An account of the preliminary experiments and ultimate construction of a refracting telescope of 7.8 inches aperture , with a fluid concave lens .
In a letter addressed to DAVIES GILBERT , Esq. President of the Royal Society .
By PETER BARLOW , Esq. F.R.S. Syc .
Read December 18 , 1828 .
I HAVE great pleasure in forwarding to you the following account of the continuation of my experiments on the construction of refracting telescopes with fluid lenses ; and after the interest you have taken in the experiments , and the recommendation you were pleased to give on the subject to the Board of Longitude , through whose aid I have been enabled to pursue them , I cannot but flatter myself that it will be satisfactory to you to submit this communication to the Royal Society , who have done me the honour of publishing my first proposition on this subject in their Transactions .
The instrument I intend more particularly to describe in this paper has a clear aperture of 7.8 inches , exceeding , I think , by about an inch the largest refracting telescope in this country .
Its tube is 11 feet , which together with the eye-piece makes the whole length 12 feet ; but its effective focus is , on the principle explained in my former paper* , 18 feet .
It carries a power of 700 on the closest double stars in SOUTH'S and HERSCHEL'S catalogue ; and the stars are with that power round and defined , although the field is not then so bright as I could desire .
The telescope is mounted on a revolving stand , which works with considerable accuracy as an azimuth and altitude instrument , so as greatly to facilitate the direction of the instrument to any star whose right ascension and declination are given , although it may not be distinctly visible to the naked eye .
To give steadiness to the stand it has been made substantial and heavy , its weight by estimation being 400 pounds , and that of the telescope 130 pounds ; yet its X Phil. Trans. 1828 : Art .
VII .
motions are so smooth , and the power so arranged , that it may be managed by one person with the greatest ease , the star being followed by a slight touch , scarcely exceeding that required for the keys of a piano-forte* .
In the first instance I erected this stand on a platform in my garden , but I soon found that exposure to the weather very much injured its action ; moreover , the difficulty of mounting and dismounting the telescope was considerable , and liable to derange its adjustments .
I was therefore almost under the necessity of erecting an observatory to contain it .
This is an excellent light piece of carpentry by Mr. SMART of Lambeth , 16 feet clear in diameter , with a revolving conical roof rising 9 feet above the walls .
The roof contains 360 superficial feet , and weighs by estimation about 10 cwt .
It is however by a simple apparatus made to revolve and open to any required azimuth , by the application of a force of about 10 or 12 pounds .
The whole is well fitted up , and forms a neat light building , which by permission of Hlis Lordship the MLaster General is erected on a piece of Ordnance ground adjoining my premises , commanding an entire view of the heavens for all altitudes exceeding 10 ? .
Having thus stated generally the nature of my operations , I shall proceed to explain them more particularly under distinct heads in the following pages .
Preliminary Experiments .
In my former paper ( Phil. Trans. 1828 : Art .
VII .
) I have endeavoured to show the effect which opening the lenses to different distances produces on the secondary spectrum -my first object , therefore , in these experiments was to ascertain by actual observation the best position of the lenses for the diminution of this defect .
In order the better to classify my experiments on this head , it will be best to refer to the original formula for the destruction of colour , given in my paper in the Phil. Trans. 1827 : Art .
XV .
in which I have shown , that with open lenses we have , when the colour vanishes , ( fd ) .
= .
If ' Where f focal length plate lens f ' = focal length fluid lens -= dispersive ratio d distance of the lenses Or calling fd =nf = remaining focus of plate beyond the fluid , this becomes nSf ( 1 ) or f ' nf ( 2 ) If now we callf " the resulting focus from this combination , reckoning from 1 &lt; , 1 the fluid , we have by common principles =Whence f _ " nf resulting focus ( 3). .
Consequentlyf " ' =n .
= equivalent focus ( 4 ) I _= '~ )f= -whole length ( 5 ) From which equations all the relations between these six quantities , viz. f , ^/ ' , , , " ' , n , and 8 are readily determined ; where it may be observed that f " ' is the focal length of a telescope on the usual construction to which this telescope is equivalent , and I the whole length of the tube .
If we consider 1 , n , and 8 as given quantities , we have f= ( n ) =platefocus ( 6 ) n I1 -v from which f ' , " , and f " ' may be determined .
It is obvious from this last equation , since n and I may be assumed at pleasure , ( at least within all practicable limits , ) that this form of telescope will admit of great variety of proportions between the different quantities , and that some classes of these have a practical advantage over others may be reasonably expected .
