On the Nerves of the Face ; being a second paper on that subject .
By CHARLES BELL , Esq. Fellow of the Royal Society .
Read May 28 , 1829 .
I HAVE to beg the indulgence of the Society to some minute details of anatomy , for the sake of those deductions which can be attained by no other means : and that a zeal for its cultivation may be preserved among us .
There is an obvious practical benefit derived from anatomy , but the public do not comprehend its importance as a science .
It is to the Royal Society that those who prosecute this science must look for countenance in their slow and painful investigations .
Nine years ago , at the request of our late President , I submitted to the Society a paper on the Nervous System ; in which I arranged the nerves strictly according to the anatomy , and illustrated the principles of the arrangement , by exhibiting the different functions of the Nerves of the Face .
On presenting a second paper on the same part of the nervous system after so considerable a lapse of time , there will be some novelty both in the facts and in the illustrations ; yet I have more gratification in showing that after the most minute inquiries in different countries , my positions drawn from the anatomy have been admitted , and my reasoning on the experiments , with oiTe exception , found to be correct .
Confident in the accuracy of my deductions from the anatomy of the fifth nerve , I had attributed to one of its branches a function which belongs to another branch of the same nerve .
The subject will form a part of the present paper .
After the announcement of the facts in my first paper , the inquiry became interesting from its application to medical practice .
I must take another opportunity of thanking those gentlemen who have so liberally afforded additional proofs of the truth of my principles .
I must restrict myself in referring to them here , since I am desirous that the Society 's Transactions should contain only the philosophical part of the inquiry .
The system of WILLIS , of which we have an elegant account in the posthumous works of Dr. BAILLIE , prevailed universally in the schools when I entered on these inquiries .
In opposition to that system I demonstrated that the nerves hitherto supposed to possess the same powers , consisted of filaments having different roots , and performing different functions .
I found myself eminbarked in this investigation , from observing the course which the nerves took in their distribution through the body .
Conceiving that the devious course and reunion of the nerves were for a purpose , I sought in their origins for the cause of their seeming irregularity .
It was discovered that the roots of the nerves arose from distinct columns of nervous matter , and that on these columns depended their different properties .
Those which were called the common nerves , that is , the nerves which arise from the spinal marrow , thirty in number , were found to consist each of two nerves derived from distinct columns , one for sensation and one for motion .
In the further pursuit of this subject , there was reason to conclude that the spinal marrow contained not only the columns for bestowing sensation and motion , but also another column , the office of which was to combine the actions of respiration .
I then drew the attention of the Society to the course of the fifth nerve of the brain according to WILLIS .
I showed that it had the same double root as the spinal nerves , that it had a ganglion , and that part of the nerve passed free of the ganglion ; and that from all these points of resemblance , it was to be considered as the anterior or superior of the spinal nerves , of that system which is called symmetrical , and which ministers to the same functions in all classes of animals , bestowing sensibility and the locomotive powers , but deficient in those filaments which command the respiratory motions .
I am particular in restating this , because from time to time it has been reported that I had abandoned my original opinions ; whereas every thing has tended to confirm them .
From the general view of the nervous system , I drew attention to the superadded or irregular nerves .
Having shown that the original or symmetrical system of nerves , of which the fifth was one , had no power over the motions of respiration , and that the human countenance in all its motions , with the exception of mastication , bore relation to the actions of respiration , it was 318 therefore required that another nerve besides the fifth , should be sent to the face .
Having shown also that the roots of the fifth nerve were distant from that column of nervous matter which gives origin to the nerves of the respiratory system , and that it could not therefore minister to the motions of the face which are connected with respiration ; and that another nerve , the portio dura , having its root in common with the nerves of respiration , took its course to the face , the subject was prepared for experiment .
By experiments on the nerves of the face these three things were proved : First , that the sensibility of the head and face depended on the fifth pair of nerves .
Secondly , that the muscular branches of the fifth were for mastication : and in the Third place , it was proved that the portio dura of the seventh , or respiratory nerve of the face , controlled the motions of the features , performing ; all those motions , voluntary or involuntary , which are necessarily connected with respiration ; -such as breathing , sucking , swallowing , and speaking , with all the varieties of expression .
Reserving the details , I shall now state shortly the occurrences which I have witnessed since the publication of that paper ; as they afford convincing proofs of the correctness of these opinions .
