V. Explanation of an optical deception in the appearance of the spokes of a wheel seen through vertical apertures .
By P. M. ROGET , M D. F. R. S. Read December 9 , 1824 .
A CURIOUS optical deception takes place when a carriage wheel , rolling along the ground , is viewed through the intervals of a series of vertical bars , such as those of a palisade , or of a Venetian window-blind .
Under these circumstances the spokes of the wheel , instead of appearing straight , as they would naturally do if no bars intervened , seem to have a considerable degree of curvature .
The distinctness of this appearance is influenced by several circumstances presently to be noticed ; but when every thing concurs to favour it , the illusion is irresistible , and , from the difficulty of detecting its real cause , is exceedingly striking .
The degree of curvature in each spoke varies according to the situation it occupies for the moment with respect to the perpendicular .
The two spokes which arrive at the vertical position , above and below the axle , are seen of their natural shape , that is , without any curvature .
Those on each side of the upper one appear slightly curved ; those more remote , still more so ; and the curvature of the spokes increases as we follow them downwards on each side till we arrive at the lowest spoke , which , like the first , again appears straight .
The most remarkable circumstance relating to this visual deception is , that the convexity of these curved images of the spokes is always turned downwards , on both sides of the wheel ; and that this direction of their curvature is precisely the same , whether the wheel be moving to the right or to the left of the spectator .
The appearance now described is represented in Plate XI .
fig. 1.* In order to discover a clue to the explanation of this phenomenon , it was necessary to observe the influence which certain variations of circumstances might have upon it ; and the following are the principal results of the experiments I made for this purpose .
i. A certain degree of velocity in the wheel is necessary to produce the deception above described .
If this velocity be gradually communicated , the appearance of curvature is first perceptible in the spokes which have a horizontal position : and as soon as this is observed , a small increase given to the velocity of the wheel , produces suddenly the appearance of curvature in all the lateral spokes .
The degree of curvature remains precisely the same as at first , whatever greater velocity be given to the wheel , provided it be not so great as to prevent the eye from following the spokes distinctly as they revolve : for it is evident , that the rapidity of revolution may be such as to render the spokes invisible .
It is also to be noticed that , however rapidly the wheel revolves , each Individual spoke appears , during the moment it is viewed , to be at rest .
2 .
The number of spokes in the wheel makes no difference in the degree of curvature they exhibit .
3 .
The appearance of curvature is more perfectly seen when the intervals between the bars through which the wheel is viewed , are narrow ; provided they are sufficiently wide to allow of the distinct view of all the parts of the wheel in succession , as it passes along .
For the same reason , the phenomenon is seen to the greatest advantage when the bars are of a dark colour , or shaded , and when a strong light is thrown upon the wheel .
The deception is , in like manner , aided by every circumstance which tends to abstract the attention from the bars , and to fix it upon the wheel .
4 .
If the numbers of bars be increased in the same given space , no other difference will result than a greater multiplication of the curved images of the spokes ; but if a certain relation be preserved between the angles subtended at the eye by the whole intervals of the bars , and of the extremities of the spokes , this multiplication of images may be correct ( l. The distance of the wheel from the bars is of no consequence , unless the latter are very near the eye , as in that case the apertures between them may allow too large a portion of the wheel to be seen at once .
5 .
If the bars , instead of being vertical , are inclined to the horizon , the same general appearances result ; but with this difference , that the spokes occupying positions parallel to the bars , are those which have no apparent curvature : while the curvatures of the other spokes bear the same relations to these straight spokes , and to each other , that they did in the 13S former case .
When the tinclination of the bars is considerable , however , the images become more crowded , and the distinctness of the appearance is thereby diminished .
The deception totally ceases when the wheel is viewed through bars that are parallel to the line of its motion .
6 .
It is essential to the production of this effect , that a combination should take place of a progressive with a rotatory motion .
Thus , it will not take place if , when the bars are stationary , the wheel simply revolves on its axis , without at the same time advancing : nor when it simply moves horizontally , without revolving .
On the other hand , if a pro .
gressive motion be given to the bars , while the wheel revolves round a fixed axis , the spokes immediately assume a curved appearance .
The same effect will also result if the revolving wheel be viewed through fixed bars by a spectator , who is himself moving either to the right or left ; because such a movement on the part of the spectator produces in his field of vision an alteration in the relative situation of the bars and wheel .
It is evident from the facts above stated , that the deception in the appearance of the spokes must arise from the circumstance of separate parts only of each spoke being seen at the same moment ; the remaining parts being concealed from view by the bars , Yet since several parts of the same spoke are actually seen in a straight line through the successive apertures , it is not so easy to understand why they do not connect themselves in the .
imagination , as in other cases of broken lines , so as to convey the impression of a straight spoke .
The idea at first suggests itself that the portions of 134 one spoke , thus seen separately , might possibly connect themselves with portions of the two adjoining spokes , and so on , forming by their union a curved image made up of parts from different successive spokes .
But a little attention to the phenomena will show that such a solution cannot apply to them : for when the disc of the wheel , instead of being marked by a number of radiant lines , has only one radius marked upon it , it presents the appearance , when rolled behind the bars , of a number of radii , each having the curvature corresponding to its situation ; their number being determined by that of the bars which intervene between the wheel and the eye .
So that it is evident , that the several portions of one and the same line , seen through the intervals of the bars , form on the retina the images of so many different radii .
The true : principle , then , on which this phenomenon depends , is the same as that to which is referable the illusion that occurs when a bright object is wheeled rapidly round in a circle , giving rise to the appearance of a line of light throughout the whole circumference : namely , that an impression : made by a pencil of rays on the retina , if sufficiently vivid , will remain for a certain time , after the cause has ceased .
