XXI .
Second Part of the paper on the Nerves of the Orbit .
By CHARLES BELL , Esq. Communicated by Sir HUMPHRY DAVY , Bart. Pres. R. S. Read June 19 , 1823 .
IN these papers I endeavour , to the utmost of my power , to distinguish between the facts which I am able to substantiate , and the hypothesis by which I have been directed in my inquiries .
I hope that the importance of the facts may give some bias in favour of that mode of reasoning by which they have been discovered , and an additional interest to anatomical studies .
In my endeavour to arrange the nerves of the orbit , I encounter , in the first step , all the difficulties of my subject ; for although there be only nine nerves properly enumerated as proceeding from the brain , six of these go to the eye ; the second , third , fourth , part of the fifth , sixth , and seventh , go into the orbit , and may be said to be concentrated into a space no larger than a nut-shell .
In this investigation it is not always possible to give demonstrative evidence , or to answer opposition by cutting across a nerve ; here we must proceed on a minute investigation of the anatomy , and by reasoning , rather than by experiment : yet I shall demonstrate what was stated hypothetically , in a former paper , that there is a correspondence between the compound functions of an organ , and the nerves transmitted to it , Of the function of the ophthalmicus , a division of thefifth nerve .
We are , in the first place , to inquire by what nerve the common endowment of sensibility is bestowed upon the membranes and surfaces of the eye .
On recurring to this subject we are reminded , that the sensibilities of the body differ as much in kind as in degree ; that the sensation of pain is provided to rouse our activity , and guard us against violence , or , by means more direct , to excite instinctive motions , which shall anticipate the most rapid actions of the will , and serve as a more perfect safeguard .
The trigeminus , or fifth nerve , bestows upon all the surfaces of the head and face , external and internal , that sensibility which is enjoyed by the rest of the body through the spinal nerves .
But through some of its branches is also bestowed that distinct sense on certain parts , for the purpose of drawing the muscles into combination ; as for examnple , that fine sensibility of the surface of the eye to the presence of minute particles , which at once excites the flow of tears , and draws the muscles into a combination to expel the offensive matter .
It has been shown in a precedingpaper , by experiment , that on dividing the branch of the fifth nerve to the cheek and lips , the skin was deprived of sensibility , although in possession of other nerves , and enjoying muscular activity .
The same has been proved in regard to this ophthalmic division ; for if that branch of it which comes through the orbit and mounts upon the forehead , be divided , the skin will be deprived of sensibility .
These facts are so strong , that when supported by the symptoms of disease they afford no apology for deep dissection in the living animal , and authorize the conclusion , that all the branches of the same division resemble each other in function , and bestow sensibility on the parts within , as well as on those without .
That the ophthalmic nerve may be deprived of its function , and the parts supplied by it of their sensibility , we may learn from the following instance , communicated to me by Mr. CRAMPTON , of Dublin .
To understand the inference from the following short narrative , it is only necessary to remember , that the nerve in question goes through the orbit , supplying the parts contained in it , but that it also extends its branches to the angle of the eye , eyelids , and forehead .
" A few days after the discharge from the ear had ceased , the eye became entirely insensible to the touch .
This loss of feeling extended to the lining of the eyelids , to the skin covering them , and to the skin of the cheek and forehead , for about an inch surrounding the eye : it did not go beyond the middle line of the face .
When she told me her eye was dead ( as she expressed it ) , to be certain , I drew my finger over its surface ; and so far was this from giving her pain , that she assured me she could not feel that I was touching it at all .
The eyelids made no effort to close while I was doing this , but the conjunctiva appeared sensible to the stimulus , as a number of vessels on the surface of the eye became immediately injected with blood .
" Here we have an insensibility of the eye itself corresponding with the insensibility of the skin , which latter part we know possesses sensibility through the fifth nerve ; and we therefore conclude , that it is the affection of the same nerve near its root , to which we have to attribute the insensibility a9 of the surfaces of the eye , as well as of the skin around the eye .
