Remarks on the tendency to Calculous Diseases ; with observations on the nature of urinary concretions , and an analysis of a large part of the collection belongig to the Norfolk and Norwich Hospital .
By JOHN YELLOLY , M.D. F.R.S. tc .
Read June 19 , 1828 .
HAVING , since my residence in the neighbourhood of Norwich , and my connection with the county hospital , paid considerable attention to calculous diseases and their concretions , I beg leave to lay some observations on those subjects before the Royal Society , to whose Transactions we owe much valuable information on the branches of pathology which relate to urinary complaints .
PART I.-Of the tendency to Calculous Diseases .
The county of Norfolk has long been remarkable for the occurrence of calculous diseases among its inhabitants ; but there are no means of ascertaining how far this disposition extended , previous to the establishment of its hospital in 1772 .
Many of its cases went , of course , to the metropolis before that time ; but there is , besides , every reason for concluding , that the operation of lithotomy was frequently performed in Norfolk , during all the preceding part of the eighteenth century , both from the reputation and extensive practice of Mr. GooCH , one of the principal surgeons and surgical writers of his time , who lived near Norwich ; and the occasional observations made by that gentleman in his surgical works , as to the skill , and experience in lithotomy , of practitioners in different parts of the county .
Operative surgery does not indeed , at this time , appear to have been confined to the regular surgeon ; for in the little church of Stoke Holycross , about four miles from Norwich , is a mural monument of a clergyman , who died in 1719 , and is represented , in an inscription surrounded by designs of various surgical instruments , as having been distinguished for his abilities in theology , physic , surgery , and lithotomy* .
From the establishment of the Norfolk and Norwich Hospital in 1772 , to the end of last year , making a period of fifty-six years , 649 operations of lithotomy have been performed in it , which is at the rate of rather more than 11 per annum , and about 1 in 40 on the total number of admissions , which amounted , in that period , to 26,521 ~ .
If we deduct from this number , the cases which have come from Suffolk and Cambridgeshire , amounting to 74 , ( of which , however , only a single instance has occurred from the latter county , ) there will remain 575 furnished by the population of the county of Norfolk , which amounts to 351,000 ; and this will produce about 10.26 cases per annum , or 1 for every 34,000 inhabitants .
The number of cases arising in Norwich+ , in the same period , is 128 , or about one fifth of the whole ; while 447 are derived from the county of Norfolk , independently .
Norwich , therefore , which contains 50,000 inhabitants , furnishes annually 2.28 cases on its population , or 1 for every 21,000 inhabitants while the other parts of Norfolk afford only 7.98 per annum on their population of 301,000 , or 1 for every 38,000 inhabitants , which is not much above one half of the proportion of Norwich.-Considerable differences likewise exist , with regard to the ratio of numbers furnished by the different hundreds of Norfolk ; the eastern parts of the county , however , contributing more largely than the western .
Thus the six western contiguous hundreds , including Lynn , have furnished not more than one half of the proportion of the six eastern hundreds , including Yarmouth ; and the difference is still more striking with regard to some of the individual hundreds ; for the hundreds of Taverhanm , Tunstead , and Walsham ( contiguous hundreds on the eastern parts of the county ) , have regularly furnished about five times the proportion of the contiguous western hundreds of Freebridge Marshland , Freebridge Lynn , and South Greenhoe ; which proportions have been pretty much preserved , during every part of the period to which the records of the establishment extend .
It is to be observed , however , that there are some singular anomalies on this subject ; for in a few instances it has happened , that a particular hundred has been remarkably free from the disease , and that the contiguous one has afforded rather an unusual number of examples of it .
There has been no material alteration in the number of cases which have -occurred , in a similar space of time , during the different periods since the establishment of the Norfolk and Norwich Hospital ; and hence , as the population of the county has augmented nearly a third during that period , the proportion of calculous cases may be considered as having diminished much in the same ratio .
With regard to the proportion in which calculous cases occur in other parts of the kingdom , the researches of Dr. DOBSON* , and afterwards of Dr. MARCET+ , and Mr. SMITH of Bristol+ , have communicated the principal information which we possess upon the subject : but it is exceedingly difficult , from the want of efficient registers , to procure such data , as can connect the occurrence of a certain number of cases , with a certain known population .
Mr. SMITH'S calculation , of the occurrence of about 47 operations for calculus annually in the hospitals of the metropolis , I believe to be pretty nearly the truth ; and I have found from the registers of the London Hospital , ( to which I was many years physician , ) that in that establishment , about two thirds of the calculous cases have been furnished by the metropolis , and one third by the country .
Taking the same proportions as applying to the other hospitals of the metropolis , I am therefore disposed to refer 31 of the 47 cases , to the population of the metropolis , amounting to rather more than 1,200,000 inhabitants ; and 16 to about the same number living in counties adjacent to the metropolis , which possess no county hospitals , or have had them too recently established to affect the calculation .
It would seem probable from this rough estimate , that 1 case of operation for calculus occurs annually for every 38,000 inhabitants in the metropolis , and about half that proportion in the counties contiguous to it .
From the information which Mr. SMITH has furnished , it appears that about 60 operations of lithotomy are performed annually in the provincial hospitals of England .
This estimate includes Wales , whose sick poor , when sent from home , are chiefly transmitted to the hospitals of one or other of the adjoining English counties , as there are no such charities in the principality.-Suffolk did not possess a county hospital when Mr. SMITH was prosecuting his researches ; and consequently was not included in his calculations , except as far as it furnished cases to the Norwich , or other hospitals .
It possesses , however , in an eminent degree , the calculous character of Norfolk ; and I have been enabled , through the kindness of some professional friends , to estimate the operations of lithotomy performed in it , by private practitioners , during the last 20 years , as about 4 annually .
