XXI .
Account of an experiment on the elasticity of ice .
By BENJAMIN BEVAN , Esq. In a Letter to Dr. THOMAS YOUNG , For .
Sec. R. S. Read April 27 , 1826 .
DEAR SIR , Norwich , January iS , i826 .
I HAVE been long desirous of repeating my experiment on the elasticity of ice , but until the present frost have not had an opportunity for two years , when I had but a single specimen , and rather too small , and which broke soon after the commencement of the experiment .
From that experiment I had calculated a modulus of 6.ooo , ooo feet ; but finding the result of my experiments in the present season much less , and pretty uniform amongst themselves , I re-examined the calculations made in 1824 , and have discovered an error , which had before escaped me , in the reduction , and which brings the result of that experiment to agree with those made in the present season , or about 2.100,000 feet .
I will not answer for the absolute correctness of the second figure , because a variation of the --tu of an inch in the thickness of the specimen will change this figure .
The present severe frost has enabled me to try experiments on a much larger scale , and upon ice from i4K to 4 inches in thickness : to explain the mode I adopted with ice of near 4 inches in thickness may be necessary , and was as follows : Upon a large pond within less than a mile of my residence at Leighton Bussard , the depth of which I found to be about 4 feet , I had a channel sawed on three sides of a parallelogram , in the following form , abc separating the specimen to be operated upon , except at the end lettered a , where its union was left undisturbed .
The dimensions of this prism was loo inches long , lo inches wide , and thickness at a-3.62 , at b=4.oo , and at c=3.75 inches .
To save some trouble in the calculation , HI considered the thickness uniformly S.97 inches or the mean of the whole : although I am aware that it would not be strictly accurate ; but as the experiment was upon a large scale , and with weights up to 25 lbs. and with deflections proportional to the weights applied , I considered the experiment a fair one .
In this experiment the weights were placed at 98 inches from the line of union with the main body , and the deflection by 2551bs .
was 0.206 inches ; from which I estimate the modulus to be.100 , o0oo feet .
After this , I repeated the experiment on ice of various dimensions and of different thickness , and in all , the result agreed quite as near as the admeasurement of the thickness could be ascertained , as well when the deflection was tried upon the water , as when the ice was taken out and tried in the manner used with wood and metal , Now the modulus of water as given in your valuable lectures , derived from CANTON'S experiment , is , if I recollect right , about 750,000 feet , calculated from a condensation of b the pressure of one atmosphere .
This condensation , I presume , was cubical or solid ; whereas the condensation used in regard to the modulus of elasticity is linear .
You are of course aware that a linear compression of 4LdO will produce a cubical condensation of y , as found by CANTON .
Allowing , therefore , 9 feet for a column of water the pressure of the atmosphere , and multiply this by 660oo , we shall have 2.178,000 feet for the modulus of water , agreeing pretty nearly with the result of my experiments .
I should not have troubled you with this letter , but as the frost may yet continue for a few days , an opportunity may be found of verifying , or correcting , the result of my experiments .
I am , with the greatest respect , Your 's truly , 1B .
BEVAN9 Leighton Bussard .
Note by Dr. YOUNG .
It does not appear quite clear from reasoning , that the modulus ought to come out different in experiments on solids and on fluids : for though the linear compression in a fluid may be only .
as much as in a solid , yet the number of particles acting in any given section must be greater in the duplicate ratio of this compression , and ought apparently to make up the same resistance .
And in a single experiment made hastily some years ago on the sound yielded by a piece of ice , the modulus did appear to be about 8ooooo feet only : but the presumption of accuracy is the greater in this case the higher the modulus appears .

