On magnetic influence in the solar ratys .
By SAMUEL HUNTER CHRISTIE , Esq. M.A. F.R.S. Ssc .
Read June 19 , 1828 .
THE facts which I communicated in my former paper on this subject appeared so inexplicable on any known principle , that I am induced to present my subsequent observations to the Society , although I have not succeeded in ascertaining the causes of the singular effects which I have observed .
From the experiments described in that paper , it appeared that a magnetized needle , when vibrated exposed to the sun 's rays , will come to rest sooner than when screened from their influence : that a similar effect is produced on a needle of glass or of copper ; but that the effect upon the magnetized needle greatly exceeds that upon either of the others .
To the experiments from which this was inferred , it might be objected , that the magnetized needle and the other metallic needle were not of the same weight , and that the effect upon an unmagnetized steel needle had not been compared with that upon a similar needle magnetized .
I therefore , on the first opportunity , made these experiments in the most unexceptionable manner , and the results most decidedly confirmed those I had previously obtained .
I endeavoured likewise to ascertain the effects that would be produced by the separate rays ; but , possibly owing to the inefficiency of my apparatus , I obtained no very decided results : the violet rays appeared to produce the same effect as partially screening the needle ; and the red rays , the greatest effect in diminishing the arc of vibration .
The observations themselves will however best point out the nature of these effects .
My first object was to compare the effects on an unmagnetized steel needle with those on a magnetized needle , under circumstances as nearly as possible the same .
For this purpose I made another needle of the same form and weight , and from the same piece of clock-spring , as the magnetized needle which I had already employed .
Each needle had pasteboard glued to the 3c 2 under side , to render it of precisely the same weight as two other needles of copper and of glass , which I had cut of the same form for the purpose of comparing the effects upon needles of different kinds .
The length of each needle is 6 inches , and the greatest breadth 1.5 inch , the boundaries being circular arcs .
The needles were vibrated by means of an apparatus , described in my former paper , from which metal was scrupulously excluded ; the suspending wire being the only metal within several feet of the needle .
This wire was of brass , and of such diameter , that the unmagnetized needles vibrated by the force of its torsion in very nearly the same time as the magnetized needle by the directive force of the earth .
The observations are contained in the following table , where the terminal arc is , in all cases , the extent to which the needle vibrated beyond zero after completing the 100th vibration ; and the terminal excess is the excess of the terminal arc when the needle vibrated in the shade above that when it vibrated exposed to the sun .
Needle vibrated screened Needle vibrated exposed from the Sun .
to the Sun .
Needle vibrated .
Extent Time of 100th or Extent Time of 100th or TermiDiffer .
of 1st making 100 Terminal Therm. of 1st making 100 Terminal Therm. nal exence of Vibration .
Vibrations .
Arc. Vibration .
Vibrations .
Arc. cess .
Temp. _mams_m Magnetized Steel Needle .
90+88 6 06.2 31.5 57 ?
.5 95+88 6 01.9 16.5 10o Weight 2521 grains .
90+88.5 6 06.0 31.5 57.5 90+88 6 02.0 16.5 107 90+88 -6 06.0 31.25 58.5 90+88 6 01.8 16.5 109 Means ... 90+88.2 6 06.1 31A 57.8 90+88 6 01.9 16.5 107.3 140.9 490.5 Apr.19 , from9h A.M.to9h40mA .
M. April 19 , from 9h 53m A.M. to lOh 17 " ' A.M. Unmagnetized Steel Needle .
90+92.5 5 59.6 25 65 90+91.5 5 59.4 19 121 Weight 3 2521 grains .
90+91.5 5 59.6 26.5 65 90+90.5 5 59.4 18.5 114 90+91.5 5 59.8 26.75 65 90+91 5 59.4 19 115 Means ... 190+91.8 15 59.7 26.1 6 90+91 5 59.4 | 18.8 116.7 7.3 51.7 Apr. 21 , from 23m P.M. to 52 'm P.M. April 21 , from lb 07m P.M. to l , 39m P.M. The circumstances under which the observations with the two needles were made , were as nearly the same as I could expect to have them ; and the results show that the effect produced by the sun 's rays on a steel needle , when vibrated exposed to their influence , is most decidedly increased when that needle is magnetized .
The small differences which are to be noticed in the extent of the first arc of vibration would have little influence on the terminal arc , the diminution in the large arcs being so much greater than in the small ones : for instance , the needle vibrating 900 beyond zero in the first vibration , in the second it would not vibrate to 880 ; whereas the 100th vibration being 260 , the 101st would be 25- ?
beyond zero .
This remark applies to all the observations which I have made .
In making these observations , I first noticed that time appeared to be required , in order that the full effect arising from exposure to the sun should be produced .
Thus the last observation in the shade with the magnetized needle being concluded at 9h 40m , the screen was immediately removed , and I comimenced an observation in the sun at 9h 43m , which gave the terminal arc 230 , and the next observation in the sun , commencing at 9 " 53m , gave the terminal arc 1610 .
With the unmagnetized needle , the last in the shade being concluded at oh 52m , I commenced an observation in the sun at 0o 53m , which gave the terminal arc 220 ; the terminal arc in the next observation commencing at Ih 07m was 190 : and again the needle being screened at 1h 39m 458 , an observation in the shade , commencing at Ih 39m 30s , gave the terminal arc 241 ?
instead of 26 ?
