XXVI .
An account of some experiments relative to the passage of radiant heat through glass screens .
By the Rev. BADEN POWELL , M. A. F. R. S. of Oriel College , Oxford .
Commua nicated March 9 , 1826 .
Read June 1 , 1826 .
( ) IN a former Paper , communicated to the Royal Society , and which has been honoured with a place in the Philosophical Transactions for 1 825 , 1 attempted an investigation of the distinctive characters of two species of heating effect , in which particular reference was made to the action of transparent screens , In the present communication , my object -is to examine a further point belonging to that part of the subject ; and to which , as well as the former enquiry , I have been led , from considering the results obtained by M. DE LA ROCHE .
The investigation given in my former paper proceeded upon the assumption , that simple radiant heat is incapable of permeating glass by direct transmission when the source is below luminosity : and the conclusion deduced from my experiments went to show , that that portion of the heat which is intercepted above luminosity , is simple heat , unaltered except in intensity , whilst that which is transmitted is of a different kind .
That this assumption , at least under all ordinary circumstances , is warranted by most decisive experiments , I conceive sufficiently certain .
It appears to me , however , that in reference to its strict universality , some further enquiry is necessary .
The general inference respecting transmission , deduced from DE LA RoCHE 's experiments , has , I conceive , been satisfactorily explained by mine ; but there is one of his conclusions to which my principle does not apply ( except in a particular case ) , and which might seem to afford considerable ground for the idea of an actual radiation through glass , under particular circumstances .
( 2 .
) That distinguished experimenter found , that if radiant heat be intercepted by two transparent screens , the additional diminution of effect occasioned by the second is proportionally much less than that produced by the ftst and the same conclusion is extended to any number of screens .
This was explained by the supposition , that the heat in its passage through the first glass undergoes a certain modification , in some respects analogous to polarization , by which ; it is enabled to pass , with very little diminution , through the second and subsequent glasses .
( 3 ) In those cases where the source of heat is luminous , such phenomenon would receive an obvious explanation on the principle investigated in my former Paper .
The simple radiant heat being stopped by the first glass , the second would produce an almost insensible diminution of the light , and therefore also of that species of heat which is transmitted in union with it .
But if the same effect is still observable below the point of luminosityv we must have recourse so some other principle of explanation .
That deduced by DE LA ROCHE appears at least plausible and though it should be considered proved that in general heat is incapable of being radiated directly through glass , it perhaps would not necessarily follow , that it might not , under peculiar circumstances , have a power of doing so -communicated to it .
Though o.n the other hand it must be confessed that , in the present case , -some difficulty would attend such a supposition .
It certainly would not be easy to conceive such a property to be communicated to the heat by the mere act of being conducted through the first glass .
Again ; a new property of heat is thus introduced which , it must be conceded , is not absolutely and exclusively established .
It appeared to me therefore a point of some interest to examine , in the case of non-luminous heat-in the first place , the accuracy of the fact ; and secondly , if verified , whether there might not be circumstances observable in the conditions of the experiment by which it might be accounted for , without the necessity of supposing any peculiar property of heat , or a direct transmission even through the second glass .
( 4 .
) My apparatus in following up this enquiry was similar to that described by M. DE LA ROCHE , and consisted of two tin reflectors .
In one focus the bulb of a thermometer coated with Indian ink , and in the other an iron ball two inches diameter , which was heated to redness , and then cooled till it ceased to be visibly red in the dark , at which point it was placed on its stand , and a thick screen withdrawn .
The indications were observed , first for the direct effect secondly , with one glass screen interposed ; and thirdly , with two .
In this way I tried various experiments ; in some using only one reflector ; in others both ; in some employing a mnercurial in others an air thermometer .
I conceive it unnecessary to bring forward all the various experiments I tried , and shall cntent myself with giving a few of the most decisive , in a tabular form .
The first experiments I shall give , are twosets made with only one reflector , in the focus of which the bulb of a large differential thermometer was placed , and the progress of the effect traced for every so seconds successively in the three cases .
