XXXIII .
On the figure of the earth .
By GEORGE BIDDELL AIRY , M. A. Fellow of Trinity College , Cambridge .
Communicated by J. F. W. HERSCHEL , Esq. Sec. R. S. Read June 15 , 1826 .
JHE ellipticity of the earth , deduced by Captain SABINE from a series of pendulum experiments the most extensive , and apparently the most deserving of confidence , that has ever been made , differs considerably from that which , as is generally believed , is indicated by geodetic measures .
The difference can only be explained by errors of observation , by peculiarities of local circumstances , or by some defect in the theory which connects the figure of the earth with the variation of gravity on its surface : under the last head may be placed defects in the mathematical part of the theory , and errors in the assumptions of the original constitution and present state of the earth .
It was with a view to ascertain the sufficiency of the mathematical theory , that I undertook the investigations contained in this paper .
The celebrated proposition called CLAIRAUT'S theorem , by which the earth 's ellipticity is inferred from the variation of gravity on its surface , is obtained only by the rejection of the squares and higher powers of the ellipticity .
It is by the same rejection that the figure of the earth , supposed a heterogeneous fluid , is proved to be an elliptic spheroid .
It appeared therefore probable , that a more accurate theory might introduce some modification into CLAIRAUT'S theorem , and might also show the figure of the earth to differ from an ellipsoid ; and there was no reason to think that the first approximation to that figure was more accurate , than the first approximation to the motion of the moon 's perigee .
The result of my investigation does not at all serve to reconcile the pendulum observations made by Captain SABINE with the measures of degrees : and with respect to one object , which I hoped to obtain , I am thereforezcompletely unsuccessful .
The theory shows however , that the earth 's figure , on the usual suppositions as to its constitution , is not an elliptic spheroid ; and the formula which I have obtained will give the means of determining very exactly the figure of the earth , when the experiments on the variation of gravity , or the measures of arcs on the earth 's surface , shall be thought sufficiently accurate .
As the subject is one whose interest is not confined to the present time , I have ventured to offer my investigations to the Royal Society .
The first part of the following sheets contains the theory of the heterogeneous earth , pushed so far as to include all the terms of the second order : it is succeeded by a comparison of this theory with Captain SABINE 's results , and with the best arcs of the meridian that have been measured : and in the conclusion , , I have offered some suggestions on the propriety of repeating some of these measures .
( 1 .
) To ascertain the form of equilibrium of a fluid , it is first necessary to find the sum of the products of each particle by the reciprocal of its distance from any point of the fluid ( LAPLACE , Mecanique Celeste , livre iii .
no. 23 ) .
This can be done only by assuming a function with indeterminate constants to represent the form of each stratum of equal density : then finding that sum , and applying to it the cone ditions of equilibrium , the values of the constants will be found .
As we propose to carry our approximation to the second order of the difference from a sphere , or the second order of the ratio of the centrifugal force to the force of gravity , it is evident that , without something to guide us , this will be a work of considerable labour .
( 2a .
) Here , however , we shall derive some assistance from former investigations .
CLAIRAUJT and LAPLACE have shown that , to the first order , the form of every surface of equal density is an elliptic spheroid : the difference , consequently , of any surface of equal density from an elliptic spheroid is only of the second order .
If a be the polar semi-axis of an elliptic spheroid , a ( 1 + e ) the equatorial semi-axis , A ' the sine of the latitude of any point , ( the latitude being that which is usually termed the corrected latitude ) , R the radius drawn to that point , then R= a ( i + e.i _.gP2 _ 3e 2_PI`4 ) The radius then of a surface of equal density is a ( i + e. *-p 13 e2 .
6r2_e4 +a quantity of the seco-d order .
Now , upon using the elliptic value of R , it would be found that the equation of equilibrium could not be satisfied , in consequence of the appearance of I 'd : but no higher powers of An ' would enter into that equation .
To enable us to take away these terms , R must be increased by a function of A ' , containing none but the even powers of P , ' as far as 4 The most convenient form that we can take is a. A ( t4'P-p2 ) , since it vanishes both at the pole and at the equator , and at middle latitudes expresses the depression of the surface below the ellipsoid whose axes are the same .
The value of R then in the spheroidal surface of equal density is assumed to be~~~~~~~e be ai +e.i I-t4"( +X = ) ( s. ) Let V be the sum of the products of each particle by the reciprocal of its distance from any point : let p be the sine of the latitude of that point , r its distance from the centre : also let A and X be the latitude and longitude of that point , 0 ' and co ' those of any other point .
Then it is easily found that their distance =V { rg-. .
2rR(sin A. sin0'+ cos 0 .
cos 0 ' .
cos ' , a ) +RV { rr 2'r R ( hIh I+ V 42V1V I2 .
Cos toSte )+ R } : let thisz .
Suppose now the heterogeneous spheroid divided into wedges by planes passing through the axis , and suppose each of these wedges divided into pyramids whose vertices are at the centre : let Rx ' be the angle of two planes , and 3J ' the angle made by the two surfaces of a pyramid which cut these planes ; and suppose the pyramid divided into frustra , the length of one being ARE .
Then the solid content of this frustrum is ultimately R A. ' , R cos I'v ' .
SR = RX SR .
to ' .
Sp , ultimately ; and if p be its density , the product of the particle into the reciprocal of its distance from the given point is ultimately PAR *R .
dw .
