On the resistance offluids to bodies passing through them .
By JAS .
WALKER , Esq. F.R.S.E. Communicated by DAVIES GILBERT , Esq. M.P. V.P.R.S. Read May 31 , 1827 .
THE principal object of this Paper is to explain a mode which I have taken to measure the resistance of fluids to bodies passing through them .
It is , I believe , new ; and being more simple and less subject to error than any yet adopted , I have thought it my duty to offer it to the Royal Society , together with the results of the experiments I have made up to the present time .
I intend to continue the experiments in a boat which is building for the purpose , with some improvement in the machine , during the ensuing summer , the only season in which it can well be done , nearly a perfect calm being necessary for making them with accuracy .
The machinery is of very easy construction , and the description of it may , I hope , lead others to follow the example , and to prosecute the inquiry in the same manner with surfaces of various forms and sizes .
The resistance of fluids has long formed an interesting subject , and has lately acquired a new importance from the introduction of steam in navigation , rendering the ratio between power and velocity essentially necessary to be known .
The comparison of canals with rail-roads , to which public attention has of late been much directed , depends also chiefly upon the ratio between the resistance and velocity by each of those modes of conveyance .
A question connected with this latter subject , to which my attention has been professionally called , led me to make the experiments I am about to detail .
It has been demonstrated and proved in the most satisfactory manner , by various experiments , that the resistance from friction to a carriage upon a road or rail-road is the same at all velocities .
I know , therefore , that the same strain upon a waggon which has the effect of moving it upon a rail-road at the rate of one mile per hour , will ( after the inertia is overcome ) be india cated at any other velocity at which the power is made to move ; but I have not found any theory or experiment by which , after knowing the strain upon a boat moving at the rate of two miles per hour , I have been able to fix satisfactorily the strain that is exerted upon it when moving at the rate of four miles per hour .
The resistance of the fluid per se increases in the duplicate ratio of the velocity.-Experiment has amply confirmed this theory in the abstract ; but there are other elements of resistance caused by viscidity , by friction , by the accumulation of the water in front and the depression towards the stern of the boat , for which our ignorance of the laws which govern the internal motion of the fluid has prevented any correct theory from being suggested ; and the experiments , from their disagreement , and from the way in which they have been made , have not done much to supply the defect .
The most important experiments upon this subject are those of the French Academy in 1776 and 1778 , conducted by Bossut and others , and those that were made by the London Society for the Improvement of Naval Architecture between 1793 and 1798 .
The Frenci experiments of 1776 were made by means of boxes six feet in length ( French measure ) , one foot wide , and two feet deep , or by the models of ships , of the same length , and nineteen inches wide ; the depth of immersion varied from seven to sixteen inches ; the velocity and resistance were calculated by the time of passing over fifty feet with uniform velocity .
The utotion was communicated by means of a silken cord two lines and a half in diameter , one end of which was attached to the float , while the other end was passed under a pulley or sheave , and then over another sheave at the height of seventy-six feet , when the weights were fastened to it .
The moving power does not appear in any case to have exceeded twentyfour pounds , nor the velocity two miles and a half per hour ; and with those velocities the friction was considered so small as scarcely to be sensible .
The general result was , that the resistance is in the duplicate ratio of the velocity ; but the small velocities , the short distance , the friction of the sheaves , and the varying friction of the line dragged through the water , as well as the small sizes of the bodies themselves , have appeared to me objections to the application of the results of these experiments , especially to larger bodies and to higher velocities .
[ 4:1 zat'r25 MDCQ(XXVliUc~ 1 pt .
3 : ~~~~~-IS ll 2~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~i N~~~~~~~~~~~~C a:~ ~ g. 2 , , , I tj II *1 II I II HIII K. If &lt; II jQ or !
VI K. II K. NIf/ 7 : i 'V 1 1,111 Va 'K -'-1 .
Vi NII I The principal object of the experiments which were made by BosSUT and CONDORCET in 1778 , was to ascertain the difference of resistance to bodies of different forms : they appear to have been made with great care , but with machinery of nearly the same description as those of 1776 , and subject , as far as respects what I had in view , to the same objections as the former ones ; only that the bodies were somewhat different in size , some of them being two feet and others four feet wide , with two feet depth of immersion .
The models which the London Society used for their experiments , so far as they have been published , were of various lengths , but all one foot broad and one foot deep ; and either sunk considerably under the surface , and held there by bars attached to a floating body , or sunk until their upper surfaces were just level with the water .
These were dragged across the water in the Greenland ( now the Commercial ) Dock , by means of a line passed under a sheave to the top of a triangle of poles , or shear legs , sixty feet high , thence through a system of pulleys , from which the box that contained the weight was suspended .