If this number be added to 1.26 , ( which is the annual proportion of 73 admissions from Suffolk to the Norwich Hospital in 56 years , ) we shall have 5.26 cases as the annual product of Suffolk on its population of 234,000 ; or 1 case for every 44,000 inhabitants .
It may be remarked , that the want of an hospital in Suffolk , till within these few years , and its distance , both from Norwich , and London , have occasioned the performance of a much larger proportion of operations of lithotomy in that county , by private practitioners , than is usual in other districts .
According to Mr. SMITH'S calculation , there will therefore be 107 public operations in the whole of England and Wales , which , with the addition of 4 from Suffolk , will make 111 operations annually , on a population of very nearly 12,000,000 , or 1 case for every 108,000 inhabitants .
This , however , is not quite a third of the proportion which occurs in Norfolk .
If we put aside from the calculation , the 15cases occurring in the Norfolk district , ( comprehending Norfolk and Suffolk ) with its population , we shall then have 1 calculous case for every 118,000 inhabitants , independently of that * Middlesex , Essex , Surrey , and Herts , may be regarded as hitherto principally dependent on the metropolis for Hospital accommodation ; Kent , Sussex , Bucks , and Berks , as only partially so , perhaps to half their demand .
58 district .
But if we further remove the cases which occur in London and the adjacent counties , with the respective population connected with them , we shall have not more than 49 examples of calculus attaching to the whole remaining population of England and Wales , or 1 case only , for every 188,000 inhabitants , which is little more than one fifth of the proportion of London , and of the Norfolk district excluding Norwich ; and only about one ninth of the proportion of Norwich itself .
The tendency of any particular class of persons to be affected with calculous complaints , in the kingdom at large , must therefore be exceedingly small .
But if we take individuals between 14 and 50 , ( which is the most extended period of active exertion in adult age , ) the calculous cases will be still further reduced ; for though it appears by the population returns , that nearly one half of the whole population of the kingdom , consists of persons between those ages , yet the calculous cases belonging to this period of life , as inferred from the Norwich register , are not quite a ir third of the total number .
Under these considerations , I feel some degree of difficulty in completely assenting to the opinion which Mr. COPLAND HUTCHISON so ably supports* , of a sea-faring life being remarkable for the comparative infrequency of urinary calculi- .
In the Norwich as well as the London Haospital , the liability to calculous diseases has been nearly as great , during the first sixteen years of life , as in the whole after period ; but if we take the cases afforded by Norwich and London , independently of their respective country districts , as many cases of calculus have occurred below 14 , as above that age ; so that in those two instances , the proportion of children affected with this complaint , ( judging from the hospital returns , ) has been larger in a town , than in a country situation .
With regard to the mortality from the operation of lithotomy , the number of deaths in the Norfolk and Norwich Hospital , has been 89 , which is a mortality of 1 in 7.29 cases , from the institution of the charity .
But it is creditable to the state of moder surgery , and to the skill of the present surgeons of that Hospital , that in the operations performed by them ( which amount to near one third of the whole number from the commencement ) , the proportion of deaths has been reduced to 1 in 8.42 , which differs very little from the average of CHESELDEN , whose improved lateral operation they follow* .
afford their full complement of men to the British navy , but have less tendency to calculous diseases , according to our present evidence , than England ; it will not be found , even if we take the smaller population of 1810 , instead of that of 1820 , that the proportion of those complaints , among large bodies of natives of the three kingdoms , between 14 and 50 years of age , acting together , will differ much from that stated by Mr. HUTCHISON .
Up to the age of 14 , the deaths are only 1 in 14I ; and above that age , 1 in 54 .
Between 14 and 40 , the mortality is 1 in 10 ; but after that period of life , it is augmented to the formidable extent of 1 in 3X .
The number of female cases , in the whole , has been 31 ; the proportion , 1 in 20 ; and the deaths 1 in 15i .
But from the improved practice by dilatation , all risk of life , in the abstraction of calculi from females , seems to be taken away .
I have mentioned , in the Medico-Chirurgical Transactions , the removal from a female of a calculus of nearly 3Aoz .
troy , in weight , by spontaneous dilatation * ; and some examples are given in the Philosophical Transactions , by Dr. MOLYNEUx , Dr. HEBERDEN , and others , of a similar kind : but it was not till of late years , that dilatation was employed to supersede the usual operation of lithotomy in women .
The following Tables will exhibit , at one view , the number of operations of lithotomy at the Norfolk and Norwich Hospital , with the mortality , at different periods of life .
Age or Sex .
Operations .
Cured .
Died .
Mortality .
Both sexes ... 649 560 89 1 in 7.29 Males ... . .
618 531 87 17.1 Females ... 31 29 / 2 1-15.5 Both sexes .
Under 14 ... .
292 272 20 I 1-t14.6 14 and upwards 357 288 69 1 5.17 14to 40 ... .
155 140 115 1-10.33 40 and upwards 202 J 148 | 54 f 1-3.74 14 to50 ... .
196 171 25 17.84 50 and upwards 161 117 44 13.56 Under 16. .
j 317 | 294 23 1-13.78 16 and upwards 332 266 66 1 5.03 Age .
Operations .
Cured .
Died .
Mortality .
Inf. to 10 255 237 18 1 in 14.16 10--14 37 35 2 1--18.5 14 -20 62 557 18.85 20-30 47 42 5 19.4 30 40 46 43 331 --15.33 , ... .
, , ... ... '1 r_ e_M X_r 40-50 41 31 10 14.1 50-60 92 69 23 14 60-70 63 43 20 13.15 70-80 '651 1-6 , rut The operation of lithotomy is always attended with more danger , when calculi are large , than when they are small .
This has been strikingly exemplified at Norwich ; for of 52 cases of adult males , in which calculi of 2oz .
or more occurred , 31 died , or nearly 2 in 3 ; while in 282 cases , also of adult males , in which the stones weighed less than 2oz .