Consequently , to find the sum of those products for the spheroid , we must integrate P with respect to R. a ' , and * ' : or , which amounts z PRz dR to the same , we must integrate Iz da with respect to a , ow ' , and fi : that is , we must take faf'j &gt; .dR , or in the common notation fff R. .
da .
d/ .
d ' .
The z da limits of PI ' are i and + 1 : those of X are oand x2X : and those of a are o , and the value of a at the external surface , which we shall call a ' .
( 4 .
) To perform these integrations , it is necessary to expand the expression for z in a series of powers of _ or l , : the former of course must be used for the strata interior to the point in .
question , and the latter for the strata exterior to that point , that the series may in both cases converge .
Suppose then ' __ V{rg .
2rR '(KEM + V/ 1-2 HI-A ' Cos ( S'-S ) + Rr } *R +Q(2)E R ( 3)R RI+ &amp; C. for the former case z+ Q r4 3 ( ) ( X ) r( ( 2 ) ( 3 ) or .
&amp; * ... fo the latter Q , Q &amp; c , being the same in both series ) : then Q satisfies the following equation .
( liv .
iii .
n0 .
9 ) d:Ah f-s e Q ?
X : I id O(i ) - which is likewise true if we put is ' for w and a ' for a. And the value of V now depends on the integral..~.L.Jffp ( zKR$+d Rr CP fpfiQ i+zdR ; iiQ/ a~c/ tPaQ *R *daoidp ; ii+ x ( since p is a function of a alone ) , for the interior strata , i being made successively 0 , 1 , 2 , 3 , &amp;c. ; and on the integral rz .
da a for the exterior strata i being made = a , 1 , 2 , 3 ) &amp;c. ( 5 .
) Suppose now R reduced into a series of the form B I Z , ( + ) +B Z ) +B Z , ( ) + &amp;c. , where B ' , &amp;c. are 00 functions of a , and Z ' ( k ) is a function of J. that satisfies the equation d { , __ }+l This equation is exactly similar to the equation above for Q i ) , since R does not depend on '_ o and therefore d.'z Z , ( k Ri+2 ~dR d R+ 3 d-___ ( ) is =O .
Then R* d= d~ ~~~d ( k ) +3 o , 1 , 2 , 3 , &amp;c. and to i the values o , 1 , S , 4 , &amp;c. For the value i 2 , we must suppose log .
R expanded into the series c y'(o ) +c y ' '+ cy ( )+ &amp;c. and must take the rd.c Ck ( )( sum of the quantities rJ P , ,I Q y , making k successively o , 1 , !
a , &amp;c. The integrals with respect to a must be taken from a=a to a= a. ( 7 .
) Now LAPLACE has shown ( Mec .
Cel .
liv .
3 .
n10 .
12 ) .
that J , fQ( ) Z'A ) from p./ -ito !
=+ i , and from ( J =O to &amp; ' 2 7r , will always be = o , except k= i. And it appears also ( liv .
s. n0 .
i1 .
) thatU O4 a ' +3 yY ) ; but U~ ) ( see n0 .
17 .
) is there .
ad + 3f f QO ) yi(Z ) between the same limits , y(i ) being the value of Y ' i ) when , and w are put for p'and W'I henceJ , Jf Q( )yI(-)_ .
lie .
where yi(i ) is any function of V , ' and Ad satisfying the equation o{ 1jp + , -2 + Consequently , f Q ? ?
2 , ( i)= + IZ~ J , Q(i2 , .
( ( 2 ) / ( z ) 4 ( 2 ) ( i ) ( i ) ZO)~i and J , ,Q .
0 where Zz and(2 are the values of Z1 ( i ) , and y ' ( z ) , when p..'is changed to u. ( 8 .
) Since we propose to include only the second order of e , and since to that order no powers of 1. .
' beyond the fourth are found in R or any function of R , it follows , that Q(i ) ( and Qi ) i(4 ) will be the last terms to be integrated , and therefore i will not exceed 4 .
And as even powers only of a ' are found in R , there will be no terms as Z ' ( i ) in which i is odd , and therefore it is not necessary to consider any but the even values of i. Now for the interior spheroids , when Ri +3_R3 = a3 le.1{ .
' Z95 ... ... ... ... .
and since by LAPLACEP'S formula ( liv .
s. no. 16 ) , Z'(i ) , when it does not depend on d is a multiple of .
-2+ 2.2ii i1 * ' i. d. a ' 1+ ze + e.-.A ) have V for the interior strata S4 -p da5 -3 a( da 3 ) d a7( ?
e2.+a S. rilaa* d a+ ( 3( ) + 9 .
7.rsJP da d.aL(ie _________O d.aS(e+ 5e +--A ) 52 7+ r +Let 2ep da + 9.=4 !
2 ( a e2+ da):"= +2 d. O a(e2 _ A ) , .
( a ) ; ( ) , the integrals ben made to ____ a '2 vanlish whena --o : taking them to a -a6 , V for the interior stratam ut Vo 3P 3 6 ' 3( lo ) .
For the strataTexteriar to the pintin question when When o , R RI -R = _a'(12 9 e. I 2+ ea _I ( 3 e+ ) 2F* = a9 +4+ Z_ _ a9 ( 2e7+-+ e +Z + a2 ( 4e2 +2 ) -s , _6 12 + 3 .
whence b= a2 ( + 4e+ -45 z ?