, which I had obtained previously .
I ought to mention , that during the observation with the magnetized needle in the sun to which I have referred , the power of the sun was diminished by a haze which produced a halo round it ; and the extent of the terminal arc might partly be attributed to this circumstance .
I have , however , observed the same effect on other occasions where no such cause operated .
In the following table , are contained similar observations , which I made with these steel needles and two others , the one of copper , and the other of glass .
The four needles were of the same form and weight , and vibrated nearly in the same time the unmagnetized steel needle , the copper needle and the glass needle being suspended by the same wire as I had used in the foregoing experiments with the unmagnetized steel needle .
Time of Time of ime of Thermometer .
Needle |vatoenc .
of first making 100 TermiRemarks .
vibrated .
ing Obser- , Vibration .
Vibrations .
nal Are .
Exposed In Rmrs vation .
to Sun .
Shade .
July 2nd .
5h00 M. s70 10 02 90+88 6 01.0 29.6 124.5 74 Sun shining clear .
10 12 90+88 6 01.0 29.0 132.0 75 Sun shining clear .
10 21 90+88 6 01.0 29.0 118.0 73.5 Clouds over sun .
s Means ... 90+88 6 01.0 29.17 74.2 es 10 38 90+87.5 6 01.0 23.0 123.0 74.8 Sun clear. .
00 46 90+88 6 01.6 22.0 132.0 78.5 Sun clear : dew on the glass of the instrument .
7 ) 0 56 90+88.3 6 01.6 23.5 141.5 79.0 Sun clear:dew on the glass of the instrument .
0 _________R Means ... 90+87.9 6 01.4 22.83 132.2 Terminal excess d6ff34 ; , s of temp.n =d 550 a : 3 35 90 ?
90 5 57.4 29.0 136 80.0 Sun clear .
3 45 90+89.5 5 57.2 27.5 140 80.6 Sun clear .
3 53 90+89.3 5 57.2 28.0 141 80.4 Sun clear .
a ?
Means ... 90 +89.6 5 57.27 28.17 139 zs 8o I4 03 90+90.5 5 57.2 32.75 142 80.0 Sun clear .
0 zi 4 12 90+91.0 5 57.2 34.0 143 80.0 Sun clear .
a a ' ce 4 20 90+89.0 5 57.0 33.0 142 80.0 Sun clear .
a. o duff , of temp. in ) 59 o Means ... 90+90.2 5 57.13 33.25 80.0 Terminal excess 5.08 ; &lt; sunandinshade .
} 59 8 July 3rd.285Sncer 9 15 90+87 6 00.2 28.5 135 74.7 Sun clear .
9 25 90+88 6 00.4 29.25 136 75.3 Sun clear .
a9 34 90+89 6 00.4 29.5 138 76.0 Sun clear .
X , , ... ... ... Means ... 90+88 6 00.33 29.08 75.3 -a.q 9 43 90 +88 5 59.8 25.25 136 76.0 Sun clear .
These two observations are not included 4 .
9 52 90+89 5 59.6 23.5 141 78.0 Sun clear .
in the mean .
41 02 9 .
55 2 .
17 Sun cer dew o th got instrument .
b| 10 02 90+87.5 5 59.2 22.0 147.8 79.0 Sun clear : dew on the glass of the instrument .
z\ o'2 10 11 190+89.5| 5 '590 |22.0 |148 79.4 |Sun clear : dew on the glass of the instrument .
10 20 90+87 5 59.0 21.0 149 80.0 Sun clear : dew on the glass of the instrument .
excss ~.3 ; Sduff , of temp. in 73 Means ... 90+88 5 59.07 21.67 148.3 Terminal excess -7.31 sun and in shade .
730 8 23 |0 38 90+87 6 12.3 29.5 142 86 Sun clear .
d |4 =|0 48 90+88 6 12.6 29.5 140 85.7 Sun clouded for 50 ' .
as ; 5a ______|1 04 90+87.5 6 12.2 29.5 122 85.4 Sun clouded .
X btl u| Means ... 90+87.5 6 12.37 29.5 85.7 -a |1 16 90+88 6 12.4 21.5 141 86.2 Sun clear .
Not included in the mean .
0'|s |1 26 90+88 6 12.4 17.5 149.8 87.6 Sun clear .
t En 1 35 00+88.3 6 13.9 16.0 155.0 88.8 Sun clear .
&gt; 4 I ; II -I -j-I-1I o0 diff. of temp. in .
Means ... 90+88.1 6 13.15 16.75 152.4 Terminal excess 12.75 ; sun and in shade .
_ This table exhibits in the clearest manner the difference between the effect on a magnetized needle and that on any other , when vibrating exposed to the influence of the sun 's rays .
Had the time during which the magnetized needle vibrated been 6m instead of 6m 13S , the terminal excess would have been 12 ?
.3 nearly , supposing it to be nearly proportional to the time .
However , to render the time in which this needle made one hundred vibrations more nearly equal to those of the others , I remagnetized it ; and four hours afterwards made the following observations .
Time of Extentof Time of Thermometer .
