Researches in physical astronomy .
By JOHN WILLIAM LUBBOCK , Esq. Fellow of the Royal Society .
Read April 29 , 1830 .
IN the first volume of the Mecanique Celeste , LAPLACE has given expressions for the varations of the elliptic constants , which are true when the square and higher powers of the disturbing force are neglected ; and he has proved , upon the supposition that the planets move in the same direction , in orbits nearly circular and little inclined one to another , that the eccentricities and inclinations vary within small limits , thereby demonstrating within these conditions the stability of the planetary system .
But these conditions are not necessary to the stability of a system of bodies , subject to the law of attraction , which obtains in our system .
I have given in the following investigation the expressions for the variations of the elliptic constants , which are rigorously tlrue whatever power of the disturbing force be retained ; and it is easy to conclude from the form of their expressions , that however far the approximation be carried , the eccentricity , the major axis , and the tangent of the inclinration of the orbit to a fixed plane , contain no term which varies with the time ; their variations are all periodic , and they oscillate therefore within certain limits .
This theorem is no longer true if the planet moves in a resisting medium .
I have also given some equations which obtain when an angle is taken for the independent variable , which in the elliptic mnovement is the eccentric , anomaly , which are of remarkable simplicity , and which , as far as I know , have never been noticed , and the developnment of the disturbing function R to the quantities involving the squares and products of the eccentricities inclusive .
Let x y , z denote the rectangular co-ordinates r ... ... distance from the sun r " ... ... distance from the sun upon the plane x , y ... ... longitude reckoned upon the plane of its orbit ... . .
' .
longitude reckoned upon the plane xy s ... ... tangent of the latitude v ... .
a variable , which in the elliptic theory is the eccentric anomaly r ... .
the mass ... ... semiaxis major ... ... eccentricity ... ... longitude of the perihelion ... ... longitude of the epoch ... ... longitude of the ascending node inclination of the orbit to the plane xy e ... .
a constant quantity which accompanies v M ... the mass of the sun..of the planet m. M+ m-= , / = n. x= -r'cos ' , y= r'sin ; ?
, z r 's , and in the elliptic motion r'2d A ' =hd t. R-m( t^ { .x +YY +z zI _I xt { ,2 +y , +1 } { ( x -^ ) + ( y -y)2 + ( z Z , ) } ( .
1 _YI 2 ) 1 =m , { rl{cos(- , )+.s , } r { _2 +)| { r(I+ ?
s2)-2r'r , ; { cos(('- ?
))+ ?
1 )+r.l ?
+))}^ f* LAPLACE uses the letter v to denote longitude , u the eccentric anomaly , and f the inclination of the orbit to a fixed plane ; but as v is very frequently used to signify velocity , and 9 geographical latitude , and as the letters of the Greek alphabet are generally used for angles , I have taken the letters A , u , and s for these quantities .
projected ae ZG V 328 aC r ' " / 1 +f'{5+2X { 1 +3 cos ( 2 ; ) + 12 ss , cos ( s'-1 ' ) -2s2 } r , 'V1 +s ?
~ +s g74 { r , r3 =-+ - ' { 3 ( 1 4 s2 ) cos ( -\ )+5 cos ( 3X -3 X ; ) 8 r , r,4 + 6-K .
' { 9 + 20 cos ( 2 ' 2A , ) + 35 cos ( 4 -4 ) ) / dBr\ cos(-X ) + ss+ r'( + s2 ) r ' { cos ( ( ' ' ) + ss , } d m1 r,2 ( 1 + s2 ) { r 2 ( 1 +s2 ) 2r r , { cos ( A )+s s , + rL2 ( 1 +s ) } dBlR _(r sin A-A r r ' sin ( A- ) _ dA --m , Xr , '2 ( 1 + sF2 ) { r'2 ( 1 2)-2 r'r , ' { cos ( '-A , ' ) + s(s } + r1 ) } ( 1 r ) ( 1 + s ) r +s2)-2r ' { cos ( A ' ) + sj } + s ) } } rI + Si 72 , r\M ( I +S s s+ rr , Let P be the place of the planet m , S the place of the sun , SN the intersection of the orbits of m and m , , SL the line from which longitudes are reckoned , P\ , the projection of P , upon the plane of the orbit of P ; then if the plane xy coincide with the orbit of m , SP= r , PS L , NSL = , P+NSL = , , P ' SL= x , SP= r , S P , = r , =r ( 1 + s2 ) RD m5S Px SP , cosPSP , 1_ { SP2-2SP x SP , cos PSP , + SPr d R\ s_ C ; cosPS P , SP-SP ; , cosPSP , Vdr =m SPr3 + { SP -2SP x SP ; cosPSP , + SP,2 fdR\ ( SP x SP , cosPSPi S P-SPx SP , cosPSP , P dr " SP SP ( S P -2 SPxSP cos PSPS P,2 } ( d\ S SPx SP ; sinPSP ; SPxS P , sin PS P ; \dahl S ~~m SP~ { Sp _ 2SPxSP ; cosPSP , +SP , }* ) ( d/ t ) { SP22SPxS P\ cos PSP'+S Pf } } dl RSP m xP , P ' SPxP , Pi , ( - ) .
=mxPt ) .
SP , SP2-2SP x SP'cosPSP\+SP'}4 cos ( , ) = cos ( X P ) cos ( , v ) + cos i sin ( k v ) sin ( X , - ) == cos2cos ( , ) + sin2 cos ( +2 v ) tan ( , v ) = cos t tan ( , v ) sin ( - ) = cos tan ( A , v ) sin ( h , )\ -U i ' ( 1 + cos21 tan2 ( A , y))* 2u2 r 329 s ( ?
-I ) ( 1 cos i tan2( ) ) r si ( )r r { sin ( s cos co -cos X sin A } cos X= cos ( v cos sin ( x ' - ) sin cos ( A v ) cos v sin ( x v ) sin v 1sin -2 ) ( 1 sin " sin2 ( % v)~ cos Xj +2 sin2 sin ( x -v ) sin v ( 1 sin2 sin2 ( v ) ) , sin X ?
= sin ( X , ) cos Y+ cos ( h ) sin v sin ( Xj- ) cos v1 -2 sin2 + cos ( A v ) sin v ( 1 sin2 i sind ( Al v))f sin P , SP= sin i sin ( X , - ) , r7 = r , cos P , S P\ = r , ( 1 -sin2 sin2 ( x , v ) ) therefore , r r ?
sin ( X X ) =r r , sin ( X X , ) +2 sin2 sin ( , s ) cos ( X v ) rr , { cos2 sin ( X , ) +sin sin ( X +,2 v ) similarly it may be shown that rr , cos -- ' ) r , cos ( cs )+ sin2 cos ( +,2 v ) s~ pi _at ( 1 e/ ) ea , _ ( 1 -eft ) ISP1 +e cos ( P S N+ NS L ) =1+ os ( X , - , ) d2x d , ,x ( dR 0 dy Yd + ( d _0 d2z Lz ( d R\ ' +- ?