, the mortality only amounted to 37 , or rather less than 1 in 7 .
Part of this unfavourable issue , is no doubt to be attributed to the injury , both local and constitutional , which the long continuance of a large calculus in the bladder may occasion ; but , at the same time , when we consider the general hazard of the operation of lithotomy , even in the most skilful and experienced hands , and the injury produced by the force necessary for extracting a calculus , and particularly a large one , there is a strong inducement afforded , to the full and dispassionate examination of the mechanical means which have been suggested , either for diminishing the magnitude of calculi , during an operation , in the revived and improved method of Mr. HENRY EARL * , or for wearing them down , by slow and gradual detrition , according to the plan which has been employed at Paris by M. CIVIALE , so as in many cases to do away with the necessity of the operation altogethert .
The circumstances which occasion death after the operation of lithotomy , form an important and interesting subject of investigation to the surgeon ; and am inclined to think , that in addition to the unforeseen and unavoidable occurrences , which sometimes succeed the very best exertions of surgical skill , there is something to be attributed to the constitutional shock of a great operation , under which the system will occasionally sink .
It is , however , a consideration , that may abate undue confidence from early success , on the one hand , and offer consolation and encouragement , under unexpected failures , on the other , that of two of the most distinguished contemporary lithotomists of this country , whose qualifications were of the most respectable kind , one lost 3 patients only of his first 50 operations , or 1 in 161 ; and 1 in 44 of the re mainder , amounting to more than double , so as to reduce his average mortality to rather below 1 in 7 ; while the other lost 11 of his first 50 patients , or 1 in 4j ; and in his remaining cases , which a good deal exceeded those in the former instance , lost only 1 in 13i , so as ' to render his whole average mortality rather less than 1 in 8* .
Recurrences of stone seem to be not very frequent ; 14 instances , or 1 in 46 only , being found in the records of the Norfolk and Norwich Hospital , of the operation having been performed twice on the same individual : 3 were below 14 , and 9 , ( of whom 2 died ) above that age .
The production of the second calculus took place , in 4 of these cases , within 1 year ; in 5 , within 2 years ; in 3 , within 3 years ; while in the 2 remaining cases , the operation did not become again necessary , till after a lapse , respectively , of 7 and 10 years .
It does not appear that a second calculus is necessarily of the same character as the first .
In the child from whom the first known specimen of cystic oxide was extracted , ( that analysed by Dr. WOLASTON ) , the disease returned ; but a second operation was not submitted to .
The child died , when a calculus , of a different character from the original one , was found in the bladder .
A curious example , of a similar kind , was shown to me at Cambridge , by Mr. JOHN OKES , one of the surgeons to the Cambridge Hospital , of a calculus of cystic oxide having a lithic nucleus , which was removed from a boy of 4 years old , and was followed , in a short time , by the formation of another of fusible exterior , with a lithic interior , which made a second operation necessary in less than a year from the first .
So speedily may the character of the animal process be changed , on which the formation or augmentation of urinary concretions depends .
With regard to the respective number of calculous cases which occur among the lower and higher orders of society , it is necessarily very difficult to obtain any correct information .
Mr. MARTINEAU , however , the senior surgeon of the Norwich Hospital , one of the most eminent and successful lithotomists of the present day , laid before the public , some years since , with much valuable information on the subject of lithotomy , a list of private patients , amounting to 10 in number , upon whom he operated , during a period that he operated on 111 public patients* .
The proportion was 1 private patient to 11 public ; which differs not much from the results of the late Mr. BRANDON TRY of Glocester , as given in Mr. SMITH'S paper .
I regret that but little advances have been made , in a knowledge of the circumstances on which a tendency to calculous complaints depends ; and I am not aware of such differences of air , water , soil , or habits of life having yet been detected , as can justify us in attributing the prevalence of stone , in the Norfolk district , to any of those causes .
A constitutional predisposition to the occurrence of calculous diseases , unquestionably exists in certain families .
Dr. PROUT , in his valuable work on Urinary Diseases , mentions an instance of a calculous tendency in three continuous generations ; and I am acquainted with a family , where the grandfather , a man of active habits living in the country , was twice cut for the stone , and died from the second operation ; the father was also cut ; and two of the sons have exhibited an unequivocal calculous disposition , from an early period of life .
I may also observe , that a few examples have occurred at the Norfolk and Norwich Hospital , where more than one individual of a family has had the disease , and undergone the operation .
The large employment of ill fermented farinaceous food , which marks in some degree the habits of the commonalty of Norfolk , may perhaps be regarded as favouring the occurrence of calculous diseases ; but a much coarser , and worse fermented material , in rye , barley , oats , and various mixtures of peas , with wheat or barley , has been , and perhaps still continues , to a certain degree , in use in Scotland , and the North of England , without being productive of such an effect .
There are doubtless , however , various collateral circumstances that have not been sufficiently ascertained , which may have the power of modifying the effects of any particular description of food ; and it is even very probable , that the laxative tendency of some of the coarser kinds of farinaceous aliment , may have a salutary influence , and obviate the disadvantages which might otherwise arise from their employment .
The cider counties were at one time supposed to be peculiarly liable to calculous complaints ; but so little ground is there for this opinion , that Herefordshire seems to have a very peculiar exemption from that malady ; and Devonshire , not to have more than the average cases of other counties .
From the documents to which I have referred , it appears , that the tendency to produce calculus , is much greater in Norwich , and London , than in their respective country districts* .
The same circumstance is very strikingly exemplified in Bristol ; for according to Mr. SMITH'S paper , to which I have had occasion so frequently to refer , 354 calculous cases have occurred in 82 years , at the Bristol Hospital , which is at the rate of 4.3 per annum .
