XI .
On the finite extent of the Atmosphere .
By WILLIAM HYDE WOLLASTON , M. D. V. P. R. S. Read January 17 , 18e2 .
T-HE passage of Venus very near the sun in superior conjunction in the month of May last , having presented an opportunity of examining whether any appearance of a solar atmosphere could be discerned , I am in hopes that the result of my endeavours , together with the views which induced me to undertake the inquiry , may be found deserving of a place in the Philosophical Transactions .
If we attempt to estimate the probable height to which the earth 's atmosphere extends , no phenomenon caused by its refractive power in directions at which we can view it , or by reflection from vapours that are suspended in it , will enable us to decide this question .
From the law of its elasticity , which prevails within certain limits , we know the degrees of rarity corresponding to different elevations from the earth 's surface ; and if we admit that air has been rarefied so as to sustain only -o of an inch barometrical pressure , and that this measure has afforded a true estimate of its rarity , we should infer from the law , that it extends to the height of forty miles , with properties yet unimpaired by extreme rarefaction .
Beyond this limit we are left to conjectures founded on the supposed divisibility of matter : and if this be infinite , so also must be the extent of our atmosphere .
For , if the density be throughout as the compressing force , then must a stratum of given thickness at every height be compressed by a superincumbent atmosphere , bearing a constant ratio to its own weight , whatever be its distance from the earth .
'But if air consist of any ultimate particles no longer divisible , then must expansion of the medium composed of them cease at that distance , where the force of gravity downwards upon a single particle is equal to the resistance arising from the repulsive force of the medium .
On the latter supposition of limited divisibility , the atmosphere which surrounds us will be conceived to be a medium of finite extent , and may be peculiar to our planet , since its properties would afford no ground to presume that similar matter exists in any other planet .
But if we adopt the hypothesis of unlimited expansion , we must conceive the same kind of matter to pervade all space , where it would not be in equilibrio , unless the sun , the moon , and all the planets possess their respective shares of it condensed around them , in degrees dependent on the force of their respective attractions , excepting in those instances where the tendency to accumulate may be counteracted by the interference of other kinds of matter , or of other powers of which we have no experience , and concerning which we cannot expect to reason correctly .
Now , though we have not the means of ascertaining the extent of our own atmosphere , those of other planetary bodies are nevertheless objects for astronomical investigation ; and it may be deserving of consideration , whether , in any instance , a deficiency of such matter can be proved , and wheg9 .
there , from this source , any conclusive argument can be drawn in favour of ultimate atoms of matter in general .
For , since the law of definite proportions discovered by chemists is the same for all kinds of matter , whether solid , or fluid , or elastic , if it can be ascertained that any one body consists of particles no longer divisible , we then can scarcely doubt that all other bodies are similarly constituted ; and we may without hesitation conclude that those equivalent quantities , which we have learned to appreciate by proportionate numbers , do really express the relative weights of elementary atoms , the ultimate objects of chemical research .
These reflections were originally suggested by hearing an opinion hazarded without due consideration , that the nonexistence of perceptible atmosphere around the moon , might be regarded as conclusive against the indefinite divisibility of matter .
There was , however , an oversight in this inference , as the quantity of such matter , which the moon would retain around her , could not possibly be perceived by the utmost power of any instruments hitherto invented for astronomical purposes .
For , since the density of an atmosphere of infinite divisibility at her surface would depend on the force of her gravitation at that point , it would not be greater than that of our atmosphere is where the earth 's attraction is equal to that of the moon at her surface .
At this height , which by a simple computation is about 5000 miles from the earth 's surface , we obviously can have no perceptible atmosphere , and consequently , should not expect to discern an atmosphere of similar rarity around the moon .
It is manifestly in the opposite direction that we are to look for information .
We should examine first that body 91 which has the greatest power , and see whether even there the non-appearance of those phenomena which might be expected from such an atmosphere , will warrant the inference that our own is confined to this one planet by the limit set to its divisibility .