Many analogous facts have been observed with regard to ?
the other senses , which , as they are well known , it is needless here to particularize .
In order too trace more distinctly the operation of this principle in the present case , it will be best to take the phenomenon in its simplest form , as resulting from the view of a single radius ; ( fig. .
) OR of the wheel VW , revolving steadily upon its axis , but without any progressive motion , and seen 135 .
through a single narrow vertical aperture which is moving horizontally in a given direction PQ .
Let us also assume that the progressive motion of the aperture is just equal to the rotatory motion of the circumference of the wheel .
It is obvious that if , at the time of the transit of the aperture , the radius should happen to occupy either of the vertical positions VO or OW , the whole of it would be seen at once through the aperture , in its natural position ; but if , while descending in the direction VR , it should happen to be in an oblique position RO , terminating at any point of the circumference at the moment the aperture has , in its progress horizontally , also arrived at the same point R , the extremity of the radius will now first come into view , while all the remaining part of it is hid .
By continuing to trace the parts of the radius that are successively seen by the combined motions of the aperture and of the radius , we shall find that they occupy a curve Rabed generated by the continued intersection of these two lines .
Thus , when the aperture has moved to A , the radius will be in the position O a ; when the former is at B , the latter will be at 0 3 , and so on .
Again ; let us suppose that when the aperture is just passing the centre , the radius should be found in a certain position on the other side OY , and rising towards the summit .
Then tracing , as before , the intersections of these lines in their progress , we shall obtain a curve precisely similar to the former .
Its position will be reversed ; but its convexity will still be downwards .
If the impressions made by these limited portions of the several spokes follow one another with sufficient rapidity , they will , as in the case of the luminous circle already alluded 136 to , leave in the eye the trace of a continuous curve line ; and the spokes will appear to be curved , instead of straight .
The theory now advanced is in perfect accordance with all the phenomena already detailed , and is farther confirmed by extending the experiments to more complicated combinations .
It readily explains why the image , or spectrum , as it may be called , of the spoke , is at rest , although the spoke itself be revolving : a circumstance which might escape notice , if the attention were not particularly called to it .
Since the curved appearance of the lines results from the combination of a rotatory , with a progressive motion of the spokes , in relation to the apertures through which they are viewed , it is evident that the same phenomena must be produced if the bars be at rest , and both kinds of motion be united in the wheel itself .
For , whether the bars move horizontally with respect to the wheel , or the wheel with respect to the bars , the relative motion between them , and its effects , in as far as concerns the appearance in question , must be the same .
The attention of the spectator should in both cases be wholly directed to the wheel , so that the motions in question should be referred altogether to it .
Thus , in fig. 4 , the real positions , at successive intervals of time , of the spoke A a , when the wheel is rolling on the ground in the direction AZ , are expressed by the lines Aa , Bb , Cc and D d. While the spoke is in these positions , the portions of it really seen through the fixed aperture VW , are the parts a , f , } , , the impressions of which , being retained upon the retina , and referred to the wheel when in its last position , form the series of points m , n , p and q , in the curved spectrum m D. That the attention may the more easily follow the wheel in its progression , it is necessary that its circumference be distinctly seen , and its real situation correctly estimated .
Hence , although it be true , that by a sufficient exertion of attention the phenomenon may be exhibited by means of a single aperture , it is much more readily perceived , when the number of apertures is such as to allow the wheel to be seen in its whole progress .
For this reason the phenomenon is very distinct in the case of a palisade .
Each aperture produces its own system of spectra ; and hence , when the aper- .
tures occur at short intervals , the number of the spokes is considerably multiplied ; but if the intervals be so adjusted as to correspond with the distances between the spokes at the circumference of the wheel , the images produced by each aperture will coalesce , and the effect will be much heightened .
A mathematical investigation of the curves resulting from the motion of the points of intersection of a line moving parallel to itself , with another line revolving round its axis , will show them to belong to the class of QUADRATRICES , of which the one which touches the circumference of the inner generating circle is that which is known by the name of the QUADRATRIX OF DINOSTRATES .
Such a system of curves is represented in fig. 3 , where MC , CN are the generating radii , A the outer , and B the inner generating circles , and PQ the common axis of the curves .
All these curves have the same general equation , namely , I88 y= ( bx ) .
tang .
x. where the co-ordinates are referred to the axis at right angles to the vertical generating radii , and passing through the centre of their revolution : the basis b being measured on the axis from the point of its intersection with the curve to the centre : and x being the arc of the inner generating circle , as well as the abscissa.* A wheel simply rolling on its circumference exhibits , when seen through fixed bars , only those portions of the curves which are contained within the inner circle ; but when its motion of revolution is more rapid than its horizontal progression , as when it is made to roll on an axle of less diameter on a raised rail-way , then the remaining portions of the curves will be seen , and others , on the lower part of the wheel , having a contrary flexure , will also make their appearance .
These are seen at FF in fig. 3 .
If the spokes , instead of being straight , be already curved , like those of the Persian water-wheel , their form , when viewed through bars , will undergo modifications , which may readily be traced by applying to them the same theory .
Thus , by giving a certain curvature to the spokes , as in fig. 5 , they will at one part of their revolution appear straight , namely , where the optical deception operates in a direction contrary to the curvature .
The velocity of the apparent motion of the visible por* This equality between the arc and the abscissa is a necessary consequence of the progressive motion of the wheel being equal to the rotatory motion of its circumference : the former motion producing the increments of the abscissa ; and the latter those of the arc of the circle .
The equation y=( - ) .
tang .
x. is deduced from a simple analogy of the sides of similar triangles .
1S59 tions of the spokes is proportionate to the velocity of the wheel itself ; but it varies in different parts of the curve : and might therefore , if accurately estimated , furnish new modes of measuring the duration of the impressions of light on the retina .

