XIV .
On the temporary magnetic effect induced in iron bodies by rotation .
In a Letter to J. F. W. HERSCHEL , Esq. Sec. R. S. by PETER BARLOW , F. R. S. Communicated April 14th , 1825 .
Read May 5 , 1825 .
DEAR SIR , IT is more than two years since , in a conversation I had with you on subjects connected with magnetism , you enquired what effect I thought might result from giving to an iron ball a rapid rotation ?
The subject however dropped , and it did not occur to me again , till in some speculative views in which I was lately engaged , as to the cause of the rotation of the earth 's magnetic poles , the apparent irregularity of the terrestrial directive powers , &amp;c. I was led to consider that , probably , rotation might have a certain influence .
We know that iron is rendered magnetic by various processes , as drilling , hammering , &amp;c. and it was possible also by rotation ; your query now occurred to my mind ; and knowing at the same time that Mr. CHRISTIE had found a permanent change in the magnetic state of an iron plate by a mere change of position on its axis , it seemed highly probable this change , due only to a simple inversion , would be increased by a rapid rotation .
In this respect , however , I was deceived ; for I found afterwards , that all the effect that was produced was merely temporary ; and if any permanent change did take place , it was too small in my cast iron shell to be observed with the small compass I employed in these experiments .
Being however thus urged to the inquiry , as well by my own speculative views as by your query , and encouraged by Mr. CHRISTIE'S results , I resolved to put the idea to the test of experiment , and to attempt it at once upon a scale that should decide the question in the first instance .
As soon as I had determined upon the experiment , I found an excellent opportunity of making the first trial , through the kindness of Generals CUPPAGE and MILLAR , of the Royal Artillery , who gave me permission to have a s1 inch mortar shell fixed to the mandrel of one of the powerful turning lathes worked by the steam engine in the Royal Arsenal , This having been done , and the compass properly placed near the shell , I turned the shell slowly round , in order to ascertain whether in this case , as in Mr. CHRISTIE'S , there were any effects depending on a change of position ; but if there were any , it was so small in the cast iron shell as not to have been rendered sensible with the small compass I employed .
The wheel being now put in geer , the shell commenced its revolutions at the rate of 640 per minute , and the needle was deflected out several degrees , at which it remained perfectly stationary while the ball was in motion : but it returned immediately to its original bearing as soon as the motion ceased .
I now inverted the motion of the shell , and the needle was deflected about the same quantity the contrary way , observe .
ing a similar steady direction as in the former case ; but as before , it returned to its original bearing the moment the motion was discontinued .
These experiments were repeated several times before some scientific officers of the artillery and engineers , always with the same results , I afterwards found , that the needle being placed in different situations , its motion was reversed , although the direction of motion in the shell was the same ; the amount of the whole deflection also differed very considerably according to the situation of the compass , its direction in some cases having been wholly reversed , while in others no perceptible motion was produced , although the rotation of the shell remained the same both in direction and in speed .
I was therefore desirous of undertaking a regular set of experiments , in order to reduce the several apparently anomalous results to some certain law of action ; and as the shell in question was rather too heavy for us to feel a perfect security , as to personal safety , when it was in rapid rotation , and moreover , as its effects were larger than seemed necessary for the purpose , I now selected a Shrapnel shell of 8 inches in diameter , which weighed only so lbs. and chose .
another lathe , whose axis was nearly north and south , that in the former instance having been east and west .
I had also a table made with a circular hole in it , which I could place at any height above , below , or about the centre of the ball ; I could also set my compass on any azimuth on the same , and observe the effects of the direct and reversed motion ; but after several days observations , I found the results so complicated , and the needle so much influenced by the iron work of the lathe and other machinery , that it would be useless to proceed , unless I could contrive to produce the rotation out of the way of any disturbing cause of the kind above mentioned .
This also , through the kindness of Colonel Sir ALEXANDER DICKSON , and the officers above named , I was enabled to 319 ' accomplish ; and having got the machine erected on my own premises , I was soon enabled to clear up the difficulties which had hitherto so much embarrassed my proceedings , although even here , in the first instance , I found some results very difficult to explain .
The machine I now employed is shown in the annexed drawing .
Plate XXIV .
ABCD is a strong wooden frame , resembling that of a common electrical machine , the shell S being hung in the same manner as the cylinder ; the axis is made in two parts of gun metal , and very strong ; ss are two strong screw bolts and nuts , which were used for fixing the frame firmly to the top of the table , the bolt passing through from below .
EGF is a substantial table with its feet sunk into the ground , and the floor of the room cut away where they passed through , in order to prevent any effect of shaking on the stand carrying the compass .
The stand consisted of an upright pedestal filled with sand , to render it steady , and to this was fixed the table ML , with a semicircular hole cut in it , so that it might be placed near the shell .
