XX .
A formula for expressing the decrement of human lfe .
In a letter addressed to Sir EDWARD HYDE EAST , Bart. M. P. F. R. S. By THOMAS YOUNG , M. D. For .
Sec. R. S. Com.municated February 2 , 1826 .
Read April 1i , 1826 .
MY DEAR SIR , THE investigation of the laws , by which the general mortality of the human species appears to be governed , is of equal importance to the statesman , the physician , the natural philosopher , and the mathematician ; and as you have had occasion to pay particular attention to the subject , I trust that it will not be disagreeable to you to receive the results of an inquiry , into which I have entered , for the purpose of appree ciating , if not of reconciling , the many discordant opinions that have been advanced , respecting the comparative mortality of mankind , at different times , and under different circums stances .
Of late years , there is little doubt , that , whether from the protective effects of vaccination in infancy , or from the iny crease of the comforts of the poorer , and of the temperance of the more affluent classes of society , or in some measure also from the simplification of the practice of physic and surgry , there is a decided increase in the mean duration of life in many parts of Europe : but it is also extremely probable that this improvement has been greatly exaggerated ; partly on account of the limited description of the persons on whom the observations have been made , and partly from an erroneous opinion respecting the profits of certain establishments , which have been attributed to the employment of too low an estimate of mortality , while they have , in fact , been principally derived from the high rate of interest which the state of public credit has afforded .
A very laborious and well informed actuary has lately asserted before a Committee of the House of Commons , that " the duration of existence now , compared with what it was a hundred years ago , is as four to three , in round numbers .
" ( Parl .
Rep. N. 522 , p. 44 .
) It does indeed happen , that this particular result may in one sense be very correctly deduced from the immediate comparison of the annual mortality of a certain number of persons of the same description , that is , annuitants , at the periods in question ; nor is it possible to deny that some importance must be attached to the remark : but the mortality of the same class of persons in France , at the earlier period , was no greater , according to Mr. DEPARCIEUX S estimate of their longevity , than in England at the later , while the general mortality in France has never been materially less than in England , and appears at present to be even somewhat greater : and it can only be conjectured , that the annuitants of the tontine of King WILLIAM were in general most injudiciously selected , while those who were the subjects of Mr. DEPARCIEUx 's observations , like the annuitants of the modern tontines , were chosen with more care , or with greater success .
Mr. FINLAISON'S tables , therefore , though they may be extremely just and valuable for the purpose of setting a price upon annuities to be granted on the lives of the proposers , cannot , with any prudence , be adopted where the parties concerned have an interest in offering the worst lives that they can find notwithstanding any partial security that might be afforded by the exercise of medical skill in their rejection ; and if it is true , that some of the tontines were principally filled by lot ( Rep. p. 16 ) , with the children of country clergymen and magistrates , it must still be supposed that the families of such persons may have been more healthy than the average of the population of London and the country taken together .
For the comparison of the general characters of different tables of mortality , the simplest and most obvious criterion is perhaps the number of individuals out of which one dies annually , which is also the number of years expressing the expectation of life at the time of birth .
But this test is liable to material objections with regard to the most usual appli- .
cation of the table , which depends more on the comparative expectations at later periods than in early infancy .
For example ; the Northampton table affords results , throughout the whole of middle and advanced life , agreeing almost exactly with DEMOIVRE 's hypothesis of equal decrements , although the annual mortality is supposed to be nearly 1 in 25 at Northampton , instead of 1 in 43 , as assumed by DEMOIVRE .
It would therefore be very unjust for a person allowing the truth of DEMOIVRE 's hypothesis , to condemn the practical employment of Dr. PRICE 's tables in common cases , on account of this variation only .
A less exceptionable test will be , to find the mean of the numbers expressing , for different ages , the full term of life , or the sum of the age and twice the expectation , taking the decads from io to 8o as the most important .
Another standard of comparison may be the age which is equal to the expectation of life , and which , in DEMOIVRE 's arithmetical hypothesis , is the mean age of all the population , and probably very near it in all tables formed from actual observation .
In this manner a general comparison of the most remarkable tables may be instituted .
Characteristics of Mortality .
AnulMean full term mortality of life , Mean age .
one in Roman estimate of Ulpian , probably with some deduction for present value ... ... ... ... 74 ( + disct ) 26 ( + disct ) Deparcieux 's Tontines , beginning 1689.,. .
47.67 94.17 32.5 Halley 's table for Breslau , 1 69o ... 33.50 87.I5 28.1 Tontine of I695 , Finlaison , males ... ... ... .