+\dx )= dtS+ rs +Yd"y\dt+ ?
r+ ( t)dzJ 0 rt2d 2 dr ( 1 +s2)+2r sdr ds +r ds2 2- , pS t+ r'"d R= 2dR d-d r\ r'(1 + S)a +OdR being the differential of R with regard only to the co-ordinates of the planet m. d2r'(l+s2)-r'dX'2+ 2sdr'ds+r'sd2s r__ __ dR -r\ dtFS " +1 + s ) _dr-- ?
r 's d A ' do .
ddt -+ ( ' =0 rsd-r'+2r'dr'ds+r'2d ss / dB\ dt"-+ 2'(l + s-)3 + dJ 330 ASTRONOMYe HddV-r , d h , / dR\ ddR R --d+ +r '(+ ) -s ds r2 d2 s+2 r'dr ' ds-'2s d x'2 , d\\ fd E\ dR d +(l s2 ) d RtsRL^'J-f t dt2 +t ( 1 +2+ Id R+ k/ 0 r2d - .
( r(1+s ) + s ' ( dR ) -O Making X the independent variable instead of t , --~5 - " 2 --2 ++0 dtr ' drd t d-2 '( +\ dR ) dr = dx'2 , d R r ' dt = 2jr'2d d ' , h being a constant , dd dd { '(- ) '2 r4 d =2r ( T dR{ +3 }{1d4f 2 1 ) d2 ( 7)d }\ d0 ( { d\2 +r }{"hfr ( dx ) dx'}-1^-7~1 8=c r ' f , s/ d 7\ / d R\ 1/ d\dr ' ) dx,2 ' +s -_ ^ d1 dr d\ d dr , + ( f , ? ?
2s+ -d)--0 + h2 { ( 1 +2 ) ( d ) d ) d dR ds 0 When the disturbing force is neglected d2 1\ d.F d ' r\ 1/ r ds s d ?
0 d ?
'+ r h(I + e ) 3 d-2 +s of which equations the integrals are , r2 d =h dt , = '-{ ( 1 + S2 ) +e cos ( X ' ) s= tan i sin ( X Y ) .
If dt a_ / r ' d v , and v be taken for the independent variable rd2r , rIt d\32 ( d Rd pd dR Ifdr t_ ds( ?
\ --/ 0 dt2 dt dt x ' s d2 t= ( )2 dr ' d d2\ d.r 's ) a ( t ar ' { f , ( d-R d ) do-- ?
-~ 'j ] ] -fd R 4F\ 0 .
dur + du J -(1 + s ) s = ?
If the orbit of the planet m coincide with the plane x y , s is of the order of the disturbing force , of which therefore neglecting the square , r ' = r , x=Ad -a +r +-{2d Rr ( dr } 0 .
When the disturbing force is neglected , the integral of this equation is r=a { 1 e cos ( u a ) ) , v being the eccentric anomaly .
nt+sva esin ( v a ) t , an ~-~ 1 $-+ e)a tan -=tan ta .
If ( be put for the quantity a{ 2fd R+r( ) and the constant a which may afterwards be replaced , be omitted for the present , r=a { 1 -e cos v } sin vQ cos vdv+ cos vcQ sin vdv dt = a/ a{1-eeco -s vd cos }-sin vdvd nt +s --= vesinvQd -- , cos odv sin v sin vd v If v=f ( n t+s z ) in the elliptic theory , then neglecting the square of the disturbing force , =f(n+g ?
-)+d.f(dt 1f -fQ d u-/ cos uQosudu-sinvQsinv } du If 3 u , vr denote the values of those parts of r and v which are due to the first power of the disturbing force , tv -= a -o f{Qdc osQ cos vdv sin VUQ sin vdvr=ae sin u sin vJQ cos udv+ cos vJ Qsin vdu sin vPe cos / c sin = ec Jc os vdIe cosuJ Sn vd In the elliptic theory , ndt cos eo sin ( 1-e2 ) _ in dv -ecos v'1 cosv 1= osu Ie cos uIe os u1e os u 332 therefore , ancosAJsinhx { 2SdR+r ( d ) } dt-ansinJcosC { 2jdR+r ( dr ) }d } ( 1 -(1-e2)e which is the equation X of the M6canique C6leste , vol. i. p. 258 .
2r'2dX ' r. dx'2 Multiplying the equation of p. 114 , 1 .
2 , by dt and integrating , d- ' i~ / d R\ + 22 ( |^)d = Ao2 , if I2 ho2 -2 J ' ( 2 ^\ ) d X ' , beingvariable , and ho the valueofhat a given epoch , h dh =r"2 ( dA ) d ' , \ r2 d -= hd t , andmaking 7^ the independent variable instead of t , 2 r ' d r ' d A ' dhdt+h d2 t dpr ' ridr 'd ?
t red0'2 , 3 / dl / d\.dd r -d d -d + r(ld2 +s)j ' + ' dr s ( d = ?
, d2r'\ r'dr'dt 2r'2dr'2dA r2"dA'2 p( / 3__ ( dR r +dtj +l hdt2 hP -'( 2)\+drj -Uds/ 121 r ' 1 p , r ' f , d\ / dR\ 1/ dr'}l d ' +r~ ( 1 +7:F)2-+ s 'r dr/ 's " -r r d- ' d ' ?
dx2 + r21 ?
.s2 f1 0 / dd\ / d ?
d\ 1ds\ d2s ++ 2{(+r ) )dR ) ( d ) idR ) ds } -+ s+ , t( +s ds J -s adsj -dA'J dA | If all the constants in the elliptic integrals are supposed to vary , subject to the condition that they still satisfy these differential equations , and that the form of the first differential coefficients , remains unaltered , d. ra cos 2Cs dS ds dx{i+Sdi( Co ) ds= tan i cos ( x'v ) 2 { ( 1 +s2 ) +e cos ( ' z ) } { h2 sin ids +cos ih d h } + h2 coS cos ( ' )de+ h2 cos e sin ( ' )d=O --2s tan cos ( X'-- ) 2 stani co(- ) e sin ( '-- ) { 2 sin d+ cos dh hcos ?
sin ( x ' z ' ) de+ h2 coss e cos ( X ' d ) dr Cosisr2 sr , dR d / dBR\ / dR\ dsA_ ( T +)T &gt; ( 1 +I 2\d -r tds ddj\d '}j 333 hi2r ' ( dR\ ( d R\ ~p , cos Is drs -~ ds/ 1r ( d2'\ ( dr ' } dO 'r k d-k/ dd =0 sin ( A ' ) CO tan cos ( ; ' v ) dv=0 d ?
, ,d2\ sd i\ / dBJdB\dB ds ) , , .
cos ( - ) CS , + tan i sin ( X'-v ) dv+ { ( + 82 ) ds ) -s ) ( ^ )dd r ( dR( d=0 h dh =--r'2 ( d ) d ' Whence by elimination , / h cos r de +2 { ( 1 + 2)2 cos ( ?
'z ) +e tan is cos ( '-v ) sin ( ; 'W ) ( 1 +sS ) 5 { sincos2 r'2 cos( ' ) { ( + 2)( ( -d , ')-( ' ) ( \ } +-cos ( )T }d +s cos r i ' sin ( ' ) ( i , dR --(1 +--s ( + s ) Xdsi k2 r ' + COS sin ( '--m ) p , COS I{r ( dr ) cl^Wi dR\ 1 d'd-A d ' ) }d , , -s dBi ) -I\ d/ \d &gt; , ' }d Uh =0 h2 cos edw+2{ ( 1 + S2 ) sin ( S'tc ) +s tacos ( '-- ) cos(- ) } _ , ,~{sin , ~ cos2sr'2cos(P.\ C/ * I -P~+ ) 2 in( ( { ( 1 + )-(^)-( )os { sinS dL d ) y , \"L()}+co5Ir2d .