This table might be elevated or depressed at pleasure , and it was divided into the points , quarter points , &amp;c. of the compass .
By means of different holes bored in the top of the table , the machine might be placed N and S , E and W , &amp;c. at pleasure , and the motion of the shell be inverted by turning the handle to the right or left .
The large wheel is six times the diameter of the small one ; and as it might easily be turned twice in a second , the number of revolutions of the shell were gradually about 720 per minute .
The little apparatus seen above the shell , is a small stand and sliding wire , carrying a common lamp glass , in which a very small dipping needle was suspended by silk ; and when the lamp glass was out of the ring , the latter served for setting the horizontal needle on , so as to bring it over any required point of the shell .
It should be observed that the pedestal was moveable , and might therefore be placed on either side of the machine .
The stand and upright figure 2 , is one of two large magnets ultimately employed for neutralizing the needle .
The machine being thus prepared , I screwed it down ; first with its axis in the magnetic meridian , and then placed the compass successively at the several points on the table all round , and registered the deviation produced at each , with the motion of the shell direct and reversed .
I then removed it , and placed the axis east and west , and again registered in the same manner ; but the results were very irregular with respect to quantity .
Although I obtained some uniformity regarding direction only , viz. in both cases I found four points of change at about 30s from each extremity of the axis , or four points of non action .
For example , when the axis was in the meridian from N 30o E to N 30s W , the motion of the needle arising from the rotation was made to the right .
From N 3o ?
W to S 30 ?
W to the left .
From S o ?
W to S 3o ?
E to the right .
From S o30 E to N 3o0 E to the left ; the direction of motion in the shell being the same ; with the direction of motion reversed , the deviation was reversed also .
While at these four points themselves , the needle had no motion .
I tried also a variety of other positions , but I could obtain no such results as to lead to a concise expression of _3 1 the effect , and for this reason I shall not trouble you with the detail of them .
It at length occurred to me , that the reason of my failure arose from the compound influence under which the needle was placed , viz. that of the iron ball and of the earth ; I therefore now neutralized it from the effect of both , by means of magnets properly disposed , adjusting it always before the rotation to a direction tangential to the ball , so that whatever effect was produced at each point , might at least become decided as to its direction .
I now immediately arrived at that kind of general law I had been in search of ; for I found when things were thus arranged , that whatever might be the direction of the axis of rotation , if the motion of the ball were made towards the needle , the north end of the latter was attracted ; and if from the needle , the north end was repelled by the iron , the points immediately in the axis ( when of course the motion of the shell was parallel to the needle ) being neutral , or those at which the change of direction took place ; in other words , if the motion of the shell continue the same , and the compass be successively placed all round the ball , in that semi-circle ( from one axis to the other ) in which the motion is towards the needle , the north end approaches the ball , and in the other semicircle it recedes , or the south end approaches ; the points of non action being in the two extremities of the axis , and those of maximum effect in two opposite points at right angles to the axis ; in which two latter the needle , when properly neutratralized , points directly to the centre of the ball .
This will be perhaps better understood by reference to fig. 3 , where S is the shell , ab its axis , and ns , ns , &amp;c. the needle in its various positions prior to the motion , and d s ' , n 's ' , &amp;c. its direction as resulting from the motion ; the rotation of the shell being from c towards d. .
of course with the rotation reversed , the effect will be reversed also .
Now this effect you will , I think , find to be perfectly consistent with the view you have taken of the subject , in your letter of Jan. s1th , where you say in reference to your former query , and to the views I then entertained , " I should rather have expected a diminution of the magnetic polarity , commensurate to the rapidity of rotation and a change in the direction of the magnetic axis of the globe , from parallelism to that of the earth , to a position somewhere intermediate between that and the axis of rotation , but approaching nearer the latter as the velocity increased , &amp;c. " The fact is , that the needle in my experiments being under no influence prior to the rotation from either the iron or the earth , the direction which it takes up in consequence of the motion , enables us to discover the precise direction of the new forces thus impressed upon the shell , and it will be seen immediately to indicate a polarization of the latter in the direction c d ; that is , in a direction perpendicular to the axis of motion , and to the plane passing through that axis and the actual poles of the ball .
You will of course understand that I do not mean that such a polarization actually takes place ; I mean merely that the cohesive power of the iron is such , as to resist in a ' certain degree the inductive powers of the earth , whereby the magnetic forces are changed , as you have suggested , from their original direction , parallel to the magnetic axis of the ball into a position oblique to it , which oblique forces being resolved into two , the one parallel to the original axis , and the other perpendicular to it , and the former being nearly neutralized by the magnets used for the purpose in the first instance , the perpendicular forces will act upon the needle in the same manner as if the ball were really polarized in the direction above alluded to .
Having got this view of the subject , I soon found that many of my former results , which appeared to have scarcely any conformity among themselves , were perfectly consistent with this hypothesis : of these the experiments given above , before the needle was neutralized , may be mentioned .