From the experiments I have made , it appears to me that the secondary spectrum is reduced as the lenses are opened , or as n decreases , but that the general field is enlarged and improved by increasing the value of n. F2 35 however directed my attention principally to the destruction of the secondary spectrum ; and with this view I ordered two 41-inch tubes , 5 feet long , to be fitted up to receive in succession lenses of different focal powers , depending principally upon the value given to n , which I assumed as follows : viz. n =.60 , n =.55 , n =.50 , n =.45 , n =.40 , the length in each case being 60 inches .
Resting on these numbers , the following values were determined , the plate glass having an index.515 , the fluid.634 , and the dispersive ratio.308 .
Tabular value of the different quantities .
n =.60 = 39.72 f ' = 46.42 , f " = 48.97 f " ' = 81.6 n =.55 f= 35.53 f ' = 34.67 , f " = 44.11 f"'= 80.2 n =.50 f= 33.30 f ' = 27.02 , f " = 43.35 f " = 86.7 n =.45 f= 30.30 f ' = 19.91 , f " = 43.20 ft = 96.0 n =.40 f= 25.62 f ' = 13.30 , f " = 44.56 f " ' = 111.4 I soon found , however , that it was impossible to get all the lenses of equally good material and figure ; and as , in consequence , one defectmmight be mistaken for another , I altered my plan , and availed myself of the two telescopes I had constructed before , in one of which n =.50 , and in the other n =.54 .
These two I had fitted with other lenses carefully made , making in one the value of n =.60 , and in the other n =.40 .
I had also a new one made with the value of n =.47 ; and after a careful and patient examination of all these five , I determined , and I was supported in that determination by others , that the best effect was produced , at least as regarded the object I had in view , when the distance of the lenses was about one half the focal length of the plate lens , and with these proportions , therefore , I determined to construct my 8-inch telescope .
Construction of the Telescope .
Having as above stated decided that the distance of the lenses ought to be about half or a little more than half the focal length of the plate lens , I determined upon a focal length of 78 inches for my plate lens , and 59.8 inches for that of my fluid ; which at the distance of 40 inches would produce a focal length of 104 inches , a total length of 12 feet , and an equivalent focus of 18 36 feet .
For the curves of the parallel meniscus checks for containing the fluid , I proposed 30 inches and +144 inches , the latter towards the eye , and then computing the proper curves for the plate by the formula given in my paper , Phil. Trans. 1827 : Art .
XV .
I found the proper curves to be 56.4 and 144 , and to these curves Messrs W. and T. GILBERT worked the several glasses and the circular ring .
Mr. DONKIN undertook to draw the tubes , which I was desirous of having 8 inches in the interior diameter , but his nearest treblet was only 7.8 inches , to which size therefore I was confined .
The tube was drawn in three pieces , each 3 feet 8 inches , making in all 11 feet ; and to this the pipe for the eye-piece being attached , gave the full length 12 feet : two of the above pieces of 7.8-inch tube are strongly and accurately jointed by a lining piece , and the other part is made to screw on for more conveniently getting in and adjusting the ui lens which is near the s is joint , and is enclosed in a cell which screws on to an interior tube 5 inches in diameter , and 3 feet 6 inches long , sliding in two collars properly turned for the purpose , having a notch in each to receive a feather attached externally to the tube to preserve a parallel motion .
The other end of this tube of course reaches to within about 4 feet of the eye end of the large tube , and to the former is fixed a brass nut properly fitted to receive a screw on the end of a brass rod 42 feet in length ; this rod works in a coupling box or collar , fixed on the inside of the large tube about 1 foot 9 inches from the end , and the end of the rod passes through the front end of the large tube , where it is cut square to receive a milled head or a universal joint key , by means of which the tube carrying the cell may be moved backwards or forwards ; and the adjustment is thus made for colour in the first instance , and afterwards the focus is obtained by the usual rack motion .
The difficulty of centering two lenses at so great a distance from each other is considerable , if not properly provided for .
In this instance the front lens is placed in a thin detached cell and confined by a counter cell .
It is then placed with its first cell in another which screws and unscrews at the object end of the telescope as usual ; except that the last cell is sufficiently large to admit of adjusting the interior one carrying the lens by means of two pair of opposite pushing screws .