S cs r / cos ( \ / d+ cos c rs { ( - ) r dv+ htan-an ( + s ) ( s)-s ( d ) ^ r'"si ( = ) ( ( * , ,\ ^dR f^ M ( d -A ) ( dA }do ( dB ( dm ' ) }d '= 0 334 -rd ( dR ) _d-R/ \ds\ d ' , U r\d r ' 1 dhd }d -(-A)(d ) }d r cos ' rsin x rs If x - , ,v , --(Is)(1 + s2 ) ( 1 + s2 ) d_ , +/ ds3 +dl ) 2 dt--+ a+ 2fdR = d2r r ( 1 ds-+ d ) ( dR ) d-1+s2 dt ' '=0-dr)- ?
d r " dx ' 1 +s ' df dR dct +\dxJ =2 rs dscr d2s + 2rdrds+ r2sd xA ( 1 +s __ _L / s1 )\2.t.f 2_t ~22 d t2 I\L I'J ( dRs s0 Of which equations the integrals are +ddt 'hd d(l+s ) ( 1 + s2)2 +e cos ( k '-A ) s tan sin ( ' -v ) If dt/ rd v , and v be taken for the independent variable d+rR / d )d =0 -dv9--+r + 2J dR+r-)j r=a1 e ' cos ( v a ) } in the elliptic motion .
e ' is accented for the present in order to distinguish it from e. If the constants in the elliptic integrals are supposed to vary , subject to the condition that they still satisfy these differential equations , and that the form dr of the first differential coefficient d remains unaltered , rdd a 1r rdPr rdrs rdrd2t d2 t=^ 2 -+ _-dr duv -d = -dt d td2r ara / da\ drda du a +r -+ t tdr 2adv 0 ( 1e ' cos ( v a ) ) d a-a cos ( v a ) d e'a e ' sin ( o a ) do =0 e ' sin ( v a ) da+a sin ( o a ) d e ' -a e'cos ( o a ) da ar3 / dJR\ , ( R ).\ r+d vu + sin ( v )dR=02r daFdR ad=2 e ' 2 cos ( v a ) e ' sin ( v a)2 } dR sin ( v a ) ( ) d a.td .
" c 2( eda= -sin ( u a ) { e ' cos ( va ) 2}d R+ cos ( -a ) ( )dd frn dt+e=a dsin ( u a ) d 6d d= dasin ( u a ) d e ' +e cos ( v a ) d a. The equation of condition which obtains between the constants a , e , 3 , v , and h may be found from the equation d+ 1r1 -sd +)2o dt92 ra dr 2__ =t dts + recosi r+a~ which gives Co , s{ e2 cos21 sin2 ( v-w ) --{ + ecos(v--r ) }{ 1ecos ( v r ) } +a =0 Equating the values of r which have been found , ... .
w.l v+ s2 , a { 1 -e ' cos ( va ) } , cos s2 { / 1 +s+ ecos ( A - ) } since the origin of the angle v is arbitrary , we may suppose X= 0 , and va=0 at the same time , A 4/ 1 +tan,8 sin ( Is -vY ) so that -I + tan si -= a ( 1e ) f cos ( 1+ tan si ( r v)2 + e } All the equations which have hitherto been proved are rigorously true , whatever powers of the disturbing function be retained .
They are susceptible of simplification when the square and higher powers of the disturbing function are neglected : in this case , if the orbit be supposed to coincide with the plane x y , tan u= 0 , and if the longitude be reckoned from the perihelion of the planet P , h2 de + { 2 cos X+e+ ecos.2 } r2 ( dA +( ) dx =0 336 h2 ed~+ { 2 + cos ?
A sin A r2 ( d ) d h2 r2 cos ; ( d dX=0 d+r2cos ( A -v ) ( dR)\ dd.r d+2 c ?
s(- ) ( dR ) dX= ?
d +r r2sin ( v ) d R\ , by equation , p. 336 , line 12 , ~a ( 1 -e2 ) = h2 , and by equation , line 17 , e= e ' .
de-=-^ 2e2cos ( v-a ) -esin ( v a)2 dR--sin ( vc ) ( deda={e cos ( v a ) 2 sin ( v- ) dR+ ( - ) ( d ) d fn dt+ sa vs e sin ( ( )dsdr= -{1 e cos ( v a ) } da sin ( v a ) de de--d -a_dd/ 1 -a_e + lsin ( a)de h2 +co( =a{e cos ( v ) ) i+ ecos(A-~ ) de=--{2 cos ( -w ) +e+e cos ( - } ( ) a2ndt V/ 1 -e sin ( dB sin ( ) dr ed__andt dR\ ~~te d7 1e2 2+e cos ( ) siln ( -w ) ( d ) a dt 4V 1 -e d " R\ d -d -/ = W 2dz +2a"n(l -e)dt ( dB\ { 1 +e cos ( A--)- } dr If the longitudes be reckoned from the perihelion of the planet P , de an ( cosA + e ) ( dR\ man V1 -e rr sin A , rsinA-r , 'sinA , ' ] dt ^/ 1--e dA/ er { ,2 2rrt cos( -A ' ) + r'2t 2x2 ' d ~r a nsin A dR\ m , a2 n1 -ef r ' cos 'r cos x r ' cos X } d-~ t1 v1 de !
d{ -e r , { r2 2rr , cos ( X Aj ) + r , } Jr and since ndtad V , der ( cos A e ) / d R\ m , are V/ 1 of Tr sin AX r sin A r1 sill AX du / ed/ r/ { r2-2rr , 'cos ( -A + r } ed _= r sin\ ( d I\ m are e/ f r ' cos Are cos r cos x dov -1ed '/ it r{r\-d-/ 2r+ r { r2 r r'\ cos ( A ; ) + r}$ } d -d r2 dw are de { ( ) a " ~1 e~L do de ... . .
d aA I e " du a(1 -+ 1 sin vd2 a2 da= -dR da=dR and since r2da ( -e2 ) d t-a l e2 rdd*_as41 es r cos A / d R\ du-+ q ; -- ?
0da 1/ r sin A dR\ du 0+ &lt; ds = ? .
The last six equations serve to determine the perturbations of a comet .
Let ( A e)n be the variation of any element e during the variation Av of v at any given epoch n , neglecting the square and higher powers of A v , ( , a\ ( de ( A e)n .
( )Ad If the values of ( A e)n be calculated for the epochs 0 , 1 , 2 ... m corresponding to the values v , v+iA v , v+2iA v , &amp;c. , differing from each other by iA v , then the whole variation ( t e ) of v corresponding to the variation iAv of u=i { ( A e)o + ( A e ) , ... ... .+ ( A e ) }_ , }+2{ ( ( a e ) , m(A )o } 12{ ( A2 e)m ( A2 e)o + &amp;c. $2 }Ai { ( )( + ( d*e)+( ) } A{ de de..de .
de de 1_(i-1)(i + 1 ) de de -+ 2 dum du A1 2i du\ A tv A00Ie de &gt; ? ?
338 When the interval Av is indefinitely diminished , iAv is still equal to the variation of v between the epochs for which the quantities ( d ) , ( d ) &amp; C. are calculated , and de z A.{(V o du ... ..+(d)m +2 d).( } ference ; iAv=m -,1 or , in other words , the resulting values of 0e and $a in the equations given above must be multiplied by 2X 3.14159 , and divided by 360 ?
expressed in the same unit as iA v. n is equal to the angular circumference divided by the periodic time expressed in the same unit as t ; so that if a degree be taken as the unity of angular circumference , n= 360 ?
divided by the periodic time expressed in the same unit as t. In the elliptic movement or first approximation =nt+s+a series of sines of arcs multiples of nt &amp;c. X= n , t+ a , +a series of sines of arcs multiples of n , t &amp;c. constant +a series of cosines .
a series of sines s=a series of sines .
de d These values being substituted in the equations of p. 334 give d - , d-A and d dw X dv d , each equal to a series of sines without any constant quantity , and , -A and each equal to a series of cosines +a constant quantity .