But of these , 173 , or very nearly one half , were derived from Bristol and its liberties , which comprise a population of 87,000 persons ; and 181 only , from the neighbouring districts , containing not less than 750,000 inhabitantst .
The annual proportion would therefore be not less than 2.1 per annum for Bristol , which is 1 for 41,000 inhabitants ; while in its extensive and populous country district , the proportion would not be more than 2.2 per annum , or 1 only , for every 340,000 inhabitants .
In some parts of the country districts of Bristol , there are very singular anomalies ; for the town of Chippenham , with only 3200 inhabitants , is stated by Mr. SMITH , to have furnished as many cases of lithotomy , as the whole remaining county of Wilts .
On the calculation of 18 cases in 82 years , or 1 in 4.5 , which is about half the amount furnished by Wilts , there would , in this little town , be a tendency to calculous complaints , exceeding by about a fourth , that of Norwich itself .
Scotland is generally regarded as but little liable to the production of calculous diseases ; and if Mr. SMITH'S calculation , of the occurrence of 8 cases only per annum , in that part of the island , is a correct one , it would , on its population of two millions , be in the ratio of I case for every 250,000 inhabitants .
But the town of Dundee , in the county of Forfar , with a population of 30,000 , has afforded to Mr. CRICHTON , of that place , in 36 years , 31 cases of stone , out of above 70 on which he operated during that period* .
This is at the rate of.86 per annum , or 1 for every 35,000 inhabitants , if they had extended to that number .
But if 5 are deducted , as having , from their designation in Mr. CRICHTON'S list , the appearance of belonging to a higher class of society than enters into the calculations of this paper , we should then have.72 per annum , or 1 case for every 41,000 inhabitants , which is about the average proportion of Bristol .
In the instances which I have mentioned , it would therefore appear , that the tendency to produce calculous complaints , is greater in towns than in the country ; and if this should prove to be the case generally , it would seem to indicate the existence , in children more particularly , of a connection between some diathesis which prevails in towns , ( probably the scrophulous , ) and the tendency to the secretion or deposition of lithic acid , on which the origin of urinary calculi so much depends .
I have not had it in my power to ascertain , whether the greater disposition of towns to calculous complaints , applies more extensively than I have mentioned .
I think it probable , however ; but in some cases , in which I had expected to be able to connect the reports of the numbers operated upon , in a particular town or district , with a certain known population , the records were not sufficiently ample to afford the requisite information .
I did not therefore , avail myself of the well known kindness and courtesy of the medical officers of other provincial establishments , to trouble them with inquiries , which the plan of their registers might not , perhaps , give them the means of satisfying .
If I might venture , however , to make the suggestion , I would respectfully submit , how subservient our public hospitals , the boasts and ornaments of the country , might be made to important statistical inquiries , by a more extended system of registry , than is at present usually adopted , either in the metropolis , or in the country ; and how conducive to pathological improvement , the information would be , which they might thus be so readily enabled to furnish .
The annexed Table will show the relation of calculous cases to population , in the principal instances which I have mentioned .
Place .
Pop'ulation .
Number of Cases per Comparative Stone Cases .
Annum .
Frequency .
Norwich ... ... ... ... 50,000 128 in 56yrs .
2.28 1 in 21,000 Norfolk , including Norwich ... ... ... ... . .
351,000 575 : 10.26 134,000 Norfolk , excluding Norwich ... ... ... ... . .
301,000 4477.98 1 38,000 Suffolk ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... .
234,000 ... ... ... .
5.26 -1 44,000 Norfolk and Suffolk , including Norwich ... . .
585,000 ... ... ... 15.5 1 37,000 Norfolk and Suffolk , excluding Norwich ... .
535,000 ... ... ... 13.33 1-41,000 Londondon ... ... ... . .
1,300,000 ... ... ... .
31 .
1 -38,000 ri s. li berties ... ..r ... ... ... ... - , I m00 --8-y _ rs Adjacent Counties ... ... ... ... ... ... 1200,000 ... ... ... 6 .
1 76,000 England and Wales ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 12,000,000 ... ... ... 1 108,000 England and Wales , excluding Norfolk and } l,415,000. .
95 1-1 ke 11,415,000. .
e. 118000 Suffolk ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 95.5 -18,000 England and Wales , excluding Norfolk , Suf , nA folk , and London , with its adjacent counties 9,015000 49 1-188,000 Ditto persons between 14 and 50 ... ... ... .
4,134,000 ... ... ... 14.7 1 280,000 Bristol and its liberties ... ... ... ... ... ... . .
87,000 17382yrs .
2.1 1 41,000 r ? ? ? ? ? ?
r ?
kr ?
rr -r 1 !
s 2.1 _r 41 000 Bristol country district ... ... ... ... ..,. .
750,000 181 22 1 340,000 Scotland , ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 2,000,000 - ... ... ... . .
8 .
1 250,000 Dundee ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 30,000 26-36yrs..86 141,300 Soon after the alkaline nature of Mrs. STEPHEN'S remedies for stone in the bladder , was made known by her in 1739 , in consequence of the recompense of 50001 .
adjudged by Parliament for the disclosure , it was found by Dr. HIALES , that caustic alkalies had the power of dissolving calculi out of the body .
But Dr. RUTTY* , and some years afterwards Dr. DAWSONt , discovered that this substance was limited in its operation , to certain descriptions of calculi ; while others were capable of being dissolved by nitric or muriatic acid alone ; and hence they concluded , that in the latter cases , acids might be regarded as important lithontriptics .
The subject , however , was not pursued ; and these experiments , with the curative deductions made from them , were entirely lost sight of , The precise nature of lithic acid was afterwards discovered by the celebrated SCHEELE ; and for a long period subsequent to his time , urinary calculi were uniformly supposed to consist of this material , and alkalies , alone , employed in the treatment of the diseases which they occasioned .