The first instance was in a man shot with a pistol ball , which entered the ear and tore across the portio dura at its root .
All motion on the same side of the face from that time ceased ; but he continued in possession of the sensibility of the integuments of that side of the face .
The next instance was in a man wounded by the horn of an ox .
The point of the horn entered under the angle of the jaw and came out before the ear , tearing across the portio dura .
He remains now a singular proof of the effects of the loss of function in the muscles of the face by this nerve being divided .
The forehead of the corresponding side is without motion , the eyelids remain open , the nostril has no motion in breathing , and the mouth is drawn to the opposite side .
The muscles of the face by long disuse are degenerated , and the integuments of the wounded side of the face are become like a membrane stretched over the skull .
They have lost their firmness , and the flesh under them is wasted , with the exception of certain muscles , the reason of which will be understood on perusing the anatomical description in the present paper .
In this man the sensibility of the face is perfect .
The same nerve ( portio dura ) 319 has been divided in the extirpation of a tumour from before the ear , and the immediate effect has been horrible distortion of the face by the prevalence of the muscles of the opposite side , but without the loss of sensibility ; and that distortion is unhappily increased when a pleasurable emotion should be reflected in the countenance .
These facts are so distinct , that I cannot presume to detain the Society with the instances of the lesser defects which I have witnessed from the more partial injuries or temporary diseases of the nerve ; -such as distortion of the features produced by glands pressing on this nerve , paralysis from suppurations in the ear affecting the nerve in its passage , or temporary derangement disturbing one or more of its functions .
As to the fifth nerve , the facts are equally impressive , and correspond with our former experiments and opinions .
By a small sacculated tumour affecting the roots of this nerve , the sensibility was destroyed in all the parts supplied by its widely extended branches ; that is , in all the side of the head and face and the side of the tongue , whilst the motion of the face remained .
Two circumstances affecting this nerve have occurred with most curious coincidence in the symptoms .
By the drawing of a tooth from the lower jaw , the nerve which comes out upon the chin to supply one half of the lip was injured , and exactly this half of the lip was rendered insensible .
When the patient put his mouth to a tumbler he thought they had given him a broken glass !
Precisely the same thing occurred from the division of that branch of the fifth nerve , which goes to one half of the upper lip .
A gentleman falling , a sharp point entered his cheek and divided the infra orbitary nerve : the effect was loss of sensation without loss of motion , in that half of the upper lip to which the nerve is distributed .
The remarkable circumstance was , that this individual made the same remark when the cup was put to his lip:-that they had given him a broken one !
The part of the cup which was placed in contact with the insensible portion of the lip appeared to him to be broken off .
I have had two or three instances before me of disease affecting the ophthalmic branch of the fifth nerve , and producing total insensibility of the eye and eyelids , without loss of vision ; whilst the eyelids continued to be closed and the eyebrow to be moved by the influence of the portio dura of the seventh nerve .
320 Such are a few of the facts which have been reaped from a patient reliance on the correctness of my first deductions , and I would now urge them in proof of the importance of reasoning upon the anatomy .
All these nerves have been irepeatedly divided , by almost every surgeon of eminence in the three kingdoms .
Although some have performed the operation of dividing the nerves frequently , and one eminent gentleman had done it six times on the face of the same man , all these operations have been performed without giving rise to the suspicion that these nerves bestowed different properties .
Even now , so slow is the progress of improvement , it is stated by a surgeon that he will not hesitate to cut the portio dura in the case of tic douloureux .
My duty is performed when I give publicity to the facts which prove that horrible distortion of the whole coulntenance , the loss of distinct articulation , the loss of expression , the loss of motion of the eyelids , and consequent inflammation of the eye , must follow such an operation .
Much has been said in favour of experiments when made by men who are positively without any expectation of the result , or , as they affirm , are unbiased .
The only instances of this that I can allow , are when the surgeon cuts the nerves of the face in a surgical operation .
In such operations as these for tic douloureux , he is indeed unbiased ; and we have seen the result , that after fifty years of such experience we remained quite ignorant of the distinctions in these nerves .
But on the other hand when attention is roused to inquiry by aantomy , facts are obtained of the utmost importance both to the knowledge of disease and to the safe practice of surgery .
