On the composition of chloride of bariuzm .
By Dr. EDWARD TURNER , Professor of Chemistry in the University of London .
Communicated by Dr. DIONYSIUS LARDNER , Fellow of the Royal Society .
Read May 14 , 1829 .
IN taking a review of the present state of chemistry ; of the numerous compounds that have been discovered within a very limited period , and of which many have as yet been but partially or imperfectly examined ; of the results , often discordant , which analysts have obtained ; -and of the opposite theoretic views which are prevalent , -it is difficult to avoid suspecting the propriety of opinions that have been thought to rest on the sure basis of correct observation , or doubting the accuracy of analyses conducted by chemists of the highest reputation .
The era of brilliant discovery in chemistry appears to have terminated for the present .
The time is arrived for reviewing our stock of information , and subinitting the principal facts and fundamental doctrines of the science to the severest scrutiny .
The activity of chemists should now , I conceive , be especially employed , not so much in searching for new compounds or new elements , as in examining those already discovered ; in ascertaining with the greatest possible care the exact ratio in which the elements of compounds are united ; in correcting the erroneous statements to which inaccurate observation has given rise ; and exposing the fallacy of opinions which partial experience or false facts have produced .
Considerable as is the labour and difficulty of such researches , they will eventually prove of great importance to chemical science by supplying correct materials for reasoning ; and will sometimes , even in the most familiar parts of analytical chemistry , lead to the detection of errors that had escaped notice , and which vitiate many analyses previously regarded without suspicion .
An instance of this kind I shall have occasion to notice in the present communication .
The foregoing reflections have been more immediately elicited by circum2 2 stances connected with Dr. THOMSON'S " First Principles of Chemistry .
" The celebrated author of that work has attempted to ascertain the equivalents of all elementary substances ; and as the result of his labours , has inferred the truth of an ingenious conjecture , suggested some years ago by Dr. PROUT , that the weights of the atoms of bodies are simple multiples of the atomic weight of hydrogen .
( Annals of Philosophy , vol. vi .
p. 321 .
) This hypothesis is of so much importance if true , and may give rise to so much error if false , that its accuracy cannot too soon be put to the test of a minute experimental inquiry .
The only chemists who to my knowledge have objected on experimental grounds to Dr. THOMSON'S support of this hypothesis , are Dr. UR and BERZELIUS ; but unfortunately both these gentlemen have written on the subject with such acrimony , and assumed a tone so unusual in scientific controversy , as in a great degree to have destroyed that confidence which their well-founded reputation for sagacity and skill would otherwise inspire .
The uncertainty in which this question is still involved , has induced me to investigate it ; and the essay which the Royal Society do me the honour to hear this evening , may be viewed as the commencement of a series of essays designed for the elucidation of the same subject .
As I shall have occasion on individual points to differ repeatedly from Dr. THOMSON , I embrace this opportunity to declare , that in considering his statements with the freedom required for eliciting truth , I bear towards him no other personal feelings than those of kindness for civility received at his hands , and of respect for a man who has devoted his life zealously and successfully to the promotion of science .
The object of the present essay is to determine the composition of chloride of barium .
The frequent employment of this compound in chemical experiments renders an exact knowledge of its constitution peculiarly important ; and it has been used so extensively by Dr. THOMSON as a medium of analysis , that an examination of it will afford an excellent criterion of the accuracy of his researches .
Dr. THOMSON has employed chloride of barium in ascertaining the equivalent of sulphuric acid , and of not less than thirteen metals and their protoxides ; so that if his examination of this substance is inexact , the error will probably affect a large portion of his treatise .
Dr. THOMSON has been led by his observations to adopt 36 as the equivalent of chlorine , 70 as that of barium , and 78 as that of baryta .
The equivalent of chloride 292 of barium is therefore 106 ; and on mixing this quantity of the chloride with 88 parts of sulphate of potash , each being previously dissolved in separate portions of distilled water , he finds that the clear liquid left after the insoluble sulphate of baryta has completely subsided , is not rendered turbid either by muriate of baryta or sulphate of soda .
It is hence inferred , that by double decomposition the whole of the baryta has united with all the sulphuric acid , and that all the potash and muriatic acid are contained in solution in the form of muriate of potash .
The resulting sulphate of baryta , after being collected and heated to redness , weighed exactly 118 parts ; while the muriate of potash , when collected and duly heated , yielded 76 parts of chloride of potassium .