It is singular , however , that the calculi which formed the subjects of that great chemist 's experiments , as well as of BERGMAN'S , should have been so little varied , as not to have led to the observations which had been before made by Drs. RUTTY and DAWSON , and which would , in all probability , have opened the way to the further important discoveries in urinary concretions , which we owe , in so great a degree , to the perspicacity and talents of Dr. WOLLASTON .
In concluding the first part of the paper which I have the honour to lay before the Society , I would beg to observe , that I have put aside the consideration of private cases , except as regards Suffolk , because it is not likely that the proportion of these , will differ much , in different districts , from that of public ones .
I would also observe , that much valuable information with regard to the Norwich operations and collection , was brought forward by my able and excellent deceased friend Dr. MARCET , in his valuable work on Calculous Diseases , to which I have already alluded ; but I have thought it desirable to present a general view of the whole subject , with such additional circumstances as I have had an opportunity of ascertaining .
II.-Of Urinary Concretions .
When I proposed an examination of the urinary calculi belonging to the Norfolk and Norwich Hospital , I had the expectation , that my attention would have been materially circumscribed by the previous labours of Dr. MARCET , who visited Norwich some years before , for the express purpose of examining the collection .
I found , however , that none of the calculi contained in it were divided , and that the experiments instituted by our lamented colleague ( of which an account was published in his work on Calculous Diseases , ) were therefore necessarily confined to the outer surface , except in cases where the calculus had been broken in the extraction , and its interior structure thus allowed to be seen .
Within the last four or five years , a certain portion of the calculi have been divided ; and these , as well as such as were broken in the extraction , amounting together to about 330 , I have carefully analysed .
I wish I could have extended the examination over the whole collection , which consists of 649 specimens* ; but as there is no very speedy prospect of the remainder being divided , so as to admit of a satisfactory analysis being made of them , I am unwilling , longer , to defer laying before the Society the results of my examinations , which exhibit a more extensive series of observations in this part of pathological chemistry , than has yet , as far as I know , been presented from any cabinet in this country .
I shall be happy in embracing a future opportunity , of going through the whole remaining part of this splendid collection , should the division of the residue be effected within a convenient period .
At the same time , however , it is not likely , that the proportions of the different descriptions of calculi which form the remainder , will differ materially from that of the large portion which I have analysed.-I have put the results of the analysis in a tabular form ; and have stated , in the order of their occurrence from the centre , the consecutive deposits of the different materials of which the calculi are composed , according to the most prominent character of such material .
I have said nothing of mixed calculi , or of calculi consisting , in the same apparent deposit , of mixtures of different ingredients ; because it is well known , that no one deposit is strictly and unequivocally unmixed ; but is blended , in various proportions , with others , so as to undergo , by this means , more or less modification of character and appearance .
Calculi consisting principally of one deposit .
Lithic acid ... ... ... ... ... . .
Lithate of ammonia ... ... ... Oxalate of lime ... ... ... ... ... ... Phosphate of lime ... ... ... ... ... ... Fusible calculus , or mixed phosphates ; that is to say , calculi composed of the triple , or ammoniaco-magnesian phosphate , united with phosphate of lime 81 20 20 4 37 Calculi consisting of two deposits .
Lithic acid and lithate of ammonia ... .
oxalate of lime ... ... mixed phosphates ... . .
phosphate of lime ... ... ... .
Lithate of ammonia and lithic acid ... ... .
oxalate of lime ... ... mixed phosphates ... ... ... .
phosphate of lime ... ... ... .
Oxalate of lime and lithic acid ... .
lithate of ammonia ... .
mixed phosphates ... ... ... .
phosphate of lime ... . .
Mixed phosphates and phosphate of lime ... . .
Calculi consisting of three deposits .
Lithic acid , phosphate of lime , and mixed phosphates -oxalate of lime , and phosphate of lime .
--oxalate of lime , and lithate of ammonia xalate of lime , and lithic acid. .
lithate of ammonia , and oxalate of lime ... e ... 37 ... . .
11.~ ... .10 2 ... . .
*25.~ ... .14 ?
****1 10. . ? ? .
1 ... ... 315 . ? ? .
2 3 ... ..~2 2 e. , 4 2 ? ? ?
* Lithic acid , oxalate of lime , and mixed phosphates Lithate of ammonia , oxalate of lime , and mixed phosphates -oxalate of lime , and lithic acid ... .
phosphate of lime , and lithate of ammonia lithic acid , and mixed phosphates ... Oxalate of lime , lithic acid , and lithate of ammonia lithic acid , and oxalate of lime ... ... .
---lithic acid , and mixed phosphates ... ... .
1 -W 3 ? . .
1 * .
2 ? . ?
... 12 Calculi consisting offour or more deposits .
Lithate of ammonia , oxalate of lime , lithic acid , and mixed phosphates 1 Oxalate of lime , lithic acid , oxalate of lime , and mixed phosphates .
1 Lithate of ammonia , oxalate of lime , phosphate of lime , oxalate of lime , and lithate of ammonia ... ... ... ... .
I 328 In this table , it will be seen , that about one half of the specimens are composed of one description of material only ; and that the remainder consist of alternating layers , more or less numerous , of most of the substances of which human urinary calculi are composed.-On each of these substances , I shall make a few observations .
Of lithic acid and lithate of ammonia .
The distinction between these substances , though very generally recognized abroad , does not appear to have been much attended to in this country , till it was noticed by Dr. PROUT , about nine years ago , in the Medico-Chirurgical Transactions * ; and afterwards , by the same gentleman , in his important and interesting work on Calculous Disorders .
The existence of lithate of ammonia , as a frequent component part of calculi , was distinctly pointed out , under the name of urate of ammonia , by Messrs. FOURCROY and VAUQUELIN , in their paper on Animal Concretions in the Annals des Chimie for 1799t ; but as they very singularly omitted all notice of Dr. WOLLASTON'S celebrated communication on a similar subject , which appeared in the Philosophical Transt Tom. xxx .
p. 57 .