37.6i 83.42 27.25 -______-____-females.(43.0 ) 87.5 29.32 Simpson 's table for London , about 1730 .
19.2 82.30 25.7 Dupre , in Buffon , about 1750.33.0 85.30 z8.67 Northampton tables , about 1760 ... ... ... . .
Z..18 87.39 z8.86 Swedish tables , about 1785 ... ... ... ... ... .
36.I2 9I.86 313 France , before the Revolution , Duvillard .
28.76 86.96 29.0 Finlaison 's tontine and annuitants , about i8o , oo , 6 males.~~~~~~~~~~~S .
93.25 32.0 m ales ... ... ... ... ... ... .
+ ... ... .
females ... 55 ... ... ... .
55.51 100.7 34.6 Finlaison 's Chelsea Pensioners ... ... .9.0 29 ... ... ... 9 ?
* ?
zg.65 Carlisle tables , about I81o , Milne , 37.14 954+7 32.6 Returns for all England , i8i I ... ... ... ... .
49 The order of the mortalities expressed by the first column of this table , is , SIMPsoN , Northampton , France , DUPRE ' , HALLEY , Sweden , Carlisle , tontine 1695 males , females , DEPARCIEUX , returns of 181i , tontines of i8oo , males , and females ; the order of the second column is SIMPSON , tontine of 1695 , males , DUPRE ' , France , HALLEY , Northampton , females 1695 , pensioners , Sweden , tontines of 18oo , males , Carlisle , females of 1800 : but besides this difference in the order , the disproportion exhibited in this column is less enormous than in the former ; the numbers of the Carlisle -hid .
Jras .
MDCCCXXVL -pA te Depwaraew 200~ 1200 H 4190 I. : ; t tt | st so 1K iRo I VAR-'\ iD a7 x SBo I tX0t1 I-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~I XA ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ A IVO~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ AG2 j lo0 4a6ogo lofg F----I -~~~ ~~~~~~~~---------~--K 10 -L 0 AA-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ All -$ 70-I~~~~~~~~6o 403020- " t~ LJF J. L JJLLL L~ ~ tables , for example , exceeding those of the Northampton by one half in the former , and by one tenth only in the latter .
The proportion of Mr. FINLAISON'S tontines also stands as s to 4 in the first , and as 7 to 8 , or 8 to 9 only in the second : the latter comparison giving a much fairer practical estimate of the comparative longevity , indicated by the tables , than the former .
Another mode of easily appreciating the regularity and the analogies of different tables is , to construct a diagram , in the form of a curve , of which the absciss represents the age , and the ordinates the corresponding decrements of life .
( Plate XI .
) The inspection of such a diagram is sufficient to convince us of the great irregularity of the Carlisle tables of mortality , which must obviously have been formed , as they confessedly were , from observations on a very limited number of individuals , so that they exhibit a succession of different climacterics , after which the mortality is diminished , while about the age of 74 the curve that represents them towers to an incredible height , affording an expectation of longevity which some of the strongest advocates of those tables have aban.s doned in their practical applications , since they take their estimate of life , in advanced age , even lower than it is represented in the Northampton tables .
It appears therefore to be highly probable , that the fairest basis for general computations , to be applied throughout Great Britain , may be obtained by a proper combination of the tables of Northampton , which have been long known and very generally approved , with the Carlisle tables , corrected however in their extravagant values of old lives , by some other documents ; and with the mortality of London as MnDCCCXXVI .
P p derived from the parish registers , which , when thus incorpo .
rated with tables formed in the country , will be freed from the objections that have been made to the observations of burials in great cities only .
The Carlisle table agrees in the earlier parts pretty nearly with the observations of Mr. MORGAN on the experience of the Equitable Office from 1768 to i8Xo , as it appears from Mr. MILNE'S comparison , as well as from the reduction and interpolation of those observations published by Mr. GOMPERTZ in the Philosophical Transactions for 1825 : but for correcting the later portions of the Carlisle table , it may be allowable to employ a subsequent register of the experience of the Equitable Office , so far as it is possible to make any inferences from it with safety .
The numbers of deaths occurring in to years , as recorded by Mr. MORGAN , might have been made the foundation of a very valuable determination of the mortality occurring in a certain class of persons , if the number of the Equitable Society had become stationary before the commencement of the record : but in order to deduce from it a just estimate of the value of life , it would then be necessary to alter the numbers of deaths at each age , in the inverse proportion of the numbers of the living compared : that is to say , not simply of the sums of the persons admitted under that age , but of the numbers of persons born whom they represent : since , in comparing the joint mortalities of any two lists of persons , we must obviously add together the deaths belonging , not to a given number of persons of various ages , but of a number proportionate to the survivors at the respective ages out of a given number of births , so that in this manner the apparent mortality in the earlier portions of the register would require to be augmented , not only on account of the smaller number of persons who have actually contributed to furnish it , but also on account of the greater proportion that these persons bear to the corresponding number at birth , when compared with the survivors at more advanced ages , who represent a population still more exceeding their own numbers .