The friction and rigidity of this machinery and line were important , when the small size of the body to be moved is considered ; -it appears that it amounted in most cases to thrice the calculated resistance of the body .
A very small error in deducting for this must have been fatal to the accuracy of the experiment ; and although every pains appear to have been taken to ascertain the deduction to be made , it is extremely difficult to get at it in all cases with the necessary correctness .
It does not appear that the friction between the water and the rope was taken into account : this alone , in so great a length , must have been considerable ; and not only so , but varying in extent in the same experiment , as the line became shorter , and different also in each experiment , according to the velocity .
My object has been to get rid of the liability to error from the above causes , and to show at one view the amount of all the resistances opposed to the body under different velocities : but to show those resistances without mixing them with the friction of the line through the water , or of the machinery .
The accompanying drawing will give a correct idea of the plan I took .
The experiments were made in the middle of the East India Import Dock , which is 1410 feet in length , 560 feet wide , and 24 feet deep ; so that there was no resistance from the sides or bottom of the dock .
A spring weighing-machine was fixed near the bow of the boat , the dial laid horizontally , so as to be easily seen by a person on board ; one end of a line three-eighths of an inch in diameter was attached to the hook of the spring , the other end was carried ashore and attached to a reel or barrel three feet in diameter , the frame of which was firmly fixed in the ground , and the handles of sufficient length for the necessary number of men to turn the barrel .
The velocities were calculated from the time of passing through 176 yards , or one-tenth of a mile ; but to obtain uniform velocity , the boat was at each experiment drawn over twice the length , and the 176 yards taken in the middle of the distance by two marks upon the line .
The time between the two marks coming to the edge of the dock was carefully noted by a person stationed there for the purpose .
Three persons at least were on board the boat ; -one to read off the strain shown upon the dial every two seconds , one to write them down , and a third to steady the boat .
An exact uniformity of motion by the men at the handles was obtained , after a little practice , by means of a pendulum varying in length ( as a quick or slow motion was required ) hung up in sight of the men , by the oscillations of which they regulated the revolution of the handles .
It will easily be seen , that although the men who worked the barrel had to overcome the resistance arising from friction of the line through the water , and of the bearings of the barrel , the weights or strain marked by the hand or index of the dial on board the boat measured the resistances to the boat only .
The experiments in the Table A were made in a full built boat loaded with two tons two cwt .
, exclusive of the men .
The length of the boat upon the surface of the water was eighteen feet six inches ; the breadth , six feet ; the depth of immersion , two feet ; the whole depth of the boat being three feet , leaving one foot above water , and the greatest immersed cross section nine feet .
The experiments in Table B were made in the same boat as those of Table A , with about two tons of ballast .
Column 1 .
is the number of seconds employed in passing 176 yards , or onetenth of a mile.-Column 2 .
the velocity per hour expressed in miles and decimals of a mile.-Column 3 .
the actual measure of resistance or strain shown upon the dial of the machine.-And Column 4 .
the resistance calculated upon the ratio of the square , taking one of the experiments as a standard .
CalculatedresistCalculatedresist. .
X Seconds in Milesand Actual rea i pn i Seconds in Miles and Actual relancelnpudsi passing 176 decimals sistance in taking No. 5 .
as Z4 passing 176 decimals sistance in taking No. 4 as F1 yards .
per hour .
pounds .
standard .
F1 yards .
per hour .
pounds .
standard .
1 124 2,903 15,75 15,04 1 79 4,557 44,85 38,59 2 85 4,235 39,50 32,01 2 80 4,500 40,32 37,64 3 146 2,465 10,00 10,85 3 93 3,871 28,07 27,85 4 140 2,571 11,00 11,80 4 94 3,830 27,26 27,26 standard 5 145 2,483 11,00 11,00 standard 5 78 4,165 49,34 39,59 6 140 2,571 12,00 11,80 6 141 2,553 10,03 12,12 7 120 3,000 14,00 16,06 7 142 2,535 9,47 11,94 8 120 3,000 14,00 16,06 8 142 2,535 9,52 11,94 9 142 2,535 10,10 11,94 10 143 2517 9,23 11,78 As a number of the above velocities are nearly the same , I have averaged the results .
The average resistance of Nos. 7 , 8 and 10 ( low velocities ) , is 9,41 pounds : the corresponding velocity , 2,529 miles .
The average resistance of Nos. 1 and 2 ( high velocities ) , is 42,59 pounds : the velocity , 4,529 miles per hour .
The resistance calculated in the duplicate ratio of the velocities would be 38,11 pounds in place of 42,59.-Again , the same low velocities , Nos. 7 , 8 and 10 , compared with No. 3 ( velocity 3,871 ) , would give , by calculation , a resistance 22,04 , while the actual resistance was 28,07 .
