On the height of the Aurora borealis above the surface of the earth ; particularly one seen on the 29th of March , 1826 .
BY JOHN DALTON , F.R.S. Read April 17th , 1,828 .
APPREHENDING that the Royal Society will favourably receive accounts that have a direct tendency to determine the height of that interesting phenomenon , the Aurora borealis , I have been induced to transmit some observations that were made upon a very remarkable one , which appeared in the evening of the 29th of March , 1826 .
From some recent observations , an opinion seems to be entertained by some writers , that the aurora is not so high as has generally been estimated ; but it is only from facts and observations such as the following , I conceive , that any near approximation to the true height can be obtained .
The aurora borealis above mentioned , was of a kind very rarely occurring .
It assumed the appearance of a rainbow-like arch , stretching across the midheaven , at right angles to the magnetic meridian .
It was subject to very little change of position for an hour or more , and therefore afforded time to observe the angle of its elevation above the horizon .
In the period of five years ' observations at Kendal formerly , above one hundred appearances of the aurora occurred to me , and only one of the kind just described .
I had not an opportunity of seeing the one which is the subject of this paper , but it was seen here ( at Manchester ) by a friend of mine about 9 o'clock on his returning home from a visit to me .
lie did not indeed observe the luminous arch , either from its having vanished , or from the obscurity of our atmosphere ; but he remarked some beams or corruscations in the north-western hemisphere , of a low altitude ; and not having seen an aurora for a long time , he induced the family at home to go out and catch a glimpse of the phenomenon , now much more rarely seen than formerly .
A few days afterwards I accidentally noticed a paragraph in the Lancaster Gazette describing the luminous arch of the aurora , as well as the accompanying appearances ; and as such a striking and unusual phenomenon could not fail to attract general attention , I examined the provincial newspapers and other periodicals of the time , and took occasion soon after to make inquiries personally , or by writing , of such individuals of judgement as had seen the phamnomenon in various places near the line of the magnetic meridian .
The result was , a collection of a more complete and extensive series of observations than was ever before made , in all probability , towards determining the height of the luminous arch of the aurora.-I shall now proceed to detail some of the particular observations .
The accounts represent the arch to have been seen in places 170 miles distant in a north and south direction , and forty-five miles distant in an east and west direction , comprising an area of seven or eight thousand square miles ; but it must have been much more extensively visible , as in most cases the writers of the different accounts describe their situation as central with regard to the phenomenon .
It was seen at Edinburgh and Leith , Kelso , Jedbergh , and Hawick in Scotland ; at Carlisle , Penrith , Keswick , Cockermouth , and Whitehaven in Cumberland ; at Kendal and at Kirkby-Stephen in Westmorland ; at Lancaster , Preston , Warrington , and Manchester in Lancashire ; and at Doncaster in Yorkshire .
Descriptions of the phenomena as seen at most of these places were immediately given in the newspapers of Lancaster , Kendal , Carlisle , Whitehaven , Kelso , &amp;c. , and some of these accounts were copied into the London papers soon after .
All the accounts that I have seen from places between Lancaster and Edinburgh , as well as at these two places , agree that a luminous arch was first seen about 8 o'clock in the evening ; that it continued without much motion for an hour nearly , and then gradually vanished , leaving the northern sky illuminated as usual after an aurora borealis of the common kind : so that it seems impossible to doubt that the same arch was seen at all the places of observation , and at the same time .
A good description of the phenomenon was published by Messrs. Coldstream and FoggQ in the Edinburgh Journal of Science for June 1826 : it is as follows " March 29th .
Immediately after the fading of the evening twilight , at s8h 15m P.M. , a bright luminous ray -was seen to rise from the eastern horizon , gradually to extend itself towards the zenith , and thence towards the western .
horizon , presenting , when completed , the appearance of an , arch of silvery light , similar to that seen here on the 19th March , 1825 .
" When first formed it was a few ' degrees to the north of the zenith of this place ; the light in the centre was rather diffuse ; its edges were irregular ; and the western limb had , as it were , a plurnose appearance .