These provisions being made , the telescope is placed opposite to a proper object , the centering is produced by trial , by means of 37 these screws ; and when every thing is right , the cell is made fast by four other screws , to prevent any trifling blow or other slight accident putting the glass again out of adjustment .
In this state the telescope may be said to be completed ; it has of course to be furnished with a finder , proper eyepieces , an apparatus for illuminating the field , &amp;c. , as in the usual cases .
With respect to enclosing the fluid , the following , after various trials , appears to me to be quite effectual .
After the best position has been determined practically for the checks forming the fluid lens , these with the ring between them ground and polished accurately to the same curves , are applied together , and taken into an artificial high temperature , exceeding the greatest at which the telescope is ever expected to be used .
After remaining here with the fluid some time , the space between the glasses is completely filled , immediately closed , cooled down by evaporation , and removed into a lower temperature : by this means a sudden condensation takes place , an external pressure is brought on the checks , and a bubble formed inside , which is of course filled with the vapour of the fluid ; the excess of the atmospheric pressure beyond that of the vapour being afterwards always acting externally to preserve contact ; the extreme edges are then sealed by the serum of human blood , or , which I believe to be equally efficacious , by strong fish glue and some thin pliable metal surface : by this process I have every reason to believe the lens becomes as durable as any lens of solid glass , At all events I have the satisfaction of stating that my first 3-inch telescope has now been completed more than fifteen months , and that no change whatever has taken place in its performance , nor the least perceptible alteration either in the quantity or quality of the fluid .
I must think , therefore , that the advantages to be gained by this means of supplying the flint glass are such as to entitle the experiments to an impartial examination ; and I cannot doubt , if the prejudice against the use of fluids could be removed , that well directed practice would soon lead to the construction of the most perfect and powerful instruments on this principle , at a comparatively small expense .
I am for instance convinced , judging from what has been paid for large object glasses , that my telescope , telescope stand , and the building for observation , with every other requisite convenience , have been constructed for a less sum than would be demanded for the object glass only , if one could be produced of the 38 same diameter , of plate and flint glass ; and this surely is a consideration which ought to have some weight , and encourage a perseverance in the principle of construction .
The telescope and the particulars relative to it being thus described , it only remains for me to state the tests to which I have subjected it , and its performance in those cases .
The first observations of this kind are commonly on Polaris ; the small star here is of course brilliant and distinct ; it is seen best with a power of 120 , but is visible with a power of 700 .
The small star in Aldebaran is very distinct with a power of 120 .
The small star in a Lyrae is distinctly visible with the same power .
The small star called by Mr. HERSCHEL Debilissima , between 4e and 5 Lyre , -whose existence , he says , could not even be suspected in either the 5 or 7feet equatorial , and invisible also with the 7 and 10-feet reflectors of 6 and 9 inches aperture , but seen double with the 20-feet reflector , -is seen very satisfactorily double with this telescope .
t Persei , marked as double in SoUTH and HERSCHELES catalogue at the distance of 28 " , with another small star at the distance of 3 ' 57 " both n p , is seen distinctly sixfold , four of the small stars being within a considerably less distance than the remote one of -marked in the catalogue : and rejecting this remote star , theprincipaland the other four small stars form a miniature representation of Jupiter andhisSateltes , three of them being nearly in a line on one side , and the othe er on the opposite : there are also other small stars within the same distance , but the most remarkable are those arranged in a line as above stated .
A number of other small stars which are spoken of as difficult to observe from their minuteness , are seen more or less distinctly with this instrument .
Amongst the closer and larger stars I have tried the telescope upon those commonly selected as tests , viz : , Castor ; which is distinctly double with 120 , and well opened and stars perfectly round with 360 and 700 .
-y Leonis and Z Piscium are seen , with the same powers , equally round and distinct .
39 Ins Bootis the small star is well separated from the larger , and its blue colour well marked with a power of 360 .
C Coronae Borealis is seen double with a power of 360 and 700 ; 52 Orionis , 2 Orionis , and others of the same class , are also well defined with the.same powers .
Still , however , it must be admitted that the telescope is not so competent to the opening of the close stars , as it is powerful in bringing to light the more minute luminous points .
Of the planets , I have only had an opportunity of trying the telescope on Venus , Saturn , and Mars ; and the latter is too low to firnish a good test .
Venus is beautifully white and well defined with a power of 120 , but shows some colour with 360 .
