On the mutual action of sulphuric acid and alcohol , and on the nature of the process by which ether is formed .
By HENRY HENNELL , Esq. Cornmunicated by WILLIAM THOMAS BRAND , Esq. F.R.S. Read June 19,1828 .
1 .
I WAS some time since engaged in an investigation of the nature of oil of wine and of the salts called sulphovinates : the results I obtained were considered of sufficient importance to be honoured with a place in the Philosophical Transactions* .
The oil of wine and sulphovinic acid are substances produced during the mutual action of sulphuric acid and alcohol in the well-known process adopted for the preparation of ether ; and an important point with me , during the above investigations and since that time , has been to develop the particular changes which take place when ether is formed from sulphuric acid and alcohol .
I perceive by the Annals de Chimie for November last , that MM .
DUMAS and BOULLAY have been engaged on the same subject , and have experimented on and considered , not only the formation of ether , but also the nature of sulphovinates , and , as they supposed , though incorrectly , of oil of wine+ .
That our results with regard to sulphovinates and oil of wine differ , may be seen from the published accounts ; and there is not less difference between their conclusions with regard to etherification , and the results I have obtained , which I have now to describe .
2 .
When alcohol and sulphuric acid in equal weights are put together without the application of any heat beyond that generated during the mixture , the most abundant and important product is sulphovinic acid , above one half of the sulphuric acid being converted into that peculiar acid by union with hydro-carbon+ .
But when such a mixture containing so large a proportion of sulphovinic acid is distilled , the most important product is a new substance , namely ether , and the sulphovinic acid disappears .
The questions which then arose were , whether the ether was formed altogether from the direct action of the remaining alcohol and sulphuric acid in the mixture , or whether the sulphovinic acid might not also assist , or whether it might not be an essential state of the elements intermediate between the mixture of the acid and alcohol and the development of the perfectly formed ether .
MM .
DUMAS and BOULLAY , who have considered the same questions , or at least some of them , -decide , that the portions of materials which form ether , are altogether independent of those which produce sulphovinic acid : but the following facts prove in my opinion the contrary of this conclusion .
3 .
A portion of oil of vitriol was selected for some comparative experiments , and also some alcohol of specific gravity 0.820 : five hundred grains of the oil of vitriol precipitated by acetate of lead , gave 1500 grains of sulphate of lead .
4 .
Five hundred grains of the oil of vitriol were mixed with five hundred grains of the alcohol , and after forty-eight hours , diluted and precipitated by acetate of lead ; only 616 grains of sulphate of lead were produced ; so that very nearly three-fifths of the sulphuric acid had become sulphovinic acid by the effect of mixture , and little more than two-fifths remained to act as sulphuric acid upon the remaining alcohol , full two-thirds of the quantity employed .
5 .
Another mixture of acid and alcohol in the same proportions , and made at the same time as the above , was then distilled until 117 grains had passed over , consisting of water , alcohol , and a portion of ether .
The residue in the retort had not undergone any charring effect ; and being diluted , was precipitated by the acetate of lead : the quantity of sulphate of lead obtained , amounted to 804 grains , indicating an increase in the quantity of sulphuric acid equivalent to 188 grains of sulphate of lead .
6 .
A similar mixture of alcohol and sulphuric acid , made at the time and in the same proportions as the two former , was then distilled until two hundred grains had been received , the greater part of which was ether ; the uncharred residual matter in the retort being then diluted , was precipitated by acetate of lead as before ; 986 grains of sulphate of lead were obtained .
This contained nearly two-thirds of the sulphuric acid first added , and the increase by distillation had been much more than one-half of that which existed before the application of heat : so that during the distillation , and simultaneously with the formation of ether , a quantity of sulphovinic acid had been re-converted into sulphuric acid , and the latter appeared to increase in quantity in proportion to the increase.of ether in the distilled products .
7 .
A similar mixture of alcohol and acid , made at the same time and in the same proportions as the three former , was then distilled until 'two hundred grains had passed over .
Two hundred grains of water were added to the contents of the retort ; 160 grains were distilled off ; a second addition of two hundred grains of water wast made , and the distillation continued : a further addition of five hundred grains of water was made , and the operation continued until as much product had been separated as equalled the water added ; the object was to separate all the ether and alcohol possible , for the purpose of ascertaining to what extent the conversion of sulphovinic acid into sulphuric could be carried .
