On the corrections in the elements of DELAMBRE'S Solar Tables required by the observations made at the Royal Observatory , Greenwich .
By GEORGE BIDDELL AIRY , Esq. M.A. , Fellow of Trinity College Cambridge , and Lucasian Professor of Mathematics in the University of Cambridge .
Communicated by1 JOHN FREDERICK WILLIAM HERSCHEL , Esq. V.P.R.S. Read December 6 , 1827 .
THE attention of the Board of Longitude having been directed to the state of the Solar Tables used in the construction , of the Nautical Almanac , the Astronomer Royal was requested to furnish the Board with a comparison of the computed and observed Right Ascensions of the Sun since the erection of the new transit instrument at Greenwich : and I was desired to examine the discrepancies with a view to the discovery of the errors in the elements of the tables .
The papers containing this comparison I received at the beginning of June last ; and in the last summer , as soon as other engagements permitted , I undertook the laborious work of examining the discordances .
The corrections of the elements determined by these calculations agree in general with those that have been obtained from other observations but in one particular , and that an important one , there is a very remarkable difference .
The results of such an inquiry will perhaps be acceptable to the Royal Society ; and the singularity of the conclusion which I have mentioned , will make it necessary for me to describe the manner in which I have obtained it .
The number of observations from which this comparison is made is 1212 , commencing on July 30 , 1816 , and terminating on December 30 , 1826 .
The only interruption of any importance is one of about three mouths , from February 4 , to May 22 , 1825 .
These do not include all that are given in the Greenwich Observations , but only those which are likely to have been least affected by irregularities of the clock , &amp;c. in consequence of the observation of standard stars at no great interval .
As far as the end of 1820 the observations are reduced by Dr. MASKELYNE'S catalogue ; after that time they are reduced by Mr. POND'S catalogue of 1820 , in which the right ascensions of the stars are increased 0",31 , of time .
Though there is sometimes a disagreement in the errors for consecutive days amounting to three or four tenths of a second of time , ( undoubtedly produced partly by the errors of observation and partly by those in the calculation of the Nautical Almanac , ) yet when the skill of the observers and the excellence of the instrument are considered , I believe it will be allowed that this mass of observations is equal to any that has been used for the purpose of correcting the tables .
A slight inspection of these errors was sufficient to indicate that a correction of the epochs of the sun 's longitude and of the longitude of the perigee , with perhaps an alteration of the equation of the centre , would bring the calculated place for any one year sufficiently near to the observed place ; and with these corrections only I commenced my calculations .
But , upon comparing the discrepancies for different years , I found that there was certainly some other source of irregularity ; and such could be found only in the erroneous mass assigned to some of the planets .
The masses of Venus and Mars being the only ones which produce any sensible effect on the Earth 's motion , and which can be measured in no other way , I supposed them subject to error , and with these five assumed corrections the greatest part of the calculations has been made .
A more critical examination showed that there was an error in the assigned mass of the moon ; but the rapidity of variation of the lunar inequality allowed me to determine this correction by a more simple process .
Suppose now 0 to be the observed error of the tables , the sun 's observed place being reduced by Dr. MASKELYNE'S catalogue ; e the error of MASKELYNE'S place of the equinox in A , or the quantity by which the right ascensions of all the stars in his catalogue ought to be increased , both expressed in seconds of time .
Then 0e is the real error of the tables in R. After January 1st , 1821 , when the observations are reduced by Mr. POND'S catalogue , in which the right ascensions are increased by,31 of time , the error of the tables is 0 +,31 e. The corresponding errors in longitude , expressed in seconds of space , are 15 sec 230 28 ' X cos2 dcc X0 e ; and 15 see 230 28 ' X cos2 dee X0+ 31 e. Now if the proper corrections were applied to the elements of the tables , the sumn of the quantity just found , and the alteration produced in the longitude by those corrections , would , if the observations wereaccurate , be nothing ' ; and if there be no constant cause of error in the observations , upon adding a great number of quantities thus formed , the errors may be expected nearly to destroy each other , and the sum may be assumed equal to nothing .
Let X be the number of seconds of space by which the epoch of the sun 's longitude ought to be increased Y the increase in seconds of the epoch of the longitude of perigee : Z the increase which must be made in the greatest equation of the centre : suppose the mass of Venus to be increased in the ratio of I : 1+ V , and that of Mars in the ratio of I : 1+ M. Then X-Y is the increase of the mean anomaly .