In the second approximation the values of x , r and s retain the same form ; and it is easy to see from the form of the expressions for d , &amp;c. .
334 , that the form of the values of these quantities is not altered however far the approximation be carried .
If the sun or primary be a spheroid , w the angle which the plane of the sun 's equator makes with the plane of the orbit of the planet ; and if the longitude be reckoned from the line of intersection of the sun 's equator with the orbit of the planet ; R is increased by the quantity c{ sin sin } , c being a constant dependent upon the figure of the sun ; but the partial differential coefficients of this quantity , which are introduced into the values of d e , d V , &amp;c. do not change the form of the expressions for those quantities .
If the planet move in a medium which resists according to any power n of the velocity , if c be a constant and v the velocity , the term 2 cJiv n+dt must be added to 2Jd R , { ~ f2 dr t ds { dR ' dC ld{)+ d.r s(dR cv " -r dt to d ) , andcv -r dt to ( ds in the equations of p. 330 .
If the orbit of the planet be supposed to coincide with the plane x y , so that s= 0 , then by the equations of p. 337 after reductions d a= --'2c a2 ( a2 { D -)-2{ +e cos ut } ( 1ecosu ) du\ a/ 1e cos unnn1/ 1 -e cos n de 2 ( 1 21e co osu 2s -n J cos vdv ed =2c( c(a ) 2 { 1 +ecosu } 2 es da/ o\ =2c f)1 cos no s-.dz^=2 c )}2 S ) { l-cosd The form of these equations differs from that which obtained before , now the variations of e , a and s are periodical , while that of a has a term which de varies with the time .
d. contains only odd powers of cos v and for that reason has no constant term .
The periods of the periodic inequalities of all the elliptic constants due to he action of the resisting medium are fractional parts of the periodic time of the planet .
If the origin of t coincides with the instant of the perihelion passage , by LAGRANGE'S theorem e d.sinnt3 e3 d. sin nte d3 sin nt cos v -= cos nte sin n t2 ... &amp; C. cov=-co t-esnt2-2 ' d.nt 2.3 ' ( d.nt)2 2.3 .
( d.nt3 &amp; c e d.sinnt cos nt e3 d. sin t3cosnt e* dS.sin ntcosnt sin v sin nte sin nt cos nt q~( .
+ 4 .
sinv =sinnt+esinntcosnt+-2 d.nt +2 .
( d. n t)0 + 2.3.4 ( d. n t ) 1 cos 2 nt 3 sinnt sin nt sin n t2 --sin n t3 43 4cos 2nt+ cos 4nt 10sin nt -5 sin 3nt sin 5nt sin n t4 = - , sin =-1 d.sin nt3 cos nt3 cos 3 nt d.nt d. sin nt 2sin2 nt sin4 nt d. sin n t4 d.nt =2 ' ( d.nt ) -2cos2nt-2cos4nt d.sinnt 10 n tos t 5cos15cos +5 cosnt d.nt 16 d2 sin n ts O0 sin nt+ 46 sin 3nt 25 sin 5nt ( d.nt)2 16 d3 .
sin nt cos nt+ 135 cos 3nt 125 cos 5nt ( d.nt ) 16 cos , ^ co e ^e e3 cos nt cos 3n t cos = cos nt+ cos 2n t{ 2 cos2nt2 cos 4 nt } 2.3.4 116 If the origin of the time does not coincide with the perihelion passage , nt+5a must be substituted for n t , but as s always accompanies n t , it may be suppressed at present for convenience , and afterwards replaced .
cosv { 18 -{2+cos(n t-r)+ I -2 -2 jcos(2nt-2a ) 3( 12 5+ -e2{ 1e2 cos(3nt-3 3)+ s cos(4nt -4)+ -84e4cos(5nt-5aw ) d. sin nt cos nt cos 3nt d.sinnt5 cos nt sinnt +3 sin nt sinnt , csn .
- .
1 - .
3'd.nt -4 ' d.nt 4 d. sin n tl 2 sin 2nt sin 4nt d. sin nt cosnt cos 2nt cos 4nt simn n , Pcos nt s4dnntnt 8 d.nt 2 d8 .
sin n t3 cos nt ( d nt = sin 2nt+2 sin 4nt ( d. nt)2 d.sin n t5 2 cos nt3 cos Snt+ cos 5nt sinnt4cost =n =t 5d.nt 16 d. sin n tl cos nt -2 sin nt+9 sin 3 nt 5 sin 5nt d.nt 16 d. sin nt cos nt2 cos nt+ 27 cos 3 nt 25 cos 5nt ( d. nt ) " 16 d. sin n tcos nt 2 sin nt 81 sin 3nt+ 125 sin 5nt ( d. n t)3 = 16 et e2 Csinnt+S3 sin 3n sinu=sinnt+ sin2nt+ 2 --sn -n +2 { sin2n t+2 sin 4te2 sinnt--81 sin3nt + 125 sin5nt T 2.3.4 l 16 J and replacing nt by nt sin v 83 e".i5 ( n sin ( n t-)+ ( 2 nt 2 r ) 18 -1 _9 e4 sin ( n t ) sin ( 2 nt 2 5w ) 8 192 ^ / ,3 da )+ e( ' ) ^ .
1e3 125_e +1 ie2 sin ( 3 nt3 + ssin n t-4 a ) +8 e4 sin ( 5t-5-4 ) +8 ' e4 sin ( 3 nt 3 ) e2 e4 ee ee COS(u+v- ) =l --4 +6 cosnt 2 cos +-S z1 } cos(2nt-r ) + e23( ( 4nt-3)+)+ 125 ( no + e2{l3 e2 }os ( 3n(4nt--3r)+ s e4cos 5nt -4 ) eq3 g- ?
fcos et--s2 e3 9 8- &lt; 1 co 12 } cos ( nt-2 3 ) )-12 cos ( 2(3 n t--4 w ) ~sin ( oq ) f e " e* ee 42 e eI sinE ( u+ )1 1-+ e 3sin nt-sin ~+2{1 2sin(2nt- ) +Jr8e21 -s ed }sin ( 3 n t-2 )+sin ( 4 n t-3 w ) + 3e4 sin(5 n t-4r ) sin6-}e 1-2 3-4 + ( 1 ) sin ( nt-2w ) +2 sin ( 2nt--3w ) + e4 sin(3 4 cos(u-v)=-( 1-)cos(nt2tj)Ccos z cos(2nt-3z ) +-e2cos ( 3nt--4)cos 4 !
2 8os(ancos nt gin(o--f ( l ~e e. ee sin(v-j= 1= ( ---)4sin(nt -2 ) +sinr+ sin ( 2nt3z ) ++e2sin ( 3nt--4z ) + sin reosX = reos ( X ) cosz-rsin ( At ) sinwt= a { ( cosv-e ) cos(1 1-e2)sinvsinI3 rsin = rsin ( k-)cosr + reos( ) sinz= a{ ( l-e2)Isinvcosz+(cosv-e ) sinz}I reos ?