No smell of sulphurous acid was produced during the operation , nor did any charring of the contents of the retort occur ; when precipitated by acetate of lead , 1480'grains of sulphate of lead were obtained .
This is very little short of the 1500 given -by the acid when unacted upon by alcohol , and shows that nearly the whole of the sulphovinic acid had beenchanged back into the state of sulphuric acid ; and is completely at variance with the opinion , that when sulphuric acid and alcohol act upon each other , hypo-sulphuric acid is formed .
8 .
From these experiments it appeared probable that the ether was the product of the decomposition of the sulphovinic acid : but a mixture of equal weights of alcohol and sulphuric acid contains , besides the sulphovinic acid , a considerable quantity of unaltered acid and alcohol ; for in such a mixture three-fifths(4 ) of the sulphuric acid would be converted into sulphovinic acid by combination with the hydrocarbon of less than one-third of the alcohol employed .
I next proceeded to ascertain , whether , when no alcohol was pre.sent ether would be produced .
A quantity of the sulphovinate of potash was therefore prepared. .
The-composition of this salt has been given in the paper in the Philosophical Transactions before.referredf to , and one hundred parts contain 28'.84 of potash .
Five hundred grains were mixed with 150 'grains .
of sulphuric acid , being nearly the equivalent of the potash in the salt , and then heat applied .
The experiment therefore may be considered as the distillation of sulphovinic acid mixed with sulphate of potash , which it may be presumed remained inert during the process , and also with the water of the acid and of the salt .
The proportion of water , Fit is found , has an important influence ; but in the present experiment about a drachm of fluid distilled over , and left a blackened and acid salt in the retort , having the smell of sulphurous acid .
A few grains of carbonate of potash being added to the distilled product , abstracted a little water : the clear decanted liquor was then mixed with a little dry muriate of lime , and by agitation separated into two portions ; the upper one being decanted , amounted to nearly half a drachm , and was found to be pure ether .
This result proves that ether may be formed from a sulphovinate or sulphovinic acid when no alcohol is present .
9 .
An -experiment similar to the last in the nature and proportions of the substances used , was made , except that the sulphovinate was dissolved in its own weight of water previous to the addition of the sulphuric acid .
The experiment is one therefore of the distillation of dilute sulphovinous acid , in place of that which is concentrated .
The distilled product had no smell of ether , nor could any be discovered in it .
About nine fluid drachms were obtained ; to these , carbonate of potash was added , which separated the water , and left three drachms of a supernatant liquid , appearing by taste , smell and flame , to be alcohol : this was decanted , and poured upon muriate of lime ; no ether separated , but the whole formed one solution ; being distilled from the muriate it was evidently alcohol ; and being mixed with its weight of sulphuric acid , gave sulphuric ether or sulphovinic acid again .
In this experiment there was no charring of the contents of the retort ; and by precipitation by acetate of lead , the whole of the sulphuric acid was obtained --not only the portion added to decompose the salt , but the double portion evolved from the sulphovinic acid upon the separation and re-arrangement of the hydrocarbon .
10 .
In the former paper it was shown that oil of wine when heated in water is resolved into hydrocarbon and sulphovinic acid : an experiment was therefore made upon it .
Two hundred grains of oil of wine were placed in a retort , a little water added , and heat applied : about a drachm was received , which being redistilled from carbonate of potash the product appeared to be principally alcohol , but the presence of ether was very evident.-This experiment proves the formation of ether from sulphovinic acid when no sulphuric acid was present as such at the commencement of the distillation .
With regard to the questions at the commencement of this paper , it appears to me from the facts detailed , that in the usual process for obtaining ether , the ether is not.formed .
altogether from the direct action of the .
alcohol and sulphuric acid considered.independently of the sulphovinic acid present ; for the quantity of free sulphuric acid is small compared to the quantity of alcohol present , two-fifths only of the acid remaining , while of the alcohol more than two-thirds remain ; and further , sulphovinic acid alone is readily converted into ether and .
sulphuric acid , ( see S. ) and during the distillation of ether in the ordinary way the sulphovinic acid is always re-converted more or less completely into sulphuric acid ( 4 .
5 .
6 .
) it probably therefore assists much in the process .
With regard to the third question , the opinion may be supported that the formation of sulphovinic acid is a. necessary and intermediate step to the production of ether from alcohol and sulphuric acid ; and although I do not mean to assert this view , yet it deserves a few remarks .
In no manner which has yet been devised can ether be formed from alcohol and sulphuric acid without the presence of sulphovinic acid .