Now the tables contain the alteration in the equation of the centre for an increase of 1O ' in the mean anomaly , and for a diminution of 17"1,177 in the greatest equation of the centre .
The sun 's true longitude then being taken from the Nautical Almanac , and his true anomaly found by subtracting the longitude of the perigee , the mean anomaly corresponding was found in the tables , and the alterations of the equation of the centre for + 1O ' in , mean anomaly and 17`",177 in the greatest equation were takenout : .
call them a and b. By the alteration of epochs and of the equation of the centre , the tabular longitude would be increased by X+ ( 600-)-17 1477 The perturbations of Venus and Mars are increased 600 1717 each by a constant to make them always positive ; ( DELAMBRE has not mentioned the values of the constants , but they appear to be respectively 16"60 , and 6 " 5 ; they are subtracted from the equation of the centre ) : call these c and d , and letf and g be the tabular perturbations .
Then the real perturbations aref-c and g -d ; and by increasing the masses of Venus and Mars , the sun 's tabular longitude would be increased by V ( f -c ) and M ( g d ) .
If then we neglect for the present the lunar equation , -which we may do , since every group of equations will comprehend several lunations , we shall have a series of equa-~ tions similar to the following , each of which is true excepting the errors of observation ; 0_ 15 sec 23028 ' x cos ' decl x O-e +X+a ( X -Y ) lbz +V ( C ) + M(g-d ) ?
6010 17,177 x x-Y Dividing this by 15 see 230 28 ' , and putting 1s_8 __ 6xe --xv.15 Sec 230 28 600 X 15 X sec 23 ? ?
28 z VM= 17,177 x 15 x sec 230 28 ' = Z1 15 sec 230 28'-1 15 sec 230281 = m , the equation becomes 0= cosdec X0e+x+ ay +bz+v ( fc ) +m ( g d ) .
The equations thus formed were to be divided into groups of two kinds : one kind in which the coefficient of one of the unknown quantities was large , another in which it was small or negative : and by subtracting the sum of one group from the sum of the other , an equation would be obtained in which the coefficient of that quantity would certainly be large , and in which the other coefficients probably would not be large .
As there was some uncertainty respecting the values of c and d , it appeared desirable to eliminate them from all the equations but one : this was done by dividing the equations into grorps of equal numbers and subtracting one from the other .
Thus the eqwations were divided into eleven groups containing 606 equations , in which the value of a was positive or &gt; 3,8 ; and eleven groups containing 606 equations , in which a was negative and &lt; 3,8 ; their difference gave this equation : 0=+ 85,484 -e x 9,382 +yx 15018,9-z x 368,58 +vx 1026,7 +nx 598,4 .
They were again divided into eleven groups containing 606 equations , in which the value of b was positive and &gt; 2,5 ; and eleven groups containing 606 equations , in which b was &lt; 2,5 or negativee : their difference gave ( y ) ... 0 -22,785-e x 13,832-y x 174,5 +zx 13319,28 +vx 517,3 +mx 636,0 .
They were then divided into thirteen groups of 606 equations , in which the value of f exceeded 15,4 ; and thirteen groups of 606 equations , in which f was less than 15,4 : their difference gave ( 6 ) ... 0=+ 61,465e x 1,536 +y x 2905,7 +zx 95,50 +vX 6655,1 +mx 223,2 .
Similarly , they were divided into nine groups of 606 equations , in which g exceeded 6,3 ; and nine groups in which g was smaller : -from their difference ( E ) ... 0= + 65,860 +ex 6,678 +yx 5706,9 -F zx 3944,46 +vx 439,9 +mx 2307,2 .
Lastly , by adding together all the equations , .
-177,278 ex 1118,282 d(x vc md ) x 1212 -y x 1744,3 4zx 1118,96 +vx 19319,1 + n ; X 7519,8 .
As it was probable that the epoch of the sun 's longitude ought to be altered , it was to be expected that the secular motion of the tables was incorrect .
I had supposed , however , that this error might be neglected in the investigations , and that the results would be sufficiently accurate for the mean time of the observations : but an examination of the groups showed that this was not the case .