Of the Motor or Manducatory portion of the Fifth Nerve .
The fifth nerve is usually called Trigeminus , from piercing the skull in three grand divisions .
But when it has been shown that it is composed of two distincet roots having different functions , the accidental circumstance of its divisions passing through the bones yields in importance to another inquiry , How is the muscular portion of the nerve distributed ?
Since the publication of my first paper this inquiry has assumed importance ; althlough the principal facts of the anatomy were known to WRISBERG , SAN TORINI , PALETTA , PROCHASKA , and ScEMMERRING .
But in no author is the ana tomy of the motor portion of the nerve traced with sufficient minuteness , or regard to the distinct uses of the muscular and sensitive divisions .
The motor division of the fifth nerve passes under the Gasserian ganglion , and free of it .
It is not seen when we look from above , as in the plates of MONRO .
When the nerve is turned up and dissected , this portion is seen to form about a fifth part of the whole nerve .
It is tied to the larger portion before advancing to the ganglion , by filaments which have been sometimes taken for nerves .
Having passed the ganglion , it attaches itself slightly to the superior maxillary nerve , but this is apparently a membranous connection only* .
The nerve itself joins the third grand division after passing the foramen ovale .
At this point the muscular and sensitive portions of the nerves are matted together , and form a mass which between the fingers feels like a knot+ .
There is , however , no red and fleshy-like matter interposed here , as in the Gasserian ganglion of the trunk of the nerve .
But the filaments of both portions of the nerve are here so complexly and intimately combined , that all the branches which go off after this union are compound nerves , and have motor filaments in their composition .
It is , however , equally obvious that the gustatory division of the nerve which descends from this mass , has not the muscular portion given to it in that abundance which those branches have which take their course to the muscles of the jaws .
The mandibulo-labralis , which also descends from this plexus , lies nearer the motor portion , and has a more distinct addition given to it than the gustatory nerve .
This motor or muscular portion which we are tracing , sends off no branch either in its course under the great ganglion , or after passing it about half an inch .
But when it has arrived at the point of union with the ganglionic portion , the filaments become interwoven ; and from this place the nerves are compound , and go off diverging to their destinations .
First , there are sent off nerves to the temporal , masseter , and pterygoid , muscles , also to the buccinator muscle .
The temporal muscle receives a large and appropriate nerve .
The nerve to the masseter passes between the coronoid and condyloid processes of the lower jawbone ; but before going into the muscle it sends branches to the temporal muscle .
The pterygoid muscles have each their appropriate nerves coming direct from this plexus .
Ramus Buccinalis Labialis .
This is a remarkable branch which arises from the same source , and goes to the cheek and lips .
This nerve where it lies on the external pterygoid muscle sends one more branch to the temporal muscle ; it then divides , one branch enters the buccinator muscle , and another is prolonged forwards .
The division to the buccinator muscle is tortuous , which is no doubt a provision for its being undisturbed by the free motion of the cheek ; its minute branches may be traced until lost among the muscular fibres , whilst others penetrate to the lining of the cheek .
The prolonged branch is the labial division ; it runs nearer the alveolar processes of the lower jaw , and becomes so superficial as to admit a union with the portio dura : from thence passing under the facial artery it may be traced into the triangularis or depressor anguli oris , the levator labiorum communis , and the lateral portion of the orbicularis oris .
In the distribution of the buccinalis labialis to the muscles of the mouth , it is joined , as I have said , by branches of the portio dura ; and nothing is more striking than the manner in which this latter nerve passes over the masseter , a muscle of the jaw , to be profusely given to the muscles of the lips .
There is one more branch important to the physiology of the fifth nerve .
At the root of the mandibulo-labralis ( where it is sent off from the junction of the muscular and ganglionic portions ) , a small nerve takes its origin .
This branch runs parallel to the greater nerve till it enters the foramen in the lower jaw ; here it seems to enter , but does not ; it takes a course on the inside of the jaw to arrive at its final destination , the mylo-hyoideus and the anterior belly of the digastricus , that is , to those muscles which open the mouth by drawing down the jaw .
2T2 323 We may for a moment interrupt our particular inquiry , to notice that all muscular nerves , and consequently the muscular divisions of the fifth nerve , form a plexus .