It soon evinced a decided motion towards the south , and in a few minutes reached our zenith .
Its edges were now sharply defined , and throughout its whole course it was nearly uniform in appearance and breadth ; the intensity of its light in the zenith had increased , while in the same quarter the breadth had considerably diminished .
" The direction it now had was very nearly at right angles with the magnetic meridian .
" 'At 2 past 8 , faint beams of the aurora began to rise from the northern horizon , and at one time promised to form a splendid display ; but the corruscations never became very vivid ; they were not rapid in their motions , and did not flit along the horizon .
" The arch still continued its motion towards the south , and in 15 minutes passed through a space of about 200 .
Its southern edge reached a point about 240 or 250 south of the zenith , beyond which it did not go .
The light now became gradually fainter , and at length disappeared .
" Meanwhile the aurora in the north continued to play , but with no increase of vividness .
For some minutes , soon after 9 o'clock , we observed broad 'bands of light , having their longer axes ( which generally subtend angles of about 180 or 20 ?
) parallel with the horizon , darting with great velocity across the illuminated space from east to west and from west to east .
These formed , ran their course , and vanished in a moment ; they had no vertical motion , but they appeared at various degrees of elevation , never higher however than 300 .
Soon after this interesting ( and perhaps unusual ) display , the beams disappeared , and nothing was left but a diffuse luminousness along the horizon .
" At Jedburgh , Hawick and Kelso , places about forty miles south of Edinburgh , the phenomena were much the same as above , as appears from the Kelso Chronicle .
( See also the London Courier , April 7th , and other of the daily papers .
) At Jedburgh the arch is said to have commenced at 8h 15m on the W. by S. point of the horizon , to have passed south of the star Aldebaran , between Castor and Pollux , and over Arcturus ; its altitude 60 ?
from the S. ; waves of light seemed to run along the arch .
At 8h 30m the whole advanced -200 to the S. At H-awick it was at first 200 S. of the zenith , and at 8 " 40m " it was stationary at 370 S. of the zenith ; the arch passed 60 N. of .
Arcturus , 70 S. of Cor Caroli , 6 ?
N. of Coma Berenices , through the hind foot of Ursa Major , 40 N. of Asellus Borealis , 6 ?
S. of Pollux , through the head of Monoceros , through the three stars in Orion 's girdle , and 1 ?
S. of Rigel .
From this it would seem that the arch , instead of appearing low in the north from the last-mentioned places , as it must have done if situated only five or even ten miles above the earth 's surface , appeared as far to the south of the zenith as at Edinburgh , or rather further .
This latter it could not do ; and in such circumstances it is reasonable to allow a difference of a few degrees in the estimates of altitudes of arches neither well defined nor absolutely fixed , and possessing several degrees of breadth ; but it clearly shows the arch was not low .
The author of the Hawick account signs , GIDEON SCOTT .
At Carlisle , seventy-five miles S. of Edinburgh , the phenomenon were much the same as in the preceding accounts .
See the two weekly newspapers of that city .
About Cockermouth , twenty-five miles S. of Carlisle , I conversed with many persons who had seen the phenomenon .
One young gentleman , Mr. HARRIS , had committed to paper at the time some notes upon it , with which he favoured me .
According to these , he first saw the arch at 71 45m P.M. , it extended nearly from the western to the eastern horizon , through the W. part of the head of Orion , over Castor and Pollux , S. of Ursa Major , and ended in Corona Borealis ; it continued with little variation in its situation till near 10 o'clock .
At first the west end of the arch was most luminous , and finally before it vanished the east end was the most brilliant .
The eastern end waxed and waned frequently .
The sky was very clear , a few streamers appeared low in the horizon .
AtKeswick , about twelve miles east of Cockermouth , the appearance was described as follows , in a letter to me from Mr. OTLEY .
This gentleman is known to the public by an elegant little description of the Lakes and Mountains of the North of England , and is familiar with observations relating to ' meteorology , and to the angles of elevation of objects .