When i"2 log Rt =log a+ e. 1_ 12_e -Wi i/ .--a constant term-(e.--15e jA7 .
+a multiple of p,4_ 6 ' tz2 +3 whence C2 e-5 e2+7 )( )_ When -z =-+ R's-Rz =a constant +a multiple of t'i~3 Z*F &amp; +3 whence , ba.2A I z(4 ) _46 fs + 3 ( i X ) .
Collecting the terms now in the same manner as in ( 9 ) , according to the directions in ( 6 ) , and observing the values of the integrals in ( 7 ) , we find that part of V which ded .
as ( I +e4 pends on the exterior strata -= 4 fi 3 da d ( e -e1+ 2 diAt 47a -3I-9r PAda * 76535 r~ t~ + re +2 , d2-5e0 ____3_d________ v ( a ) i 14 _7_ NG a ) jp a *aA9(a ; then taking the integrals from aa 4=0 to a=a we have for the exterior strata , V= 3 { 2 A3 ( 12 ) .
Adding together the expressions in ( 9 ) and ( fm , ) we find for the complete value of V , str a vt(a ) , i 3 ) f { %(a)(a )Ia{ r(a)ao(o)}m ) ( 13 .
) When a fluid is in equilibrium , * if x , y , and z , be the co-ordinates of a point in it , and P. Q. R. the forces in those directions then at a surface of equal density P(+Q Jy +R Axz= o ( liv i. n0 .
17 ) ; and the equilibrium ais impossible except P JA + Qy + RAz be the complete variation of some functionU .
The equation then to a surface of equal density is U C. In the present instance .
if the ordinates be measured from the centre , and ?
be the axis of revolution , and T the time of revolution , the only -force besides the attraction is the centrifugal force ; the resolved part of which in the direction of x is o , that ill the direction of y is T y. that in the direction of z is Z. This contributes to SU the terms T ( ySy +z and to U the terms T ?
( y +z 2 ) = .
I r2 .
1 And if &amp; M be any attracting particle whose co-ordinates are x ' , y ' , z ' , its attractions in those directions are ( w~2 + ( y 2+ y,72 + B2A ' or +L ; + .
and consequently it contributes to 'U the term AM ( x'x +( - , 3 ' + , Zand to U the ( a Xh +Z +T T &gt; l )v term ++ The expression then which the attraction of the whole adds to U is the sum of all the quantities .
+ &amp; + 1 , i= ) ' or the sum of the products of each particle by the reciprocal of its distance from the attracted point ; that is , V. The whole value of U then isV + -i-.r.r2 _ pi,2 and the equation to a surface of equal density is C= { ( +3 ft ( a)- .
( a ) } + ( +k3 +r { X~ta)-X(M ) } ) * S+ 22Lr +t rS+ 9r C~a ) ( ?
)}).1-3 73 Ir 2 } r3 ~~ ~~~~5 2 T. +9 ( ? ?
3V ( 14 .
) If then for r we put its value in terms of the semisaxis of the spheroid which terminates it , and the angle which it makes with the equator , we shall have an equation which , so far as it depends on that angle , must be " identically true , Now if a and E are the same functions of a which e and A are of a , _ to the second order I= ?
( I. TI +.~~~1 0 " Now +E IAthe ) to the first order ( 1-3 E.1 -B ) ; r2 = a2 ( 1 + !
2 E. 1-ad ) X including no small quantities Ad r= a. These are not to be taken farther , because 3 ( M ) , ( and 3T , are of the first order , and v ( s ) and ?
( z ) of the second order .
Substituting these values , in the last equation , we find C=5 ( a ) 32 { T ( a)-t ( M ) } ( X3f +( a+ { ( a ) 3 %(a ) } )*+ex Making the coefficient Of p2 = 0 , and that of A* 0 , and observing that , as the equations which we shall find are general for all values of a , we may put a for Af e~q , ( a)1A4(a)I 3I~z 2~a cev ( a)_ 3 .
( a ) ( A a ) 9 e4(a)0 = to pa +3( , ,a)+z5 ( a ) ( a ) }70 7( as +g4 { a ( a ) ?
( a ) } )~~~~~~7 These are the equations of equilibrium ; and since by differentiation they may be reduced to two differential equnal tions , from which the two quantities A and e are to be found , their solution is possible , and the equilibrium with the assumed figure is therefore possible .
( 05 .
) At the surface these equations become )ea ( 5 5e ) a ) 3a +9a v(a ) o_e+ A ) ( a)e 3 aBy +4e T2 ea 0 ... ..e~~-I--~-.k5eJ Tz ~~ 7 as~ Ie..\9(a ) + 4(a)).3 L3v ( a ) ( 16 ) .
The force on any point in the direction of r is found by differentiating the expression at the end of ( is ) with respect to r. For since , by ( , is ) , the force in the direction of X = , d U.if we conceive x to coincide with r , the force in the dU direction of r In this expression a is a function of r ; but it will be found ( as may also be proved by independent reasoning ) that the terms produced by differentiation with respect to a destroy each other .
The force then in the direction of r ( with its sign changed , as we have to estimate not a repulsive but an attractive force ) is 43i~ p(a ) ( 3 4T )+rXa-%( a ) ) 1-3 2t , ,.:'z 3(T~ i.+ 5~tf4 -X(a ) 0 zT7 'r + } At the external surface this is t ( a)+ - .
