XXX .
On electrical and magnetic rotations .
By CHARLES BABBAGE , Espy F.R. S. &amp;c. T &amp;c. Communicated May 2g,1826 .
Read June 15 , 1826 .
THE known fact , that artificial magnets receive additional increments to their power by slowly adding weight to the load they support , combined with the circumstance , that pieces of iron or steel exposed to the influence of a magnet , neither acquire nor lose their magnetism instantaneously , led me to explain Mr. BARLOW'S experiments " On the temporary magnetic effect induced in iron bodies by rotation , " * without having recourse to any new property of matter , and to apply the same consideration of the time of acquiring and losing magnetic virtue to the curious experiments of M. ARAGO .
These views are stated in a paper printed in the Phil. Trans. for 1825 , which contains the observations that occurred to Mr. HERSCHEL and myself , in repeating and varying those experiments .
As the explanation there given is intimately connected with the experiments detailed in the present paper , and as they were undertaken with a view of giving additional evidence to the principle to which I have alluded , I shall here briefly re-state the manner in which time influences the results of certain magnetic phenomena , whose production depends on the application of motion to some part of the apparatus employed .
If N represent the north pole of a magnet , Plate XIX , fig. 4 , placed above an indefinite plate AB , of iron or any substance susceptible of magnetism , then the point S immediately under N will become a south pole from induced magnetism : but the two poles will attract each other , and if they are prevented from moving directly towards each other , motion cannot arise in any other direction .
The point S immediately under N will possess the strongest south polar rity , but other adjacent points will also acquire the same property in a smaller degree : if an ordinate SK be erected at S , and if at every other point in the line AB other ordinates be raised , each proportional to the intensity of the induced magnetism at that point , a curve EKF will be formed , which will represent the magnetic force of the plate , and at equal distances CS , SD , on each side of the point S the ordinates EC and FD will be equal .
If the plate is now supposed to be moved in the direction A B , and if the time in which it acquires or gives up any portion of magnetism be not instantaneous , then the ordinates which represent the magnetic intensities at equal distances from the middle point S will not be equal : for the point D has , in consequence of the motion of the plate , just passed through a point S , considerably nearer to the source of magnetism , at which point its magnetic intensity was expressed by SK .
As it is supposed not to part immediately with its acquired magnetism , some portion will remain when it reaches the point D : therefore the ordinate DG , at this point , will be greater than it is when the plate is at rest ; consequently the curve EKG , expressing the magnetic force when the plate is in motion , will , on the side towards which the motion is directed , be exterior to that which denotes the same force when the plate is at rest .
But in the case of the plate being in motion , the force which is measured by the area of the curve is greater on one side than on the other ; there will therefore be a small tendency in the plate to draw the point N towards that side to which it is moving .
The points which have not passed vertically under the pole N , will in reality be a little less magnetised than they would be if they were at rest , because when they reach any particular place , they may not be exposed to the magnetic influence for a time sufficient for them to acquire the full degree of magnetism which they would obtain , if they remained longer in that place .
-If the moving plate be circular , and if the magnet be suspended in a balance of torsion , this extremely small tendency of each part to drag the pole N in the direction of its motion being repeatedly applied by each succeeding particle , and during many revolutions , may at last produce motion in the magnets above , even though the attractive force of the revolving substance be so exceedingly feeble as to be insensible to other methods .
In this analysis of the action of a magnet on a moving body susceptible of magnetism , it is to be observed , that no part of the effect is attributed to the velocity with which the agent* immediately producing the attraction traverses from the former to the latter ; the nature of the action is not ' It is difficult to write on any physical subject without employing words which are more or less connected with the various hypotheses prevailing at the time .
In the present Paper I have no intention of giving any opinion on the theories at present received , but merely propose stating facts that I have noticed , and the reasoriings to which they appear to me to lead .
therefore analogous to that which produces the aberration of light .
The essential circumstance in producing the rotation of the suspended magnet is , that the substance revolving below it shall acquire and lose its magnetism in a finite time , and not instantly .
It appeared , therefore , that if any other attractive or repulsive property exists in matter which is capable of communication to other matter situated near it ; and if such communication require time for its performance ; and if , when it is communicated , the force is not instantly annihilated on removing the cause , then such a property of matter may be substituted in the preceding reasoning instead of magnetism , the same deductions may be made , and similar consequences may be expected to result .
On reviewing the known properties of matter , electricity seemed to be the only one which satisfied the requisite conditions : imperfect conductors placed in the neighbourhood of excited bodies do not immediately attain a state of electric equilibrium ; and when they have arrived at that state which is due to such a position , on the removal of the excited body they do not instantly return to their former state .
I therefore made the following experiments .
Experiment 1 .
A needle was made of thin sheet brass , of the form , fig. 5 , having two circular ends i.25 inches in diameter , and the distance of their centres 3.i inch ; it had its edges coated with sealing-wax .
Another similar needle was made , about one-third larger .
One of these needles was suspended from a filament of silk , of several feet in length , at the distance of.26 inch above a circular glass plate six inches in diameter , which was fixed by sealing-wax on a disc of box wood 2.5 inches in diameter : this latter was screwed upon a wooden axis .