71 actions two years before* , it is not a matter of surprise , that the labours of these very eminent chemical philosophers , did not , in this department , obtain an authority in this country , which an appearance of greater candour would unquestionably have ensured them .
Feeling , however , as I do , that Dr. WoLLASTON'S paper , even after a lapse of above thirty years of the most active and successful period of chemical investigation , is not only to be regarded as a model of elegant and accurate deduction , but as containing nearly every thing of importance which is yet known on the subject of urinary calculi , I must still do Messrs. FOURCROY and VAUQUELIN the justice to state my conviction , that their operations were independent of those of our distinguished countryman .
They were the first to notice lithate of ammonia ; and their claim to originality may even derive some degree of support , from their having overlooked the most striking characteristic of the fusible calculus , noticed in Dr. WOLLASTON'S communication , -ready fusibility , notwithstanding they were aware of the existence , as separate substances , of both the sets of materials of which it is composed , and knew also , that these substances are frequently united .
The subject , it is also to be observed , was not a new one with them ; for it appears from a paper which was published in the Annals de Chimie for the year 1793 ?
, that M. FoURCROY had been engaged , at various periods since the year 1787 , in prosecuting researches into the nature of animal concretions , during which he materially enlarged the bounds of our acquaintance with those substances .
Several of the specimens in the Norwich collection , bear a close resemblance to the plate which M. FOURCROY gives of a calculus of la f ithate of ammoniat .
They are small , gray , and laminated ; and in addition to the usual characters of lithic acid , elicit ammonia copiously , on the addition of pure potash .
Like those mentioned by Messrs. FOURCROY and VAUQUELIN , they are likewise generally derived from young subjects .
The combination of ammonia with lithic acid , is not , however , confined to small calculi , or to those which occur at an early period of life .
It is to be found in calculi of all sizes , and belonging to all ages .
But in such cases , ammonia invariably communicates a lighter colour , and diminishes the cohesion " On Gouty and Urinary Concretions : Philosophical Transactions for 1797 .
t Analyse Comparee des differentes Especes des Concretions Animales et Vegetales , tom.xvi .
p. 23 .
+ Annals du Museum d'Histoire Naturelle , tom .
i. pl. vii .
72 of the calculus , as indicated on the addition of pure potash ; though there is not , except occasionally towards the centre , the laminated structure of early life .
In a few instances , the appearance of the lithate of ammonia calculus is not very dissimilar to the chalk-like excrement , or rather urine of the Boa Constrictor , which , as is well known , consists of lithate of ammonia* .
Immersion , for a few days , in pure ammonia , converts yellow laminated lithic acid , whether in small masses , or in powder , into light-coloured lithate of ammonia , from which ammonia is readily evolved by the action of pure potash , after that which is loosely adherent , has been carefully separated by distilled water .
But the artificial addition of ammonia does not , as far as I have observed , communicate any degree of decrepitation to a lithic calculus , as might be imagined from an observation of Dr. PROUT .
It seems to be exceedingly likely , that some , at least , of the specimens of lithic calculus , which gave rise to SCHEELE'S discovery of lithic acid in urinary calculi , really consisted of lithate of ammonia ; since we are informed , that in his original experiments , a disengagement of ammonia took place , during the solution of the subjects of his analysis in liquid caustic potash , which would not have been the case , if the lithic acid , on which he operated , had been pure and uncombinedt .
One of the most able and experienced of our English chemists , Professor BRAND , has been induced to infer , that the evolution of ammonia from calculi , which were regarded as consisting of lithate of ammonia , depends , in all instances , on the decomposition of the ammoniacal salts contained in such calculi , and more especially of the ammoniaco-magnesian phosphate , with which the lithic acid is united .
As this is an interesting point in the history of those substances , I have made it a particular object of attention ; and the following is the result of my observations .
After exposing calculi bearing the character of lithate of ammonia , either to alcohol or distilled water , whether cold or heated , I have never found that by the abstraction of any substance from them , which those fluids were able to carry off , the development of ammonia was at all diminished , on subjecting the remainder to the action of pure potash .
When a portion of such calculi , either before or after exposure to alcohol or distilled water , was submitted to the action of acetic acid , none of the crystals of triple phosphate were to be observed on the addition of carbonate of ammonia to the filtered liquor , though the existence of -that salt is capable of being detected , by this process , in the most minute quantity .
By adding pure potash to the dried deposit which is obtained by evaporation from a solution of lithate of ammonia in boiling water , a copious development of ammonia took place , and the deposit itself was capable of undergoing complete solution in pure potash .
It does not therefore appear , that in those instances , the evolution of ammonia depended on the decomposition of triple phosphate .
Mr. BRAND has shown , that muriate of ammonia is capable of being obtained from lithate of ammonia ; and hence , he thinks , that this substance is one of those , which may afford the ammonia supposed to characterize the lithate of ammonia calculus* .
My experiments coincide entirely with those of Mr. BRAND , as to muriate of ammonia being a constant component part of that description of calculus ; but besides that this substance is in too small a quantity to give rise to the elicitment of ammonia , which occurs on the addition of pure potash to a lithate of ammonia calculus , the disengagement of ammonia takes place , with equal freedom , after the muriate of ammonia has been withdrawn from it , as before .
I would also add , that on heating dilute muriatic acid on the calculus , from which muriate of ammonia has been withdrawn by distilled water , muriate of ammonia is formed , by the union of such muriatic acid , with the ammonia which is in combination with the lithic acid in the calculus ; an increase in the weight of the calculus , when thoroughly dried , is found to have taken place ; and the newly formed muriate of ammonia , is freely given up to distilled water .