Saturn with the 120 power is a very brilliant object , the double ring and belts being well and satisfactorily defined , and with the 360 power it is still very fine .
The moon also is remarkably beautiful , the edges and the shadows being well marked , while the quantity of light is such as to bring to view every minute distinction of figure and shade .
Description of the Telescope Stand .
A correct representation of the stand , with the telescope upon it within the building , is given in Plate III .
The fixed base is a strong built oaken curb six feet in diameter and six inches broad , imbedded on a circular brick foundation : to this is screwed an interior fillet or ribbon , projecting higher than the other part of the curb , and serving the double purpose of keeping the stand to its centre and of receiving graduations to degrees and quarters , thus forming an azimuth circle .
The outer part of the curb is beveled to the centre , and on this run three cast-iron rollers made to the same bevel : by these means the principal azimuth motion of the instrument is effected .
At the corners of the triangular base are three strong cast-iron sockets for receiving the ends of three oaken bars four inches square , which form the moveable base of the stand , the plate below each socket being a detached casting , screw-bolted through the timber and upper side , admitting thereby of being screwed up and tightened , in case any shrinkage takes place in the wood .
The front socket is different from the others , as it forms one piece with an upright socket which carries a strong oaken stancheon , to the upper part of which the machinery described below is attached .
This stancheon having to support a great part of the weight of the telescope , at least in some positions of the latter , is strongly braced back by an oaken beam to the opposite ledge of the triangular base .
The principal upright part of the stand are two oaken bars framed or secured together in the middle and on the top , and turning on strong iron bolts in two cast-iron ears below ; about which bolts this part , called the swinging frame , has a motion .
These bars are cased on the outside by grain-cut oaken facings , and thus form two grooves in which an interior frame slides freely .
This frame , on one of its interior sides carries a fixed racket , not seen in the plate , its whole length ; and between the two connecting pieces in the centre of the swinging frame , is a spring pall which catches each tooth of the racket as it passes , being intended to prevent any accident in case of the breaking of a rope when the telescope is elevated .
To the pall is attached a string which descends near the upright stancheon ; and when it is necessary to let down the telescope , this string is pulled by one hand , and the other having hold of the proper apparatus , the descending motion takes place in the most gentle and easy manner possible .
On the upper part of the front upright stancheon are two strong wroughtiron checks , terminating about two inches above it , having two circular holes -ths of an inch diameter , in which turns , as in two collars , a strong iron screw 1I inch in diameter , having two threads to the inch : on this works a strong brass nut with corresponding threads , and to this nut the frame which carries the telescope , and is called the bearing frame , is properly united , turning on a moveable joint near the screw .
The screw is turned by four long cross handles , seen in the plate , by means of which the azimuth motion of a star or planet is followed .
The length of the screw is about 11 inches and of the nut 3 inches , leaving a motion of 8 inches , which enables a star to be followed for a considerable time without moving the stand : the turning point on which this motion of the frame takes place , is exactly in the centre of the upper part of the interior or sliding frame , where a pin is fixed , which traverses in a parallel groove under the bearing frame ; but to prevent confusion this is not shown in the plate .
On the upper part of the same interior frame are fixed two cast-iron rollers , on which the bearing frame rests , serving to relieve the machine of the friction that would otherwise take place when the telescope is raised or lowered .
The two iron rods seen on each side , turning in two eyes below and adjustable at top by nuts and screws , were intended to serve as braces and to preserve steadiness ; they are not , however , essential , as the instrument has every requisite stability without them .
Such is a general description of the stand ; the manner of working it will be understood from what follows .
Below the fixed cross pieces , in the middle of the swinging frame , is a double fixed pulley , and to the lower part , on the inside of the sliding frame , is another double pulley , which rises and falls with the sliding frame .
The end of the rope is fixed to the cross piece , descends and passes over one of the lower pulleys , thence over one of the upper , again descends , passes over the other lower pulley , then over the upper pulley , thence again to another single fixed pulley on the diagonal brace ; it then passes over the lower barrel , which is turned by means of the wheel , pinion , and handle , shown in the plate .
The power gained by the pulleys is 4 to 1 , by the wheel and pinion 4 to 1 , and by the barrel and handle 4 to 1 , making in all 64 to 1 .
By these means the telescope may be raised even at its heaviest purchase with great facility .
This part of the machinery , however , is only intended to bring the telescope to an approximate altitude ; after which , the part employed for bringing a star into the field , and for following it in altitude motion , is as follows .