No electricity was communicated either to the needle or the glass disc , except that which resulted from cementing the latter by sealing-wax to the box wood on which it was fastened , and perhaps the coating of wax on the edges of the needle might have given it a very slight charge .
The glass disc was now made to revolve at about s8 revolutions in a minute : there was a small motion of the needle in the same direction .
Experiment 2 .
The same apparatus being employed , a large stick of common sealing-wax was excited and applied two or three times to the needle , in order to charge it .
As soon as it was quite at rest , the glass disc was made to revolve more slowly than before , when the needle began to deviate in the direction of rotation , and followed the glass .
Some doubt being expressed by a friend who was present as to the influence of the air set in motion by the apparatus , the electric charge of the needle was increased , and the velocity of rotation was diminished : the needle deviated as before , but much more rapidly .
To remove some doubt as to the influence of any twist in the silk ; whilst the needle was revolving in one direction , the rotation of the glass disc was reversed ; after a short time the motion of the needle was destroyed , and it returned in the contrary direction .
For the purpose of ascertaining still more satisfactorily the effect which might be ascribed to the influence of air , the following experiment was made .
Experiment A. The apparatus was left many hours , in order that the electricity of its parts might , as far as possible , be dissipated .
On returning to it , the glass disc was made to revolve -with very great rapidity : not the slightest sensible effiect was produced on the needle .
Experiment 4 .
The needle was now electrified , and the same velocity being given to the glass plate , and all the other circumstances being the same , the needle followed slowly .
On trying various degrees of velocity , it was observed , that the effect on the needle was greatest when the motion of the glass plate was slow .
A velocity of about five turns in a minute produced a considerable effect .
Experiment 5 .
A stick of excited sealing-wax was substituted for the brass needle , and placed at the distance of about half an inch above the glass disc .
On giving a slow motion to the glass plate , the wax needle followed in the same direction , and continued to move through many revolutions , notwithstanding the torsion of the silk ; but on giving the glass a very rapid rotation , the sealing-wax needle remained nearly immovable .
Experiment 6 .
A new apparatus was constructed , which is represented in fig. i. It consisted of a circular piece of wood A B , 9 inches diameter , having a hole of 1.5 inches in the centre , supported by three legs , two of which only , C and D , are represented in the figure ; these , by screwng into it , .
served to adjust its height .
A cylinder of thick millboard F G , 5 inches high , was glued together , and was fastened to the board A B. In two very small recesses in its upper part rested a narrow bridge of glass or of wood b b , for the purpose of supporting a needle .
A circular ring of pasteboard c c , was fixed near the top , which supported an engraved circle divided into degrees .
A square piece of millboard P P , having a circular opening rather less than the diameter of the cylinder , rested on the top of it .
Upon this was placed another millboard cylinder Q Q , of rather larger diameter , and 2inches high .
Another cylinder was fitted to the outside of this , in order to admit of fixing screens of muslin and various substances to the under side of the upper cylinder .
Through the aperture in the centre of the wooden plate A B. a steel axis working in a brass frame passed up into the cylinder .
The frame was supported by being screwed to a block of wood at S. On the lower end of this axis a pulley H , was fixed , to which motion was given by connecting it with a common jack .
On the upper end of this axis a thin brass chuck K2 inches in diameter , was fixed , to which was attached a wooden disc Z , 5 inches in diameter .
Three wooden screws aa a , rose from this plate , and supported a disc M , of any substance on which experiments were to be made .
A needle made of pasteboard covered with sealing-wax , and having an agate cap in its centre , was supported on the point of a steel sewing needle fixed in a wooden bridge oat inch square .
A plate of glass revolved below .
The following were the times in which different revolutions were performed .
When ' the glass disc made 261 When the glass disc made x9j turns per minute .
turns per minute .
Number of Time .
Difference .
Number of Time .
Dirence Revolutions .
Revolutions .
o 21 00 34 0.25 21 49 4.25 34 5252.5 221 is.50 35 20.25_ .
23 91 75 3537 ' 7.75 22 30 _____ _____ I 224 4 3552 2 23 27 2 3650o 3 24 233 / S 4 24 37 ci ma 38 ig 40 5 2510 ~~3339 5 ; Z5 10 32 5 3858 6 25 42 3:2 63737 26 12 32 7 4015S 40 8 z6 ~~~~29 8 4.5 40 8 26 44 ~~38 40S 9 27 j6 30 9 41 35 43 10 2745 ~~30 10 428 41 In the latter of these experiments , , at the seventh revolution , the passing of a carriage may have slihl feteth remaining revolutions .
Experiment 7 .
A thin disc of copper , such as is used for engraving upon ; .
about seven inches in diameter , was connected by vax with the glass plate employed in experiment 1 , and the same apparatus was used with a needle of sealing-wax suspended above : on making the copper plate revolve rather quickly , the needle followed it , and went through two revolutions .
Several plates of lead , pewter , brass and copper were tried , and the results were similar .