" About 8 P.M. , a luminous arch appeared very brilliant ; the outside of the curve seemed a , little south of the zenith .
The eastern end tapered to a point above the horizon ; the western end was broader , and lost in a cloud which rested on the mountain .
It disappeared about 10 o'clock .
" At Whitehaven , one hundred miles from Edinburgh , and a few miles more to the westward , a minute description of the pheanomenon was given in one of the newspapers of that place , by Mr. HOLDEN , lecturer on astronomy , whohappened to , be there at that time .
At 8h 45m the east leg of the arch covered a. Coronae Borealis , the northern edge of the bow touched Castor near its greatest altitude , and the west leg went over the three small stars marked X in the head of Orion .
The breadth at greatest altitude was 40 40 ' , but tapered down to the horizon , where it was not more than one-fourth of that breadth .
The east leg was 150 north of the east point , and about the same number of degrees south of the zenith ; and the west leg was 150 south of the west point .
At 9h 8m the arch had moved southward , Pollux touched the north of the bow , the west leg extended over &amp; , Orionis , and the east leg was still upon M~ Coronae Borealis , but this star had been moving in its apparent track by the earth 's motion for the space of twenty-three minutes .
He saw several small clouds move before and cover portions of it for a few seconds of time .
From Kirkby-Stephen , about forty-five miles east of Whitehaven , a good description of the phenomenon is given in the Westmorland Gazette .
The mean breadth of the luminous arch exceeded that of the rainbow , the vertex broader , the extremities narrower , and the light more dense .
The arch gradually faded about 10 P.M. , having existed nearly two hours .
The light was white and transparent .
Position at 9 P.M. , the arch of a great circle from E. 250 N. through the zenith to W. 250 S. : : I At first the eastern extremity of the arch was near 3 1Herculis , thence it passed the north side of Corona Borealis , through the midst of the seven stars in the Great Bear , over the zenith to the north of LCastor , exactly over Bellatrix , after which it contracted to a point in Eridanus just above west .
This writer makes no mention of any appearance of the common aurora borealis at the same time .
, Accounts from Penrith were much the same as the preceding ones ; but I had no opportunity of seeing any of them .
At Kendal , which is 1 10 -or 115 miles S. of Edinburgh , and very nearly on the same magnetic meridian , ( consequently the same part of the arch must have crossed the meridian at both places , ) the following is a description of the phenomenon as they appeared there , and might have been adopted with very little error , it should seem , for that at Edinburgh or any one of the intervening places , except as to the altitude of the summit of the arch .
" C A most magnificent meteor was observed here between 8 and 9 o'clock .
The appearance was that of a luminous arch , stretching quite across the heavens .
Its direction was that of the magnetic east and west , intersecting the magnetic meridian at right angles .
At the same time a splendid light was observable in the northern horizon .
This meteor was similar in some particulars to one which appeared a few years ago .
" [ Query in 1819 ?
] The arch itself appeared like two frustums of cones , with the less extremity in the horizon , and their bases meeting in the zenith .
The densest parts of the bow were those near the horizon , and the west end the denser of the two .
" The phbenomenon was seen at Lancaster , twenty miles S. of Kendal , and 130 miles S. of Edinburgh ; it was described in the next Lancaster Gazette , but without being specific as to the altitude of the centre of the arch .
Inquiry having been made of an intelligent medical gentleman who had seen it , he described the luminous arch as extending from east to west across the zenith , the light increasing in intensity from the arch of the zenith to the line of the horizon ; there were those faint corruscations which usually attend an aurora borealis .
This was about 8 o'clock ; at IOh 30m P.M. there was a luminous appearance along the northern horizon .
The aurora was seen at Preston , twenty miles S. of Lancaster ; but I have not been able to learn the particular appearances at that place .
It was also seen at Doncaster in Yorkshire , but I have not noticed any description of its appearance at that place .
At Warrington the luminous arch was seen by a friend of mine , Mr. JOSEPH : CROSFIELD , who was so obliging as to give me interesting information on the subject , both verbally and by writing .
