On some circumstances relating to the economy of bees .
By THOMAS ANDREW KNIGHT , Esq. F.R.S. President of the Horticultural Society .
Read May 22 , 1828 .
IN a paper which I had the honour to address to the Royal Society about twenty years ago ( in the year 1807 ) upon the Economy of Bees , I stated , that having adapted cavities in hollow trees for the reception of swarms of those insects , I had observed that several days previous to the arrival of a swarm , a considerable number of bees were constantly employed in examining the state of the tree , and particularly of every dead knot above the cavity which appeared likely to admit water into it .
At that period it appeared to me rather extraordinary , that animals so industrious as bees , and so much disposed to make the best use of their time , should , at that important season of the year , waste so much of it in apparently useless repetitions of the same act : for I , at that time , supposed that on different days , and at different periods of the same day , I saw only the same individuals .
But in a case which at a subsequent period came under my observation , where the cavity into which the bees apparently proposed to enter , was not more than a quarter of a mile distant from the hive whence a swarm were prepared to emigrate , I witnessed a very rapid change of the individuals who visited their future contemplated habitation ; and the number which in the course of three days entered it , appeared to me to be fully equal to constitute a very large swarm : and upon the evidence of these and other facts , which I shall proceed to state , I am much disposed to infer , that not a single labouring bee ever emigrates in a swarm without having seen the future proposed habitation of that swarm .
That the queen bee has also always seen her future habitation , I am also much inclined to believe , as she is well known to absent herself from the hive some time previously to the emigration of a swarm : though her object may be to meet a male of another hive ; for I much doubt whether she ever receives the embraces of a brother .
The results of some of HuiEm 's experiments are very favourable to this conclusion , as is the otherwise excessive number of male bees , and in both the animal and vegetable world nature has taken very ample means of facilitating what the breeders of improved varieties of domesticated animals call cross breeding .
I have also been led by the following facts to believe , that not only the future permanent habitation of each swarm , but the place where they temporarily settle , apparently to collect their numbers , soon after they quit their hive , is known also to each individual .
Different families of domesticated animals of every species present some peculiarities of disposition and habit ; and the swarms of the family of bees , which were the subject of my experiments , showed , I think , more than an ordinary disposition to unite , by two apparently joining the same queen .
My attention was consequently attracted to the circumstances which preceded such unions .
The simultaneous movements and agitation of two hives , had during several days led me to expect that a junction of their swarms was contemplated ; and the two -ultimately issued out almost at the same moment , and instantly united , as I had concluded they would .
The weather was excessively hot ; and I put them into a hive which was scarcely large enough to hold them , affording them no further shelter from the sun than I thought just sufficient to prevent the melting of their combs .
This occurred upon the first day of June , and in the morning of the twenty-third a very large swarm emigrated .
There was in this , I believe , nothing very extraordinary or peculiar , except the excessive expedition apparently employed in raising a second queen .
In the following year two other hives presented similar indications that their swarms would unite ; and being anxious to ascertain whether such unions were accidental , or the consequence of previous arrangements , I paid very close attention to their proceedings , and the following singular circumstances came under my observation .
After both hives had given frequent indications that a swarm was ready to issue from each of them , one swarm only rose , and that , after hovering in the air during a much longer time than ordinary , settled upon , and around , a bush about twenty-five yards distant from the hive , whence they had issued : but instead of collecting together into a compact mass , as they usually do , they remained thinly dispersed , scarcely two being any where in contact with each other .
In this state they continued nearly half an hour motionless and apparently discontented and sulky ; and they then gradually began to rise and return home , not apparently in obedience to any command or signal ; for they did not rise more abundantly at any one point of time than at another , but each individual seemed to go when tired of waiting .
The next morning a swarm issued from the other hive , and proceeded to the bush upon and around which the other swarm had settled on the preceding day , collecting themselves into a mass as they usually do when their queen is present .
This was precisely what I had anticipated , but I was much disappointed that no movement or agitation took place in the other hive .
Within a very few minutes , however , and very soon after the swarm above mentioned had fully settled , a very large number of bees suddenly rushed from the hive to which the swarm had returned on the preceding day , and proceeded so directly to the swarm which had just settled , that their course was marked through its whole extent by a perfectly visible dark and narrow line , and they united themselves , without hovering a single instant , to the other swarm .
These circumstances conjointly with others which I have stated in my former communication upon this subject , satisfied me that these unions are generally , if not always , the result of previous and perfectly well understood arrangements , though it is not easy to conjecture how such arrangements can be made .
I shall proceed to state a few circumstances which appear to throw light upon some of the phenomena observable in the mode of breeding of bees .
It has long been known that these animals possess the power of raising a queen bee from any recently deposited egg , which under ordinary circumstances would have produced a labouring bee ; but whether this power extends to those eggs , which , when deposited in larger cells , afford male or drone bees , has not , I believe , been accurately ascertained .
The following circumstances lead me to believe that sex is not given to the eggs of birds , or to the spawn of fishes or insects , at any very early period of their growth .
I selected early in winter four female birds of the common duck , which I kept apart from any male bird of that or any kindred species , till the period of their laying eggs approached .
One was then killed , and the largest of its eggs was found to be three lines in diameter .
A musk drake ( Anas moschata ) was then put into company with the three remaining ducks ; and from these I obtained a numerous offspring , six out of seven of which proved to be males , as the result of similar previous experiments ( but in which the male of another species had been introduced at a period when the growth of the eggs was less advanced , ) had led me to expect .
I repeated the experiment often , and always with nearly the same result , a large majority of male birds being uniformly produced ; and hence I conclude that the eggs of birds in early periods of their growth are without sex .
I have never possessed means of obtaining mule fishes ; but one kind of fish , which I think is obviously a mule , is found in many rivers where the common river-trout abounds , and where a solitary salmon is sometimes seen .
These formerly existed , in some seasons , in considerable numbers , in the river which passes near my residence , ; but since salmon have become scarce , they have wholly disappeared .
I had formerly opportunities of examining a large number of them .
, without having ever found a single female .
I have subsequently found them in large numbers in small mountain rivulets in Wales , below , but never above , the lowest Cataract .
They are readily distinguished from the young salmon , by their form being intermediate between that of a trout and of a salmon ; by their being all , or nearly all , males ; and by their remaining through the summer and autumn in the rivers , long after the young salmon have descended to the sea : they leave the fresh water with the first winter floods , and I believe are not known ever to return .
In the North of England they are distinguished by the name of wrackriders , and by that of samlets in some other parts .
If these be mules , as I do not entertain any doubt that they are , the spawn of fishes must be without sex when it is deposited by the female ; and I am much disposed to entertain the same -opinion respecting the spawn ( for it is more properly spawn than eggs ) of bees .
I have frequently witnessed some somewhat analogous circumstances in the vegetable world , respecting the sexes of the blossoms of plants ; and I can at any time succeed in causing several kinds ofmonoecious plants to produce solely male or solely female blossoms .
If heat be , comparatively with the quantity of light which the plant receives , excessive , male flowers only appear ; but if light be in excess , female flowers alone will be produced : the experiments necessary must of course be made with skill and accuracy .
In a former communication to the Royal Society " ' Upon the comparative influence of the male and female parent upon the character of the offspring , " , have inferred from facts there stated , that the sex of the offspring of some species of animals is given by the female parent .
Subsequent experience and observation have strengthened my belief in the truth of this inference : but I believe the power of the female parent to be rather strongly influential than positive , and that external causes operate , which ( I have some reason to suspect ) are not in all cases wholly beyond the reach of human control .
THOMAS ANDREw KNIGHT .
London , May 20th , 1828 .