3 r , r3rv ( a ) ( 9 45 2L Ld -l 2* -I+ r6 14 74X+ Z4)K } *Observing that -h-=[A , , + 4 .
e. -I 2 A. 4 41 ; 14'_p *r-a e 'r4-a4..7,.L ; the force on a point of the surface in the direction of ( a.e. 0 ( a)(a r=4hi a ; 2 )+j &amp; m4e(w 1sf .
I -a.1=S+ a a ; 43e d(a ) 'A z.(a ) xze4( ) - !
3'2 v ( a),9 a4 - , is 2s1 3PT-.g2 e a. 1-f + mow ( " 45 7 2 ( i.7.)Now since this is the resolved part of the whole gravity at any point , which is necessarily perpendicular to the surface , we shall find the whole gravity by dividing this expression by the cosine of the angle of the vertical .
To the order which we are considering , the angle of the vertical is the same in the spheroid and in the ellipsoid with the same axes , and it is therefore =X e. sin lat. cos lat. 92e 1/ i p iIts cosine therefore =l e. is -i ' : consequently V __ ( a ) z. e. p ( a ) gravity at anypoint= __ ~~~~~~3 ( a)2 34 ( a ) 3.fr 2 e2.p(a ) T a4 Ty-i.2 a. f+ a2 3 er .
( a ) zA@ ( a ) 27 12 e.(a ) 2 a2 IJ+ azIk a4 23T 2 .
w2e a. t212+ ( a ) ( _e+ }.But this is in terms of A , the sine of the corrected latitude : it will be more convenient to have it in terms of AX , the sine of the real latitude .
Since the corr .
lat. real lat. 2 e. sin. lat. cos. lat. it is easily found that = ? ?
4 eAt-* e -A substituting , gravity =w{ ( a ) I-42 e+3 e2 ) +3 a , ( a ) '(e 3w a ( a + 2a e ) +9v ( a ) ja4( se za4 ( +-5e+3zt+2)l &gt; a ) { i@(a)(6~~~~~~1 15v ) ( Zeva+3z e ( a)a).- : } )a4 ( 22 t , at ( 2+ 23e + a3 +55 44 p a)72 e55 ( a T3 vJ ( a)1n)egv ( 8 .
) From the'equations of ( 5 ) , ( ( a ) ge ++ e ) ae(a+ ea ) 21 ) zT2 + 3A +2 ' ae a. 3/ 32 103 --a e.Substituting these , gravity + ( a ) ( 2+ZA+32 39 + a1 + -A.a( L ( 19 .
) Let m be the ratio of the centrifugal force at the equator to gravity at the equator .
The centrifugal force there --a ti Be)--3 ?
2-T2X 2a ( i + e)* the grat TV 323V vity there =41 e ) 25 a : , therefore 3a9a ( 2 +2e).a(m m e ) a.m ; whence 3 X(a ) m-m e up ( a ) me3m a= 2+ze+ a te4 +)a Making this substitution , gravity = 43.e 32 + e2++ me+ 92 m2+ -LA):+ 52 e++2e2_ me ~~~in2 ~~ 72 4m -2 A)e -( me+ +3A)+ +A ) 3a2 24 4T 3~~~~~1 2~ +3 A ) .
x2.i -X2 } .
If then the equatorial gravity be represented by G , the gravity in latitude I will be G2I 5zmee e+ me+ 94 A)sin,2/ ( ~~~~-m e-4 2-( Im e _e +3 Am ) sin2 .
cos / Whatever thereforebe the la of density in the interior of the earth , the gravity at any point of the surface can be expressed from a knowledge of the form of that surface only .
This is an extension of CLAIRAUT'S theorem .
( 20 ) .
We shall now proceed to find an expression for the length of an arc of the meridian included between two given latitudes .
If 0 be the corrected latitude , and u , the radius of curvature is T iI ) } Here u= a(l-e.i 2+ u , + ^ ... .__ dO e ' .
i_ _+ A.* 1I{jae A+ 2 COS 2 0( +8 cos 4 0 ) , and the radius of curvature -=a 1+ -++j -~~ CO 20m ' O:z } e56e _2 jot 6 +8 ) Let this = an It was found that,2=)2 -_ 4 e. X2A-X , or sins0 =-sin ' 4 e. sin ' I. cos ' l ; from which cos 20 = It lb ~~~~~~~~1e e~ A cos 2 -+e-ecos 4 1 : hence vahj , -T+ 12b-I- .
~~~~6 8 Now~ 7s th COS 2+( -5 A ) cos Now since I is the angle made by the normal with a fixed line , the increment of the arc , corresponding to the increment 6S of the latitude , is ultimately fy1 , and the arc =fv ; integrating therefore from 1L to = L ' , and making a ( + e+ R+I the arc included between the latitudes L and L ' =R LL ( Sin 2L -sin 2 L ) +iI0* ( sin04 L '-sinn4L ) ( 21 .
) An arc of a parallel in latitude 1 , comprehending the difference of longitude D , is most easily obtained by observing that the decrement of its radius upon increasing I is equal to -sin Ix the increment of the arc = sin Ix y ; 1 , and therefore the radius = sin I ; the integral being corrected so as to become o when 1= 9O .