The area of heating rays was limited by a circular aperture , about two inches diameter , in a pasteboard screen .
The first screen , or that nearest the ball , was about It inch in thickness , the second rather less .
The divisions on the scale are arbitrary .
( 6 .
) One Reflector .
Dist .
iS inches .
No. I. One Reflector .
Dist .
iB inches .
No. IL _~~~ ____ -_ _ __ If Min .
Sec. No Screen .
I Screen .
2 Screens .
Min .
Sec. No Screen .
i Screen .
2 Screens .
0000000o 30 5 0.5 0 30 5I .
I9I 0.25 X 9.5 1.5 1 30 12 1.25 0.25 30 132I2 13.5 1.25 0.25 _ 15 21 30 14.5 1.5 0.25 30 i6 2.25 73l5 1.5 0.25 3 I6I 30 15 .
1.75 0.5 30 16.75 2.5 X4 15.75 1.75 0.25 4.i6 2.25 1.25 30 i6 1.75 0.5 30 15.75 2.25 1.25 51 5.75 175 0.5 5 15x5 2 1.25 -30 15.5.75 0,75 30 52 3.5 6 15 75 0.25 6 14.75 z 1.5 30 14.25.5 0.5 * * progress of the direct effect follows a different law from that with one screen , and this again from that with two ; and in particular , that the maximum in the last case does not occur till considerably later than in the former .
But if the effects were produced by a direct transmission , though their intent sity would be diminished , they would follow a similar law ; and the maximum would take place at the same time .
These results then tend to show that the effect takes place by a secondary radiation .
But from the inaccurate nature of the instrument , I place no reliance on these results alone .
( 7 .
) To examine the point in a more complete and satisfactory manner , the two following sets of experiments were made with particular care , in which a mercurial thermometer was used , and the temperatures of the screens observed by means of a small thermometer attached to the face of each away from the ball , towards its central part ; thea bulb being kept in contact by the spring of a wire with which the thermometer was fastened .
These thermometers were very nearly equal in size ; the diameters of their bulbs being about 0.175 inch that of the focal thermometer o.5 inch , and detached about an inch from the mounting .
It was graduated to quarters of centigrade degrees ; the others only to whole degrees .
Both the screens were of plate glass : the first or nearest the source of heat about 2-i inch in thickness t the second about Xinch , ( .
2 Reflectors , i5 inches distant .
No. I. 1st .
Screen 32 inches .
2d .
g inches from ball .
No Screen .
1 Screen .
2 Screens .
Min .
Sec. Focal Focal Temp. of Focal Temp. of Temp. of Therm. Therm. Screen .
Therm 1st Screen .
2d Screen .
o 16.75 16.75 17.5 i6.5 18 I7 30 20 17 20 i 6.5 20 17 I 22.5 17.25 2 i6.75 22 I830 24.5 17.5 24 17 24 I82 25.75 17.75 26 17 25.5 i8.S 30 27 18 .
27 17 28 i 8.5 3 28 18e 28.5 17 29.5 * 8 .
30 29 I8.25 29 17 30 4 29.25 18.25 30 17 31 18.5 30 29.5 i8.5 31 17 31.5 18.75 5 29.75 18.5 3 !
17 312 18.75 30 30 I8.5 31 17 32 18.75 6 30 18.5 31 17 32 19 30 29.75 1 8.5 31 17 32 19 7 29.5 1 8.5 3117 32 19 30 29.5 18.5 31 17 32 19.5 8_ 29 i8.5 31 17 31 .
19.5 30 18.5 30.5 17 31 19.5 91 8.5 30 17 ' 19.5 30 18.25 30 17 31 39.5 1o 18.725 30 17 30.5 19.5 30 i8.z2 29.5 I675 30 19.5 1I 1 8.25 29 I 6.75 29.75 19.5 30 i8.25 29 16.75 29.5 19.5 12 _i 8.25 28.5 16.75 29 .