The plexus , formed by the motor and ganglionic divisions of the fifth nerve before they diverge to the muscles of the lower jaw , corresponds with the plexus formed on the nerves sent to other classes of muscles .
Even that branch of the third division of the fifth nerve which comes out before the ear , joins the portio dura in a plexus* ; and this is the reason of that sensibility evinced in the facial nerve in making experiments upon it .
The form of the fifth nerve , and its resemblance to the spinal nerves , had struck some of the best continental anatomists .
But as they had made no distinctions in the functions of the roots of the spinal nerves , so neither did they imagine any difference in the roots of the fifth nerve , and therefore no consequence resulted from having observed this resemblance .
This part of the anatomy , together with the whole minute relations of the nerves , was a dead letter , and led to no inference .
But now resuming the course I have hitherto followed , the anatomy of the fifth nerve points to curious results .
We see that the motor division of this nerve goes first to the muscles which close the jaw and give it the lateral or grinding motions .
Secondly , we see that it is distributed to the muscles of the cheek , which place the morsel under the operation of the teeth ; and thirdly , we find it going to the muscles which open the jaws .
We proceed to the second method of proof , by experiment .
Does the fifth nerve move the jaw ?
is it indeed the manducatory nerve as suggested by the anatomy ?
Let the following experiments determine the fact .
EXPERIMENT I. The root of the fifth nerve being exposed in an ass and irritated , the jaws closed with a snap .
EXPERIMENT II .
The fifth pair being divided in an ass , the jaw fell relaxed and powerless .
If we consider the action of mastication , we shall see what the consequence would be , were there no accordance between the motions of the lower jaw and .
See the adjoined plate .
324 the cheeks .
Conceiving that there must be such an accordance , and contem- .
plating the roots of the fifth pair and their distinct functions , I had imagined that this office was performed by the branches of the second division of the fifth .
But finding that the connection between the motor root and the superior maxillary nerve proved to be only by cellular texture , and considering the affirmation of M. MAGENDIE and those who followed him , that the infra-orbitary branch had no influence upon the lips , I prosecuted with more interest the Ramus Buccinalis Labialis .
And nobody , I presume , will doubt that the distribution of this division confirms the notions drawn from the anatomy of the trunk , -not only that the fifth nerve is the manducatory nerve as belongs to the muscles of the jaws , but also that it is distributed to the muscles of the cheek and lips to bring them into correspondence with the motions of the jaws .
Let us take in illustration the articulation of the bones .
In the joints the muscles are attached to the capsular membrane in such a manner as to draw it from between the bones and adapt it to the degree of flexion of the joint .
If the cheek were a passive membrane like the capsule of a joint , it would have required some such mechanical connection with the jaw or its muscles , as might have drawn it from between the teeth in the motions of mastication .
But being a muscular part , , to bring it into just relation with the motions of the teeth , it must have an accordance through nerves , and act in sympathy ; -relax when the jaws are apart , and contract when they are closed .
I think therefore we may perceive why a branch of the motor nerve of the muscles of the jaws sends a division to the muscles of the cheek and to the angle of the mouth .
By such a process of reasoning we see also why a branch of the same nerve should prolong its course under the chin to the muscles which are opponents to those which close the jaw .
In short , the motor portion of the fifth nerve sends no twigs with the ophthalmic division , nor the superior maxillary nerve , but only with the lower maxillary nerve .
To the muscles of the lower jawalone which are in action during mastication , and to the muscles necessarily associated in that action , the manducatory nerve is distributed .
It remains only that we observe what takes place in man , and compare the circumstances with experiments on brutes .
325 was consulted in the case of a lady with an uncommon disease in the side of the head : the description of her condition puzzled me very much ; there was so much said of tumours with pulsation on the head and face .
But when I saw and examined her , the mystery disappeared ; she had powerful spasms of the temporal and masseter muscles , which rose and swelled , under the excitement of a disease of the cheek , and with a pressure of the jaws so powerful as to displace the teeth .
During this violent spasm of the muscles supplied by the fifth nerve , the motions of the features were free and unconstrained under the influence of the portio dura of the seventh nerve , I have the precise counter-part to this morbid condition of the muscles of mastication in the case of a poor man now under my care .
He has a disease affecting the fifth nerve of the left side , attended with the loss of sensibility of the side of the face and of the surfaces of the eye .