We must therefore integrate -Rsin Ii4 COS 21+ ( IS ISA ) CO 44 This gives the radius of the parallel R{(1 + 38 ( 4l ( ~ + 3A ) cos 3OS + ( L z ) cCOS l } ; and therefore the arc corresponding to the difference of longitude D=-D.R.{(1+2$-)Cos Co1 D =. .
( f + 48 )csl 4+ 3-2 -56 )CS + 32e 6 ) Cos 1 } I now proceed to compare this theory with observation .
In selecting from the numerous determinations of the variation of gravity one set for our present purpose , there can be no hesitation in fixing on Captain SABINE'S , as extending over the greatest arc of latitude , and as being made by the same observer with the same instruments at no great interval of time .
The following are the places of his observations and their latitudes , with the lengths of the seconds ' pendulum determined by him .
Length of seconds ' penPlace .
Latitude .
dulum in inches .
St. Thomas * 24 41,2 39,02074 Maranham .
2 31 43,3,01214 Ascension .
7 55 47,8,02410 Sierra Leon .
8 29 27,9 01997 Trinidad .
e 10 38 56 , o1884 Bahia .
e 12 59 21,02425 Jamaica The , irregularities in the lengths at the places nearest to the equator are considerable ; but the number of these places is so great , that the errors will probably destroy each other .
Assuming the length of the seconds ' pendulum M+N cos 2 lat +P cos 4 lat. the errors are 3902074 +M+N x,99989 +Px 99959 -39,01214 +M+N x,99610 +P x,98445 39,0410 +M+Nx )96 1 94 +P x,8 5 o63 -39,01997 +M+Nx 95640 +P x,89,38 390 10884 +M+Nx 93171 +P x,7361i 39,02425 +M+N x,89895 +P x,61626 _ 9,03510 +M+Nx 81034 +P x,3133o 39,10168 +M+Nx 14910 P x,95552 -39,13929 +MNx 22559 Px 89821 39917456 +MNx 599992 Px 28024 -39,1951^9 + M-N x,78082 +P x,21936 _ 39,2033k4 +MNx 8578 +P x,47184 -39,21469 + M-N x 93767 +P x,7584-9 To determine -M ) N , and P , by the method of least squares , we must form three equations , by making equal to nothing the sum of these errors-first ; when each is multiplied by the coefficient of M in t at line , then when each is multiplied by the coefficient of N , and finally when each is multiplied by the coefficient of P. Thus we find o0 -508,18390 +Mx 13+ Nx 3,30259 +Px 4,64544 O " 1 28,29476 +M x,30e59 +Nx 8,82265 +Px 4 , o2629 o-181,31213+M x+,64444+Nx 4,026294+Px7,04391 By the solution of these equations M 39,1t647 : N 1 , i46 P _,00to06 and the length of the seconds ' pendulum in inches -39,11647 -10146 x cos 2 lat + , ooio06 x Cos 4 lat =39,01606 +,20292 X sin2 lat _,00844 x sinr2 lat. cost lat. = 39,01606 1 +,005201 x sin1lat -,000216 x sin2 lat. cos 2 lat } and gravity is proportional to this .
Comparing the coefficients of sin " lat and sin ' lat. cos ' lat with those in the expression of Art .
19 , we have the following equations 2 -e + es _7me+ 27 A , oo52o1 14 7 5X men e2 + 3A 0,000216 From the length of the equatorial pendulum , supposing the equatorial radius of the earth = 3486908 fathoms , we find m = , oo3464 .
And in the terms of the second order instead of e we may put ' , which is certainly not far from the truth .
Making these substitutions , the equations become , oo8657-e +7A = , oo52ol7 ; 000024 +8A = , o00026 From these , e= , oo3474 = -2 8 ; and A=oooo64 .
The sign of A shows that the earth is less protuberant at the latitude of 450 than an ellipsoid of the same polar and equatorial radii .
For the elevation of the spheroid above the ellipsoid a. a 2 .
1 where p= sine of latitude ; making the latitude = 450 , Dn= V , ' and the elevation of the spheroid is A A4 : as A here is positive , this elevation is negative , or the spheroid at that latitude is depressed below the ellipsoid .
This I should be inclined to expect : for though I have not been able to solve the differential equation in A , even in the cases in which the differential equation for e can be solved to the first order , yet by the examination of a simple hypothesis ( that of a homogeneous fluid whose density is very small surrounding a central nucleus ) , it may easily be seen that in this case the spheroid is not so far protuberant in middle latitudes as the ellipsoid .
If the attraction of the fluid be neglected , and the central mass be called m , the force on any point in the direction of xmx that in the ++ direction ofy_ my +)r2 ' that inz-mz +y++ ( + Y2 + Zq)2 ( * % f+i+ +)C ft+ z. Hence U-2 + ms , C ; or 'if y,2 + z~v2 , --X .
+ -VY C ; whence xi ' mV2m4 At m 21 6 w4 m IE CSV 29CsT2 } ( 1 )V2+~ VC 4V nearly , CTs IV 7 .
IV supposing &lt; :-Tsmall ; and this may be put under the form ( a2 v2 ) ( np V2 ) , from which the proposition is evident I conclude therefore that the results of Captain SABINE'S observations , as far as they go , are in strict agreement with theory .
I now come to the comparison of the expression for the length of a meridian arc with those arcs which have been most accurately measured .
