XXIV.-On the Illumination of Light-houses .
By Lieut. THOMAS DRUMMOND , of the Royal Engineers .
Communicated by Lieut. Colonel COLBY of the Royal Engineers , F.R.S. Read June 17th , 1830 .
IN a former paper which the Royal Society has done me the honour to place among its Transactions* , a method of producing intense light is described , the object of which is to render visible distant stations in geodetical operations .
At the conclusion of that paper I ventured to suggest that this method might be found useful for other purposes besides that for which it had been contrived ; and more especially for the illumination of light-houses .
Soon after its publication , I received , through my friend Colonel COLBY , a communication from the Trinity House , under whose jurisdiction and management the greater number of light-houses on the coast of England and Wales are placed , intimating the intention of that Corporation to give the method proposed a fair trial , whenever the apparatus should be brought to such a state of perfection as would ensure the steady continuance of the light , while at the same time it admitted of being entrusted with safety to the hands of the ordinary attendants .
A good deal remained to be accomplished before this degree of simplicity could be considered as attained : nevertheless , the offer of the Corporation was prompt and liberal ; and , with the assurance that the time and labour devoted to this object would not be vainly and unprofitably expended , I was anxious to undertake the necessary experiments without delay .
The survey of Ireland , however , had just been commenced ; and being employed on that service , I found it impossible to continue these experiments , in the first instance from constant occupation and absence from London , and latterly from a long and severe illness , the consequence of a very laborious and anxious duty in Ireland .
During the last winter , however , I was again able to return to this subject , and take part in a course of experiments instituted by order of the Trinity House , and carried on under the direction of the Committee for the Management of Light-houses , with a view to ascertain the relative merits of different methods either adopted or proposed to be adopted in the illumination of lighthouses .
The result of these experiments I have received permission to communicate to the Royal Society ; but in order that the particular methods to which they refer may be better understood and more fully appreciated , a few preliminary observations may be necessary .
The more rude and ancient methods of illuminating light-houses with open coal fires , with common lamps or candles , sometimes aided by reflectors composed of small facettes or plane mirrors* , have in this country been completely superseded even in light-houses of secondary importance ; and it may be said that there is only one method now in use for this purpose along the coast of Great Britain and Ireland .
This consists in the use of a parabolic reflector of about three or four inches focal length , and from twenty-one to thirty inches in diameter , illuminated by an Argand lamp , seven-eighths of an inch in diameter , placed in the focus .
The reflector is hammered out of a plane surface consisting of two plates of silver and copper rolled out together , and though executed with great skill , considering the means , cannot be regarded as a very perfect instrument .
This description must be understood as applying only to lighthouses under the management of public bodies : with respect to those which have been let to private individuals , I have no very accurate information ; but , if they should , on examination , prove to be of an inferior order , it would only be the natural consequence of so pernicious a system .
In fixed lights the number of these reflectors varies according to the portion of the circumference required to be illuminated ; but it should not be less than this arc divided by the angle of divergence of the reflected light .
At the Eddystone , where the whole circle requires to be illuminated , the number should not be less than " ' = 21 : if it be less than this , there must be dark spaces diverging from the light-house as a centre , in which nothing but the unassisted light of a single Argand will be visible .
In revolving lights there are five , seven , and even ten reflectors on a side , the number of sides being usually three or four .
In the light-houses lately erected on Beachy I-Iead , and on the Perch Rock at the mouth of the river Mersey , there are thirty reflectors in each , disposed on three sides , each beairing ten reflectors .
These are the latest , and may be considered as the best specimens of this method of illumination ; being about ten times more powerful than the ordinary fixed lights .
In some few instances oil gas has been introduced , but the intensity of the flame being very little , if at all , superior to that of an Argand lamp supplied with the best spermaceti oil , little or no advantage can be expected from this introduction , as far as regards the brilliancy of the light , when reflectors are used .
About thirty-eight years ago the experiment was tried , in three or four lighthouses , of substituting glass lenses instead of metallic parabolic reflectors .
These lenses were 20 inches in diameter , of 19 inches focal length , and about 5 inches thick ; but from the imperfection of form and the badness of material , the light transmitted by them appears by our late experiments to be about one-third of that of the reflectors now in use , while their divergence is so small , that at 1 ?
on each side of the axis they cease to be visible .