For the purpose of procuring more powerful and durable charges of electricity , I placed a small excited electrophorus on the three screws a , a , a , fig. 1 , the copper plate was placed upon it .
A very thin slip of glass -b , b , formed a bridge , on the centre of which various needles were supported .
The effects which resulted were not constantly the same , and the uneqial distribution of electricity on the electrophorus , combined with the action of the glass bridge , seemed to present very complicated results .
I shall only detail one of theseexperiments .
Experinent 8 .
The apparatus just referred to being employed , And the electrophorus without a copper plate being used , a needle of thin bracSs , similar in shape to that of experiment i , with an agate cap , was supported by a fine needle point fixed by cement to the centre of the glass bridge .
The brass needle rested nearly at right angles to the glass bridge ( strictly at 980 from it ) .
On giving a slow motion to the electrophorus , the brass needle immediately advanced in the same direction about 10 , then stopped , then returned back to its original position , and , after a few vibrations , settled at a point 20 in advance of its original position .
On increasing the speed of the electrophorus , the needle again advanced , and settled at between ST and 4 ?
in advance of its first position .
The velocity was again considerably increased , when the brass needle began to oscillate in a vertical direction , and the stationary point advanced to 90 or io0 , where it remained steadily , except that the vertical motion continued The velocity was again increased , when the stationary point moved on to 120 from its position at the beginning of the experiment .
On stopping the motion , the needle advanced i i , , and then rested .
These experiments appear to me to admit of explanation , on precisely the same principles which I had previously applied to those relating to magnetism .
It seems that electricity excited by induction is not instantly destroyed by removing the inducing body ; nor is it instantly excited , to the full extent which the circumstances admit , on presentig an excited to an unexcited body .
Admitting this principle , the whole of the reasoning which was given at the commencement of this paper , relative to rotations from magnetic causes , applies equally to those which arise from electricity .
The velocity with which electricity travels , has been urged as an objection to this explanation of the phenomena ; and the immense rapidity with which the metals conduct that fluid , renders it difficult to admit that the motions employed in these experiments are at all comparable with that of electricity .
There are two circumstances that may be stated as some explanation of this difficulty : the first is , that although the forces thus set in action are exceedingly weak , yet , from the nature of the apparatus , they act constantly for a considerable time , and in the same direction ; thus gaining , by the duration of their total action , a power far superior to the almost infinitely small one which arises from the transient action of each part : the second is , that although the velocity with which electricity of considerable intensity moves through good conductors is excessively great , I am not aware of any exiperiments which prove that the small inequalities which are produced in a very weakly electrified body by induction , from some neighbouring body , are removed with the same velocity .
The analogy of a fluid similarly circumstanced , would lead us to infer , that when the deviations above the level are minute , the return to it will be more slow .
Of Screens .
Although the preceding experiments , when repeated under various circumstances , had convinced me that the rotations which had been observed were not attributable to currents of air set in motion by the apparatus employed I was desirous of examining what effect would result from the interposition of a screen .
I therefore suspended the needles I employed by a silver wire , 5 inch in diameter , and about two feet in length , which was contained in a glass tube , supported over the middle of the apparatus represented in fig. 1 .
-This tube andwire passed through a circular hole in the centre of the glass plate R. The bridge b b , was removed , and a screen of fine muslin was stretched across the bottom of the lower cylinder Q , by means of the external one c c. This screen and the needles were occasionally changed .
Experiment 9 .
A brass needle , having a very fine thread of spun glass cemented to one end by a little wax , was suspended by the silver , about I inch above a screen of coarse gauze ( not silk ) .
A pewter disc , of 4 inches in diameter , was placed on the , revolving stand , A inch below the gauze screen .
Neither the needle nor the disc were electrified ; and they were completely protected from any currents of air moving about itithe room in which these experiments were made .
The three first oscillations of the needle were : ISt .
12 7.8 2nd .
126 3rd .
127.8 The disc was then set in motion , and kept revolving at about 78 turns in a minute .
After six minutes no result was apparent in the needle different from those which had been observed before the motion commenced .
This seems to show that the faction of air , if it is driven through the screen , is insensile .
Experiment io .
Having placed a screen of coarse gauze above the pewter plate at I inch distant an excited needle of sealing-wax was substituted fork that of brass .
I observed the extent of the oscillations , and then setting the plate of pewter in motion , I was surprised to find that the returning arc ( contrary to the direction of the plate 's motion ) was almost invariably increased , generally at the first , and almost constantly at the second oscillation , and that the arc in the same direction was diminished .
So unexpected a result naturally induced me at first to attribute it to some error in the observations ; but on repeating it many times , and having measured the greatest error which the means I employed were susceptible of when used even a little carelessly , I found that half a degree was the greatest error I could make in reading of the oscillations , and that this retrograde motion was in many cases equal to three , four , or five degrees ; so that the measure of the observed fact was from four to eight times the extent of the greatest possible error of observation , even admitting it to take place at both extremities .
It is true , I did not always observe this retrograde motion ; but in twenty experiments the needle , screen and plate , not being always at the same relative distances , I noticed it seventeen times .