Needle commencEte fir * making Terv i brated .
ing Obser a te rst Vi-o Viminal Exposed In the Remarks .
vation .
bration .
brations .
Arc. to Sun .
Shade .
July 4th .
a ) 0 10 90+88 6 01.1 29 149 84.5 S un clear .
50 28 90+87.75 6 01.3 29 150 84.6 Sun clear .
00 37 90+88 6 01.4 29 149.6 83.0 Sun clear. .
Means 90+ 87.9 6 01.42 29 84.0 0O0 46 90+ 88 6 02.4 18 149.0 83.5 Sun clear .
At6m 02s.4 , terminalarc = 18 I1 00 90+88 6 05.8 16.75 146 83.2 Sun clear .
At5 58.5 or 98th vib .
arc= 17.25 1 12 90+87.75 6 06.4 16.5 147 83.0 Sunclear .
At5 59.1or98thvib.arc=17.0 e1 24 90 + 87.75 6 06.8 15.5 145 83.4 Sun clear .
At 5 59.5 or 98th vib .
arc = 16.0 B Means 90 +87.9 6 05.35 16.7 146.75 83.3 Time = 5m 59.98 ' , arc = 17.06 1 33___ 90+__7_75 6-762 .
450 8 .
u clear .
At 6m 0.0 ' or 98t 1 vib .
arc =24.75 ~1 33 90 + 87.75 6 076 24.5 145.0 83.8NSunincluded in the mean .
81 46 90+87.75 6 08.8 27.5 144.0 83.8 Sun clear .
At 6 01.4 or 98th vib .
arc = 28.25 41 55 90 + 87.75 6 09.0 27.75 140.8 82.8 Sun clear .
At 6 01.6 or 98th vib .
arc = 28.5 Q Means 90+ 87.75 6 08.9 27.62 83.3 Time = 6m01s.5 , arc 28.38 Taking the mean of the arcs in the shade , and in the sun , when the time of vibrating was the same , we have , Terminal Excess 110.5 ; Difference of temperature in sun and in shade 630. .
Some of these observations again appear to indicate , that the full effect of diminishing the terminal arc was not produced immediately on exposing the needle to the sun 's rays , nor was the full effect of increasing it immediately produced on screening the needle from their influence .
The first observation with the unmagnetized needle exposed to the sun , commenced immediately that the screen was removed , and the terminal arc was 25 I ' ; in the next observation the terminal arc was 231 ?
, but in those which followed , it was reduced to 220 and 21 , which appeared to be the limit .
The observations with the magnetized needle give similar results .
The terminal arc was 21i in the first observation with the needle exposed to the sun , which commenced immediately that the screen was removed ; and this arc was only 171 ?
and 160 in the subsequent observations .
The result was similar in the first observation in the sun on the 4th of July ; although the difference between the terminal arc in this and the following observations was not so considerable : but in the first observation when the needle was screened , after having been exposed to the sun , and which commenced immediately that the needle .
was screened , the terminal arc was only 2430 instead of 29 ?
, which it had been in the shade previous to exposure to the sun .
This circumstance would appear to indicate that the diminution of the terminal arc , on exposure to the sun , was caused by the heat which it imparted ; but subsequent observations clearly showed that this was not the case , and that the effect was only so far dependent on the heat of the sun , that this appeared in some instances to measure the intensity of the action which produced the diminution .
These observations in July , compared with those in April , appear to indicate that the effect of the sun 's rays on the magnetized needle in April was greater than in July ; although their intensity , measured by the heat imparted , was much less in the former case than in the latter .
If , however , such is really the case , nothing but observations carefully made and repeated during a series of years , would satisfactorily establish such a fact .
It may appear that I have unnecessarily multiplied observations all pointing to the same conclusions : my object in making them was , in the first instance , to satisfy myself that the effects which I observed invariably took place under certain circumstances ; and I , in all cases , give these repeated observations , that others may be enabled to draw their own conclusions from them , should they doubt the correctness of mine .
In order to determine how far the vibrations of a needle are influenced by the separate rays , I placed a glass cylinder , ground plane on the under edge , upon the plate of glass covering the compass-box ; and I proposed , by having fluids of different colours in this cylinder , to transmit only particular rays to the needle .
Owing , however , to the irregularities on the sides of the cylinder , so much light was lost in transmission through the cylinder even when empty , that the effect was considerably diminished ; and after a few trials I gave up this method of observing , as before I could have procured another cylinder better adapted to my purpose , I should no longer have been able to devote the requisite time to the inquiry .
The only effect which I observed was , that transmitting the rays through half an inch of the sulphate of indigo very much diluted , appeared to be nearly equivalent to intercepting them altogether .
Another method which I adopted for transmitting only particular rays , was by placing circles of glass painted with different transparent colours over the compass ; but in this manner I obtained no very determinate results as respected the effects of rays of different colours .
Although I failed in the particular object I had in view , the observations led to one important conclusion , which I have already noticed , that the diminution in the terminal arc was not produced by the heat imparted by the sun , either to the needle or the medium in which it vibrated .