It follows from this experiment that 40 is the equivalent of sulphuric acid , and 48 of potash ; and on mixing with one equivalent of chloride of barium such a quantity of any soluble sulphate as should produce a similar interchange of elements , the constitution of that salt would be exactly determined .
This leading experiment , from which Dr. THOMSON deduces the composition of chloride of barium as well as the atomic weight of baryta , is maintained by BERZELIUS to be inexact .
He prepared chloride of barium and sulphate of potash with the greatest possible care ; and on mixing them in the proportion mentioned by Dr. THOMsON , he found that a considerable quantity of the former , about 2.25 per cent of the amount employed , remained free in the residual liquid .
( Lehrbuch der Chemie , vol. iii .
p. 106 .
) In an answer to this objection , published in the Philosophical Magazine and Annals of Philosophy for last March , Dr. THOMSON has maintained the accuracy of his original experiment , stating that it had recently been repeated by six of his practical pupils , and in no case did the residual liquid contain a trace either of sulphuric acid or baryta .
I regret that my observations have forced me to a conclusion precisely opposite .
I have made the experiment in question repeatedly , with the greatest care , and with perfectly pure materials , and in every instance the result coincided with that obtained by BERZELIUS .
The sulphate of potash which I 'used was prepared by repeated crystallization from the crystals of that salt as sold by the druggists , and was so pure that I could not detect in it a trace of foreign matter .
The chloride of barium was formed by the action of pure iumriatic acid on native carbonate of baryta .
The resulting solution was 293 rendered alkaline with pure baryta , in order to precipitate any oxide of iron or manganese which might be present ; and the crystals subsequently obtained by evaporation were reduced to powder , boiled in successive portions of alcohol , and fused .
The fused chloride was redissolved in distilled water , and again obtained in crystals .
This salt dissolved without residue or turbidity in water , and the solution was not affected by pure ammonia ; it was not discoloured by sulphuretted hydrogen , hydrosulphuret of ammonia , or chloride of lime ; when precipitated by an excess of sulphate of potash , the soluble parts were not rendered turbid by an alkaline carbonate or oxalate of potash ; and when thrown down by pure sulphuric acid , evaporated , and ignited , the dry mass did not yield a trace of any soluble sulphate to water .
Both compounds were heated to redness before being employed ; and the chloride of barium , which if perfectly anhydrous , attracts moisture freely from the atmosphere , was always placed while hot in a weighed bottle secured by a tight cork , and its weight ascertained when cold .
This precaution is not necessary with sulphate of potash .
I have thought it right to enter into these details , not only that chemists may judge of the accuracy of my experiments by the care with which they were conducted , but because the error committed by Dr. THOMSON appears referable to the neglect of some of these precautions .
This opinion seems the more probable , since Dr. THOMSON is uncertain whether in his original experiments he did not employ the muriate of baryta of commerce , and if so he doubtless must have operated with an impure substance .
But independently of any inaccuracy arising from this source , I shall now endeavour to prove that his method involves an error which precludes an exact result even with the purest materials .
When solutions of muriate of baryta and sulphate of potash are mixed together , a small portion of the latter invariably escapes decomposition , and falls tenaciously adhering to the sulphate of baryta .
I was led to this fact by observing , that when a known quantity of chloride of barium is precipitated by sulphate of potash , the resulting sulphate of baryta always weighed more than when the precipitation was made with pure sulphuric acid .
The appearance of the salts after exposure to a red heat , was likewise different ; the impure sulphate being harder , more brittle , and less opaque than the pure sulphate .
The former reduced to powder and boiled with water , yielded a solution which precipitated barytic salts freely , and afforded certain evidence of the presence of potash with muriate of platinum .
The presence of sulphate of potash was at first naturally ascribed to imperfect edulcoration ; but as it was still found , even after the precipitate had been washed with unusual care , I was led to examine the subject minutely .
A solution of sulphate of potash was mixed with a large excess of muriate of baryta ; the insoluble sulphate was edulcorated until the washings ceased to contain a trace of baryta , and was then collected on a filter , and ignited .
On boiling it in powder with water , sulphate of potash was dissolved .
The experiment was varied by mixing the solutions at a boiling temperature , and continuing the ebullition for some minutes ; but the result was the same as before , On edulcorating the precipitate with boiling water , sulphate of potash begins to make its appearance in the washings as soon as the excess of muriate of baryta has been removed ; but neither by this means , nor by boiling the recent precipitate for hours in successive portions of distilled water , have I succeeded in removing all the sulphate of potash .
The adhesion of this salt ensues even in a dilute solution ; and it is not prevented by the presence of other salts , such as nitre , and nitrate or muriate of ammonia , nor by free muriatic acid .