With a view probably to remedy these defects , a somewhat extraordinary arrangement was adopted , viz. the addition of parabolic reflectors behind the lenses .
It is true that by this means some addition is made to the direct light of the lens , and , what is of more consequence , the divergent light is increased so that at an angle of about 30 with the axis , it is equal to about thirteen times the light of an Argand .
So far therefore the reflector , though but a small portion of it comes into use , contributes to the effect of the lens ; but the converse experiment does not appear to have been tried , viz.-how far the reflector was improved by the lens placed before it ; otherwise it would quickly have been perceived that the effect of the reflector alone was about double the united effects of the reflector and lens ; while at the same time its effective divergence was also greater , being about eight times that of the combined lens and reflector , at an angle of 3 ?
on either side of the axis .
This plan was fortunately never very extensively adopted ; and in those lighthouses belonging to the Trinity House , where it was tried , it has subsequently been discontinued , and the lenses replaced by reflectors .
The North Foreland , however , under the management of the governors of Greenwich Hospital , still renlains a solitary example of a method which cannot be too soon abandoned , more especially since the remedy is so easy , -merely to remove the lenses , and leave a free and unobstructed passage to the light of the reflectors .
Another mode , differing from any of those now described , has lately been introduced into France by MM .
ARAGO and FRESNEL , which rivals the most powerful of our lights in brilliancy , and surpasses them in economy and facility of management .
A large Argand lamp with four concentric wicks , the exterior of which is 3inches in diameter , occupies the centre of the light-house .
Around this powerful light eight magnificent lenses 30 inches square are disposed , touching each other at the edges , and forming a hollow octagonal prism about the lamp .
Above these , smaller lenses of a similar construction , but in the form of trapezoids , are placed , inclining towards the centre till their axes form angles of about 50 ?
with the horizon , at which inclination their sides come into contact , and thus completely enclose the central light .
By the intervention of plane mirrors , the beams of light issuing from the secondary lenses are rendered parallel to those of the principal ; but by the same means a horizontal deviation of about 70 is given to them , so that this addition to the light is made to contribute to the divergence and consequent duration of light when revolving , rather than to add to its brilliancy .
The lens , which is plano-convex , is of a peculiar construction , being formed of separate rings or zones , whose convex surfaces preserve nearly the same curvature as if they constituted portions of one complete lens , the interior and useless part of the glass being removed ; so that a section of these zones resembles a wedge placed with the edge uppermost ; one side , that next the lamp , being a straight line , the other an arc of a circle* .
The idea of such a lens appears first to have occurred to the celebrated BUFFON , when engaged in some experiments on burning-glasses ; but he supposed , what is not possible , that it might be ground out of one large piece of glass .
Dr. BREWSTER , in an article on the same subject in the Edinburgh Iiii/ I , ii Ii iP i/ I / " ij i ?
4ii / ji , , t:i 'Yi 3 i !
iii i. BIiriI i , ?
P ; Isiixaiiii jli i I : i P ; ;r , 1_1 11 .
r / I'ji iir%iiFiij = ; It E i/ iirise ai iaaiii 5 ; t i1iii s ?
iiiii ii ciiit -I : rF ii fi ill i iiii ' i:ll'i ' : ii L'ii *L 'i te ii rr ii Qif ruifi / ?
-cij Q ii z ' ' ''D IV ''I./ // are %^./ ey 2v IV / y l'./ P1121 [ w LU'~~~~~~~~~~ : *79~~~~~~~~~ K_ I~~~U Y Y~~~~~ is~~~~~~~~~~~ / 4 ' ?
[ d vld '1:3 %(r ' F. idy Zy __ F. an ?
p z Encyclopedia , in 1811 , showed that it might be built of separate pieces ; and this was an important step , inasmuch as it rendered of easy execution what was before impracticable .
To Dr. BREWSTER therefore the priority of suggesting this improvement is due .
To MM .
ARAGO and FRESNEL , obviously unacquainted with what had been previously done or recommended , belongs the praise of having first got such a lens constructed , of combining it with a very powerful lamp , and above all of giving it a most useful and beneficial practical application .