The next step seemed to be to find some mode of increasing the unequal distribution of electricity on the metallic plate , supposing that to be the cause of the phenomena .
I therefore made a very small lamp , which being lighted , was placed on the stage L of the revolving apparatus , immediately under the copper .
It was afterwards found convenient to make a small aperture in the lower millboard cylinder , just opposite the platform supporting the lamp , for the purpose of lighting it when requisite : this opening was closed by a piece of mica , fastened on a card .
Experiment ix .
A small stick of sealing-wax being suspended from the silver wire above a leno muslin screen , the pewter plate was supported just above the lamp , and under thescreen , the following observations were made : Oscillations of the Diff. Di .
an point .
needle .
0002I L_ ... ... S_ The lamp was now lighted .
R i2.5 19.5 4.75 20.25 L ... .
3'6 .
2 .
L 31 j4 R ... .
14 ~20 10 74 R ... .
14.25 19 9.5 23.7 L,..33.z R ... .
i6 L ... .28 ~12 6 22 L 28~ 42 R ... .z2o L ... .
29~ 94.5 24.5 The wax now became more heated , and gradually bent until the glass index touched the graduations .
The number of revolutions of the pewter plate and lamp were 56 per minute .
Experiment 12 .
The same apparatus being used , a brass needle was substituted for that of sealing-wax ; it was suspended L inch above the leno muslin screen , which was 8 inch above the pewter plate ; these distances were the same in Experiment i. The plate and lamp made -j6 revolutions per minute .
The observations were made as in the last experiment .
The apparatus being at rest , the mean point was 20 .
Oscillations .
Diff. Diffj Mean point .
Lighted lamp , and set it and plate revolving .
R -.5 L+ I0.5 II 5-5 5L +12o~ R -8156.L + 10.5 i8.5 9 25 1.25 R 5.8 9.8 4.9 -0.9 L +36 9.5 4.75 + I-75 L+ 6.5 R 9 .
L+ 1z 25.5 12.75 0R+1 32 .
i6.o .
+ 1.0 R 26 13.0 1.0L+ iz R-i L+ 20 10 -1.0 The lamp burned with a very dull flame , -X3 inch long , the .
top of the flame about 58 inch below the pewter disc ; it was 8 lighted by a small stick , which burnt with a flame , and gave more heat than the lamp during the short time it was under the plate .
This experiment lasted about twenty minutes .
Experiment 12 .
The same brass needle being used in the same apparatus ; the distances remaining as before , the lamp was trimmed , so as to give a much brighter flame .
Oscillations of Diff. fi Diff. Mean point .
needle .
R2+I L ... . .
o0 02 The lamp was now lighted , and set in motion .
R+ S~ 7-5 3175 -1.25 L *R + 6.X 7.5 3.75 + 2.75 R+ 6.5 R+ 6 .
s 0.0 5.0 + I.5 L 5.o I2.0 6.o +I7 540 Soon after the commencement of the experiment a mist arose within the case , which continued about five or six minutes : this frequently happened in the other experiments .
The duration of the observations was about twenty-five minutes in the two preceding experiments .
On examining the column of the mean point of the needle , I am not inclined to draw any inference respecting it : whatever action may have been exerted on it , does not appear to have produced a marked or decisive effect on that point .
I was induced to insert them , from the circumstance of the remarkable and gradual increase of the arc of vibration in both instances .
This will be observed on looking down the columns of half differences , which is , in fact , the amplitude of each oscillation about the mean point .
The observed retrograde movement in the eleventh experiment being so small , and yet exceeding many times the greatest possible error of observation , I was now desirous of enquiring whether , amongst the accidental circumstances to which the needlerwas exposed , there -might not be found some one to whose influence this apparent anomaly might be ascribed .
The number of causes to which it might be attributed was considerable but I hoped by variations in the circumstances of the experiment gradually to eliminate them .
The following list comprised the greater part of them .
The reverse motion might arise from , 1 .
: Currents of air in the room ; 2 .
Fro m currents of air excited within the apparatus ; s. By air driven through the gauze screen ; 4 .
By heated air rising from the metal plate heated by the lamp ; , .
By the vibration excited in the apparatus by the motion of the jack ; 6 .
By the torsion of the silver wire to which the needles were attached 7 .
By the electricity of the bridge ; 8 .
By the bending of the wax needle .
The first of these causes , namely , the action of currents of air in the room in which these experiments were made , was obviated by the form of the apparatus in which the needle was afterwards enclosed , and care was taken to render all the parts of it as close as possible .
The second source of this retrograde motion might be supposed to arisefrom the movement impressed on the air within the lower cylinder of millboard being-communicated through the screen , not by actually passing through its apertures , but by the vibrations it might impress on it The fact of the direction of the motion in , the lo were cylinder being in the contrary direction to that of the needle in the upper one , was exceedingly unfavourable to this hypothesis .
Before I relate the various experiments-which I made , with the view of successively placing each of these causes out of action , I think it may be necessary to detail a few additional experiments in confirmation of the fact .
Experiment 13 .