The difference made in the apparatus was , that the compass-box was nine inches..in .
diameter , to 'contain a graduated .
circle of paper eight inches in diameter ; so that the needle having bristles in the direction of its axis projecting 1.5 inch beyond its extremities as indexes , I was enabled to read the direction of the needle , although it was hid by the coloured glass placed over the glass top of the instrument .
In order that I might have a tolerably correct measure of the temperature within the compass-box during the different observations , I placed inside , a small .
spirit thermometer , graduated on .
ivory , and having the tube fixed to the scale by narrow bands of paper .
I likewise employed a powerful lens eleven inches in diameter to concentrate the rays on the space in which the needle vibrated .
I attempted also to bring the focus of the lens within the compass-box , but the heat was so great that it burned part of the apparatus ; and I desisted , lest by injuring the essential parts I should put an end to my experiments .
The coloured glass consisted of two semicircles , each having a small concentric semicircle cut out , so that they fitted each other round the tube carrying the suspending wire .
Having clearly ascertained the fact that the effect produced on the magnetized needle was different from that on any other , the observations which I now made were on the vibrations of a magnetized needle alone ; and I employed that which I had already used , .
removing however the additional weight of paper which had been fixed to it , so that its weight was now only 197 grains , and its time of vibration was likewise diminished .
The following are the observations which I thus made .
Thermometer .
Circumstances Time of Extent of the Time of Terunder which the commencfirst arc of making minal Within the Exposed In Remarks .
Needle vibrated .
ing the Ob .
Vibration .
100 ViArc .
Compassto the Shade .
servation .
brations .
box .
Sun .
July 29th .
9 15 90+84.5 5 31.0 19.8 72.5 123.0 61.4 Sun clear .
rO 9 30 90+84.8 5 31.5 21.5 73.0 110.6 60.8 Sun clear .
9 40 90+84.8 5 31.1 20.5 73.0 126.0 63.0 Sun clear .
a9 50 90+84.8 5 30.0 9.8 100.0 134.0 65.0 Sun clear Thefulleffectappearstohavebeen * cear .
t produced almost immediately .
o 10 04 90+84.8 5 30.4 14.8 95.5 104.0 64.6 Sun obscured by dark clouds .
e= 10 -15 90+84.8 5 29.8 9.3 102.9 120.0 64.8 Sun clear .
10 23 90+84.8 5 31.1 14.3 102.5 108.4 64.6 Sun obscured by dark clouds , 165 ' + 35S .
MK 10 35 90+84.5 5 29.8 9.3 117.7 127.4 66.0 Sun clear .
= Ad o 11 20 90+84 5 33.4 18.5 114.5 143.0 68.8 Sun clear .
-o .
es 11 29 90+86 5 34.0 17.3 107.5 140.0 69.5 Sun obscured , 120 sec. a , a ; X0 11 40 90+86.5 5 34.3 18.5 107.4 147.0 69.8 Sun obscured , 15 sec. Wa03 11 58 90+85.5 5 34.0 20.8 104.5 142.5 70.0 Sun clear .
11 c ' 010 89.5 +83 5 32.6 19.5 109.0 143.0 72.0 Sun clear .
removed Bluemoe glass 0 22 90+84.8 5 34.4 |10.5 128.0 |141.0\ 73.0 Li ht haze wit coloured halo round the sun.| Lens edge- ) wiseto the 0 44 90+84 5 33.8 15.5 113.9 115.3 73.0 Sun scarcely seen ; obscured by dense haze .
Sun .
Im noved .
}|0 58 90+84.8 5 34.2 17.5 111.0 108.2 74.0 Sun cast a very faint shadow .
al |1 11 90+84.8 5 34.3 20.5 104.6 122.4 74.6 Sun not clear ; faint haze over .
QS5|1 21 90+85.3 5 33.6 21.5 97.0 132.7 73.6 Sun clear at intervals .
00 4.* |1 35 90+85.3 15 33.7 20.5 91.7 113.6 71.8 Sun hid entirely by a hazy cloud .
Time of The intensity of the needle had been so much l1I making reduced by having the rays concentrated on I98vibrait in some attempts with the lens , that the t |\ tions .
$|ll| time of vibration was increased .
e0 |3 15 90+85.3 5 34.1 16.0 101.3 127.2 74.0 Sun obscured by a light hazy cloud .
3 ; =13 24 90+85 5 34.7 13.0 111.5 128.7 74.0 Sun slightly obscured by very light haze .
3 45 90+85 5 33.8 15,0 117.0 132.2 74.0 Sun slightly obscured by very light haze .
3 56 90+85 5 34.4 20.3 104.0 130.0 74.6 Sun obscured by light haze .
4 07 90+84.5 5 33.4 21.0 93.5 122.0 74.0 Sun obscured by hazy cloud .
a a ) 15 43 90+84.5 5 34.4 22.5 79.5 80.5 72.2 Sun obscured by cloud .
5 54 90+84.5 5 34.6 22.0 79.0 80.3 72.2 Sun obscured by cloud .
From these observations it appears , that the diminution in the terminal are in all cases corresponded to the intensity with which the sun shone on the needle ; that this arc was in all cases increased by a screen being interposed , whether the screen entirely excluded the direct rays , as when the wooden screen was interposed , or only partially , as in the cases of the sun being obscured by haze or cloud , or the needle being covered with blue glass , which appeared to act simply as a screen ; and that the diminution in the terminal arc did not correspond to the heat imparted to the needle or the medium in which it vibrated , excepting so far as this in some cases might correspond with the intensity of the sun 's rays .
