An account of a series of experiments made with a view to the construction of an achromatic telescope with afluid concave lens , instead of the usual lens of flint glass .
In a letter addressed to DAVIES GILBERT , Esq. M.P. President of the Royal Society .
By PETER BARLOW , Esq. F.R.S. &amp; Sc. Read January 17 , 1828 .
You are aware that I have been for some time engaged in a set of experiments directed to the construction of achromatic fluid telescopes , and that I have succeeded in constructing , by the aid of Messrs. GILBERT , two instruments of that description , the one of 3 inches aperture and the other of 6 inches .
You are aware also that it was my intention to have laid these before the members of the Board of Longitude ; and if the construction had met with their approbation , I hoped they might have been disposed to have ordered a like instrument ( but upon a scale much exceeding anything yet attempted ) , the construction of which it would have given me great pleasure to have superintended .
It is , however , doubtful whether I shall be able at present to pursue the experiments * and I wish therefore to place on record the progress I have made , the results which have been obtained , and the ultimate object I had in view ; and I am in hopes this communication may not be thought undeserving a place in the Philosophical Transactions .
These experiments may perhaps date their origin from an attempt on the part of the opticians above referred to , to submit to actual practice the rules and principles laid down by Mr. HERSCHEL , in the Phil. Trans. for 1821 , Art .
XVII .
, for the construction of aplanatic object-glasses .
These experiments led to others , which I have described in the Phil. Trans. for 1827 , Art .
XV .
In following out the latter , I saw a strong practical instance of the great difficulty of obtaining flint glass of sufficient size and purity for astronomical telescopes ; and this led me to consider the practicability of substituting a fluid for the flint lens .
Dr. BLAIR many years back had projected the construction of fluid object-glasses , and is said to have succeeded in making very perfect telescopes of that description .
His view , however , in these constructions was not the same as mine ; because with him it was still necessary to retain the flint lens ; his only object being to destroy what has been named the secondary spectrum , due to a want of proportionality between the coloured spaces of the spectrums of flint and plate , or crown glass , as compared with their respective refractive indices ; whereas my design was to dispense altogether with the flint glass , by substituting in its place a fluid medium of the requisite refractive and dispersive power .
A great number of fluids may be thus employed ; and the first business was to determine amongst the many , that which seemed best suited for the purpose .
With this view I undertook the examination of the properties of various oils , acids , &amp;c. and was ultimately led to try the sulphuret of carbon , which at once appeared to claim a preference , and to possess nearly every requisite I could desire ; having a refractive index about equal to that of the best flint glass , with a dispersive power more than double , perfectly colourless , beautifully transparent , and , although very expansible , possessing the same , or very nearly indeed the same , optical properties* , when hermetically sealed , under all temperatures to which it is likely to be exposed for astronomical purposes , -unless indeed it should be found that direct observations on the solar disc in some extreme cases are inadmissible .
Its high dispersive power also gives it an advantage which no glass ever made , or likely to be made , can possess ; although the fixed'nature of the latter material may probably always give it a preference in the ; construction of telescopes : and I wish clearly to be understood , not as proposing to supplant the use of flint glass in these instruments , but simply to supply its place by a valuable substitute , in cases where it cannot be obtained sufficiently large and pure ; or where it can only be obtained at an expense which must always limit the possession of a powerful astronomical telescope , to a small number of individuals and to public bodies .
Having , as above stated , selected my fluid , my next object was to determine the best means of confining it , which after several trials was satisfactorily accomplished ; and -I now at once attempted a telescope of 6 inches aperture and 7 feet in length : but after several unsuccessful experiments , arising from unforeseen difficulties , I laid it by , and undertook one of 3 inches aperture .
I was here molre fortunate , having withthis instrument in its rude exp erimental form , without any adaptation -or selection of glasses , separated a great number of double stars of that class which Sir W. 1ERsCHEL has pointed out as tests of a good 3k-inch refractor .
I can see with it the small star in Polaris with a power of 46 ; and with the higher powers several stars which are said to require a good telescope as for example , 70 p Ophiuchi , 39 Bootis , the quadruple star A Lyre , 4 Aquarii , Herculis , &amp; e. Encouraged by my success on this instrument I again attempted the 6-inch object-glass , with a different manner of adjusting and securing the lenses and the result of my endeavours I consider to be perfectly demonstrable of the practicability of the construction , allowance being made for the imperfections of a first attempt , at a novel construction , on a considerable scale , and which professes only to prove the applicability of the principle , and not the completion of the experiment .
With this instrument the small star in Polaris is so distinctand brilliant with a power of 143 , that its transit might be taken with the utmost certainty .
The small stars-in a Lyrve , Aldebaran , Rigel , s Bootisj &amp;c. are ' very distinctly exhibited ; amongst the larger close double stars , Castor and ey Leonis are well defined with a power of 300 ; and amongst the smaller double stars I may mention w Aurigue , 52 Orionis , g Orionis , and a variety of-others of the same class .