Using the same apparatus , I substituteda disc .
of copper , 5 inches in diameter , and '-I inch thick instead of that of pewter ; the sealing-vax needle was suspended half an inch above the leno screen the lamp wasplaced-at one inch from the edge of the-copper plate , towards its centre : the flame was large and smoky .
Oscillations of Diff. Duff , Mean point .
needle .
000 L ... 347.8 4.2 2.1 345.7 R.O. .
343.6 L ... 347.0 3,5 1.75 345.25 R* .
343.5 The lamp was now lighted .
L 348 42 346 L 346 6.5 3.25 342.75 R 346 IL. .
33.2 |5.8 2.9 334.1 R 337 3 I 's 35 R 337 L ... 330 1:2.5 6.2z5 3 36.25S R ... 34-2,5 L ... 33025 I0 120 344.5 L ... 341.4 54.6 27 3 368.7 R. .
396 2 .
6 .
At one part of this experiment the needle became stationary , as if it had arrived at the end of its arc ; it then went on again in the same direction as before .
This stationary point should perhaps be considered as the extreme right of one vibration , and the extreme left of the next : I have noticed it more than once in these inquiries .
The column of the mean point of the needle has , in this experiment marked the same retrograde motion on the first application of heat , and the same motion in advance , when that heat has continued , as in former ones .
Experiment 14 .
The same apparatus ; the copper disc revolving at j inch flu below leno screen ; the lamp in the centre.t inch below the copper ; the sealing-wax needle ( inch above screen I shall , in this instance , only give the gradual progress of the mean position of the needle , as calculated from the observations .
Position of the mean point .
0 23 203.5 , Lighted the lamp .
200 190.1 189.9 199.9 205.3 213.33 212.0 211.5 217.3 216.5 221'.3 224.6 This experiment presents the same results as the preceding one ; and shows , that the observed fact is not influenced by the eccentric position of the source of heat , As the silver wire , from which the needles were sus-f pended , had been unwound from a small cylinder , I thought it probable that it might be a little twisted ; in which case it would , from the weight of the needle , untwist until counterbalanced by the elasticity of the wire .
If , in these circumstances , heat were applied , it might happen that the elasticity of the wire would be altered , and consequently , from that circumstance alone , that the needle might change its position .
If this where the case , on reversing the direction of rotation of the plate , the torsion , which was previously supposed favourable for the reversed motion of the needle , would now act against it ; I therefore made the following experiment .
Experiment is .
The motion of the copper plate was reversed , and reading in the new direction , the following were the mean positions of the wax needle .
0 15.6 16.o The lamp lighted .
15.0 Observation lost .
2.0 1.1 3.5 37.2 68.8 45,5 50.3 The greatest regression of the mean point of the needle was nearly i4 ?
, so that if torsion had any influence on the former experiments , it was unfavourable to the production of the retrograde motion .
Experimment 16 A screen of sheet zinc , about .
' inch thick , was placed under a needle of sealing-wax , at about X. inch below it , The lamp was placed on the platform below , having its wick at the distance of about an inch from the zinc .
The following observations were made .
Mean position of the needle .
0 249.0 249.25 Lamp lighted .
250.75 2956.25 258.75 256.2d5 254.75 260.25 258.75 26-2.25 260.5 261.25S 261 95 268,5 In this case , where a source of-heat was revolving under a metal plate , the needle suspended above did not retrograde , but moved on in the same direction as the heat : the small comparative recession , at the sixth and 'seventh observation , not being of sufficient magnitude to be noticed , and it never having returned as far back as the point from which it started .
From this experiment it appears , that , whatever may be the cause of these movements , it does not arise from any vortex produced by the moving part of the apparatus , nor is it owing to the passage of any air through the screens .
In order to prove that no tremors arising from the moving power , and communicated through the solid parts of the apparatus , had produced these effects , the following experiment was made .
Experiment 17 , The apparatus being in precisely the same state as in the last experiment , the lamp was not lighted , and the following observations were registered .
Oscillation of Diff. Ditf .
Mean position .
wax needle. .
- .
000 L ... 259 42 257 R ... 255 L ... 258.5 2.5 1.2 R ... 25.5 257.25 The apparatus was set in motion ; the lamp revolving , but not being lighted .
LX. .
258.8 R. .
2564 2.4 1.20 25754 L.258.8 241 1.05 257.65 R 25.4 L ... 258.8 2.6 o.85 258-5 R ... 257.5 Li ... 258.8 R.:256.8 1,4 0.7 257.5 L. .
258.2 This experiment clearly proves , both from the stationary position of the mean point , and from the decrease of the arc through which the needle oscillated , that no vibrations are communicated from the jack to the needle .
I now tried the effect of winding up the jack , and found that it did not increase the arc half a degree on each side , although it caused the needle and silver wire to oscillate slightly , as a pendulum .
Considering it possible , by means of an agate cap , to suspend the various needles employed in these experiments , with sufficient delicacy to allow them to obey the minute forces under investigation , I made the following experiment .
Experiment i-8 .