The Cordouan light-house at the mouth of the Garonne , the difficult entrance to Bourdeaux , has been fitted up in this manner ; and as the lens and lamp used in our experiments were purchased at Paris of the same makers , a pretty accurate estimate may be formed of its merits when compared with the light-houses of this country .
Such are the methods at present in use in the best light-houses of Great Britain or France .
The third and last method is that which I have ventured to propose , and in which the light is derived from a source altogether different from the preceding two ; a ball or cylinder of lime , intensely ignited , being substituted for the Argand lamps .
For the purposes of a survey , when portability rather than economy is the more important object , this intense heat was obtained by directing a stream of oxygen gas through a flame of spirit of wine : but for a light-house , where , from the long continuance of the light , economy is a primary object , and portability is no longer required , it was desirable if possible to substitute hydrogen gas for the alcohol .
As the effects produced in this manner are very remarkable and consider ?
ably exceed those formerly obtained , I shall now give a short description of the apparatus , and then proceed to state the results of our experiments .
Plate XII .
fig. 1 .
represents the lamp .
The two gases , oxygen and hydrogen , proceding from separate gasometers , enter at o and h , but do not mix till they arrive at the small chamber c , of which fig. 2 .
is a section : into this chambeir the oxygen gas from the inner tube is projected horizontally through a series of very small apertures , and the hydrogen gas rises vertically through a series of similar apertures at d. The united gases then pass through two or three pieces of wire-gauze placed at e , and being thus ths oroughly mixed , issue throug the two jets against the ball b. To prevent the wasting of the ball opposite the two jets , and at the same time to diffuse the heat more equably , it is made to revolve once in a minute , by means of a movement placed underneath the plate mz , and with which the wireJ , carrying the ball and passing through the stem , is connected .
Notwithstanding , however , this arrangement , the effect of the heat is such as gradually to cut a deep groove in the ball , so that at the end of about 45 minutes it becomes necessary to change it* .
In a light-house where it is of essential consequence to maintain a constant light , it would be unsafe to entrust this to an attendant , and hence the necessity of devising some means for remedying this inconvenience .
The apparatus represented by fig. 3 .
is designed for this purpose , and is drawn in the manner in which it is applied to a reflector , the dotted outline of which is shown .
The wire ab passes through the focus of the reflector , and upon it are placed the number of balls at A , required for any given time ; these , by means of the shears s , as shown in fig. 4 , are admitted between the plates p p , and thence permitted to fall in succession to the focus .
No. 1 .
represents the focal ball ; about two minutes before the change , the ball 3 .
falls into the position 2 , where it becomes gradually heated .
At the end of that time , the curved support t , moving on a pivot , is thrown into the position represented by the dotted line , by the momentary descent of the ring r , which , receiving an impulse from the weight w , acts upon the extremity u of the support .
No. 1 .
falls , but is prevented from descending more than its own diameter by the loop 1 , and No. 2 .
following it , occupies the focus .
The support t , being immediately released , returns by the action of a spring to its former position , retains No. 2 , and suffers No. 1 .
to escape through the loop into the cistern .
The wire ab and the support t revolve together , and carry round the focal ball , which is ignited as in fig. 1 .
by the two jets z z. These jets , which are moveable round the joints d d , enter through small apertures cut in the sides of the reflector , and are easily adjusted to the proper distance from the ball .
Wherever the light is required to be diffused equally around , the renewal of the lime may be effected still more easily , by using a cylinder as represented in fig. 5 , instead of a ball , which being gradually raised while revolving , brings fresh portions in succession opposite the jets .
In a reflector , a cylinder occa " When a cylinder is used instead of a ball , a ring of minute crystals is found adhering to the surface above and below this groove .
sions partial shadows at the top and bottom ; still , however , the simplicity and certainty with which it may be renewed will probably entitle it to a preference even in this case .
These different instruments were prepared by Mr. Simms of Fleet-street , to whom , for various ingenious suggestions , for the trouble which he has bestowed upon them , and the assistance which hle contributed during the progress of the experiments , I am greatly indebted .
The apparatus for supplying the lamps with gas is represented in fig. 6 .
It consists of two strong cylinders , A , 3 feet high , the one for oxygen , the other for hydrogen : the gas is comrpressed two or three times in each , the latter by being generated under pressure , the former by being pumped in .