By converse of the same rule which gives an estimate of extreme rarity at the moon 's surface , we may form a conception at what distance round the sun refraction from such a cause should be perceived .
If we calculate at what apparent distance from the body of the sun his force is equal to that of gravity at the surface of the earth , it is there that his power would be sufficient to accumulate ( from an infinitely divisible medium filling all space ) an atmosphere* fully equal in density to our own , and consequently producing a refraction of more than one degree , in the passage of rays obliquely through it .
If the mass of the sun be considered as 330.ooo times that of the earth , the distance at which his force is equal to gravity will be V330.ooo , or about 575 times the earth 's radius ; and if his radius be 111,5 times that of the earth , then this distance will be 1575 or 5.15 times the sun 's radius ; and 1 1.5 15 49"x 5,15 = ? ?
21 ' 29 " , will be the apparent distance from the sun 's centre on the 23d of May , when the following observations were made .
What deduction should be allowed for the effect of heat , it may be time to consider when we have learned the amount of apparent refraction at some given distance ; and we may then begin to conjecture , whether heat can counteract the increase of density that would occur in the approach of only ' of a second towards his centre.* As I had not any instrument in my possession that I considered properly adapted for the purpose , I requested the assistance of several astronomical friends in watching the progress of Venus to the sun for some days preceding superior conjunction , and in recovering sight of her afterwards .
But neither the Astronomer Royal at Greenwich , nor Professor BRINKLEY of Dublin , nor Mr. SOUTH , with the admirable instruments they possess , were able to make any observation within the time required , not being furnished with the peculiar means adapted to this inquiry .
Captain KATER , however , who entered fully into my views , and engaged in the prosecution of them with all the ardour necessary for success , by using a reflecting telescope , was able to furnish me with a valuable set of observations , 3X days preceding conjunction , which , together with those in which I had the good fortune to succeed at nearly an equal interval subsequent to the passage , afford data quite sufficient to show , that no refraction is perceptible at the period of our observations ; and these come far within the specific distance above estimated .
A selection from the series given to me by Captain KATER is contained in the following table : Diff. calc .
Diff. R. A from N. Aim .
h. mn s.:m .
s. m. s. May 18 2 40 25 4 25.6 .
2 3050 3 431 * 23 27 58 3 8.8 19 oo o ... 3 37 Diff. Decl. May 18 2 44 83 45 56 23 19 40 4 ? ?
57 19 ... . .
4 36 It is evident , that in these observations the differences between the observed and calculated places of the planet , are not such as to indicate a refraction that can be relied on .
My own observations were very few in number , and not to be compared to the former in precision ; but they are necessary to supply a deficiency when Captain KATER was at a distance from his instruments , and could make no observation .
On the e6th , between XI .
20 and XI .
30 I had three comparative observations , the best of which gave me the passage of Venus 3m 55 ' after the sun .
The mean of two others being 3"1 49 .
I consider the result as on the 25th , 3h 24m .
Diff. R. A. Sm 5~ .
The nearest second to be inferred from the Natitcal Almanac for this time being 3m 53* after the sun , it is evident that no perceptible refraction occurred at this time .
From the observations of Captain KATER , no retardation of 94 the motion of Venus can be perceived in her progress toward the sun , as would occur from increasing refraction ; and by comparison of her motion in the interval between his last observation and my own , with her change of place for the same interval given in the Nautical Almanac , there seems no ground whatever to suppose that her apparent position has been in the least affected by refraction through a solar atmosphere , although the distance at the time of Captain KATER'S last observation was but 65 ' 50 " from the sun 's centre , and at the time of my own only 53 ' 15 " ' Although these distances appear small , I find that Venus has been seen at a still less distance by Mons. VIDAL of Montpellier in 1805 .
On the goth of May , he observed Venus 3 16 " after the sun , when their difference of declination was not more than 1 ' , so that her distance from the centre was about 46 minutes of space .
Since his observations also accord with the calculated places of Venus , they might have superseded the necessity of fresh observations , if I had been duly aware of the inference to be drawn from them .