In the following observations I varied some of the circumstances- : the day was most favourable for them , the sky continuing cloudless throughout , and the heat of the sun great , in the middle of the day intense .
Time of Extent of Time of Thermometer .
Circumstances under commencthe first arc making Terwhich the Needle ing the Obof Vibra100 Vi_ minal Within the Exposed In Remarks .
vibrated .
servation .
tion .
brations .
Arc. Compassto the Shade .
box .
Sun .
Sa .
5 July 3Oth .
0* hm00Mso0 *3 n 10 27 90+86.55 41.0 19.5 77.5 132.8 64.8 The sky cloudless throughout the day , aJ 2 10 36 90+86.5 5 41.0 20.5 77.5 139.5 68.2 and the heat of the sun very great , i 10 45 90+86.3 5 42.2 20.5 78.4 143.5 69.0 th middle of th day intense .
_______ -98 .
1 The full effect does not appear to have o Although it appears from these observations , as from the preceding ones , that the diminution of the terminal arc did not in all cases correspond to the temperature of : the needle or of the medium , yet it depended essentially on the intensity of the rays in the space in which the needle vibrated ; the terminal arc being 30.8 when the rays were most concentrated , and 50 ?
5 , 50.8 , 60.8 , 70 , 80 , and80.8 as their intensity was diminished .
The results obtained with the coloured glasses appear to indicate that the red rays had a greater effect in diminishing the terminal arc than the blue ; for although the blue on the glass was very transparent , and the red far from being so , yet when the needle was screened by the-blue glass , the terminal are was 170.5 , and when screened-by the red 130 , the thermometer within the compass-box indicating nearly the samei temperature in the two cases .
The effect which I observed on throwing the violet rays , as -separated by the lens , further from the end of the needle and then bringing them ; nearer , although not very decided favours the : same conclusion .
No further effect than that of partially screening , appears to have been produced by making one end of the needle vibrate in the blue rays while the other vibrated in the direct light of the sun .
If we may conclude from these observations , that the red .
rays .
are those which cause the diminution in the terminal arc , we might infer that the heat imparted to the needle or to the air was the cause of this diminution ; but the experiments themselves show that this was not the case .
However , to remove all doubt on this part of the subject , I determined to observe the terminal arcs with the different needles when their temperature and that of the medium in which they vibrated varied , and all other circumstances remained precisely the same .
For the purpose of making these observations , I placed a graduated circle of paper in a shallow vessel of earthenware , 7.5 inches in diameter , and 1.2 inch deep , having a rim projecting 1.2 inch all round .
This rim rested on the rim of another vessel of earthenware 9.4 inches in diameter , and 3.6 inches deep , and which contained hot or cold water , according to circumstances , so as to surround the upper vessel to its rim .
The glass cover of the compass , having in its centre the glass tube carrying the wire of suspension , was placed over the upper vessel , which thus supplied the place of a compass-box .
The needles were successively suspended within this vessel by the same wires and in the same stirrups as before ; the magnetized needle by the very fine brass wire ; the glass , the copper , and the unmagnetized steel needle by the much thicker wire , which caused them to vibrate in nearly the same time as the magnetized needle .
So that , as before , the needles and suspending wires were the only substances of metal used in the apparatus .
The upper.vesselcontained the small spirit thermometer which had before been placed in the compass-box .
The ivory scale rested upon pieces of cork , which prevented.the contact of the bulb or scale with the bottom or sides of the vessel ; so that this thermometer indicated pretty accurately the temperature of the air within the vessel in which the needle vibrated ; and likewise nearly that of the needle itself , by allowing some time to elapse , after making a considerable change in the temperature , previously to commencing the observations .
In making the observations , the under vessel was first filled with cold water , and the apparatus so adjusted that the needle pointed to zero on the graduated circle when the wire was devoid of torsion .
The needle was then made to vibrate until the arc on the western side of zero was as near to 900 as I could obtain* ; the time of its next passing zero was noted , and also the arc of vibration on the other side .
At the hundredth vibration , the time and the arc beyond zero were noted , as before .
The state of the thermometer in the upper vessel was taken at the commencement and likewise at the conclusion of the observation , the mean being considered as the temperature of the needle and .
of the air in which it vibrated .
After thus making three observations , the upper vessel containing the needle was removed , the cold water contained in the lower one poured out , that vessel heated and filled with boiling water , and the upper vessel replaced and adjusted as before .
Cloths steeped in boiling water were placed over the glass cover , for the double purpose of more rapidly heating the air in the vessel in which the needle vibrated , and of preventing the deposition of dew on the under surface by , condensation .
When the temperature of the air within the upper vessel had nearly attained its maximum , observations on the vibrations of the needle were made as before .
The lower vessel was again filled with cold water , and the observations repeated .
The following table contains two sets of observations with the magnetized steel needle : in , the first set , the plane of the needle having been somewhat inclined laterally X The magnetized needle was made to vibrate by means of a weak magnet held on the outside of the box , and the other needles by turning the index to which the upper part of the suspending wire was attached , and again bringing that index to zero .