The quantity of adhering sulphate of potash is variable , depending apparently as well on the relaive quantity of the two salts , and the strength of the solution , as on the manner and extent of edulcoration .
I have known it to increase the weight of the sulphate of baryta by one per cent. The foregoing observations , unless I am much deceived , will fully justify the statement , that Dr. THOMSON'S method of analyzing chloride of barium is radically defective .
For if chloride of barium and sulphate of potash be mixed in the proportion to make a perfect interchange , some of the former will remain in the liquid , proportional to the quantity of the latter which escapes decomposition ; whereasthe absence both of sulphuric acid and baryta from the liquid can only occur , when the quantity of chloride of barium is insufficient for effecting complete double decomposition with the sulphate of potash .
So that when the proportions appear to be right , they are certainly wrong ; and they may be right , when they appear to be wrong .
It is obvious , too , that Dr. THOMSON'S analysis of sulphate of potash by means of chloride of barium , is not more satisfactory than his analysis of chloride of barium by sulphate of 295 potash .
The equivalent of potash , deduced from that analysis , cannot be relied on ; and his proof of 40 being the exact equivalent of sulphuric acid is also liable to objection .
But the error upon which Dr. THOMSON has so unhappily fallen , has been also committed by other chemists .
Every analysis of sulphate of potash , or of salts containing this alkali and sulphuric acid , must be regarded with suspicion .
Thus the analysis of common alum by Dr. THoMsON and BERZELIUS can scarcely be quite exact ; and the analysis of potash-minerals , in which baryta has been separated by sulphuric acid , may also be suspected of slight inaccuracy .
The process by which I have endeavoured to analyze chloride of barium consists of two parts .
In the first , a given quantity of the chloride was dissolved in water , and the baryta thrown down as sulphate by sulphuric acid .
In the second , a similar solution was precipitated by nitrate of silver , and the chlorine inferred from the quantity of fused hornsilver which was produced .
The quantity of chloride of barium employed in each experiment varied from 30 to 40 or 45 grains .
The sulphuric acid had of course been purified by distillation , and left no residue when evaporated on platinum .
The process by sulphuric acid was varied : one while the solution and precipitate were evaporated to dryness in a platinum capsule ; and at another , the insoluble sulphate was collected on a double filter .
Both methods were frequently repeated , and the sulphate of baryta was always dried by exposure to a red heat .
The quantity of sulphate of baryta obtained by the first method from 100 parts of the chloride ranged from 112.17 to 112.2 , being more frequently the latter than the former ; and 112.19 may be adopted as a mean of the most successful experiments .
The quantity obtained by filtration fell rather short of this , varying in the best experiments from 112.08 to 112.12 .
The difference is referable to a trace of sulphate of baryta being retained by the acid solution , in which it may really be detected by evaporation .
The first series of experiments may therefore be considered the more accurate , , and it may be inferred that 100 parts of pure chloride of barium are capable of yielding 112.19 parts of sulphate of baryta .
This result agrees very closely with that stated by BERZELIUS in the last edition of his System of Chemistry , who in one experiment got 112.17 , and in another 112.18 , of sulphate from 100 parts of chloride of barium .
According to Dr. THOMSON , 100 parts of the 296 chloride yield only 111.32 parts of sulphate of baryta .
It is proper to state , in reference to the foregoing experiments , that traces of chloride of barium are apt to adhere to the sulphate of baryta ; but this source of error is easily avoided by decanting the supernatant fluid after subsidence , and stirring the precipitate with hot water acidulated with sulphuric acid .
In order to determine the chlorine of chloride of barium by mreans of silver , it was desirable to ascertain the composition of hornsilver .
For this purpose some fine silver containing only traces of gold and copper was dissolved in nitric acid , precipitated by sea-salt , digested in dilute nitro-muriatic acid , and washed .
The dry chloride was then reduced by means of carbonate of potash in the usual manner , and after throwing a few fragments of nitre upon the fused metal , it was granulated and then boiled repeatedly in distilled water .
In the silver thus prepared I could not detect potash , gold , copper , or any other impurity ; whereas it is difficult in employing common silver , to purify it completely by one operation .
1 .
Of this silver 28.407 grains were dissolved in pure nitric , and precipitated by pure muriatic acid , both of which had been prepared with the greatest care .
The whole mass was evaporated to dryness , and yielded 37.737 grains of fuse : chloride of silver .
2 .
In a second similar experiment 41.917 grains of silver yielded 55.678 grains of hornsilver .