He saw the arch about 9 o'clock , or between that and 10 , in company with two other persons , to whom he pointed it out at the time .
At the first glance he took it for the milky way , but soon discovered his mistake .
The direction of the arch was from W.S.W. to E.N.E. , passing .
to the north of the zenith .
The western branch was longer and more brilliant .
He saw no northern lights , at the time , neither did he apprehend the phenomenon was connected with them .
On elevating the pole of a celestial globe till the axis passed through a series of angles with the horizon , I desired him to fix upon an elevation which he judged most nearly to coincide with the elevation of the centre of the luminous arch .
On examination , the angle was found to be 61 ? .
I then fixed the axis at 700 ; this he was almost certain was too high .
When it was fixed at 500 , he was still more certain it was too low .
The aurora was seen at Manchester , as has been stated ; but it does not appear to have attracted much attention at this place .
I have not been able to trace any account of the phenomena having been , seen further south .
These are all the material observations I have collected ; from which it must appear that the descriptions every where given evidently apply to the same luminous arch .
In proceeding from north to south we find the arch gradually advancing in altitude , always crossing the meridian to the south of the zenith , till we , arrive about Kendal , at which , place it crossed nearly in the zenith , and when -at Warrington its culminating was to the north of the zenith .
It is further remarkable , that in all the places the arch .
seemed to terminate nearly in the magnetic east and west , or at two opposite points of the horizon ; these facts indicated the great height and extension of the arch .
In order to apply the data to calculate the height of the arch , it is evident that observations at the extremities of the magnetic meridians are to be preferred , and those on or near the same meridian , all other circumstances being the same .
Unfortunately , the Edinburgh and Hawick observations do not harmonize together : however , those at Jedburgh , a place nearly of the same latitude as Ha1aick , seem to show that both the others are wrong , or rather perhaps , that they had not been cotemporary with each other and the rest of the observations .
The liawick altitude is probably too low , and that at Edinburgh considerably too high .
In this uncertainty we may be allowed to take the observations at Whitehaven and Warrington as guides .
Those places , are very nearly on the same magnetic meridian ; they are distant eighty-three .
miles , giving an extensive base : the observations were nearly cotemporary , and made on the same part of thearch , the altitude at Whitehaven being 750 from the south , and that at Warrington 610 from the north .
From these data , I find the height of the arch very nearly one hundred miles above the earth 's surface , and its position vertical about Kendal and Kirkby-Stephen , which accords well with the observations at those places .
This conclusion is corroborated by the observations at Jedburgh and Warrington , where , if we take the angles of elevation at 600 and 610 respectively , and the distance on the magnetic meridian 120 miles , the height will be found between 100 and 110 miles .
But , lastly , if we assume the angle at Edinburgh to be correct at 650 , and that at Warrington at 610 , the height comes out 150 or 160 miles , and its position vertical about Carlisle , which is in opposition to the general tenor of the rest of the observations .
As for the heights of the streamers or vertical beams seen low in the north , we have no sufficient data for determining it .
But it is evident that the beams which were seen low at Edinburgh were the same as those seen still lower at Cockermouth , Kendal , Lancaster , and Manchester , at which last place the angle was about 100 as my informant says .
Now an object elevated about 2.5 ?
from the north at Edinburgh would apparently be 100 or 120 at Manchester , if its real height were about one hundred miles above the earth 's surface .
On the whole , I think it is fairly to be inferred that the height of the arch could not differ much from one hundred miles ; and that its breadth would be eight or nine miles , and its visible length in an east and west direction , from any one place , would be about 550 miles .
( See the accompanying figure .
) Observations on other Aurorae .
The height of a luminous arch calculated by the late Mr. CAVENDISH , F.R.S. in the Phil. Trans. for 1790 , is entitled to notice .
It was found to be betwixt fifty-two and seventy-one miles .
The observations , however , were made at too small a distance from each other to admit of precision .
A base of at least forty or fifty miles seems necessary , where the object to be measured is generally neither steady nor well defined .