The influence of local circumstances on these measures , it is well known , is greater than that on pendulum experiments ; and the discordances in different measures are such that , in order to get a result of any exactness , we must confine ourselves to the longest arcs which have been measured with the greatest care .
I have selected the following 1 .
BoUGUER s arc in Peru : 2 .
LAMBTON'$ whole arc in India : s. The French arc from Formentera to Dunkirk : 4 .
The English arc from Dunnose to Clifton : 5 , The Swedish arc from Mallorn to Pahtavara .
The Peruvian arc I have taken as recalculated by DELAMBRE in the Base du Systeme Metrique , Tome iii .
p. 112 , &amp;c. I have supposed the toise of Peru equal to 1,065766 fathoms .
The Indian arc is taken as finally corrected by Colonel LAMBTON in the Philosophical Transactions for 1823 .
In the estimation of the length of a part of the French are , which Colonel LAMBTON has given in the Philosop1hical Transactions for 1818 , and which Captain KATER has sanctioned by copying without any remark there appears to be a serious error , arising from an unnecessary reduction for temperature .
As I am sensible that I am now opposed to two Gentlemen whose assertion on such a point is almost decisive , I will state distinctly the reasons which have led me to this conclusion .
In the measure of the base at Melun ( Base du Systeme Metrique , Tome ii .
p. 44 ) , the length of the.base was re .
duced to the length which it would have had if the measuring rods had been used at the temperature of 13 ?
of REAUMUR , or 16 ?
4 centigrade .
The number of rods employed was four ; but the rod or module No. 1 was compared with each of the others , and the base was expressed by the length of the module No. 1 at the temperature of 16 centigrade .
From the logarithm set down in p. 698 , it appears that this was the length used in the calculation of the triangles The module No. i was found at this temperature to be less than two toises ( the toise being the length of an iron standard , called the toise of Peru , at the temperature of 130 of REAUMUR ) ; but from an error in the zero point of the metallic thermometers there were some errors in the reduction of the base , which exactly corrected the difference ( Tome iii .
p. 136 ) .
The semi-module , therefore , in the expression for the arc of the meridian , is exactly equal to the tolse of Peru at the temperature of 16 centigrade .
The standard metre at the temperature of 00 centigrade 443,296 lines of the toise of Peru at 160k centigrade ( p. 139 ) .
The standard metre at the temperature of oo centigrade was found by Captain KATER ( Philosophical Transactions 1818 ) to be 3g,37079 inches of the English standard at the temperature of 620 Fahrenheit .
Consequently the semi-module in the expression for the arc of the meridian is = , o65766 fathoms measured by the English standard at the temperature of 620 FAHRENHEIT ; and since the English and Indian measures are estimated by this standard at the same temperature , no reduction is to be made for temperature .
( The degree between Paris and Evaux is found thus to be 60822,5 fathoms ; Col. LAMBTON has stated it to be 60779 fathoms ) .
The length of the French arc given below , in fathoms , is therefore found by merely multiplying the number of semi-modules by 1,065766 .
The English arc has the corrections which Captain KATER has given in the Phil. Trans. for 1821 .
The Swedish arc is taken from SVANBERG 's Exposition des Operations , &amp;c. supposing their standard compared with the French standard at the temperature of oa centigrade .
Thus the following table is formed .
Place .
L L| Length in Fathoms .
0 , 1J0 , , Peru. .
-0 2 3l,29 34 31,9 188,51o India * .
89 38,39 18 3 29,6 598630 France .
3 38 39 56,11 51 2 9,25 751567 England .
50 37 5,27 53 27 29,89 172751 Sweden .
65 31 30,27 67 8 49,55 98870 In the application of the method of least squares , it must be observed , that the accuracy of the terrestrial measures can scarcely be questioned , and that the chance of errors in the determination of the extreme latitudes , arising either from faults of observation or from local attractions , is principally to be considered .
This however amounts to the same as supposing an error in the length of the meridian arc .
Assuming the form , Mx number of seconds in L'- .
L+N ( sin 2 11 -sin 2 L ) +P ( sinl 4 Lsin 4 L ) , the errors in the lengths are -i885io +Mx 1i22 m3j +Nx,0o86 +P x,216 -59863o + Mx 35625,2 +N x,3084 + Px,412 -751567 +Mx 44533,1 +N x , oo23 -Px,837 1792751 +Mx 10224,6-N x 0241 -P X,175 98870 +Mx 5839,3-N x,0383-P x,009 and the equations formed in the same manner as before are o-=5929552,32 +Mx 3516949,8 +N X 11,8382-P x 22,016 0-_ 198869 +Mx 11 838,2 +N x , logo +P x , 5s = 7285 -M x 2201,6 +N x , o'53 +P x , o93 from which M-16,88 t64 ; N =-9358 ; P-=267 ; and the length of an arc of the meridian in fathoms 16,88164 mo.ofsecondsinLU .
L-9358 x ( sin 2 L'-singL ) + 267 x ( sin 4 L'-sin 4L ) .
The lengths of the several arcs found from this expression differ from those above by - , ; + 4 , '9 , + s , and + 63 fathoms respectively .
The largest of these errors falls ( as will generally be the case when the method of least squares is used ) on that length in which the coefficients of M , N , and P. are smallest ; but in a mountainous country , I conceive that an error of less than 4 " in the difference of latitudes is by no means inadmissible .