On the other hand , since the register in question relates only to a limited number of years , immediately following a very rapid increase of the Society , it is evident that the deaths must have occurred at earlier ages than if it had been continued until all the lives had dropped .
Of these three modifications , it may be sufficiently accurate for the present purpose to omit the two latter as nearly counterbalancing each other , and to augment the earlier numbers in the proportion only of the members of the Society to whom they must necessarily have belonged , supposing that the admissions had taken place about the same ages at all periods assuming also the number of survivors at 45 to be in the same proportion to the births as in the Carlisle table .
We may then proceed to take a mean between the mortality thus obtained , with proper interpolations , and the observations at Carlisle , as the second of the three principal bases to be afterwards incorporated with the mortality of Northampton and of London .
Further than this , it is impossible to place any great reliance on Mr. MORGANS document , which makes the annual deaths , in " s a population exceeding ioooo , " not quite 1 in 1500 .
Of the mortality of London , taken for the ten years from i8ii to 1820 , it may be observed , that its results bear the internal evidence of greater apparent correctness than either of the other bases , exhibiting a curve less irregular in its flexures , and generally intermediate between the others it has also the advantage of exhibitingthe duration of life as prolonged by the general introduction of vaccination : and when thus incorporated with the registers of two places in the country , each reduced to an equal supposed population , it must probably be sufficiently corrected for the errors that may be attributed to the effect of an afflux of settlers at an early age .
The mean obtained in this manner might be employed at once as a standard table without much inconvenience , but it still exhibits some minute but obvious irregularities , as an inspection of the line of stars in the diagram will show , principally perhaps from the want of skill or care with which the interpolations have been made-by Dr. PRICE and others .
The most effectual of all interpolations for harmonising the various orders of differences , is to obtain a formula which shall extend with sufficient accuracy throughout the whole curve .
It may be easily believed that it must be extremely difficult to find such an expression ; and that its form must be too complicated to be applied to any practical purpose throughout its extent .
I have however drawn a curve which comes extremely near to the line of stars , and crosses it in io or 12different points , by means of the equation y=368 +lox .
1oX-1.(156+ 2Ox-Xx ) +6 285 +2 0o5 x x+z(j -55 '(X ) +4 X\20 5 ( 00 l ) : Y being the number of deaths among 0ooooo persons , in the year that completes the age x. The terms of this formula have some remarkable relations to the different periods of life .
HALLEY'S first approximation was y =ooo , throughout life .
DEMOIVRE 's arithmetical hy10000o prsn pothesis was y.- . ?
1 ? ?
1163 : but of the present formula the principal foundation , as extending to the whole of life , is , y =368 + lo x. In infancy the term containing the reciprocal of the powers of x has a preponderating value : in youth , the term ( 156 + 20 X xx)2 , which diminishes the mortality , ends somewhat abruptly at 2 , and would be incapable of being employed with safety in algebraical calculations , from its having a negative as well as a positive value .
Old age is expressed almost exclusively by the high powers at the end of the formula , which terminate the series with great and increasing rapidity .
It is obvious that for many purposes of calculation , the terms belonging to youth and to old age might be neglected without inconvenience , and that , for the middle portion of life , the terms 368 + lo alone , with some little modification , night be employed as sufficiently correct ; or certainly as much nearer to the truth than either the arithmetical or geometrical hypothesis of DEMOIVRE .
The relations of the different parts of the formula will be best appreciated from their developement in the following tables .
DOCUMENTS .
Deaths among persons assured by the Equitable Society , for 20 years , from l8Qo to 1821.-Morgan on Assurances , 182i , p. s25 .
Age .
Deaths .
Assured .
Deaths cor .
Interpolations .
10 tO 20 7 1494 25 1 514 .
63I 630 20 to 30 37 8996 z75 566 636 630 3 ?
0 to40 166 33850 299 6o6 646 63o 40 tO 50 299 45429 630 323 6i6 655 630 50 to 60 458 36489 649 347 6I8 663 630 6o to 70 536 19042 604 37 1 6zo 665 70 to 80 345 r 359 395.6zz 663 above 8o 82 454 82 419 624 657 I_ 440 6z6 644 151754 470 6z8 630 ( 820 ) 3590 6040 649Q 20090 Carlisle 45070 Mortality of London from 1811 to-1820.-Gent .