The belts and double ring of Saturn are well exhibited with a power of 150 ; and the belts and satellites of Jupiter are very tolerably defined with the same power , but will not bear a higher power than about 200 , in his .
present situation , which is certainly.not favourable : in both cases the discs of the planets are satisfactorily white , and belts and shadows well marked ; but in Jupiter , and perhaps in both , there is some uncorrected colour round the edge of the disc .
Of this however I shall speak again after describing the principle of the construction .
In the usual construction of achromatic telescopes , the two or three lenses composing the object-glass , are brought into immediate contact ; and in the fluid telescope proposed by Dr. BLAIR the construction was the same , the fluid having been enclosed in the object-glass itself .
Nor could any change in this arrangement in either case be introduced with advantage , because the dispersive ratio between the glasses in the former instance , and between the glass and fluid in the latter , is too close to admit of bringing the concave correcting medium far enough back to be of any sensible advantage .
The case , however , is very different with the sulphuret of carbon .
The dispersive ratio here varies ( according to the glass employed ) between the limits 299 and 334 ; which circumstance has enabled me to place the fluid correcting lens at a distance from the plate lens equal to half its focal length ; and I might carry it still further back , and yet possess sufficient dispersive power to render the object-glass achromatic .
Moreover , by this means the fluid lens , which is the most difficult part of the construction , is reduced to one-half , or to less than one-half , of the size of the plate lens ; consequently , to construct a telescope of ten or twelve inches aperture involves no greater difficulty in the manipulation , than in making a telescope of the usual description of five or six inches aperture , except in the simple plate lens itself : and , what will be thought perhaps of greater importance , a telescope of this kind of ten or twelve feet length will be equivalent in its focal power to one of sixteen or twenty feet .
We may therefore , by this means , shorten the tube several feet , and yet possess a focal power more considerable than could be conveniently given to it on the usual principle of construction .
This will be better understood from the annexed diagram .
_ A:== __ DrD In this figure , A , B , C , D represent the tube of the 6-inch telescope , C , D the plate object-glass , F the first focus of rays , de the fluid concave lens , distant from the former 24 inches .
The focal length MF being 48 inches , the diameter of the fluid lens is consequently as 48 : 6 : : 24 : 3 inches .
The resulting compound focus is 62-5 inches : it is obvious , therefore , that the rays df , of arrive at the focus under the same convergency and with the same light , as if they proceeded from a lens of 6 inches diameter placed at a distance beyond the object glass C , D , ( as C ' D ' ) determined by producing these rays till they meet the sides of the tube produced in C ' D ' , viz. at 62-5 inches beyond the fluid lens .
Hence , it is obvious , the rays will converge as they would do from an object-glass C ' D ' of the usual kind with a focus of 10 feet 5 inches .
We have thus , therefore , shortened .
the tube 38-5 inches , or have at least the advantage of a focus 38-5 inches longer than our tube ; and the same principle may be carried much further , so as to reduce the usual length of refracting telescopes nearly one-third without increasing the aberration in the first glass , beyond the least that can possibly belong to a telescope of the usual kind of the whole length .
It should moreover be observed , that the adjustment for focus may be made either in the usual way , or by a slight movement of the fluid lens , as in the Gregorian reflector by means of the small speculumn ; in the latter case the eye-piece is fixed , which may probably be convenient for astronomical purposes , in consequence of the great delicacy of the adjustment .
Besides the above advantages attending this principle of construction , I am willing to hope that another very important one ( which I have not however been able at present practically to demonstrate ) may still be effected ; namely , the reduction of what has been termed the secondary spectrum , either to zero or to a very inconsiderable amount .
In order to examine the practicability of this object , let us first consider the two lenses in contact , and inquire into the conditions requisite for uniting the violet , the red , and the mean ray , which latter may be accounted that on the confine of the violet and red sides of the spectrum .
Let the focal length of the mean ray in the plate lens bef , and the length of the focus beyondf , viz. the red side of the spectrum , be r , its whole focus being f+ r ; let f ' , r ' and of course ft + r ' denote the same in the correcting fluid lens : then , in order that the red ray may coincide with the mean-ray , we must have 11_11 if f f+ r ' ; f ?
r Now f+ af f(f+r ) and 1r 11 1T therefore , when r we must have ( _= fl+A f ( f ?
+ r ) f ' ( f'+ r ' ) and therefore , f:f::r f-r r That is , the mean focal lengths must be to each other as the red part of the focus divided by : the whole focal length of the red ray , or , as the .
dispersive powers for this side of the spectrum , in each lens .
In the same way , if we denote by v and v ' the length of the violet part of each focus ; then to have the violet and the mean ray coincide , we must have 1_1 11 ffif iv f ' -v " and as before , we shall find that this can only take place when v '~ t , -vdorwhenf:f f(f-v ) = f'(f'-v ) f-v f '-v ' Hence , in order to unite these three colours , the conditions must be that rv Vt , f~r * Jf-v f* jr iVBut asf r and v , in one case , and f ' , r ' and VI , in the other , are dependent and proportional in each respective focus , if these proportions do not arise from the natural properties of the two media , they cannot be produced by art , while the lenses are in contact ; but in any case where the violet side of the correcting or concave lens exceeds that of the red in a greater proportion than the violet exceeds the red in the convex lens , and if the dispersive ratio be so great as to admit of the lenses being sufficiently opened from each other , then such a distance may be found as shall produce the above proportion ; and hence unite these three rays in one common focus , or at least approximate towards this result .