As I could have no perforation either in the side of the vessel containing the needle , or in the glass cover , I was obliged to adopt this method .
to the horizon , it was rendered horizontal previous to ' making the second , which is the reason that the terminal arcs in the first are rather less than the corresponding arcs in the second .
Time of 100th or Enclosed Termi_ DifferE~xtent of making TermiThermonal Exence of 1st Vibration .
100 Vibranal Arc. meter .
cess .
Tempetions .
ture .
M ; m s_ Magnetized Needle .
90 ?
88 5 55.0 28.5 62.0 Weight = 197 grains .
90 +88 5 55.4 28.75 62.5 90 +88 5 55.1 28.5 63.0 Means ... ... 90 +88 5 55.2 28.6 62.5 go +89 6 01.8 34.5 137.5 89 +87.5 6 02.2 34.0 139.0 go +89 6 00.8 33.75 137.5 Means atHighTemperature 89.7 + 88.3 6 01.6 34.1 138.0 5.05 75.1 90.5 +88 5 54.8 29.5 64.25 90.5 +88 5 54.7 29.5 62.5 Means ... ... 90.5 +88 5 54.75 29.5 63.37 Means at Low Temperature 90.25 + 88 5 55.0 29.05 62.9 Magnetized Needle .
90 +89 5 55.2 33.0 50.0 Weight =197 grains .
89.5 +89 5 55.2 32.0 50.0 91 +90 5 55.7 32.0 50.0 Means ... ... 90.2 + 89.3 5 55.4 32.3 50.0 go +90 6 01.8 36.5 124.5 90 + 90.5 6 02.2 37.0 128.5 go +89 6 01.5 36.5 126.0 Means at HighTemperature 90 +89.8 6 01.8 36.7 126.3 4.1 75.2 91 + 90.5 5 56.4 33.0 53.5 89.5 +89 5 55.8 32.75 52.0 Means ... .
90.25+89.75 5 56.1 32.9 52.75 Means at Low Temperature 90.2 +89.5 5 55.7 32.6 51.1 Since , as might have been anticipated , it appears here that the effect upon the terminal arc , produced by an increase of temperature , is decidedly the reverse of that caused by the direct influence of the sun 's rays , it follows that the latter effect does not arise from an increase in the temperature of the needle or of the medium in which it is vibrated .
That there might be no doubt on the subject , I repeated the observations with the magnetized needle , and made corresponding observations with the other three , the two steel needles having been previously rendered , as before , of the same weight as the others .
In these observations , contained in the following table , the extent of the arc at the hundredth vibration was observed on both sides of zero , except with the copper needle .
Time of Extent of 100th Enclosed TermiDifferNeedle vibrated .
Extent of making Vibration or Thermonal Ex-~ ence of ist Vibration .
100 viTerminal Arc. meter .
cess .
Tempebrations .
rature .
Magnetized Steel Needle .
90 +888.5 5 58.8 33 +33.5 51.5 Weight = 2521 grains .
90 + 88 5 58.5 33.5 +33.5 51.0 90 +88.5 5 58.2 33.5+33.5 51.5 Means ... .
90 + 88.3 5 58.5 33.3 +33.5 51.3 go +88 6 13.2 40 +40 140.5 90 +88 6 11.8 39 +38.5 135.5 90 +88 6 11.8 41 +39.8 ]34.0 Means at High Temperature.90 +88 6 12.3 40 + 39.4 136.7 5.885.2 90.5 + 88.5 6 06.5 34 + 34 51.75 90.5 + 88.5 6 05.0 35 + 34 51.75 90.5+88 60 5.2 35 + 34 51.75 Means ... 90.5+ 88.3 6 05.6 34.7+34 51.75 Means at Low Temperature .
90.3+ 88.3 6 02.05 34 + 33.8 51.5 Unmagnetized Steel Needle .
90 + 87 5 52.8 21 + 22 49.0 Weight =252k grains .
90 +s88 5 52.6 21 +23 49.5 90 +87 5 52.6 21 +23 50.0 Means ... ..90 + 87.3 5 52.7 21 +22.7 49.5 89 +87 5 51.4 26 +26.5 143.5 go +88 5 50.8 25.5+26.5 139.0 90 +87.5 5 50.5 26 +26.5 130.5 Means at High Temperature .
89.7+ 87.8 5 50.9 25.8+26.5 |137.7 4.4 88.6 90.5+88 5 50.0 22 +22 48.0 90 +87.5 5 49.9 21.5+22 48.5 90 +87 5 49.8 21.5+21.5 49.5 Means. .
90.2+ 87.5 5 49.9 21.7+ 21.8 48.7 Means at Low Temperature .
90.1+ 87.4 5 51.3 21.3+22.2 49.1 Extet o mTimego Extent of l00th Enclosed TermiDiffer-o Needle vibrated .
Extent of maki Vibration or Thermo .
nal Exence o| I1st Vibration .
1oo ViTemnlAc ee .
cs .
Tempebrations .
TemnlAc ee .
cs.rature. .
_ms_ Copper Needle .
90 +89 5 51.1 28 57.0 Weight= 252-4 grains .