\~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~C~el ---0 i ; / z 00 05 X~~~~~~~~~~ 7 , , , , tt.b ' .
I'~~~~~~~~~70 C ' I f~h JICI , ~~~~~~~~ * iA ________________________ w~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ .
} !
j , The luminous arch seen at Keswick and Kendal by Mr. CROSTHWAITE and myself , on February 15th , 1793 , was calculated to be 150 miles high ; but this was from a base of only twenty-two miles .
( See my Meteorological Observations and Essays , page 69 .
) Dr. THOMSON has given a brief history of the Aurora borealis in the Annals of Philosophy for 1814 , Vol. IV .
He has copied a table from BERGMAN , being estimates of the heights of about thirty aurorwe observed during the last century , calculated from observations made by different persons in various places .
According to these results , the aurorae would seem to be of variable heights , from 130 to 1000 or more miles .
The places of observation are often unsuitably situated ; and the data from which the calculations were made not being given , I apprehend the great differences in the heights arise more from defects in the observations than from real differences .
In the same volume Mr. LONGMIRE gives a description of a luminous arch seen at Troutbeck near Kendal , on the I1th of September , 1814 .
It was similar to that above described , and was most extensively seen : namely , at Glasgow , Dumfries , and Annan in Scotland ; at Dublin and Newry in Ireland ; and at Whitehaven , Carlisle , Kendal , Lancaster , Warrington , and Liverpool in England .
It was accompanied with the usual appearances of the aurora borealis , or streamers distant in the north .
The observations are insufficient for calculating the height .
I find in my journal the aurora was noticed at Manchester that evening , but no particulars are given .
Mr. LONGMIRE mentions a similar arch seen at Kendal and Dublin on the 17th of April the same year .
An aurora was seen in London at the same time .
( Annals of Philosophy , Vol. III .
p. 400 .
) 1819 , October 17th.-A remarkable aurora , borealis was seen this evening in very distant parts of England and Scotland .
Mr. OTLEY of Keswick first drew my attention to this , by communicating the notes he made at the time upon it , on the occasion when he favoured me with his remarks upon that of the 29th of March , 1826 .
After which I collected such other accounts as I could meet with from the journals of the time .
The series of observations is as follows : Annals of Philosophy , Vol. XIV .
p. 472 .
Account from Newton-Stewart , ( Scotland .
) October 18th.- " A singular and beautiful phenomenon appeared ill our atmosphere here last night ( 17th ) , about 8 o'clock : it was a bow or arch of silvery light stretching from east to west , and intersecting the hemisphere [ meridian ] at a few degrees to the southward of the zenith .
After it had remained very bright for twenty minutes or so , dark blanks were first observed to take place here and there , and then , after expanding a little in breadth and shifting for a short way further to the southward , it disappeared .
, Some time before its appearance the atmosphere had been very cloudy ; but when it was formed the sky was free from clouds , except towards the horizon to the westward and northward , where they hung very dark and heavy.-It was strikingly different from any of the usual forms of the boreal lights , which too were seen very vivid in thecourse of the evening .
" Keswick .
Mr. OTLEY 's account-:- " ; About 7 P.M. ( the 17th ) , a dense cloud appeared in the horizon to the N.N.W. bounded by a bright line , the rest of the heavens beingstarry .
Presently beams of an aurora began to shoot towards the Great Bear .
About 8 o'clock a luminous arch extended from west to east ; the crown of the arch at first appeared to me a little to the north of the zenith , and after some time to the south of it , and again more northerly before it disappeared , which it did suddenly , a few minutes after 9 o'clock .
" Manchester.-I have-an account in my journal of an aurora seen here the same evening , but no particulars are given .
London.-The aurora was seen in and about London the same evening .
( See pages 478 and 480 , Vol. XIV .
Annals of Philosophy .
) Gosport .
In the same volume of Annals , page 395 , there is an account of the same aurora as seen at Gosport Observatory , Hampshire , on that evening by Dr. BURNEY .
The following is an extract : " On the 17th instant , at 7 P.M. a light about 300 on either side of the magnetic north point appeared in the shape of a luminous arch whose apex was 18 ?
above the horizon .