Mag. Between 0 &amp; 2 2 &amp; 5 5 &amp; 10 10 &amp; 2020 &amp; 3030 &amp; 40 0 &amp; 5050 &amp; 6060 &amp; 7070 &amp; 8080 &amp; 9090 &amp; 100 100 101 102 103 104 105 108 109 111 113 I8II 5Io6 1638 654 509 1231 1641 1741 1591 1385 1038| 449 56 I8i2 5636 I907 6 ; ; 6zo I226 '68 ; 184 .
1543 1425 1193| 492 71 00I I813 5167 1733 604 5z6 xio8 1501 1751 16o6 19 1211 489 6I III02 i8I4 5845 2038 77o 649 i268 i678 1950 i8io 1747 1343 592 88 III00I0I I8I ; 5200 I9I6 870 677 i425 i824 .
2075 I886 i6zi 122i 674j I67 2I01 18i6 S400 I960 845 675 | 464 1912 2123 1955 1720 1308 78I I68 300I| 18I7 5698 2019 929 706 1364 1795 I983 1788 I6I4 1224 683 156 7000 0 ? ?
2 I818 538I I8I5 808 703 1453 1884 2040 I864 .
i585 1271 722 175 III000I I819 4779 1771 8z6 631 1577 1990 2095 I9I8 i6oo 1230 666 144 000I i8zo 4758 1975 887 667 1484 zoo6| 2069 I878 1632 izo8 66z 119 52970 18772 7848 363 13600 179i6 L9668 17839 15888 1224762i0 | i6 55 f4 |222| ( 39 ) 190565 Interpolations , Age , Deaths .
Age .
Deaths .
Age .
Deaths .
Age .
Deaths .
Age .
Deaths .
Age .
Deaths .
03 2970 -20 710 4 ?
0 I85 6o 1 62z 8o 529 xoo16 I 20000 21 ~~~770 4 !
1885 6x 81 768 101 -S52970 ; 22 g960 42 192 5 6z I 607 872 71$8 102 52 8500 ; 23 I i6o 43 1963 63 x6oo 83 678 103 43 6ooo 24 i46o 44 1990 64 1592 84 638i 104 2 44272 25 I 68o 45 zo2o 65 1585 85 5 105 2 .
, I- ... ..1877z z6 1700 46 2020 66 1577 86 556 'o6 I5 2800 27 1710 47 2020 67 1570 87 516 I07 6 i800 , z8 1720 48 zo2o 68 1563 88 475 lo8 i7 1400 29 1730 49 1990 69 1557 89 435 log J 1008.-i436oo 1i9668 1588 -67 i9 84o 30 1741 50 1959 70 Isso 90 380 110 I 7848 31 1752 5 !
I920 71 I478 9I 290 III 0 1o 740 32 1763 52 i88o 72 1405 92 I80 I 12 oII 66o 33 1774 53 1840 73 1333 93 9gc 113 0 12 6i5 34 1786 54 18o74 126[ 9+ 70 I3 605 35 1798 55 1760 75 1 188 95 57 14 6oo 36 I 809 56 1720 76 Iii6 96 48 IS 603 37 18zo 57 i6So 77 1044 97 40 I6 6io 38 I831 58 I650 78 972 98 30 17 62o 39 1842 59 I63 79 900 99 20 I8 64 , 1-1 7916 7839 12247 -1205 9 670 _6363 Comparative Decrements from various Tables .
Age .
North .
Carligi .
Equitable Mean of Carlisle London General Living .
ampton .
Office Red .
and Eq. Office .
Bills .
Mean .
0 2575 !
15390 17301 1948I 99124 1I I734 682o 10493 9682 79643 2 4309 5050 4460 4606 69961 3 2876 2760 3148 2928 65355 4 169I 20IO 2242 198 !
623Z7 5 1579 1210 II469 I419 60346 1202 82o 94S 989 58927 7 944 580 725 750 S7938 8 687 430 529 549 57188 9 5I 5 330 441 429 565+49 IC 446 290 389 375 56izo 11 429 310 346 362 55745 12 429 320 323 357 55383 13 429 330 318 359 SSo26 14 429 350 315 365 54667 Comparative Decrements from various Tables .
Age .
NorthCarlisle , Equitable Mean oiCarlisle London General Living .
ampton .
Office Red , and Equi .
Office .
Bills .
Mean .