In these I found the point of change to be at about o30 on each side of the axis , so that the arcs in which similar effects were produced were divided into the unequal portions of 60 ?
, 12o ?
, 60 ?
, and 1o20 , which appeared to be anomalous ; but according to the view now taken of the subject , this is perfectly consistent ; it is precisely what ought to happen according to the law tan .
dip .
=2 tan .
mag .
lat. and which actually takes place on the earth .
That is in passing from the magnetic equator 30o towards the pole , the dipping needle has actually described a quadrant , as referred to its position at the equlator ; and it would describe a quadrant , in an opposite direction in going 3o ?
towards the other pole ; so that in passing through 60 ?
the needle is actually inverted ; but if we start from mag .
lat. 30 ?
through the pole , we must pass through an arc of 120 ?
before the direction of the needle is inverted , and the same in the other half of the meridian ; and in like manner by referring the motion of my needle as induced by the rotation of the shell to its original magnetic direction , it is obvious that I ought to have found , as I actually did before I was aware of the cause , a point of change at 30 ?
distance , on each side of the meridian passing through the axis ; which meridian , as respects the induced power , is actually the equator of the new magnetic sphere .
To render this more obvious , let us refer to fig. 4 , in which AB represents the axis of rotation of the shell , the black lines the needle in its natural direction , and the dotted lines the direction the needle has a tendency to assume according to the law above named , in consequence of the magnetism impressed by the rotation in the line n s. Beginning at the point A , if we say the motion is from left to right , that is from n to n ' , it will be from right to left at 600 , 75 ?
, go0 , &amp;c. till we arrive again at 0o ?
; at this point as at the former the new power is exerted in the actual direction of the needle , and if it were greater than its natural directive power , it would wholly invert it ; in this case it would pass to either hand ; but as the new power cannot invert it , it has no tendency to deflect it , and it therefore remains stationary .
Thus one of the results which was at first the most perplexing , serves to confirm the law we have established .
On similar principles , if we conceive a circle passing vertically from 90 ?
to 90o , and if the needle be perfectly neutralized at different positions in this circle , and rendered parallel to the axis at each , then in every case the needle will have a tendency to take up a position directly at right angles to the axis of the shell , and it will point in opposite directions at certain parts of this circle : thus , if to fix the idea we conceive the axis to be in the meridian , and the motion of the shell from west to east , then at the east point of the horizon the needle will point to the west , and it will do the .
same at all points between the horizon and an altitude of 60 ?
; beyond this , the north end will point to the east till we have passed the zenith 30 ?
on the west side ; and then again from this point to the west horizon the north end will again point to the west ; and similar changes will take place below the ball .
This , which is a necessary consequence of our hypothesis , is completely verified by experiment .
It will of course be understood , that the supposition of the axis being in the meridian is merely to fix the idea ; for a similar motion takes place whatever direction the axis of the shell may have .
It is presumed , that what has now been stated is sufficient , without referring to any further experiments , to establish the principal fact adverted to in this letter , viz. that when any iron body is put in rapid rotation on any line not coinciding with its magnetic axis , a temporary derangement takes place in its magnetic powers , which in its effects is equivalent to a new axis of polarization perpendicular to the plane passing through its axis of polarization and rotation .
I have stated in the beginning of this letter the motives which led me to undertake these experiments ; but notwithstanding I have certainly found a stronger effect produced by the rotation than I anticipated , yet it does not appear to be of a kind to throw any new light upon the difficult sub .
ject of terrestrial magnetism .
I think there are strong reasons for assuming , that the magnetism of the earth is of that kind which we call induced magnetism ; but at present we have no knowledge of the inductive principle , and are therefore unable to judge , how far the earth 's rotation may be influential in producing those discrepancies from the general laws which are known to exist .
The formula , which we owe to Mr. BIOT and to Mr. KRAFT , expressing the law of the dips in different latitudes , viz. tan .
dip .
=2 tang .
mag .
lat. certainly agrees with observation in many cases , but the variation computed on the same principles , and which necessarily ought also to coincide with observation , is widely in error .
It seems therefore very obvious that some disturbing cause exists , but whether any part of it can be attributed to the rotation of the earth is , notwithstanding the preceding results , very doubtful ; at the same time I may perhaps be allowed to observe , that one of the essential conditions for the production of such an effect has place in the earth , viz. that it does not revolve about its polarized axis ; and if the inductive principle through which it receives its magnetism be exterior to itself , then it would follow almost of necessity that some such an effect should take place .
I beg however to be understood as advancing nothing in this letter , beyond the mere experimental fact above stated , which , even if it should find no useful application , may perhaps be thought sufficiently curious to be recorded in the Transactions of the Royal Society .
PETER BARLOW .
3a7