To each of these gas-holders , a governor , B , is attached , of one of which a section is shown ; by which means , whatever be the variation of pressure in the gas-holder , provided it exceed that of the governor , the gas will issue at x with a uniform and constant stream ; in the present instance under a pressure of 30 inches of water .
Although this apparatus was of great use in the experiments at the Trinity IHouse , and subsequently at Purfleet , by enabling me to keep within a small compass a supply of gas sufficient for two hours consumption , and even to renew it without impeding the progress of the experiments , yet I may remark , that on a large scale the gasometers required would be much more simple , since compression would no longer be required .
This apparatus was made for me by Mr. SAMUEL CROSLEY , the ingenious inventor of the gasgovernor .
Our first experiments were on the illuminating powers of the different lights , independently of the lenses or reflectors with which they are generally used .
The method of shadows and that of equally illuminated surfaces , both depending on the same principle , but requiring different instruments , were employed * ; the former after the manner of , and with all the precautions recommended by , Count RUMFORD+ ; the latter according to the arrangements proposed by Mr. RITCHIE + , who was kind enough on this occasion to make several experiments with his own instruments , and without being made acquainted with the results previously obtained by us .
The standard we used was an excellent Argand lamp 7 inch in diameter , supplied with the finest spermaceti oil , and capable of supporting a flame 1 inch in height .
The following results were obtained : Wax candles , 1 inch Standard .
diam. , the wick consisting of 40 threads .
French lamp , Mean of 5 observations by shadows. .
1 .
= 9.1 --__~ 9. .
8.7.4 94.6 - ; ~9 ~ ?
*'7`~ 10.4*= 94.6 .
6 by illuminated surfaces 12.1 Oil gas burner , same _ .
diam. as standard 4 ---by shadows. .
0.95 = 8.7 f 2 ... ... ... .
9.2Lime-ball or cylin-1 2- ... 4 =1229 13.5 =122.9 der a inch diam. 4 -by illuminated surfaces 18.6 10 ----. .
--16.0J The light of the ball , depending upon the intensity of the heat , is very different at different parts , being greatest opposite the jets , and diminishing towards the sides .
The mean of the greatest and least intensity is taken in the above Table ; and moreover , though the greater number of observations might appear to warrant giving greater weight to their results , yet being made on the same day , and under the same circumstances , it was found that the results seldom differed , whatever might be the number of observations hence the arithmetical mean is taken , and we obtain this remarkable result , that the light emitted by a lime-ball only ?
of an inch in diameter , heated by two jets , is equal to 13 Argand lamps .
With respect to the intensity or intrinsic brightness of the different lights , the property on which their utility in light-houses more immediately depends , we have the following results : The intensity of Mean .
French lamp , Mean of 11 observations by shadows. .
= 4.1 -8. .
3.8 40 times the inOil gas 6. .
=s 0.85 fth Lime ... . .
6 .
= 263.9 264.1 and-- ... ... .
3 by illuminated surfaces = 264.4 J J These results were obtained by screening the different lights , and then placing equal apertures opposite each , changing the apertures and taking the mean to destroy the effect of any inaccuracy in size .
The intensity of the lime-ball being therefore 264 times that of the Argand lamp , a single reflector illuminated by the former will be equal to 264 reflectors illuminated by the latter ; but the divergence of the reflected light , depending upon the size of the luminous body in the focus , will be smaller with the ball than with the lamp in the proportion of about 3 to 8 : hence in such a light-house as that of Beachy Ilead , 8 reflectors may be substituted for 30 , and yet an effect would be produced 26 times greater than that of the present light , the most perfect of its kind in this country .
By similar experiments it was found that the French lens was equal to 9.1 reflectors ; and if the effect of the additional lenses and reflectors which ought to accompany it , and which has been estimated at one-seventh , be added , then the lens is equal to 10.4 reflectors .
In like manner , therefore , the effect of a single reflector with a lime-ball would be equial to 25 times that of such a combination of lenses .
Such appear to be the singular and important results of our late experiments at the Trinity House , made as they have been with every precaution by different individuals , with different instruments , and unbiased by the knowledge of each other 's results .