Is 429 390 317 379 54302 i6 45 420 320 398 53923 17 497 430 325 417 53525 x 541 4-30 33S 435 53io8 19 57S 430 352 452 52673 20 6-i8 430 37 473 5222 zi 644 420 404 489 51748 22 644 420 -503 522 : 51259 23 644 420 6o8 S57 50737 24 644 420 766 6I0 50I8Q 2s 644 430 88z 65Z 49570 z6 644 430 89 2 655 489I8 27 644 45O 897 664 48263 8 644 .
500 90 68z 47599 29 644 56o 907 704 46917 30 644 570 913 709 46213 31 644 570 919 711 45504 32 644 56o __ 925 710 44793 33 64 550 931 708 44083 34 64+ 550 937 710 43375 35 644 550 943 712 42665 36 644 56o 950 718 41953 37 644 570 955 723 41235 38 644 580 961 728 40512 39 644 6io 967 740 39784 40 6g 66o 974 762 39044 41 66x -69o 990 780 38282 42669 710 1010 796 37502 43 669 710 1030 803 36706 4+ 669 710 1044 8o8 35903 45669 700 1346 ( 765 ) 1055 830 35095 46 669 69o 1346 ( 821 ) 1059 850 34265 47 669 670 1346 ( 873 ) 1059 867 33415 48 L 669 630 I6 ( 916 ) 1055 880 32548 49 678 610o 1346 978 1044 900 31668 5o695 590 1346 968 1028 897 30768 1 704 6ZO 1375 997 1007 903 29871 52 704 6XO 1404 1Q27 987 906 28968 53 -704 68o 0 416 1048 966 9o6 28o6 ; 54 74 700 142I1 1o6o 945 903 Z7156 55 704 70 1416 1073 924 goo 26253 g6 704 76o 1399 902 894 25353 57 704 820 1381 * , * 881 895 24459 58 704 930 1359 866 904 23564 59 704 io6o 1348 856 921 22066o Comparative Decrements frm various Tables .
Age. .
NorthCarlisle .
Equitable Mean of Carlisle London General Living .
ampton .
Office Red .
and Equit .
Office .
Bills .
Mean .
6o 704 I1220 1342 -851 94521739 6i 704 iz6o 1338 ... .
848 950 20794 62 695 1270 13 33 844 94+8 19844 63 695 1250 1329. .
840 941 18996 64 687 I250 1325 ... .
836 936 18055 65 687 1240 I321 ... .
832 936 17119 66 -687 13 0 1317 828 929 168 67 67 23 125824 925 15254 68 687 1230 1210 819 909 14329 69 687 I240 1098..8I7 889 13420 70 687 1240 1005 813874 12531 71 687 1340 940 ... .
776 867 11657 72 687 1460 895 ... .
738 868 10790 73 687 I56o -844 700 863 9922 74 687 i66o 792 ... .
66i 858 9059 75 687 16oo 742 623 839 8201 76 66i i ; 6o 690 58 790 7362 77 627 1460 639 ... .
548 741 657-2 78 , 584+ 1320 587 ... .
510 683 5831 79 548 1280 536 472 643 S148 8o 541i ii6o 480 ... .
435 599 4505 81 515 1120 440 402 549 3906 82 489 1020 300 376 508 3357 83 472 ~940 20356 466 2849 84 412 840 100 335 406 2383 8S 35 !
780 6o ... 313 361 1977 86 291 710 40 292 319 x6x6 87 241 640 30 ... .
271 284 1:297 88 x8o 510 20 25 !
3 11 89 137 390 10 ... .
230 I90 779 90 103 370 8 ... .
199 164 589 91 86 300 7 ... .
152 130 425 ' 92 ~69 210 7 ... .
94 87 295 93 6o 140 647 60 94 43 100 6 ... .
37 44 148 95 26 70 5 30 3 104 96 9 50 5 25 19 73 97 0 40 5 21 14 54 98'. .
30 4 ... .
6 940 99. .
20 4. .
10 6 3 !
Comparative Decrements from various Tables .
Age .
NorthCarlisle .
Equitable Mean of Carlisle London General Living .
ampton , Office Red .
and Eq. Office .
Bills .
Mean .
100. .
20 486 25 101 20 33 ... 5 19 102 .
20 3351+ 103 .
20 2249 104 .
- .
10 z 1[ ] 25 I05 3 .
0I11 107 ... .,..25 ( 1.oo 076 * ... o.z ( .2 .
' ... * z.75 Io8 ... ... ... . .
5.25 1.50 10 ... ..5 .
5 1.25 110 ... 5 25 1.00 I II 0 25 Decrements of Mortality mputedfom the Formula Age 368 -.1(156+32 + IV ) ( Decrement .