The experiments in Table C were made in a boat twenty-eight feet in length ( See the drawing ) ; but being light , and more exposed to the action of the wind , the smaller boat already described was afterwards substituted .
TABLE C. a. .
2 .
3 ... ~~~~~.~~~~~~~ ~Calculated resistSeconds in Miles and Actual rein s , z passing 176 Decimals sistance in ance in unds , Z yards .
taking No.1 .
as A ~~a per hour .
pounds .
~~ standard .
1 162 2,222 13,08 13,08 standard 2 187 1,925 11,00 9,82 3 89 4,045 47)26 43,34 4 87 4,138 49,50 45,35 5 137 2)609 18,10 18)02 A few experiments were also made in a small Thames wherry , the distance 80 yards .
The average velocity of four of these experiments was 106 yards per minute , or 3,660 miles per hour ; resistance 10,4 pounds : and of four others , the velocity was 160 yards per minute , or 5,5 miles per hour ; and the resistance 29 pounds ; while the ratio of the square of the preceding four experiments would have given 24,27 pounds .
The smaller excess beyond the calculated resistance in the larger boat and the wherry , as compared with the other boat , I consider to have been owing to the form of the bow of those boats causing less heaping of the water in front of them .
In almost every experiment , therefore , the resistance shows an increase amounting to the square of the velocity ; but where the velocity is considerable , the resistance follows a still higher ratio , and this in open water .
In narrow canals the increase must be considerably greater .
The excess beyond the square is to be attributed in a great degree to the raising of the water at the bow in high velocities , and to the depression at the stern .
This does not take place until the velocity is considerable ; and in the low velocities of the French experiments it could not be so important .
The boats which I used were taken without any previous preparation ; my object being to collect all the resistances to a boat in the ordinary state when in use ; and the results have satisfied me , that , as respects the comparison of canal navigation with rail-roads , the rapid increase of resistance upon water brings the rail-road to a par with it at a lower velocity , than if the resistance upon canals were as the squares of the velocities , as hitherto calculated .
If , with a speed of two miles and a half per hour , thirty tons upon a canal be equal to seven tons and a half upon a level rail-road , a speed of five miles per hour would , upon the principle of the square , bring the rail-road and canal to an equality ; while the result of the experiments makes the two modes of conveyance equal , considerably under four miles per hour , and gives the railroad the decided preference at all higher velocities .
It will be observed , from the manner in which former experiments have been made , that the weights employed have been in proportion to the resistance ; that is at least to the square of the velocity .
The way in which I made the experiments , required a weight or power at least in the ratio of the cube .
Thus if the weight put into the scale in the former experiments produced a velocity 1 , a weight 4 produced a velocity 2 ; while in my experiments , if one man at the wheel produced a velocity 1 , eight men ( even without regarding the excess beyond the commonly received theory ) were required to produce a velocity 2 .
The cause is evident ; and would scarcely deserve mentioning , but that it affords a simple way of removing the confusion I have heard and seen expressed on the subject of the ratio of the square and the cube .
As the weight 4 descended in the scale with twice the velocity , the expense of power per second was as 8 , or as the cube ; but the distance ( 50 or 96 feet ) being performed in half the number of seconds , brought the quantity of power exerted to pass through the given distance back to 4 .
And in my case , as one man overcame the resistance 1 , four men would be required to overcome the resistance 4 with the same velocity : but the velocity being twice the former velocity , it required twice the power , or eight men ; the distance was , however , gone over in half the time , so that the expense of power , by doubling the velocity , was only as 4 to 1 , as in former experiments .
So in overcoming the friction upon a road or rail-road , if a fixed engine of one-horse power move a waggon upon a level road one mile per hour , a two-horse power , acting through a wheel and pinion , or otherwise , will be required to double the speed , although the friction at all velocities is uniform : and ccvteris paribus , the quantity of power required for moving a given weight a fixed distance upon land , is the same at all velocities ; while upon water the quantity increases considerably beyond the square of the velocity .
The following statements with velocities at two and four miles per hour upon a road and upon water , show at one view the whole of the points .
Land Experiments .
Water Experiments .
Velocity per hour ... ... ... ... 2 miles Velocity per hour ... ... . .
2 miles Distance passed over ... ... ... ... . .
2 miles Distance passed over ... ... 2 miles Power of engine required ... ... ... ..1-horse Power of engine required 1 -horse Time occupied.1 ... ... ... ... ... .
hour Time occupied.1 hour Quantity of mechanic 1 Quantity of mechanic power expended ?
power expended f ' ' Land Experiments .
Water Experinzents .
Velocity per hour ... ... 4 miles Velocity per hour ... 4 miles Distance passed over .
e *