I see no reason to doubt their accuracy ; and the comparative appearances of these different lights , when exhibited at a distance of ten miles , to which I shall presently allude , though not admitting of being reduced to numbers , confirm the striking superiority of this method of illumination .
It may now perhaps be asked , At what expense can such a light be maintained ?
Can the gases by which the requisite heat is produced be procured at such a price as to compete with oil or coal gas ?
The data I possess for forming an estimate of the expense of the gases are very scanty , but the quantity consumed was accurately determined ; at the same time the consumption of the other lights was also tried , and the results are as follow : Consumption Expense in 34 hours .
per hour .
An Argand lamp seven-eighths of 1 gill ... .
069 penny an inch in diameter ... The same placed in a reflector. .
1 gill. .
0.83 penny The French lamp ... ... 2 qts .
~ pt. .
s. 2 'd .
The lime requires 4 cubic feet of hydrogen and 2 of oxygen per hour , and the probable expense is 5d .
per hour .
In a revolving light of the first class , containing 30 reflectors , the expense per hour would therefore be about 2s .
Id. If the French method were employed , the increase of light would be ith , and the expense only Is .
22d .
per hour .
If six reflectors illuminated with lime-balls were used , which would probably be sufficient , the probable expense would be 2s .
6d .
per hour , and the increase of light 26 times .
If this estimate be erroneous , I think it will prove to be so in excess : admitting , however , that the expense should , in the first instance , somewhat exceed what has been stated , it may in this as in every similar instance be expected that after a little experience a considerable reduction would be effected .
This is a new source of artificial light , differing from every other at present in use , and the materials by which it is produced are among the most abundant products of nature ; but never having yet been applied on a great scale to any practical purpose , it has not hitherto been an object to obtain them in a separate state at a small expense .
When this is effected , it will no doubt receive many useful and important practical applications .
Meanwhile , however ; the case in question may perhaps be regarded as one where expense ought not to be a primary object of consideration .
On all ordinary occasions , the preference of one mode of illumination to another is a question of convenience , luxury or economy ; but in this it assumes a more important character , for it involves to a great extent the preservation of life and property .
To complete the preceding account , it only remains to add a description of the appearances presented by the different lights when exhibited at a distance ; and to those who have entered with any degree of interest into the above details , such a description , it is hoped , cannot fail of proving acceptable .
The experiments at the Trinity House being concluded , the whole of the apparatus was removed to Purfleet , where on a knoll of chalk about 100 feet above the river a temporary light-house had been erected , and being fitted with the requisite machinery , the different lights were made to revolve in succession , and the appearance which they presented , as well as the duration of the light , were observed from the Trinity Wharf at Blackwall , a distance in a straight line of 104 miles .
The four faces of the revolving machine were thus occupied : No. 1 .
A single reflector 21 inches diameter , 3 inches focal distance , with an Argand lamp .
No. 2 .
Seven reflectors with ditto .
No. 3 .
French lens , with its lamp .
No. 4 .
Single reflector with lime-ball .
The respective lights were accurately placed in focus .
On the evening of the 10th of May , the machine performing one revolution in eight minutes , Captain PELLY of the Trinity House made the following observations on the different lights from the Trinity House Wharf , Blackwall , 10{ miles distant .
Computed No. Duration .
Divergence .
maximum Divergence .
min. sec. 10 25 17.40 17.81 20 25 17.40 17.81 307 5.17 5.18 409 6.1 6.7 When No. 4 , the reflector lighted with the lime-ball , was turned towards the Wharf , the light was so great that the shadow of the hand and fingers was distinctly visible even on a dark brick wall , while no such effect was discernible when the other lights were turned in the same direction .
In order more justly to estimate their comparative effects , No. 4 .
was removed to a temporary tent about twenty-five yards to the right of the light-house , as far as the edge of the cliff would permit , and on the evenings of the 25th and 31st May regular series of experiments were made .
Being-engaged at Purfleet , directing these exhibitions , I never had an opportunity of witnessing their effects at Blackwall ; but Captain BASIL I-IALL , R.N. , who from the interest which he took in these experiments was an attentive observer of all that occurred , has at my request kindly favoured me with the following interesting account : 4 , St. James 's Place , 1st June 1830 .