( x-I ) + I0o x x ) 2.85+2.05 xx 0 15 528 359 178 .
347 IS 538 313 iS6 381 17 548 29 I 136 393 i8 558 25 5 119 42z 19 568 2I4 104 458 20 578 174 93 .
, .
497 21 588 130 8z2 540 22 598 89 7258 23 6o8 51 64 6zI 24 6I8 19 57 O'a 656 25 6z8 s -0 678 26 638 44 68z 27 648 39 687 28 6S8 .
34 ... .
, 692 29 668 9O0 30 698 30 678 , 27 705 31 688 224 72 32 698 21 719 33 708 *8 726 34 -78.6 734 35 728 14 ... ... 742 36 738 1 3.O ' 19 9 751 37 748 ii I 759 38 758 8o** * ?
IO +10 768 39 768 9.6 776 40 778 , 8 W7 785 41 788 , .
, 9 795 42 798 872 804 43 8o8 , ecc 6 I.5 813 44 8I8 5 1.9 821 45 8z8 5to &gt; S 2.3 831 46 838 4 3.0 839 47 848 4 3*9 848 48 858 Decrements of Mortality computed from the Formula .
Age 368 ' +lo oi5.5(# )IO7 50 Decrement .
( x-I ) + lox 7+285+2.05 x x+(Th ) 5.-5( 2o01(o 50 55 92z8 2 17 ... ..913 56 938 1 20 ... 9'7 57 948 1 24 ... 923 S8 958 1 28 ... .929 59 968 133 se*934 .
6o 978 '3 + 0 ... .
938 6i 988 396'. .
4 62 998 551. .
4 63 ico8 I64 I. .
944 64 ioi8 I75 ' 943 65 1o28 ... .-88 2 ... 942 66 1038 102 3 ... .
939 67 1048 119 4 ... 933 68 lo58 137 5 ... .
926 69 lo68 159 6 ... .
915 70 1078 ... .183 8 ... 903 71 io88 ... .211 11 ... .
888 72 1098 ... .242 15 ... .
871 73 iio8 ... .277 19 ... 8so 74 mi8 317 25 ... 826 75 iiz8 359 32 ... .
8oi 76 1138 4242 ... .
768 77 1148 ... .470 55 ... .
733 78 ii58.4..532 71 0o 697 79 i68 ... .604 91I654 So 1178..684 117 16io 8i ii88.000772 145 2 559 82 1198 ... .872 Ig90 3 513 83 1208.*..984 242 6 460 8+ 128 ... ..iio8 307 9 408 85 1228 ... .124-3 386 14 357 86 1238..1399 490 22 307 87 17248 ... .1567 61 I , 7 25 8 88 i7.58 ... ... ~1756 771 52 215 88 iz58 ... .1963 96386 178 90 1278 ~ ~ ... ..21972 1201 I39 148 91 1288 2441493 212 125 92 128 273 849 333 101 93 1308 3032 2300 496 8o 94 1318 ... .3371 2840 734 53 95 1328 ... .3744 3504 1041 27 ( 96 1338 ... .4150 4306 1746 0\97 1348.98 1358 99 1368 1oo ) 1378 MEAN STANDARD TABLE OF THE DECREMENTS OF LIFE IN GREAT BRITAIN , 18244 Age .
Decrement .
Living .
Age .
Decrement .
LVving .
Age .
Decrement , Living .
Age , Decrement .
Living .
0 20531 100003 30 705 46527 6o 938 zi8io 90 I64 589 I 9I06 79472 31 712 45822 6i 942 20872 91 130 425 2 4780 70366 32 719 45IIO 62 943 19930 92 87 295 3 2854 65586 33 726 4439I 63 944 I8987 93 6o 208 4 i88o 62732 34 734 43665 64 943 18043 94 44 I 48 5 1342 6o852 35 742 4293 I 65 942 17100 95 31 104 6 979 59511 36 751 42i89 66 9 i6iS8 96 19 73 7 752 58532 37 759 41438 67 933 15219 97 14 54 8 603 57780 38 768 40679 68 926 24z86 98 9 40 9 494 57177 39 776 3991i 69 9I5 13360 99 6 31 0 423 56683 40 785 39135 70 903 12445 100 6 25 12 377 S6z6o 4I 795 38350 71 888 11542 10 5 29 12 349 55883 42 804 3755 72 871 20654 102 ? ?
14 13 337 55534 43813 3675I 73 850 9783 203 49 14 337 , 55197 44 82I 35938 74 8z6 8933 104 25 I5 347 54860 45 83I 35127 75 8oI 8107 105 .
