I have given a formula expressing the relations between the length , foci , and distances of the lenses , and have remarked upon the almost infinite variety of forms to which it leads ; some of them , I have stated , would probably be found in practice preferable to others , although they are all equally correct in theory .
Of these cases , some have since suggested themselves to me ; and others will also probably be detected , by a due examination of the formula and tables , which Professor LITTROW , of Berlin , has recently presented to the Astronomical Society , relative to this form of telescope ; with tables of curvatures , both direct from the formulae of EULER ( reduced to the 13 case of open lenses ) , as also indirectly from principles of his own .
I have not as yet had an opportunity of examining these cases , but , from the well-known ingenuity of their author , I cannot doubt of finding in this memoir many useful suggestions .
The great change , however , which I propose to make in the construction of this giant telescope , is to have two front lenses , which will be attended with advantages not involved in the above considerations .
At present , in consequence of the diamleter of the fluid lens being only half that of the front lens , it is difficult to get a sufficient quantity of spherical aberration in the former , to correct that of the latter ; -for although we give to the plate lens the curvature requisite for reducing its aberration to a minimum , yet the fluid lens is obliged to be made considerably concavo-convex ( a form not to be used when it can be avoided ) , in order to produce a sufficient aberration in the fluid to correct it .
Moreover I have hitherto employed parallel meniscus cheeks to contain the fluid , which present a practical difficulty , if not a positive impediment , to good centering .
This will be seen immediately when we consider that when a lens is double-concave or convex , and also when it is concavoconvex , if the radii of curvature are very unequal , the centering may always be effected : for the line joining the centres of the two spheres , or this line produced in the latter case , must pass through the lens , and indicate its true centre : but when the lens has parallel surfaces , or the radii equal , if the two spherical centres be not coincident from the tool itself ( a very improbable case ) the line which joins them can never cut the lens , and consequently it can have no true centre .
All these evils will , however , be avoided in the proposed application of two front lenses , which , by being placed each in what opticians call their best position , will at once reduce the spherical aberration of the front lens to about one third of its present amount , and thereby enable us to correct it by the fluid lens without adopting the distorted form rendered necessary under present circumstances .
Another important consideration is also involved in this form , relative to the facility it affords of obtaining the plate-glass .
If the front lens were single , the thickness would be such as would require the glass to be made specifically for the purpose , and of course all the delay and expense of previous experiments would be incurred ; whereas , by dividing the whole amount of curvature 14 between the two , the usual thickness of plate-glass , as at present manufactured , would be sufficient , and we might have the selection from large stores of the best glass at a trifling expense ; and as to that of the correcting fluid , or substitute for the flint-glass , it is so very inconsiderable as not to deserve being mentioned ; although , if it were possible to obtain a piece of flint-glass large enough for such a purpose , scarcely any price , however great , would be thought exorbitant .
In the instrument proposed , nearly the whole expense would be the workmanship , and I must think it very inconsiderable in comparison with the magnitude and importance of the undertaking .
I had intended to have concluded this paper by giving the curvature , foci , &amp;c. which I have computed ; but as they are merely supposititious , as far as they are dependent on the index and dispersion of the front glass , it is perhaps better to withhold them .
The only object I had in making them was to form some idea of the requisite curvature , thickness of glass , &amp;c. They can only of course be permanently made after the plate-glass has been selected .