In him there is no motion of the muscles of the jaw of the affected side .
In chewing , the action is only on the right side of the head ; the masseter muscle and temporal muscle of the left side do not rise or bulge out as in their natural actions ; but his command over his features is perfect through the operation of the portio dura .
It appears , therefore , that the disease of the fifth nerve , which has destroyed the sensibility on one side of the face , has caused a loss of motion in the muscles of the jaw on the same side .
A more frequent occurrence establishing the distinction of motions influenced by the fifth and seventh nerves , is presented in the case of paralysis of the portio dura ; for then all the muscles waste but those supplied by the fifth .
In the case referred to , of the man wounded by the horn of an ox , in whom the portio dura was torn , and who had the skin of his forehead , side of the nose , cheek and lips , deprived of all fleshiness and substance , and in fact wasted to mere skin , the muscles of the jaw were entire and prominent ; and on introducing the finger into the mouth and making him imitate the motions of mastication , a weak contraction could be felt in the cheek* .
These facts close the evidence of the fifth nerve being a double nerve ; not only the nerve of sensibility to the head and face , but a muscular nerve to the muscles of the jaws , active in mastication , and otherwise useful in all animals whose jaws are prehensile and used as hands .
This curious fact , originally drawn from the anatomy and now confirmed by it , had nearly been obscured by experiment ; since the external branches of the fifth nerve , those most exposed to the experimenter , are not muscular .
I am bound to acknowledge here the correction by M. MAGENDIE , in regard to the office of the suborbital division of this nerve , since it has given occasion to the revisal of the anatomy* .
We were involved in great confusion by the discovery of new branches of nerves and of ganglions , through which we had no guide , until we formed a correct arrangement of the whole system .
It is satisfactory to find that the ideas first suggested by a comparison between the roots of the nerves and their complex distribution in the face and neck are correct , when tried by a minute investigation of the internal nerves of the head ; and that the conclusions drawn from the anatomy , are confirmed both by experiment and by a knowledge of the effects of injuries and of disease in the human frame .
ADDITIONAL NoTE.-As the most important fact in this paper is that ascertained by experiments on the fifth nerve , I am bound to say by whom they were made , and for what purpose .
To my late brother-in-law Mr. JOHN SHAW , whom I educated , I have been indebted through the whole of this inquiry .
He had long been acquainted in the most intimate manner with my pursuits .
He had repeated my experiments on the roots of the spinal nerves , confirming the results , -that the anterior roots when irritated caused the muscles to contract , and that the posterior roots had no such influence .
He assisted me in my experiments on the nerves of the face , which were for the purpose of establishing that the fifth pair resembled the nerves of the spine , and at the same time proving , what was incomplete from the experiments on the spinal nerves , that a ganglion on one of the roots of a nerve is no cause of ' interruption to sensation , but the sign that it bestows sensibility ; making certain what could be only assumed from the experiments on the spinal nerves .
But he was acquainted also with my opinions drawn from the distribution of the nerves in the body contrasted with the anatomy of their roots .
And when the correctness of these opinions was established by experiment , he let no opportunity pass of advocating and supporting them .
In collecting information and making dissections he was ever active , as all the real students educated with him will testify .
It was in the fervour of his zeal that he went to Paris and explained the arrangement by which I distinguished the nerves , and repeated my experiments with M. MAGENDIE and others at Charenton near Paris in 1821 .
At this time an idea was thrown out that the fifth nerve was no more than the sensitive nerve of the face accidentally separated from the muscular nerve ( the portio dura ) .
Perceiving that if this notion prevailed we should be thrown back into our former state of confusion , and to put the matter beyond all question , Mr. SHAW performed those experiments which are contained in this paper , -experiments which in the gentleness of his nature he would have hesitated to make from their severity , but for their being imperatively called for .
Had Mr. SHAW lived , this subject would have been further advanced .
Whilst his excellent judgement and indefatigable exertions aided me in every difficulty , his gratification in witnessing the progress of these inquiries was a reward beyond what I have now to look for .
Explanation of Plate VIII .
In this figure the superficial nerves of the face are turned off , and the distribution of the third division of the fifth to the muscles of the jaws and cheek exposed .
