VIII .
Notice on the Iguanodon , a newly discovered fossil reptile , from the sandstone of Tilgate forest , in Sussex .
By GIDEON MANTELL , F. L. S. and M. G. S. Fellow of the College of Surgeons , &amp;c. In a Letter to DAVIES GILBERT , Esq. M. P. V. P. R. S. &amp;c. &amp;c. &amp;c. Communicated by D. GILBERT , Esq. Read February io , 1825 .
SIR , I AVA^L myself of your obliging offer to lay before the Royal Society , a notice of the discovery of the teeth and bones of a fossil herbivorous reptile , in the sandstone of Tilgate forest ; in the hope that , imperfect as are the materials at present collected , they will be found to possess sufficient interest to excite further and more successful investigation , that may supply the deficiencies which exist in our knowledge of the osteology of this extraordinary animal .
The sandstone of Tilgate forest is a portion of that extensive series of arenaceous strata , which constitutes the iron-sand formation , and in Sussex forms a chain of hills that stretches through the county in a W. N. W. direction , extending from Hastings to Horshamn .
In various parts of its course , but more particularly in the country around Tilgate and St. Leonard 's forests , the sandstone contains the remains of saurian animals , turtles , birds , fishes , shells , and vegetables .
Of the former , three if not four species belonging to as many genera are known to occur , viz. the crocodile , megalosaurus , plesiosaurus , and the iguanodon , the animal whose teeth form the subject of this communication .
The existence of a gigantic species of crocodile in the waters which deposited the sandstone , is satisfactorily proved by the occurrence of numerous conical striated teeth , and of bones possessing the osteological characters peculiar to the animals of that genus of the megalosaurus , by the presence of teeth and bones resembling those discovered by Professor BUCKLAND in the Stonesfield slate ; and of the plesiosaurus , by the vertebrae and teeth analogous to those of that animal .
The teeth of the crocodile , megalosaurus and plesiosaurus , differ so materially from each other , and from those of the other lacerts , as be to identified without difficulty ; but in the summer of 1822 , others were discovered in the same strata , which although evidently referable to some herbivorous reptile , possessed characters so remarkable , that the most superficial observer would have been struck with their appearance , as indicating something novel and interesting .
As these teeth were distinct from any that had previously come under my notice , I felt anxious to submit them to the examination of persons whose knowledge and means of observation were more extensive than my own ; I therefore transmitted specimens to some of the most eminent naturalists in this country , and on the continent .
But although my communications were acknowledged with that candour and liberality which constantly characterises the intercourse of scientific men , yet no light was thrown upon the subject , except by the illustrious Baron CUVIER , whose opinions will best appear by the following extract from the correspondence with which he honoured me .
Ces dents me sont certainement inconnues ; else no sont i8o point d'un animal camassier , et cependant je crois qu'elles appartiennent , vu leur peu de complication , leur dentelure sir les bords , e lee couch mince d'dmail qui les rev6t , kt l'ordre des reptiles .
A l'apparence ext6rieure on pourrait aussi les prendre pour des dents de poissons analogues aux tetrodons , ou aux diodons ; mais leur structure int6rieure est fort different de celles la .
N'aurions-nous pas ici un animal nouveau , un reptile herbivore ?
et de mrme qu'actuellement chez les mammif6res terrestres , c'est parmi les herbivores que l'on trouve les esp &amp; ces I plus grande taille , de m~me aussi chez les reptiles d'autrefois , alors qu'ils etaient les seuls animaux terrestres , les plus grands d'entr'eux no se seraient-ils point nourris de v6gdtaux ?
Un party des grands os que vous possidez appartiendrait h cet animal , unique , jusqu'a present , dans son genre .
Le tems confirmera ou infirmera cette idee , puisqu'il est impossible qu'on no trouve pas unjour un party du squelette r6unie I des portions de machoires portant des dents .
C'est ce dernier objet surtout qu'il s'agit de rechercher avec le plus de persevCrance .
" These remarks induced me to pursue my investigations with increased assiduity , but hitherto they have not been attended with the desired success , no connected portion of the skeleton having been discovered .
Among the specimens lately collected , some however were so perfect , that I resolved to avail myself of the obliging offer of Mr. CLIFT , ( to whose kindness and liberality I hold myself particularly indebted ) to assist me in comparing the fossil teeth with those of the recent lacertae in the Museum of the Royal College of Surgeons .
The result of this examination proved highly l8l satisfactory , for in an Iguana which Mr. STUTCMHBRY had prepared to present to the College , we discovered teeth possessing the form and structure of the fossil specimens .
In the annexed drawing , Plate XIV .
examples of the recent and fossil teeth are represented , and the peculiar characters of each accurately shown ; a description of it in this place will render the subsequent observations more intelligible , Fig. 8 represents a portion of the upper jaw of the iguana viewed from within ; it is magnified four diameters .
9a shows .
the inner , and 9b the outer surface of a tooth of the-same , greatly magnified .
It may be proper to remark , that the teeth differ considerably in the number of points , and that the eminence atf , fig. 9 a , is sometimes the first or second in the series , instead of being the third , as in the figure .
In some teeth the points vary but little in size ; they are more distinct on the edges of the teeth occupying the centre of the jaw , than in the anterior and posterior ones .
The skeleton from which the drawings were made is three feet six inches in length .
It is said to be the common edible iguana of the West Indies , but I have not been able to ascertain its species with certainty .
The remaining figures represent different examples of the fossil teeth .
Fig. i. a represents the outer , and fig. 1 .
b the inner surface of one of the largest and most perfect specimens of the teeth of the iguanodon .