19.Z5 30 18.25 28.5 1x6.75 28.75 19.25 I13 I8.25 28.5 16.75 28.5 19 30 I8 28 16.75 28.25 19 IA _8 2z8 16.75 28 19 2 Reflectors , i7 inches distant .
No. II .
ist Screen 2 in.-2fld 3i in .
from ball .
No Screen , 1 Screen .
2 Screens .
Min .
Sec. Focal Focal Temp. of Focal Temp. of Temp. of Therm. Therm , Screen .
Therm. ist Screen .
2d Screen .
0 17 17 I8 I7 17 17 30 21 1 17.25 20.5 17 19.5 17 _ 24 .
I17.75 25 17.25 25.5 17.5 30:6 2 27 17.5 30 I8 a~ 28 18.5 3 75 33 85 30 29.5 18.75 32.5 I 7.5 35 18.5 3 30.5 19 34 175 379 30 3.1 I 9.25 351 7.5 38 I9.5 4 31.5 I9.5 36 17.75 39.5 20 30 3 I.5 19.75 37 I 7.75 40 20 5 31,5 19.75 375 17.75 40.5 20 30 3I.5 I 9.7 5 37.5 17.75 40.5 20.5 6 3I.25 19.75 38 17.75 40.5 20.5 30 31.25 I9'75 38I 7.75 40.5 2I 7 31 I9.75 38 17.75 40 21 30 19.75 37.5 17.75 40 21 8 19.75 37.5 17.75 39 21 30 1975 37 i8 39 2I 9 19.75 36.5 i8 38.5 2I 30 I9.75 36 I8 38 2I I0 I9.75 1$,5 17.75 37.5 2I 31 9.75 35 17.75 37 21 II 19.5 35 17.75 37 21 30 19.5 34.5 I 7.75 36.5 21 1 .
19.5 34 17.75 36 2I 30 19.5 33.5 I7.75 35.5 21 13 19.25 33 17.75 35 21 30 19.25 33 I7.75 34.5 21 14 -19.25 32.5 17.75 34 21 30 17.75 33.5 2I 15 17.75 32I 9 .
) From these results ( with which all the others I obtained closely agree ) I conceive it fully appears,1 st. That the additional diminution occasioned by the second screen is proportionally much smaller than that occasioned by the first .
Thus DE LA RoCHE'S conclusion is shown to hold good , not only in the case of luminous , but also of nonluminous hot bodies ; which is perhaps of consequence , as I believe doubts have been entertained respecting it ; and it may be remarked , that here the greater thickness of the second screen would be against such a result .
2dly .
If the progress of the indications of the direct effect be followed , it appears that the rise in the first so seconds is the greatest , and those in the subsequent periods gradually diminish .
Sdly .
With one screen , the effect in the first period is equal to , or even less than those in the subsequent ones ; and if we follow the temperature of the first screen , it appears to sustain a rapid increase at first , and afterwards continues gradually to rise till sometime after the focal thermometer has become stationary .
The progress of the focal thermometer -exactly accords with what must be the heating effect of the screen as a source ; viz. rising slowly at first as the screen acquires heat sufficient to supply it , and remaining stationary so long as the still increasing ; temperature of the screen could balance its loss of heat .
4thly .
With two screens , there is no rise till the 2d half minute ; when it is not greater than in the next half ; after which the thermometer becomes stationary ; and this trifling effect exactly accords with what the temperature of the second screen should produce .
It does ; not begin till the second screen has acquired a- , higher temperature , and it is stationary while the temperature of thescreen continues : to increase ; and the temperature of the second screen is such as is clearly accounted for from the heating effect of the first .
It does not begin to rise till after that of the first has ris:n : it continues stationary some time after the first has begun tocool as the first screen did when the iron was cooling .
But , as in this cases , the -source of heat was cooling during the whole time of the experiment , whilst in the other it was heat .
ing during the first part of the time , it follows , that a greater proportional temperature should be communicated to the second screen by the first , than to the first by the iron ball .