At the extreme end of the bearing frame is a fixed pulley : to the back of the sliding frame , another ; to the front of the same frame is another similar one ; and a fourth at the other end of the bearing frame .
The rope is first made fast at the extreme end , thten passes over the pulley at the back of the sliding frame , thence over the pulley at the extreme end ; whence it comes directly to the upper barrel ; and after a few turns about this barrel , passes to the pulley on the front of the sliding frame , and returning passes over the pulley in the bearing frame near the upright stancheon , then over a fixed pulley on the brace : to the end of the rope is attached an iron weight of fifty-six pounds , which passes through a hole in the floor and hangs suspended in a well-hole below , serving thus to take in the slack of the rope , thereby keeping it always tight on the barrel , and also serving as a counterpoise to the swinging frame 42 when thrown out beyond its perpendicular position , as is necessary to bring the instrument to small angles of elevation .
This counterpoise is not , however , sufficient ; another therefore is introduced , by suspending a chain from the swinging frame to the front stancheon ; to the centre of which a 56-pound weight is suspended , passing over another pulley on the brace into the same well-hole : by this contrivance the tension of the chain increases as it approaches most to a straight line ; that is , when the frame is thrown furthest out , and where its weight acts with greater force .
By a slight adjustment of the length of the chain and weight , we may thus produce a perfect equilibrium in the whole machine , and the telescope is of course obedient to the slightest power sufficient to overcome the friction .
Things being thus equipoised , in order to render the motion as gentle as possible , a wheel and pinion are attached to the barrel last mentioned , similar to the one already described , but with four cross handles like those belonging to the screw .
The power thus gained is 2 to 1 by the pulleys , 4 to 1 by the wheel and pinion , and about 9 to I by the handles , equivalent to 72 to 1 .
The slightest touch therefore of one of these handles will produce a change of elevation of the telescope , either to increase or diminish it , accordingly as that motion tends to pull in or out the swinging frame .
The operation therefore of putting the instrument on a star is : first , to swing round the whole stand towards the star , on the circular curb ; then to bring it nearly to its proper altitude by the apparatus first described ; then , being seated at a proper height , the eye being applied to the finder , with the handle belonging to the screw in one hand and that belonging to the altitude motion in the other , the star is brought immediately to the centre of the field , and is of course then in the large telescope .
The observer is thus seated at perfect ease and follows the star at pleasure , one of the four handles on each side being always ready to receive a touch of the finger , which is sufficient for the purpose .
I have observed that this stand acts with considerable accuracy as an altitude and azimuth instrument : it may therefore be proper to say a few words on this subject .
Such a purpose was not contemplated in its construction , and therefore , notwithstanding the usual accuracy of millwright workmanship , it could hardly have been expected to find the stand susceptible of such a degree G2 43 of accuracy ; and it will not of course be understood that I am now speaking of extreme astronomical accuracy .
I found , however , the action so complete , that I determined to try how far it could be useful in this way .
The lower curb was therefore carefully divided by hand into degrees and quarters , the meridian obtained by the best means in my power , an index fixed to the bottom of the frame and adjusted to the zero of the circle .
A graduated circle , not seen in the plate , was then attached to the bering frame with a suspened plummet , th e telescope put upon a meridian star whose altitude was known , and the arc adjusted accordingly .
With these apparently rough means , and another for converting right ascension and declination into azimuth an altitude ; and with the help of an excellent pocket chronoimeter by Messrs. PARKINSON and FRODSHAM , my son , who has acquired great dexterity in the use of the instrument , can at any time select the right ascension and declination of the star from the catalogue , convert these into azimuth and altitude , direct the instrument towards the object , and be seated quite at his ease observing , in three minutes .
In a bright night , and for observing a known star this is of course unnecessary ; but for less conspicuous stars , which are scarcely distinguishable except by their catalogue positions , as also for finding any star before daylight is quite gone , or a planet in the day-time , these means , although far short of those afforded by an accurate equatorial , are very serviceable .
It should be observed that the stand was originally designed to work from the horizon to the zenith , which it is capable of doing ; but I have limited its present action to an altitude of 65 ?
, this being the greatest height I can obtain without cutting the upper curb of my observatory roof , which I am rather unI .
willing to do , for obtaining what is at best , with such an instrument , a very inconvenient position for observation , Description of the Observatory .
It has been already stated that this room is circular , having a clear diameter of 16 feet .