" My dear Sir , " You wished me to take particular notice of last night 's experiments with the different kinds of lights exhibited at Purfleet , and observed at the Trinity Wharf , Blackwall ; but I have little to add to what I told you respecting those on the evening of the 25th instant : indeed it is not within the compass of language to describe accurately the details of such experiments , for it is by ocular evidence alone that their merits can be understood .
" Essentially the experiments of last evening were the same as those of the 25th , and their effects likewise .
The degrees of darkness in the evenings however were so different , that some particular results were not the same .
The moon last night , being nine or ten days old , lighted up the clouds so much , that even when the moon herself was hid , there was light enough to overpower any shed upon the spot where we stood by your distant illumination : whereas on the 25th , when the night was much darker , the light cast from the temporary light-house at Purfleet , in which your apparatus was fixed , was so great that a distinct shadow was thrown upon the wall by any object interposed .
Not the slightest trace of any such shadow , however , could be perceived when your light was extinguished , and any of the other lights were exposed in its place .
" In like manner on the evening of the 25th it was remarked by all the party at the Trinity Wharf , that , in whatever direction your light was turned , an immense coma , or tail of rays , similar to that produced by a beam of sun-light in a dusty room , but extending several miles in length , was seen to stream off from the spot where we knew the light to be placed , although , owing to the reflector being turned too much on one side , the light itself was not visible .
" Now , last night there was none of this singular appearance visible ; but whether this was caused by the presence of the moonlight , or by the absence of the hIaze and drizzling rain which fell during the evening of the 25th , I cannot say .
I had hoped that the appearance alluded to was to prove a constant accompaniment to your light , in which case it might , perhaps , have been turned to account for the purposes of light-houses .
If in hazy or foggy weather this curious effect of reflected light from the atmosphere be constant , it may help to point out the position of light-houses , even when the distance of the observer is so great that the curvature of the earth shall render it impossible for him to see the light itself .
" The following experiments tried last night were the same as those of the 25th , and certainly no comparative trials could be more fairly arranged .
The first light exposed was the single Argand burner with a reflector .
This was quite distinctly seen , and all the party admitted it to be a good light .
After several minutes this was put out .
EXP. II .
The seven Argand burners were next shown , each in its reflector ; and this was manifestly superior to the first ; but how much so I cannot say , perhaps four times as conspicuous .
Both these lights had an obvious tinge of brown or orange .
E"EXP .
III .
The third light which was exposed , ( on the seven Argands being put out , ) was that behind the French lens ; and I think it was generally admitted by the party present , that this light was whiter and more intense than that from the seven Argands , though the size appeared very much the same .
" EXP. IV .
The fourth light was that which you have devised , and which , instead of the clumrsy word 'Lime ' , ought to bear the name of its discoverer .
The Drummond light , then , the instant it was uncovered , elicited a sort of shout of admiration from the whole party , as being something much more brilliant than we had looked for .
The light was not only more vivid and conspicuous , but was peculiarly remarkable from its exquisite whiteness .
Indeed there seems no great presumption in comparing its splendour to that of the sun ; for I am not sure that the eye would be able to look at a disk of such light , if its diameter were made to subtend half a degree .
" The next series of experiments was the most interesting and decisive of all .
Each of the lights above enumerated , viz. the single Argand burner , the seven Argands , and the French lens , were exposed , one at a time , in company with your light , in order to try their relative brilliancy .
" First comparative Experiment.-The singleArgand burner was first exposed to this comparative ordeal , and nothing could be more pitiable than the figure it cut .
Many of the party could not see the Argand light at all ; while others could just detect it 'away in a corner , ' as some one described it .
It was also of a dusky orange tinge , While your light was of the most intense whiteness* .
" Second comparative Experiment.-The seven Argand burners were now substituted in place of the single light .
All the party could now see both lights , but the superiority was not much less obvious .
I really cannot affix a proportion either as to size or brilliancy ; but I should not hesitate to say that your light was at least six or eight times as conspicuous ; while in brilliancy , or purity , or intensity of light , ( for I know not precisely what word to use to describe the extreme whiteness , ) the superiority was even more remarkable .