By experiment it can farther be made evident , that the sensibility of the eye enjoyed through the ophthalmic nerve , does not bestow on the organ directly , the power of combining the muscles , either for the defence of the eye , or for any other purpose .
The impression must be referred back to the brain , and the muscles excited by their proper nerves .
I have not been able to excite the motion of the eye by irritating the ophthalmic division of the fifth after the division of its root , * and in the instance just given , the eyelids did not move when the surface of the eye was irritated , because no sensation was conveyed inward to the sensorium , and consequently no mandate transmitted from it .
The young lady could see , and could move the eye and eyelids ; the eye itself was irritated by touch , as appeared from the rising inflammation ; but by the insensibility of the ophthalmic nerve , a link was lost in the relation necessary to join the action of the muscles to the sensibility of the surface .
Of the nerves performing the involuntary motions .
We have just seen that nerves in great profusion come out upon the eyelids andc forehead , and until these experiments were made , it was supposed that they directed the motions of the forehead and eyelids .
But I have found that they have nothing to do with this function .
On the contrary , a very small branch of the respiratory nerve of the face , that nerve which comes out before the ear , controuls the motions of the forehead and eyelids .
If this small nerve be divided , then the motions of the eyelids are lost , and they remain open .
The inquiries instituted in the first part of this paper , give a lively idea of the consequences of this imperfection ; showing that the eye being unguarded and unwashed , becomes dry by evaporation and inflames , and the cornea becomes opaque .
It is unnecessary to point out the importance of this fact to the operating surgeon .
It has been asked , why should this nerve be called respiratory ; and what have the actions of respiration to do with the eye-lids ?
The name was given to excite attention to certain relations ; that the question might be asked , and the connections of remote parts noticed and remembered .
These connections of remote parts are so curious , the knowledge of them is sometimes so useful , and they are so immediately related to the present subject , that I may be permitted to explain them .
During the state of excitement of the respiratory organs , a very extensive consent of the muscular frame is necessary to bind together and support the textures , that they may bear the strain either during violent efforts of the body , or in coughing , sneezing , &amp;c. We may take the act of sneezing , as a familiar example of the manner in which the eye is guarded during a sudden and violent act of expiration .
At the instant of this convulsive action of the respiratory muscles , a violent impulse is communicated to the head along the column of blood in the vessels of the head and neck .
Every body is sensible of the eye flashing light , but the cause is mistaken ; for it is supposed to be the impulse of blood forced into the eye ; whereas it is the contraction of 293 the eyelids to counteract the force of the impulse , and to guard the delicate texture of the eye .
If the eyelids be held open during the act of sneezing , no sensation of light will be experienced &amp; because the contraction of the eyelids upon the eyeball is prevented .
Can we believe this action of the muscle of the eyelids in combination with the action of the respiratory muscles , to be an accidental connection ?
Is it not rather a provision to compress and support the vascular system of the eye , and to guard it against the violent rush of blood which attends certain acts of respiration ?
If we open the eyelids of a child to examine the eye while it is crying , and struggling with passion , by taking off the natural support from the eye , the blood at the same time being forced violently into the head by the act of respiration , we shall see the conjunctiva suddenly fill with blood , and the eyelid everted .
The respiratory nerve of the face performs two offices , one of which is voluntary , as in moving the cheeks and lips in speech ; and the other involuntary , as in moving the nostrils in breathing during sleep or insensibility .
In like manner that branch of the respiratory nerve which is prolonged to the eyelids performs a double office , contracting the eyelids by volition , and also producing those involuntary winking motions of the eyelids which disperse the tears , and preserve the lucid surface clear.* But it has been observed , in the First Part of this Paper , that the shutting of the eyelids is not the only part of this act of preservation , and that the motions of the eyelids are attended with a rolling of the eyeball .
How is this relation between the eyelids and eyeball established ?
This leads to an examination of the fourth nerve .
The fourth nerve .
This is a fine nerve , which takes its origin from the brain , at a part remote from all the other nerves which run into the orbit .
It threads the intricacies of the other nerves without touching them , and is entirely given to one muscle , the superior oblique .