3 .
In a third , 40.006 grains of silver yielded 53.143 of hornsilver .
According to the first and third experiments 100 parts of silver correspond to 132.84 , and according to the second to 132.83 parts of hornsilver .
4 .
In a fourth experiment , 30.922 grains of silver were dissolved in nitric acid , and precipitated by muriate of baryta in excess .
The precipitate after being carefully washed and collected on a double filter , yielded 41.07 grains of fused chloride ; and hence the silver and chloride are in the ratio of 100 to 132.82 .
5 .
In a fifth experiment , 42.255 grains of silver were dissolved as usual , precipitated by an excess of muriatic acid , and collected on a double filter .
The fused chloride amounted to 56.09 grains , giving the proportion of 100 to 132.74 .
When the silver is thus precipitated by free muriatic acid , and the chloride collected on a filter , the result is constantly below that obtained by the other methods , owing to a trace of the chloride being dissolved by the strong acid solution .
It may be inferred , as a mean of the four first experiments , that 100 parts of silver correspond to 132.83 parts of chloride of silver .
The proportion stated by BERZELIUS iS 100 to 132.75 ; and it is estimated at 100 to 132.72 by Dr. THOMSON .
All these results , therefore , are closely correspondent .
From one of the experiments ( No. 4 .
) just mentioned , it is manifest that the precipitation of chloride of barium by nitrate of silver does not involve any appreciable source of error .
To be quite certain , however , as to this fact , chloride of barium was mixed with nitrate of silver in excess , and the precipitate carefully washed .
It was then boiled in distilled water , and the fluid examined for silver and baryta ; but not a trace of either could be detected .
It dissolved completely in ammonia , and the addition of sulphuric acid did not cause the slightest turbidity .
In five analyses made by precipitating chloride of barium by an excess of nitrate of silver , I obtained the following proportions .
Chloride of Barium .
Chloride of Silver .
Exp. 1 .
100 yielded ... ... ... . .
137.45 2 .
100 ... ... ... ... ... .
137.54 3 .
100 ... ... ... ... ... 137.70 4 .
100 ... ... ... ... ... 137.62 5 .
100 ... ... ... ... ... 137.64 Though all these analyses were made with great care , the last two were the most successful , as being less influenced by errors of manipulation than the others .
Instead , therefore , of taking the mean of the five , which is 100 to 137.61 , I adopt the mean of the two last experiments , which is 100 to 137.63 .
In one of these the precipitate was washed with distilled water only , and in the other with water acidulated with nitric acid .
BERZELIUS in his experiments on this subject found that 100 parts of chloride of barium corresponded to 138.06 in one experiment , and 138.08 in another .
This is the only material difference between us which I have yet had occasion to notice .
It induced me to reconsider every part of my experiments ; but as I am unable to detect the slightest inaccuracy in the two analyses from which my result was derived , I cannot 298 hesitate to adopt it .
I conclude , accordingly , that 100 parts of chloride of barium correspond to 137.63 parts of chloride of silver ; and as , consistently with the preceding researches , this quantity of hornsilver contains 34.016 parts of chlorine , it follows that chloride of barium consists of Barium ... ... ... ... ... 65.984 " Chlorine ... ... ... ... ... ... 34.016 100.000 Its constitution according to Dr. THOMSON and BERZELIUS is shown by the following numbers : THOMSON .
BERZ ELIUS .
Barium ... ... . .
66.037 ... ... . .
65.926 Chlorine ... ... . .
33963 ... ... . .
34.074 100.000 100.000 It is impracticable , from the composition of chloride of barium as above stated , to make any satisfactory inference relative to the real equivalent of barium , because the real equivalent of chlorine is not yet clearly ascertained .
By Dr. THOMSON it is estimated at 36 , and by BERZELIUS at 35.43 and on .
calculating the equivalent of barium according to both estimates , the following result will be obtained .
Barium ... ... . .
69.832 ... ... ... 68.726 Chlorine ... ... . .
36.000 ... ... . .
35.430 105.832 104.156 Hence if 36 is the equivalent of chlorine , that of barium will be 69.832 , or very near 70 as stated by Dr. THOMsoN ; but if the calculation be continued , still taking the results of my experiments as its basis , the equivalent of sulphuric acid will turn out to be 40.901 instead of 40 .
From these considerations it appears evident that at least one of the equivalent numbers concerned in the calculation must be incorrect .
I abstain , however , from offering any further opinion on this point at present , as it will form the subject of another communication .
2 Q2 299