A card of the same form and size as the brass needle described in Experiment i , covered with sealing-wax , having an agate cap in its centre , was balanced on the point of a sewing needle , cemented to a glass bridge , which rested on the screen .
The wax card was about 1.5 inches above the leno screen ; under which , at the distance of.3 inch below , the copper plate was placed .
The lamp was placed below the copper , at the distance of.75 inch from its edge .
No motion was communicated to any part of the apparatus ; the waxed card needle rested at 1680 .
The lamp was lighted , and at the end of 75 " the needle had moved 80 ; it gradually advanced towards that part of the copper immediately above the lamp , and at the end of four minutes and a half became stationary at 870.5 , a point not precisely over the lamp , but a little on one side of it .
Experiment 19 .
The same apparatus and relative distances being used , no motion was employed ; a piece of red-hot iron , one inch long , by half an inch broad , was placed on the platform below the copper , instead of the lamp .
The red-hot iron was placed under 2100 , about one inch below the copper ; and the waxed card needle rested at 1430k The experiment began at 4h 2.3m 4 28 no effect .
4 32 The nearest end of the needle had moved over 470 , to a spot not quite above the edze of the hot iron , and about 100 from its centre .
In order to get rid of the electrical effect of the glass or wooden supports , which I have called bridges , and which sometimes supported the needles , I placed a cork on the centre of the screen , immediately above the centre of the copper disc ; into this was fixed the point of a sewing needle , on which the agate caps of the needles rested .
I conceived this arrangement necessary , because , when no screens were employed , and the distance ; between the needle and the revolving plate was considerable , it sometimes happened that the needle followed the copper in its motion until it came over the supporting bridge , where it sometimes rested , instead of continuing its revolutions as long as the copper plate was kept in motion .
Experiment 20 .
Using a wax card needle supported by a cork placed over the centre of the leno screen , and the lamp placed in the centre , under the copper plate , a slow motion was given to the lamp and plate .
After some minutes , the needle had receded in a direction contrary to that of the motion of the plate through 3,5 .
This experiment was repeated several times , and I observed that the needle , ( if it moved at all , ) generally went in an opposite direction to the plate ; and that its motion was often so slow as to be imperceptible to the eye , although it could be very distinctly perceived after the lapse of a short time , by its altered position .
In various repetitions of this experiment , the needle slowly retrograded from 1o to go degrees.* $ In one experiment which lasted above half an hour , and in which I had the advantage of Mr. CHRISTIE'S assistance , the needle slowly retrograded over I57 ? .
In this case the motion was rather slower than that of the minute hand of a watch .
For the purpose of determining whether the air , heated by the upper surface of the metal ; disc , acted on the needles , as it does on the vane of la smoke-jack , I made the following experiment .
Experiment 21 .
Having formed a needle of sheet brass , thinner and lighter than those hitherto employed , but of the same form , I bent the circular parts , at the extremities , in such a manner , that they formed angles with the longitudinal axis of the needle ; one of about ?
, the other about i,5 ' .
This being balanced above the copper plate , the lamp was lighted below it , but no rotation was communicated to the apparatus .
The needle soon began to acquire vibrations in a vertical plane ; but after five minutes ' exposure there was no perceptible rotation .
I now bent the circular extremities of the needle so as to form angles of about s5 ' and 4o ? .
On replacing it , and lighting the lamp , the needle moved about ?
in a contrary direction to that which the impinging air ought to have produced ; it then returned , and went on through several revoolutions in the opposite direction .
The needle employed in this experiment projected a little beyond the copper plate , and would therefore receive some of the heated air passing from the lamp along the under side of the plate , to which cause the vertical vibrations may perhaps be ascribed .
From this experiment it appears , that if the needles are made flat with ordinary care , rotation will not ensue from the action of the heated air .
I shall now briefly restate the various causes to which these rotations might be ascribed , and refer back to the experiments which refute each supposition .
ist .
The various currents of air in the room could not prow duce an almost uniform result .
Considerable care was taken not to move about more than was requisite , and the experiments were generally made after the apparatus had been left , and the room shut up for some hours previous .
In all but the earliest experiments the cylindrical millboard cases , in which the needles were placed , effectually excluded all currents of air exterior to them .
2nd .
The rotation of a current of air produced within the lower cylinder by the motion of the lamp , metal plate , and the wooden platform supporting them , would , if it produced any effect , tend to make the needle rotate in the same direction .
But we have seen from many experiments , that when a muslin screen is interposed , the rotation at the commencement is in the opposite direction .
Also in Experiments iS and wg there was no rotation given to the apparatus , and yet the needle advanced ; and in Experiment i6 a sheet of zinc prevented the air set in motion in the lower cylinder from communicating with that in the upper .
Srd .
That air driven through the screen was not the cause of these motions , appears from their taking place when the screen was impenetrable to it .
In Experiment 9 , where no electricity was employed , a rapid rotation was kept up during six minutes immediately under a gauze screen , and no motion was produced in the needle above it .
4th .