We may observe too , that this singularity prevails in all animals .
What office can this nerve have in reference to this one muscle ?
Why is it 's root , or source , different from the other nerves , from the nerve of vision , the nerve of common sensibility , and the nerve of voluntary motion ?
We now reflect , with increased interest , on the offices of the oblique muscles of the eye , observing that they perform an insensible rolling of the eyeball , and hold it in a state of suspension between them .
We have seen that the effect of dividing the superior oblique was to cause the eye to roll more forcibly upwards ; and if we suppose that the influence of the fourth nerve is , on certain occasions , to cause a relaxation of the muscle to which it goes , the eyeball must be then rolled upwards.* The course of inquiry leads us , in the next place , to observe the vicinity of the root of this fourth nerve , to the origin of the respiratory of the face , and we find them arising from the same track of fibrous substance .
The column of medullary matter which constitutes that part of the medulla oblongata from which the respiratory nerves arise , terminates upwards , or at its anterior extremity , just under the corpora quadrigemina , and there the fourth arises .
Is it possible then , we say , that there can be any correspondence between the general act of respiration , and the rolling of the eye ?
Led thus to make the experiment , I was gratified to find it so easy to give the proof .
On stopping the nostrils with the handkerchief , every effort to blow the nose will be attended by a rapid rising of the cornea under the upper eyelid .
And on every occasion when the eyelids suffer contraction through the agency of the respiratory nerve of the face , as in sneezing , the eyeball is rolled upwards through the agency of the fourth nerve .
I might , perhaps , be satisfied with having made the observation of these two facts ; first , that there is such a combicombine to one effort , but also that relation between the classes of muscles by which the one relaxes while the other contracts .
I appended a weight to a tendon of an extensor muscle , which gently stretched it and drew out the muscle ; and I found that the contraction of the opponent flexor was attended with a descent of the weight , which indicated the relaxation of the extensor .
To establish this connection between two classes of muscles , whether they be grouped near together , as in the limbs , or scattered widely as the muscles of respiration , there must be particular and appropriate nerves to form this double bond , to cause them to conspire in relaxation as well as to combine in contraction .
If such a relationship be established , through the distribution of nerves , between the muscles of the eyelids and the superior oblique muscle of the eyeball , the one will relax while the other contracts .
296 nation of the motions of the eyeball and eyelids as I have before noticed ; and secondly , that the nerves which move the eyelids , and the nerve of the obliquus muscle of the eyeball , are associated at their roots ; but I should not do full justice to this interesting subject , if I did not attempt something farther .
It is plain that we must consider the nerves and muscles of the eyelids in a double capacity , in their voluntary , and involuntary actions .
In the first , the motions of the eyelids combine with the whole muscles of the eyeball , as we may perceive in the voluntary contractions and squeezing of the eye ; but in the insensible and involuntary motions of the eyelids , there would be no sympathy with the muscles of the eyeball , and therefore no correspondence in the motion of these parts , without a nerve of the nature of the fourth ; that is , a nerve which having diverged from the root of the respiratory nerves , takes its course to the oblique muscles .
In one word , the connection of its root declares the office of this nerve .
The expression of the eye in passion , confirms the truth of this relation being established by a respiratory nerve , and consequently by a nerve of expression .
In bodily pain , in agony of mind , and in all this class of passions , the eyes are raised and dragged , in conjunction with the changes to which the other features are subjected .
If it be asked now , as it has been asked for some hundred years past , why the fourth nerve goes into the orbit , where there are so many nerves , why it is so distant in its origin from the other nerves , and why it sends off no twig or branch , but goes entirely to one muscle of the eye ?
The answer is , to provide for the insenMDcccxXIIIr Qq 297 sible and instinctive rolling of the eyeball ; and to associate this motion of the eyeball with the winking motions of the eyelids ; to establish a relation between the eye and the extended respiratory system : all tending to the security or preservation of the organ itself .
Of the voluntary nerves .
The voluntary nerves of the eye are the Third and Sixth .