A. The portio dura of the seventh or respiratory nerve of the face coming out from the stylomastoid foramen ; the principal branches are cut and folded forwards .
B. The trunk of the portio dura of the seventh , dissected off the face and pinned out , while it is left at its connections with the branches of the fifth on the cheek and lips .
328 ,72fn MD CC{C/ XfX PlPYY -VITT .
v - ?
^2TI 7 } I1 / / B f-^H II Ii IIIiI 69 ?
~/ 6'~ ai6'6f .
, , _/ 2 --/ 7 A d !
.-- ... . .
--I Z. : " ; .
-1------- , --.I11 -----II..- .
" .--. .
1 .
-~ - .
I ... .
I~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ... .1 , ~f .
-c .
2 .
B}3 t97 &lt; , / .c .
, -A. .
TU fhz .
-razm .
MD\1 DCCG IXXII/ X.f329 .
C v , .
--~~~~~-.I ? ? ?
?-~ ~~~~~`i KIVI/ /A I , IiIiiI iI --^'--i------------~--Y---------i.----- .
il if I - , &lt; 3 o~ 0 ^zZ , , ea/ /cS ft. Mc7 ' / y -',. .
/ .
' fi J. ce. .
The branch of the third division of the fifth nerve , which joins the plexus of the portio dura before the ear .
Some experimenters , ignorant of this junction of a sensitive nerve with the muscular nerve , have occupied themselves with experiments to ascertain the degree of sensibility of the portio dura .
D. In this figure the masseter muscle is dissected from the jaw-bone and lifted up to show D , the branch of the fifth pair of nerves going into the muscle .
E. The Ramus Buccinalis-labialis , that branch of the fifth nerve which goes to the buccinator , triangularis , levator labiorum , and orbicularis muscles .
F. That branch of the fifth nerve which separating from the mandibulolabralis goes to the muscles which depress the lower jaw .
G. The suborbitary nerve , a branch of the fifth nerve .
H. The mandibulo-labralis , a branch of the fifth nerve coming out from the bone to the muscles and integuments of the lip and chin .
I. A branch of the fifth nerve descending from the orbit .
D , E , F , are muscular branches of the fifth nerve , and are motor nerves .
C , G , H , I , are sensitive branches of the same nerve which join the branches of the portio dura in its universal distribution ; and although these branches of the fifth enter the muscles , they possess no power over their motions .
B is the portio dura , which , though taking the same course with the last , is for a different purpose ; while it is a motor nerve , by its association with the respiratory nerves , it is enabled to excite those actions of the face and lips which are necessarily connected with the act of breathing .
Explanation of Plate IX .
Fig. 1 .
Represents the fifth nerve dissected out and seen on its lower surface .
A. The posterior or sensitive root before it forms the ganglion .
B. The Gasserian ganglion .
C. The anterior or motor root of the nerve passing the ganglion .
D. The third or lower maxillary division of the fifth nerve .
E. The motor portion joining the lower maxillary nerve and forming a plexus with it .
From this plexus go off the muscular nerves to the muscles of the jaw , viz. 1 .
Temporalis .
Massetericus .
3 .
Buccinalis labialis .
4 .
Pterygoideus .
5 .
Mylo-hyoideus .
F. Division which joins the portio dura .
G. Mandibulo-labralis .
H. Gustatory nerve .
I. The chorda tympani .
Fig. 2 .
This figure represents the ganglion on one of the spinal nerves , to show its resemblance to the ganglion of the fifth nerve in every particular .
A. The posterior or sensitive root of the nerve .
B. The ganglion formed upon the posterior root .
C. The anterior or motor root of the nerve ; this arises in minute branches which join to form the larger subdivisions , whilst the posterior root is composed of simple and abrupt portions .
This division joins the sensitive division beyond the ganglion exactly in the same manner that the motor portion of the fifth joins the lower maxillary nerve , Fig. 3 .
Represents one of the ganglions of the sympathetic nerve to show how different it is from those on the symmetrical system of nerves .
In fig. 1 and 2 the nerve on entering the ganglion and escaping from it , is separated into branches in a manner very different from the mode in which the sympathetic nerve joins or forms its ganglions ' .
X Authors who have treated of the anatomy of the ganglions , have not distinguished between the two classes of ganglions as belonging to the sensitive and sympathetic systems of nerves .
330