It is constructed as follows : A foundation wall 4 feet deep of 14-inch brickwork is first laid , and on this is imbedded a circular wooden curb in two thicknesses , each 2 inches deep and 4 broad , properly united with bolts , screws , and keys .
Another exactly similar curb , united in the same way , forms the 44 upper part of the wall ; and between these two are mortised 17 upright stancheons , each 2 inches by 4 ; and round the middle are framed other pieces of the same dimensions , viz. 2 inches by 4 , cut also circular .
These form the framing , which is lastly covered with inch boards properly tongued to keep out the wind and rain .
Four windows are introduced , the size of the upper divisions , as seen in the plate , with a door not seen , being in the part supposed to be removed to show the instrument .
The height of the boards is 6 feet 8 inches above the brickwork , and 7 feet 3 inches above the floor .
In another curb , exactly like those already described , are placed 12 iron rollers , which run on a circular plate of iron laid on the upper fixed curb .
On the interior face of this moveable curb are also fixed 12 other iron rollers , which keep the curb to its centre by running against a plate of hoop iron , properly fixed to a fillet nailed to , but projecting above , the upper fixed curb .
This moveable curb is , as we have seen , 16 feet 8 inches exterior diameter , and forms the base of the roof .
The latter is formed of about 60 six-inch boards cut nearly diagonally , the broader end being securely nailed to the bottomn curb of the roof , and the smaller to an upper curb 2 feet 8 inches in diameter , the boards being each 12 feet in length and securely dowelled together .
Two rafters , each 12 feet long , 2 inches broad , and 4 inches deep , placed parallel to each other from the upper to the lower curb , and 16{ inches asunder , form an opening for observation ; these are closed at other times by two shutters which turn on hinges in opposite ways the whole length of the roof .
The joints of the boards of the roof are covered externally by canvass fillets of 1t inch in breadth , secured by white lead in oil ; and lastly , the whole is protected by three thick coats of paint .
The force necessary to overcome the friction of the roof is sixty pounds , and the motion is produced by an inch-and-a-half tarred rope passing externally round the moveable curb under the projecting eaveboards , which protect it from the weather : it then passes .
over two guide pulleys , and descends to a drum about 8 inches in diameter , turned to the proper ?
curve for surging ; it takes three turns round this drum , which is fixed to an axle that passes inside ; this axle carries a toothed wheel , which is worked by a pinion and handle , seen in the plate .
The power thus gained is 8 to 1 ; so that to move the roof ought to require but a force of eight pounds : but in consequence of the extra friction , it practically requires twelve pounds : it may , however , be turned round with comparative ease in about a minute .
The two ends of the rope , as will have been understood , are fixed to the upper curb , crossing each other about 2 feet , viz. double the distance of the guide pulleys where they pass through holes in the curb to the inside , one of them being left so as to allow of taking in the slack of the rope , which is requisite in the beginning : but after being in use a few days this operation is no longer necessary , the rope being every where protected from the weather ; viz. the part round the curb by the eaves of the roof , and the two descending parts by an external casing of wood .
As the stand will work from very nearly a horizontal position to a vertical one , it was at first intended that , after the building was completed , the upper curb should be cut away , on one side , the breadth of the shutters , and its place supplied by an iron bolt ; and thus , by having a shutter in the upper flat part of the roof , the instrument might have been brought vertical .
This , however , has not been done ; so that at present the limit of observation is between 10 ?
and 650 ; and through this range the instrument may be managed with the greatest possible facility by one person .
Such is the general description of my operations ; and for the rest , I have only to express my hope , that this attempt to introduce a new principle of construction for achromatic telescopes will be examined with candour and impartiality : that the instrument is so complete and delicate in its action as the most perfect refractors which constitute the chefs-d'oeuvre of opticians , will scarcely be expected .
To produce such results requires a great deal of well directed practice , and selections from numerous attempts .
I trust , however , I may say that the principle has been shown to be practicable , and that the result is by no means unsatisfactory : and when I state , that , with less than an ounce of the sulphuret of carbon , of the value of three shillings , I have supplied , in point of material , the place of the most perfect lens that could be procured of flint glass 8 inches in diameter , it will at least be admitted that the success of the experiment is not altogether uninteresting to the patrons and promoters of astronomical science .
I will only add , that I should feel no hesitation in undertaking the construction of another telescope of double the dimensions of the present .