The third nerve arises from the crus cerebri , that track of medullary matter which gives off all the nerves purely of volition .
It is given to the muscles of the eye generally , and to no part but muscles .
For these reasons we retain the name motor oculi , given by WILLIS , although his reasons for calling it so were fanciful and unsatisfactory .
The Fifth nerve , by its ophthalmic division , gives branches to the muscles of the eye , but not so profusely as to the surrounding parts ; and not more than sufficient to give them sensibility in the degree possessed by muscular substance generally .
Since the branches of this fifth nerve , transmitted to the muscles of the eyelids and forehead , do not minister in any degree to muscular action there , it would be unwarrantable to suppose that they served the purpose of giving action to the muscles within the orbit .
For these reasons , I conceive the Third nerve to be that which gives volition to the muscles of the eye , and that it is , of all the nerves of the body , the most perfectly and directly under the power of the will .
The sixth nerve is called abducens , and motor externus .
With regard to its origin and distribution , there is no obscurity in this nerve ; it arises from the same track of medullary matter which gives rise to the motor nerves , and it is , distributed to 298 a voluntary muscle , the rectus externus .
In this respect it is like a subdivision of the Third , and without doubt it is a voluntary nerve ; but there is a circumstance in its connection which I cannot explain .
It receives a gross branch from the great visceral nerve called Sympathetic .
This nerve , ascending through the base of the skull , unites with the Sixth nerve as it is entering the orbit .
Some having proceeded so far , would be inclined to call this an accidental connection , and so leave it ; but similar investigations for many years have brought me to the conviction that there is no accident in an animal body ; and Comparative Anatomy proves this to be a regular established relation .
To return to the consideration of these nerves of volition as they regard the eye , we may affirm , that although they want sensibility in the common acceptance of the term , they no doubt furnish the mind with the rudiments of certain sensations , and so far resemble the nerves of the senses .
From experiments narrated in the first part of this paper , it appears , that we are sensible to the degree of agency exercised by the voluntary muscles of the eye .
These nerves , the Third and Sixth , although they receive no external impression , are nevertheless agents which give rise to the perceptions of place or relation , in aid of that sensibility enjoyed by the optic nerve and retina .
I hope I have now unravelled the intricacy of the nerves of the head , and have correctly assigned to each nerve its proper office .
In our books of Anatomy , the nerves are numbered according to the method of WILLIs , an arrangement which was made in ignorance of the distinct functions of the nerves , and merely in correspondence with the order of succession in which they appear on dissection .
The first nerve is provided with a sensibility to effluvia , and is properly called olfactory nerve .
The second is the optic nerve , and all impressions upon it excite only sensations of light .
The third nerve goes to the muscles of the eye solely , and is a voluntary nerve by which the eye is directed to objects .
The fourth nerve performs the insensible traversing motions of the eyeball .
It combines the motions of the eyeball and eyelids , and connects the eye with the respiratory system .
The fifth is the universal nerve of sensation to the head and face , to the skin , to the surfaces of the eye , the cavities of the nose , the mouth and tongue.* The sixth nerve is a muscular and voluntary nerve of the eye .
The seventh is the auditory nerve , and the division of it , called portio dura , is the motor nerve of the face and eyelids , and the respiratory nerve , and that on which the expression of the face depends .
The eighth , and the Accessory nerve , are respiratory nerves .
The ninth nerve is the motor of the tongue .
The tenth is the first of the spinal nerves ; it has a double root and a double office ; it is both a muscular and a sensitive nerve .
Had I taken the nerves of any other complex organ rather than of the eye , I should have had an easier task .
If I had taken the nerves of the tongue , I should have been able to prove by experiment , and in a manner the most direct , that the three nerves belong to three distinct functions , and stand related to three different classes of parts .
I could have shown that taste and sensibility belong to the office of the fifth nerve , voluntary motion to the ninth , and deglutition to the glossopharyngeal nerve of the tongue .
In concluding these papers , I hope I may be permitted to offer a few words in favour of anatomy , as a means better adapted for discovery than experiment .