3i6 38I 54513 46 8-39 34286 76 768 7306 io6.25 2 27 393 54I32 47 848 33447 77 733 6538 107.25 1,75 i8 422 53739 48 857 32599 78 697 5805 io8.25 2.50 29 458 533I7 49 866 31742 79 654 5108 lO9.25 1 , ,25 20 497 52859 S 874 30876 8o 6io 4454 120.25 2.0 22 540 52362 52 88z 30002 8i 559 3844 III.25.75 22 58i 51822 52 890 29I20 82 513 3285 I12.25.50 23 6zI 51241 53 898 28230 83 460 2772 113,25 .
5 24 656 5o62o 54 9o6 27332 84 408 2312 I14 00 2S 678 49964 55 9I3 26426 8S 357 1904 26 682 49286 S6 917 255I3 86 307 1547 27 687 48604 57 923 24596 87 258 2240 28 692 479I7 58 929 23673 88 215 982 29 698 47225 59 934 22744 89 -78 767 ~~~~~~~U I__ ___ __ ___ I shall take this opportunity of endeavouring to demonstrate , in a simple and undeniable manner , the error into which Dr. PRICE and his followers have fallen , in consequence , as it appears , of their adopting the legal restraints on usury as essential steps in the mathematical calculation of the amount of compound interest .
The error has indeed of late years been very commonly admitted ; but its effects have not been so satisfactorily rectified as could be desired .
In the 66th volume of the Philosophical Transactions , for the year 1776 , we find a Paper of Dr. PRicE , in which he lays down these theorems , r denoting the interest of Li .
for a year , and n the term or number of years during which any annuity will be paid , p the perpetuity , or I , y the value of an r annuity paid yearly , and h half yearly : then , I , y=p r(+ a ) " ; and , II , h -ps_ : and as examples taking r.=04 , r(z +Lf and n= , we havey4,.4,58 , andp=4.4913 .
Now , if we analyse the results thus obtained , by dividing them into the present values of the separate payments , : they will stand thus : I. Present value of Li .
payable at the end of } ? ?
658 1 year.~ 92 years.924556 3 years.888996 4 years.854804 s years.821927 4.451821 II .
Present value of 1o shillings , payable at the L 4902 end of half a year5 1 year.48058 1 -2.47127 2.461992 2L 2 *528 6.4528 3 _.44398 3j .
-.43528 4 -.42674 41 _ _.41837 5_ _.41018 4.49138 The present values of io shillings are therefore assumed ; I , at i year.48077 ; II,.48058 2 years.46228,46X92 3 years.44450.44398 4 years.42740 *42674 b years.41o96.41018 The latter column exhibiting obviously a larger deduction for discount than the former ; so that the rate of interest in the two calculations is by no means the same : although in the case of r.o0 , they would respectively represent the highest rate of interest allowed by our laws to be received without a new investment or engagement : but this arbitrary restraint ought certainly not to affect the mathematical consideration of the , question .
The difficulty , if any person thinks it such , may be avoided by a mode of investigation which I have lately had occasion to point out .
" c An annuity , of which a payment is due on a given day , is more valuable than an annuity purchased on that day , andto commence a year after , by the amount of a year 's payment : and the value of a life annuity , becoming payable at any intermediate time between the day of purchase and its first anniversary , will be greater than the simple tabular value of the annuity by a sum proportional to the anticzpation of the payment ; " the increase of the value being very nearly uniform , when we supposethe anticipation to bee gradually increased:this increase of the value comprehending obviously the greater probability as well as the greater proximity of each payment , and proceeding from day to day by very nearly equal increments .
Thus , if we wished to purchase an annuity of Lioo .
a year , and its value were ?
iooo .
, upon the ordinary supposition of the payments commencing after the end of a year ; supposing that we desired to have the first payment made at the end of nine months , and the subsequent payments at annual intervals as usual , we should have to add ?
25 to the purchase money , making it ?
1025 .
at whatever rate of interest the value might have been computed .
If we began at six months , ?
5o .
, and if at three months , ? ?
75 .
must be ' added to the purchase : it being obvious that an additional ?
ioo .
would be equivalent to an anticipation of twelve months , or to an immediate payment of a year 's annuity .
From this simple and incontestable principle , in which the second differences only are neglected , it is very easy to deduce the values of annuities , payable at intervals shorter than a year .
An annuity of i , payable half yearly , is equal to two annuities of the one beginning as usual at the end of the year , the other anticipated by half a year ; and the value of this portion is greater than the other by half of one of the payments , that is , by o : SO that " We may always find the value of a life annuity payable half yearly , by adding a quarter of a year to the tabular value of the same annuity .