It is not only cognizable by its mode of crystallization , but by its ready sublirnation ; by the extrication of ammonia from it by pure potash ; by the deposition of triple phosphate on the addition of magnesia and phosphoric acid ; and the formation of luna cornea , through the means of its muriatic acid , on the addition of nitrate of silver .
The existence of muriate of ammonia in lithate of ammonia calculi , led me to inquire , whether , as that substance is always found in urine , some portion of it may not insinuate itself into the other species of calculi , and not be an attendant on lithate of ammonia alone .
On examining various urinary concretions with a view to this point , I have always found that muriate of ammonia is distinctly traceable in common lithic acid .
It likewise exists in calculi of the mixed phosphates , and in those of oxalate and phosphate of lime ; and is also capable of being detected in that very rare species of calculus , the cystic oxide* .
The quantity , however , is exceedingly minute ; but though perfectly sensible to appropriate re-agents , it is incapable of being detected by any development of ammonia which pure potash can render evident , either to the senses or to vegetable colours .
From these circumstances I am disposed to infer , that the ammonia by which so many of the lithic calculi are distinguished , which have come under my notice , is usually in actual combination with lithic acid , and does not arise from the decomposition of an accessory ingredient , as in the specimens analysed by Mr. BRAND .
Lithate of ammonia , whether natural or artificial , bears a temperature much above that of boiling water without decomposition ; for it does not part with its ammonia when exposed to the heat of melted tin , which requires a temperature of about 440 ?
for its liquefaction .
Its ammonia , or at least the greater part of it , is , however , readily yielded to any dilute acid , particularly on the application of heat ; and from the nature and amount of the saline compound which is formed , the quantity of ammonia existing in the lithate , might , I presume , be ascertained .
The lithic calculi form , as is usual , the most numerous class of concretions in the Norfolk collection , where they amount to nearly a third of the whole number analysed .
But when , in addition , we take those into account , which have lithic acid , or lithate of ammonia as a nucleus , it appears that nearly threefourths of such number ( namely 238 out of 328 ) either consist of the lithates , or have those substances as their nuclei .
The same observation may be made as to about two-thirds , or 27 out of 41 , of the calculi belonging to the Cambridge Hospital , of which the kindness of Dr. HAVILAND , the Regius Professor of Physic , and my other medical friends of that flourishing and well-regulated establishment , allowed me the particular inspection .
In the collection of calculi belonging to the University of Leyden , which I had an opportunity of examining about two years since , by the courtesy of Professor SANDIFORD , 38 out of 49 specimens which it contained , or three-fourths of the whole , bore the character which I have just mentioned .
Dr. HENRY , of Manchester , published a valuable analysis in the MedicoChirurgical Transactions some years since , of 187 calculi ; and of those , 158 , or five-sixths , were also either lithic calculi , or had lithic nuclei* .
The evidence , therefore , which is derived from places far distant from each other , agrees as to the siilarity in nature , of the pimordia , of by far the larger proportion of urinary calculi ; and evinces , that in appreciating the tendency to calculous disorders , and the means by which it is to be obviated , the attention must be particularly directed to the circumstances under which lithic acid is formed , or developed .
The importance of this attention is put in a very striking point of view by Dr. PROUT , when he says , " that if a lithic acid nucleus had not been formed and detained in the bladder , two persons at least out of three who suffer from caloulus , would never have been troubled with that affection .
" A deposition of the phosphates , is not , according to Dr. PROUT 's experience , followed by that of the other materials of calculi ; and in this important particular , my observations , with hardly an exception , agree with his .
Sometimes , indeed , I have seen little studs of lithic acid , or lithate of ammonia , imbedded in the mixed phosphates ; but these appear to have descended from the kidney , as small calculi , and to have attached themselves to the phosphates during their existence in the bladder ; for the laminated form which those phosphates often assume , is not interrupted under such circumstances , but only slightly altered in direction .
Notwithstanding , however , the well marked character of the different species of urinary calculi , or their varied laminae , there is still hardly a single deposit , with which a small portion of some of the other ingredients is not blended ; a circumstance which probably arises , ( as in the case of muriate of ammonia ) from the readiness with which urine parts with a minute portion of most of its component parts .
Of oxalate of lime .
The calculus of oxalate of lime , has been generally designated as the mulberry calculus , from its resemblance , both in shape and colour , to a mulberry .
Its appearance , however , varies from the darkest brown to a milk white , not differing much in colour from the fusible calculus .
Its texture is generally tuberculated , or nodular ; but this substance not unfrequently exists , in bright amber-coloured , or transparent white crystals , of the shape of flattened octohedrons .
This form was noticed by M. FOURCROY , in concretions taken from the bladders of some animals , and was particularly observed by Dr. WOLLASTON , in three human calculi shown him by Dr. MARCET .
There are not less than twenty examples , in the Norwich collection , of such crystallization : and I have seen a few examples elsewhere.-I had occasion to observe a similar form of crystal , in two or three small calculi of oxalate of lime , taken from the bladder 77 of a rat by a medical student some years since , and also in a calculus taken from the bladder of a pig .
I have since found , that concretions of a similar description and form , are by no means uncommon in the former animal .
Of the triple phosphate , or ammoniaco-magnesian phosphate .
This substance is rarely found in its simple state , except as minute , transparent crystals , deposited between other laminae .
The nearest approach to it seems to be in the irregular white , or yellowish , or brownish-white crystallization , which is not unfrequently found on the surface of the mixed phosphates .
This crystallization , I have always found to contain a small quantity of lime ; and it must therefore , I presume , be considered , according to the division adopted by Dr. WOLLASTON , as belonging to the fusible calculi , or those consisting of the mixed phosphates , but possessing , perhaps , the smallest quantity of lime , which enters into the composition of this form of calculus .
Dr. PROUT is inclined to view it as having some unknown , but regular proportion of the two sets of ingredients .
