XXI On the re-establishment of a canal in the place of a portion of the Urethra which had been destroyed .
By HENRY EARL , Esq. Surgeon to the Foundling , and Assistant Surgeon to St. Bartholomew 's Hospital .
Communicated by Sir HUMPHRY DAVY , Bart. P. R. S. Read April 12 , 18 i. IF any apology be requisite for bringing forward the following insulated fact , I hope it will be found in its tendency to throw some light on an interesting physiological subject , which has lately occupied the attention of this learned Society , as well as in its novelty and general importance .
Of all the complaints to which the human body is liable , there is , perhaps , no class more productive of corporal and mental suffering , than the various affections of the male urethra .
For it is most obvious , that any deviation from healthy structure in that part , which , from its peculiar function , is called into action after very short intervals of repose , must , from that circumstance alone , be productive of almost constant suffering ; while the mind of the patient is also depressed from the effect of a continual anticipation of pain , and the apprehension of impaired virility .
The following is a statement of the result of a new operation in a very aggravated case , by which an individual has been raised from such a state of despondency to one of comparative happiness .
JoHN WHITAKER , whilst serving on board his Majesty 's ship Pylades , off the island of Sardinia , in May 1813 , when returning on board from Magdalina , fell with one leg on each side of the boat , the stem of which injured his urethra so much in the perineum , that he was obliged to have the catheter introduced for above six weeks .
From that time he continued to experience more or less difficulty in discharging the contents of the bladder until the beginning of May , 18 9 , when he was attacked with a sudden retention of urine , which was soon followed by extensive effusion into the cellular substance .
Before he could obtain surgical assistance mortification had taken place , and the integuments in the perineum , with above an inch of the canal of the urethra , had sloughed away .
A free vent being thus obtained , the mischief did not extend itself to the scrotum .
During the healing process , the medical gentleman who attended him , made several unsuccessful attempts to unite the integuments over a catheter .
He came under my care the following August , in Saint Bartholomew 's Hospital ; at which time a large smooth cicatrix occupied the place of the urethra , no vestige of which remained at that part .
The mucous membrane of the canal was distinctly visible , terminating above , and recommencing below , the cicatrix .
Through the posterior aperture the whole of the urinal and seminal discharges came away , while the anterior portion of the urethra , particularly that part which passed behind the scrotum , was increased in density and much contracted , and probably would ultimately have been completely obliterated by disuse .
The man was by trade a carpenter ; and , as he was obliged to work , it was a very serious inconvenience to him every time he obeyed the calls of nature .
This , coupled with the distressing excoriation attendant on the scattering of the urine , made him anxious to submit to any plan of treatment which afforded a possibility of relief , and I determined on pursuing the following one .
The integuments on the right side had suffered less extensively than those on the left , so that when a catheter was introduced , that portion which passed across the cicatrix could be about half covered by drawing the skin and cicatrix from the right towards the opposite side .
My first attempt , therefore , was to encourage this disposition in the integuments to fold over ; and as some delay was requisite in order to dilate the anterior part of the urethra with bougies , he was directed to remain in bed with his knees tied together over a pillow , and a truss was so applied as constantly to press the integuments from the right to the left side.* To this plan the ultimate cure of the patient is in some measure referable .
After some weeks , the urethra being sufficiently dilated to admit a moderate sized catheter , I determined to attempt the following operation .
The smooth cicatrized surface having become insensible to the irritation of the urine , I resolved to employ it in the formation of a canal , and to endeavour to connect by it the two portions of the urethra : for , as many months had elapsed since the healing of the wound , all contraction in the cicatrix had ceased , and it was probable that a passage formed of such parts would not be liable to any farther diminution in its calibre .
On the other hand , I had to contend with two great difficulties : in the first place , the portion of cicatrized integument intended to be separated , was not of original formation ; consequently , it was endued with less vital energy , and possessed fewer blood vessels : secondly , it was not possible to allow the parts to be at rest for the completion of any curative process for many hours together ; the force also with which the urine was expelled , and the acrid nature of that discharge , were alike unfavourable to the cure by adhesive inflammation .
All these circumstances having been well considered , a portion of integument was removed about an inch and half long , and one-third of an inch in width , on the left side of the cicatrix ; the groove thus formed being intended to receive the edge of skin to be detached from the opposite side .