Other circumstances will partially co-operate in producing this effect ; as the greater proximity of the second screen to the thermometer : also more heat might be lost in communicating an equable temperature to the first screen from its central and most heated part ; whilst the heat would be thus more equally radiated to all parts of the second without such loss .
Thus it appears that the fact stated by M. DE LA RoGHE is fully substantiated ; while on the other hand it is satisfactorlly accounted for , without supposing any new property of heat , or any direct radiation through glass .
( to .
) I have been more particularly led to this enquiry , from becoming acquainted with some experiments on the subject by Mr. RITCHIE , published in the Edinburgh Philosophical Journal , No. XXII .
p. 281 ; in which , among other conclusions ( to which I shall presently advert ) , he maintains , that at high temperatures below luminosity a portion of the heat radiates through glass of ordinary thickness , but without giving any details by which it can be made to appear that the effect is not sufficiently accounted for by secondary radiation .
He has also given an explanation -on his own theory of the conclusion I have above examined , as deduced from DE LA RocHE 's experiments ; but both that conclusion , and with it any such explanation , are now I conceive shown to be unnecessary .
( 1 I. ) The principal result obtained by Mr. RITCHIE , and described in this Paper , is however of a nature deserving more attention .
It exhibits an exception to the general law , in the instance of glass of extreme thinness ; in which case the heat from a source below luminosity appears capable of radiating through such a screen when transparent , but not when rendered opaque .
As experiments conducted like those of Mr. RITCHIE , with air thermometers , are always liable to uncertainty , I conceived it desirable to try the same thing with a mercurial thermometer .
( 12 .
)I used as screens pieces of a large bulb blown to an extreme degree of tenuity ; these were attached ( as in Mr. RITCHIE 's experiments ) , to a circular aperture about A1 inch 4 diameter in a pasteboard screen .
A second screen of milled board , with an aperture of i inch diameter , was placed about an inch from the first ; and behind this the iron ball , previously cooled to just below visible redness .
The same thermometer as in the preceding experiments was suspended at aboutS inch from the screen .
I made various trials , comparing the effect of the thin transparent screen with a similar opaque one : in some instances using three thicknesses of the glass , and afterwards the middle piece blackened on both sides with the soot of a candle ; and in others two thicknesses , the inner surface of one being afterwards blackened ; thus forming an opaque screen with the same vitreous surface .
In all the experiments a thermometer suspended by the side MDcccxXVI .
D D of the apparatus did not vary .
The results of two sets of experiments are as:follows : Distance 6 inches .
No. I. 3 Glasses .
Middle Glass blackened .
Min , Sec. _____ 2 Glasses .
2d blackened .
Exp , 1.| Exp.:2 .
EXp .
1 .
Exp. 2 .
0 17.25 17.25 17.25 17.25 17.25 30 17.5 17.5 17.5 17.5 I7.5 17.75 17,75 17.5 17.75 17.75 30 17.75 17.75 17.75 17.75 17.75 2 I8 17.75 I 7.75 I7.75 18 30 I818 17.75 17.75 i83 x8 i i8 1 Distance 3 inches .
No. 11 .
2 Glasses .
2d blackened .
Mm Sec. 1Glass .
Glasses .
Exp. 1 .
) Exp. 2 .
0 -6 I6 30 z I6 1 6.25 I6.5 I 6.75 Ii 6.5 i 6.5 16.75 I730 17 17 17.25 17.25 2 17.75 17.25 17.75 17.75 ( 1 .
) From these results , I think it will be admitted that no sensible difference appears in the two cases , sufficient to warrant any such conclusion as that alluded to .
If the experiments described in this paper be regarded as sufficiently accurate , it follows upon the whole , that two principal exceptions to the general law , that simple heat cannot radiate through glass , are done away .
St. Helen 's Place , March 9 , 1826 .