The equations in which the coefficients of x and those of y were alternately positive and negative , as well as those in which the coefficients of v were alternately great and small , were distributed with tolerable uniformity over the several years .
But it was not so with those in which the coefficients of m were alternately large and small .
A single group in which the coefficients of m were large , extended over nearly two yearsat the beginning of the period of the observations , and comprehended 219 observations .
The equation then ( E ) intended to have the coefficient of m large , would be of the same nature as if the sum of the equations for several years were subtracted from the sum of the equations for several years previous ; and would therefore be much affected by the error in the secular motion .
This was taken into account in the following manner : let S be the number of seconds of space by which the secular motion ought to be increased ; and let X now represent the correction of the epoch for 1816 .
Then in q years after 1816 the tabular longitude would have ( IS been greater , had the secular motion been correct , by j-S ; and in r years by rS 0 If in this interval N observations had been made , distributed almost uniformly over the interval , the sum of all the increments of the tabular longitude would have been nearly I( + .
N ( q + r ) in seconds of space .
By this quantity the errors of the tables ( in the original equations containing X , Y , &amp;c. ) ought to be increased : and therefore , in the equations conS taining x , y , &amp;c. they ought to be increased by 0 sec 230 28 XN ( q + r ) .
Let 3 23 28 ' p : then the first term of each group , ( in which N is the number of equations , and q and r the years and fractions of years from the beginning of S16 to the first and last observation respectively , of that group , ) must be increased by pXN ( q + r ) .
Applying this to all the groups , it is found that ( a ) ought to be increased by + 14051 .
p ; G ) by 220 .
p ; ( r ) by + 393.p ; ( Z ) by 241.p ; and ( s ) by -3817.p .
Solving the equations thus augmented , we find x-vc-m d,37718 +e x,9696 -p x 24,182 y=,0043027 +e x,000964 -p x,0697 % =,0029488 +e x,001419 -p x,1278 v =,006674 +e x,000049 -p x,0004 mn =-,021682 -e x , 00775 +px 2,042 And ( supposing c= 16,6 , d:-6,5 ) , x =,12547 +e X,9200 pX 10,915 ; whence X=+ 2,0518 +ex 15,045 S x,05458 Y=+ 41,2690 +ex 5,589 +S x,1545 Z=,8283-ex,399 +S x,01096 V=,1091 +e x,0008-S x,000002 M=,3546-e x,1267 +S x,01021 in which X , Y. Z. and S are expressed in seconds of space , and e in seconds of time .
The Astronomer Royal , in his latest catalogue , has made e= 0",20 .
To determine S we have the following data .
From the researches of M. BURCKHARDT ( Conn. des Tems , 1816 , ) it appears that the correction of the epoch in 1783 , using MASKELYNE'S catalogue , was 0",25 : in 1801 , 0",8 .
And from the expression above for X it appears that the correction , using MASKELYNE'S catalogue , was + 2,05 in 1816 + 5,458 years , or in the middle of 1821 .
The coinparison of this with the correction for 1783 gives S= 4",7 : the comparison with that for 1801 gives S= 6",1 .
Now if there be in the sun 's motion any inequality of long period , the value of S which is wanted here is not the real increase of mean secular motion , but that which , independent of the inequalities taken .
into account in the tables , but including all others , applies to the period of the observations .
I have therefore taken S= 6",0 .
After these substitutions I find that The epoch for 1816 ought to be increased by 4",734 ; or , more exactly , free from any uncertainty respecting the value of 5 , the epoch for 1821,5 ought to be increased by 5",061 .
The epoch of the perigee ought to be increased by 46",3 .
( These epochs are to be measured from the equinoxial point adopted by .
Mr. POND in his catalogue of 1826 .
) The greatest equation of the centre ought to be diminished by 0",84 .
The mass of Venus ought to be reduced in the proportion of 10000 : 891 1 , or 9 : 8 nearly .
The mass of Mars ought to be reduced in the proportion of 10000 : 6813 , or 22:15 nearly .
Hitherto I have not considered the possible error in the coefficient of the lunar equation .
The variations of this equation are so much more rapid than any of the others , that the other corrections may be determined independently of it , and it can be determined independently of them , and even without reducing the errors to errors of longitude .
I have merely arranged the observed errors in A from the middle of 1816 to the end of 1820 in two groups , one comprehending all the observations between new moon and full and the other all the observations between full moon and new ; from each group I have found a mean , and have taken the difference of the means .