= a { ( i e cos(v+ ecosa 1 ) cos(+)-+ ) reos1\ a e4\ cos(o-c ) e( rsinx a sin(+a ) iY ( 1+ e sin ( I ) 8 ( 1+ S ) ( n-2 ) +s ( 2n-3 ) + e4S ( 3n-4 ) &amp;c. } reos { e e)cos ) ecos e3C - ) os r sin x -a-n t2sin t( --I ) Csi ( 2nt-f )+ 8 , ke ( 5t- , -4 ) +8 ( l ( 1 ) 3ss ( 8 s-2i ) -2 Sin ( 2nt+n , t-3 ) + il e:i ?
n ( 3nt *1 t{d%ira .
( n-2z3 ) 64/ V 26sin ( 4/ t--3zs ) f38sin o1 Cs ( CO 3n)--+24 Cos +-e , ( 1 ( ne2 ) + -{cs ( n-(4 , ) ) I e1 ( lIe sin s ( 2nt-)C ( 3nt-2r ; - ) 12I e2 e el\ e/ 2 C'sin 23'4 sin +__(6cos +ent-st-)i +(+ +e3 ( 4nt-c ) cos ( ( 2+nt---n3v + c+s ( 3nt--c 42 &amp; c2 M 2 ' sin -2 1sin 3s e cos -r-e sn ( I-2a ( ct 3 n1 2 e1 e ( 4 nt-3w-t 3 ~13 2i sin -1 3ee ( 5n1 ntt_ e4 ) ( nt-zI-z ) 3 'e , c ( nt-n , t-_ _w ) +1-8 sin 83 2sin cos ( 2nt3)YAte3 ) 12ec ?
Sn ( 3nt+n , t-4)3 X2 2 sin 2 elsinx 2-e_rq1 ' sin 2 COS +s 2n x -e e si ( 3ntq-n2t-3v)+ V ) fI+ 16sin -T sin 1]es sin ( nt + ( 1 e2 ( -4 e si(n t-2 t+(3 -2 n t-2 ee+ e6 ( 4co-2 -3+ Js n ( 3 o +2nst-2 os 41 e4e2 si 1( -3 -+ sin 2 -3 +2 ) , e2e,2 3s ( 3 c-3n S-2n --2 % , --+ ) -6 , )+ e 2e , s ain ( nt -2 n n , -2 : ) -+ c ( s n-4nt+3 , ) .
, ,-416sin ( t -3 , ) + e3 el cos 1+e si ?
n ( 2nt -42n , t-+3-)+ -e , ( a -5n-+4 ) ) sin +J ( 1 ' +ee 2 ) co s ( nt nt-2 , ' ) -ee2 O ( n , -t -2 )9 s2ns ( 2 + n.t--2 ) + ee2 ( 3 s n , t-2-2 ) + 1 % eej2 sin ?
e sin ( 2nt + 2v ) e si6 ( 3t-t3n-2-+2,2 ) + e2e , ons ( nt+3nt -2-3-2 + Ce4scos ( nt+3nt-4r 3ar , ) + &amp; cn { siX+X } = aa { ( l s 1 ) cos ( nt +n , t ) e os ( njt+ w)+2 Csi n+ e2os ( 3nt-+n , t-2sz ) cs ( nt e t-2 ) 6J sin 1sin 48 sin Cos nn ( t+nt ) +2e ( 3en , t ( n+3 &amp; c ) q61 sin 24 sin Se cos ( nt+3n , t-n4-- ) + &amp;c. 128 sinsi 32e GS~S ( " lt+s aa cos ( nt-{ -n , t--s_ eI sin ntT eel sin ( ee sin es CO_XS 3e}- , COS e+ 2I in ( n+r 2n- , t -v z ) ee , csi ( 2n , t + , - ' , v ) +lc ( 2nt +2--- ) + &amp; C. rr sin{X+-2v}= aa , { ( -- ) C ( nt+n , t-2v ) 3c+3 e2 c"s ( 3nt+nt-2v-2y ) +8s ( nt-n , t-2 +2 ) t ; 8cs ( nt-i--2nsi ) 3 cos 9 ( nt 2OS ) s ( 2 ) e , csin ( nt-2v ) + e+ sin ( +n + re , -2 )4 ee , CS ( 2nt-a+4 , -2v ) , + c csi ( nt+2nt-z-2 ) 4 sin 3 cos cos 4 esin 42G z ; --Y 4 sin 3 ee , Csi ?
n ( 2n , t+m-- , -2v ) + 4 ' Csi ( 2nt+2r/ , t-r-^ris-2v ) +- &amp;c. r=a{+ -( e cos ( n( 24 co s ( 2nt -2.- ) e3 cos ( 3nt-3a ) cos ( 4nt-4r ) + &amp;c. " 2_a2 { 1 e3 e2 ( e2\ e2 ( ) ecs r{ +--3 { 1 +( ++2 )3e ( 1 + 98 e2 ) cos ( nt-- ) 9 eell + e2 ( 1 ) cos 2nt-2 + e3 cos ( 3nt--3+ ) 31 + e4 cos ( 4nt-4v ) + &amp;c. a ?
e2 + -~01 +3eI+ TO cos +n t.z If the coefficient of cos nO in the development of { 1 cos + } a3 according to cosines of arcs mulitples of 0 is called b2 If 2a " 1 / 1.3\2a " , 1.3.5\2 aG bl= + ( +)2 + ( .3)2a + ( I::.)26 + &amp;c. 2 2 a 1.a3 3 1.3.3..5a5 bl , l =+ q.4 + a. .
a5 + &amp; C. a , ' a 2.43a , '2.4.4.6 a--c 3 a2 1.3.5 as 1..3.35.7 a6 b , =4a+ 2.4.6 a+ 2.4.4.6 .
a6 + &amp; 6 C 3.5 as 1.3.5.7 a3 1.3.3.5.7.9 a7 b3 4.6 a+ 2.4.6.8 a+ '..44.6.8..10 a &amp; =1 +( 32a+ ( :.52 ) + / 3.5.72a6 bs , o 1+'2 af +\24 ) a/ 3 5.7 2 all + &amp; C 3a 3.3.35 a3 3.5.3.5.7 a3 sb3j =a + 7.4 a+ 2.4.4 .
a5 + &amp; c 3.5 a2 3.3.5.7 a4 3.5.3,5.7 6 .
=22 4 af + '.4 .
6a+ 2.4.4.6.8 l &amp; 3.5.7 a3 3.3.5.7.9 a5 3.5.3.5.7.9.11 a7 b33 = 4.6 a~3 + 2.4.6.8 -5 + 2.4.46. .
10 ab(5 )2 + ( 5.7)2 a / 5.7.9 a6 1 +\'.4/ -a + ( 4 !
a-+ &amp;c. tgt~ ~~a ; ~tl 5.5.7 as 5.7.5.7.9 a5 + 2.4 a ' 2.4.4.6 5+ &amp; C. b5 .