An incision was then made across the perineum above and below , so as to pare away the callous edges of the urethra .
The cutis was next dissected off from a portion of integument on the right side of the perineum , about an inch and half in length and half an inch broad , leaving a smooth space of rather more than an inch between the cut surfaces , which was intended to form the lining of the new canal .
The integuments on the right side were now dissected up , turned over a catheter , and brought in contact with the opposite groove .
The detached portion of cicatrix bled little during the operation , and , before it could be applied to the groove , the edge had so livid an appearance as to create an apprehension that 303 it must perish .
Two ligatures were employed to assist in retaining it in the desired position , and some straps of adhesive plaster and a bandage completed the dressings .
The day following the operation , it was evident that some urine had escaped by the side of the catheter ; and on the third day , when it became necessary to remove the dressings , it was found that the portion of the flesh which had been denuded of skin had sloughed , but that a sufficient quantity had united above and below to form a canal open at one side , and large enough to include the whole catheter .
This result was quite as favourable as could , under all circumstances , have been expected ; and I was led to entertain sanguine expectations of ultimate success .
The two surfaces , from whence the integuments had been removed , were now suffered to heal ; but as the cicatrix on the right side contracted , it drew the newly formed canal rather to that side , and tended to increase the opening into it .
It was , consequently , determined not to attempt any thing farther until all contraction had ceased .
So much , however , had been gained by this operation , that when the catheter was introduced , and the finger pressed on the left side , no urine escaped , and some could be made to pass through the penis without the aid of the catheter .
My patient however , soon after this , became much disordered in his health , and had an attack of lepra vulgaris , to which he had for years been subject , on which account for some months nothing was attempted , except several times freely excoriating the edges of the canal , and thus endeavouring to unite them by keeping them in contact .
In this we were constantly foiled by the astonishing rapidity with which the skinning process took place from within outwards .
This disposition to form new skin was so remarkable , as to excite the surprise of several gentlemen who witnessed it , and appeared to arise from the moist state in which the parts were constantly kept.* In the summer of 18o2 , the man had recovered from his cutaneous affection , and his general health was so much improved , that he resolved to submit to a second operation .
In this attempt I borrowed integuments from the opposite side to that I had taken them from in my first .
A deep groove was made on the right side , the surface was denuded of its cutis to some extent , a considerable portion of integument was then detached from the left side , and , in order to obtain healthy skin , I encroached a little on the thigh , and laid bare the edge of the fascia lata .
Instead of passing any ligature through the detached portion , the old quill suture was employed , which was passed from the two outer cut surfaces .
A pad of adhesive plaster was interposed between the ligatures and the flap of skin , to diffuse the pressure more generally ; and my patient , being now quite an adept in passing the catheter , was directed to introduce it about three times in the twenty-four hours , instead of retaining it in the bladder , which had permitted some of the urine to pass insensibly away , and had acted prejudicially in the former operation .
By this attempt much more was gained , and about two-thirds of the canal were completed ; still , however , there remained a small aperture at the upper part .
We again attempted to close this by denuding the edges with escarotics and the lancet , but it skinned over too rapidly to allow of any union between the opposite surfaces .
A third operation on a smaller scale was therefore necessary , which so nearly completed the cure as to leave only an orifice large enough to admit a bristle , which has subsequently closed , and , at the present time ( March , 1821 ) , he remains perfectly well , and is able to expel the contents of his bladder pleno rivo .
I may perhaps incur the charge of prolixity in the foregoing narrative , but I conceive it important to give a circumstantial account of the whole process , to mention all the difficulties I had to contend with , and the means which were employed to surmount them .
Should I ever have occasion to repeat this operation , I should entertain sanguine hopes of succeeding at once , by avoiding some circumstances , and availing myself of others , a knowledge of which could only be gained by actual experiment .
The above case is , I believe , the first on record in which so extensive a portion of the whole canal of the urethra has been restored ; and the mode of performing the operation has never , as far as I have been able to ascertain , beent resorted to before .
Mr. A. COOPER , in the second part of his Surgical Essays , which was published soon after my first operation on WHITAKER , has given an account of two very interesting cases , in which he succeeded in closing unnatural openings in the urethra .
In neither , however , of the cases which he has related , was the breach so extensive , nor did it occupy the whole canal .
The second case , related in page 207 , approaches nearer to WHITAKER'S than the first .