The same has been done from the beginning of 1821 to the end of 1826 .
Thus , to the end of 1820 , Mean of 248 errors between new moon and full =,0825 .
Mean of 265 errors between full moon and new =,1609 .
Excess of the former +,0784 in seconds of time .
After 1820 .
Mean of 374 errors between new moon and full -- , 4493 .
Mean of 325 errors between full moon and new =-,5445 .
Excess of the former +,0952 .
Mean of the whole,0881 in seconds of time , equivalent to 1",322 of space .
To find the alteration which this requires in the coefficient of the lunar equation , suppose k to be that alteration : then the correction to the sun 's longitu'de would be very nearly kX sin difl .
long .
of sun and moon .
Now in the number of observations that we have taken , we may suppose that the difference of longitudes of the sun and moon has had different values between 00 and 3600 without any remarkable preponderance of any particular values .
To reduce this to calculation , suppose while the angle increased from o to z , n observations were macde at the intervals - : then we must find , the mean of the quantities k sin 7 , k sin 2 , &amp;c. up to k sin % : in other words we must find nn * x~~~~~~r n~~7 Cos Xthe value ofI sin- .
lNow I sin-= which from xI to n U.X 2 sinIT -2n 2 cos ~-n xzn+ 1 is _ : and the mean= , which when n is very 2 Sinltan 2n tan2n 2n 2n great becomes nearly 2k .
This then is the mean quantity by which the longitudes between new moon and full , so far as they depend on this equation , 2k are too great , and similarly is the mean quantity by which the longitudes 4k between full moon and new are too small .
Taking the difference then , -= difference of mean errors = 1",322 ; whence k= 1",04 .
And since the sun 's longitude , as far as it depends on this , is too great between new moon and full , at which time the lunar equation increases the longitude , it follows that the coefficient of the lunar equation ought to be diminished by I",04 .
The coefficient in DELAMBRE'S tables is 7",5 : hence , if the moon 's parallax be not altered , the quotient of the moon 's mass by the moon 's mass + the earth 's mass is to be diminished in the ratio of 29 25 nearly .
If these deductions could be relied on , we should have Mass of Venus = X01211 xthat of the Sun .
Mass of Mars X602 X that of the Sun .
Mass of the Moon =X that of the Earth .
And the limits of the errors of DELAMBRE'S tables , roughly estimated , would be as follows , Error in epoch for 1830 .
-5",6 Greatest error from error in place of perigee ... + 1",5 Greatest error from error in greatest equation of centre ?
,8 Greatest error from the combination of these .
1,7 Greatest error from error in mass of Venus .
+ 1"5 Greatest error from error in mass of Mars.+ 1,9 Greatest error from error in mass of the Moon.+ 10 Greatest possible negative error.1.",7 Greatest possible positive error. .
+ 0",5 I shall now compare these results with those which have been found from an examination of some of Dr. MASKELYNE'S observations .
In the Connaissance des Tems for 1816 , M. BURCKHARDT has given the results of a comparison of DELAMBRE'S tables with nearly four thousand of MASKELYNE'S observations , extending from 1774 to ISI0 .
The following are his most important conclusions .
1st .
The correction of the epoch in 1801 was + 0`,8 .
In 1783 , + 0",25 .
In 1752 , 3",0 .
The latter was found from 310 of BRADLEY'S observations , and the result seems doubtful , from the uncertainty of the reductions .
2nd .
The correction of the longitude of the perigee in 1783 was+ 25 " ; in 1801 it was 2",7 .
If these places of the perigee be used , the variable part of aberration is not to be applied , in order to find the sun 's apparent place .
3rd .
The correction of the greatest equation of the centre in 1783 was -0",84 ; and in 1801 , 1",23 .
4th .
The coefficient of the lunar equation to be diminished from 7",5 to 6",8 .
5th .
The mass of Venus to be diminished -1-th .
6th .
The mass of Mars to be diminished.-th : which produces an almost insensible effect on the sun 's longitude .
The general agreement of my conclusions with those of M. BURCKHARDT is highly satisfactory .
The correction of the equation of the centre and the diminution of the mass of Venus are absolutely the same : the diminution of the coefficient of the lunar equation differs very little .