= 5a a , 5.7 a 5.5.7.9 a4 b,2 4a+ 2.4.6 a+ _5.7.9 a3 5.5.7.9.11 b5sS = 4.6 a3 + 2.4.6.8 b3,3 =3 a { bs,0bs 5,2 } 3a2 3,2= 1s , , b , ,3 3 b3,3 =+ { b 2 b)5,4 } 5.7.5.7.9.11 a6 2.4.4.6.8 a/ 6 9C as 5.7.5.7.9.11.13 a7 '+ 2 4.4.6.8.10 a7 bil a b'0 I 6,2 } 2 b,2 = b31 b3 3 b1i3 ] a{b 2 3 , R =m , ( r r , cos ( X X , 1 - &gt; r1 { rs2 rr ' cos ( A A ; ) + r , }/ and since rr ' C ( - ) = r , cos2 cos ( + --2 , ) }- , p. 33O ; 346 bs,4 PRn =r{rrl { cos9 cos ( A - ) + sin 2 cos ( A +x2 v ) er rr { coscos ( A A ) + sin c+ 2 ) + r , Neglecting the cubes and higher powers of e ( in2 e2 -ee,2 3 R=-m , -( -sin2-cos(nt-n t)---ecos(n , t-t ) e , cos(nt-)c e3+ os ( 2 nt n , t -- ) + cos ( nt 2n t+z ) +e cos ( 3 nt -n , t-2 ) 32 +--8 e2c os ( nt-3 n , t 2 ) cos ( nt+nt-2 ) t8 cos(nt+nt 2 % ) 933+ Tee , cos ( a ) qee , os(2nt-.-- ) ee , cos(2n , t , ) + cs(2 2nt--a+ +Sn2cos(2nt-2-+ ) cos(nt+njt-2y ) 1+e+3 e , cos(n , t- ) + e,2cos ( 2n , t-2 + ) + &amp;c. -m1{a2 { 1+ e22ecos ( nt cos(2 nt2 ) 2aa { ( 1-sin2-n e9 ) cos ( nt-t ) t ecos(nt- ) Cose e ( n(t_nlt_ ) ecos(nt-)+ cos(2 cos ( ( nt-nt- ) n cos ( nt--2n , t ?
+ ' ) +4 e2cos(3nt--n , t2a ) + -8 e2cos(nt -3n , t +2 , )-+ 8 cos(nt+ n , t2r ) 93+ -cos(nt-+ n , t--2 , ) +-4 eecos(ar- ) -ee , os(2nt - ) 3 eI 4 ee , cos(2n , t - , ) + cos(2nt-2n , t-+ s ) + sin2 cos ( nt + n , t2 ) } +2 { 1+ e2 2e , cos ( n , t- , ) cos(2n , t2 , ) + &amp;c. } } terms independent of b ?
I { b1 , o + &amp; bl , cos ( nt -nt ) + b1,2 cos ( 2 nt 2 n , t ) + &amp;c. +a bso + , b3 , , cos ( nt--n ) +bs,2 cos(2 nt-2nt ) &amp;c. { a2 e eo , , * ' e3 e,2 2ecos(nt-)2 cos(2-nt-2 ) -2aa , e ( nt-n , t ) 33e -ecos(n , t/ - ) -e , cos(nt--w ) + cos(2nt--nt-- ) + -2 cos(nt2n , t + , )+e2cos(3nt-n , t-2z)+ e,2cos(nt-3nt +2 a , ) 60 e9 -cos(ncost(nt-2n/ -2-)+ s-n , eecos ( 2- ) 8-e e , o ( 2 n t-s ) ee os ( 2n , t -n )+ 4- ' cos ( 2 nt 2 n , t -s +3e+ sin2 cos(nt+n , t-2v , ) } + a,2 { e22e , cos(n , t/ -- ) -cos(2n , / -2w , ) &amp;c. }4 1 .
{ b5,0 + b5 , cos ( nt -nt ) + b5,2 cos ( 2nt-2n ) + &amp;c. }{ 2a2ecos ( l-i )3 aa , ecos ( n , t-- ) 3aa , e , cos ( nt , ) + aa , ecos(2nt-n , t--a ) +a a , e , cos ( nt-2n , t+ , - ) +2 a,2 e cos ( nt-- ) + &amp;c. { 2 a2 e cos ( nt-w ) 3a a , e cos ( n , t-- ) 3aa e , cos ( nt-- , ) aa , ecos ( 2 nt--nt--z ) + aa , e , cos ( nt2 n , t )+2 a,2 e , cos ( n , t , ) }=2 a4 e2 +5 a2 a,2 ( e2 + e2 ) +2 a4 e2 + a2 ( 2 a2 3 a,2)e2 cos ( 2nt--2 ?
) 9922 +a2 a2 e2 cos ( 2 nt-2 ) +9 a2 e2cos(2nt-2 , )+ ace2cos(4nt-2n , t--2 )+ ee2 cos ( 2nt4n , t+ 2 , ) + a2 ( 2 a,2 3 a2 ) e2 cos ( 2n , t2 , ) 4 ( a2 e2 + a2 e,2)aa , cos ( nt-nt ) 6 a3 a , e2 cos ( nt+n , / -2r ) aa,3 e,2 cos ( nt+n , t-22 ) 6 ( a2 -+ a,2 ) aa , ee , cos ( r , ) 2 ( 3 a2 a,2 ) a , ee , cos ( 2nt-)z ) 2 ( 3 a,2a2 ) aa , ee , cos ( 2n , ti ) +2 a3 a e2 cos ( 3nt--n , t-2 z ) +2a a,3 e2 cos ( nt--3n , t+2 , ) +2 ( a2 + a,2 ) aa , ee , cos ( 2 nt 2 nit-+ )+9 a2 a2ee , cos ( nt -n/ +w -- ) + 14 a2 a2 e e , cos ( nt + nt--z-- , ) 3 a2 a,2 ( e2 +e 2 ) cos ( 2 nt--2n , t ) 3 a2 a2 ee cos(nt--3nt/ +-+a ) 3 a2 a2 ee cos ( 3nt-n , t- , -- % ) 2 a2 a2 eeO cos ( nt--t -%+ , )+ a2 2 ee , cos ( 3nt--3n , t-w+ , ) Replacing e which accompanies nt , ' m ?
b{ ( a2e + ae ( e )aae e2I ) ----3 I 2.a ?
bs , ot-a +_ sin2- ?
bs , l 1 35 ( 2a4e2+ 5a2a,2(e2+ e,2)+2a,4e,2)^ o+. .
( a2e2+a,2e,2 ) aa , b5 , I. .
3a4 a.2 + .
4 .
a " ( e2+e,2)b , o [ 0* ] a{f a , ?
e , +j2 _ 1,1 ff , .
2 e2 + Ce2 1 1c2( aaa i.Ca1 ( iU3 --C +( e " a e , ).4 ( a2e+ 2 ) aa bs { 2a42+ a2a,2(e2 +e , )+2a4e } b , + .
( a2e2a -a,2e , )aa,2 1.3.3 a2ta +* 42.a(e2 + e2 ) ) [ 1 + a ] ' ?
W{ sl22a n2-~+ ' ~2 } { bs.~ , S+-( 23,.a " b bs3,2 a ?
-- ' , +a - , } { .i .
} ?
( , ?
1 1.3.3 a " a , ( e ?
+ e , a ) b 1.3 .
g2 ( a+ e2 +a , b e7 ) + 2 .
4 a5 ' s+.4.a aa , 5 , Q. 4 a/ 4 g4 4 { 2a4e2+5a2a12(e2+e,2 ) +2a4e,2 } b2 + .
3 .
( a2e2_+a2e2 ) bs,3 } cos(2nt-2n , t+2g2 , ) [ 2 ] bla a , t e , 3+ eae + rt sin e3 2+ 3+ )a 61 , 2aa , f ___3 + 1.3.3 aqa ( ea + e2 ) , 1.3 }b ( ae2 +ape )b+ez 4 .
a ?
b5,1 + .