89.5+88 5 51.2 28 57.0 90 +88.5 5 51.2 28 57.0 Means .
89.8+88.5 5 51.2 28 57.0 91 +89 5 49.9 32 136.5 89.5+89 5 49.8 32.3 138.0 90 +88.5 5 49.6 32 135.0 Means at High Temperature .
90.2 + 88.8 5 49.8 32*1 136.5 4.0 79.75 90 +89.5 5 51.2 28 57.5 90 +88 5 51.0 28.5 56.0 90 +88 5 51.2 28.5 56.0 Means. .
90 + 88.5 5 51.1 28.3 56.5 Means at Low Temperature .
89.9+ 88.5 5 51.15 28.1 56.75 Glass Needle .
90.5+90 5 56.0 27 51.0 Weight =2524 grains .
9o + 88 5 56.2 26.5 51.0 90 + 88.5 5 56.2 26.5 52.0 Means ... ... 90.2+88.8 5 56.1 26.7 51.3 90 +88 5 56.6 32.5+31.5 142.0 90 +88.3 5 56.4 31 +32 139.0 : 90 +88 5 56.4 32+31.5 135.5 Means at High Temperature .
90 + 88.1 5 56.5 31.8+ 31.7 138.8 5.4 86.6 90 + 88 5 56.4 26 + 25.5 57.0 90.5+88.5 5 56.0 26 +26 51.5 9i +90 5 56.2 26.5+26 50.75 Means ... 90.5+ 88.8.5 56.2 26.2+ 25.8 53.1 Means at Low Temperature .
90.3+88.8 5 56.2 26.3 52.2 The effects here are not very different with the four needles .
The glass needle and the two steel needles presenting broader surfaces on their sides to the air 's resistance than the copper needle , it was to be expected that the terminal excess with these should be greater than with that needle ; and I am not aware of any circumstance,.except the shorter time during which the vibrations continued , that should have rendered it less with the unmagnetized steel needle than with the other two .
The principal fact , however , which I looked to ascertaining by these experiments was , whether the terminal excess was of the same character here when the temperature was increased , as that arising from vibrating the needle successively in the shade and exposed to the sun , when an increase of temperature likewise took place ; and on this point they were quite conclusive , showing clearly , that if the terminal excess is considered plus in the latter case , it will be minus in the former .
It is evident then from all these results , that if the rays of the sun had simply , uniformly increased the temperature of the medium in which the needle vibrated , and of the needle itself , the effect would have been in all cases to increase the length of the terminal arc , instead of diminishing it , as was invariably the case when exposure to the rays of the sun caused an increase of temperature .
There can therefore be no doubt that the influence of the sun was not confined to uniformly heating the medium and the needle , but that , in all cases , other effects than would arise from this were produced , and that the influence upon the magnetized needle was very different from that upon either of the others .
I next proposed to determine the effects that would be produced on the arcs of vibration by the heat of a fire .
For this purpose I placed the apparatus before a strong fire , at the distance of about two feet from .
the front , and six inches below the bottom of the iron grate containing it , and vibrated the magnetized needle , and likewise the glass needle , when successively screened from , and exposed to its direct influence .
The observations , which are contained in the subjoined Table , show that the effect produced by exposure to the fire , though small , was to bring the needle sooner to rest , or that it was of the same character as that produced by exposure to the sun .
I am not disposed to lay any stress upon the circumstance that the terminal excess was almost precisely the same in the two cases , but to attribute it to the small errors in the observations having accidentally so compensated each other as to produce this very close agreement .
Indeed , if I could have detected such minute differences , the terminal excess ought to have been rather greater with the magnetized than with the glass needle , since the intensity of the fire 's heat appeared to be greater with the former than with the latter .
We may , however , infer from these experiments , that if the intensity of the fire 's heat had been precisely the same with the two needles , no sensible difference would have been observed in the effects produced on them .
The observations were made in this order : The first three observations with the apparatus screened from the fire by a thick board ; then immediately there four with the screen removed ; after which it was : replaced , and the other observations made .
Needle vibrated screened Needle vibrated exposed from the Fire .
to the Fire .
Needle vibrated .
Extent of Time of Extent of Extent Time of 100th VibraInclosed Extent making 100 100th VibraInclosed TermiDiffer of 1st making 100 tion or Ter .
Therm. of 1st Vibrations .
tion or TerTherm .
nal ex. ence of Vibration .
Vibrations .
minal Arc. Vibration .
minal Are .
cess .
Temp. D -rm Rs______-i Magnetized Needle .
90+89 5 48.2 35 t34'.5 5X.0 Weight 252 grains .
90+88.5 5 48.4 34.5+34.3 51.5 ma 90+89 5 48.4 34.54-34.3 52.0 90+89 5 48.8 34.3+3Y s6.s 90+89 5 49.2 34.5+34 84.0 90+89 5 49.8 33.5+34 76.0 90+88.5 5 48.8 34.5+34.2 76.5 90+88.5 5 50.4 33.5+34.2 83.0 90+89.5 5 48.7 '35 +34.5 67.0 90+89 5 50.6 33.8 ?
34 90.0 Means , ... 90+88.9 5 48.6 34.7+34.3 63.7 90+88.9 5 49.9 33.8+34 76.4 0.57 12.8 Glass Needle .