Perhaps the most probable of these suppositions is , that the motions result from the effect of currents of air which rise from the surface of the heated metal disc : these will cause other lateral currents , arising from the cold air flowing in to supply the place of that which has been heated , and has ascended .
Such an hypothesis might explain Experiments 18 and 19 , if , on measuring its influence , the cause were found sufficiently powerful ; but it appears from Experiment 21 , that when the needles are not visibly bent in the form of vanes , this cause is not sufficient to produce the effect , although it acts in the same direction .
The heated air above a revolving plate will revolve in the same direction and if it pass through the interstices of the muslin , it ought to impress motion in the same direction as the plate from which it rises .
The heated air above the zinc screen had not this rotatory motion ; and we have seen by experiment 21 , that its vertical action was not sufficient to produce the effect .
In many of the experiments no heat was employed ; and yet the same motions resulted , as is apparent by Experiments.5 and 6 for direct motions , and by Experiment io for the retrograde .
5th .
Vibrations excited in the apparatus by the motion of the jack .
This cause was decisively refuted by Experiment 17 , in which they were measured , and found to be quite insensible .
Also in Experiments 18 and 19 the apparatus was not in motion , yet the needles did move .
6th .
The torsion of the silver wire to which the needles were attached .
Until I had measured this torsion by reversing the direction of the moving plate , as in Experiment 5 , , I had some suspicion that the heat of the lamp might have altered the elasticity of the wire and although I did not then see how the reverse motion could be well accounted for , yet I was desirous , if possible , of removing altogether this disturbing action .
Some of the previous experiments in which no heat was employed , and many of the subsequent ones in which no wire was used , effectually refute this supposition .
7th .
The electricity of the bridge might be supposed to produce some of the motions .
It was more necessary to get rid of the action of this cause than of any of the others , because electricity , modified indeed by the circumstances under which it was placed , did , in my opinion , produce the whole of these curious phenomena .
The action of the glass or wooden support was apparent , and is noticed in the remarks on the 19th Experiment ; but as it was not employed in any of those experiments in which the balance of torsion was used , and as it was dismissed from several of the latter ones in which reversed motions of the needle appeared , they cannot be attributed to this cause .
8th .
The bending of the wax needle .
The application of heat after some time altered the form of the wax needle ; 'it sometimes became so soft as to bend by its own weight down to the graduated circle , This change , however , only took place at the latter part of the experiment in which it occurred , and the phenomena recorded usually appeared at a much earlier period , when if it had commenced the change was quite imperceptible .
In those experiments in which heat was not employed this cause was absent ; and in many of those in which it was applied , a needle of card , or of thin brass covered with sealing-wax , or a mixture of resin and shell lac , was used , in which no bending took place .
Having shown that none of the causes to which I have alluded are common to all the experiments in which the phenomena occurred , I shall now offer that explanation of them which appears to me to be warranted by the observations that have been recorded in the preceding part of this paper .
They naturally divide themselves into two .
classes .
1tst .
Those in which the motion communicatedis in the same direction as that of the revolving plate .
&lt; 2ndly .
Those in which the motion of the needle is in a contrary direction to that of the plate .
The instances in which the needles employed followed the directions of the revolving plate are so numerous , and the extent of their motion so great , that no doubt can remain , of the fact , and some of them may be repeated with a very simple apparatus .
The circumstance of one of the bodies employed being generally an electric , such as wax , resin , glass , and of the increase of the observed motions when these were previously excited by friction , or by a change of temperature during the experiment , naturally points out electricity as the cause .
It is indeed the only one common to all the cases detailed .
If it be admitted that induced electricity is neither acquired nor-given up ?
in aninstant of time , then it necessarily follows , from the reasoning I have explained at the commencement of this paper , that such motions must arise .
2rnd .
The case of a retrograde motion is much more diffIl cult of explanation .
Its existence rests on measures of , much smaller magnitude , and it is by no means so easily re-produced , requiring some delicacy both in the adjustment of the apparatus , and in the observations of the needle .
I have myself observed it so frequently , as to have not the smallest doubt of the fact .
I have occasionally shown it to several friends ; although I have not in every instance succeeded in this .
To have omitted to state in this paper the fact of such a retrograde motion would have been uncandid , because it is one which is strongly opposed to all the reasoning that it contains .
To abstain from giving any explanation , however imperfect , that might reconcile it with my view of the subject , would be to leave untouched a very powerful , and almost solitary argument against the explanation which I have proposed both of magnetic and electric rotation .
I shall therefore attempt to show , not merely that it is not repugnant to .
the principle which I have already explained , but that that very principle may , in certain circumstances , produce the retrograde motion , and that in others nearly similar , it shall itot take place ; thus not merely showing the possibility of the fact , but accounting for its apparently capricious nature .
In figure 2 , N represents the end of an excited needle , situated above a metal plate C , and having a muslin screen G interposed between them .
All three being at rest , the screen and the metal plate will become electric by induction , and one of the two following arrangements must take place : either the electricity developed on the screen and on the plate will be of the same species , in which case it will be contrary to that of the needle N ; or the electricity on the screen and the metal plate will be of different kinds , in which case one of them must be of the same species , the other of a different one from that of the needle .