As the letters of reference in each figure indicate the same parts , they are explained here to avoid repetition .
a. Surface worn by mastication .
b. The serrated edges .
c. Fang broken ; the cavity filled with sandstone .
1,3 d. Cavity or depression in the base of the fang , the effect of absorption caused by the pressure of a secondary tooth.* e. Ridge extending down the front of the tooth .
Fig. 2 .
This tooth evidently belonged to a young animal ; yet even in this example the apex is worn away , ( see a. fig. 2 c. ) The ridge extending down the front ( see e fig. e a. ) is more or less distinct in every specimen .
Fig. s. A tooth much worn by mastication .
The serrated edges and other characters are obliterated , the tooth being worn down to the point marked by the line at g. fig. 1 .
a. The fang has been removed by absorption ; and the cavity formed by the pressure of the new tooth is very deep .
Fig. 4 .
In this specimen the point is perfect , and it therefore more closely resembles the recent tooth ( fig. 9.)than those above described .
5 .
Is another example , where the point is but little worn .
6 .
A large strong tooth less curved than fig. l and a. It probably occupied a place in the posterior part of the jaw .
7 .
In this figure , the cavity of the base of the fang for the reception of the new tooth is remarkably distinct .
The teeth above described , although varying from each other in some particulars , do not present greater dissimilarity than the differences arising from age , and the situation they respectively occupied in the jaw , would be liable to produce .
Like the teeth of the recent iguana , the crown of the tooth is accuminated ; the edges are strongly serrated or % The hollow here described is so constantly found in every example , that it cannot be accidental .
From the close resemblance it bears to the cavity formed in the base of the fangs of the recent iguana , by the secondary teeth , ( Vide d , fig. 8 ) it may be confidently presumed that it is the effect of a similar cause .
dentated ; the outer surface is ridged , and the inner smooth and convex ; and as in that animal the secondary teeth appear to have been formed in a hollow in the base of the primary ones , which they expelled as they increased in size .
From the appearance of the fangs in such fossil teeth as are in a good state of preservation , it seems probable that they adhered to the inner side of the maxillae , as in the iguana , and were not placed in separate alveoli , as in the crocodile .
The teeth appear to have been hollow in the young animals , and to have become solid in the adult .
The curved teeth ( figs. i , 2 .
) probably occupied the front of the jaw ; and those which are nearly straight , ( fig. 3 .
) the posterior part .
It appears unnecessary to dwell longer on the resemblance existing between the recent and fossil teeth .
Whether the animal to which the latter belonged , should be considered as referable to existing genera , differing in its specific characters only ; or should be placed in the division of enalio-sauri of Mr. CONYBEARE , which includes marine genera only , cannot at present be determined .
If however any inference may be drawn from the nature of the fossils with which its remains associated , we may conclude , that if amphibious , it was not of marine origin , but inhabited rivers or fresh-water lakes ; in either case the term IGUANODON , derived from the form of the teeth , ( and which I have adopted at the suggestion of the Rev. W. CONYBEARE ) will not , it is presumed , be deemed objectionable .
It has already been mentioned , that of the bones of oviparous quadrupeds found in the sandstone of Tilgate forest , some are decidedly referable to the crocodile , and others to the megalosaurus and iguanodon ; but our knowledge of the 8 .
osteology of the latter is at present so limited , that until some connected portion of the skeleton shall be discovered , it is impossible to distinguish the bones of the one from those of the other .
Since , however , the teeth of the iguanodon are not known to occur in the Stonesfield slate , perhaps such of the bones from Tilgate forest as resemble those figured and described by Professor BUCKLAND , in Vol. I. Second Series of the Geological Transactions , may be attributed to the megalosaurus ; while others not less gigantic may be assigned to the iguanodon .
That the latter equalled , if not exceeded the former in magnitude , seems highly probable ; for if the recent and fossil animal bore the same relative proportions , the tooth , fig. i. must have belonged an individual upwards of sixty feet long ; a conclusion in perfect accordance with that deduced by Professor BUCKLAND from a femur , * and other bones in my possession .
The vertebrae , as in the greater part of the fossil saurians , differ very materially from those of the recent iguana , crocodile , &amp;c. They are not concave anteriorly , and convex posteriorly , but have both faces slightly depressed , resembling in this respect the vertical column of one of the fossil crocodiles of Havre and Honfleur .
But among the recent lacertae there are some , as the Proteus of Germany , the Siren of Carolina , and the Axolotl of Mexico , in which the vertebrae are deeply cupped at both extremities ; and since the fossils in question are clearly of the saurian type , having the annular part united to the body of the vertebra by 186 Mr. MANTELL on the iguanodon , &amp;c. suture , the discrepancy alluded to does not appear to be sufficiently important to invalidate the accuracy of the opinions which I have attempted to establish .
I have the honor to be , SIR , your most obedient Servant , GIDEON MANTELL .
Castle Place , Lewes , Jan. i , 1825 .
, _"_____________ ______ _a__ _________ Z______ ___ ]72 % .
7a , .
MD CC CX-V .
IZ ZIiV .
p 7,6..7e4^ z ro 7u IGUANODO : N g nel27y e7scovere6e ?
FOSSYIL zV1iAMLL , frm , te o\ i8 Suca &gt; Wotne o ' [ / TI GATE FOREST7 S ?
&gt; S767SSJYS .
1l i7.a 2 .
a 2.1 G.3 .
a.6 75 L. b 6 .
c9 .
71 / .'0 , r66 ' .
) j2/ z172e J72a 5f7e 66/ J7 ?
77.,7/ bJio t es m^76 .
/ .e^'e.16.7 % 67.6 -2 .
7 1i e