" lie then describes several beams of the commonaurora which successively appeared and traversed about for a time chiefly within the arch , and then -vanished and were succeeded by others .
After which , he adds : " Soon after this ( 9 o'clock ) the luminous arch in the northern hemisphere entirely disappeared , and some haze collected near the horizon .
" Gosport and , Keswick are very nearly under the same magnetic meridian , and 265-miles distant .
Newton-Stewart is N.W. by W. of Keswick , distant about sixty-five miles , but only thirty-five miles in a meridional direction .
Now I imagine it will be allowed that an extraordinary luminous arch seen at Newton-Stewart to cross the meridian a few degrees south of the zenith , and to continue from 8 to near 9 o'clock , nearly in that position , must have been the arch seen at Keswick at the same time to cross the meridian in like manner from east to west , and to pass nearly through the zenith .
It may well be supposed , then , that this arch crossing through the zenith at Keswick would have a very diminished altitude if seen at Gosport , 265 miles south .
From the account I have extracted , it appears that a luminous arch was seen there at the same time it was seen at the other places , and crossing the meridian at right angles , only its altitude 180 from the north instead of being in the zenith , as at Keswick , or a few degrees south of it , as seen in Scotland .
And further , the arch vanished at all the places at the same time .
It scarcely admits of doubt , then , that these arches were all one and the same .
By calculation from the data at Gosport and Keswick , I find the height of the arch above Keswick to be 100 or 102 miles ; from which the angle of elevation from Newton-Stewart must have been 710 from the south , or the zenith distance of the arch 19 ? .
A luminous arch was seen at Kendal on the 27th of December , 1827 , of which my friend Samuel MARSHALL was so good as to write me a circumstantial account .
It was first seen at ten minutes past 6 in the evening , being an arch between the magnetic east and west , and passing through the zenith .
It was broadest in the zenith , and it was more condensed in the eastern extremity than in the western .
Another parallel arch appeared about 200 north of the former , of rather less intense light ; and the northern horizon was luminous as usual on such occasions .
After ten minutes or more , the arches advanced each of them to the south 200 with their centres .
The appearance lasted about half an hour .
A few streamers were seen in the east , which moved slowly northward .
Mr. MARSHALL thinks the appearance would have been splendid if the moon had not shone at the time- : a halo round the moon vanished whemi the bow approached it .
I observed a halo round the moon at Manchester that evening .
Mr. BUCHAN , a gentleman accustomed to meteorological observations , had mentioned his having seen a similar arch at Manchester on that evening ; but apprehending it might only have been a local phenomenons I did not inquire particulars till I received the above account from Kendal .
Mr. BUCHAN informs me he saw a luminous arch that evening , about 9 o'clock ; the arch was highest to the west of the meridian , and its altitude was very nearly the same as the north pole , just under which it passed ; he estimates it at 53 ?
, and thinks it could not be above 10 more or less .
As this observation was not cotemporary with that at Kendal , nothing certain can be deduced from them , but it may not be amiss to observe that an object in the zenith at Kendal , and elevated 530 from the north at Manchester , must be nearly one hundred miles high .
The results of this series of additional observations agreeing so nearly with that of the 29th of March , 1826 , I am induced to believe that these luminous arches of the aurora which occasionally appear , stretching from east to west , are all of the same height , and that height about one hundred miles .
What length the upright beams , -or to speak more properly , those parallel to the dipping needle , -may be , which are the ordinary forms of the aurora , we have not observations to determine .
Whether those beams arise above the arches as from a base , or whether they descend below , as if appended to the arches , we cannot ; -absolutely determine .
It is remarkable that the arches and beams should rarely , if ever , be seen cognate or in juxta position , but always in parts of the heavens at a considerable distance from each other .
Manchester , IMlarch 18 , 1828 .
POSTSCRIPT .
Query , Are the parallel bands usually about 20 degrees asunder ?
If so , their distance from each other will be about thirty-six miles .