The question lies between observation and experiment , and it may be illustrated by astronomy and chemisty .
In the first , the objectsbeing beyond the influence of man , he makes observations , not experiments ; and the science at length attains a state of perfection which raises our estimate of the human intellect .
In the latter , for the most part , the subjects lie out of the sphere of mutual influence ; they must be brought together by artifice , and chemistry becomes a science of experiment .
But anatomy is more allied to the former than to the latter SO1 science , in as much as things are obvious to the eyes .
In the animal body the parts present distinct textures , and are laid in a natural and perfect order ; it is necessary only to trace the tubes , or to observe the symmetrical order of the nervous cords , in order to discover'their respective uses : the motions , whether of the solid or fluid parts , are so regular and uniform , that the whole offers a subject for observation and induction .
Anatomy is already looked upon with prejudice by the thoughtless and ignorant : let not its professors unnecessarily incur the censures of the humane .
Experiments have never been the means of discovery ; and a survey of what has been attempted of late years in physiology , will prove that the opening of living animals has done more to perpetuate error , than to confirm the just views taken from the study of anatomy and natural motions .
In a foreign review of my former papers , the results have been considered as a farther proof in favour of experiments .
They are , on the contrary , deductions from anatomy ; and I have had recourse to experiments , not to form my own opinions , but to impress them upon others .
It must be my apology , that my utmost efforts of persuasion were lost , while I urged my statement on the grounds of anatomy .
I have made few experiments ; they have been simple , and easily performed ; and I hope are decisive .
If we turn to the opinions which have been entertained on the subject of the brain and nerves , we find one theory to have prevailed from the Greek authors to the time of WILLIS , and to have descended from him with little alteration , to modern writers .
The brain has been supposed to secrete and supply a nervous fluid , and the nerves to be the conduit 302 pipes for its conveyance .
In every age the brain has been considered a common sensorium , and all the nerves to be capable of conveying sensation , unless when they had ganglia .
If ganglia intervened , then the nerves were said to be cut off from the brain ; and those so distinguished were called vital nerves , neither serving the purpose of governing the muscles , nor of conveying sensation .
With all this apparent simplicity of doctrine , there never has been presented such a crude heap of errors , in the history of any department of science .
These notions were obviously founded on the mistake , that the same nerve served different purposes , and that a fluid moved in the same tube outwards to stimulate the muscles , and inwards to convey sensation of external impressions .
So incolsistent are those opinions with the structure of the frame , that the simplest dissection proves them false .
So far is it from being true that ganglia cut off sensation , that I have ascertained , and proved by experiment , that all the nerves , without a single exception , which bestow sensibility from the top of the head to the toe , have ganglia on their roots ; and those which have no ganglia arenot nerves of sensation , but are for the purpose of ordering the muscular frame .
The hypothesis , that the nervous fluid streams out from the great officina along the nerves , has had an unfortunate influence in directing the labours of the experimentalists .
During the last age it kept the pupils of HALLER engaged in inquiries regarding the influence of the nerves : de nutritione imprimis nervosa : and de nervorum in arterias imperio ; and the interest of this question has not subsided , but , on the contrary , has increased among us .
This notion of a fluid moving backwards and forwards in the tubes of the nerves , equally adapted to produce motion and sensation , has perpetuated the error , that the different nerves of sensation are appropriated to their offices by the texture of their extremities , " that there exists a certain relation between the softness of the nervous extremities , and the nature of the bodies which produce an impression on them .
" On the contrary , every nerve of sense is limited in its exercise , and can minister to certain perceptions only .
Whatever may be the nature of the impulse communicated to a nerve , pressure , vibration , heat , electricity , the perception excited in the mind will have reference to the organ exercised , not to the impression made upon it .
Fire will not give the sensation of heat to any nerve but that appropriated to the surface .
However delicate the retina be , it does not feel like the skin .
The point which pricks the skin being thrust against the retina , will cause a spark of fire or a flash of light .
The tongue enjoys two senses , touch and taste ; but by selecting the extremity of a particular nerve , or what is the same thing , a particular papilla , we can exercise either the one or the other sense separately .