And I am the more inclined to allow this error , because , upon applying the formula to the arc measured in Sweden by the French Academicians , the error , which is much greater than this , has a different sign .
I may here perhaps without impropriety , make some remarks on the credit which appears to be due to the French measure in Sweden .
That measure has often been mentioned with contempt ; but more particularly since the late measure by SVANBERG .
I have not however been able to discover any reason for this contempt , except-3the disagreement of its results from those of other operations .
The last part of the process , it is well known , was the measure of the base ; and the Academicians themselves were so much astonished at the result , that they immediately proceeded to verify every part of the measure , particularly the latitudes .
And the general accuracy of the measure has been confirmed by the late measure .
The triangles were admirably chosen ; the length of the arc agrees within a few fathoms with that found by SVANBERG ; the latitude of the southern extremity at Tornea is precisely the same as that calculated by SVANBERG from the observations at Mallorn ; the latitude of Kittis their northern station , unfortunately was not examined .
The presumption , I think is , that though a part of the discrepancy may be attributed to errors of observation , yet a great part of it must be due to the irregularities of local attraction in so rugged a country ( though SVANBERG appears to think this impossible ) , and that the new measure probably is not free from errors of the same kind .
The measure at the Cape of Good Hope , conducted by the ablest astronomer of the age , has generally been thought inadmissible for the same reason .
Since LS .
L= sin id/ x number of seconds in !
L , we have for the length of a meridian arc Sill it/ 4 fL ' L(sin IV i. 93568 X Sfli x(sin2 Lsin2L ) +6 X88X6 ( iJ_ L ) } 16,8816+ i 6,8816+km.m~4JJ Comparing this with the formula in ( 2o ) , 3e 3 4 .
8 ___ and__ 15 An __ =6 I From these equa16,8 8 i64 ad64 .
32 6,88164 tions e = , oo03589 2 6 ; A,000157 .
The difference between the polar and equatorial axes is even greater than that assigned by Captain SABINE .
But the most striking difference in the deductions is that the value of A , now found , has a ne~gative sign ; which would seem to indicate that the earth is protuberant at the latitude 450 above the ellipsoid , which has the same axes .
And it does not appear that by any alteration of the values of A and e it is possible to reconcile the different observations .
If we suppose the Indian and French arcs to be quite accurate , we shall find e,0o3269 Ax 2,3g9 : this evidently cannot be reconciled with the values of e and A deduced from the pendulum experiments .
On the whole I conceive , that we cannot assert that , on the figure of the earth , theory and observation are in perfect agreement .
If the arcs which have been measured were no longer than that in Sweden , or even than that in England , I should not hesitate in attributing to errors of observation and local attraction a considerable part of the discrepancy .
And had the theory been confined to terms of the first order , I should have thought it probable that terms of importance might be omitted in the second and higher orders .
But it appears that with the improved theory , applied to the comeparison of the Indian and French arcs , the shorter of which has an amplitude of nearly ten degrees , it is impossible to establish any agreement with the pendulum observations of Captain SABINE and I know no other series which for extent and other advantages can be compared with those .
The measures of arcs of the meridian which have hitherto been made are , I imagine , insufficient for the determination of the figure of the earth .
The arcs in India and France are the only ones in which the possible errors in latitude would not bear a sensible proportion to the effects of ellipticity .
Captain SABINE has proposed to measure an arc in Spitzbergen .
The shortness , of the arc , and the mountainous character of the country , would make it almost useless .
The desideratum at present is an extensive arc in a high latitude .
We have two good arcs near the equator ; of which the Indian , at least , is as long as can be , desired .
We have a still longer arc almost exactly bisected by the .
parallel of 450* With an .
arc of equal length in the neighbourhood of the pole , wte might determine the three terms in the expression for an arc of the meridian to great accuracy .
This perhaps it will be impossible ever to execute .
There are some measures in which such extraordinary disturbances appear to have existed , that it seems desirable to examine and extend them : of these , the most remarkable is that made by LACAILLE at the Cape of Good Hope .
And perhaps in speaking of the probable effects of local attraction , I may be permitted to allude to one of a different kind in England .
This is the correction which it has been found necessary to apply to the longitudes of places in England , as deduced from the observations made at Beachy Head and Dunnose .
For this investigation I prefer the method of DALBY , explained in the Philosophical Transactions for 1790 and 1 795 to any other ; as being unobjectionable on the ground of accuracy , and as applying to any surface in which the intersections of the normals at the two stations with the earth 's axis , or with a line parallel to the earth 's axis , are not very distant .
The difference of longitude is then made to depend on this case of spherical trigonometry : given two sides ( a , b ) and the sum of the opposite angles ( A + B ) , to a-b cos. CzA +13 find the third angle ( c ) .
The formula is , tan .
Cd In this instance a colatitude of Dunnose = 22 ' 52",69 ; b= colatitude of Beachy Head 390 15 ' 36",29 ; A+B= sum of observed azimuths = 178 592 ' I5 " ; hence C= 10 26 ' 41',87 .
And if the errors in the observed quantities a , b , A , B , were A a , a ' b , A A , A B , the error in C would be a -b -Z CA +B COS.a COS. S COS. X+B.COS.t _ + ' AB ( M A + ; -B3 + 2 , ,+^2(sin.b .
a2 2(A'A+a'B++b cos. , _S .
sin. 2(i2 2.-2 a+ sin. a. A'b).-1-293 ( FAA +B ) + , oio3 .
a+ , o104 .
b. Now the chronometer observations for the difference of longitude of Dover and Falmouth , according to Dr. TIARKS , ( Phil. Trans. 1824 ) give by proportion the difference of Ion ' gitude of Dulnnose and Beachy Head 10 27 ' 4",75 .