Let the distance of the lenses be d , and let the plate focus remain as before f , then the negative focus must be reduced till ( 2= dispersion* .
Conceive this length to be found , which may still be denoted byf , and r ?
and v ' may also denote the same as before , the ratio i. , , to will likewise still remain the same .
But the coloured focus of the plate lens remaining the same as before , while the mean focus is changed fromf tof-d ; we must now , in order to unite the three rays , have r v !
v f-d +r Jf-d-v *o+r !
The two latter terms remaining in the same ratio , while the two former may be varied at pleasure by changing the value of d ; which will have no effect on the ratio of the latter terms , although the actual value off ' , r ' and v ' , must necessarily vary for every change in the value of d. Li Let the constant ratio of the latter terms be m : ; then we have to find d , such that g~~ ~ ~~~~ ~ ~~~ rM nVm A : a : : ~~~m : n , ; or , I _ , -r f-d+r f-vmv ffd+ r f-d-v. .
~~~mvf + , mvr -nrf + nvr which reduced , gives d =r my nr If now at , a " ' , a " ' be taken to denote the refractive indices of the red , green , and violet ray in the front lens , we shall find f , r and v , to be to each other as all a1 alit art 1 , a1 , and aII ; and substituting these proportional values for the above letters , our expression becomes d=f a " m~II ( " all ) -n ( a"la ' ) dfm a ' ( al'al ) -'n ad11 ( all"a ' ) In like manner , if oat oz " , or " ' be taken to denote the refractive indices of the red , green , and violet ray in the correcting lens , then we shall find rl vt~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~i Jf+ r1 f_VI m : na Which latter may therefore be substituted for m and n. The formula then becomes d= tfa " '-(all Ot ) ( al"'all ) ( 0..t all ) ( allat ) =fa lf(fz'-1 ) ( a"'a " ) at(o1II..att ) ( all"at ) a1l1 5 an expression for the distance in terms of the indices and focus only .
In plate glass , according to FRAUNHOFER , a ' = *515 , a " 525 , and a " ' *535 .
Which values being substituted , give d =f *S1 ( a"-(a')-l(a9(o"a " ) df -.981 ( a " -x ' ) -1-0 19 ( a " ' all)i In flint glass , from the same authority , a ' = 602 , c= *620 , ,I " = *640 .
Which numbers being substituted , give d= *734 f. An impracticable distance in this case , because the dispersive power of flint glass is not great enough to correct the plate lens when so far removed .
If these indices had been 602 , *621 , and 640 , then we should find d= 0 , or the lenses ought then to be in contact .
A change therefore of 001 in the index of the green ray , changes the distances of the lenses from nothing to nearly three-fourths of the whole focus of the plate ; consequently , the determination of the proper distance to combine the three colours , when the media are such as to admit of it , depends upon the most delicate determination of the indices of the red , green , and violet rays ; but these being so determined , and the dispersive power of the medium being great enough , the most complete union may be effected .
Whether the sulphuret of carbon fall within this limit or not , I am not at present able to say .
I have attempted to find the indices of the different colours by means of a prism ; but it is extremely difficult to determine the limits of the different shades , and perhaps after all the best way is by actual experinent on the telescope itself .
Fearful in the beginning of advancing too far in opening the lenses , the first experiment was made with the fluid at a very inconsiderable distance behind the plate , and the quantity of uncorrected colour was very great .
I next tried a distance of 18 inches , and the uncorrected colour was considerably less than before , but still too great .
With this distance the experiment was witnessed by Captain KATER .
I next opened the lenses 24 inches , and at this distance the experiment was witnessed by Professor AIRY , who still detected some uncorrected colour , which , however , is not sensible to my eye till the telescope is applied with a high power to Jupiter , Venus , or some bright star ; neither was this defect felt in any sensible degree by Mr. SOUTH or Captain BEAUFORT , who were also present .
From the gradual diminution of the outstanding purple by opening the lenses from contact to 24 inches , I suspect with a distance of 32 inches , ( which is perhaps the most I can venture upon with a focus of 48 inches for my plate , ) that the red would be outstanding , and if so the proper point must be between these limits .
This , however , remains to be verified by experiment ; should it be effected , we may enumerate the advantages of this telescope as follow : 1 .
It renders us independent of flint glass .
2 .
It enables us to increase the aperture of the telescope to a very considerable extent .
3 .
It gives us all the light , field , and focal power of a telescope of one and a half times at least , probably of twice the length of the tube .
4 .
It is presumed that further experiments may enable us to find such a distance for the lenses as shall reduce what has been termed the secondary spectrum , ( inseparable from the usual construction , ) either to zero or to an inconsiderable amount .