4 ... ... .ff.i aa , b5,2 , +r1 , -{ b4+ ai { sln2 -t+ e ib3 , '}s + 2:2 a2 -( 5,2 a+ { +a4e2 a ( e,2 ) } ) cos(5nt-5n , t+5[5 ] a+ m ' { ^ ac2'..2a aa e +e , - ) ( +1 wb a3 ~0+ ^'3b1 &lt; }ecos ( nt +s- ) [ 7 ] + m_ , { 2a-c aj b{e a }3 , + 33,2 } eacos(2nt-'4 , t+2 ?
- , - ) [ 8].+ 1 .
27.a 31 ae b2 +a2e .
)aa 33 ; }e cos ( 3nt2nt + 34-2g , -w ) [ 9 ] +m{ B , ,aI 1 .
a , -^ a b.,3f ecos(4ntn , t+ 4 .
, ) [ 1 ] 3 el 3a aa m , 2s.,3 e cos ( 5nt+5- , r ) [ ] a3a aa a2 3 +m , ab .
3o X3 -b3,1 a-2ecos ( nt -nt+ 2 ] ) [ ] + M , { c2 a ^b3 ' 37 b32 ~jf b3,3 } ecos(3nt-2an , nt +6 -2 + - ) [ 12 ] aaa + , " 41 112 ; ?Q Q1Qa8.3'3ecos(2nt-3n1t+24s3s+y- ) [ 13 ] ?
, M a b53.3 ecos ( nt-4nt 5s -4 ) [ 14 ] 3aaaa -Jm , -.2 -a , S a2 bs , ~6sbs,2 ~~a , ~ , ecos(nt--2n , t+s-2s , +'O ) [ 12 ] + m , b3 , !
a ~-a , b3 , s ecos(2nt-3nt+2s-36 , +~ ) w13 ] $aa -~m , Q ~-2 ~ ats 45bs e cos ( 3nt-4n , t 3 4~ , + ) [ 14 ] + M. { aso ~ 2a b3,1 e , cos(n , t-+ ?
) [ 15 ] { a cos(2 ) [ 17 ] + , bsa,2 a ecos ( 4 cs(2nt-3n , t+ 2-e- , -r ) [ 1 + M , n2 { 6 a , a+ ab e , } e , cos( 2n+-2+ ) [ 20 ] { a 1-2 3aa , a +m , ,{2 , 2ea 3,1 ~ 63,2 +e cos(2nt-2n , t+2'-32 , + , ) [ 21 ] m - , -3 obs , a e c , coS ( 4n t-5n,3 , +44-5 + , ) [ 23 ] fa a2 3 aa9 a8 a1 Ma.4 2.a1 aa2 b s.e , cos ( 4nt -5n+2t -2 - ) [ 243 aa aa 3 aa 1 1..6 a " a 9 , ,'iZal~ 3,1 .
$ a , 2 .
4$a , -3 2 .
aa_'~4 , abs. .
ai ( 4a2 , as ) 1.3 a3 a.27 .
4 .
4 --a15 ?
4 a 2542 -a , C CX a2 az 1 , aI aI 1.3 a ( 4 a+ 3 a)s 1 .
4 aa a2 a , 47427 , a-ai ? ?
3.'~ -3 c -a^~ &gt; --a +3 a~ a 54 ab e2 cos 2ntt-2n - ) 2[26 ( 3a3 za , aa a1 , 1.3.2 ga3a -{m , ' .
g.--~aSOs.o g. 2 bs,1 -~T_ 4I aB,0 1.3a ( e4a-5a .
) 1.5 a33 a ae2 ~C 4^ -a,5 a65 , +5 24 5m .
MDCCCX .
2Za aaaa ae as + m , ( s ~a a 2a .
, , b , oa , 4 a , b , 1.13 a " ( 4 a.1 as aj , T.4.4 ai b. 3ab b5 , s e2 cos ( 3nt nlt+3s , -2 ) [ 27 ] --.4.4 a15 fa3 a_ a , aa1 1.3a2 am --g.---8-a bs , l ~ , b ab3 , s.ga bs , s_ 4- .
b a ?
bs , o 2 .
8 a , a 3,1 ~4 3 .
s a,8 ( ~ a78b , a. 1,3 3 a , 1.3 a2 ( 2e -3 a,2 ) .
24 at5 ' ~ 2.4,2 a --b 1.3.3 a3 a } + .
3 abs , e2 cos ( 4nt-2n , t+46-2-,2r ) [ 28 ] , 3aab , a , 1.3 a2a , l a^ b , - , ~.8a13.4a 36s~ G2'4 4ag4a2 -1 .
( 'i a5a ) a } e2Cs(5nt-3n-t+5$-3a-2 ) [ 29 ] .
7~ 4 .
4 a1a,6 1 43 a4 a5 b5,3 e2 cos ( 7nt-5nt + 7s--5 , --2 ) 231].aa,6 a1-379-a a , +m,1 ?
a. 438 9 a " , a 2 b. , a1l + .
a5 .
5 , s + b.,2 1Sa ( g a8 a ) a } e cos ( nt3n , t+C--3- , +2 ) [ 32 ] r 2.4 .
a1 9 1 .
a , 1.3 .
'2,8a~~ b a5 , +~g 28a bs , a4 2.4 a b5 , r.aa 1 .
3.9 a a2 abs , -a bs , o 2. .
a4 a)5 , 5s,2 232 a1 ' ' .
a4 ' .
4 a ?
t Iaf 29a a. 9 at 3.-2( a+ 2af ) +mija '-2aj 3,0-749 a a3 22 a4 a , 5 M. L4 a , a a , b.o aa 1b..3 a + .
a ?
al + 4.2 b5 , + i , --4 aa , b5,2 aa 9 aae l.a72a1 1 a+a28 1 a2 aa 3 9a.a9 a +.3a ?
a A. } s,3}ee , cos(3(2nt -32n2+3--2 3-s -{-r+ ) [ 37 ] a a , 9a a , I3aa 1 .
( a + a , ) a b. .
Saq -m '.-~ 7-- ' a-- , b ab-4a ?
, bb'~ a bs , L i Q.4a 43 2,2.4.a3 a/ 3 12 , 4,1.4aa 1 .
33 a2 + a , 2 43 a aa b , ee , [ cos(33nt3n , t+ 339--+ % ) 37 ] a+,1 a1 { -2 1 .
3 ( al + a2 ) ab , +27 -3a.3}eCoS(4n-4t b+ 4s-4 a+ , ) [ 38 +mQ -t 2.7 4a b3s .
--4 .
Qa2 a,5 5"2 4 .
( a ) aa , b 5 , 3 } ee , cos ( 4 5n--4n/ + 4-5 , --4 + w ) [ 39 ] -m 2 5.3cos(6nt-6nt- ?
w ) [ 40 ] 9 aa a 1.3.6 ( + a2 ) 1 a.3.7a { + 9 62.+ at b3,0~ 4 3+ Q.4 a. a5 aa5,0 2742 ~a ba.(a2a , + 1 .
aa + aI at bs 2e cs ( nt--n , t + 5s--5+ , ) 4 b3l22.4 a , 0+ 274ar aa , b5 1 3a2at 1 2(a2 ?
a ) +44 e , cos((6nt 6nn , t+-t a-{ - ) [ 42 ] 1-.3m 4a2 a4 +2 a bs , s } ee , cos(2nt-2n/ + 2g-2g , +r 43 ] -+6 a oa , b3,2a , &amp; o b5 , f a9 a , 2 .
4 a2.4 a , a , +.3 ( a2 + a2 ) 53 s } eecos(3r-3s-3+[44 a4 aa b , 6 -b 42 z 24 9aa aa 1.3.9a tsa , o4 1. .