90+84 5 56.8 25 +25.5 58.0 Weight = 252-grains .
90+85 , 5 57.2 25.2+25.8 58.25 90+84.5 5 58.0 24 +25.5 62.5 90+84 5 57.3 25 +25.5 58.75 90+85 5 58.4 24 +25.3 70.0 90+84 5 57.8 25 +25.3 74.5 90+85 5 58.6 24.2+25.3 75.0 90+84 5 57.5 25 +25.3 71.5 90+85 5 58.6 24.2+25 77.0 90+84.2 5 57.3 25 + 25.564.25 J90+84.9 5 58.4 24.1-j-25.3 71.1 0.56 6.9 From all the experiments which I have described , there can , I think , be no doubt that the rays of the sun have a peculiar influence on a magnetized needle , which causes , when such a needle is exposed to them , a greater diminution in its arcs of vibration than in those of any other needle under like circumstances ; and that this effect is independent of the heat imparted to the needle or to the medium in which it vibrates .
That part of the effect which is produced on all needles may perhaps be caused in this manner : as the air directly below the needle is in the shade , and therefore colder than that above it , a current of air will pass the edges of the needle , which may considerably increase the resistance and consequently diminish the terminal arc ; and this may possibly account for the full effect not taking place immediately , since these currents would not be excited in full force immediately on exposing the needle to the sun , nor on screening it would they immediately subside* .
Had this , however , been the If this : is the cause of the terminal excess with the non-magnetic needles , this excess would nearly vanish if a wire frame of the same form as the needles were successively vibrated in the shade and exposed to the -influence of the -sun , since in this case there would be little shadow below the needle .
This experiment I proposed making , but have not yet had an opportunity .
only cause : of the terminal ; -:excess with the magnetized needle as well.as with the others , this excess would have been nearly the same for all , or it would only have differed according to the thickness of the , needle .
The terminal excess ought in this case to have been nearly the same for the glass , the unmagnetized steel and the magnetized steel needles , and less for the copper than for either of these .
This accords , in some measure , with the-experimental results which I obtained with the copper needle , the glass needle , and the unmagnetized steel needle , but:as the effect on the last was only about four-sevenths of that on the magnetized steel needle , we must , for part of the effect upon this needle , look to causes distinct from that which produced the effect on the others .
It is extremely difficult to point out any principle to which this effect upon the magnetized .
needle can be referred .
Are we to infer from these experiments that light and magnetism have relative density , althoughthe density of either is evanescent with regard to that of the rarest gas ; and that -therefore light may offer a sensible resistance to magnetic particles in their passage through it , and consequently also to the bodies with which they are united ?
That light is of such extreme tenuity as to offer no resistance to the passage of the rarest gas , of which , .
however , we have no proof , -cannot be adduced as an argument against such an inference .
Or , is it possible that the effect may be produced in a manner similar to that on needles vibrating within metallic rings ?
If this be the case , we must suppose that the rays become magnetic by induction , in their passage by the needle , and that their maximum of magnetism not being developed until after they have passed it , the most magnetic rays will always be in the rear of the needle , and by their attraction impede its progress .
If the effect is produced in this manner , we might expect , when a strong magnet is brought near to a ray of light transmitted through a small opening into a dark room , that the ray would be inflected .
I have not had an opportunity of making this experiment in a conclusive manner , but in the trials which I have made I have observed no such effect .
In the conclusion of my former paper I stated , that as magnetic influence in the compound solar rays was indicated by the effects which I had described , this would tend to remove the doubts which had been entertained respecting the results obtained by MORICHINI , by means of the violet rays ; and Mrs. SoMERVILLE'S paper , read almost immediately after mine , describing the effects which that lady had observed to be produced under different circumstances by the more refrangible rays , appeared completely to verify MORICHINI'S results , and to corroborate my opinion .
Although the experiments of Mrs. SOMERVILLE have , on repetition , in many instances failed , we cannot , seeing the precautions that were taken , suppose that the effects described were due to other causes than the influence of the rays , but must rather infer that we are not aware of all the circumstances which may interfere with the success of the experiment .
It cannot , however , be denied that the subject is at present involved in much mystery ; and it is therefore very desirable that the circumstances on which the success of Mrs. SOMERVILLE'S experiment depends should be clearly ascertained , and that the effects which I have invariably found to be produced by the conipound rays should be traced to some known principle of action .
I had proposed to myself to make several series of observations with the view of obtaining comparative results with different azimuths of the sun , at different seasons of the year , and likewise with the horizontal needle and the dipping needle vibrated both in the meridian and at right angles to it ; and also to determine , with some degree of precision , the effects produced by the several separated rays under different circumstances .
But in the experiments which I have already made , I have met with so many and such vexatious interruptions , arising principally from the uncertainty of our climate , and partly from my not always being able to avail myself of a favourable state of the weather , that seeing no prospect of succeeding in experiments requiring continued clear weather and uninterrupted leisure , I must leave them to be made by those who may be placed under more favourable circumstances , and be content to prosecute the inquiry by making such experiments as intervals of leisure , which I may have during fine weather , will allow .
Iovyal Military Academy , i. H. CHRISTIE .
2nd June , 1828 .