The discrepance then is nearly 17 " ; which ( since a small error in a or b produces an almost insensible effect on C ) implies an error of 13 " in the sum of the azimuths .
This I should think is absolutely impossible .
We must suppose then either that , in consequence of some local attraction , the apparent difference of longitudes was altered , or that some error has crept into the observations of Dr. TIARKS .
The method of obtaining apparent time by corresponding altitudes , which was employed by Dr. TIARKS , is not the most accurate , nor perhaps the most proper , when the whole time in dispute is only five seconds .
As Dr. TIARKS has not given the details of the observations , it is impossible to form any correct estimation of their accuracy .
If however any local attraction have drawn aside the plummet at the eastern station towards the cast , and that at the western station towards the west , the longitude would thus be made to appear smaller than it really is .
The error produced in the longitude of either deviation place would be e and thus an error in longitude of 17 " would be accounted for by supposing the plummet at Beachy Head drawn 5",4 , to the east , and that at Dunnose 5",4 to the west .
Each of these is a larger deviation -than we have reason to believe has taken place at any station in England ; and it appears therefore desirable that the observations should be re-examined .
This operation would not be difficult : the easiest method perhaps would be by rocket signals ; and it is obvious , that the local causes which affected the difference of longitude found by observations of azimuth , would produce exactly the same effect by disturbing the levels of the transit or other instruments used to obtain the time .
The immediate effect of such observations then , whould be merely to confirm or to refute the conclusions deduced from the observations of 'azimuth : if the observations of Pir .
TIARKS should be considered free from objection , they would serve to establish , or to destroy the belief , that local attraction may produce sensible disturbances in longitude .
G. B. AIRY .
Since the above was written , I have been favoured by Captain SABINE with a more detailed statement than I had before seen of the extent and probable circumstances of an arc in Spitzbergen .
It appears that an arc might be measured extending nearly from latitude 760 25 ' to 800,5 ' : the extremities of which would be on islands at a small distance from the main land of Spitzbergen .
With the same formula as before , the error to be used in the method of least squares would be -measured length + Mx x iooo.-N x,338 +P x,2o .
Upon comparing this expression with those given before , it will be observed , that this is the only error in which the coefficient of N has a large negative value ; and that from the preponderance at present of negative signs in the coefficients of P , an error with a positive coefficient of P would be very desirable .
On these accounts then , an arc of that extent in that latitude would contribute much to our knowledge of the figure of the earth .
But it is very likely that there would be sensible disturbances in the latitudes of the extreme stations .
We cannot imagine a situation in which there is a greater probability that the difference of latitudes would be made too large , than when the latitudes are observed at two stations at the level of the sea , with high land between them .
But this would depend much on the nature of the rocks .
In Peru , for instance , though far more mountainous , it is probable that the disturbance was not great .
If then , as Captain SABINEproposes , any preliminary survey be made , it would perhaps be proper to examine not only the circumstances which would affect the practical facility of the operation , but also those which might have an influence on the determination of the latitudes and should these be found not very unfavourable , a meridian arc of four degrees measured with great care would be highly valuable .
ADDITIONS .
THE equations of Art .
15 , it will easily be seen , are equally true , whether the interior of the mass be supposed to be fluid , or to consist of solid shells of different density , in which the radius of each separating surface is expressed by the formula aI e. e. p3A } And the expression for gravity in Art .
19 , and all its consequences , hold equally on either supposition .
A theorem similar to CLAIRAUT'S may be shown to be true , to whatever order the investigations be extended .
For upon using the value of R found in the investigation above , and upon carrying all the operations one step farther , it would be found that the equation of equilibrium could not figure of the earth .
be satisfied , in consequence of the introduction of terms multiplyimig A1 , Which would not destroy each other .
It would be necessary then to assume for Ra Value Of the form ( ~~~~~~es __ S a4al+ e.1-r l ( j 4 .
A ) .
2-/ 3 4 .
B ~I ) .
Vt2~ 6 { r+t~sfrj : .
~~~~~~~~~ t.1 by which there would be introduced two new functions of a , e , &amp;c. in the general expression for V , and in that for the force at any point ; and one new function of a , e , &amp;c. in the expression for the force at the surface .
But as a power of Id is introduced , which did not appear before , there would be found , by the process of Art .
14 , one equation which was not found in the preceding approximation .
By this equation the new function could be eliminated , and therefore the force at any point could be expressed in the same manner as in the preceding approximation , namely , by means of one function of ( a ) multiplying a quantity depending solely on the form of the external surface , and the latitude of the point on that surface .
The same may be proved for every such ceeding approximation ; and thus we arrive at the following theorem : " 1 If a heterogeneous fluid , the particles of which attract each other with accelerating forces inversely proportional to the squares of their distances , revolve round an axis ; and if the proportion of the centrifugal force at the equator to the whole force there be given ; the force at any point of the surface can be exactly expressed from a know- .
ledge of the form of the surface and the position of that point , without any knowledge of the law of the internal density .
" This is likewise true if the interior be solid .
G. B.eAs