The varying proportions , of the two phosphates seem , indeed , ( as Dr. MARCET very judiciously observes , ) to communicate every degree of fusibility to the calculi which are composed of them .
The usual mode of detecting minute quantities of the triple phosphate , is , I believe , that recommended by Dr. WOLLASTON , of observing the formation of a white line , by the deposition of the crystals of that substance , on any part of the glass vessel containing them , which has been rubbed by a glass tube , or other pointed instrument .
I have employed , however , what appears to me a still more ready mode of ascertaining the formation of the triple phosphate , by placing the fluid expected to contain it , in a watch-glass , in the field of a compound microscope of moderate power .
The triple crystals are thus capable of being observed at the period of their earliest formation ; and their gradual increase of size , and union with each other in various accidental ways , but mostly in a stellated form , come within immediate view , and form an interesting subject of observation.-It is the more desirable to have a ready and unequivocal mode , of determlining the existence of minute quantities of the ammoniacomagnesian phosphate , in the examination of animal bodies , as the production of thatsubstance affords a means , to which it is difficult to find a limit , of ascertaining the existence of ammonia , magnesia , and phosphoric acid .
78 Of phosphate of lime , and the mixed phosphates .
During my analysis of the Norwich collection , I was accidentally led to suspect that carbonate of lime , though very unusual in urinary calculi in a separate and distinct form , was not an unfrequent concomitant of phosphate of lime .
A particular examination of the collection , with a view to this special point , convinced me that such was the case .
The existence of carbonate of lime was evinced by effervescence , on submitting a portion of the powdered calculus , to the action of dilute muriatic acid , in a small tube , after boiling it in distilled water , to extricate the atmospheric air involved in it .
The gas evolved , was readily absorbed by pure potash over water ; while pure ammonia deposited the phosphate of lime , leaving a portion of fluid , from which lime was thrown down by oxalate of ammonia.-The same circumstance , likewise , happened , when the muriatic solution was evaporated to dryness , and the dried portion submitted to distilled water ; the muriate of lime , formed by the solution of the carbonate being dissolved , and the lime precipitated in the form of oxalate , by oxalate of ammonia .
Carbonate of lime , I have likewise seen in the mixed phosphates , and so extensively , as to induce me to think it probable , that phosphate of lime is seldom or never found in urinary concretions , either separately , or in combination with the triple phosphate , uncombined with carbonate .
This circumstance seems to be the less unlikely , when it is considered , that carbonic acid gas has been found to exist in a pure state in urine , and separable by the mere aid of diminished atmospheric pressure .
This being the case , it may fairly be expected to unite with some portion of lime during the evolution of the latter , instead of suffering the whole of it to be employed in forming oxalate , or phosphate of lime .
I am happy in having had the kind assistance of Dr. PROUT , and of Mr. FARADAY of the Royal Institution , in ascertaining the existence of carbonate of lime , in some of the specimens of calculi in which that substance is not usually looked for .
To Dr. PROUT the circumstance was not unexpected ; for he has long considered the existence of carbonate , with phosphate of lime in human concretions , exceedingly likely , though he had not put his ideas to the test of experiment.-An important confirmation of these observations I have likewise met with , in a paper by the distinguished Spanish chemist PROUST , who states , 79 that in every instance of urinary concretion which came under his observation , he found carbonate of lime , when there was phosphate* .
In one or two calculi of mixed phosphates which are in Dr. PROUT 's possession we found carbonate of lime ; and the courtesy of Sir WILLIAM BLIZARD , the chairman of the Board of Curators of the Hunterian Museum , gave me the opportunity of making the same observation , in some of the specimens contained in that noble collection .
I likewise had the particular favour from Dr. BENJAMIN BABINGTON , of not only examining with him , with the same result , several calculi of his small but valuable collection , ( many of which are duplicates of those in the museum of Guy 's Hospital , ) but of being permitted the loan , and full use of his cabinet , which gave me the important opportunity , of instituting more ample experiments , than were at all admissible with the calculi belonging to the Norfolk and Norwich Hospital , where it was of course necessary to be limited to the smallest portion requisite for correct analysis .
I have likewise always found carbonate of lime in combination with phosphate , both in concretions formed in various parts of the body , and in prostatic calculi , ( one of which I examined at the College of Surgeons , ) although both sets of substances are generally regarded as consisting of phosphate of lime alone .
The same observation has been made by Dr. PROUT , as to several similar substances which have come under his notice .
No specimen of cystic or xanthic oxide has yet been found in the Norwich collection .
The calculations which are comprised in this paper , can in many instances , only be regarded as approximating to the truth ; and as depending on future , and more extended observation , for greater accuracy and precision .
The inquiring disposition of the present age , has made us acquainted with the physical features of the principal parts of the united kingdom , whether in relation to power and variety of production , diversity of scenery , or peculiarities of geological character .
A similar degree of talent and energy to that which has been so successfully employed on those objects , may be no less advantageously directed , to an examination of the habits and modes of life , by which the in* Annals de Chimie , tom .
xxxvi .
p. 263 .
80 habitants of different districts are distinguished ; to the description and influence of their food ; to the maladies most prevalent among them ; and the effect of their occupations , in producing , or modifying disease .
These inquiries would lead to the knowledge of many important facts , which would not only be useful in throwing light on the nature of various obscure complaints , and in particular of those of a calculous description , but would have an extensive and advantageous bearing on general pathology .
I h. iv alluded to a probable connection in towns , between the scrophulous , and the calculous diathesis and in the Norfolk district , there is unquestionably a great disposition to every form of scrophula , from a slight enlargement of a submaxillary gland , to the severest states of articular , or pulmonary disease .
Whether , however , the disposition is greater than in other counties ; and how far , in this case , it may be connected with the calculous character of the district ; future observations must determine .
Carrow Abbey near Norwich , June 10 , 1828 .