In this instance the opening was anterior , but close to the scrotum ; and Mr. COOPER availed himself of this circumstance in effecting a cure ; a portion of the skill of the scrotum was partially detached , and turned over so as to cover the opening , the callous edges of which were previously pared away .
The operation in this case differed materially from the one which I performed ; for in Mr. COOPER'S case , the raw surface was turned towards the urethra , whilst in mine the canal was wholly formed of a previously cicatrized smooth surface , which had undergone its utmost degree of contraction before it was employed to form the canal .
The fact I conceive is new , that , from a cicatrix of common integuments , a canal may be formed capable of conveying so acrid a fluid as urine , and of fulfilling all the functions of a healthy urethra , without being liable to any subsequent variation in its calibre .
It is important , also , in throwing some light on the still disputed question of the muscularity of the urethra ; for since the patient quitted my care , he has more than once indulged in sexual intercourse ; and he assures me , that the jet of semen is as forcible as before the accident .
When we consider that nearly , if not entirely , the whole of the ejaculator seminis must have sloughed away with the portion of the urethra which perished , and that an interval of above an inch of common integument at present exists between the two portions of the meatus urinarius , it is difficult to account for this phenomenon .
It is probable , that the semen is in the first instance projected into the urethra with some impetus , and it would there immediately receive additional impulse from the spasmodic action of the levator any and other muscles in the neighbourhood of the urethra ; but the vis a tergo must be nearly , if not entirely , lost in its passage t-hrough the .
portion of integument in the perineum .
It must then depend for its final projection , either on the muscular fibres which have been described by Mr. BAUER as surrounding the mucous membrane of the urethra at its anterior part , or on the elastic property which has , been assigned to it .
If I might venture to offer an opinion on the subject , I should consider the present case rather in favour of the muscularity of the urethra , as the quantity of fluid secreted is hardly sufficient ' to distend the whole canal , a circumstance very essential to the reaction of an elastic tube .
From the tortuous course of the muscular fibres , as described by Mr. BAUER in Sir E. HOME'S paper , it seems probable that they would require to be elongated before they could act with force ; and precisely such would be the effect of the injection of blood into the corpus spongiosum which takes place in coitu .
One more circumstance I may venture to allude to , as tending to support such an opinion , namely , the complete emission of the contained fluid which takes place , which requires a forcible and very sensible contraction of the whole canal , and cannot be accounted for on the supposed principle of elastic compression , unaided by muscular action .
On reflecting on the preceding case , it appears to me not less important in a practical than a physiological point : of view ; for the curative principles which were acted on , may lay the foundation of an improved mode of treating some of the more lamentable cases of strictures with fistulous openings and diseased integuments in perineo .
It is well known , that such cases occasionally baffle the skill of the ablest practitioners , and often terminate in premature death after years of continual suffering .
When we consider that that part of the urethra situated opposite the perineum , is by much the most frequent seat of disease , and that it is often confined to this situation , it is probable that in such cases , if we could remove the diseased portion of the urethra , together with the thickened fistulous integument , much good might be effected ; and perhaps even a permanent cure might be accomplished , by subsequently pursuing a somewhat analogous operation to the one performed on WHITAKER .
Such a practice would , I conceive , be justifiable on two grounds .
In the first place , the patient 's state is nearly hopeless from all common plans of treatment , and should the operation not eventually succeed , he will not be rendered worse ; for instead of making water through numerous fistulous apertures , and being subject to frequent depots of urine and the formation of fresh abscesses , he would at once empty his bladder from the extremity of the membranous part of the urethra ; and farther it may be urged , that no parts of vital importance would be endangered by the operation .
It is true , that such a plan would be both painful and tedious , but I should still consider it worth the experiment , after in vain trying all the usual modes of relief .
The case just related , and the success which attended Mr. COOPER , encourage us to hope that , in many cases which have hitherto been abandoned as incurable , much good may yet be effected by judicious treatment , and 309 a right application of the known laws of the animal economy .
Should future operations be equally successful , the borrowing from one part of the body to repair the loss of another , must be considered as one of the happiest modes of directing the reparative processes of nature ; for the closing of large fistulous openings in the male and female urethra , must certainly be acknowledged as contributing more essentially to the happiness and comfort of an individual , than almost any other operation in surgery .
HENRY EARL .
28 , George Street , Hanover Square , March 22 , 18zx ,