In the diminution of the mass of Mars there is a sensible difference : and though my equation for M is not so favourable for its exact determination as those for y , z , and V. yet I am inclined to think that M. .
BURCKHARDT 's diminution is not sufficient .
The slight disagreement in the increase of secular motion deduced from the comparison of my correction of the epoch with the two given by M. BURCKHARDT , ( a correction which in general is liable to less uncertainty than any other , ) seems to show that there is still some very small inequality in the sun 's motion not included in the tables .
But our deductions as to the correction of the place of the perigee do not present the same agreement .
It must be observed that the variable part of aberration is included in the longitude given by M. BURCKHARDT'S corrected perigee .
Now the effect of this variable part is the same as if the longitude of the perigee were increased by 10",1 .
Consequently M. BURCKHARDT'S correction of the perigee ought to be diminished by 10",1 .
Thus we have , Correction of perigee in 1783 , + 14"1,9 Correction of perigee in 1801 , 12",8 Correction of perigee in 1821 , + 46",3 The motion of the perigee then appears to be of the most irregular kind .
Of the accuracy of the correction for 1816 , as established by Mr. POND'S observations , there can be no doubt .
Independently of the very great care which has been used , by systematic checks on every part of the operations , to insure accuracy in the numerical calculations , it is sufficient to glance at the discrepancies of the observed and calculated lR , in order to see that the longitude of the perigee must be increased .
The negative errors of the tables are invariably greatest in summer .
The necessity of diminishing the masses of Venus and Mars , and even of diminishing the equation of the centre , is not evident till the equations are formed : but the error and the kind of error in the place of the perigee will never be doubted by any one who has seen the observations .
The equation also ( G ) in which the coefficient of y is large , is very favourable for its exact determination .
I can see only two ways in which this singular irregularity can be accounted for .
One is by supposing that the term in the motion of the perigee which depends on the square of the time is incorrectly calculated .
I have too much confidence in the accuracy of the results in the M6canique Celeste to suppose there the existence of an error sufficiently great .
The other is by supposing some yet undiscovered inequality of the form a. sin ( b D+ c ) where a is the sun 's mean longitude and ba coefficient differing very little from unity .
This I suspect to be the true cause of the discordance of theory and observation .
The corrections which I have stated as the result of this examination differ in some degree from those deduced in the Phil. Trans. for 1827 , p. 65 , &amp;c. from Mr. SOUTH'S observations .
The smallness of the number of observations there used , and the rejection of any alteration of the planetary perturbations , are sufficient to account for this difference .
G. B. AIRY .
Trinity College , Cambridge , Oct. 3rd , 1827 .
POSTSCRIPT .
I have the satisfaction of stating to the Royal Society , that since the communication of the paper above , my conjecture with regard to the origin of one of the irregularities noticed in it has been completely verified .
Upon examination of the planetary theory , I find that in consequence of the action of Venus , the Earth 's motion in longitude is affected with an inequality for which the expression , taking the mass of Venus as determined in this paper , is 2"1,6 x sin{8 x mean long .
Venus13 x mean long .
Earth + 390 57 ' } .
The period of this inequality is about 240 years .
This term accounts completely for the difference in the secular motions given by the comparison of the epochs of 1783 and 1821 , and by that of the epochs of 1801 and 1821 .
From the known relations of terms in the investigations of physical astronomy , it will be seen that there must be in the expression for the Earth 's longitude , terms , probably sensible , of the forms A. sin.8 x mean long .
Venus 12 x mean long .
Earth +B and C. sin 14 x mean long .
Earth 8x mean long .
Venus'+ D } ; and these may account for the alteration of the equation of the centre , and the irregular motion of the perigee .
The earth 's latitude also must be affected with similar terms I : have been .
prevented from calculating these terms , and from extending the former so as to include the parts depending on the secular variations of the elements , and even from examining some parts so carefully as I. could wish , by the excessive labour attending these investigations .
The tern calculated is of the 5th order ; and I believe it may be fairly stated that the labour of the calculation is twenty times as great as for the long inequality of Saturn , .
and far greater than for any term hitherto treated of .
I shall resume the investigations as soon as I have sufficient leisure and spirits : and I propose then to lay before the Society a more detailed account of the calculation .
G. B. AIRY .
Trinity College , December 16th , 1827 .