" In a similar manner it is very easily shown , that " for quarterly payments , we must add -8 of a year 's value to the comput ation made on the supposition of annual payments ; " and " the continual bisection of the interval would at last afford as the addition of half a yearly payment for the value of a daily or hourly payment of a proportional part of the given annuity .
' " It may also be observed , that when we reckon at s per cent. interest , an annuity payable half yearly is the same , throughout the middle of life , that would be granted on the life of a person a year older , if payable annually .
" If it is required to ascertain the value of a reversionary annuity payable half yearly or quarterly , the calculation becomes in appearance a little paradoxical for since the true value of a reversionary annuity for the life of one person , for example , after the death of another , is the difference between the values of two annuities on the single life and the joint lives , and since an equal addition must be made to these values in consideration of the period of payment being shortened , it follows that the reversionary annuity must be of equal value in either form .
This conclusion would indeed be strictly true if the periodical times of payment remained unaltered according to the supposition from which the value of the annuities is deduced ; while in fact it is usual to grant such an annuity to commence at the first quarterly , half yearly , or annual period after the contingent event : a variation which would have no sensible effect in the case of daily payments , but which lessens the value of reversionary annuities at other periods byT that of half a payment for the given period , reduced to the present time in the same manner as any other sum assured as payable upon the same contingency of survivorship .
The simplicity observable in the progression of the values of annuities , calculated according to the values of lives here supposed , and at 3 per cent. interest , leads us to inquire what would be the exact law of mortality required to make that progression strictly uniform throughout life ; and it will appear on investigation , that in order to have the value 24.45 - .
x , x being the age of the person , which is nearly true between 2o and 70 , the annual mortality must be expressed by.03 +.066 : a fraction which at 2o becomes 1 .
at 40 , 2 ... at 100.8 x 48 ' 60 , o- , and at So , 2-4 .
Our table gives respectively - , .
; 2:2 8.4 .
O'T and 2- .
the a and Mr. FIN3 7-3 Nrhmtn-p7I ' 7.4 LAISON'S male annuitants 8 ' ' , and 8 The healthiness 87 ' 73'38 .
of Mr. FINLAISON 's annuitants about 4o and 5o is one of the most remarkable features of his table : he observes ( p. 58 ) , that out of io , ooo persons at 23 , 141 will die in a year , and 141 will die out of the same number at the age of 48 ; but at the age of 34 there will only die 124 .
The curve marked by obelisks , + , in the diagram , will show the comparative progress of mortality in this system ; which , however valuable the data may be , appears to exhibit too many novelties , if not anomalies , to be generally adopted with confidence : while the line of crosses , X , representing the tontine of DEPARciEux , will serve to show how little difference the lapse of a century has made in the results of these two similar cases .
I shall conclude , my dear Sir , with a comparison of the climacteric years , as they may be called without impropriety , in which the greatest numbers of adults die , as taken from different tables .
I sincerely hope that these considerations may help to undeceive the too credulous public , who have of late not only received some hints that tend to insinuate the probability of an occasional recurrence of a patriarchal longevity , but who have been required to believe , upon the authority of a most respectable mathematician , that the true and unerring value of life is not to be , obtained by taking an average of various decrements , but by adopting the extreme of all conceivable estimates , founded only on a hasty assertion of Mr. MORGAN , and unsupported by any detailed report ; an estimate which makes the grand climacteric of mankind in this country , not a paltry fifty four , or the too much dreaded sixty three ; but no less than EIGHTY TWO !
An age to which nearly one sixth of the survivors at ten are supposed to attain !
Climacterics , or greatest Decrements .
Berlin , formerly ... .
38 Breslau , 1695 .
6i Montpellier , 1782 ... 67 Deparcieux ... ... . .
73 London , about 1733 .
4oFormula ... ... ... 63 Duvillard , France ... 67 Carlisle ... ... ... .
74 Paris , formerly ... . .
40 Brandenburg ... ... .
65 Sweden , 1762 ... ... .
6.8 Ackworth , 1752 ... 75 Stockholm , 1762 ... .
42 Warrington , 1777. .
65 Chester , 1776 ... ... 68 Kersseboom. .
77 London , 1764 ... ... 43 Norwich , 176S .
66 Sweden , 1785..69 Finlaison. .
78 London , I8I5 ... ... 46 Holycross , 1760 ... .
70 E. 0 .
Mr. B.'* 8z Northampton , 1757 .
56 Believe me , dear Sir , Your faithful and obedient Servant , THOMAS YOUNG .
Park Square , 28 Feb. i826 .