If we press a needle against a nerve of touch , we shall feel the sharpness , and know the part of the tongue in contact with the point ; but if we touch a nerve of taste , we shall have no perception of form or of place , we shall experience a metallic taste .
The innovations of the celebrated continental authority BICHAT , did not bring us a step nearer the truth .
When he at once threw off respect for his contemporaries , and for the authority of those who had preceded him , he equally disregarded the facts of anatomy .
There may be merit in taking new views of a subject , but BICHAT was continually holding a thing up by the wrong end , and presenting it in an aspect so singular , as to puzzle any one to say whether or not it was that with which he had been long familiar ; accordingly , what had been termed the sympathetic system of nerves , he called the ganglionic system ; although they are not more distinguishable by ganglia than the other nerves , upon which indeed the ganglia are remarkable for their size , number , and regularity .
These ganglia must not be thrown out of the system altogether , merely because they are contained within the skull and vertebrae , which circumstance should rather mark their importance .
BICHAT persuaded himself that his ganglionic system was isolated and a thing by itself ; when , on the contrary , the connections of this part of the nervous system are universal .
The wide spreading fifth pair , and the thirty spinal nerves , give large and conspicuous roots to this system .
It exhibits a tissue extending universally .
It was a still more unfortunate mistake of this ingenious physiologist , to suppose the sympathetic nerve to be the same with that , which in the lower animals ( the vermes ) , is seen coursing from one extremity of the body to the other .
In the leech , or worm , those nerves produce union and concatenation of all the voluntary motions , and bestow sensibility as well as motion ; yet he saw in the sympathetic system of the human body , only the developement of the same system of nerves , although he was aware that in man the sympathetic nerve bestowed neither sensibility nor the power of motion .
BIcHAT announced his system with a popular eloquence , which had a very remarable influence over all Europe , Physiologists yielding to him , mistook the importance of the several parts of the nervous system ; and even the multiplied experiments of LE GALLOIS failed to convince them of the nature of the spinal marrow .
The experiments of M. LE GALLOIS were of the rudest kind possible .
The spinal marrow was cut across , or destroyed , by passing ?
skewers into the spinal canal , and the effects " were observed ; as if the spinal marrow were a simple body .
Whereas , by such destruction of its substance , the original ganglia , which form a series along the spine , must have been hurt ; the track of nervous matter which gives rise to the nerves of sensation : that also which gives roots to the nerves of voluntary motion : and the lateral column connected with the offices of respiration , must all have been destroyed by such coarse experiments .
It cannot surprise us that the results were obscure and contradictory .
But the most extravagant departure from all the legitimate modes of reasoning , although still under the colour of anatomical investigation , is the system of Dr. GALL .
It is sufficient to say , that without comprehending the grand divisions of the nervous system , without a notion of the distinct properties of the individual nerves , or having made any distinction of the columns of the spinal marrow , without even having ascertained the difference of cerebrum and cerebellum , GALL proceeded to describe the brain as composed of many particular and independent organs , and to assign to each the residence of some special faculty .
When the popularity of these doctrines is considered , it may easily be conceived how difficult it has been , during their successive importations , to keep my Pupils to the examples of our own great Countrymen .
Surely it is time that the schools of this kingdom should be distinguished from those of France .
Let physiologists of that country borrow from us , and follow up our opinions by experiments , * but let us continue to build that structure which has been commenced in the labours of the MONROS and HUNTERS .
The whole history of medical literature proves , that no solid or permanent advantage is to be gained , either to medical or general science , by physiological experiments unconnected with anatomy .
To disregard the anatomy of the nervous system , or to take it in the gross ; to make a new science of life ; and influenced by a false analogy to call it a fluid ; to attempt to direct it along a cord or a wire , is to transgress all the rules of philosophical enquiry , and must be attended with the rapid decline of anatomical studies .
They will be considered as imposing restraints on genius , or be rejected as useless ; and with them pathology , and all that is most necessary to medical science , will fall into disuse .