In the first case let BB represent the curve of the intensity of induced electricity on the muslin screen , that is , let each of its ordinates be supposed proportional to the electricity at the corresponding point on the screen ; then , part of the influence of the electrified body N passing through the interstices of the screen , produces on the metal plate the same kind of electricity as it did on the screen .
Let the curve of electric intensity in the metal plate be A. Whilst the metal plate C remains at rest , both its electricity and that of the screen tend to draw the needle N directly towards it ; but if the plate C move in the direction of the arrow with an uniform velocity , and if induced electricity be not instantly annihilated , then there will arise a new electric equilibrium , and the curve representing its intensity and position will have advanced towards that part to which the motion is directed , and may be represented by the dotted line a. The influence of this electricity , which is of the same kind with that on the screen , and which consequently it repels , will be , that the electric curve on G must be driven back in the opposite direction : let it be represented by b , b. Now the attraction of b , b on the needle N tends to give it a motion in the direction contrary to that which is impressed on it by the attraction of a , which is on the opposite side of the perpendicular , dropped from N to the metal plate .
That proportion of the resolved action of b , b , which communicates horizontal movement , is larger than it is at the greater distance of the plate C , and the whole force acts at a shorter distance : it may therefore exert a more powerful influence in turning the needle in that direction , than a stronger force at a greater distance , C acting more unfavourably .
Thus the needle may , by the advance of the plate C , be caused to retrograde .
It does not , however , follow , that this must always happen , for the susceptibility for induced magnetism in the plate may be much greater , and it may retain it much longer than the screen , and in this case we ought to anticipate a motion of the needle in the same direction as the plate .
Let us now examine the case of one of the bodies possessing the same kind of electricity as the needle .
Let the same letters in figure 2 represent the electricities when the plate is at rest ; thus , when it moves in the direction of the arrow , the electric curve will assume the position of the dotted line a ; and since it is of an opposite kind to that of the screen , it will attract it , and will tend to draw the electric curve B on the screen into the position b. b , marked by the dotted lines .
In this case the electric forces are both on the same side of the perpendicular from the needle ; but since they are of opposite kinds , one will attract , the other will repel the needle ; and according to the strength of these forces , it will advance , be stationary , or recede .
This explanation accords with the apparently capricious nature of the fact ; the circumstances on which a direct or a retrograde motion depends are so numerous , and in the present state of our knowledge we have so few data for calculating their influence , that it is not surprising that the result of any given combination should be uncertain .
Besides the relative distances , we ought to be acquainted with the relative conducting powers of the screen and plate , the intensity which can be excited in each by a given inducing source- the quantity of that inducing action which can be transmitted through the interstices of the screen the time each body takes to acquire and give up electricity-before we can attempt accurately to predict the result of any proposed arrangement .
There is another circumstance in which the above explanation agrees well with the observed facts ; since the motion communicated to the needle is the difference of two forces , each of which is very small , it must itself be smaller than either ; and in case of any approach to equality in those opposing forces , it will become exceedingly minute .
With respect to the action of heat in increasing these rotations , I am inclined to conjecture , that the distribution of electricity on the metallic plate is altered by the application of heat ; that the part under the needle becoming electrified , produces in it induced electricity ; and thus the plate being made to revolve , the rotation of the needle follows from the explanation previously given .
It may , however , happen , that the wax needle becomes itself electric by the heat it receives from the plate below it .
It will naturally be enquired , whether a parallel to this retrograde motion cannot be produced with magnets .
I have made a few trials with a plate of soft iron , an iron gauze screen , and neutralized magnets , but have not succeeded .
I found the needles stationary over whatever point they were placed .
I shall conclude this paper with mentioning some of the methods by which I observed the angles passed over by the needles ; this is the more necessary , because it was desirable to remove all the parts of the apparatus as far from them as could be conveniently done .
If the angle was small , a fine thread of glass was made to project from the end of the needle , and a lamp was placed in such a position as to throw its shadow on the graduations below ; this of course would only do for the measure of a few degrees , and was inconvenient by day .
In some instances I used a plano-convex lens cut into halves , one half being fixed as much before the other as the distance of the needle from the graduations required ; this brought the image of the glass thread and the graduations into the same plane ; but as the lens I had cut was of too short focal length , this plan was not often adopted .
I occasionally employed a narrow ring of glass , on one half of which the graduated card circle was pasted ; the back of the glass ring was blackened .
By placing the eye above the needle in such a position that the direct image of the glass thread covered that which was reflected from the black glass , all parallax was avoided ; and I found that , without great carelessness , repeated observations never differed more than a quarter of a degree .
Another method which I made use of was to draw a fine line along the needle ; and having made a small hole in the centre of the glass plate which covered the apparatus , I fixed an index of card , which couldrevolve about it as a centre ; this index extended to a graduated circle fixed on the same glass cover .
When I wished to observe the position of the needle , I brought one edge of the index to coincide with the line on the needle .
There were some advantages in this me .
thod , but it had the inconvenience of obliging me to touch the apparatus at each observation .