Whenever ether has been formed , sulphovinic acid has been present ; whenever the sulphuric acid is diluted so far as not to forum sulphovinic acid with alcohol , it also refuses to form ether with alcohol .
Sulphovinic acid will produce ether without the assistance of alcohol .
And although the ether produced when a mixture of equal weights of alcohol and sulphuric acid are distilled , appears to be in greater quantity than can arise from the decomposition of the sulphovinic acid existing in the mixture previous to the action of heat , it is not I think inconsistent to suppose , that at the same time that one portion of sulphovinic acid is resolved into sulphuric acid and ether , another may be formed from alcohol and sulphuric acid ; and that sulphovinic acid is formed in a mixture of sulphuric acid and alcohol by heat , is proved by the following experiment .
Five hundred grains of oil of vitriol were diluted by five hundred grains of water ; when cold , to the dilute acid was added two thousand grains of alcohol , specific gravity 0.820 .
The following day this mixture was examined for sul phovinic acid , but none had been formed : it was placed in a retort , and a quantity distilled off nearly equal to the= weight of the alcohol employed this had a specific gravity of 0.842 .
Carbonate of potash separated a considerable portion of water , the original alcohol would not even moisten that salt ; the residue in the retort was examined , .
and now sulphovinic acid was found ; the evidence of which was , carbonate of lead being dissolved in considerable quantity ; here sulphovinic acid had been formed by heat , where it did not previously exist .
This result appears , also opposed to the opinion , that in the formation of ether the sulphuric acid acts simply by abstracting water from the -alcohol for the dilute acid here gave up a , portion of its water during .
the distillation , and separated from the alcohol a. portion of hydrocarbon .
It has already been shown , 1(9 .
) that the production of ether is materially influenced by the , quantity of water , present and , that the same sulphovinic acid will yield either ether or alcohol , as it is in a concentrated or dilute state .
The hydrocarbon which as was shown in the former paper , has the extraordinary power in oil of wine of neutralizing the whole of the acid properties of sulphuric acid , and in sulphovinic acid of neutralizing the half of them , being in the latter body in so peculiar a : condition that it will unite either with that proportion of water necessary to form ether , or with the larger proportion requisite to form alcohol , according to circumstances. .
: In the experiments ( 8 .
9 .
) , in the production by distillation of ether or alcohol from sulphovinic acid more or less diluted , it appeared that sulphovinic acid might easily have its proximate elements separated and restored to their original state of sulphuric acid and alcohol .
The following experiment was made with a view to illustrate this point .
Five hundred grains of acid and five hundred grainsof alcohol were mixed as before , and left for several days : by , previous experiment it is known that more than half the sulphuric acid in this way becomes sulphovinic acid ( 4 ) .
By distillation and dilution at proper periods this would have given ether and alcohol , and nearly the whole of the sulphuric acid ( 7 .
) : but instead of doing this , it was mixed with one thousand grains of water , and : then distilled until 1400 grains had passed over .
No charring or decomposition of the sulphuric acid took place ; no ether was formed ; but nearly the whole of the original alcohol and sulphuric acid were recovered .
It may be a question whether the production of alcohol and ether in those and similar experiments is altogether determined by the proportion of water present , or whether the difference of temperature consequent upon its variation may not have an effect .
When ether and sulphuric acid are heated together , oil of wine and sulphovinic acid are amongst the products obtained ; and as this sulphovinic acid is readily converted when diluted into alcohol and sulphuric acid , so it affords a method of converting ether into alcohol : thus ether may be formed from alcohol , and alcohol from ether at pleasure , by throwing the hydrocarbon of these bodies into that peculiar state which it assumes when combined with sulphuric acid in sulphovinic acid .
We may even proceed beyond this , and form either alcohol or ether , using olefiant gas as the hydro-carbon base : for I have shown in my last paper , that olefiant gas by combining with sulphuric acid , forms sulphovinic acid , and the acid so produced forms either ether or alcohol , according to circumstances which are under perfect command .
It can hardly be necessary to refer to the extraordinary remark at the end of MM .
DUMAS and BOULLAYSs second paper , except to state that it is singularly at variance with the facts and opinions given throughout the former part of that and the preceding paper by the same authors .
Those persons who read both papers , and also those of Mr. FARADAY and myself , which were published long before the appearance of the former , will be able to decide without further comment from whom the particular views contained in those papers first emanated .
H. HENNELL .
Apothecaries Hall .