The same skilful observer has also recorded an observation of Mercury on the 31st of March of the same year , when he was seen at about 65 ' from the sun 's centre .
If I were to describe the little telescope with which my observations were made , without taking due care to explain the precautions adopted , and the grounds of their efficacy , it might perhaps be scarcely credible , that with an object glass less than one inch in aperture , having a focal length of only seven inches , I could discern an object not to be seen by telescopes of four and five inches aperture .
We know , how .
* Conn. des Tems .
18o8 .
95 ever , that this small aperture is abundantly sufficient for viewing Venus at a distance from the sun ; and , since the principal obstruction to seeing her nearer ( when the atmosphere is clear ) , arises from the glare of false light upon the object-glass , the success of the observation depends entirely on having an effectual screen for the whole object-glass , which is obviously far more easy to accomplish in the smaller telescope .
Since the screen which I employed was about six feet distant from my object-glass , a similar protection for an aperture of five inches would have required to be at the distance of thirty feet , to obviate equally the interference of the sun 's light at the same period ; but this is a provision with which regular observatories are not furnished for the common purposes of astronomy .
As I hope at some future time to avail myself of a larger aperture for such observations , without the necessity of mounting a more distant screen , it may be desirable that I should suggest to others the means by which this may be effected , if they think the question of a solar atmosphere worthy of farther investigation .
If an object-glass of four inches aperture be covered , so as to expose only a vertical slit of its surface one inch in width , the surface of glass to be so used is about five times as large as the circular aperture one inch in diameter , and yet will be as completely shaded by a vertical screen at any given distance : and an interval of only five feet , might allow a star or planet to be seen within a degree of the sun 's disc .
When the sun and planet have the same declination , the vertical position of the slit is manifestly the most advantageous that could be chosen on the meridian ; 1 but , for the purpose of seeing to the greatest advantage when the line of the centres is inclined to the horizon , it would be requisite to have the power of turning the slit and screen together at right angles to any line of direction of the centres .
The only fixed star sufficiently near to the ecliptic , and bright enough to give any prospect of its being seen near the sun , is Regulus , which passes between the aoth and 2tst of August ; but I have not yet had an opportunity of ascertaining within what distance from the sun this star can be discerned .
In the foregoing remarks , I have perhaps dwelt more upon the consideration of the solar atmosphere- , than -may seem necessary to those who have considered the common plhenomena observable in the occultations of Jupiter 's satellites by the body of the planet .
Their approach , instead of being retarded by refraction , is regular , till they appear in actual contact ; showing that there is not that extentof atmosphere which Jupiter should attract to himself from an ' infinitely divisible medium filling space .
Since the mass of Jupiter is full 309 times that of the earth , the distance at which his attraction is equal to gravity must be as V/ 30 , or about 17.6 times the earth 's radius .
And since his diameter is nearly eleven times greater than that of the earth , 176i = 1.6 times his own radius will be the distance from his centre , at which an atmosphere equal to our own should occasion a refraction exceeding one degree .
To the fourth satellite this distance would subtend an angle of about ? ?
87 ' , so that an increase of density to 83 times our common M DCCCXXII .
0 finite extent of the atmosphere .
atmosphere , would be more than sufficient to render the fourth satellite visible to us when behind the centre of the planet , and consequently to make it appear on both ( or all ) sides at the same time .
The space of about six miles in depth , within which this increase of density would take place , according to known laws of barometric pressure , would not subtend to our eye so much as 3oof a second , a quantity not to be regarded in an estimate , where so much latitude has been allowed for all imaginable sources of error .
Now though , with reference to the solar atmosphere , some degree of doubt may be entertained in consequence of the possible effects of heat which cannot be appreciated , it is evident that no error from this source can be apprehended in regard to Jupiter ; and as this planet certainly has not its due share of an infinitely divisible atmosphere , the universal prevalence of such a medium cannot be maintained ; while , on the contrary , all the phenomena accord entirely with the supposition that the earth 's atmosphere is of finite extent , limited by the weight of ultimate atoms of definite magnitude no longer divisible by repulsion of their parts .