All this which I have been describing was expressed , and appeared to be quite as strongly felt by the rest of the company , to the number , I should suppose , of five-and-twenty or thirty persons , who were all closely on the watch .
" Third comparative Experiment.-The next comparative trial was between the French lens and your light .
The superiority here was equally undeniable ; though the difference in the degree of whiteness was not so remarkable .
The French light , however , is so nearly similar to that from the seven Argands , that the comparison of each of them with your light gave nearly the same results , and all equally satisfactory on the score of your discovery .
c"Final Experiment.-The flashes with which the experiments concluded were very striking , and might I think be turned to great account in rendering lighthouses distinct from one another .
The revolutions were not effective , and , as I said before , there was no appearance last night of those enormous comets ' tails which swept the horizon on the night of the 25th , to the wonder of all who beheld them : neither could there be detected the slightest trace of any shadow from the light thrown towards us , and I suspect none will ever be seen , when the moon , whether the night be clouded or not , is of so great a magnitude .
" Such is the best account I can give of what we witnessed ; and I need only add that there seemed to be amongst the company but one opinion of the immense superiority of your light over all the others brought into comtparison with it .
" I am , &amp;c. " BASIL HALL .
" The advantage of such a light being fully recognised , attention may now be exclusively directed to remove some of those minor obstacles that might render its use in light-houses objectionable ; and I have great pleasure in adding that the Trinity Corporation are desirous that every facility in their power should be afforded with a view to effect this object , and that a series of preliminary experiments is accordingly to be carried on at their expense .
Simple as the apparatus and the experiments now described may appear , they have occasioned more trouble and anxiety than would be supposed by those who have not been engaged in similar pursuits ; but , on the other hand , I fully acknowledge the encouragement derived from the interest which they appeared to excite .
His Royal Highness the Duke of CLARENCE , Master of the Trinity Corporation , was pleased to be present on one occasion , and remained more than an hour , entering with great interest into the details , and expressing himself much gratified with the effects which were produced .
Sir GEORGE COCKBURN and Mr. BARROW from the Admiralty , and several other naval men whose opinions on such subjects are entitled to the utmost deference , not only attended at the Trinity House , but went afterwards to Blackwall to observe the relative appearance of the lights when exhibited at a distance .
The night of the 31st May had been appointed by the Deputy Master for this purpose ; and , being desirous that the subject should be fully scrutinized , I was glad to learn on returning from Purfleet that , besides the gentlemen immediately connected with the Trinity House , the experiments described in Captain HALL'S letter had been witnessed by Admiral Sir THOMAs HARDY ; by the LORD ADVOCATE of Scotland , one of the Commissioners for the northern light-houses ; by Sir THOMAS BRISBANE , Colonel COLBY , Captain BEAUFORT , Hydrographer to the Admiralty , and several other individuals eminent for their professional and scientific attainments ; and as far as I have been able to learn , the opinions of these distinguished persons coincide with those expressed by Captain HALL , who in fact , as he has given me authlority to state , endeavoured to frame his account of what passed in strict conformity with the general sentiments of the party , and neither to exaggerate nor under-rate any of the results .
It now only remains for me to perform the agreeable task of bearing testimony to the liberal spirit evinced by the Trinity Corporation on this occasion , and to the desire which they have manifested of facilitating , by every means in their power , the introduction of this method of illumination into light-houses .
Indeed I hesitate not to express my belief that , if this do not take place , it will arise from some insurmountable difficulties in the way of its practical application , and not from the want of a full and impartial trial on the part of that body , to whom these establishments are entrusted .
I owe this acknowledgement in an especial manner to JOHN WOOLMORE , Esq. the Deputy Master of the Corporation , to Captains CLARKE , PELLY and BROWNE , the gentlemen constituting the Light Committee , for the fairness and impartiality of their decisions , as well as the indulgence which they extended to those defects inseparable from a new apparatus ; and to Mr. HIERBERT the Secretary , for his uniform desire to promote every arrangement that appeared likely to bring this inquiry to a satisfactory termination .
To these acknowledgements I may be permitted to add my obligations to my commanding officer and friend Colonel COLBY , for the facilities he has afforded me in carrying on these experiments , and for the advice and assistance which he has on this and many other occasions so kindly rendered me .
London , June 17th , 1830 ,