( ad + a , !
) +.4 ?
c~sr E3 , r ` e._3-.4 a , e4 .
4 a , s.4 a , , 1 .
3$d2 aa 1 .
3 ( as + a,9 ) q- .
a ?
+4 a~ aab , , [ 4eecos(n]t--n , t+--%[42 ] aa 1.9 a.9 aa 1. .
3 ( as + aa , , 9 -=b 4 -o b5il aa , ba~ ~ a ' a bs .
ee , cos 2nt--2n t+ 2s-25 , { s r - % ) [ ~43 ] 9 aa4 1 .
3 a2 a , { I3 93 a ( bs , a --2 .
a ~a b s4 a , 4 2z2 aa MQ 49 aa5 b , s ee , cos(4nt-4n , t+4--4g , +w---r , ) [ 45],4 a , 3( a 3aa ) 3a laa 1.3 .
2 ( 3 a2_ -a2 ) 1 .
3 .
a1 a a,1 aa ?
a , i + .
+a 3o+2 4.2+ a bs , o-e -a5 b *+ 13 ( 5 a-as ) aa b5,2 + 33 a , s } ee , cos ( 2n , t +2s , ) [ 46 ] -.4 a 21.4.2 +3 aa 1.3.l4 a2a 1.3.2(a2 + a2 ) +m , 2.2 b3 , a2.4 a 5,0 +2 a5 aa^5,1 1.3.3 aa .
-a +1 43 a-a b5,2 ee , cos ( nt+n , + E+ , ----r , ) [ 47 ] ( r 3_a 1 , 3 1a at 1 .
3 ( 3.a a ) 1.3.1 1 aa , m. , b.b , o + b , -aab5 5,1 +m4j-2 .
a/ ~U.l 2.4a 3 b3+ 2 .
4 a1 Q5 .
a +2.4 a5 a , bo .
4 a. a b , 1.3 ( 3a--a2 ) 1.3.3 $ a2 1+24aa aa , b5 , ee , c+ os t nt3 ecos(-2nt+s-- , [ 48 ] ( 3 aa 3 .
, 1.3.3aa2a + m , 124 a3 bs.3 + 2.423.+ a , b~o 1.+ 3(3a2 -a 2 ) , +2 a4 a5 a1.4 [ I ] 52 ++.4 ( a aa b5,3 ee ( cos(3nt-4nt+3s- , ) [ 549 ] 3f aa 3aa 1.3(3aa a +fm 24{ 72 ab3 I,2 + -4 as b5,3 +4a5 aa , 5,4 aa b , ee , cos(4nt -2n 4 2 , -- ) [ 50 ] f+3 4 af , , 2 .
) .
2a 50].a --4 a - ' s ( s7 a &amp; aL a a , bee , cos(5nt 3n -53e , -w w ) [ 51 ] n+,1 .
3 .
3 a2 a 2b 3 ee , cos ( 6nt 4nt +6s 4s , - ) [ 52 ] i ?
2.4 a,.4 a , 2.$.$a , ' { 3 aa3a 1.3 ( 3 a a2 ) 1.3.7 a2a2 +74 a ?
aa b,1 ba 2 2 .
a2 .
1 +1 " ( a4 a,5 4-s-,3 ee , os(nt-3n , t+ g-3 , +w+ , ) [ 53 ] +2 4 a , t aa 1.*3a + mi 4/ ab , ~ t+24 -5 b , -b+ a 4aob +n , 5 bqI -t .
s 3,2a e ) 3 3al a , b5 , o. 3 .
( s a , a ) e , s ( 32 _ ?
) -,4 + a. g,5- , .
4 , 2e 24 ab aa , U5 , _ 7a b5,3 eeos ( 2nt4nt +2s4s , + + , ) [ 54 ] r o.3.aa2 8 .
hs a h5,3 ecos ( 4nt6n/ +4s-6s , + 43+t , ) [ 56 ] 2.f 4 .
2i+ i + .
a b5,3 e,2cos(4nt2n , t+4--2-2E , ) [ 61]. .
9aa b , sej2cos ( 5nt-3n , t+5 3 , --2 , ) [ 62 ] -m , ~ 24 4 ' b , e [ 62* ] ( 27 a 3ac b ar2 b aa 1.3.2 a3 a ( rOT 8 Tfa 1.4 3a , 302.4a,33~ 2.8ai 3 2.4 a5,50 1.3 ( 4a,285 a2 ) 21 3.3 aas13 2.4.4 a15 a b5 , l + 2.4 a,52 1 .
3.9 a2 a'2 c3 -2 44 a1 b }e , cos(nt-3n , t+ -3 +2a ) [ 63 ] 3aa a2 aat 1.3 a , a2 + m~ { b. b3,1'-I b2b5,0 + rn,1--~ a131 a3~ 6,4 3b 2~2.8 a3 s. 4 .
a , b5 1.3 aaJ,3 1.3 ( 2 a , 3a ) 2 b.4 a 5 ' 2.4.2 a,5 a5,2 + 1.3 .
aa b53s } e2cos(2nt-4n , t-+2-4e , +2i ) [ 64 ] 2.4 a'3 aa , a , 1.3 as a2 1.3 aa3 + m , 2.8a 3 3,2 , 4a3 b3,34.4 a b5,1l4 al bs,2 1 1.3 ( a , ' .
3a ) 253 be 2.3 ( 2 a a)2 bs } e,2cos(3nt-5n , t+3s-3s , + 2 , ) [ 65 ] aa 1.3 a 13 a2 +m 2a.8a b33 2.4 b5,2 22 -m , , .
4a b5 ( 5 7 +57+ ) [ 67 ] a1 + 32 _.aajs bs }~ qos ( 4nt6 n , t 4 -2 6,4 2%1 ) + { a( + e2 )a s ^b3'o } sin2 2 cos(nt+nt+E+E , -2y , ) [ 68 ] aa a a , s3 , sin2 cos ( + 3n , -3 E +2y , ) [ 71 ] m bsaa m , a^ , bsin2-2 cos(3nt-n , t +3s- , --2v ) [ 72 ] a aI3 31 !
2 72 ] -me , ^a s3b sin2 -cos ( 2nt4 n/ , t 2--4+2 ) [ 73 ] -m , as b3,3 sin2 , cos(4nt-2nt+ 4]--2-2v , ) [ 74 ] In the development of R , I have supposed r= 0 , so that i , is the angle contained between the orbits of the planets P and P , , or P1 and P2 ; in the general case , when ql , and 12 , are retained , cos:= cos 1 cos 2+ sin h sin 2 cos ( 1 2 ) , q and 2 , being the inclinations of the orbits of the planets P , P2 to any plane x , of which the direction is arbitrary , r ' r , sin ( ; = rr2 co2 .
cos2 sin ( X ; A2 ) sin2 2 cos2 1sin ( 1 + ; 2 vl ) + sin2 L cos2 L sin ( 1 + ; 2 v2 ) sin2 'cos2 sin ( 1 -2 v+2 v2 ) r'r , { cos ( X ' )+s s , = rr cos 2r cos ( cos ( --2 ) + sin2 c2 cos cos ( x1 +2 vl ) + sin2 cos2 cos ( 1 + 22 2 ) + sin2 sin2 cos ( X1 ~2v+2 2 ) + sin i sin 2 cos ( x1 2l+ 2 ) sin s sin 2 cos ( X1 + 42zPv ) } ERRATA .
In page 330 , for i and P , read ir and v , .

